Centres and Peripheries in Ottoman Architecture Rediscovering A Balkan Heritage Ed Maximilian Hartmuth Sarajevo Stockholm Cultural Heritage Witho PDF
Centres and Peripheries in Ottoman Architecture Rediscovering A Balkan Heritage Ed Maximilian Hartmuth Sarajevo Stockholm Cultural Heritage Witho PDF
Centres and Peripheries in Ottoman Architecture Rediscovering A Balkan Heritage Ed Maximilian Hartmuth Sarajevo Stockholm Cultural Heritage Witho PDF
University of Sarajevo
Franje Rakog 1, Sarajevo
Bosnia and Herzegovina
+ 387 33 253 200
www.ff.unsa.ba
CHwB |Report series No. 9/2010 Centres and peripheries in Ottoman architecture: rediscovering a Balkan heritages | Centri i periferije u osmanskoj arhitekturi: ponovo otkrivanje balkanskog naslijea
Proceedings of the international conference "Centres and peripheries in Ottoman architecture: rediscovering a Balkan heritage"
Zbornik radova meunarodne konferencije: Centri i periferije u osmanskoj arhitekturi: ponovo otkrivanje balkanskog naslijea"
22-24 April, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Edited by Maximilian Hartmuth
:BORNIKRADOVAMEUNARODNEKONFERENCIJE
!"#$%&'('()#&'*#&'+#(,(-./0$.1-+(0&2'%#1%,&'3((
ONMNUNNSJQHUAMIDAKJAMRJNFMARKHIDA
APRIL3ARAJEVO"OSNAI(ERCEGOVINA
0ROCEEDINGSOFTHEINTERNATIONALCONFERENCE
!"#$%&#.(0$4()#&')2#&'#.('$(5%%-/0$(0&62'%#6%,(
QDCHRBNUDQHMFA"AKJAMGDQHSAFD
!PRIL3ARAJEVO"OSNIAAND(ERZEGOVINA
%DITOR7(!"#$%&'()809'/':'0$(;0&%/,%2
3ARAJEVO
<4'%-&(7(=$'13(
-AXIMILIAN(ARTMUTH
0TKHRGDQ[)YCAUA
#(W"2EGIONALOCE3ARAJEVO
>#)-&%(?#&'#.(7(@AB+#C%0+(D&-+(EFGHIH
J0$K,0K#(#4'%'$K(DL(7(M#1.%()&#K:#40:'3)
!DISA$INOAND!DAM-C#ONNELL
N&'$%'$K(7(O%0/)03)
"EMUST3ARAJEVO
P#.'$K(DL(7(P'A0+$3)
0OETA0ISTA
#HQBTKASHNM[4HQA
COPIESPRIMJERAKA
)
#NUDQHLAFD[&NSNFQAIARMARKNUMDRSQAMHBD)
$ETAILOFTH
CENTURYDOMEDMAUSOLEUMNEXTTO!LADAMOSQUEIN3KOPJE
PHOTOGRAPHBY-AXIMILIAN(ARTMUTH
$ETALJSTURBETAUHAREMU!LADADAMIJEU3KOPJUSTOLJEE
FOTOGRAF-AXIMILIAN(ARTMUTH
4HEDESIGNONTHEHPAGEANDBACKCOVERISBASEDONTHEDECORATIONOFTHE(ANDANIJAMOSQUE
IN0RUSACANDHASBEENPREPAREDBY,EJLA(ADI
)LUSTRACIJANAPETOJSTRANICIINAPOLEININASLOVNICEJEBAZIRANANADEKORACIJISDRVENEDASKE
SVODA(ANDANIJADAMIJEU0RUSCUAUTOR,EJLA(ADI
o#(V"2DFHNMAK/BD
Content / Sadraj
11.............................................................................................................................................. Preface
15..........................................................................................................................................Predgovor
18.......................................................................................................................... Maximilian Hartmuth
The history of centre-periphery relations as a history of style in Ottoman provincial architecture
Historija odnosa centar-periferija kao historija stila u arhitekturi osmanskih provincija
30..................................................................................................................................Johan Mrtelius
Ottoman European architecture
Osmanska europska arhitektura
36....................................................................................................................................Grigor Boykov
Reshaping urban space in the Ottoman Balkans: a study on the architectural development of Edirne,
Plovdiv, and Skopje (14th-15th centuries)
Transformacija urbanog prostora na osmanskom Balkanu: studija o arhitektonskom razvoju Jedrena,
Plovdiva i Skoplja (od 14. do 15.vijeka)
60.......................................................................................................................................Machiel Kiel
The campanile-minarets of the southern Herzegovina: a blend of Islamic and Christian elements
in the architecture of an outlying border area of the Balkans, its spread in the past and survival until our time
Zvonici-minareti u jugoistone Hercegovine: spoj elemenata islama i krianstva u
arhitekturi pograninog pojasa Balkanskog poluostrva, njihovo irenje u prolosti i opstanak do sadanjeg vremena
90...................................................................................................................................Federica Broilo
The forgotten Ottoman heritage of Florina on the River Sakoulevas,
and a little known Ottoman building on the shore of Lake Volvis in Greek Macedonia
Zaboravljeno osmansko naslijee Florina na rijeci Sakoulevas i manje poznata
osmanska graevina na obali jezera Volvis u Egejskoj Makedoniji
108..............................................................................................................................Zeynep Ahunbay
Ottoman architecture in Kosova and the restoration of Hadum Mosque in Gjakovo (akovica)
Osmanska arhitektura na Kosovu i restauracija Hadum damije u akovici
!"#$%"#&'"$(")!"#!$%&%'("$!)&%*%+"!"$%!)&#,%%-(+.*!#/ !"$%!*01)#*(21!!"#$%"&'(#)'*"%+*,"%+"&'+#'-$$./
0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"3'%")+&1.4"%+#5'('6(78(#',"%+$(5"3!#&.4+(5%-!60!728"2&48!9%&("4.%!'("$#2"!:#&-%&*!;79':<!
(+!=4&4>%?#3!:#*+(4@9%&5%.#?(+43!#+!A)&(8!BB@BC3!BDEDF!G#&!79':3!4!='%-(*$!/#2+-4"(#+3!"$%!,$#(,%!
RI ORFDWLRQZDVPRVWWWLQJ)RULWZDVLQ%RVQLD+HU]HJRYLQDLQWKDW&+Z%EHJDQLWVDFWLYLWLHV
(+!&%*)#+*%!"#!"$%!-%*"&2,"(#+!#/ !,28"2&48!$%&("4.%!(+!"$%!'4H%!#/ !I2.#*84?(4J*!-(*(+"%.&4"(#+K!79':!
'4*!/#2+-%-!/#88#'(+.!"$%!(+("(4"(?%!#/ !4!+216%&!#/ !='%-(*$!4&,$("%,"*3!>#2&+48(*"*3!4+-!#"$%&!,28"2&%!
)&#/%**(#+48*F! L$%! /#&148! /#2+-(+.! #/ ! 79':! 4*! 4+! #&.4+(54"(#+! '4*! *2))#&"%-! 60! 4! +216%&! #/ !
(+*"("2"(#+*!4+-!)(+%+"!(+-(?(-248*3!41#+.!'$(,$!4&%!"$%!='%-(*$!M4"(#+48!9%&("4.%!:#4&-3!"$%!!
='%-(*$!A**#,(4"(#+!#/ !A&,$("%,"*3!?4&(#2*!12*%21!4**#,(4"(#+*3!4+-!"'#!='%-(*$!NO*F!L$%!4(1!'4*!
QRWRQO\WRVDYHDQGUHVWRUHKLVWRULFDOEXLOGLQJVEXWDOVRWRSURPRWHUHFRQFLOLDWLRQ$UVWHOGRIFH
ZDV RSHQHG LQ 6DUDMHYR WR VXSHUYLVH WKH SURMHFWV LQLWLDWHG LQ DQRWKHU HOG RIFH LQ 3ULVWLQD
.RVRYRIROORZHGDQGLQDWKLUGZDVRSHQHGLQ7LUDQD$OEDQLD$OVRWKUHHQHWZRUNVIRVWHULQJ
H[FKDQJHFRQFHUQLQJKHULWDJHUHODWHGLVVXHVZHUHHVWDEOLVKHGLQVL[RI WKHUHJLRQVFRXQWULHVLQ
G!"$%!#+*%"3!$#'%?%&3!79':J*!/#,2*!$4*!6%%+!#+!"$%!)$0*(,48!&%*"#&4"(#+!#/ !-414.%-!$(*"#&(,48!
1#+21%+"*3!(+!8(+%!'("$!"$%!$(.$%*"!(+"%&+4"(#+48!*"4+-4&-*!4+-!(&&%*)%,"(?%!#/ !1#+21%+"3!)%&(#-3!
ORFDWLRQRUHWKQLFRUFRQIHVVLRQDOJURXSLGHQWLHGZLWKLW&+Z%UHFRJQL]HVWKDWFDSDFLW\EXLOGLQJRQ
4!128"("2-%!#/ !8%?%8*!(*!(1)%&4"(?%!/#&!("*!1(**(#+!(+!=#2"$%4*"!P2&#)%!(/ !"$%!#2",#1%!(*!"#!6%!*2*"4(+@
468%F!79':!)&#>%,"*!4&%!+#"!,#+,%(?%-!4*!,#*1%"(,!(+"%&?%+"(#+*3!62"!4*!(+?%*"1%+"*!(+!-%?%8#)1%+"F!
%\KHOSLQJWRUHVWRUHGLJQLW\WRWKHFRPPXQLWLHVDIIHFWHGDQGEXLOGLQJFRQGHQFHUDLVLQJDZDUHQHVV
4+-!/#*"%&(+.!*#,(48!4+-!%,#+#1(,!-%?%8#)1%+"!"$.$!"$%!2"(8(54"(#+!#/ !8#,48!&%*#2&,%*3!79':!4(1*!
"#!)#"%!4!,28"2&%!#/ !)%4,%!4+-!&%,#+,(8(4"(#+F
Q4"$%&!"$4+!4!1%&%!4,4-%1(,!)2&*2("3!"$%!,#+/%&%+,%!!"#$%"&'(#)'*"%+*,"%+"&'+#'-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"3'%")+&/
1.4"%+#5'('6(78(#',"%+$(5"!'4*!*(1(84&80!4+!%R%&,(*%!(+!,4)4,("0@62(8-(+.F!S"!&%?(*("%-!(+!.&%4"%&!-%"4(8!*#1%!
SUREOHPVDGGUHVVHGUVWLQDZRUNVKRSWLWOHG-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"'(#)'92%.*"(#',"%+$(5"3'#&.4+(5%-!(+!M#@
YHPEHUDWWKH6ZHGLVK5HVHDUFK,QVWLWXWHLQ,VWDQEXO65,,7KH6DUDMHYRFRQIHUHQFHVFRQFHSW
ZDVIRUPXODWHGEHWZHHQDQGE\-RKDQ0nUWHOLXVRI &+Z%DQG0D[LPLOLDQ+DUWPXWK7KH
-%*(.+4"%-!4(1!'4*!"#!-%*(.+!4+!%?%+"!"$%!"$%1%!#/ !'$(,$!(*!1%4+(+./28!6#"$!"#!,2&&%+"!(+"%&+4"(#+48!
GHEDWHVLQWKHHOGRI 2WWRPDQDQG(XURSHDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOKLVWRU\DQGWRWKHFRQFHUQVVXUURXQGLQJ
79':!4,"(?("(%*!(+!"$%!:48H4+*3!'$%&%!("!$4-!62(8"!4!+%"'#&H!#/ !*,$#84&*!4+-!%R)%&"*!#?%&!"$%!0%4&*F!S"!
'4*!48*#!,8%4&!"$4"!"$%!,#+/%&%+,%!12*"!6&(+.!"#.%"$%&!*,$#84&*!/!"$%!&%.(#+!4+-!/!%8*%'$%&%!
WKHQDOSURJUDPPHIHDWXUHGVL[VSHDNHUVIURP%RVQLD+HU]HJRYLQDWKUHHIURP7XUNH\WZRIURP
:28.4&(43!4+-!#+%!%4,$!/!"$%!TU3!S"4803!92+.4&03!4+-!='%-%+<F!=(1(84&803!"$4"!"$%!,#+/%&%+,%!("*%8/ !
'4*!+#"!"#!6%!$%8-!46-!62"!(+!"$%!?%&0!&%.(#+!"$4"!'4*!("*!*26>%,"!'4*!(+"%+-%-!4*!4!*(.+48F!V(?%+!
"$%!+4"2&%!#/ !79':J*!)4*"!4,"(?("(%*!(+!"$%!&%.(#+3!("!'4*!48*#!,8%4&!"$4"!"$%!%?%+"!*$#28-!6%!#&.4+(5%-!
LQFRRSHUDWLRQZLWKORFDOLQVWLWXWLRQV,WIRXQGWWLQJSDUWQHUVLQWKH$UW+LVWRU\3URJUDPHVWDEOLVKHG
LQDW6DUDMHYR8QLYHUVLW\V)DFXOW\RI 3KLORVRSK\DQGLQ+DULV'HUYLHYLDQDVVLVWDQWLQWKDW
)&#.&41F!S+!"$%!)&%)4&4"(#+*!/#&!"$%!*01)#*(213!'$(,$!"##H!)84,%!(+!"$%!G4,28"0!#/ !O$(8#*#)$0J*!42-(@
WRULXP'HUYLHYLZRUNHGFORVHO\ZLWK$GLVD'LQRRI WKH&+Z%5HJLRQDO2IFHLQ6DUDMHYRZKRVH
Preface
11
12
#&.4+(54"(#+48!-%R"%&("0!'4*!,#1)(*%-!+#"!%?%+!60!4+!S,%84+-(,!?#8,4+#3!"$%!%&2)"(#+!#/ !'$(,$!
,#(+,(-%-!'("$!"$%!'%%H!#/ !"$%!%?%+"F!L$%!*01)#*(21J*!#)%+(+.!%?%+"!'4*!#&.4+(5%-!(+!,##)%&4"(#+!
'("$3!4+-!#+!"$%!)&%1(*%*!#/3!"$%!W%148>*H(!N25%>!(+!=4&4>%?#3!'("$!'$(,$!79':!$4-!)4&"+%&%-!#+!
)&%?(#2*!#,,4*(#+*3
X4*"803!("!'4*!-%"%&1(+%-!"$4"!"$%!)4)%&*!.(?%+!4"!"$%!*01)#*(21!12*"!6%!)268(*$%-3!4+-!"$(*!6&(+.*!
2*!64,H!"#!"$%!Y2%*"(#+!#/ !,4)4,("0@62(8-(+.F!L$%!)&#,%%-(+.*!4&%!+#"!#+80!1%4+"!4*!4!&%,#&-!#/ !"$%!
