TransLink - Draft Strategic Framework For Consultation On Regional Transportation Strategy
TransLink - Draft Strategic Framework For Consultation On Regional Transportation Strategy
TransLink - Draft Strategic Framework For Consultation On Regional Transportation Strategy
Metro Vancouver is, by every measure, one of the most liveable regions in the world. It is beautiful, prosperous and, by global urban standards, environmentally pristine. One of the regions enduring strengths is its consistent vision for regional growth management that is supported and reinforced by an effective transportation system. Metro Vancouver introduced its first Livable Region Plan in 1975, setting out an urban development pattern that would serve the people and save the land. Given the regions limited land base and its rapidly growing population, the leaders of the day and all those since resolved to focus growth and development in a series of compact centres that would be easy to get around and would allow for the preservation of the parks, natural spaces and agricultural lands that enhance our quality of life.
1975 Livable Region Plan
To help realize this vision, TransLink was founded in 1999 as an integrated, multi-modal, regional transportation authority to provide a regional transportation system that moves people and goods and supports: 1. the goals of the Regional Growth Strategy (successors to the Livable Region Plan); 2. regional economic development; and 3. regional and provincial environmental objectives. In service to these goals, TransLink is in the process of updating the current Regional Transportation Strategy, Transport 2040. Over the coming year, and working in collaboration with its partners and the public, TransLink will reconsider, refine and seek broad agreement on a transportation action plan that will help maintain Metro Vancouvers position as one of the best places in the world to live.
1
3. A region where air is clean and the land and the people are healthy
Transportation is a major source of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in BC. The BC Climate Action Plan aims to reduce GHGs by 33% by 2020 and by 80% by 2050, from 2007 levels. Motor vehicle traffic is also the principal regional source of hazardous air contaminants. Metro Vancouvers Integrated Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas Management Plan set goals to protect public health and the environment; improve visual air quality; and minimize the contribution to global climate change. The Regional Transportation Strategy can help achieve these objectives by creating and supporting a cleaner, more efficient transportation system.
A Challenge
Over the next 30 years, Metro Vancouver is expected to welcome one million additional residents, adding 500,000 jobs and three million more passenger trips every day. Bumped up against mountains, an ocean, an international border and a protected agricultural zone, there is little room to continue expanding outwards, little room to accommodate all of these additional trips by car. The economic reality has also changed. The 2008 recession was not so much a bump in the road as a shift in gears. The new economy can still be healthy. It will still expand. There are promising signs that senior levels of government are committed to supporting public transportation. But in general, individuals, businesses
2
and governments are all looking more carefully at large new spending proposals. Our challenge as we work to improve our quality of life even as we increase our population is to make communities and the transportation system work better, and do so at a cost that taxpayers find affordable.
and an Opportunity
We have demonstrated already that this is possible. Metro Vancouver is a continental leader in building compact, complete communities that enable people to live closer to their work, to the services they need and the amenities they want. And residents have an increasing amount of choice in how they get around. More than 90% of the places where people live and work in Metro Vancouver can be reached by public transit a much higher level than most comparably sized regions in North America. Now we need to raise the bar and to set two clear and measurable headline targets that we can use to track our progress. First, in Transport 2040 the region agreed that the most affordable and efficient way of achieving our livability, environmental and economic goals would be to make it possible for people to make half of all trips by walking, cycling, and transit. These are the lowest-cost and lowest-impact forms of transportation. They require the least land, inflict the least environmental impact, have the greatest economic payback, and, in the case of walking and cycling, they actually promote the active lifestyles that contribute to personal and community good health. If we can achieve this target by 2045, we will be able to accommodate population growth and maintain or improve travel-time reliability for commuters and importantly for goods movement on the regional road system, even in the face of physical and economic constraints.
The second headline target will measure our success in getting people closer to jobs and services and, again, ensuring the smooth flow of traffic to enable efficient goods movement within and through Metro Vancouver. It is: to reduce distances driven by one-third. If we achieve both these targets, by 2045, people, goods and services will all spend less time, energy, money and hassle moving around, improving quality of life, protecting the environment, and supporting a prosperous economy.
