How to Make Scotcheroos (No Bake Scotcharoos Recipe) No bake, easy dessert--these soft and chewy peanut butter Scotcheroos are amazing! Just 6 simple ingredients and about an hour has these yummy soft scotcheroos ready to serve. Great for goodie plates for neighbors, friends and coworkers, perfect for big parties and awesome for just a simple treat. Let's get started with a batch of scotcheroos! My sister in law taught me this recipe and it's become a family favorite that I've been making for about 15 years! She made it one year for an Easter party, she formed the scotcharoos in plastic Easter eggs, so they were egg shaped instead of balls. These are great pressed into a 9x13 inch pan and cut into bars as well...lots of options and super easy and fast! Scotcharoos are an easy treat and a step up from traditional rice crispy treats with a delicious combination of peanut butter, butterscotch and chocolate. Ingredients Needed for Scotch-a-Roos! 1 Cup Peanut Butter (Chunky or C...