Grid Integration of Renewable Energy Sources: Challenges, Issues and Possible Solutions
Grid Integration of Renewable Energy Sources: Challenges, Issues and Possible Solutions
Grid Integration of Renewable Energy Sources: Challenges, Issues and Possible Solutions
Abstract-India is considering renewable energy resources renewable energy sources. Challenges and issues are
(RES ) like solar and wind as alternative for future energy presented in Section III. Some possible solutions are
needs. As on March 31, 2012 the grid interactive power proposed in Section IV. A Conclusion followed by the
generation from RES is 24914 MW i.e. around 12.1 % of the
references is discussed in Section V.
total installed energy capacity. Further Ministry of New and
Renewable Energy (MNRE) , Government of India is targeting
II. LITERATURE REVIEW
to achieve 20000 MW grid interactive power through solar
and 38500 MW from wind by 2022. However there are
In this paper a literature review is carried out related to
various issues related to grid integration of RES keeping in the
view of aforesaid trends it becomes necessary to investigate
grid integration of RES. Number of authors/researchers has
the possible solutions for these issues. Integration of renewable presented the various issues, challenges and their possible
energy sources to utility grid depends on the scale of power solutions in the context of grid integration. The variability
generation. Large scale power generations are connected to of wind power limits its grid penetration and increases
transmission systems where as small scale distributed power costs. At high penetration levels, the variable output of
generation is connected to distribution systems. There are wind requires utilities to dedicate much of their available
certain challenges in the integration of both types of systems
reserve generation capacity to accommodate this variability.
directly. This paper presents the some issues and challenges
This paper [5] presents research on improving wind energy
encountered during grid integration of different renewable
integration through more effective coordination of
energy sources with some possible solutions.
traditional generation resources and energy storage systems
Keywords-Renewable energy source, grid management, that can optimize wind energy production while also
distributed generation increasing the predictability of wind farm output. The
increasing use of the Renewable Energy Sources (RES) and
I. INTRODUCTION the intermittency of the power generated by them create
stability, reliability and power quality problems in the main
Use of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) is increasing electrical grid [6]. The micro grid is called to be a feasible
drastically due to depletion of fossil fuels and associated alternative to solve these issues. As it is a weak electrical
environmental problems. Since most of the renewable grid, the micro grid is very sensitive to load or generation
energy sources are intermittent in nature therefore it changes. To reduce the effect of these variations and to better
becomes a challenging task to integrate RES into the harness the energy generated by RES, the Energy Storage
power grid infrastructure [1]. This trends leads to Systems (ESS) are used. As the different ESS technologies
numerous technical and non-technical challenges. For that are currently available are not enough to satisfy the wide
maintaining a reliable and cost effective supply, new frequency spectrum of the generated energy, the use of a
efforts have to be undertaken for the management of energy Hybrid Energy Storage System (HESS) is necessary. A
networks, integration of RES and DO in the distribution HESS is usually formed by two complementary storage
networks, for generation and load management and for a devices that can be associated in many different topologies.
range of other technical and socio economic aspects of Of course, the two devices have to be coordinated by an
decentralized energy markets. In this paper PV and wind Energy Management System (EMS). In this work the
energy sources have been considered under study. The different topologies and energy management algorithms that
increasing penetration level of PV and wind systems is have been applied in the RES and microgrid contexts have
raising the concerns of some utilities due to the possible been analyzed and compared. The micro grid can operate
negative impacts of the power fluctuations generated from both connected to the main grid and in islanding mode.
these systems on the network operation [2]. Also, the This system is used to overcome the intermittency and
fluctuation in the power of these systems can lead to uncertainty of the RES. The power converters are used as
unstable operation of the electric network prior to the fault interfaces between the ESS and the micro grid, to control
conditions, high power swings in the feeders [3] and the power flow of the storage devices and operate the
unacceptable voltage fluctuations at certain nodes in the system optimally. However, the power losses of the
electric network [4]. Moreover, the random fluctuations converters (mainly switching losses) and their
of the power output generated these systems does not economical cost are limiting factors for their use. Although
allow for considering them in the scheduling process of there are methods like the soft-switching designed to reduce
electricity generation. the switching losses of the PCS, depending on the
This paper is organized as follows: Section II presents the application, in some cases it is more economical not to use
literature review pertaining to the grid integration of it.
regulations favor the increasing number of wind farms due conversion systems. Further these challenges are broadly
to the attractive economical reliability. On the other hand, classified into technical and non-technical and described
the trend of the PV energy leads to consider that it will be below.
