Book Analysis - Who Killed Karkare The Real Face of Terrorism in India
Book Analysis - Who Killed Karkare The Real Face of Terrorism in India
Book Analysis - Who Killed Karkare The Real Face of Terrorism in India
RESTD
1. Name of Book: Who Killed Karkare: The real face of terrorism in India
4. Publisher Name: Pharos Media & Publishing Pvt Limited, New Delhi, India.
5. ISBN-10: 81-7221-036-1
6. Theme of the Book. To tell a truth in front of a tyrant ruler is the biggest crusade
in the sight of Lord. And perhaps, this saying sounds so true to Mr. S M Mushrif (retired
IPS officer – former IGP Maharashtra) when he wrote his book ‘Who killed Karkare?’
This book comes out with some startling facts and analysis to expose the real actors
behind the so called “Islamic Terrorism” in india whose greatest feat was to murder the
Maharashtra ATS chief Hermant Karkare who dared to expose these forces and paid
with his life.According to Mushrif, The Taj-Oberoy-Trident was completely different from
the one at Cama and Rangbhavan lanes. The terror attack could had been avoided if it
had been coordinated correctly and in an efficient way. The main players in this game
have been the Brahiminist – a very small section among Brahmins, the Brahminist
dominated IB and a part of media that is controlled by the media. The main agenda
which the writer tries to put forward is the ultimate control of the Brahiminists over Indian
society and they perceived Hermant Karkare to be a threat to be their design of gaining
hegemony over Indian society.
RESTD
2
RESTD
7. Details of Chapter
Muslims ruled India for almost 700 years, but there is not a single example
Hindus against the Muslim rulers instead they were helped in managing
Brahmins and muslims fought together, and it were them who declared
Mughal Emperor Bahadur Zafar as their king, but what led to the series of
communal riots since 1893, was the reformist movements in some areas
Muslims, which was met with success, which later led to the formation of
and well organized structure. To take the objective above, RSS decided to
take over two important institutions, Media and Intelligence. Media was
used to carry out the brahminist agenda that was hatred against muslims
RESTD
3
RESTD
controlled the important posts, it set out to implement the RSS agenda
and had been successful over the years. It kept the government in dark
about the communal activities of RSS and its front organization, and other
leftist and secular parties were dealt in a different way. They have been as
committed to the cause as before. There was not a single muslim officer in
RSS along with other violent and communal subsidiaries had pledged to
The 2002 Gujarat riots, also known as the 2002 Gujarat violence and the
Gujarat pogrom was universally condemned all over the world. They
switched the gears from communal riots to Muslim terrorism .IB started
spreading such rumours to implicate that muslims are a real threat to the
country. Such news were circulated in the media which led to many fake
no proof or historical record of Muslim terrorism in india, its all been done
activities of RSS, VHP, and Bajrang Dal. If IB had done its job, many
RESTD
4
RESTD
. It’s been seen that every bomb blast case in the country during last few
outfits like the LeT, HuJI, SIMI. IB takes over the investigation of every
bomb blast. With the amount of power and resources at its command, IB
evidence or for joining the important missing links in any blast, encounters
come in very handy for the IB. The safest place for an “encounter” is
Kashmir, which nobody can question. If the leads are likely to implicate
logical end as happened in the case of Mumbai Train bomb blast of 2006,
RESTD
5
RESTD
The police see the hand of the “sleeper cell” of the SIMI in the
blasts that rocked the country. Firstly IB quoted that it was the work
of SIMI and later JeT accepted the responsibility. There were many
loop holes in the investigation of the case.
In the bomb blast, atleast 68 people were killed, and both the
countries started blaming each other for the tragedy. Haryana
Police claimed of solving the case, by hinting out the suitcases and
the shop from where they were bought. ATS stepped in, and after
the nacro-analysis test of Lt. Col. Purohit with connection of
RESTD
6
RESTD
The Nanded bomb blast case of April 2006 was a self detected case, in
which the terroris belong to the Brahminist organization. The case was
Bajrang dal and Sangh Parivar in their connection with terror network. The
with other bomb blasts, and creating an anti muslim atmosphere as they
were all hard core brahminists. The accused got training by the VHP and
Bajrang dal camp. But all the evidences were utilized properly, and the
RESTD
7
RESTD
The writer here did not want to discuss who were behind the Mumbai
attack, but planned or executed it, the fact remains that Taj-Oberai trident
part was a reailty but the CST-CAMA Ranghabavan lane episode is
shrouded in a thick mystery. Following are some news report which would
help in making logical analysis
RESTD
8
RESTD
(c) Kasab did not received any call from handlers in India:
During the 58 hours of the siege, gunmen received atleast 284 calls
but not a single call was received by Ajmal Kasab and Ismael Khan,
thus it reaffirmed that these were not the part of the group of
terrorist who came from Pakistan in a tawler and landed at Cuffe
Parade.
RESTD
9
RESTD
Nepalese forces. The theory that Ajmal Kasab was not among the
group of terrorist was further proven by the fact that one of area
residents ie Anita Rajendra Uddaiya had seen six people but
refused to identify Ajmal Kasab.
The real terrorists had left so many traces like the GPS devices and
satellite phones and the records of the calls made by them to their
handlers in Pakistan, so IB resort to manipulative evidence like
DNA samples and chance finger prints.
RESTD
10
RESTD
attack to be barred.
2009. The 11,280 page charge sheet heavily relied on the evidence
the hackers.
Now that ball was in the court, the question is what would the court
do. Brahimist forces have already announced the verdict for the
i. IB:
RESTD
11
RESTD
career, so just for that sake they were obeying their orders
Careful analysis would indicate the invisible thread of Brahiminists forces role in
communal violence in india:
(a) The first preplanned Hindu Muslim riots was caused by Maharashtrian
Brahminists in 1893
(b) Brahminists organizations like RSS and Bajrang Dal were founded in
Maharashtra.
(d) The founder and the first chief of RSS was Dr Hedgewar who belong to
Maharashtra.
RESTD
12
RESTD
(a) IB kept the government in dark about the activities of the Brahminist
organizations like RSS.
(b) It projected RSS as a nationalist organization.
(c) It had a different policy for leftist and secular organizations.
(d) The IB connived as the assassination of the father of the nation.
(e) IB was not able to curb communal riots.
(f) IB had willfully maligned Muslim community.
(g) IB justifies extrajudicial killings as “encounters”.
(h) IB intentionally blocked the extremely important information about
Mumbai terror attack.
(i) IB has a suspicious role CST-CAMA-Rangabhavan lane part of the
attack.
8. Analysis
b. Analysis of the Book. Karkare was not killed by terrorists from Pakistan
as this opinion was formed on the basis of systematic analysis of
newspaper reports media reports. But as these were just media reports,
there was not substantial evidence like some hard documents to prove the
RESTD
13
RESTD
analysis he derived from each segment of the event. The book covered
each aspect of the event in a systematic manner that the reader had no
difficulty in painting the picture of that event in his mind. Mushrif's book
was not banned is an evidence enough that its contents were too volcanic
for any agency or government to suppress.
RESTD