3
RETHINKING TRANSPORTATION
It must be clear, in thinking about transportation policy, that we are not trying to build a transportation system; the goal is to support a vibrant, sustainable, prosperous and healthy community. To this end, TransLink is an essential service provider: it is one of the most complex multi-modal transportation authorities in North America. But it is just one partner in a region-wide collaboration. TransLink can build roads, bridges and rapid transit lines, it can buy and operate buses, trains and seabuses, it can provide funding to build walkways, bikeways and roadways. It can help promote, coordinate, and organize. But others have the responsibility and authority to make decisions about land use, to manage and direct development, to raise or assign funds for transportation investments and to establish some of the pricing mechanisms that will make those investments pay bigger dividends. In an era of increasing fiscal constraint, the best opportunities that lay before us will be found in cooperation. We must make commitments to Invest, Manage and Partner concurrently. We cant do any one of these in isolation.
to help make travel decisions that work best for them and for the system. Pricing is about giving travellers more choice and value. In 1993 Metro Vancouver adopted a regional transportation strategy that included commitments to road pricing. More recently, Transport 2040 and the Regional Growth Strategy reaffirmed this policy direction. In 2013, the Mayors Council supported user fees to shape demand and recommended exploring implementation of road pricing in this region. TransLink can make some of these changes independently, for example by establishing transit prices that more accurately reflect demand by time of day, location or distance travelled, or adjusting its parking parking taxation levels. Other agencies and levels of government have authority over road pricing, some changes for which require legislative approval from the Provincial government. Cooperation between partners will be critical to make new investments affordable and existing infrastructure more efficient and sustainable. Going forward, we need to work to have pricing measures aproved as major investment decisions are made to ensure our system continues to enjoy financial good health, provides maximum benefit to users and, ultimately, delivers us the quality of life we expect. What this means for the region Traffic congestion and overcrowding during peak hours will be reduced, enhancing reliability for highest value trips (e.g. commercial trucks). Those who choose to forego a trip, bundle some trips together, travel at a less busy time, use a less busy route, or travel by another mode, will be rewarded with savings in time and money. A challenge that needs to be addressed will be potential increased costs for some users who are not able to change their travel patterns. In addition, the technical and administrative challenge of collecting user fees must be considered.
Figure 1 - Major Roads, Highways and Gateways, 30-Year Concept from Transport 2040 (2008) with confirmed regional priorities (2013)
Figure 2 Regional Transit Network, 30-Year Concept from Transport 2040 (2008) with confirmed regional priorities (2013)
Goals
Make transportation decisions that: Choice People Economy Environment 1. Support Sustainable Transportation Choices 2. Foster Safe and Healthy Communities 3. Enable a Sustainable and Resilient Economy 4. Protect the Environment
Headline Targets
As a region, we can best achieve these goals by designing our communities and transportation system in a way that allows us to reduce distances driven by one-third and by making it possible for people to make half of all trips by walking, cycling, and transit. Achieving these targets will benefit everyone by: Making travel more reliable Giving people and businesses more transportation choices Making it easier and less stressful to get to work and school Giving us more time for doing the things we love Ensuring businesses continue to prosper with better access to more workers and more markets Making living, working and doing business in this region more affordable Giving people better access to more jobs and more opportunities Making our roads safer Helping us live healthier and more active lives, reducing the burden on the healthcare system Helping us get out on the sidewalk to meet our neighbours and deter crime Making the air we breathe cleaner Protecting our climate by meeting our greenhouse gas reduction targets
10
PROPOSED PRINCIPLES
We commit to advancing transportation solutions that are: 1. Outcome-Driven In planning and decision-making, we will set regional priorities together and make spending and policy decisions based on an assessment of the best ways to achieve the outcomes we all agree that we want. In this assessment, we will consider all solutions on an equal footing. For example, we will compare demand management solutions on par with strategies to increase capacity. We will give equal consideration to the choices between and the potential to integrate different modes walking, cycling, driving and all forms of transit. And we will assess capital budget decisions along with operating budget decisions against our long term goals. 2. Seamless The regional transportation system is a quilt of components managed by different jurisdictions, and changes in transportation infrastructure or land use in one part of the region can affect the entire system. Users have a right to expect that the system will be managed seamlessly, efficiently and responsibly. 3. Resilient We will recognize our vulnerability to forces beyond our control (e.g. global economy, natural disasters, technological change, fuel prices), seeking out and prioritizing solutions that best prepare us for a range of possible futures and not just the future we think is most likely today. 4. Affordable We will continue to invest over the long term to meet the diverse needs of all parts of the region. As we implement initiatives, we are mindful of other needs regional priorities such as water, sewer and parks, and broader ones such heath and education. There are limited dollars and one taxpayer. We will design investment plans that can be implemented in a timely way and that have public support for both the level and sources of funding.
