Air Europa A332 Incident Report
Air Europa A332 Incident Report
Air Europa A332 Incident Report
Expte. Nº 342/14
ADVERTENCIA
INFORME FINAL
Nota: Todas las horas están expresadas en Tiempo Universal Coordinado (UTC),
que para el lugar del incidente corresponde al huso horario – 3.
1
1 INFORMACIÓN SOBRE LOS HECHOS
2
ANEXO
ala fuselaje, y daños en una compuerta de acceso al pack de aire acondicionado de-
recho. Dos tubos pitot con ligeros daños. En el ala izquierda se encontró la cobertura
del faro de aterrizaje izquierdo rajado y dos paneles de intradós afectados por los
golpes del granizo. En el ala derecha se encontraron daños en paneles de intradós,
en el flight spoiler número 4, como así también en el slat número 1 derecho. En los
estabilizadores horizontales se encontraron pequeños golpes de ambos bordes de
salida.
No hubo.
1.5.1 Piloto
3
De acuerdo con lo informado por la CIAIAC, el certificado de aptitud psico-
fisiológica, estaba vigente hasta el 16 de enero de 2015, con la limitación de tener
disponible lentes correctores para visión cercana y llevar un par de repuesto.
1.6.2 Célula
4
ANEXO
1.6.3 Motores
5
y -80ºC. Los radares mostraban ecos compactos con desarrollos verticales que su-
peraban los 58 dBZ. También se encontraba una corriente en chorro al NW del sis-
tema con fuerte cortante vertical de viento.
1.9 Comunicaciones
El incidente tuvo lugar en la fase de descenso del vuelo AEA 041, aproxi-
madamente entre las 90 y 60 NM, radial 054º del VOR EZE, entre los niveles de vue-
lo FL260 y FL150.
6
ANEXO
1.14 Incendio
No hubo.
1.15 Supervivencia
7
1.18 Información adicional
1.18.3 El Proyecto de Informe Final (PIF) del incidente fue enviado a la “BEA
Bureau d'Enquêtes et d'Analyses pour la sécurité de l'aviation civile”, la junta
de investigación de accidentes de Francia, a fin que conjuntamente con el asesor del
representante acreditado (Airbus, fabricante de la aeronave), fuese evaluado y se
emitiese una opinión.
1.18.4 Las consideraciones enviadas por la BEA han sido tenidas en cuenta e in-
corporadas al informe. Dicho documento se encuentra como apéndice al informe, al
final del mismo.
2 ANÁLISIS
2.1.1 Las licencias y los certificados de aptitud psicofisiológica de los pilotos es-
taban vigentes.
8
ANEXO
3 CONCLUSIONES
3.1.3 Las defensas tecnológicas para estas situaciones, a saber, radar de abor-
do de la aeronave y radares de superficie del SMN, funcionaron correctamente y de
acuerdo con lo previsto.
9
Deficiencia en la empresa aérea para inducir las conductas operativas
comprometidas con la gestión de la seguridad operacional en las tripulaciones.
5 REQUERIMIENTOS ADICIONALES
BUENOS AIRES,
10
AEA A330-202 EC-JPF (MSN0733)
Hailstorm in descent
09-Sep-2014
Airbus Report
The sole objective of this report is to prevent reoccurrence. It is not aimed to apportion blame
or liability.
This report has been compiled thanks to the information available at Airbus at the date of its
publication and could be updated should new information becomes available.
On September 9th, 2014 the Air Europa (AEA) A330 MSN0733 (EC-JPF) experienced a
severe hailstorm during descent to Buenos Aires (EZE). The aircraft suffered extensive
damage on windshield and radome and minor structural damage on pylon, wings and
horizontal stabilizer.
1. FACTUAL INFORMATION 5
1.6.1 Monitoring 8
2. SEQUENCE OF EVENTS 11
3. CONCLUSION 15
On September 9th, 2014 the A330-202 MSN0733 (EC-JPF) operated by Air Europa
(AEA) was performing flight AEA041 from Madrid (MAD) to Buenos Aires (EZE).
During the descent to EZE, the aircraft entered a turbulent area and experienced a
hailstorm. During this period, Recorded CAS dropped by more than 90kt in 1sec. In the
same second, AP1, both FDs and ATHR disengaged, followed by a reversion in
Alternate Law.
During the turbulence zone, the Vertical Acceleration (VRTG) varied between 0.05g
and 2.2g and the Lateral Acceleration (LATG) between 0.06g (left) and 0.25g (right)
and CAS increased up to 314kt.