*01)#*(213!62"!48*#!4*!4!*)&(+.6#4&-!/#&!/2"2&%!*"2-(%*!#/3!4+-!28"(14"%80!4!&%+%'%-!(+"%&%*"!(+3!"$(*!
$%&("4.%F!A*!94&"12"$!*"&%**%*!4"!"$%!6%.(++(+.!#/ !$(*!)4)%&3!("!$4*!6%%+!4!)D%1!"$4"!"$(*!$%&("4.%!
'4*3!4"!8%4*"!(+!&%,%+"!0%4&*3!1#&%!#/"%+!4--&%**%-!4*!4+!(-%+"("0!14&H%&!"$4+!4*!4+!#6>%,"!#/ !4&"@$(*"#&@
(,48!(+"%&%*"F!S+!"$%!)4*"3!?4&(#2*!H(+-*!#/ !6#&-%&*!Z!8(+.2(*"(,3!)$0*(,483!1%"$#-#8#.(,483!#&!(-%#8#.(,48!
Z!$4-!#6*"&2,"%-!"$%!/288!4))&%,(4"(#+!#/ !"$%*%!1#+21%+"*!(+!"$%(&!4&"(*"(,!4+-!$(*"#&(,48!,#+"%R"*F!M#'!
("!(*!"(1%!"#!)2"!"$%!*"2-0!#/ !"$(*!$%&("4.%!64,H!#+!"$%!14)!4+-!&%48(.+!("!'("$!,#+"%1)#&4&0!-%64"%*!
(+!$(*"#&0!4+-!4&"!$(*"#&0F!94&"12"$!)&#)#*%*!4+!4R(*!#/ !(+?%*"(.4"(#+!48#+.!,%+"&%*!4+-!)%&()$%&(%*!4*!
#+%!)#**(68%!*"&4"%.0!/#&!&%*,2(+.!"$(*!$%&("4.%!/!(+?(*(6(8("03!$%+,%!"$%!*01)#*(21J*!"$%1%F!L$(*3!
+DUWPXWKDUJXHVKDVWKHSRWHQWLDORI LQYHVWLQJWKH%DONDQPRQXPHQWVZLWKDQRYHOVLJQLFDQFHLQQDU@
UDWLYHVRI 2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOKLVWRU\LQZKLFKWKH\KDYHEHHQQHJOHFWHG6LPLODULVVXHVDUHUDLVHGE\
0nUWHOLXVZKRIRFXVHVRQWKH%DONDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOKHULWDJHVSODFHLQ(XURSHDQGLVFRXUVHVRQKLVWRU\
4+-!,28"2&%F!A!H%0!/#&!"$%*%!1#+21%+"*J!6%""%&!(+"%.&4"(#+!(+"#!"$%!$(*"#&(,48!+4&&4"(?%*!#/ ![%*"%&+3!
(XURSHDQ2WWRPDQRU,VODPLFDUWLVLQFUHDVHGSURGXFWLRQRI NQRZOHGJHDQGLWLVKRSHGWKDWWKLV
?#821%!'(88!6%!4+!(+*"&21%+"!(+!"$(*!)&#,%**F
7KH FRQWULEXWRUV FRYHU D ZLGH DUUD\ RI VXEMHFWV +DUWPXWK DQG 0nUWHOLXV VWDUW IURP LGHQWLI\LQJ
"$%!:48H4+!1#+21%+"*J!,2&&%+"!)84,%!(+!$(*"#&(%*!#/ !4&"!4*!4!)D%1!"$4"!-%*%&?%*!4""%+"(#+F!L$%0!
)#(+"!"#!"$%!+%,%**("0!#/ !&%"$(+H(+.!"$%!*,#)%!4+-!1%"$#-*!#/ !)&%?(#2*!(+Y2(&0F!L$%!&%14(+-%&!#/ !"$%!
)4)%&*!,#+"&(62"%!60!)&#?(-(+.!,4*%!*"2-(%*!'$(,$!*$%-!8(.$"!#+!)&#,%**%*!4+-!)$%+#1%+4!&%8%?4+"!
WRXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKH2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOKHULWDJHRXWVLGH,VWDQEXO0DFKLHO.LHOSUHVHQWVWKHUVW
(+@-%)"$!*"2-0!#/ !"$%!8(""8%@H+#'+!9%&5%.#?(+(4+!)$%+#1%+#+!#/ !1(+4&%"*!(+!"$%!*$4)%!#/ !,41)4+(8(F!
V&(.#&!:#0H#?!-(*,2**%*!"$%!%!#/ !4&,$("%,"2&48!/#2+-4"(#+*!(+!"$&%%!:48H4+!,("(%*J!-%?%8#)1%+"!(+!
WKHHDUO\2WWRPDQSHULRG,ERO\D*HUHO\HVSURYLGHVDVXUYH\RI SDVWDQGSUHVHQWHIIRUWVLQWKHVWXG\
RI +XQJDU\V2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOKHULWDJHLQFOXGLQJWKHSURPLVLQJHOGRI DUFKDHRORJ\)HGHULFD
%URLORVLPLODUO\WDNHVDHOGZRUNDSSURDFKWRWKHVWXG\RI 2WWRPDQ%DONDQPRQXPHQWVGLVFXVVLQJ
XQNQRZQRUOLWWOHNQRZQPRQXPHQWVLQ*UHHN0DFHGRQLD0HKPHW=EUDKLPJLOWXUQVRXUDWWHQWLRQ
"#!4!&4"$%&!,2&(#2*!,#1)#2+-!"$4"!%?#8?%-!4+-!4!1#*Y2%!62(8"!(+!4!*%414+J*!$#+#2&!(+!"$%!,("0!#/ !
Q$#-%*F!S+!4!)4)%&!"%,$+(,4880!2+&%84"%-!"#!"$%!:48H4+*3!62"!-(*,2**(+.!4!+216%&!#/ !"$%1%*!"#2,$%-!
XSRQLQWKLVYROXPHVRWKHUSDSHUV0DULDQQH%RTYLVWORRNVDWWKHDUFKLWHFWXUHRI 2WWRPDQZD\VWDWLRQV
LQKLVWRULFDO6\ULDDQGWKHTXHVWLRQRI SURYLQFLDOYVPHWURSROLWDQVW\OHD]LP+DGLPHMOLGLVFXVVHV
RQHVSHFLFDUFKLWHFWXUDOHOHPHQWWKH0+,%(:'RUSUD\HUQLFKHDQGLWVWKHRORJLFDODQGDUWLVWLFVLJQLFDQFH
LQ %RVQLD DQG HOVHZKHUH 0LU]D +DVDQ HPDQ DGGUHVVHV WKH TXHVWLRQ RI QRUWKHUQ %RVQLDQ XUEDQ
VHWWOHPHQWVSODQQHGE\WKHODWH2WWRPDQVWDWH7KHVHWRZQVGHVLJQHGRQDUHJXODUJULGZHUHWRKRXVH
;(%5(%"$('<2&=#';=%,&%"4&0!V%+%&48!#/ !79':<
>.,(#';?%$"7+2&';79':!6#4&-!1%16%&<
;(@+0+7+(#'<(%$02$,';%-("#&<
0XVOLPVHYDFXDWHGIURPQHLJKERXULQJ6HUELDLQ1HQDG0DNXOMHYLZULWHVRI WKHDUFKLWHFWXUH
LQWKHSRVWSHULRGRI 2WWRPDQUHIRUPV/HMOD%XDWOLGLVFXVVHVWKHQHJRWLDWLRQRI ROGDQG
QHZRI WUDGLWLRQVVXUYLYDOVDQGUHYLYDOVLQWKHDUFKLWHFWXUHRI %RVQLDQFLW\UHVLGHQFHVDURXQG
=H\QHS$KXQED\DQG9MHNRVODYD6DQNRYL6LPLQDOO\UHSRUWRI UHFHQWUHVWRUDWLRQVRI WZR"$@
,%+"2&0!1#*Y2%*!Z!#+%!(+!U#*#?#3!"$%!#"$%&!(+!9%&5%.#?(+4!Z!4+-!"$%!,$488%+.%*!1%"!(+!"$(*!)&#,%**F
G#&!&%4*#+*!#2"8(+%-!46#?%3!("!'4*!(1)%&4"(?%!/#&!"$%!#&.4+(5%&*!"#!)268(*$!"$%!)&#,%%-(+.*!4*!*'(/"80!
4*!)#**(68%3!'("$(+!"$%!*41%!0%4&!4*!"$%!*01)#*(21F!A*!4!8%**!"(1%@(+"%+*(?%!48"%&+4"(?%!"#!"$%!)&#)%&!
"&4+*84"(#+!#/ !488!"%R"*!4+-!"$%(&!*(128"4+%#2*!)268(,4"(#+!(+!"$%!,#+/%&%+,%J*!84+.24.%*!Z!P+.8(*$!4+-!
:#*+(4+\7"(4+\=%&6(4+!Z!'%!$4?%!#)"%-!/#&!6(8(+.248!46*"&4,"*!,#1)#*%-!60!"$%!%-("#&3!(+!'$(,$!
WKHSDSHUVPDLQDUJXPHQWVDUHLGHQWLHGLQERWKODQJXDJHVDWHDFKWH[WVEHJLQQLQJ,QHGLWLQJWKH
)4)%&*3!'%!$4?%!(+"%&?%+%-!"#!"$%!8%4*"!)#**(68%!%R"%+"3!488#'(+.!/#&!)%&*#+48!#)(+(#+*!4+-!(+"%&)&%"4@
WLRQVWKDWPD\QRWUHHFWWKHHGLWRUVRU&+Z%VYLHZV$WORQJODVWZHZRXOGOLNHWRWKDQNWKHSURMHFW
)4&"(,()4+"*!4+-!"$%!,#+"&(62"#&*!"#!"$(*!?#821%3!4+-!%R)&%**!#2&!$#)%!"$4"!"$%!)&%*%+"!)268(,4"(#+!
1(.$"!"&(..%&!&%84"%-!(+("(4"(?%*!(+!"$%!/2"2&%F![$4"!"$%!"%R"*!*$#'!2*!(*!$#'!12,$!,4+!*"(88!6%!8%4&+%-!
46#2"!"$(*!$%&("4.%F
13
Predgovor
*$)+,+'-(.,+#/$0#-"LWDRFXSUHGVWDYLWLSXEOLNDFLMXVLPSR]LMXPD&HQWULLSHULIHULMHRVPDQVNHDUKL@
WHNWXUHSRQRYQRRWNULYDQMHEDONDQVNRJQDVOLMHDNRMDMHRUJDQL]RYDQDRGVWUDQH.XOWXUQRJQDVOMHD
6%5!.&4+(,4!2!=4&4>%?23!:#*+4!(!9%&,%.#?(+43!2!)%&(#-2!#-!BBF!-#!BCF!4)&(84F!W4!]?%-*H2!/#+-4,(>2!
&+Z%VDPL]ERUORNDFLMH]DNRQIHUHQFLMXVHLQLQDMSULNODGQLMLP%RVQDL+HUFHJRYLQDMH]HPOMDXNRMRM
MH&+Z%JRGLQHXWRNXUDVSDGD-XJRVODYLMHSRHRVYRMHDNWLYQRVWLNDRRGJRYRUQDXQLWDYDQMH
NXOWXUQRJQDVOLMHDJUXSDYHGVNLKDUKLWHNDWDSURIHVLRQDODFDXNXOWXULLQRYLQDUDVHDQJDRYDODWRMH
UH]XOWLUDORNUHLUDQMHP&+Z%DRGVWUDQHYHGVNRJ1DFLRQDOQRJRGERUD]DQDVOMHHODQRYDYHGVNRJ
SDUODPHQWDPX]HMVNLKDVRFLMDFLMDLYHGVNHDVRFLMDFLMHDUKLWHNDWD&LOMQLMHELRVDPRGDVHVDXYDMXL
&%*"42&(&4>2!$(*"#&(>*H(!#6>%H"(3!+%.#!-4!*%!)#-2)&%!!)&#,%*!)#1(&%+>4F!O&?4!H4+,%84&(>4!(5?4+!^?%-*H%!>%!
ELODRWYRUHQDX6DUDMHYXJGMHVXDNWLYQRVWLNDQFHODULMHELOHYH]DQH]DQDG]RUQDG]DSRHWLPSURMHNWLPD
.DQFHODULMDX3ULWLQLQD.RVRYXMHELODRWYRUHQDDWUHDNDQFHODULMDMHRWYRUHQDJRGLQHX
7LUDQL $OEDQLMD 7DNRHU NUHLUDQH VX L WUL PUHH NRMH LQH RUJDQL]DFLMHLQVWLWXFLMH SUHGVWDYQLFL HVW
]HPDOMDXUHJLMLDNRMHUDGHQDUD]PMHQLLVNXVWDYDLVWDYRYDQDSROMXNXOWXUQRJQDVOLMHD2GVDPRJ
SRHWND IRNXV &+Z%D MH ELR QD ]LNRM UHVWDXUDFLML RWHHQLK KLVWRULMVNLK VSRPHQLND X VNODGX VD
QDMYLLP PHXQDURGQLP VWDQGDUGLPD EH] RE]LUD QD SHULRG ORNDFLMX HWQLNX LOL UHOLJLMVNX ]DMHGQLFX
NRMRMSULSDGDMXWLVSRPHQLFL,]JUDGQMDNDSDFLWHWDQDUD]OLLWLPQLYRLPDMHSUHSR]QDWDNDRLPSHUDWLY]D
PLVLMX&+Z%DXMXJRLVWRQRM(YURSLNRMD]DFLOMLPDRGULYRVW&+Z%SURMHNWLQLVXNR]PHWLNHLQWHU@
YHQFLMHYHLQYHVWLFLMHXUD]YRM3RPDXLGDVHYUDWLGRVWRMDQVWYRUD]RUHQLP]DMHGQLFDPDL]JUDXMXL
SRYMHUHQMHUDGHLQDSRGL]DQMXVYLMHVWLLSRPDXLHNRQRPVNLUD]YRMNUR]NRULWHQMHORNDOQLKNDSDF@
("%"43!79':!)#?(&4!H28"2&2!1(&4!(!)#?>%&%+>4F
3ULMHQHJROLVDPRDNDGHPVNDWHQMDNRQIHUHQFLMD&HQWULLSHULIHULMHRVPDQVNHDUKLWHNWXUHSRQRYQR
RWNULYDQMHEDONDQVNRJQDVOLMHDMHELODLIRNXVLUDQDQDVDPXL]JUDGQMXNDSDFLWHWD1DNRQIHUHQFLMLVX
XQDMYHRMPMHULGLVNXWRYDQLQHNLRGSUREOHPDNRMLVXYHELOLVSRPLQMDQLQDUDGLRQLFLNRMDMHRUJDQL@
]RYDQDJRGLQHXQRYHPEUXRGVWUDQHYHGVNRJLVWUDLYDNRJLQVWLWXWDX,VWDQEXOXDNRMDVHWLFDOD
RVPDQVNHDUKLWHNWXUHLHYURSVNRJQDVOMHD
.RQFHSWNRQIHUHQFLMHX6DUDMHYXMHELRIRUPXOLUDQL]PHXLJRGLQHRGVWUDQH-RKDQD
0nUWHOLXVD&+Z%L0D[LPLOLDQD+DUWPXWKD&LOMMHELRGDVHGL]DMQLUDGRJDDMLMDWHPDHRERVWUDQR
ELWL]QDDMQDLVDDVSHNWDPHXQDURGQLKGLVNXVLMDQDSROMXRVPDQVNHHYURSVNHDUKLWHNWRQVNHKLVWR@
ULMHLVDDVSHNWDFLOMHYD&+Z%RYLKDNWLYQRVWLQD%DONDQXNRMHVXQDNRQQL]DJRGLQDL]PHXRVWDORJ
UH]XOWLUDOH L XVSRVWDYOMHQRP PUHRP NRQWDNDWD XHQMDND L HNVSHUDWD ,VWR WDNR MH SRVWDOR MDVQR GD
NRQIHUHQFLMDWUHEDGDVSRMLXHQMDNHL]UHJLRQDLLUH)LQDOQLSURJUDPMHELRVDLQMHQRGSUHGDYDQMDHVW
.#?#&+(H4!(5!:#*+%!(!9%&,%.#?(+%3!"&(!(5!L2&*H%3!-?#>%!(5!:2.4&*H%3!(!#-!)#!>%-+#.!.#?#&+(H4!(5!_%8(H%!