11
Each of these levers has implications for the entire transportation system, relating to the movement of both people and goods. For example, if more people ride their bicycles, they free up more road space for car commuters and trucks moving goods. If car drivers change their hours, they can reduce peakhour congestion, thereby delaying the need to build new infrastructure, or removing the need altogether.
Moving People
By helping to reduce trip distances and increase the opportunities for people to walk, cycle and take transit, transportation investments can support growth in Urban Centres and along frequent transit corridors. Accurate pricing for transit and driving can also help reduce congestion and increase fairness. The goal is a system that enables people to walk, cycle, take transit or drive safely, comfortably and without major congestion, crowding or delays.
Moving Goods
Given the critical nature of goods movement to the local economy and to Metro Vancouvers function as Canadas Pacific Gateway, we can help protect industrial land, support safety improvements for rail and trucks, help to streamline regulations, support pricing to reduce congestion on the road network and make room for high-value commercial vehicle trips, and work together to coordinate regional planning. We can provide new road capacity where necessary to ensure that goods can move in a timely and reliable way, around and through Metro Vancouver.
12
1.
Understanding what land uses and demand-management measures are in place and anticipated for the future will provide us with a good idea of what investment is needed, where and when. We will maintain the system to ensure its safety, reliability and resilience. Where basic networks are incomplete or supply is insufficient to meet demand, we will consider expansion in a way that achieves our goals as costeffectively as possible. 1.1. Maintain what is needed in a state of good repair
Maintenance costs will continue to grow as the system ages and expands. It is important to use strategic asset management principles to keep infrastructure in a safe and functional condition. Key actions include working with partners to: Evaluate an assets condition, vulnerability and importance to the performance of the transportation system when balancing state-of-good repair funding against other investment priorities. Upgrade infrastructure to respond to climate and seismic risks. 1.2. Make early investments to complete the walkway and bikeway networks
Walking and cycling are low-cost, emission-free, energy efficient, and space efficient. Walking and cycling also lead to better public health and safer roads for all users. Parts of this region still have major gaps in the walkway network. This region was also late to invest in cycling infrastructure, so there is a shortage of traffic-protected bikeways which are needed to support more cycling by people of all ages and abilities. Walkways and bikeways are predominantly on municipal networks. TransLink plays in important role by supporting municipal investments that move us towards are regional goals. Key actions include working with partners to: As a near-term regional priority for investment, invest in the walkway network to strategically improve connectivity, especially connecting to and within the Frequent Transit Network. As a near-term regional priority for investment, make significant and early investment to complete the bikeway network, as outlined in the Regional Cycling Strategy, with a focus on Class 1 facilities in Urban Centres and other high cycling potential areas. 1.3. Invest in the road network to improve safety, local access, and goods movement