Several pitch up orders on captain side resulted on slight pitch increase. Thrust levers
were pulled to IDLE detent and then CAS decreased. AP1 was reengaged. The thrust
levers were selected back to CLIMB and ATHR was reengaged.
A/C Flight Hours and Cycles, here above, are the latest values known by Airbus at the
time of the event.
The METAR information at Buenos Aires airport (SAEZ / EZE) around the time of the
turbulence event (that occurred between 10:30:30 and 13:35:21 UTC) is the following:
• SAEZ 091000Z 29007KT 230V320 9000 -TSRA BKN020 FEW050CB OVC080 20/19 Q1000
• SPECI SAEZ 091028Z 17014KT 140V210 5000 TSRA BKN007 FEW045CB OVC050 20/19 Q1001
• SPECI SAEZ 091040Z 18015G27KT 150V220 5000 TSRA BKN007 FEW045CB OVC050
20/19 Q1002
• SAEZ 091100Z 18020KT 5000 TSRA BKN010 FEW045CB OVC080 16/15 Q1002
1.6.1 Monitoring
In case of Pitot obstruction, if voted CAS drops by more than 30kt within 1s (which
could only happen if at least 2 Pitots are obstructed by ice crystals), the 3 ADRs
are not used anymore by FCPC during 10s and F/CTL downgrades in Alternate 2B
Law (normal longitudinal law + direct lateral law + loss of protections).
After 10s, current voted CAS is compared to the voted one recorded just before
Pitot obstruction. If the difference is lower than 50kt, the 3 ADR are used again and
the Normal law is available again. If not, the 3 ADRs are considered as lost by the
FCPC and the Alternate 2B law is latched.
If AIR DATA selector is set to “NORM”, DFDR CAS parameter is recorded from:
ADR1 (CAS1, i.e. from CPT side), as long as CAS1 is valid, i.e. Normal
Operation (NO) and
ADR2 (CAS2, i.e. from F/O side), if CAS1 becomes invalid, i.e. Non Computed
Data (NCD) of fault. CAS is NCD when below 30kt.
Note: AOA from IRS are also recorded in this DFDR data frame (AOAIRS parameters).
For these parameters, a value is recorded from each ADIRU (3 different parameters
recorded) independently of the AIR DATA selector position. AOAIRS corresponds to a
pure copy of each CAOA but transmitted via the IRS part of the ADIRU
The following description and analysis have been carried out using data extracted from
DFDR, Pilot Report (ref. Annex N°1 ) and Post Flight Report (ref. Annex N°2 ). The DFDR
parameters’ list is available in Annex N°3 . The associated plots are available in Annexes
N°4 and 5 .
2.1 INITIAL CONDITIONS
According to the Pilot Report, before starting the descent, at FL360 the flight crew
experienced some light turbulence in clear air, and decided to put the Seat Belt Sign
to “ON”.
They started the descent, and still according to Pilot Report, the weather radar
showed areas of turbulences (magenta) on the right of their route, and areas of
precipitations ahead which occupied an area of approximately 100NM to each side of
their track and was 10 to 15NM deep. They saw areas of red colour clearly sided by
areas of yellow and green towards they were heading.
• From 10:30:30 UTC to 10:33:28 UTC, between 27700ft and 23200ft, the Vertical
Acceleration (VRTG) and the Lateral Acceleration (LATG) variations started to
increase:
VRTG between 0.54g to 1.64g and
LATG between 0.06g (left) to 0.13g (right)
• At 10:31:14 UTC, speed control was changed to Selected and selected CAS was set
at 280kt, then at 283kt at 10:32:06 UTC and finally at 260kt (recommended
turbulence speed) at 10:33:32 UTC.
• From 10:31:47 UTC to 10:36:23 UTC, AOA3 reacted with a low sensitivity during
several short periods.
Note: Such behaviour has been already encountered and is likely due to transient ice
crystal accumulation at the AOA3 vane base.
• At 10:33:38 UTC, the flight crew selected HDG-V/S (FCU V/S was at -1024ft/min).
• From 10:34:31 UTC to 10:34:35 UTC, between 22400ft and 22200ft recorded CAS
dropped from 275kt to 156kt with a loss of more than 90kt in 1sec. During the event,
the recorded CAS is CAS1.
Note: As per DFDR logic, if AIR DATA selector is set on “NORM”, the CAS recorded
by the DFDR is the CAS from CPT side (i.e. CAS1) as long as the CAS1 is
valid (NO). During the whole event period, the AIR DATA selector was in the
“NORM” position and CAS1 remained valid (no fault or NCD).