%ULWDQLMH,WDOLMH0DDUVNHLYHGVNH6DPLPWLPNRQIHUHQFLMDQLMHWUHEDODELWLRGUDQDXLQRVWUDQVWYX
YH X UHJLRQX NRML MH L VDP WHPD UD]PDWUDQMD 8 VNODGX VD &+Z%RYLP DNWLYQRVWLPD X UHJLML VDP
GRJDDMMHELRRUJDQL]RYDQXVDUDGQMLVDORNDOQLPLQVWLWXFLMDPD3DUWQHU]DNRQIHUHQFLMXMHELR2GMHO
54!$(*"#&(>2!21>%"+#*"(!#*+#?4+!BDDBF!.#-(+%!)&(!G(8#5#/*H#1!/4H28"%"23!T+(?%&5("%"4!2!=4&4>%?23!H#>(!
MHELRSUHGVWDYOMHQ+DULVRP'HUYLHYLHPDVLVWHQWRPQDRGMHOX8VDPLPSULSUHPDPDNRQIHUHQFLMH
NRMDVHRGUDODXDPWHDWUX)LOR]RIVNRJIDNXOWHWD+DULVMHXVNRVDUDLYDRVD$GLVRP'LQRL]&+Z% 15
16
5HJLRQDOQHNDQFHODULMHX6DUDMHYXLMXHNDVQRVWQLMHQDUXLRQLLVODQGVNLYXONDQVNLSHSHRNRMLMHHUXS@
"(&4#!*%-1(,2!)&(>%!*41%!H#+/%&%+,(>%F!=41#!#"?4&4+>%!H#+/%&%+,(>%!>%!6(8#!#&.4+(5#?4+#!)&#*"#&(>414!
W%148>*H#.!125%>4!2!=4&4>%?23!-2.#.#-(]+>%.!)4&"+%&4!79':@4F
1DNUDMXSULMHVDPRJSRHWNDNRQIHUHQFLMHRGOXHQRMHGDVHSUHGDYDQMDVDVDPHNRQIHUHQFLMHWUH@
64>2!(!#6>4?("(3!(!#?#!+4*!)#+#?+#!-#?#-(!+4!"%12!(5.&4-+>%!H4)4,("%"4F!M41>%&4!(54!*41%!)268(H4,(>%!+%!
OHLXWRPHGDVHNRQIHUHQFLMDVDPR]DELOMHLWLYHMHSXEOLNDFLMD]DPLOMHQDNDR]DHWDNEXGXLKVWXGLMD
NRMHHQDGDPRVHREQRYLWLLQWHUHV]DRYDMWLSQDVOLMHD
.DRWR+DUWPXWKQDYRGLQDVDPRPSRHWNXVYRJSUHGDYDQMDQDMYHLSUREOHPSUHGVWDYOMDWRWR
MHRYRQDVOLMHHEDUHPXSUROLPJRGLQDPDELORYLHRELOMHHQRNDRVLPERO]DSUHSR]QDYDQMHLGHQ@
WLWHWDQHJROLVSRPHQLNRGDUKLWHNWRQVNRKLVWRULMVNRJ]QDDMD8SURORVWLUD]QHJUDQLFHMH]LNH
PHWRGRORJLMVNHLOLLGHRORNHVXQDUXLOHSXQRXYDDYDQMHRYRJQDVOLMHDXVYRPXPMHWQLNRPLKLVWRUL@
>*H#1!H#+"%H*"2F!=4-4!>%!?&(>%1%!-4!*%!*41%!*"2-(>%!#6+#?%!(!-4!*%!2*H84-%!*4!*4?&%1%+(1!-(*H2*(>414!2!
KLVWRULMLLKLVWRULMLXPMHWQRVWL8VNODGXVDVDPRPWHPRPVLPSR]LMXPDRQSUHSRUXXMHPRJXXVWUDWH@
JLMXVSDVDYDQMDRYRJQDVOLMHDRGQHSRVWRMDQMDNUR]L]UDGXQL]DLVWUDLYDQMDXFHQWULPDLSHULIHULMDPD
2YDMSULVWXSQDYRGL+DUWPXWKLPDSRWHQFLMDOLPSOHPHQWLUDQMDYDQLKEDONDQVNLKVSRPHQLNDX]DSLVH
RVPDQVNHDUKLWHNWRQVNHKLVWRULMHDXNRMLPDMHGRVDGDELOD]DSRVWDYOMHQD6OLQRQDYRGLL0nUWHOLXV
NRMLVHIRNXVLUDRQDSR]LFLMXEDONDQVNRJDUKLWHNWRQVNRJQDVOMHDXHYURSVNRPGLVNXUVXRKLVWRULMLL
QDVOMHX.OMXEROMHLQWHJUDFLMHRYLKVSRPHQLNDXKLVWRULMVNH]DSLVHR]DSDGQRMHYURSVNRMRVPDQVNRM
LOLLVODPVNRMXPMHWQRVWL]QDLSRYHDQMH]QDQMDLQDGDPRVHGDHRYDSXEOLNDFLMDELWLYDQRRUXHX
*41#1!)&#,%*2F
6DPLSUHGDYDLVXSRNULOLLURNGLMDSD]RQWHPD+DUWPXWKL0nUWHOLXV]DSRLQMXLGHQWLNDFLMXWUH@
QXWQHSR]LFLMHEDONDQVNLKVSRPHQLNDXKLVWRULMLXPMHWQRVWLSUHSR]QDMXLMHNDRSUREOHPNRML]DVOXXMH
SDQMX2QLXND]XMXQDQHRSKRGQRVWSRQRYQRJSURPLOMDQMDRQDLQLPDLPHWRGDPDSULMHUDHQLK
LVWUDLYDQMD2VWDOD SUHGDYDQMD VX GRSULQLMHOD GDMXL NRQNUHWQH SULPMHUH NRML EDFDMX VYMHWORVW QD VDP
)&#,%*!H#>(!>%!+%#)$#-+#!*$?4"("(3!H4H#!6(!*%!)#>1(#!/%+#1%+!&%8%?4+"4+!54!&4521(>%?4+>%!#*14+*H#.!
DUKLWHNWRQVNRJ QDVOMHD L]YDQ ,VWDQEXOD 0DFKLHO .LHO SUHGVWDYOMD LWDWHOMLPD SUYX GHWDOMQX VWXGLMX R
UHODWLYQRQHSR]QDWLPKHUFHJRYDNLPPXQDUDPDNRMHSULPDMXREOLN]YRQLND*ULJRU%R\NRYUD]PD@
"&4!28#.2!4&$("%H"#+*H($! 2"(,4>4! 2! &45?#>2! "&(! 648H4+*H4! .&4-4! 2! &4+#1! #*14+*H#1! )%&(#-2F! S6#804!
*HUHO\HV GDMH LVWUDLYDQMH SUROLK L WUHQXWQLK QDSRUD X VWXGLUDQMX RVPDQVNRJ QDVOMHD X 0DDUVNRM
XNOMXXMXL L REHDYDMXH SROMH DUKHRORJLMH 6OLQR )HGHULFD %URLOR SUHX]LPD WHUHQVNL SULVWXS VWXGL@
UDQMXRVPDQVNLKEDONDQVNLKVSRPHQLNDUD]PDWUDMXLQHSR]QDWHLOLPDOR]QDQHVSRPHQLNHX*UNRM
0DNHGRQLML0HKPHW=EUDKLPJLOQDVXYRGLXUHODWLYQRLQWHUHVDQWDQNRPSOHNVNRMLMHQDVWDRXRNROLQL
GDPLMHNRMDMHVDJUDHQDXDVWPRUHSORYDFDJUDGDQD5RGRVX8SUHGDYDQMXWHKQLNLQHSRYH]DQLPVD
%DONDQRPDOLUDVSUDYOMDMXLWHPHNRMHVXGRWDNODLGUXJDSUHGDYDQMD0DULDQQH%RTYLVWUD]PDWUDDUKL@
"%H"2&2!#*14+*H($!*?&4"(]"4!2!$(*"#&(>*H#>!=(&(>(!(!*41#!)("4+>%!)&#?(+,(>*H#.!+4*)&41!*"(84!1%"&#)#8%F!
D]LP+DGLPHMOLGLVNXWXMHRNRQNUHWQRPDUKLWHNWRQVNRPHOHPHQWXPLKUDEXLOLPROLWYHQRMQLL
WHWHRORNRPLXPMHWQLNRP]QDHQMXNRMHLPDX%RVQLLGUXJGMH
;(%5(%"$('<2&=#';V%+%&48+(!*%H&%"4&!79':@4<
>.,(#';?%$"7+2&'ODQRGERUD&+Z%D
;(@+0+7+(#'<(%$02$,';2&%-+(H<
0LU]D+DVDQHPDQQDYRGLSLWDQMHXUEDQLKQDVHOMDSODQLUDQLKXNDVQRMRVPDQVNRMGUDYLQDVMHYHUX
%RVQH2YLJUDGRYLGL]DMQLUDQLXNUXWRMHPLELOLVXUDHQLGDELSULKYDWLOLPXVOLPDQHHYDNXLUDQHL]
VXVMHGQH6UELMH1HQDG0DNXOMHYLSLHRDUKLWHNWXULRVPDQVNLKUHIRUPLL]D/HMOD%XDWOL
UDVSUDYOMDRVSRUD]XPXL]PHXVWDURJLQRYRJWUDGLFLMHSUHLYOMDYDQMDLSUHREUDDMDXDUKLWHNWXUL
UH]LGHQWQLK JUDGRYD X %RVQL RNR JRGLQH =H\QHS $KXQED\ L 9MHNRVODYD 6DQNRYL 6LPL QD
NUDMX L]YMHWDYDMX R SRVOMHGQMLP UHVWDXUDFLMDPD GDPLMD L] YLMHND MHGQH QD .RVRYX L GUXJH X
+HUFHJRYLQLLR]DKWMHYLPDVDNRMLPDVXVHVXRLOHWRNRPRYRJSURFHVD
,]JRUHQDYHGHQLKUD]ORJDRUJDQL]DWRULVXQDVWRMDOLREMDYLWLSXEOLNDFLMXXWRNUDHPYUHPHQVNRP
URNXLXLVWRMJRGLQLXNRMRMRGUDQDVDPDNRQIHUHQFLMD.DRPDQMHYUHPHQVNL]DKWMHYQDDOWHUQDWLYD
)#")2+#1!)&%?#-2!*?($!"%H*"#?4!+4!>%5(H%!H#+/%&%+,(>%!Z!%+.8%*H(!(!6#*4+*H(\$&?4"*H(\*&)*H(!Z!1(!*1#!
VHRGOXLOL]DGYRMH]LQLVDHWDNNRMLMHVDLQMHQRGVWUDQHXUHGQLNDJGMHVXJODYQLDUJXPHQWLVYDNRJ
SUHGDYDQMDLGHQWLFLUDQLQDREDMH]LNDQDSRHWNXVYDNRJSRMHGLQDQRJWHNVWD8SUHJOHGXWHNVWRYD
SUREDOL VPR LQWHUYHQLVDWL WR MH PDQMH PRJXH GRSXWDMXL OLQD ]DSDDQMD L LQWHUSUHWDFLMH NRMH QH
SUHGVWDYOMDMXQHRSKRGQRPLOMHQMHXUHGQLNDLOL&+Z%D,QDVDPRPNUDMXHOMHOLELVPRVH]DKYDOLWL
XHVQLFLPDXSURMHNWLPDLRQLPDNRMLVXGRSULQLMHOLRYRMSXEOLNDFLMLLL]UDDYDPRQDGXGDHRYDSXE@
OLNDFLMD]DSRHWLUHOHYDQWQHLQLFLMDWLYHXEXGXQRVWL1HNLRGWHNVWRYDQDVQDSRPLQMXNROLNRWRJDMR
XYLMHNWUHEDPRQDXLWLRRYRPQDVOMHX
17
Maximilian Hartmuth
18
T,"'(2$,.%')+&12&&"&'P(R&'+#'P,+1,'$,"'6(78(#'-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%(7',"%+$(5"'1(#':"'0()"'0.%"'%"7"4(#$'$.'
-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%(7'#(%%($+4"&'+#'5"#"%(7N'-#"'*.&&+:7R'B%2+$B27'(@+&'.B '+#4"&$+5($+.#M',"'17(+0&M'"@+&$&'(7.#5'
Z1"#$%"&/*"%+*,"%+"&M['(#'(**%.(1,')"4+&")'$.')"&1%+:"'(#)'"@*7(+#'$,"'&$%21$2%(7'%"7($+.#&,+*':"$P""#'(#'()4(#1")'
0"$%.*.7+&M'.%'Z1"#$%"M['(#)'('7"&&')"4"7.*")'Z*"%+*,"%RN['A#'$,+&'(#(7R$+1(7'0.)"7M'7(18'.B '&R#1,%.#R'P+$,'$,"'
0"$%.*.7+&'E+#172)+#5'Z*%.4+#1+(7+&0[L'+&'#.$'(&&20")'(&'('5+4"#':2$'(&'*%.)21$'.B '$,+&'2#"4"#'%"7($+.#&,+*N'\($,"%'
$,(#'$.'0"%"7R'$"&$'$,+&'$,".%R'B.%'+$&'(**7+1(:+7+$R'$.'$,"'-$$.0(#/6(78(#'1.#$"@$M',"'"@*7.%"&'$,"']2"&$+.#'.B '$.'