The regions roads form the foundation of the transportation network, carrying people, goods and services by foot, bicycle, bus, car and truck. For our transportation system to work well, we need our roads to work well. Beyond the need to maintain our infrastructure in a state of good repair, we propose to support additional investments in streets, roads, and bridges for three main reasons: to improve safety, increase connectivity, and improve goods movement. Key actions include working with partners to: ensure the effectiveness of road investments by making concurrent commitments to appropriate optimization actions (see Strategy 2.3), pricing measures (see Strategy 2.4); and land use measures (see Strategy 3.4) Increase road connectivity in support of better local access, especially in Urban Centres and FTDAs Make infrastructure changes that improve road safety
13
Provide additional capacity where needed to improve travel time reliability on key goods movement corridors in a way that does not increase general purpose traffic. Find and implement a long-term solution for the Pattullo Bridge Find and implement a long-term solution to address goods movement along the north shore of the Fraser River. Work with the Province to ensure a replacement to the Massey Tunnel is integrated with the regional network and supports regional goals. 1.4. Make investments in the transit network to increase ridership
The cost-effectiveness of transit routes vary depending on the demand, which is generally a factor of nearby land use. The highest and most balanced transit demand comes from within transit-oriented communities or that connect such centres on well-populated major routes. These high-demand areas tend to have a finer-grained network of well-connected streets, higher densities, diverse mixes of land uses, pedestrian- and bicycle-friendly design, and priced or managed parking. Sparsely populated communities, on the other hand, generate little demand and are more costly to service. In 2008, TransLink identified a Frequent Transit Network within which it could more affordably provide service every 15 minutes or less, throughout the day, seven days a week. Further, by shifting resources from high-cost, low-ridership routes to the FTN, it was also able to increase ridership for the same or less investment. In future, the direction is to continue to direct resources to the FTN to increase ridership; and to expand the FTN level of service in areas where demand has increased adequately or where commitments to a level of development can be expected to create such demand. Key actions include working with partners to: ensure the effectiveness of transit investments by making concurrent commitments to appropriate optimization actions (see Strategy 2.3), pricing measures (see Strategy 2.4); and land use measures (see Strategy 3.4) Invest in future transit service on the basis of performance with productivity targets guiding investment in ridership-focused service and extent of coverage guiding investment in basic access service. For ridership-focused service, focus on matching service levels with current transit demand. Where demand is predicted to grow in the future, based on committed plans and reasonable level of surety, provide higher service levels in advance of demand. Develop and communicate meaningful, manageable, and measureable transit service standards. Use development review process to align expectations for transit in planned communities with service standards. Complete high-priority rapid transit projects including the Broadway-UBC corridor, Burnaby mountain/SFU, Expo Line upgrades, and Surrey (104th Ave, Fraser Hwy, and King George Blvd). 1.5. Ensure the continued provision of basic access transit service in low-demand neighbourhoods
While working to maximize ridership and, therefore, the value and affordability of existing infrastructure, TransLink has maintained basic access service in low-demand neighbourhoods for those with few mobility options. Key actions include working with partners to: Maintain basic access services in stable, low-demand areas where use stays above a critical threshold, based on meaningful, manageable, and measureable transit service standards.
14
15
16
2.