• At 10:34:33 UTC, the Rudder Travel Limit function was lost (TLU1V and TLU2V
parameters switched to 1 = Not avail).
Note: These two recorded parameters (TLU1V and TLU2V) correspond to the
availability of the rudder Travel Limiter Unit which computes the available
range of the rudder function of the speed. The loss of this function is the
consequence of the loss of speed information by the FCPC.
• From 10:34:33 UTC to 10:35:21 UCT, the aircraft continued to experience strong
turbulences:
VRTG varied between 0.17g and 1.60g and
LATG varied between 0.10g (left) and 0.15g (right).
• At 10:34:34 UTC, loss of AP1, FD1&2 and A/THR and Normal Law reverted in
Alternate Law. Master Warning (MW) triggered during 10sec and the message “THR
LK” was displayed on the FMA until 10:34:57 UTC. ISISCAS dropped from 280kt to
241kt in 1sec and then re-increased to reach 300kt at 10:34:38 UTC.
According to the PFR, at 10:34 UTC the following ECAM alerts were triggered:
A. ICE L WSHLD HEAT
NAV IAS DISCREPANCY associated with the failure message
PROBE PITOT 1+2/2+3/1+3 (9DA)
A. ICE L+R WSHLD HEAT
AUTO FLT A/THR OFF
F/CTL ALTN LAW
FLAG ON CAPT PFD SPD LIMIT
FLAG ON F/O PFD SPD LIMIT
Note: The triggering of the “A. ICE L WSHLD HEAT” followed by “A. ICE L+R
WSHLD HEAT” could be explained by the hail impacts on the windshield.
• At 10:34:35 UTC, Recorded CAS (i.e. CAS1) increased from 156kt and reached a
maximum of 314kt at 10:34:40 UTC.
• At 10:34:37 UTC, the FD2 was recovered followed 1sec later by the FD1.
Analysis: Since ADR failures are not latched by the FMGEC as long as AP is off, FD
reengaged automatically as soon as at least 2 CAS are recovered by the
FMGEC (difference less than 20kt during 450ms).
• At 10:34:43 UTC, the Normal law and TLU function were recovered.
• At 10:34:56 UTC, a pitch up order (4.13° back stick) was recorded f ollowed by a
second one at 10:35:20 UTC (6.33° back stick). The pitch increased to 3.52°. C AS
reached 305kt and then decreased. ALT was increasing and reached 23150ft at
10:35:59 UTC before decreasing again.
• At 10:34:57 UTC, the Thrust Levers were retarded from CLIMB to IDLE detent.
• At 10:35:33 UTC, the Thrust Levers were set back to CLIMB detent and A/THR was
reengaged (in SPD mode).
• At 10:35:55 UTC, OP DES mode was engaged (lateral mode remained in HDG).
Then the aircraft proceeded to the approach and performed an uneventful landing in
Buenos Aires airport (EZE).
On September 9th 2014, A330 MSN0733 (Reg. EC-JPF) operated by Air Europa (AEA)
was performing a flight from Madrid (MAD, Spain) to Buenos Aires (EZE, Argentina).
During the descent to EZE, passing FL230 the aircraft crossed a turbulence area and
hailstorm conditions.
According to Pilot Report, the flight crew was aware of the vicinity of strong weather cells
(weather radar was in WX+TURB mode) but did not expect such heavy precipitations.
The hailstorm severely damaged both windshields and radome. The turbulence zone last
almost 5mn during which the Vertical Acceleration (VRTG) varied between 0.05g and
2.2g and the Lateral Acceleration (LATG) between 0.06g (left) and 0.25g (right).
There are some indications (TAT probe freezing and low AOA sensibility) that the aircraft
was flying in ice crystal environment for at least few minutes before entering the
turbulence area. When crossing 22350ft, the CAS1 dropped by more than 90kt in 1sec.
3sec after, ISISCAS (equivalent to CAS3) dropped by 30kt in 1sec. In the meantime,
AP1, both FDs and A/THR were lost and F/CTL law reverted in Alternate law.
Loss of AP, FDs and A/THR is most likely due to the rejection of the three ADRs by the
FMGEC (due to CAS monitoring). The transient reversion in Alternate law is due to the
temporary rejection of the 3 ADR by FCPC (icing monitoring).
FD2 and FD1 were recovered respectively 3 and 4sec after their disengagement,
meaning that at least two ADRs were revalidated by the FMGEC. 10sec after the
reversion in Alternate law, the Normal law was recovered (as per FCPC icing monitoring
logic in case of CAS recovery).