an interesting alternative in the near future when the current A. Technical Issues
problems and disadvantages of this technology (high cost The following are the technical issues are described as
and low effIciency) are solved. Finally, for the energy 1. Power quality
storage systems (flywheels, hydrogen, compressed air, super a. Harmonics
capacitors, superconducting magnetic, and pumped b. Frequency and voltage fluctuation
hydroelectric), the future presents several fronts, and 2. Power fluctuation
actually, they are in the same development level. These a. Small time power fluctuations
systems are nowadays being studied, and only research b. Long time or seasonal power fluctuations
projects have been developed focusing on the achievement 3. Storage
of mature technologies. 4. Protection issues
New trends in power-electronic technology for the 5. Optimal placement of RES
6. Islanding continuously fluctuating power gives rise to the security
Apart from aforesaid technical issues some of the non concern to the grid for making stable grid. Solar PV plant
technical issues are also presented in this paper. owner have to install the different type of storage system
B.Non- Technical Issues which gives additional cost to the plant owner. Once the
1. Lack of technical skilled man power storage system is fully charged then this storage elements
2. Less availability of transmission line to accommodate gives no profit to the system owner. Therefore solar based
RES water pumping system may be installed instead of storage
3. RES technologies are excluded from the competition by system.
giving them priority to dispatch which discourage the
installation of new power plant for reserve purpose. V. CONCLUSIONS
IV. POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS In this paper, some issues related to grid integration of
RES and their possible solutions available in the literature
The renewable energy sources such as solar, wind etc. have been presented. To minimize the fluctuations and
has accelerated the transition towards greener energy intermittent problems p o w e r e l e c t r o n i c s devices a r e
sources. The increasing number of renewable energy the viable options. Further, energy storage and use of
sources and distributed generators requires new dump load and MPPT could be used for reducing the power
strategies for the operation and management of the fluctuations in PV systems. In addition to the aforesaid, the
electricity grid in order to maintain or even to improve the up gradation in balance of systems by incorporating the
power-supply reliability and quality. Keeping in view of new materials and storage elements could reduce the
the aforesaid some of the possible solutions have been problems associated with grid integration.
proposed by researchers.
1. The power-electronic technology plays an important REFERENCES
role in distributed generation and in integration of [1]. F. Richard Yu, Peng Zhang, Weidong Xiao, Paul Choudhury,
renewable energy sources into the electrical grid, and it is "Communication Systems for Grid Integration of Renewable Energ
widely used and rapidly expanding as these applications Resources",IEEENetwork,pp22-29,September/October 20 II.
[2]. Fazeli Meghdad, Asher M. Greg, Klumpner Christian,and Yao
become more integrated with the grid- based systems.
Liangzhong, "Novel Integration of DFIG-Based Wind Generators
During the last few years, power electronics has Within Micro-grids", IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol.
undergone a fast evolution, which is mainly due to two 26, no. 3, pp 840-850, September 2011.
factors. The first one is the development of fast [3]. Van Li and Yun Wei Li, "Power Management of Inverter Interfaced
Autonomous Micro-grid Based on Virtual Frequency- Voltage
semiconductor switches that are capable of switching
Frame", IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 2, no. I, pp 30-41,
quickly and handling high powers. The second factor is March 2011.
the introduction of real- time computer controllers that can [4]. Bakos G.c., "Distributed power generation: "A case study of small
implement advanced and complex control algorithms. scale PV power plant in Greece", Applied Energy, vol. 86, pp
1757-1766, February 2009.
These factors together have led to the development of
[5]. H. Hanl, T.K.A. Brekkenl, A von Jouannel, ABistrika2,
cost- effective and grid-friendly converters. A.Yokochi, "In-Lab Research Grid for Optimization and Control of
2. Intermittence of power generation from the RES can Wind and Energy Storage Systems", 49th IEEE Conference on
be controlled by generating the power from distributing Decision and Control Hilton Atlanta Hotel, Atlanta, GA, USA,
December 15-17, 2010.
the RES to larger geographical area in small units instead
[6]. A Etxeberria, 1. Vechiu, A Etxeberria, JM.
of large unit concentrating in one area. For example Vinassa,H.Camblong, "Hybrid Energy Storage Systems for
output power of large solar PV system with rating of tens Renewable Energy Sources Integration in Micro-grids: A Review",
of mega watt can be change by 70% in a five to ten International Power Electronics Conference (IPEC), pp 532-537,
[7]. V. C. Ganti, Bhim Singh, S. K. Aggarwal, and T. C.
minutes of time frame by the local phenomenon like cloud
KandpaI, "DFIG-based wind power conversion with grid power
passing etc therefore large number of small solar PV leveling for reduced gusts," IEEE Transactions on Sustainable
system should be installed in larger geographical area. Energy, vol. 3, no. I, pp 12-20, January 2012.