P,($'"@$"#$'#"P'8#.P7")5"'1(#':"'5"#"%($")':R'$,+&'(#(7R$+1(7'0.)"7^&'(@+&'.B '+#4"&$+5($+.#M'(#)'$.'P,($'"@$"#$'+$'
1(#',"7*'$%(18'(#)'"@*7(+#'1,(#5"N'T,"'(2$,.%'27$+0($"7R'&255"&$&'$,($'$,+&',"%+$(5"'+&M'$.'('5..)'"@$"#$M'$,"'4"%R'
%"&27$'.B '1,(#5+#5'1"#$%"/*"%+*,"%R'%"7($+.#&'P+$,+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'%"(70_',"'&$(8"&'.2$'B.2%':%.()'*"%+.)&'+#'P,+1,'
1"#$%"/*"%+*,"%R'%"7($+.#&',(4"'+#B.%0")'1.#1"*$2(7')"&+5#'+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'6(78(#&'+#')+BB"%"#$'P(R&N
$XWRUUD]PDWUDRQDLQLPDQDNRMLPDELVHRVPDQVNRNXOWXUQRQDVOLMHDQD%DONDQXSUHGVWDYOMDORUHOHYDQW/
QLMLPXJHQHUDOQLPQDUDWLYLPDRRVPDQVNRMDUKLWHNWXUL2QWYUGLGDMHGQDPRJXHSORGQDRVLVWUDLYDQMDMHVWH
GX FHQWDUDSHULIHULMD MHGDQ SULVWXS RVPLOMHQ GD RSLH L REMDVQL VWUXNWXUQH RGQRVH L]PHX UD]YLMHQH PHWUR/
SROHSULMHVWROQLFHLOLFHQWUDLPDQMHUD]YLMHQHSHULIHULMH8RYRPDQDOLWLNRPPRGHOXQHGRVWDWDNVLQKURQLMHVD
SULMHVWROQLFRPXNOMXXMXLSURYLQFLMDOL]DPQLMHQHWRWRMHSUHWSRVWDYOMHQRGDMHSUHWKRGQRSODQLUDQRYHUH]XOWDW
#"%(4#.0V"%#+,'.)#.&(N'\()+V"'#"5.')('*%.&$.'$"&$+%('.42'$".%+V2'+'#V"#2'*%+0V"#V+4.&$'#('.&0(#&8./:(78(#&8+'
NRQWHNVWRQLVWUDXMHSLWDQMHSURLUHQMDQRYLK]QDQMDVWYRUHQDL]D]YDQDVOLMHGHLRVHLVWUDLYDQMDNRMHSURPRYLH
RYDMDQDOLWLNLPRGHOLGRNOHWRPRHSUDWLWLLREMDVQLWLSURPMHQX$XWRUQDNUDMXVXJHULUDGDMHRYRQDVOLMHHNDR
WDNYRGREULPGLMHORPUH]XOWDWSURPMHQHRGQRVDFHQWDUSHULIHULMDX2VPDQVNRPFDUVWYXRQREMDQMDYDHWLULSHULRGD
XNRMLPDRGQRVLFHQWDUSHULIHULMDREMDQMDYDMXNRQFHSWXDOQLGL]DMQRVPDQVNRJ%DONDQDQDUD]OLLWHQDLQH
B!
!"#$%&'%#(!$)&*$"$%!,#+/%&%+,%!"("8%-!!"#$%"&'
(#)'*"%+*,"%+"&'+#'-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"3'%")+&1.4"%+#5'('
6(78(#',"%+$(5"3!'$(,$!"##H!)84,%!(+!=4&4>%?#!#+!
A)&(8!BB@BC3!BDED3!4+-!#+!'$(,$!"$(*!)4)%&!'4*!
UVW UHDG KDG EHHQ GHYLVHG LQ FRQVLGHUDWLRQ
#/ !*#1%!/2+-41%+"48!)D%1*!/4,%-!60!"$#*%!
LQWHUHVWHGLQWKH%DONDQ2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUDO
KHULWDJH 2QH RI WKRVH SUREOHPV LV WKLV KHUL@
"4.%J*! (+*"&21%+"48(54"(#+! (+! (-%+"("0! )#8("(,*3!
'$(,$!$4*!14-%!,28"2&48!1#+21%+"*!4!"4&.%"!(+!
DUPHGFRQLFWVDQGGHOLEHUDWHJRYHUQPHQWDORU
12+(,()48!-%1#8("(#+!,41)4(.+*3!#&!Z!8%**!-&4*@
"(,!62"!*(1(84&80!,#+*%Y2%+"(48!Z!*(1)80!&%*28"%-!
LQ GLVLQWHUHVW DQG QHJOHFW 2Q WKH RQH KDQG
"$(*!$4*!&%*28"%-!(+!4+!(+,#1)8%"%!4&,$("%,"2&48!
&%,#&-3! 4! )D%1! +#"! /4,%-! "#! 4! ,#1)4&468%!
-%.&%%!603!*403!*"2-%+"*!#/ !:4&#Y2%!4&,$("%,"2&%!
LQWKH:HVW2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLWVVWXG\(&'(%$'
'4*!#/"%+!&%8%.4"%-!"#!4!)#*("(#+!(+/%&(#&!"#!("*!
4))&4(*48!4*!4+!(-%+"("0!14&H%&F!L$(*!,#+/%&%+,%!
WKHUHIRUHLQWHQGHGWRFRQWULEXWHWRDUHGLVFRY@
HU\RI WKLVKHULWDJHDVVWDWHGLQWKHVXEWLWOHE\
(7&.')#"(+.!"$%!*"2-0!#/ !"$4"!4&,$("%,"2&%!(+!
("*!$(*"#&(,48!4+-!4&"(*"(,!-(1%+*(#+*F!A!*%,#+-!
H%0!)D%13!4+-!#+%!"$4"!(*!"$(*!)4)%&J*!/#,2*3!
,#+,%&+*! "$%! )84,%! #/ ! "$%! :48H4+*! 4+-! #"$%&!
SURYLQFHVLQ2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOQDUUDWLYHVE!
N2,$! #/ ! "$(*! "#)(,J*! *"4+-4&-! 8("%&4"2&%! ,84(1*!
19
20
,OO6NRSMHPRVTXHRIVk%HRQHRIWKHODVW
H[DPSOHVRI7VKDSHGPXOWLIXQFWLRQDOEXLOGLQJVLQWKH2WWRPDQ
GRPDLQ,WVLQVFULSWLRQLGHQWLHVLWQRWDV)ULGD\PRVTXHEXWDV
LPkUHWFKDULWDEOHSXEOLFEXLOGLQJ,QWKHHQGRZPHQWGHHGLW
LVDOVRUHIHUUHGWRDVDKkQNDKGHUYLVKORGJH
(*3!(+!"$%!*%+*%!#/ !&%84"(#+*$()*!6%"'%%+!"'#!"%&@
&("#&(48!2+("*F!S"!,4+!48*#!4))80!"#!-(*,#2&*%3!4*!"$%!
V&%%H!4&"!$(*"#&(4+!M(H#*!94->(+(,#84#2!*#2.$"!
WRDUJXH:HVD\DUWKLVWRU\KHZURWHLQ
EXW ZKDW ZH UHDOO\ PHDQ LV (XURSHDQ DUW
/!"$%!74(+.(4+*!2+"(8!"#-40!)82*!"$%!4&"!#/ !
"$%!T=A!(+!"$%!BD"$FHQWXU\C!L$%!&%8%.4"(#+!(+!
14(+*"&%41!4&"!$(*"#&0!#/ !4&"!)&#-2,%-!60!+#+@
:HVWHUQFXOWXUHVWRIRONDUWDVRSSRVHGWRWKH
KLJKDUWRUQHDUWSURGXFHGLQE\WKH:HVW
(*!,84(1%-!60!94->(+(,#84#2!"#!6%!4!&%*28"!#/ !"$%!
2+%?%+! &%84"(#+*$()! 4--&%**%-! 60! "$%! ,%+"&%*@
)%&()$%&(%*!1#-%83!'("$!#+%!6%(+.!-#1(+4"%-!60!
"$%!#"$%&F
c(*,2**(+.! ,%+"&%*! 4+-! )%&()$%&(%*! (+! -(*@
,#2&*%! *%%1*! %*)%,(4880! )%&"(+%+"! "#! "$%! *"2-0!
$V IDU DV LW SHUWDLQV WR RULHQWDOLVP DV RQH H[DPSOH VHH DOVR
%R]GRDQ 6LEHO DQG *OUX 1HFLSROX (QWDQJOHG GLVFRXUVHV
*,&2"(+(5(+.! #&(%+"48(*"! 4+-! +4"(#+48(*"! 8%.4,(%*! (+! "$%! 4&,$("%,"2&48!
KLVWRULRJUDSK\ RI WKH /DQGV RI 5XP LQ ;2](%#(&3! _#8F! ffS_!
SS
)RU RQH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ VHH 1HFLSROX *OUX T,"' (5"' .B ' U+#(#3'
(%1,+$"1$2%(7'127$2%"'+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'90*+%"F!X#+-#+K!Q%4H"(#+3!BDDC3!)F!
II
$UWKLVWRU\DVDQDUWLVWKLVWRU\KDVSURYHQODUJHO\LPSRVVLEOHLQ
WKH 2WWRPDQ FDVH :LWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI 6LQkQ DQG VRPH RI KLV
*2,,%**#&*3! '%! H+#'! 481#*"! +#"$(+.! 46#2"! "$%! 8(?%*! 4+-! '#&H*!
RI 2WWRPDQ DUFKLWHFWV XS WR WKH "$! ,%+"2&0F! P?%+! '$%&%! 64*(,!
(+/#&14"(#+!(*!4?4(8468%3!"$%*%!4&,$("%,"*J!,#+"&(62"(#+!"#!"$%!-%*(.+!
4+-! 4&,$("%,"2&48! )&#,%**! &%14(+*! 2+*%""8%-F! G#&! 4! &%,%+"! ,&("(Y2%!
RI IRUPDOLVWVFKRODUVKLSRQWKHRWKHUKDQGVHH3DQFDUROX2\D
)RUPDOLVP DQG WKH DFDGHPLF IRXQGDWLRQ RI 7XUNLVK DUW LQ WKH
%4&80! BD"$ FHQWXU\ LQ ;2](%#(& 9RO ;;,9 SS
6FKRODUVKLSVLQFHWKHVKDVLQFUHDVLQJO\IRFXVHGRQWKHTXHVWLRQ
#/ ! )4"&#+4.%3! .&%4"80! 42.1%+"(+.! #2&! H+#'8%-.%! #/ ! ,#+,%)"248!
-%*(.+!)&#,%**%*!4*!4!&%*28"F!S+!$%&!&%,%+"!1#+#.&4)$!C5"'.B 'U+#(#3!
1HFLSROX KDV V\VWHPDWL]HG WKH DUFKLWHFWXUDO SURGXFWLRQ LQ WKH
8(/%"(1%! #/ ! =(+e+! +#"! (+! 4! ,$&#+#8#.(,48! #&! .%#.&4)$(,48! 14++%&!
62"!4,,#&-(+.!"#!)4"&#+4.%!8%?%8*3!"$%&%60!)&#?(+.!"$4"!,#+,%)"248!
GHVLJQZDVFRQVLVWHQWO\LQIRUPHGE\2WWRPDQQRWLRQVRI GHFRUXP
21
22
2QWKLVSRLQWVHHWKHSLRQHHULQJVWXG\E\$QKHJJHU5REHUW=XU
6WHOOXQJHLQHU6WlGWHLQQHUKDOEGHURVPDQLVFKHQ%DXJHVFKLFKWHYRU
6LQDQLQ)XDG.|SUODUPDDQF!S*"4+628K!iA+H4&4!j+(?%&*("%*(k!c(8!
YH7DULK&RUDI\D)DNOWHVLSS
ED 2QWKHFDVHRI "$@,%+"2&0!=H#)>%3!4*!'%88!4*!#+!14+0!4*)%,"*!#/ !
"$(*!*%,"(#+J*!)D%14"(,!(+!.%+%&483!*%%!48*#!:#0H#?3!"$(*!?#821%F
EE! G#&!"$%!64,H.+-*!#/ !"$(*!)$%+#1%+#+!(+!1%-(%?48!A+4"#8(43!*%%!
DOVR:ROSHU(WKHO6DUD3ROLWLFVRI SDWURQDJHSROLWLFDOFKDQJHDQG
WKHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI GHUYLVKORGJHVLQ6LYDVLQ;2](%#(&M'_#8F!fSS!
SS
/##-FEB2IWHQWLPHVWKH7VKDSHG+0`%"$*\X`4+R"*!
*%&?%-!4*!+2,8%(!/#&!-%?%8#)(+.!S*841(,!"#'+*!(+!
14+0!4!:48H4+!8#,48%3!41#+.!'$(,$!'4*!48*#!=4@
&4>%?#F!L$%0!'%&%!62(8"!60!(+-(?(-248*!%+.4.%-!
LQ H[SDQGLQJ WKH 2WWRPDQ VSKHUH RI GRPLQD@
"(#+!#+!"$%!:48H4+!/&#+"(%&F!L$%*%!'%&%!+#"!0%"!
1%&%! *%&?4+"*! #/ ! "$%! *28"4+*! -(*)4",$%-! "#! "$%!
)&#?(+,%*3!$#'%?%&3!4*!'#28-!6%!1#*"!4&,$("%,@
WXUDOSDWURQVLQWKH"$!,%+"2&0!4+-!6%0#+-3!62"!
/&#+"(%&!4.%+"*!%+>#0(+.!4!.&%4"!-%48!#/ !42"#+#10!
(+!"$%(&!&%*)%,"(?%!14&,$%*F!L$%!*28"4+!&%,%(?%-!
D[HGVKDUHRI WKHERRW\IURPUDLGVFRQGXFWHG
LQWRQHLJKERXULQJWHUULWRULHVVWLOOXQGHUQRQ2W@
"#14+!&28%3!4*!4!&%*28"!#/ !'$(,$!$%!140!$4?%!+#"!
/%8"!"$%!+%%-!"#!(+"%&?%+%!4*!8#+.!4*!"$(*!*0*"%1!