The Thrust Levers were selected on IDLE detent for 36sec, to reduce the speed
according to the Pilot Report (at that time the CAS was 305kt). When the thrust levers
were set back to CLIMB detent, A/THR was reengaged. In the meantime AP1 was
reengage in HDG-V/S mode and then in OP DES mode. Then the aircraft proceeded to
the approach and performed an uneventful landing in Buenos Aires airport (EZE).
On last September 8th, I signed-in at 20:25 UTC in MAD for the AEA 041 flight. I had previously
downloaded the flight plan at home and also inserted the route in the Jeppesen iPad app, and also
updated weather information provided by this and thus have extra help.
We took off from Madrid, made the expected flight level changes during the flight, run the entire
route without any impact initially, and carried out the planned rests for all members of the crew.
According the weather information obtained during the flight, we selected a VOR approach to
runway 29, and loaded an ILS 25 in the secondary flight plan, giving the briefing in this way.
Once in contact with Montevideo Control, as we could not receive yet the ATIS-EZE by VHF (only
means possible, having no D-ATIS), they told us the runway in use was the 35. We activated the
secondary flight plan and re-programmed as a secondary RWY 29, again reviewing the briefing for
this new plan.
Before the descent, at level 360 we experienced some light turbulence in clear air, and we decided
to put the belts sign ON.
We started the descent, and the weather radar showed areas of turbulence (magenta) to the right
of our route, and areas of precipitation in front of us which occupied an area of approximately 100
NM to each side of the track and 10-15 NM deep initially at that time. We saw areas of red color
clearly sided by areas of yellow and green, that was where our path was directed. We began our
descent aiming to that green/yellow narrow aisle, that couldn’t predict high-intensity precipitation.
Passing through FL260, we receive hail impacts, cracking both windshield from the very beginning,
and experiencing at the same time severe to extreme turbulence; as I mentioned, it did not show
on the radar for this area we were flying, nor had been reported by radio, VOLMET ATIS, or the
presence of storm or hail at these levels.
Just at the beginning of the descent we received the ATIS, which gave RWY 35 in use, but in the
subsequent communication with EZE they said then that RWY in use was 11. Therefore, I asked the
Copilot to load the ILS approach to runway 11, while I had controls and communications, and the
relief Copilot assisted us with the QRH procedure “cockpit windshield/window cracked”.
Due to that turbulence turbulence, the autopilot disengaged without crew action, so I set IDLE to
reduce our airspeed, then selected 260Kts and connected back A/P and ATHR. They told us to
proceed direct to point ARSOT and we told them back that we were to fly to a heading to the left of
the route due to the weather conditions.
An ECAM Caution consistent to the cracked windshields arose: “L & R Windshield Heat Fail”, getting
help from the relief Copilot.
Once free of adverse weather (around FL150), we required priority for landing, telling them about
what we just experienced in the aircraft and weather. At this time the Copilot had the
communications back and I had the controls.
I gave another briefing for the new runway in use, preparing for CATIIIA at the prospect of poor
visibility due to the damaged windshield. We made an uneventful approach from the South of the
field towards ARSOT, and in final I decided to land manually, since although it was within limits for
autoland, the wind was strong enough to consider it the best option, and my window was less
damaged that the one on the other side.
We taxied to the ramp and had to wait for the marshaller, since the ground personnel was not
allowed to approach any aircraft under those storms at the airport. Once the technician climbs on
board, he told us that we also had a damaged nose radome, as well as some damage on each
engine pylon and the landing light, so I checked and took pictures of all damage before filling-in the
logbook.
I called the Flight Manager and the Flight Following Captain on duty, telling them what had just
happened, and reporting that pictures would be sent from the hotel.
We had to wait a while for the baggage at the claim area (until handling personnel were allowed to
work on the ramp), what gave the opportunity to many passengers to congratulate us personally,
which we thank them.
Once in the hotel, we called back the Flight Following Duty Captain, in order to arrange an interview
with the National Authority (JIAAC) personnel, what we had at noon in the hotel lobby.
We were then told that another aircraft was on its way to EZE, with some spare parts, and that we
would fly back to MAD as scheduled.
During the afternoon, the whole crew (pilots and cabin crew) had the opportunity to join for a long
debriefing were to explain and discuss all that happened.