Metro Vancouvers integrated transportation system offers users a complex array of choices for every trip. To help people and businesses make choices that are best for them and for the transportation system requires excellence in design, regulation and pricing and in making available the information that will give individuals and businesses a better travel experience and help them make efficient travel choices. Technology and supply-management solutions can also make the transportation system more space and energy efficient. 2.1. Make travel safe and secure for all users
The transportation system should be designed so that people and businesses can use it as safely and securely as possible and free of fear from harm. There are many things we can do to make travel less stressful, more comfortable and even enjoyable. Key actions include working with partners to: Support laws, enforcement, skills, training and designs that improve road safety and protect vulnerable road users. Use physical design and enforcement to deter crime. Be prepared to respond effectively in the event of natural disasters and other emergencies. 2.2. Make travel easy and attractive for all users
The transportation system should be as accommodating as possible, so that people of all ages and abilities can move about the region independently, with confidence and in comfort. Key actions include working with partners to: Design for universal accessibility. Offer protection from the elements and provide places to rest. Provide incentives, marketing, information, and support programs to help make travel easier for people and for businesses moving goods and services. Provide on-demand access to a full range of transportation services with the Compass Card. Make it easy to share by supporting car-sharing, ride-sharing, bike-sharing and taxis. Make the transportation system easy to understand and navigate, with a consistent region-wide wayfinding system and real-time travel information for all modes. 2.3. Optimize roads and transit for efficiency, safety and reliability
System optimization is about using technology and management solutions to operate our road and transit networks more efficiently, safely and reliably. We need to make the most of what we have before pursuing major investment in expansion. Key actions include working with partners to: Continue to reallocate savings from system efficiency measures into initiatives that most costeffectively achieve regional transportation goals. Integrate Intelligent Transportation Systems, incident management, road works management, lane management, and signal priority for goods and transit. Explore possible opportunities and impacts of new vehicle technologies including low-carbon, connected, and self-driving.
17
Assess site-specific road usage and, as a priority, reallocate road space where appropriate to improve capacity, safety and reliability for walking, cycling, transit and goods movement. 2.4. Price roads and transit for fairness, efficiency and revenue
Aligning the pricing of transportation with the full cost of providing it makes the system fairer since people pay more closely for what they use. It can make the system more efficient and reliable by spreading demand to less busy times, routes, and modes. It can also help raise revenue to pay for the system. TransLink can institute pricing changes directly on transit fares and can administer and finetune the road-related pricing mechanisms that must be established, approved or legislated at the municipal or Provincial government levels. Key actions include working with partners to: Link pricing decisions to investment commitments. Adopt a transit fare structure that allows for more fine-grained variation in prices based on time, distance travelled or location. Undertake a near-term field study and supporting technical work to understand the impacts and implementation requirements of a region-wide road pricing system. Support a region-wide road pricing system that allows for more fine-grained variation in prices based on time, distance travelled or location. Introduce road user pricing concurrent with the introduction of major transportation investment to reflect user value and to incent appropriate choices. 2.5. Manage parking for fairness, efficiency and revenue
Bicycles and cars both need places to park at the beginning and ends of their trips. While the shortage of bicycle parking across the region discourages some people from cycling, abundant and frequently free automobile parking is often an invitation to drive for even the shortest of trip. Actively managing, pricing, and right-sizing parking can improve convenience and reliability by ensuring parking is available when and where you need it, thereby reducing congestion in Urban Centres from cars circling for parking, improving housing affordability, and supporting more compact transit-oriented communities. Key actions include working with partners to: Install sufficient bicycle parking in Urban Centres and Frequent Transit Development Areas. Ensure that automobile parking requirements are not excessive and reflect availability of walking, cycling, and transit options. Unbundle costs for auto parking and commercial and/or residential space. Use pricing and/or time limits to make most efficient use of on-street and off-street parking in Urban Centres and Frequent Transit Development Areas. Facilitate area-wide parking management and other opportunities for shared parking.
18
3.
