Voodoo Dolls in The Classical World
Voodoo Dolls in The Classical World
Voodoo Dolls in The Classical World
GYÖRGY NÉMETH
Abstract: Magic dolls play a major role in ancient literature when Greek or Roman au-
thors describe the activity of sorcerers or witches. Another group of sources applying
magic puppets includes inscriptions and magical papyri, which may contain recipes or
prescriptions and obviously provide a more authentic image of magical procedures than
poetry does. The credibility of written sources can be tested by a fortunately growing
number of magic dolls found in excavations. Still, the picture emerging from dolls and
their finding circumstances hardly matches the magical operations implied by literary
sources.
Key words: voodoo dolls, magical puppets, ancient magic, curse tablets.
Ancient magic dolls are known from four distinct groups of sources: inscriptions,
literary works, papyrus recipes, and the growing number of original figurines found in
excavations1. It is also worth examining the well-documented finding circumstances of
recently uncovered puppets.
The earliest extant reference to magic dolls is made in the foundation oath of the settlers
of Cyrene2. Although the text of the oath was formulated in the 6th c. BC, it is preserved
to us in a 4th c. BC inscription. Another inscription from Cyrene (around 300 BC) describ-
ing an apotropaic procedure mentions two figurines of wood or clay. A third inscription
from the 2nd c. AD suggests that a wax statue made by the evil sorcerer should be demol-
ished to avert an epidemic.
As for literary sources referring to dolls, we have a Sophocles-fragment (5th c. BC)
and a slightly more detailed description from Plato (4th c. BC). Theocritus’ poem is Hel-
lenistic, while the rest of our literary sources come from late republican Rome and from
the Imperial Era3.
Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest
nemeth.gyorgy@caesar.elte.hu
1
The following paper was supported by the research project „Procesos de aculturación religiosa en
el mundo antiguo y en la América colonial: un análisis comparativo de la retórica y la construc-
ción de la alteridad” (HAR2014-56067-P) and by "Research on ancient magic II: magical gems"
(OTKA K 119979).
2
The Egyptian origin of magic puppets is addressed in another paper, Németh 2017.
3
I did not include the chameleon mentioned by Libanius 1.249 in my list, since it was a genuine animal
the remains of which were applied to baleful sorcery. Ogden treated it as a voodoo doll, see Ogden
2009, 259. I also ignore the Christian legend narrating the conversion of St. Cyprian, see Ogden
2009, 329–331.
180 György Németh
4
Ogden 2009, 245.
5
Hesychius s.v. “melted” [aistôsas]), see Ogden 2009, 83.
6
Ogden 2009, 22.
7
Ogden 2009, 109.
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 181
drop their white crap on my head, may Julius come to piss and shit on me, and so too the
feeble Pedatia and the thief Voranus. Why should I go through all the details? Why should
I tell you how the ghosts held a conversation with Sagana, making mournful, shrill noises;
how they secretly hid a wolf’s beard together with a tooth from a variegated snake in the
ground; how the fire flared up higher because of the wax image, and how I shuddered at
the voices and actions of the two Furies, although this witness did not go unavenged?"8
The wax doll was burnt. The fate of the woollen doll is not revealed in the source.
Horatius Epodes 17.
"Or am I, who can animate wax effigies, as you yourself know from interfering, I, who can
snatch the moon down from the sky by my incantations, I, who can raise up the cremated
dead, I, who can blend love potions, am I to weep for my craft not encompassing your
death?"9
The wax doll was ‘animated’.
Vergilius Eclogues 8.80-81.
"As this clay grows hard and as this wax melts in one and the same fire, so may Daphnis
melt in his love for me. Scatter the meal, and burn the crackling bay leaves with pitch.
Wicked Daphnis burns me, so I burn these bay leaves against Daphnis. Bring Daphnis
home, my spells, bring him from the city."10
The wax doll was burnt.
Ovidius Heroides 6.93–94.
"She places binding spells [devovet] on people from afar, molds voodoo dolls out of wax,
and pushes fine needles into their pathetic livers."11
The wax dolls were tortured and presumably burnt as well.
Ovidius Amores 3.7.27–30; 77–80.
"Did my limbs grow heavy, bound [devota] by a Thessalian drug? Was I damaged by a
spell and herbs? Or did a witch bind [defixit] my name with red wax and drive fine needles
through the middle of my liver?"
"Who told you to lay yourself in my bed if you didn’t want to perform, crazy man? Either
some Circean witch [venefica] is binding you by piercing wool, or you come to me after
wearing yourself out by having sex with someone else."