Signed,
Captain
Annex N° 2
STKP
10
STKPC
STKPF
VRTG VSPD
1.5 -1000
G VRTG FT/MI
1.0 1.05 G -2000
LONG
0.70 0.5
MNADC
SALT
G LONG FCU
0.65 0.0 10:34:31-666.667 36
0.04 G
ALT
N1A1
275.00 KT
KT
80 390 270
389.25
N1A
CAS_ADC
TRA KT
40 100 46.91 %
47.03 % 260
TRA2 260.00
TRA1
0 50 TRA GS
46.85 DA
47.11 DA
% DA
-40 0
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
CG (%) 31.36
GWL (LBS) 347320
GWK (KG) 157542
CRUISE(LONGITUDINAL AXIS) Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/T1-cruise-longi.ilv 1.1.1
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
AP1E STKR
AP2E
1.00 10
STKRF
0.00
STKRC
AIL
O SIDE STICK ROLL POSITION FIRST-OFFICER (STKRF - - ) DA
10 0
AILRO -0.09 DA
-0.04 CAPTAIN (STKRC ___ )
AILLO
AIL
DA I OUTER AILERONS RIGHT (AILRO - -)
0 10 1.49 DA
AILRI LEFT (AILLO__ )
-1.85 DA
AILLI
DA DA
SSLIP
5 0
0.00 DA
DA
0
ROLL
13.36 DA 10
RUDT DA
-10
DRIFT ANGLE
DA RUDP RUDD RUDT
0 0
0.79 DA
0.00 DA
LATG -10.72 DA
0.1
LATG
SAT
G
0.02 G
0.0 -20
SAT
-20.75
SAT
10:33:25-833.333 -30
CTAS
SAT
500 -40
GS
HDG
400 360
400.55 KT CTASSAT
WD
GS
362.00 KT
305.86 DA
KT
300 WD 270
258.05 DA HDG
80.00 KT
WS DA
180
WS
60
KT
40
SFLP
0
0.00
DA DA SLAT FLAP
0 0
0.00 DA
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
CG (%) 31.36
GWL (LBS) 347320 CRUISE (LATERAL AXIS)
GWK (KG) 157542 Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/source/dfdr/dfdr/LR/cruise_lat.ilv 1.1.2
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
FMA :ZONE E1,E2 ET E3
AP1E AP1 (WHITE)
AP2E
AP2 (WHITE)
0.00
FD1E
FD2E
0.00 FD1 (WHITE)
1.00 FD2 (WHITE)
ATHRE 1.00
ATHRA ATHR (WHITE)
0.00 ATHR (CYAN)
APOFFW
APOFFV
0.00
1.00
SRSD FMA LONGI. MODE: ZONE B1 0.00 SRS (GREEN)
ALTCSTD 0.00 ALT CST (GREEN)
ALTCRZD ALT CRZ (GREEN)
0.00
ALTMODD 0.00 ALT (GREEN)
ALTACQCS 0.00 ALT CST* (GREEN)
ALTACQCR ALT CRZ* (GREEN)
0.00
ALTACQD 0.00 ALT* (GREEN)
VSD V/S (GREEN)
0.00
CLBD 1.00 CLB (GREEN)
DESD 0.00 DES (GREEN)
OPCLBD OP CLB (GREEN)
0.00
OPDESD 0.00 OP DES (GREEN)
GSTRKD G/S (GREEN)
0.00
GSCPTD 0.00 G/S* (GREEN)
FPAD 0.00 FPA (GREEN)
0.00
FCU: BARO. REF. SELECTION
STDC
STDF 1.00
QNHF
QNHC 1.00
QFEC 0.00
QFEF 0.00
FE1V 0.00
FE2V
FG1F
0.00
1.00
FG2F 1.00
FM1F 0.00
FM2F 0.00
0.00
FMAD 0.00 FMA DISPLAYED
EVTMKR 1.00 EVENT MARKER
0.00
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
FCTL
HYDGW
HYDYW
HYDBW
LAW
NLAW
ALAW
DLAW
FCPC1CL
FCPC2CL
FCPC3CL
FCSC1CL
FCSC2CL
NCCL
STKR
10
STKRC
PH
7.0 STKRF
6.5
FLIGHT PHASE
6.0
STKCF
STKFF
STKFINOP
STKCINOP
AILLIBV
CAS_ADC
AILLIGV
CAS_ADC ALT
300 36000
CAS_ADC ALT
AILLOGV
AILERON VALIDITY
AILLOYV 1=AVAILABLE
AILRIBV
AILRIGV
200 28000
ALT
AILROGV
AILROYV
100 20000
ELVRGV
ELVRYV
SBNR
RUDTW
MASTER WARNING
CPTMW1
CPTMW2
FOMW1
FOMW2
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