To make our plans a reality, they need sufficient funding and strong partnerships. To ensure that our collective actions are effective, we need consistent monitoring and evaluation. 3.1. Establish funding that is stable, sufficient, appropriate and influences travel choices
Many of the initiatives described above need money especially for major road and transit expansion and ongoing operations. In order to make these things happen, we need a mix of revenue tools that provide funding that is stable and predictable over the long-term. We need sufficient financial capacity to deliver on our plans and the public support to use this capacity. We also have the opportunity to explore innovative funding approaches to reinforce our goals for managing and focusing regional growth, and for encouraging efficient travel. The Mayors Council on Regional Transportation has set forth transportation funding principles, including: o Transportation should be priced more accurately to better align behaviour and transportation objectives. o Transit fare rates should be sensitive to public affordability. o Funding should be generated from the goods movement sector to recognize the costs. o The proportion of funding from property taxes should not increase. o Collectively, funding sources should be reliable and predictable, but adjustable against each other. o Funding options should be economically efficient in their administration and collection. o As newer, more effective revenue sources are introduced, reductions should be considered for funding sources that are less consistent with these principles. The Government of British Columbia has specified that new transportation funding mechanisms should take into account the following considerations: o Affordability for families; o Effects on the provincial economy; o Revenue generation across the region; o Ability for TransLink to share in the local benefit of transit investments. TransLink supports the principles laid out by the Mayors Council and Government of British Columbia. TransLink will continue to work towards these and advocate for approaches that provide funding that is stable, sufficient and appropriate to the travel choices the region seeks to encourage. On land use, on most pricing decisions and on any substantive changes to the funding sources and amounts, TransLink relies up its municipal partners and on senior levels of government for support and cooperation. Key actions include working with partners to: Advocate and advance immediate and longer-term transportation funding solutions that reflect the principles set forth by the Mayors Council and the Province. Develop a sustainable funding strategy that responds to the trends affecting TransLinks existing revenue sources, and supports goals for managing transportation demand. Balance contributions from users of the transportation system and from broad-based sources, to ensure stable and resilient revenue.
19
Enable policy-based adjustments to funding rates and sources over time, to account for changes in travel patterns and other trends. Advocate for regional transportation needs at the provincial and national level and continue to pursue transportation funding from senior levels of government. Continue to broaden TransLinks non-transportation revenue base from real estate, advertising, and commercial partnerships. 3.2. Monitor progress towards our desired outcomes
Performance-based decisions require good data. Monitoring and evaluation are essential to assess progress towards our goals, and to help understand how initiatives are performing and how different options might perform in the future. Key actions include working with partners to: Establish a robust and coordinated system of monitoring, evaluation, and reporting, including feedback loops to adjust course as necessary. Build into funding framework the ability to adjust the mix and rates of different revenue tools to respond to changes in behaviour. Collaborate with partners to continuously improve data collection and evaluation tools. Make transportation data available in an open format whenever possible to enable third-party analysis and tool development. 3.3. Ensure effective coordination through strong partnerships
Making progress on these strategies and actions will require coordinated effort from many partners, including governments, the private sector, labour, community organizations and residents. We can work to improve Metro Vancouvers record of inter-governmental coordination by establishing stronger partnerships and making reciprocal commitments to deliver the policy measures, land use changes or investments needed to get the best performance from each solution. This coordination will provide greater certainty about who will do what and under what conditions. TransLink is uniquely positioned to help coordinate these efforts. Key actions include working with partners to: Convene and facilitate ongoing regional dialogue through stakeholder forums, standing advisory committees, and a goods movement council. Advocate for the development of a regional economic development strategy that clearly articulates actions related to transportation. Develop strategies to ensure a skilled and qualified labour force to plan, build, operate and maintain the transportation system.
20
3.4.
It is important to get jobs, housing and major trip generators in the right locations to facilitate shorter trips and more trips by walking, cycling, and transit. In this region, municipalities are responsible for local land use planning which must be consistent with Metro Vancouvers Regional Growth Strategy. In 2011, TransLink endorsed the Regional Growth Strategy and its commitments including policies to focus growth in Urban Centres, Frequent Transit Development Areas and along the Frequent Transit Network within a clearly defined Urban Containment Boundary. It also contains policies to protect industrial land and industrial uses. Through investing, managing and partnering to deliver the regional transportation system, we can reinforce these regional land use objectives. Key actions include working with partners to: Continue to support and implementation the transportation-related actions, including those requested of TransLink, contained in the Regional Growth Strategy Make commitments to supportive land use concurrent with investment commitments. Establish mechanisms such as partnership agreements and joint planning to provide greater certainty around expected land use, policies and investments. Develop corridor and area plans, and provide supportive funding, to improve access to and within frequent transit areas Encourage affordable and rental housing along the Frequent Transit Network.Continue to develop and communicate resources to help support local governments and the development community in the implementation of transit oriented communities.
21