'4*!'#&H(+.!4+-!"##H!)84,%!(+!4!&%84"(?%80!,#1@
)4,"!4&%4FE`!L$(*!&%84"(?%!42"#+#10!12*"!48*#!6%!
4!&%4*#+!/#&!'$0!"$%!-(//%&%+,%!6%"'%%+!1#+2@
PHQWVLQYDULRXV2WWRPDQWRZQVLQWKLVHUDLVQRW
4*!.&%4"!4*!(+!84"%&!)%&(#-*F!A--("(#+48803!(+!"%&1*!
#/ !*"08%!4+-!/#&13!"$%*%!)4"&#+*!&%8(%-!#+!1#-%8*!
(1)#&"%-!/!A+4"#8(4K!"$%!)84++%&*!4+-!62(8-@
%&*!'%&%!4))4&%+"80!6.$"!/!"$%!A*(4+!$48/ !
EB $QHDUO\QRZFODVVLFVWXG\LV(\LFH6HPDYLON2VPDQOGHYULQLQ
GLQLLoWLPDL ELU PHVVHVHVL ]DYL\HOHU YH ]DYL\HOL FDPLOHU LQ h
NWLVDW)DNOWHVL0HFPXDV9RO;;,,,1RSSZKR
$#'%?%&3! 1(*"4H%+80! *2..%*"*! "$4"! "$%*%! *"&2,"2&%*! (+("(4880! *%&?%-!
4*! G&(-40! 1#*Y2%*! 60! &%/%&&(+.! "#! "$%1! 4*! X(4+R"7+' 1(0+7"% 2Q WKH
SUREOHPDWLFVHHDOVR$QKHJJHU5REHUW%HLWUlJH]XURVPDQLVFKHQ
%DXJHVFKLFKWH,,,LQA&$(#:27"%';+$$"+72#5"#9RO;;9,,SS
HVS SDUW ,, =XU )UDJH GHU 73ODQPRVFKHHQ SS
DQGIRUDUHFHQWUHDSSUDLVDO%R\NRYWKLVYROXPH$QH[FHOOHQW
*"2-0! #/ ! "$%*%! (+*"("2"(#+*J! '#&H(+.*! (+! 4! EC"$ DQG "$@,%+"2&0!
%DONDQ FRQWH[W LV 1RUPDQ <RUN ,PDUHWV ,VODPL]DWLRQ DQG
XUEDQGHYHORSPHQWLQ6DUDMHYRLQb"")+#5'*".*7"M'B"")+#5'
*.P"%3'+0(%"$&'+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'90*+%"F!P-*F!M(+4!P&.(+3!7$&(*"#)$!UF!
M%214++3!4+-!A10!=(+.%&F!S*"4+628K!PQPM3!BDDb3!))F'
+HUH UHIHUHQFH LV PDGH WR WKH HDUO\ V X`4+R"! *)#+*#&%-! 60!
Vk %H 2Q WKLV EXLOGLQJ LQFOXGLQJ D QRWH RQ LWV WKUHHVSDFHG
7VKDSHG"OD\RXWDVUHODWHGLQWKH4(8BcR"VHHPRVWUHFHQWO\$HUL
,QHV1HNHQDSRPHQHRSUREOHPLPDL]KLVWRULMH,VDEHJRYHWHNLMH
(+K!3ULOR]L]DRULMHQWDOQXORORJLMX9RO/,,/,,,SS2Q
WKHGHYHORSPHQWRI 6DUDMHYRDQGWKHDJHQF\RI Vk%HVHHDOVR
1RUPDQ6DUDMHYR
E` 5HFHQW VWXGLHV RQ WKH IURQWLHU G\QDVWLHV LQFOXGH /RZU\ +HDWK
T,"'&,(*+#5'.B '$,"'-$$.0(#'6(78(#&'EFHdK/FddKL3'$,"'1.#]2"&$M'&"$$7"0"#$'
e' +#B%(&$%21$2%(7' )"4"7.*0"#$' .B ' O.%$,"%#' f%""1" ,VWDQEXO %DKoHHKLU
T+(?%&*("0!O268(,4"(#+*3!BDDa3!%*)F!,$F!EgB3!4+-!U()&#?*H43!N4&(04F!
7KH 0LKDOROX IDPLO\ 5(X+' '4&&(#&*! 4+-! )4"&#+*! #/ ! -%&?(*$!
KRVSLFHVLQ2VPDQO$UDWUPDODU9RO;;,,,SS
EC 7KLVLVVXJJHVWHGQRWOHDVWE\DUWLVWLQVFULSWLRQVDVIRULQVWDQFH
(+!"$%!,4*%!#/ !"$%!%4&80!EC"$@,%+"2&0!0+g0`%!L#.4+3!*#+!#/ !lA6-288e$!
DFRQYHUW"ZKRVHQDPHLVIRXQGRQWKHdHOHEL0HKPHGPRVTXH
LQ'LG\PRWHLFKRQ*UHHN7KUDFHDQGWKH%k\H]vG3DDPRVTXHLQ
$PDV\D,GRQRWFRQVLGHU+DFYD]3DDVLPLODUO\PHQWLRQHGLQ
WKH'LG\PRWHLFKRQLQVFULSWLRQDVZHOODVLQEXLOGLQJVRI WKH<HLO
FRPSOH[LQ%XUVDWRKDYHEHHQDQDUFKLWHFWLQWKHSURSHUVHQVH
7/F! =m+1%53! W%H(F! %DODQJoWDQ \]\OD NDGDU $QDGROX 7UNVOkP
PLPDULVLQGHVDQDWoODU$QNDUD7UN7DULK.XUXPX%DVPHYLS
I$PDV\DI'LG\PRWHLFKRQDQG%XUVD
)RUWKHEDVLFWHQHWVRI WKH"$@,%+"2&0!*0*"%1!4+-!("*!,#+*%Y2%+"!
"&4+*/#&14"(#+3!*%%!U2+"3!N%"(+F!T,"'&27$(#^&'&"%4(#$&3'$,"'$%(#&B.%0($+.#'
.B ' -$$.0(#' *%.4+#1+(7' 5.4"%#0"#$M' FddK/FQdKN! M%'! I#&HK! 7#8216(4!
8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV )RU WKH FHQWUDOL]DWLRQ XQGHU 0HKPHG ,,
DQG LWV LPSDFW RQ DUFKLWHFWXUH VHH 1HFLSROX *OUX C%1,+$"1$2%"M'
1"%"0.#+(7M' (#)' *.P"%K! WKH 7RSNDS SDODFH LQ WKH IWHHQWK DQG VL[WHHQWK
1"#$2%+"&&DPEULGJH0,73UHVFK
Eb &I1HFLSROXC5"'.B 'U+#(#SDQGFKLQJHQHUDO
RI WKH2WWRPDQHPLUDWHVXOWDQDWHEC!'$(8%!1#*"!
#/ !"$%!'#&H/#&,%!'4*!,%&"4(+80!&%,&2("%-!8#,4880!
/#&!)&4,"(,48!&%4*#+*F
7KH SURFHVVHV WULJJHUHG E\ WKH 2WWRPDQV
,#+Y2%*"!#/ !"$%!8#+.!-%*(&%-!:054+"(+%!,4)("48!(+!
HYHQWXDOO\JDYHULVHWRDGLIIHUHQWVLWXDWLRQ
(+!"%&1*!#/ !4&,$("%,"2&%3!'%!%+"%&!'$4"!(*!.%+%&@
DOO\ FDOOHG WKH FODVVLFDO SHULRG DQG VW\OH :LWK
WKLVLPSRUWDQWFRQTXHVWWKH2WWRPDQVHQWHUWKH
(1)%&(48! )$4*%! #/ ! "$%(&! -0+4*"(,! $(*"#&03! /2&"$%&!
4,,%8%&4"%-! 60! "$%! (1)#&"4+"! ,#+Y2%*"*! #/ ! H%0!
,VODPLFVLWHVVXFKDV'DPDVFXV&DLUR-HUXVDOHP
4+-!N%,,4\N%-(+4!(+!"$%!%4&80!ECDD*F!L$%&%!-%@
YHORSHGDFHQWUDOL]HGDEVROXWLVWVWDWHSHUVRQLHG
60!"$%!*28"4+!4+-!(+!'$(,$!"$%&%!'4*!8(""8%!"#8%&@
4+,%!/#&!)#**(68%!)&#?(+,(48!,#+"%*"4+"*!/#&!)#'%&F!
2YHUWKHFRXUVHRI GHFDGHVPLOLWDU\OHDGHUVZLWK
4! )#'%&@64*%! (+! "$%! :48H4+! )&#?(+,%*! '%&%! &%@
)84,%-! '("$! 4+! S*"4+628@"&4(+%-! ,84**! #/ ! 1(8("4&0!
.#?%&+#&*F$WDWLPHRI KHLJKWHQHGFRQLFWZLWK
+%(.$6#2&(+.!=$(("%!S&4+3!"$%!*28"4+*!"2&+%-!"#!4+!
#&"$#-#R!=2++(!(+"%&)&%"4"(#+!#/ !"$%!S*841(,!/4("$!
4+-!)%&*%,2"%-!4*!$%&%"(,*!14+0!#/ !"$%!$%"%&#-#R!
.)*!'$(,$!$4-!)&%?(#2*80!.&%4"80!4(-%-!"$%1!(+!
*)&%4-(+.!"$%(&!$%.%1#+0!#?%&!"$%!:48H4+*F!
A88!"$(*!48*#!$4-!4+!%//%,"!#+!"$%!4&,$("%,"2&%!
62(8"!"$%&%4/"%&F!A))4&%+"80!4*!4!&%*28"!#/ !4!.&%4"%&!
+%%-!/#&!+%'!,#+*"&2,"(#+!)84++(+.3!%*)%,(4880!(+!
WKHLUQHZFDSLWDOWKHQVWLOODJKRVWWRZQOOHG
'("$!,$2&,$%*!Z!"$%!*28"4+*!.4"$%&%-!2+-%&!"$%1!
4!.)!#/ !4&,$("%,"*!"#!2+-%&"4H%!'#&H!/#&!"$%1!
4+-! "$%(&! ,8(%+"*F! [("$(+! "$(*! .)3! /#&! *%?%&48!
.%+%&4"(#+*3!*H(88!*%%1*!"#!$4?%!6%%+!"&4+*/%&&%-!
/!/4"$%&!"#!*#+FEb!9#'%?%&3!'("$!=(+e+!(+!"$%!
23
24
-%*(.+!4+-!)84++(+.!#/ !"$%!*28"4+J*!4&,$("%,"2&48!
)&#>%,"*h!"$%#&%"(,48803!488!,#+*"&2,"(#+!4,"(?("0!(+!
"$%!,4)("48!4+-!"$%!)&#?(+,%*!6%,41%!$(*!&%*)#+@
*(6(8("0F!9%!&%8%.4"%-!>#6*!"#!4&,$("%,"*!'#&H(+.!
2+-%&!$(1!4+-!-(*)4",$%-!"$%1!"#!"$%!)&#?(+,%*!
'$%&%! +%%-%-F! 9%! 48*#! *4'! "#! ("! "$4"! "$%! )84+*!
/#&!$(*!(+*"("2"(#+J*!4&,$("%,"2&48!)&#>%,"*!/#&!"$%!
*28"4+J*!*%&?4+"*!(+!"$%!,4)("48!4+-!"$%!)&#?(+,%*!
'%&%! ,#11%+*2&4"%! '("$! "$%(&! )4"&#+*J! &4+HF!
L$%!4&,$("%,"2&48!#2",#1%!"$2*!-%)%+-%-!+#"!#+!
4!)4"&#+!#&!4&,$("%,"J*!/#880h!"$%!+216%&!4+-!-(@
$W OHDVW FRQFHUQLQJ KLV UROH LQ ,VWDQEXO WKLV MRE SUROH VHHPV WR
$4?%!&%14(+%-!2+,$4+.%-!2+"(8!"$%!84"%!Ea"$!,%+"2&0F!7/F!"$%!&%14&H*!
RQ WKH 0LPDU$JKD LQ '2KVVRQ ,JQDWLXV 0RXUDGJHDN' T(:7"(2'
5=#=%(7' )"' 7^"0*+%"' .$,.0(#3' )+4+&=' "#' )"2@' *(%$+"&' h"$1NiF! S*"4+628K! S=S=3!
>@9RO,,S
1%+*(#+*!#/ !/%4"2&%*!*2,$!4*!1(+4&%"*!#&!-#1%*!
'%&%!&%.284"%-!60!"$(*!(+*"("2"(#+!(+!"$%!,4)("48FBD!
7#+,%&+(+.! "$%! :48H4+*3! "$%! )&%/%&&%-! "0)%*!
#/ ! 4&,$("%,"2&%! *)#+*#&%-! 60! ?4&(#2*! )4"&#+*!
,$4+.%!(+!4,,#&-4+,%!'("$!"$%*%!-%?%8#)1%+"*F!
L$%! 128"(@/2+,"(#+48! L@*$4)%-! 62(8-(+.*! -(*4)@
)%4&h! "$%0! 4&%! &%)84,%-! 60! ,82*"%&*! #/ ! 62(8-(+.*!
,%+"&%-!#+!4!G&(-40!1#*Y2%3!"$4"!(*3!+#"!1%&%80!
4!)&40%&!&##1!#&!#&4"#&0!;0"&1c)<!62"!4!1#*Y2%!
(+!'$(,$!"$%!G&(-40!*%&1#+!;,2$:"<'(*!&%4-!60!4!
)&%4,$%&! ;,($c:<! $4?(+.! 2+-%&.#+%! 4! )&#)%&! 0"/
)%"&"'%-2,4"(#+F!L$%!,($c:''4*!%R)%,"%-!+#"!#+80!
"#!(+?#H%!"$%!*#?%&%(.+J*!+41%3!62"!48*#!"#!*)&%4-!
DQG FRQVROLGDWH ZLWK WKHLU SUHDFKLQJ 2UWKRGR[
,VODPLQDUHDVVWLOOXQGHUWKHLQXHQFHRI KHWHUR@
-#R!8%4+(+.*F!
$OOWKLVKHOSVH[SODLQWKHVSUHDGRI DVSHFLF
W\SHRI PRVTXHLQWKH"$@,%+"2&0!:48H4+*K!"$%!
*(+.8%@*)4,%-!1#*Y2%!'("$!4!$%1(*)$%&(,48!-#1%3!
DVWHHSPLQDUHWDQGDSRUWLFRZLWKWKUHHRUYH
ED\VLOOV7KHVXOWDQH[SHFWHGKLVVHUYDQWV
"#!*$4&%!(+!$(*!)&#>%,"!#/ !*)&%4-(+.!$(*!)#8(,0!#+!