The wax doll and the woollen doll was tortured by needles.
Petronius Satyricon 63.
"You see, the witches had stolen the boy and left a straw doll in his place."
8
Ogden 2009, 115.
9
Ogden 2009, 120.
10
Ogden 2009, 113.
11
Ogden 2009, 126.
182 György Németh
It is questionable if the straw doll left in the place of the boy is really a voodoo
doll or not. Although the doll was fabricated by witches, I presume this is rather a case
of tricky stealing. Nevertheless, D. Ogden treats it as a voodoo doll12.
Laying of attacking ghosts from Cyrene
"Rules for attacking ghosts [hikesioi]. An attacking ghost sent upon one: if ever an attacking
ghost is sent against one’s house, if one knows from whom it comes to attack one, one is
to give name to him, proclaiming the name over three days. If he is dead in the earth, or
dead in some other condition, if one knows his name, one is to proclaim the name. But if
one does not know the name, one is to proclaim “O person, whether you are man or woman.”
He should make dolls [kolossoi], a male one and a female one, from wood or from clay,
entertain them, and set before them helpings of all food. When you have performed the
rites, take the dolls to an unworked forest and fix them there with their helpings."13
The wooden or clay dolls are entertained to dinner, and then taken to an intact forest.
An oracle against pestilence from a Western Anatolian town
"Put her (Artemis) up in a temple, full of joy: she will provide deliverance from your afflic-
tion and will dissolve the poison (or: magic) of pestilence, which destroys men, and will
melt down [8] with her flame-bearing torches in nightly fire the kneaded works of wax, the
signs of the evil art of a sorcerer."14
A wax doll produced by an evil sorcerer induced an epidemic afflicting an Anatolian
town (otherwise not known). Destroying the wax puppet brought the epidemic to an end.
Apuleius Apologia sive de magia. 61.
"And after all this, they have also come up, on reading Pudentilla's letters, concerning the
manufacture of a statuette. This statuette, they assert, I had fashioned of the rarest wood
by some secret process for purposes of the black art. They add that, although it is loathly
and horrible to look upon, being in the form of a skeleton, I yet give it especial honour
and call it in the Greek tongue, basileus, my king."15
As Apuleius claims in his apology, the statuette is in fact not a voodoo doll but an
image of Mercurius.
Lucian Philopseudes 14.
"Eventually, the Hyperborean fashioned an eros-doll from clay and said to it, ‘Off you go,
and bring Chrysis.’ The clay flew aloft, and soon there she was knocking on the door. She
came in and embraced Glaucias as absolutely insane with love, and she slept with him
until we heard the cocks crowing."
12
Ogden 2009, 141.
13
Ogden 2009, 163.
14
Graf 1992, 268–269.
15
Translated by H. E. Butler. See Ogden 2009, 251–252, with a commentary.
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 183
The ‘animated’ clay doll shaping Eros fetches the sweetheart of Glaucias. This story
corresponds to certain recipes in the magical papyri referring to ‘animated’ statuettes16.
Heliodorus Aethiopica 6, 14.
"She made a libation of honey into the pit, another of milk from a second bowl, and another
again of wine from a third bowl. Then she crowned with laurel and fennel a dough cake
molded to resemble a man and threw it into the pit. After all that she took up a sword,
worked herself up a sword, worked herself up into an inspired frenzy and invoked the moon
with names that sounded foreign and strange. She cut her arm open, wiped up some of
the blood with a laurel branch, and threw it into the fire."17
The text describing the most detailed magic scene refers to puppets from dough. The
procedure of the witch’s sorcery is based on the Nekyia of the Odyssey (Book 11).
Pseudo-Callisthenes Alexander romance 1.
"For they say that Nectanebo, the very last of the pharaohs of Egypt, gained mastery over
all peoples by magical power. By speech he could subject all the elements of the universe
to himself. For if a cloud of war had suddenly come upon him, he did not bother with the
army-camp, processions of arms, the sharpening of steel or engines of war, but he would
retreat into his palace, take a bronze bowl, fill it with rain water, and mold some little boats
and little human figures out of wax, put them in the bowl, and recite a spell while waving
an ebony wand. He would call upon the angels and upon Ammon, the god of Libya. So it
was that he would destroy and prevail over the enemies that attacked him, with lecanomancy
of this sort and by <sinking> the boats."18
The story provides a distant echo of an official Egyptian magical practice in the
pharaonic age, during which enemy warriors (perhaps from Libya or Meroe) were moulded
as wax puppets and cast into fire19.
