Nature: 616 November 2, 1946
Nature: 616 November 2, 1946
Nature: 616 November 2, 1946
158
~
l of August. Under the title,
by a map and classified list of archreological sites in ' ms- tis Mutandis", Dr. Allan advocates
Illinois at the beginning. It would have been easier tea.chin n the musemn and less congestion of
to follow had the descriptions of sites been arranged e ibits, and he is of the opinion that museums
in some intelligible kind . of order, segregating those should not strive to increase already immense collec-
of various cultures. The introduction says that it tions. " To perform its function adequately," he says,
was impossible to include the maps and diagrams of "each museum, large or small, must adopt a plan and
the sites ; the inclusion of at least some of them work it out. It is not enough merely to tidy-up a
wou11f undoubtedly have been an advantage. museum; it ,must be put into working order; it.
'?>\''
IN a rece
.
Mineral-insulated Metal-sheathed Conductors
bli d paper (J. Inst. Elec. Eng.,
must show less and ·teach more." H e also appeals
for the establishment of special museums to demon-
strate the history and applications of British mech-
93, Par~ . .1946),Messrs. F. W. Tomlinson anical invention and engineering, mining and agricul-
and H. . iscuss the development and uses ture, and looks for the further development of folk
o~~al-sheat conductors employing as insulating museums so that there may be one to each distinctive
~:~ highl ompressed magnesium oxide powder. region of the British Isles.
In consequen of the high-temperature stability
and the good insulating properties of this material, Economics of International Trade i(b
these conductors have found wide application as o. 7, "International Trade", in the
electrical heating elements in radiant boiler-plates rward" series issued by the Royal
and as power supply cables in circumstances where International Affairs, G. A. Duncan
the avoidance of fire -risk is of special importance, poin t that international trade between two
or where the ambient temperature or atmospheric
c ! : s really means a multitude of independent
conditions are too severe for other types of electric t ctions linked by nothing more serious than the
cable. The low dielectric loss exhibited by magnesium a ent that their participants happen to live in
oxide at very high frequencies, combined with the two politically defined areas ; hence, while all the
other advantageous characteristics mentioned, has problems, spurious as well as real, would still be there
also enabled specially designed cables to be used for if the world··was politically unified, they would not
certSll important radar purposes. be linked up with political units and. political power.
He then attempts to set out the nature of the principal
Status tof Transl tions and Translators questions that arise on the assumption , that one
et "On Translations", reprinted from State, one supreme political government, e~braces
rs, Sir Stanley Unwin directs attention the whole earth. The complications i.n,troduced by
he problems arising in translation from the existence of sixty-odd sovereign and independent
a to another, and to inadequacies and States are then considered, and the conditions precedent
ies still encountered, although during the to the revival and growth of international trade in
p "rty years the quality of translations into the post-war world are indicated. International trade,
En h and the status of translators have steadily Mr. Duncan argues, consists of an economic sub-
improved (London: Allen and Unwin, Ltd. Pp. 8. stratum overlaid by a political scum. The economic
6d. net). Sir Stanley emphasizes that first and fore- reality is that the real welfare of the world's human
most the translator should be adequately paid, and population is a function of the optimum use of its
payment for translation should be a first charge, diversified resources-mineral, vegetable, animal and
taking precedence over the author's remuneration. human-under contemporary conditions of technical
The translator's name should always be given, pro- knowledge.
vided it is his (or her) exclusive work, an'tl it should The optimum pattern, according to Mr. Duncan,
b e a universal practice to print, on the back of the is not a matter of merely technical comparison, but
title-page of any translation, the title of the original of economic balancing, taking into account differing
wbrk. The best remedy for'mistranslation and for valuations of r esources in differing areas, and the
deliberate tampering with the text is informed correct distribution can only be determined by the
criticism ; bad translations should be denounced. empirical method of competition, which continually
Authors should help by giving preference to pub- presents the dilemma of .choice between immediate,
lishers who take pride in the quality of their trans- loca lized and vocal loss, and more distant, diffused
lations and maintain a high standard ; but while and inarticulate gain. The competitive process can
the publication of translations is in general more only yield its dividends when it is a.Ho.wed to proceed
speculative than the issue of original work, Sir so far as possible on economic grounds. The political
Stanley does not agree that the publication of trans- scum consists of the arbitrary importance attached
lations should be financed by governments. If, to trade crossing political frontiers and to the signi-
however, for commercial reasons any work of out- ficance of partial calculations about its component
standing importance had remained untranslated for, elements ; the tendency to think of international
say, five years, governments would be well advised trade as trade between definable political entities
to offer to bear the cost of translation, if a publisher instead of an arithmetical accident ; and the invasion
was willing in that event to produce the work at his of economic problems by notions of political power
own. risk and expense. The pamphlet also includes and prestige. The problem for economic statesman-
some notes on "Our Universal Language", which ship in the next few years, he concludes, is that of
stress the importance of the new demand for British · working out by common agreement a form .a nd
books. extent of political impositions upon international