/4("$!4+-!#/ !,%+"&48(5%-!*#?%&%(.+"0F!L$%!(+?%*"@
1%+"!$4-!"#!6%!"$%(&*!Z!4+-!("!,%&"4(+80!'4*!4+!
(+?%*"1%+"3!4*!'%!'%88!H+#'!"$4"!"$%!%*"468(*$@
1%+"!#/ !4(8B*!'%&%!+#"!48'40*!64*%-!(+!%+"(&%80!
)$(84+"$&#)(,! 1#"(?%*! Z! 62"! "$%! *28"4+! '#28-!
14H%!4?4(8468%!"#!$(*!4-1(+(*"&4"#&*!"$%!&%*#2&,%*!
#/ !"$%!,4)("48J*!4&,$("%,"2&48!(+*"("2"(#+F!S"!'#28-!
*%+-!4!)84+!,#11%+*2&4"%!'("$!"$%!)&#>%,"!4+-!
"$%!)4"&#+J*!*"4"2*!"#!"$%!)&#?(+,%*!/#&!("!"#!6%!
%R%,2"%-! 60! 8#,48! '#&H1%+! 2+-%&! "$%! *2)%&?(@
*(#+!#/ !*H(88%-!*"4// !*(1(84&80!-(*)4",$%-!/!"$%!
,4)("48FBE!S+!"$(*!,4*%3!4+!#8-%&!1#-%8!$4-!%?#8?%-!
LQWRDJHQHULFSODQW\SHIRUKLJKUDQNLQJRIFLDOV
'(88(+.!"#!62(8-!(+!"$%!)&#?(+,%*F!S"!(*!"$(*!1#-%8!
"$4"! -#1(+4"%*! 1#*Y2%! 4&,$("%,"2&%! (+! :#*+(43!
ZLWK H[DPSOHV RI PRVTXHV LQ 6DUDMHYR )RD
0RVWDUDMQLH3RLWHOM0DJODM.ODGDQM/LYQR
4+-! L&4?+(H3! 488! 62(8"! 6%"'%%+! "$%! EC`D*! 4+-!
VDQGVKRZLQJYHU\OLWWOHYDULDWLRQIURPWKLV
)&#"#"0)%F!X##H(+.!4"!"$%!14"%&(48!/!"$(*!)%&@
*)%,"(?%3!4"!4!-#5%+!481#*"!(-%+"(,48!1#*Y2%*3!"$%!
25
26
,OOXPHQPRVTXHRIHUvI+DOvO3DD
BB! G#&! "$%*%! 62(8-(+.*3! "$%(&! "0)%*! 4+-! )84+*3! *%%! A0?%&-(3! PH&%1!
+DNN $YUXSDGD 2VPDQO PLPkUv HVHUOHUL 9RO ,, ,VWDQEXO VWDQEXO
G%"($! 7%1(0%"(3! BDDDB $QGUHMHYL $QGUHM A&7(0&8(' 0.#20"#$(7#('
XPHWQRVW;9,YHNDX-XJRVODYLMLNXSROQHGDPLMH%HOJUDGH6$18
0XMH]LQRYL0HKPHG,VODPVNDHSLJUDND%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQHYROV
6DUDMHYR9HVHOLQ0DVOHD
! G#&! *#1%! %R41)8%*3! 1#*"80! -4"(+.! "#! "$%! Ea"$! ,%+"2&0J*! 1(--8%!
GHFDGHVVHHP\(LJKWHHQWKFHQWXU\2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHDQGWKH
SUREOHPRI VFRSHDFULWLFDOYLHZIURPWKH%DONDQSHULSKHU\LQ
T,+%$""#$,'A#$"%#($+.#(7'!.#5%"&&'.B 'T2%8+&,'C%$F!P-*F!Vn54!G%$%&!4+-!
,ERO\D*HUHO\HV%XGDSHVW+XQJDULDQ1DWLRQDO0XVHXPSS
7KHUH ZDV FRQVLGHUDEOH EXLOGLQJ DFWLYLW\ LQ DUHDV QHZO\
FRQTXHUHGE\WKH2WWRPDQVLQZKDWLVQRZ+XQJDU\DQG5RPDQLD
4/"%&!"$%!1(-@Eb"$!,%+"2&03!62"!8(""8%!#/ !"$4"!&%14(+%-!4/"%&!"$%*%!4&%4*!
'%&%!8#*"!"#!"$%!946*62&.*F!:%/#&%!"$%!1(-@Ea"$!,%+"2&03!"$%&%!'4*!
48*#!*#1%!&%,#+*"&2,"(#+!4,"(?("0!(+!"$#*%!4&%4*!#/ !*#2"$%&+!V&%%,%!
"%1)#&4&(80!8#*"!"#!"$%!_%+%"(4+*F
B` )RU WKH EXLOGLQJ LQ 1HYHKLU VHH *RRGZLQ *RGIUH\ C' ,+&$.%R' .B '
-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"/RQGRQ7KDPHV +XGVRQSIIRU
XPHQFI+DUWPXWK(LJKWHHQWKFHQWXU\2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUH
SDQGUHIHUHQFHV
IRXQGDWLRQVRI *k]v+VUHY%HLQ6DUDMHYRDQG
RI 6RNROOX )HUKkG 3DD LQ %DQMD /XND HPHUJH
4*! &%14&H468%! %R,%)"(#+*3! ?%&0! )ﲨ! -2%! "#!
"$%(&!)4"&#+*J!&%84"(?%!)(+%+,%FBB
:%"'%%+! "$%! 1(-@Eb"$! 4+-! 1(-@Ea"$! ,%+"2&03!
.%+%&4880!?%&0!8(""8%!+%'!,#+*"&2,"(#+!4,"(?("0!#+!4!
1#+21%+"48!*,48%!,4+!6%!"&4,H%-F!L$%!P1)(&%!
DQGLWVDJHQWVDUHEXV\JKWLQJZDUVEXWWKHSHUL@
#-!#/ !*%&(48!"&(21)$*!(*!8#+.!#?%&F!L$%!946*62&.!
4&10!)&%**%*!4*!/4&!4*!N4,%-#+(43!"$%!_%+%"(4+*!
(+"#! )%+(+*284&! V&%%,%h! 6#"$! %?%+"24880! -%)4&"!
4.4(+3! 62"! 8%4?%! 6%$(+-! 4! "&4(8! #/ ! -%*"&2,"(#+F!
0XFKRI WKHUVWKDOI RI WKH"$!,%+"2&0J*!4&@
,$("%,"2&48! 4,"(?("0! &%?#8?%*! 4+-! &%*"#&4"(#+3!
&%)4(&3!4+-!&%62(8-(+.F!L$%&%!4&%!"'#!#2"*"4+-(+.!
1#+21%+"*!/!"$%!*%,#+-!Y24&"%&!#/ !"$%!Ea"$!
,%+"2&0! (+! "$%! ,%+"&48! )&#?(+,%*! Z! "$%! 1#*Y2%!
FRPSOH[HVRI HUvI +DOvO3DDLQXPHQ%XOJDU@
LDLOODQGRI 'kPkGEUkKvP3DDLQ1HYHKLU
;74))4-#,(4<!Z!62"!6#"$!12*"!6%!,#+*(-%&%-!%R@
,%)"(#+*F!="(883!"$%!)4""%&+!(*!*"(88!12,$!8(H%!"$4"!#/ !
WKH"$!,%+"2&0K!"$%*%!62(8-(+.*!4&%!*)#+*#&%-!60!
2WWRPDQRIFLDOVZLWKFDUHHUVUHYROYLQJDURXQG
S*"4+6283! "$%(&! 62(8-(+.*! /#88#'(+.! "$%! ,%+"&%J*!
*"08%!,8#*%803!4+-!?%&0!)ﲨ!14H(+.!2*%!#/ !("*!
(+/&4*"&2,"2&%! #/ ! )84++(+.! 4+-! -%*(.+F! S+! 6#"$!
,4*%*! "$%! 1#+21%+"*J! )4"&#+*! *%%1%-! "#! $4?%!
GHVLUHG WR HTXLS WKHLU UHODWLYHO\ LQVLJQLFDQW
QDWLYHWRZQVZLWK VRPH PDJQLFHQFH IURP WKH
,4)("483!4+-!"#!)#"%!"$%1!4*!2&64+!,%+"&%*!60!
,#+"&(62"(+.! "#! "$%(&! )(+%+,%! "$.$! "$%(&!
(+/&4*"&2,"2&%FB`!
27
28
(+!"$%(&!,4&%%&*!-%"%&1(+%-!0%"!4.4(+!(+!"$%!,4)(@
"48F!M%R"!"#!"$(*!+%'3!)268(,!(+/&4*"&2,"2&%3!+#'!
QDQFHG QRW E\ LQGLYLGXDO 4(8B*! 62"! 60! ,%+"&48!
*"4"%!(+*"("2"(#+*3!"$%!#"$%&!14>#&!(++#?4"(#+!"#!
"$%! :48H4+! ,("0*,4)%*! (*! "$%! &%"2&+! ;#&! )%&$4)*!
UDWKHU WKH DGYHQW" RI PRQXPHQWDO FKXUFK DU@
,$("%,"2&%F!="4&"(+.!/!"$%!EaBD*3!'%!*%%!#/"%+!
84&.%!62"!%R"%&+4880!?%&0!$2168%!62(8-(+.*F!G!
"$%! EaCD*! #+'4&-*! '%! 48&%4-0! *%%! ?%&0! -4&(+.!
-%*(.+*3! 2+-%&1(+(+.! S*841(,! 62(8-(+.*J! "&4-(@
WLRQDO SURPLQHQFH LQ PRVW 2WWRPDQ FLWLHV -XVW
4*! "$%! *"4"%J*! +%'! (+/&4*"&2,"2&48! 62(8-(+.*3! "$%0!
4&%! (+,&%4*(+.80! -(*"(+.2(*$%-! 60! "$%! 6#&&#'(+.!
#/ ! /#&1*! /! '%*"%&+! P2&#)%4+! 4&,$("%,"2&%3!
*#1%"(1%*!%+"(&%!"0)%*!;(88F!b<F
L$%&%/#&%3!/#2&!)%&(#-*!%1%&.%!-(*"(+.2(*$%-!
60! "$%! &%84"(#+*$()! 6%"'%%+! "$%! ,%+"&%! 4+-! "$%!
)%&()$%&0!4+-!%?(-%+,%-!(+!("*!(1)4,"!#+!4&,$(@
"%,"2&48! )&#-2,"(#+F! L#! %1)$4*(5%! "$(*! )#(+"! S!
*$488!+41%!"$%1!4*!/#88#'*K!E<!)#80,%+"&(*1!;,4F!
WRXQWLODIWHUFHQWUDOLVPODWH"$!
"#!1(-@Ea"$!,"F<3!-(?(-%-!481#*"!%Y24880!(+"#!4!)%@
29
Johan Mrtelius
30
C2$.%'%(&*%(47V('.'0V"&$2'8.V"'.&0(#&8+'&*.0"#+1+'&('6(78(#('*%")&$(47V(V2'2'X(*()#.V'+'+&7(0&8.V'(%,+$"8$2%+N'
8ND]XMXLQDQHNHRVPDQVNHJUDGLWHOMVNHFMHOLQHLOLVSRPHQLNHNRMLVXQHGDYQRSURJODHQL6YMHWVNLPNXOWXUQLPGR/
EULPDSRG]DWLWRP81(6&2DRQVPDWUDGDMHMDNRLQWHUHVDQWQRGDMHIRNXVVWDYOMHQQDJUDGLWHOMVNHFMHOLQHDQH
QDLQGLYLGXDOQHVSRPHQLNH7LPHMHSUL]QDWXWLFDMRVPDQVNRJSHULRGDPHXWLP]DL]YDQUHGQHVSRPHQLNHVHPRUD
RWLLX,VWDQEXOLOL(GLUQH,QGLYLGXDOQLVSRPHQLFLQD%DONDQXRQVHDOLVHQHPRJXSURQDLQLSUHJOHGDYDQMLPD
HXURSVNHQLWLLVODPVNHDUKLWHNWXUHDNQLXVWDQGDUGQLPSUHJOHGDYDQMLPD2VPDQVNHDUKLWHNWXUHNRMDVXSUHWHQR
RJUDQLHQDQDSURVWRUGDQDQMH7XUVNHDNQLXVNRULMLPVWXGLMDPDUD]PMHQHL]PHXHYURSVNHLVUHGQMRLVWRQH
LLOLERJDWLKD]LMVNLKNXOWXUDRYHVWXGLMHVXSUHWHQRRJUDQLHQHQDUD]PMHQHL]PHXGYRUDLJODYQLKJUDGRYD
$XWRUVHSLWDGDOLMHQDSULPMHU3DOD]]R'XFDOHX8UELQXL]JUDHQRGVWUDQHDUKLWHNWHL]=DGUD9HQHFLMDQVNL
5%()':7+X2'5%(#+1"'&'-&0(#&8+0'1(%&$4.0L'0.5(.'+0($+')4('0+#(%"$('p'$.%#V"4"'8(.'%"X27$($'$(84+,'*%.1"&(N'-#'
WDNRHSRGYODLSDUDOHOXL]PHXEDONDQVNLKMHGQRNXSROQLKGDPLMDL]SHULRGDYLMHNDLLGHDOQHFUNYHQH
$+*.7.5+V"'0.)"%#"'A$(7+V"N' -8.' FoQKN' 5N' 1%84(' U(#' b%(#1"&1.' 2' \+0+#+V2' V"' $%":(7(' :+$+' *%".:7+8.4(#(' *%"0('
GL]DMQX$OEHUWLMDSRNULYDMXLMHSROXNUXQRPNXSRORPLVWDYOMDMXLVWXERYHVDXOD]QHVWUDQHGDELSRGVMHDODQD
NODVLQLKUDP0DGDSURMHNDWQLMHQLNDGD]DYUHQWRMHVWDQGDUGQDUHIHUHQFDXSUHJOHGLPD]DSDGQHDUKLWHNWXUH
0RGHUQDGDPLMDL]JUDHQDRGVWUDQH0HKPHGD,,X3ULWLQLVGUXJHVWUDQH-DGUDQDVOLMHGLLVWHSULQFLSHDOLRVWDMH
SRWSXQRQHSR]QDWDLURMMDYQRVWL
E!
n'!"#$2%+"&'.B '-$$.0(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"3'Z('&2*%(/#($+.#(7',"%+$(5"['iS*"4+6283!
1RYHPEHU @ (GV 1XU $NLQ $IH %DWXU DQG 6HOoXN
:4"2&3!S*"4+628K!IPN3!BDDDF!