OVERViEW
WGT(KG) 157542
CDVE-LAW-FAULT-STICKS-YAW DAMPER
WGT(LBS) 347320 Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/source/dfdr/dfdr/LR/CDVE.ilv 1.1.4
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
CAPT / FO MAST WNG & CAUTION
CPTMW1
FOMW2
CPTMC1
FOMC2
ICE DETECTOR
DD1F
DD2F
DD1ICEDET
DD2ICEDET
D1SICEDET1
D2SICEDET1
WSHRW
N1L1 N1L2
N1A1
100
N1A2
N1A1
50
N1A2
AIR TEMP
CTAT
0
SAT--
(%)
0 CTAT
SAT
-50
DEGC
-100
ALT
40
30
ALT
CAS
400
CAS
20
200
10
KT
0
10^3
0
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041 Immat: . E C- J P F
Airline: X F Type: Flight: A EA 0 4 1 From: LEMD To: SAEZ
CG (%) 31.12
WGT (LBS) 347320.00
OVERViEW
WGT (KG) 157378.41 ICE Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/source/dfdr/dfdr/LR/Ice.ilv 1.1.5
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
AP12E
FD12E
ATHRE
ATHRA
MW
STALLW
TLU2V
TLU1V
NLAW
ALAW
WAION (1=ON)
CPT ADC1
F/O ADC2
CPT IRS1
F/O IRS2
ADR2F
ADR1F
ADR3F
ADR123F
AOAIRS1
5
AOAIRS2
AOAIRS3
AOAIRS3
AOAIRS2
AOAIRS1
(DA)
-0
VRTG
1.0 VRTG
VRTG
G
0.5
AOA ALT
5 37500
CAOA1 ALT
ISISALT
CAOA2 CAOA1 (__) CAOA2 (--)
DEG
MNADC
-0 35000
CMACH
1.0
CMACH
MNADC
32500
CAS
0.5 350
CAS
CAS
ISISCAS 30000
()
0.0 300
AIR TEMP
ISISCAS
27500 50
SAT
(KT)
250 CTAT
ALT
CTAT
25000 0
ISISALT
DEGC
22500 SAT -50
(FT)
20000
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR Time
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
CG (%) 31.4
WGT(KG)
OVERViEW 157542 AIR DATA DISCREPANCY
WGT(LBS) 347320 Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/ADR-DISAGREE.ilv 1.1.6
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
OIL LP 1
OIL LP 2
Oil Q
20 Oil Q2
Oil Q2 Oil Q1
Oil Q1
10
Qts
0
N2VIB
3
1 N2V1 N2V2
N1VIB CU
3 0
1
N1V1 N1V2
CU
0
N2ACT
100 N2A2
N2A1
80
60
40
20
%
0
N1ACT
100
N1A2
80
60 N1A1
40
20
%
0
EGT
800
EGT2
deg C EGT1
400
TRA
80
TRA1 TRA2
deg A
0
ZP
40
SAT
-30 100 0.4
10^3
FT deg C KT
0 -60 0 0.0
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00 10:39:00
TIME(H)
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041 MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
DFDR Data - A330 MSN 0486 - GE - Oil and Vibrations parameters AT GMT START
ZP = 35980 FT
10NMF
20NMF
40NMF
80NMF
160NMF
320NMF
ND CAPTAIN RANGE
10NMC
20NMC
40NMC
80NMC
160NMC
320NMC
ARCF
PLANF
RVORF
RNAVF
RENGF
ND CAPTAIN MODE
ARCC
PLANC
RVORC
RNAVC
RENGC
RADSTBY
RADWEAT
RADMAP
RADCONT
RADTEST
RADTURB
RADWXRTURB
RADWSHR
10:28:00 10:29:00 10:30:00 10:31:00 10:32:00 10:33:00 10:34:00 10:35:00 10:36:00 10:37:00 10:38:00
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
STKP
10
STKPC
-0.09 DA
STKPF
-0.22 DA
VRTG VSPD
1.5 0
G VSPD
VRTG FT/MI
1.0 -1000
MNADC
0.70 MNADC 0.85 G
LONG CTASSAT
0.65 0.5
0.65
10:35:09-166.667
ALT SALT