Orphic Argonautica 950.
"When I arrived at the enclosure and the divine abode I dug a triangular pit in some flat
ground. I quickly fetched some logs of juniper, dry cedar, prickly boxthorn and much-lamenting
black poplars, and I made a pyre of them in the pit. Knowledgeable Medea brought many
drugs [pharmaka], taking them from the coffers of an incense-laden crypt. At once I fash-
ioned figures from barley meal. I threw them onto the pyre and slaughtered three all-black
puppies as a sacrifice to the dead."20
The dough puppets are cast into the pit, similarly to the scene in Heliodorus’ novel.
The ultimate source of the scene might be the Nekyia of the Odyssey.
16
PGM XII.14–95.
17
Ogden 2009, 200.
18
Ogden 2009, 55–56.
19
Kákosy 1969; Pinch 2006; Zinn 2013, 4237.
20
Ogden 2009, 92.
184 György Németh
A number of papyri provide a recipe for making a magic doll. The figurine is not always
anthropomorphic: it can also shape a dog, a hippopotamus, or even a three-headed chimaera.
According to recipes, the figurines are manipulated in various ways but they are never
fully destroyed, not even if it was made from wax.
PGM IV. 296-335.
Take some wax or some clay from a potter’s wheel and mould two figures, male and female.
Arm the male one like Ares, brandishing a sword in his left hand and striking the female’s
neck on her right side. Put the female doll’s hands behind her back and make her kneel.
You will fasten the stuff [ousia] on her head or on her neck. Inscribe the doll of the woman
21
An excellent summary for magical papyri: Maltomini 2008.
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 185
being attracted: on her head, “ISEÊ IAÔ ITHI OUNE BRIDÔ LÔTHIÔN NEBOUTO-
SOUALÊTH”; on her right ear, “OUER MÊCHAN”; on her left ear, “LIBABA ÔI-
MATHOTHO”; on her face, “AMOUNABREÔ”; over her right eye, “ÔRORMOTHIO
AÊTH”; over the other one, “CHOBOUE”; on her right collarbone, “ADETA MEROU”;
on her right arm, “ENE PSA ENESGAPH”; on the other one, “MELCHIOU MELCHIEDIA”;
on her hands, “MELCHAMELCHOU AÊL”; on her breast, the name of the woman
being attracted, with her metronymic; over her heart, “BALAMIN THÔOUTH”; under
her stomach, “AOBÊS AÔBAR”; on her vulva, “BLICHIANEOI OUÔIA”; on her bottom,
“PISSADARA”; on the soles of her feet, on the right one, “ELÔ”; on the other one,
“ELÔAIOE.” Take thirteen bronze needles and insert one of them into the brain while
saying, “I pierce your brain (insert her name)”; insert two into her ears, two more into
her eyes, one into her mouth, two below her rib cage, one into her hands, two into her
vulva and anus, and two into the soles of her feet, while on each occasion saying once, “I
pierce the (insert name of part) of (insert her name), so that she may think of no one,
except me alone, (insert your name).” Take a lead tablet, inscribe the same spell on it, and
say it through. Bind the tablet to the figures with the warp from a loom, in which you
have made 365 knots while saying, as you know how to, “Abrasax, constrain her.” Lay it
as the sun sets beside the grave of one untimely dead or dead by violence, and lay flowers
of the season there with it. The inscribed and recited spell is this...22
The recipe prescribes the following manipulations concerning the female magic doll:
1. The arms shall be bound behind her back.
2. Ousia shall be fastened on her head or neck.
3. Magic words shall be inscribed on the doll
4. The doll shall be pierced by 13 bronze needles on specified parts of her body
5. The spell (logos) shall be bound to the doll with a thread with 365 knots.
During this procedure, the magician had to recite continuously the spell and every-
thing he wished to happen to the woman. For sure, not every doll was exposed to all these
actions, but magicians definitely had to perform some manipulation during the course of
the magic rite.
PGM III. 424.
"Take cow's milk and pour it. Put down a clean vessel and place the tablet under [it]; add
barley meal, mix and form bread: twelve rolls in the shape of female figures. Say [the for-
mula] three times, eat [the rolls] on an empty stomach, and you will know the power."23
The female figurines shaped from milk and barley meal had to be eaten on an empty
stomach.
PGM XXIVb. 1-15.
The highly fragmentary text instructed the magician what spells to inscribe on specified
parts of the magic doll24.
22
Ogden 2009, 247–248.
23
Betz 1996, 29.
24
Betz 1996, 264.