The fluctuation of total output power can be minimized [8]. D. Schulz, "Improved grid integration of wind energy systems",
Bulletin of the Polish Academy of Sciences Technical Sciences,
because of local problem can affect only small unit power
vol. 57, no. 4, pp 311-315, 2009.
not the total output power. [9]. Yuvaraj, S. N. Deepa, "Improving Grid Power Quality With
3. In case of irrigation load the load is fed during the FACTS Device on Integration of Wind Energy System", Student
night time or off peak load time and this is fed by Pulse, www.studentpulse.com. vol. 3, issue 4, pp 1-8, April 2011.
[10]. Stefan Marko, Ivan Darul' a, "Large Scale Integration of
conventional grid. On other hand power generated by
Renewable Electricity Production Into The Grids", Journal of
RES like solar PV is generated during day time so we can Electrical Engineering, vol. 58, no. I, pp 58-60, 2007.
use this power for irrigation purposes instead of storing [II]. Lin .lin, Sun Yuan-zhang" Poul S0fensen,Li Guo-jie, and Gao
the energy for later time which increases the cost of the Weng-zhong, "Method for Assessing Grid Frequency Deviation
Due to Wind Power Fluctuation Based on Time-Frequency
overall system. Using the solar water pumping for
Transformation", IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,
irrigation gives very high efficiency approx 80% to 90% vo!.3, no. I, pp 65-73, January 2012.
and the cost of solar water pumping is much lesser than the [12]. Omran A Walid, Kazerani M., and Salama M. M. A,
induction motor pumping type. "Investigation of Methods for Reduction of Power Fluctuations
Generated From Large Grid-Connected Photovoltaic Systems",
4. In large solar PV plant output power is fluctuating
IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol. 26, no. 1, pp 318-
during the whole day and this power is fed to the grid and 327, March 201I.
[13]. T. Ito, H. Miyata, M. Taniguchi, T. Aihara, N. Uchiyama, and H. [18]. Li Wang,and Long-Yi Chen, "Reduction of Power Fluctuations of
Konishi, "Harmonic current reduction control for grid-connected a Large-Scale Grid-Connected Offshore Wind Farm Using a
PV generation systems", International Power Electronics Variable Frequency Transformer", IEEE Transactions on
Conference, pp 1695-1700, 2010. Sustainable Energy, vol. 2, no. 3, pp 226-234, July 2011.
[14]. Marcelo G. Molina, Euzeli C. dos Santos Jr., and Mario Pacas, [19]. Douglas A Halamay, , Ted K. A Brekken, Asher Simmons, and
"Improved Power Conditioning System for Grid Integration of Shaun McArthur, "Reserve Requirement Impacts of Large-Scale
Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conversion Systems", 2010 IEEE/PES Integration of Wind, Solar, and Ocean Wave Power Generation",
Transmission and Distribution Conference and Exposition: Latin IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. 2, no. 3, pp 321-
America, pp 163-170,2010. 328, July 2011.
[15]. Singh Mukhtiar, Khadkikar Vinod, Chandra Ambrish, and Varma [20]. Douglas A. Halamay, and Ted K.A. Brekken, "Factorial Analysis
K. Rajiv, "Grid Interconnection of Renewable Energy Sources at for Modeling Large-Scale Grid Integration of Renewable Energy
the Distribution Level With Power-Quality Improvement Sources", PowerTech, 2011 IEEE Trondheim, pp 1-6 June 19-23,
Features", IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 26, no.l, pp 2011.
307-315, January 2011. [21]. Juan Manuel Carrasco, Leopoldo Garcia Franquelo, Jan
[16]. S.K.Khadem,M.Basu,M.F.Conlon, "Power quality In grid T.Bialasiewicz, Eduardo Galvan, Ram6n C. Portillo Guisado, Ma.
connected Renewable energy system: Role of custom power Angeles Martin Prats, Jose Ignacio Le6n, and Narciso Moreno
devices", International Conference on Renewable Energy and Alfonso, " Power-Electronic Systems for the Grid Integration of
Power Qualities, Granada (Spain), pp 1-6, 23-25 March 20 I O. Renewable Energy Sources: A Survey", IEEE Transactions on
[17]. Yann Riffonneau, Seddik Bacha, Franck Barruel, and Stephane Industrial Electronics, vol. 53, no. 4, pp 1002 -1017, August 2006.
Ploix, "Optimal Power Flow Management for Grid Connected PV [22]. Kithsiri M. Liyanage, M.A Muhammed Manaz, A Yokoyama,
Systems with Batteries", IEEE Transactions on Sustainable YOta, H.Taniguchi, T. Nakajima, "Impact of Communication
Energy, vol. 2, no. 3, pp 309-320 July 2011. over a TCP/IP Network on the Performance of a Coordinated
Control Scheme to Reduce Power fluctuation Due to Distributed
Renewable Energy Generation", 6th International Conference on
Industrial and Information Systems, ICllS 2011, Sri Lanka.