,OO8UELQR3DOD]]R'XFDOHVHFRQGKDOIRIWKHWKFHQWXU\
32
,OO5LPLQL7HPSLR
0DODWHVWLDQR$OEHUWLV
XQLPSOHPHQWHGGHVLJQ
IURPFRPPHPRUDWHGRQ
FRLQFD
,OO5LPLQL7HPSLR0DODWHVWLDQROHIWLQFRPSOHWHLQ
4!1#&%!)#)284&!8%?%8!(*!"$%!+%'!,("0!12*%21!#/ !
U40*%&(!(+!,%+"&48!A+4"#8(43!"$%!&%.(#+!(+!'$(,$!
=(+4+! *)%+"! $(*! ,$(8-$##-! 6%/#&%! &%*%""8(+.! (+!
S*"4+628F![$(8%!U40*%&(!6#4*"*!4!+216%&!#/ !)&%@
2WWRPDQ PDVWHUSLHFHV ZH QG WKHUH RQO\ RQH
&%84"(?%80!1(+#&3!1#*Y2%!4""&(62"%-!"#!=(+4+F!I%"!
"$%! +%'! 12*%213! /2+-%-! 60! "$%! )&(?4"%! U4-(&!
94*! /#2+-4"(#+3! $4*! ,$#*%+! "#! /#,2*! #+! =(+4+!
4+-! $(*! '#&H*F! M%R"! "#! "$%! '%88@H+#'+! *("%*! (+!
S*"4+628! 4+-! P-(&+%3! $(.$8(.$"%-! 4&%! 48*#! "$%!
81(6&2OLVWHGEULGJHVLQ9LHJUDGDQG0RVWDU
L$%!/#&1%&!(*!(+-%%-!4!'#&H!#/ !=(+4+h!"$%!84"@
"%&!(*!)&%*%+"%-!4*!-%*(.+%-!60!#+%!#/ !$(*!)2)(8*F!
9%&%3!,%+"&48!A+4"#8(4!(*!&%)&%*%+"%-!4*!"$%!$26!
#/ !=(+4+J*!'#&H!(+!4!.%#.&4)$0!'$(,$!%R"%+-*!"#!
$(*!'#&H*!(+!:48H4+!P2&#)%!%?%+!(+!,4*%*!'$%&%3!
4*!'("$!N#*"4&3!"$%!,#++%,"(#+!(*!&4"$%&!(+-(&%,"F!
A*!$(+"%-!4"!46#?%3!(+,&%4*%-!&%,#.+("(#+!#/ !
2WWRPDQ(XURSHVDUFKLWHFWXUDOKHULWDJHE\LQVWL@
WXWLRQVOLNH81(6&2VZRUOGKHULWDJHFRPPLW@
B!
`!
C!
m"#+1"'(#)'$,"'A&7(0+1'P.%7)N!P-F!="%/4+#!74&6#+(F!M%'!94?%+K!I48%!
T+(?%&*("0!O&%**3!BDDbF
"%%!(*!+#'!%?(-%+"F!A"!"$%!*41%!"(1%3!"$(*!$%&("4.%!
,#+"(+2%*!"#!84&.%80!&%14(+!#2"*(-%!"$%!-(*,#2&*%!
#/ ! P2&#)%4+! 4&,$("%,"2&%F! 9%&%! "$%! 8(1("(+.!
/&41%'#&H! *$#'+3! /#&! %R41)8%3! (+! M(H#842*!
O%?*+%&J*!*"4+-4&-!-2$7+#"'.B '92%.*"(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"'
LVVWLOOPRUHRUOHVVWKHUXOHB!A!1#&%!&%@
,%+"!:&("(*$!*2&?%03! S"&$"%#' (%1,+$"1$2%" E\
S4+!=2""#+3!"&(%*!"#!.#!6%0#+-!"&4-("(#+48!6#&-%&*!
60! (+,82-(+.! *#1%! M#&-(,! %R41)8%*3! 4+-! +#"!
#+80!(+!"$%!*%,"(#+!#+!1#-%&+(*1F!=2""#+!48*#!
14H%*! &%/%&%+,%! "#! 4+,(%+"! "%1)8%*! #/ ! :4486%H!
(+! )&%*%+"@-40! X%64+#+! 4+-! (+,82-%*! 4! *%,"(#+!
#+!"$%!94.(4!=#)$(4!4+-!84"%&!:054+"(+%!4,$(%?%@
1%+"*3! ,#+,82-%-! '("$! +#"%*! #+! Q2**(4+! %,,8%@
VLDVWLFDO DUFKLWHFWXUH RI WKH "$@Ea"$! ,%+"2&(%*F!
9#'%?%&3!=2""#+J*!*2&?%0!#/ !4&,$("%,"2&%!(+!"$%!
:HVW LQFOXGHV QRW RQH H[DPSOH RI 2WWRPDQ
4&,$("%,"2&%! #&3! /#&! "$4"! 14""%&3! "$%! N2*8(1! 4&@
,$("%,"2&%!#/ !=)4(+!;7#&-#?4!(*!1%+"(#+%-!#+80!
(+!&%84"(#+!"#!4!Eb"$FHQWXU\FKXUFK2I FRXUVH
RQHPD\VD\WKDWWKHWHUP:HVWHUQDVRSSRVHG
WR(XURSHDQLPSOLHVVRPHWKLQJPRUHFXOWXUDO
UDWKHUWKDQJHRJUDSKLFDVGRHVWKHVLJQLHU(X@
URSH%\H[FOXGLQJ6SDQLVK,VODPLFDUFKLWHFWXUH
$#'%?%&3!'$(,$!(+!4!8("%&48!.%#.&4)$(,48!*%+*%!(*!
1#&%!'%*"%&+!"$4+!1#*"!#/ !"$%!&%*"!#/ !P2&#)%3!
DVZHOODV2WWRPDQFRQWULEXWLRQVLWSODFHVWKHVH
4&,$("%,"2&48!,28"2&%*!(+!%R(8%!)#*("(#+*F!
L$(*!%R,82*(#+!(*!*#2&,%-!(+!"$%!%R(*"%+,%!#/ !
4+#"$%&! ,4"%.#&0! (+! '$(,$! "$%*%! "&4-("(#+*! 4&%!
XVXDOO\FXOOHGWRJHWKHU,VODPLFDUFKLWHFWXUH2QH
,4+! -%64"%! "$%! )D%1*! ,42*%-! 60! "$%! 6(+4&0!
DQG E\ LPSOLFDWLRQ RSSRVLWLRQDO FODVVLFDWLRQV
RI (XURSHVKHULWDJHLQWRRQHWKDWLV:HVWHUQ
DQG WKH RWKHU EHLQJ ,VODPLF EXW LW PXVW EH
QRWHGWKDW2WWRPDQ(XURSHLVW\SLFDOO\PDUJLQ@
48(5%-! (/ ! +#"! %R,82-%-! 48"#.%"$%&! /! 6#"$! #/ !
"$%*%! -(*,()8(+4&0! "&4-("(#+*F! [$%+! %?%+! V#-@
IUH\ *RRGZLQV VWDQGDUG VXUYH\ RI 2WWRPDQ
4&,$("%,"2&%!84&.%80!%R,82-%-!1#+21%+"*!#2"*(-%!
!
1#-%&+!L2&H%03 `LWPXVWQRWEHH[SHFWHGWRQG
,OO3ULVKWLQDPRVTXHRI0HKPHG,,)DWLK
33
34
$GULDWLFUHJLRQDVDHOGRI H[FKDQJHLQ5HQDLV@
*4+,%!,28"2&%!&%14(+*!"#!6%!%R)8#&%-F!L$%!%!#/ !
/XFLDQR/DXUDQDGWKH'DOPDWLDQERUQ
4&,$("%,"! '$#! -%*(.+%-! "$%! O48455#! c2,48%! (+!
T&6(+#! '("$! ("*! 1(+4&%"@8(H%! "#'%&*! ;(88F! E<3! 140!
6%!4!,4*%!(+!)#(+"F!
2WKHUSRWHQWLDOO\LQWHUHVWLQJSDUDOOHOVEHWZHHQ
"$%! :48H4+! *(+.8%@-#1%-! 1#*Y2%*! #/ ! "$%! EC"$@
Eb"$! ,%+"2&(%*! 4+-! "$%! (-%48! ,$2&,$! "0)#8#.0! (+!
,#+"%1)#&4&0! S"480! %R(*"F! 9%&%3! #+%! 140! &%/%&3!
/#&! %R41)8%3! "#! "$%! *#@,488%-! L%1)(#! N484"%*@
"(4+#!(+!Q(1(+(3!#+!S"480J*!A-&(4"(,!,#4*"F!A+-!
E`CD3!"$%!/41#2*!X%#+!:4""(*"4!A86%&"(!-%*(.+%-!
4!)&#>%,"!/#&!,#+?%&"(+.!"$%!,$2&,$!#/ !=4+!G&4+@
,%*,#!60!,#?%&(+.!("!'("$!4!$%1(*)$%&(,!-#1%!4+-!
/4,(+.! "$%! %+"&4+,%! *(-%! '("$! ,#821+*! *#! 4*! "#!
*2..%*"!4!,84**(,48!"%1)8%!;(88F!B<F!L$%!)&#>%,"!'4*!
DEDQGRQHGKDOIZD\ZKHQLQWKHSURMHFWV
)4"&#+! =(.(*1#+-#! N484"%*"4! '4*! #?%&"$&#'+3!
DQG WKH GRPH ZDV QHYHU LPSOHPHQWHG LOO
L$4"!*41%!0%4&3!4,&#**!"$%!A-&(4"(,3!"$%!1#*Y2%!
#/ ! G4"($! =28"4+! N%$1%-! (+! O&(*$"(+4! '4*! ,#+@
*"&2,"%-3!'("$!("*!-#1%-!,26(,!*"&2,"2&%!/&#+"%-!
60! 4! ,#821+4&! )#&"(,#! ;(88F! `<F! S"*! "0)#8#.0! #/ !
,#2&*%3!'$(8%!64*(,4880!,#(+,(-(+.!'("$!"$%!L%1@
SLR0DODWHVWLDQRSURMHFWIROORZHGWKH2WWRPDQ
*(+.8%!-#1%!1#*Y2%!"&4-("(#+!%*"468(*$%-!(+!"$%!
!
E`"$ ,%+"2&0F![$%&%4*!"$%!2+,#1)8%"%-!*"&2,"2&%!
(+!Q(1(+(!(*!4!*"4+-4&-!&%/%&%+,%!(+!488!*2&?%0*!#/ !
Q%+4(**4+,%!4&,$("%,"2&%3!4+-!%?%+!#/ !P2&#)%4+!
#&! [%*"%&+! 4&,$("%,"2&%! (+! .%+%&483! "$%! 62(8-(+.!
*"(88!*"4+-(+.!(+!"$%!,%+"&%!#/ !"$%!U#*#?4&!,4)("48!
,("0! &%14(+*! 2++#"(,%-! 60! $(*"#&(#.&4)$%&*! #/ !
(XURSHDQDQG2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHDOLNH
$WKLUGWRSLFVXJJHVWLQJDQHFKRRI 2WWRPDQ
P2&#)%4+!4&,$("%,"2&%!(+!,#2+"&(%*!/2&"$%&!'%*"!
#&! +#&"$! 1(.$"! 6%! "$%! %1)$4*(*! #+! "$%! *4,&%-!
,OO'UDZLQJRI2W
WRPDQKDPDPQRWIDU
IURP%XGDE\)LVFKHU
YRQ(UODFK
6##H!4+-!*#1%'$4"!(,#+#,84*"(,!?(%'!#/ !*4,&%-!
VSDFHLQUHIRUPPRYHPHQWVVXFKDV"$!,%+"2&0!
/XWKHUDQ &KULVWLDQLW\ &RXOG WKHUH QDOO\ KDYH
6%%+! 4! ,#++%,"(#+! 6%"'%%+! 4&,$("%,"2&48! &%)&%@
*%+"4"(#+*! (+! )4(+"%-! ,$2&,$! (+"%&(#&*! 4+-! "$%!
(11%+*%! )#)284&("0! #/ ! 12&48*! *$#'(+.! 1#+2@
PHQWVDQGODQGVFDSHVLQODWH2WWRPDQPRVTXHV
VXFKDVWKHRQHVDW7HWRYRRU*MDNRYD"
N#&%!.%+%&48803!("!*%%1*!"$4"!S*841(,!,28"2&%J*!
(1)4,"!#+!P2&#)%!'4*!1#&%!&%4-(80!.&4+"%-!"$%!
1#&%! -(*"4+"! (+! "(1%! #&! *)4,%! "$%! ,4*%3! 4*! '("$!
N##&(*$! A+-482*(4! #&! '("$! "$%! &%*28"*! #/ ! "&4-%!
48#+.!"$%!=(8H!Q#4-F!S/ !&%8(.(#+!(*!'$4"!*2))#*@
HGO\MXVWLHVWKHFOHDUGLVWLQFWLRQLQWRWKHVHWZR
,4"%.#&(%*! Z! S*841(,! 4+-! P2&#)%4+\[%*"%&+! Z!
#+%!*$#28-!)#(+"!#2"!"$4"!"$%!"$&%%!1#+#"$%(*"(,!
&%8(.(#+*!488!#&(.(+4"%-!(+!"$%!N(--8%!P4*"F!G!
"$%&%!"$%0!*)&%4-3!(+"%&!48(43!"#!"$%!N%-("%&&4+%4+3!
(+!'$(,$!"$%(&!$%.%1#+0!;4+-!"$2*!"$%(&!4&"<!+#"!
UDUHO\RYHUODSSHG<HWRQHFDPHWREHLGHQWLHG
DV :HVWHUQ DQG DQRWKHU DV (DVWHUQ ZLWK D
*2))#*%-80!2+6&(-.%468%!.4)!6%"'%%+!"$%1F
L$%!-(*,#2&*%!#+!P2&#)%4+!4&,$("%,"2&%J*!$(*@
"#&0!$4*!("*!&##"*!(+!"$%!Ea"$!,%+"2&0!4+-!&%14(+*!
,8#*%80! 4""4,$%-! "#! "$%! ,#+,%)"! #/ ! 1#-%&+("0F!
L$(*!-#%*!+#"!1%4+!"$4"!"$%!"&4>%,"#&0!"$.$!
"$%! ,%+"2&(%*! /! 4+,(%+"! "#! ,#+"%1)#&4&0! (*!
,#+*(-%&%-!4!2+(/#&1!8(+%!#/ !)&#.&%**F![$(8%!(+!
-(//%&%+"! )%&(#-*! ,#11%+"4"#&*! $4?%! /4?#2&%-!
"$%! &%8%?4+,%! #/ ! ?4&(#2*! *"08%*! 4+-\#&! )%&(#-*!