186 György Németh
25
Betz 1996, 105.
26
Betz 1996, 321.
27
Betz 1966, 71.
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 187
28
Betz 1996, 81.
29
Pinch 2006, 91.
30
Betz 1996, 81–82.
31
Suarez de la Torre 2011.
32
Betz 1996, 94.
188 György Németh
Magic dolls
The modern starting point of studying ancient magic dolls is an article by C. A. Faraone,
or more precisely its Appendix, which includes 34 groups of finds from the Graeco-Roman
world.36 The decades that have passed since this publication have seen the emergence of
a number of new finds that extended our knowledge on magic dolls considerably. The most
significant find is undoubtedly the magical ensemble of the Anna Perenna sanctuary in
Rome, which contained seven puppets37. One of them is a peculiar item: the doll is attacked
by a snake that is biting its face38. Excavations at the Isis – Mater Magna sanctuary (Mainz)
33
Betz 1996, 98–99.
34
Cf. the prescription on the second Cyrenean inscription.
35
Betz 1996, 181.
36
Faraone 1991, 200–205.
37
Piranomonte 2002; Piranomonte 2012; Piranomonte 2015.
38
Inventory number of the wax doll attacked by snake: 475550. Cf. Sánchez 2015, 194–202.
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 189
yielded three magic dolls39. The study of Hans-Jörg Nüsse is an excellent summary of the
finds from Germania. Recent finds from Great Britain and France are presented by Magali
Bailliot, whose publication also provides us with a detailed description of the finding cir-
cumstances of items uncovered in Germany and Austria40. A surprising number of Romanian
and Moldavian finds are known from the comprehensive work of Valeriu Sîrbu41. However,
the latter volume (written in Romanian) provides little information on finding circum-
stances, therefore international scholarship would find a new, more detailed and linguis-
tically more accessible survey very useful.
The following table presents the provenance of known items and indicates the material
of magic dolls. The data concerning dolls found before 1991 comes from C. A. Faraone’s
mentioned article, whereas the data concerning more recent items is given after the table.
The dolls preserved various marks created during the ritual, providing us with an
insight into the magicians’ workshop. An important type of manipulation is writing vari-
ous names or magic words onto the puppet42. The Mnesimachos doll in a coffin from the
39
Witteyer 2004.
40
Bailliot 2015.
41
Sîrbu 1993, 58–62.
42
This is prescribed by several magical papyri, e.g. PGM IV. 296–335; PGM XXIVb. 1–15; PGM XCV.
1–6; PGM CXXIV. 1–43.
190 György Németh
43
Ogden 2009, 246.
44
For detailed discussion see Németh 2013, 69–74.
45
Friggeri 2012, 621.
46
Gassner 2008, 225–226; Bailliot 2015: 102–103.
47
Spindler 1983; Nüsse 2011, 135; Bailliot 2015: 101–102.
48
Spindler 1983. The photos of magic dolls from Germany are published by Nüsse on pages 134–135;
by Bailliot on page 99.
49
Nüsse 2011, 133.
50
Not included in Bailliot 2015.
51
Nüsse 2011, 133.
52
Not included in Bailliot 2015.
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 191
5-7. Excavations at the Isis and Mater Magna sanctuary of Mogontiacum (Mainz)
yielded three clay puppets53. The intensive magical activity performed in the sanctuary is
also proved by 34 local curse tablets found54. The clay dolls had been broken, and one of
them shows traces of piercing. The upper part of one broken item was buried face down,
while the bottom part was buried with feet upwards.
The following description of the most recent finds from Britannia and Gaul is based
on the study of Magali Bailliot.
8. Britannia: Fishbourne, Sussex55. Though the lead puppet was found in a villa, evi-
dence of frequent ritual activities (probably connected with Cybele and Attis) is detected
in the surrounding area. The figurine was probably twisted during the ritual56.
9. Gallia: The excavation of a cellar under a Roman building at Durocortorum (Reims)
yielded two clay puppets of obviously magical context, however, the group of finds has
not been published57. One of the puppets was better preserved, while the other one is merely
a pile of fragments. The legs are broken off the larger puppet, and traces of piercing by
needle or nail are visible. The puppet was closed into a clay bowl.
10. Piriac-sur-Mer (Pays de la Loire): A lead puppet (13 cm high) was found in a
Roman villa with a wine-press in 2004. The masculinity of the doll is clearly indicated58.
Both arms and one leg were twisted during the ritual. The right arm is bent as if bound
behind its back. The puppet was broken due to twisting.