G FCU
LONG
0.60 0.0 20
0.02 G
SALTFCU ALT
22492.00 FT
CAOA 14976.00 FT
2
10 10
3.52 DA
PTCH
10^3
FT
5 0
405.31 CAOA1 ___
CAOA
GS CAOA2 - -
1
400
DA CTASSAT 1.76 DA
287.12 KT
1.05 DA
0
SCAS
PTCH PFD
390 280
GS
CAS_ADC
385.00 KT
N1A2
160 380 270
N1A1
SCASPF
KT 263.00
120 370 CAS_ADC 260
TRA KT
80 100 250
TRA2
TRA1
N1A
56.53 %
52.91 %
40 50 TRA
% DA 16.08
14.06DA
DA
-0 0
10:33:00 10:33:20 10:33:40 10:34:00 10:34:20 10:34:40 10:35:00 10:35:20 10:35:40 10:36:00 10:36:20
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
CG (%) 31.20
GWL (LBS) 346960
GWK (KG) 157378
CRUISE(LONGITUDINAL AXIS) Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/cruise-longi.ilv 1.2.1
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
AP1E STKR
AP2E 10
STKRF
STKRC
AIL
O SIDE STICK ROLL POSITION FIRST-OFFICER (STKRF - - ) DA
10 0
AILRO
CAPTAIN (STKRC ___ )
AILLO OUTER AILERONS RIGHT (AILRO - -)
AIL
DA I
0 10
AILRI LEFT (AILLO__ )
AILLI INNER AILERONS RIGHT (AILRI - -)
DA SSLIP
0 5
LEFT (AILLI__ )
DA DA
5 0
SSLIP
DA
0
ROLL
10
RUDP RUDD
ROLL
10 10 0
RUDT DA
-10
LATG
SAT
G
0.0 -10
SAT
-20
SAT
CTAS
SAT
500 -30
GS
HDG
400 360
CTASSAT GS WD
WD
KT
300 270
HDG
DA
180
WS
WS
60
KT
40
SFLP
0
DA DA SLAT FLAP
0 0
10:33:00 10:33:20 10:33:40 10:34:00 10:34:20 10:34:40 10:35:00 10:35:20 10:35:40 10:36:00 10:36:20
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
CG (%) 31.20
GWL (LBS) 346960 CRUISE (LATERAL AXIS)
GWK (KG) 157378 Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/cruise-lat.ilv 1.2.2
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
FMA :ZONE E1,E2 ET E3
AP1E AP1 (WHITE)
AP2E 1.00 AP2 (WHITE)
FD1E
FD2E
0.00 FD1 (WHITE)
1.00 FD2 (WHITE)
ATHRE 1.00
ATHRA ATHR (WHITE)
0.00 ATHR (CYAN)
APOFFW
APOFFV
0.00
FMA LONGI. MODE: ZONE B1 0.00 SRS (GREEN)
SRSD 0.00
ALTCSTD 0.00 ALT CST (GREEN)
ALT CRZ (GREEN)
ALTCRZD 0.00 0.00
ALTMODD 0.00 0.00 ALT (GREEN)
ALTACQCS 0.00 ALT CST* (GREEN)
ALTACQCR ALT CRZ* (GREEN)
0.00
ALTACQD ALT* (GREEN)
VSD V/S (GREEN)
CLBD CLB (GREEN)
DESD 0.00 DES (GREEN)
OPCLBD OP CLB (GREEN)
0.00
OPDESD 0.00 1.00 OP DES (GREEN)
GSTRKD G/S (GREEN)
0.00
GSCPTD 0.00 G/S* (GREEN)
FPAD 0.00 FPA (GREEN)
FCTL
HYDGW
HYDYW
HYDBW
LAW
NLAW
ALAW
DLAW
FCPC1CL
FCPC2CL
FCPC3CL
FCSC1CL
FCSC2CL
NCCL
STKR
10
STKRC
PH
7.0 STKRF
6.5
FLIGHT PHASE
6.0
STKCF
STKFF
STKFINOP
STKCINOP
CAS_ADC
AILLIBV
CAS_ADC ALT
AILLIGV
300 23600
CAS_ADC ALT
AILLOGV
AILLOYV AILERON VALIDITY
1=AVAILABLE
AILRIBV
AILRIGV
200 22800
AILROGV ALT
AILROYV
100 22000
ELVRGV
ELVRYV
ELVLBV
ELVLGV ELEVATOR VALIDITY
1=AVAILABLE
YAW DAMPER
YDGV
YDYV
SBNR
RUDTW
MASTER WARNING
CPTMW1
CPTMW2
FOMW1
FOMW2
10:33:00 10:33:20 10:33:40 10:34:00 10:34:20 10:34:40 10:35:00 10:35:20 10:35:40 10:36:00 10:36:20
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
ZOOM
WGT(KG) 157378
CDVE-LAW-FAULT-STICKS-YAW DAMPER
WGT(LBS) 346960 Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/CDVE.ilv 1.2.4
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
CAPT / FO MAST WNG & CAUTION
CPTMW1
FOMW2
CPTMC1
FOMC2
ICE DETECTOR
DD1F
DD2F
DD1ICEDET
DD2ICEDET
D1SICEDET1
D2SICEDET1
WSHRW
N1L1 N1L2
N1A1
100
N1A2
N1A2
N1A1
50
AIR TEMP
CTAT
0
SAT--
SAT
(%)
0 CTAT
-50
DEGC
-100
ALT
40
30
CAS
400 ALT
CAS
20
200
10
KT
0
10^3
0
10:33:00 10:33:20 10:33:40 10:34:00 10:34:20 10:34:40 10:35:00 10:35:20 10:35:40 10:36:00 10:36:20
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041 Immat: . E C- J P F
Airline: X F Type: Flight: A EA 0 4 1 From: LEMD To: SAEZ
CG (%) 31.36
WGT (LBS) 346960.00
ZOOM
WGT (KG) 157160.68 ICE Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/Ice.ilv 1.2.5
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
AP12E
1.00
FD12E 0.00
1.00
ATHRE
1.00
ATHRA
1.00
MW
STALLW 0.00
0.00
TLU2V
TLU1V 0.00
NLAW 0.00
1.00
ALAW
WAION (1=ON) 0.00
CPT ADC1 0.00
1.00
F/O ADC2
1.00
CPT IRS1
1.00
F/O IRS2
1.00
ADR2F
ADR1F 0.00
ADR3F 0.00
ADR123F 0.00
AOAIRS1 0.00
5
AOAIRS2
AOAIRS3
AOAIRS3
AOAIRS2
AOAIRS1 2.11
2.11 (DA)
(DA)
(DA)
-0
10:36:15-833.333
VRTG
1.13 G
1.0
VRTG
VRTG
G
0.5
AOA ALT
5 23850
CAOA1 ALT
ISISALT
CAOA2 CAOA1 (__) CAOA2 (--)
2.46
2.11 DEG
DEG
DEG
-0 23600 MNADC
CMACH
1.0
MNADC
23350
CMACH
CAS
0.64
0.64
0.5 350
CAS
ISISCAS 23100
CAS
()
0.0 300
AIR TEMP
22850 279.38 KTS
kt 50
ISISCAS 278.75 SAT
22816.00 ft
22804.00
(KT) (FT)
250 CTAT
ALT CTAT
22600 0
1.01
DEGC
22350 -50
ISISALT
(FT)
22100
10:33:00 10:33:20 10:33:40 10:34:00 10:34:20 10:34:40 10:35:00 10:35:20 10:35:40 10:36:00 10:36:20
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR Time
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041
CG (%) 31.2
WGT(KG)
ZOOM 157378 AIR DATA DISCREPANCY
WGT(LBS) 346960 Edited : 8/10/2014 Figure
/workgroup/operation/dfdr/visage/bertille/2014/P0733V0041-Hailstorm/ADR-DISAGREE.ilv 1.2.6
Electronically validated - Released on 20 Oct 2014
OIL LP 1
OIL LP 2
Oil Q
20 Oil Q2
Oil Q2 Oil Q1
Oil Q1
10
Qts
0
N2VIB
3
1 N2V1
N1VIB N2V2
CU
3 0
1
N1V1 N1V2
CU
0
N2ACT
100
N2A1 N2A2
80
60
40
20
%
0
N1ACT
100
80
60 N1A2
N1A1
40
20
%
0
EGT
800
deg C
400 EGT1 EGT2
TRA
80
TRA1 TRA2
deg A
0
ZP
40
SAT CAS
CAS
30 300
MACH ZP
20 0 200 0.8 MACH
SAT
10NMF
20NMF
40NMF
80NMF
160NMF
320NMF
ND CAPTAIN RANGE
10NMC
20NMC
40NMC
80NMC
160NMC
320NMC
ARCF
PLANF
RVORF
RNAVF
RENGF
ND CAPTAIN MODE
ARCC
PLANC
RVORC
RNAVC
RENGC
RADSTBY
RADWEAT
RADMAP
RADCONT
RADTEST
RADTURB
RADWXRTURB
RADWSHR
10:33:00 10:33:20 10:33:40 10:34:00 10:34:20 10:34:40 10:35:00 10:35:20 10:35:40 10:36:00 10:36:20
TEMPS(H)
MR1 : P0733V0041DFDR
A/C : A330- MSN 0733 FLIGHT No 0041