53
Witteyer 2004, 42–47; Bailliot 2015: 100.
54
Blänsdorf 2012, 50–180.
55
Bailliot 2015, 103.
56
Bailliot 2015, 103: "The damage to the upper limbs may be due to twisting."
57
Bailliot 2015, 103–104.
58
Bailliot 2015, 104–105. The find has not been published satisfactorily.
192 György Németh
Carnuntum 1
Poiana 32
Hanska 1
Total 18 32 10 1 7 52
Considering the above, the following types of manipulation can be observed in magic
dolls:
• Twisting the head back (bronze, lead)
• Piercing (clay, wax, lead)
• Burning (wax – written sources)
• Breaking the body (clay, wax, lead)
• Placing it into coffins / capsules
• Burial or submerging into water
• Writing names onto it (Rome, Athens, Etruria, Puteoli, Sicily)59.
The material of the doll affected the available means of manipulation: it was obviously
impossible to pierce a bronze puppet, and there was little chance to melt it by casting it
into fire. On the basis of the above, a manikin statuette can be considered a magic doll
only if we can observe typical ways of representation (e.g. bending an arm back, bind-
ing) or one of the mentioned manipulations60.
The surviving dolls prove that most manipulations formulated in literary sources
did exist, but magicians applied numerous other methods in practice, and not all wax statu-
ettes were destined to perish in fire.61 If the procedure required, the doll was pierced, closed
into a capsule, buried, or thrown into water, but destroying it was not necessary, because
the spell worked until the doll rested in a grave or in water62. The destruction of the doll
could surely not have secured the same result.
Primary sources
Betz 1996: Hans Dieter Betz, The Greek Magical Papyri in Translation
including the Demotic Spells, 2nd Edition (Chicago–London,
1996).
Blänsdorf 2012: Jürgen Blänsdorf, Die Defixionum Tabellae des mainzer Isis-
und Mater Magna-Heiligtums, (Mainz, 2012).
Daniel/Maltomini 1990: Robert W. Daniel, Franco Maltomini, Supplementum Magicum I.
(Opladen, 1990).
59
Faraone 1991, 200.
60
This condition rules out the identification of most Romanian manikin statuettes in magical context
(Sîrbu 1993).
61
Naturally, the probability of finding archaeological traces of actually burnt wax dolls is rather low.
62
Cf. the inscription of a curse tablet from Savaria, SEG (40, 1990, 919).
Voodoo dolls in the classical world 193
Bibliography
Bailliot 2015: Magali Bailliot, “Roman Magic Figurines from the Western
Provinces of the Roman Empire: An Archaeological Survey”,
Britannia 46 (2015): 93–110.
Faraone 1991: Christopher A. Faraone, “Binding and Burying the Forces of
Evil: The Defensive Use of “Voodoo Dolls” in Ancient Greece”,
Classical Antiquity 10 (1991): 165–205.
Faraone 1992: Christopher A. Faraone, Talismans and Trojan Horses (Oxford,
1992).
Friggeri 2012: Rosanna Friggeri, Maria Grazia Granino Cecere, Gian Luca
Gregori (eds.), Terme di Diocleziano: La collezione epigrafica
(Roma–Milano, 2012).
Gassner 2008: Gassner, Verena, “Eine Zauberpuppe aus dem Heiligtum des
Iuppiter Heliopolitanus in Carnuntum, ANODOS. Studies of
the Ancient World 8 (2008): 221-230.
Graf 1992: Fritz Graf, “An oracle against Pestilence from a Western Ana-
tolian Town”, ZPE 92 (1992): 267–279.
Kákosy 1969: Kákosy László, Varázslás az ókori Egyiptomban (Budapest,
1969).
Maltomini 2008: Franco Maltomini, “I papiri e la magia antica”, Atene e Roma
3-4 (2008): 221–237.
Németh 2013: Németh, György, “Curses in the Box”, MHNH 13 (2013):
69–74.
Németh 2017: Németh, György: “Bones in dolls”, in: Benkő Elek ed. Across
the Mediterranean - along the Nile: Studies in Egyptology,
Nubiology and Late Antiquity (Budapest, 2017), forthcoming.
Nüsse 2011: Hans-Jörg Nüsse, “Römischer Schadenzauber bei den Germa-
nen?”, Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt 41 (2011): 133–137.
Pinch 2006: Geraldine Pinch, Magic in Ancient Egypt, (London, 2006).
Piranomonte 2002: Marina Piranomonte, Il santuario della musica e il bosco sacro
di Anna Perenna, (Roma, 2002).
194 György Németh