Z!*#1%"(1%*!"$%!V#"$(,3!*#1%"(1%*!"$%!Q%+4(*@
,OO'UDZLQJRI
2WWRPDQPRVTXHLQ
3HVWE\)LVFKHUYRQ
(UODFK
)OHWFKHU %DQLVWHU C' ,+&$.%R' .B ' (%1,+$"1$2%"' .#' $,"' 1.0*(%($+4"' 0"$,.)F!
/RQGRQ$WKORQH3UHVV
*4+,%3!4+-!*#1%"(1%*!"$%!:4&#Y2%!Z!4!,#11#+!
P2&#)%4+! "&4-("(#+! (*! +#&14880! ,#+*"&2,"%-!
4*! 4! *%Y2%+,%! #/ ! "$%*%! )%&(#-*! 4+-\#&! *"08%*F!
728"2&%*! +#"! $4?(+.! )4&"(,()4"%-! (+! "$(*! %?#82@
"(#+4&0! )&#,%**3! %?%+! '$%+! "$%(&! 4&,$("%,"2&48!
#2")2"! '4*! 4-1(&%-3! '%&%! 2+-%&*"##-! 4*! 6%(+.!
"(1%8%**!#&!"4H(+.!,(&,284&!)4"$*F!S+!=(&!:4+(*"%&!
G8%",$%&J*!,84**(,!*2&?%0!#/ !4&,$("%,"2&48!$(*"#&03!
UVWSXEOLVKHGLQDQGVWLOOLQSULQWDFHQWXU\
84"%&<3!4!-%*(.+4"(#+!2*%-!/#&!4&,$("%,"2&%!#2"*(-%!
RI (XURSH ZDV WKDW RI QRQKLVWRULFDO VW\OHV!
[$(8%! "$(*! )$&4*%! (*! ,%&"4(+80! #2"-4"%-3! 60! (1@
SOLFDWLRQWKHQRQKLVWRULFDOODEHOVWLOOVHHPVWR
>2*"(/0!"$%!"&%4"1%+"!#/ !+#+@P2&#)%4+!$(*"#&(,48!
4&,$("%,"2&%! 4*! #2"*(-%! 4! )4&4-(.1! #/ ! )&#.&%**F!
1HHGOHVV WR VD\ ZKDW ZH PD\ FDOO 2WWRPDQ
(XURSHDQ DUFKLWHFWXUH ZDV RXWVLGH WKH VFRSH
#/ !"$(*!,#+,%)"F!S/ !4+0!,#1)4&(*#+*!-#!4))%4&3!
2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHVHHQDVRSSRVHGWR(X@
URSHDQSURJUHVVUHSUHVHQWHGWKHSURFHVVQRWRI
KLVWRU\EXWRI GHFOLQH
A+#"$%&!%4&80!4,,#2+"!#/ !4&,$("%,"2&48!$(*"#&0!
VKRXOG EH UHPHPEHUHG LQ WKLV FRQWH[W -RKDQQ
:%&+$4&-! G(*,$%&! ?#+! P&84,$! "##H! 4! .8#648! 4)@
),$! "#! 4&,$("%,"2&%! 4+-! ("*! $(*"#&0! (+! $(*!
9#$P2%BB '"+#"%',+&$.%+&1,"#'C%1,+$"1$2%3!4!,#11%+"%-!
,#88%,"(#+!#/ !)&(+"*!(**2%-!(+!EbBEF!PR41)8%*!/#&!
ZKDW KH FDOOHG DQ KLVWRULFDO DUFKLWHFWXUH LQ@
,82-%-!62(8-(+.*!/!14+0!)%&(#-*!4+-!&%.(#+*3!
EXWWKH2WWRPDQH[DPSOHVDUHYHU\SURPLQHQW
:%*(-%*!"$%!*28"4+(,!1#*Y2%*!#/ !S*"4+6283!*%%+!"#!
FXOPLQDWHLQWKDWRI 6XOWDQ$KPHG,ZHDOVRQG
UHSUHVHQWDWLRQV RI DQ 2WWRPDQ PRQXPHQW LQ
:2&*4!4+-!"'#!(+!92+.4&0K!4!,(0(0!+%4&!"$%!,%+@
"&%!#/ !:2-4!;(88F!C<!4+-!4!*(+.8%@-#1%-!1#*Y2%!
LQ 3HVW LOO $ JOREDOL]LQJ SHUVSHFWLYH RQ DU@
,$("%,"2&%!4+-!"$%!,#++%,"(#+*!6%"'%%+!-(//%&%+"!
)4&"*!#/ !"$%!'#&8-!,4+!6%!*4(-!"#!/#&1!4!"$%1%!
(+!84"%!:4&#Y2%!,28"2&%!1#&%!.%+%&48803!$#'%?%&!
*$#&"@8(?%-F! N2,$! 84"%&3! :4&#Y2%! 4&,$("%,"2&%J*!
G\QDPLVPIRXQGLWVSODFHLQGHQLQJWKHWUDMHF@
"#&0!#/ !P2&#)%4+!1#-%&+("03!62"!64*%-!#+80!#+!
VWULFWO\IRUPDODQDO\VHV6LJQLFDQWO\)LVFKHUYRQ
P&84,$3! '$#! (*! .%+%&4880! &%,#.+(5%-! 4*! 4! $(.$80!
3HYVQHUV 3K' WKHVLV ZULWWHQ LQ WKH V KDG EHHQ RQ *HUPDQ
:4&#Y2%!4&,$("%,"2&%F
35
Grigor Boykov
36
T,"'(2$,.%')+&12&&"&'"(%7R'-$$.0(#'2%:(#')"4"7.*0"#$'&$%($"5+"&'$,%.25,'(%1,+$"1$2%(7'B.2#)($+.#&M'P+$,'&*"1+(7'
%"5(%)'$.'P,($'(**"(%&'$.':"'('0.)"7'1.00.#'$.'7($"'0")+"4(7'C#($.7+('(#)'$,"'6(78(#&M'(#)'('#20:"%'.B 'Z-$/
$.0(#+X")['1+$+"&N'T,+&'+&')"0.#&$%($")':R'('1.0*(%($+4"'&$2)R'.B '2%:(#'$%(#&B.%0($+.#'+#'$,%""'"(%7R'-$$.0(#'
$.P#&'p'9)+%#"M'a7.4)+4M'(#)'U8.*V"'p'P+$,'($$"#$+.#'*(+)'$.'$,"'7.1($+.#'(#)'B2#1$+.#&'.B '1.002#(7'0.&]2"&'
YHUVXVWKH7VKDSHGKRVSLFHVDW\SHVSHFLFWRWKH$,'(#)'Fd$,'1"#$2%+"&'(#)'B.2#)'+#'(77'$,%""'1+$+"&N'b.%'U8.*V"^&'
1(&"',"'(%52"&'$,($'P"',(4"':"B.%"'2&'(#'"@(0*7"'.B '('Z)R#(&$R['.B 'B%.#$+"%'5"#$%R'(**7R+#5'$,"'&(0"'*%+#1+*7"&'(&'
VXOWDQLFSDWURQVLQWKHLUUHVSHFWLYHVSKHUHRI LQXHQFH
$XWRUGLVNXWXMHRUDQLMLPRVPDQVNLPVWUDWHJLMDPDXUEDQRJUD]YRMDNUR]DUKLWHNWRQVNH]DGXELQHVDSRVHE/
QLPRVYUWRPQDRQRWRNDVQLMHSRVWDMH]DMHGQLNLPRGHONDVQRMVUHGQMRYMHNRYQRM$QDGROLMLL%DONDQXLPQRJLP
.&0(#+X+%(#+0'5%().4+0(N'-4.'V"'*%")&$(47V"#.'8.0*(%($+4#.0'&$2)+V.0'2%:(#+,'$%(#&B.%0(1+V('#('*%+0V"%2'$%+'
UDQDRVPDQVNDJUDGD(GLUQH3ORYGLYL6NRSOMHVDSDQMRPQDORNDFLMHIXQNFLMDPMHVQLKGDPLMDQDVXSURW
NRQDLWLPD7REOLNDWLSVSHFLDQ]DLYLMHNLSURQDHQXVYDWULJUDGD8VOXDMX6NRSOMDRQWYUGLGD
LPDPRSUHGVRERPSULPMHUGLQDVWLMHSRJUDQLQLKSOHPVWDYDNRMLSULPMHQMXMXLVWLSULQFLSNDRLQMLKRYLVXOWDQVNL
*.8%.4+$"7V+'2'#V+,.4.V'2$+1(V#.V'&B"%+N
E!
`!
S6(-F3!))F!`D@EF
QDOFN+DOLO3HULRGVLQ2WWRPDQKLVWRU\VWDWHVRFLHW\HFRQRP\
(+K!-$$.0(#'1+4+7+X($+.#N(GV+DOLOQDOFNDQG*QVHO5HQGD$QNDUD
0LQLVWU\ RI &XOWXUH SS .DIDGDU &HPDO 6"$P""#' $P.'
P.%7)&3' $,"' 1.#&$%21$+.#' .B ' $,"' -$$.0(#' &$($"N' :%&H%8%0K! T+(?%&*("0! #/ !
&DOLIRUQLD3UHVV
QDOFN KDV SURGXFHG D QXPEHU RI VWXGLHV RQ WKH ORQJ ODVWLQJ
68#,H4-%!4+-!*26*%Y2%+"!,#+Y2%*"!#/ !"$%!)&(+,()48!:("$0+(4+!,("(%*3!
1LFDHDDQG3URXVD+LVODWHVWLGHDVDUHSUHVHQWHGLQQDOFN+DOLO
7KHVWUXJJOHEHWZHHQ2VPDQ*D]LDQGWKH%\]DQWLQHVIRU1LFDHD
(+K!]QLNWKURXJKRXWKLVWRU\(GV,O$NED\JLOHWDO,VWDQEXO7UNL\H
%DQNDVSSLGHP2VPDQOVXOWDQ2UKDQ
$YUXSDGD\HUOHPHLQ6"77"$"#9RO/;;,,,1R
SS 6HH DOVR WKH ZRUNV RI /RZU\ +HDWK : 2WWRPDQ
S5+(H! ;M(,4%4<K! "$.$! "$%! %0%*! #/ ! "&4?%8%&*! 4+-! 4*! &%,#&-%-! (+!
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH GRFXPHQWV LQ ]QLN WKURXJKRXW KLVWRU\3'
SS DQG -$$.0(#' 62%&(' +#' $%(4"7' (11.2#$&F! :8##1(+."#+3!
,QGLDQD8QLYHUVLW\RI ,QGLDQD2WWRPDQ 0RGHUQ7XUNLVK6WXGLHV
3XEOLFDWLRQV
!"#$,&'-&.$/'0+1/&'$#/ !A+4"#8(4!(+!"$%!1(-@
"$!,%+"2&0!2+-%&1(+%-!"$%!,%+"&48(5%-!42"$#&@
("0! #/ ! "$%! =%8>2H! *28"4+*3! &%)84,(+.! ("! '("$! "$4"!
#/ !"$%!%1%&.(+.!8#,48!4&(*"#,&4"(,!%8("%*3!'$#!4,@
,21284"%-!(+!"$%(&!$4+-*!84&.%!84+-%-!)&#)%&"(%*!
4+-!4,"%-!"#!4!.&%4"!%R"%+"!4*!(+-%)%+-%+"!&28@
%&*F! =,$#84&*! 8(H%! 9#'4&-! 7&4+%! #&! P"$%8! =4&4!
[#8)%&!$4?%!4&.2%-!"$4"!"$%!-&414"(,!,$4+.%*!
LQSROLWLFDOSRZHURI WKHPLG"$!4+-!%4&80!E`"$@
FHQWXU\ $QDWROLD UHVXOWHG LQ D VLJQLFDQW VKLIW
(+! )4"&#+4.%! )4""%&+*3! (+! '$(,$! )#'%&/28! 8#,48!
"0+%*!&%)84,%-!"$%!*28"4+*!4*!)&(+,()48!*)#+*#&*!
#/ ! 4&,$("%,"2&%FE! G2&"$%&1#&%3! "$%! "0)%*! #/ !
(+*"("2"(#+*!*2))#&"%-!,$4+.%-K!"$%!8#,48!8#&-*3!
UDWKHU WKDQ EXLOGLQJ IRUWLFDWLRQV PRVTXHV
#&! ,4&4?4+*%&4(*3! /#,2*%-! "$%(&! )4"&#+4.%! #+!
0")%"&"*3! "#16*3! 4+-! Z! 1#*"! +#"4680! Z! -%&?(*$!
8#-.%*FB!L$%0!*#2.$"!"#!"&4+*/#&1!"$%!$(%&4&,$0!
#/ !,("0!*)4,%!4+-!"#!1#-(/0!"$%!%R(*"(+.!*)4"(48!
#&-%&!"$.$!4!,#+*,(#2*!4""%1)"!"#!*$(/"!"$%!
2&64+! ,#&%! 4'40! /! "$%! =%8>2H! ,%+"&%F! L$%!
(+*"&21%+"! #/ ! "$(*! 2&64+! "&4+*/#&14"(#+! '4*!
"$%!)4"&#+4.%!#/ !-%&?(*$!8#-.%*!62(8"!+%4&!,("0!
.4"%*!#&!14&H%"!4&%4*F!L$%0!14+(/%*"%-!"$%!48@
8(4+,%! 6%"'%%+! "$%! 8#,48! &28%&*! 4+-! "$%! ("(+%&@
4+"! A+4"#8(4+! -%&?(*$%*3! '$#! $4-! %+#&1#2*!
37
38
a!
0DMRUWKFHQWXU\2WWRPDQPRQXPHQWVLGHQWLHGRQDWK
FHQWXU\SODQRI(GLUQH
14&,$%*3!%1)8#0%-!"$%!*41%!)4""%&+!'$%+!"$%0!
+%%-%-! "#! "&4+*/#&1! "$%! ,#+Y2%&%-! ,("(%*! #/ !
"$%(&!#'+!-#14(+*!#&!%*"468(*$%-!+%'!"#'+*FEB!
,Q WKLV VKRUW FRQIHUHQFH SDSHU , ZLOO EULH\
%R41(+%! "$%! 2&64+! "&4+*/#&14"(#+! #/ ! "$&%%!
14>#&!:054+"(+%!,%+"&%*!(+!"$%!:48H4+*3!8##H(+.!
/#&! *(1(84&("(%*! (+! "$%(&! -%?%8#)1%+"K! E<! P-(&+%3!
WKHVHFRQG2WWRPDQFDSLWDO3ORYGLYWKHPH@
"&#)#8(*!#/ !T))%&!L$&4,%!Z!8(H%!P-(&+%!*("24"%-!
#+! "$%! 1%-(%?48! :48H4+! $(.$'40! H+#'+! 4*! "$%!
m+(';+7+$(%+&DQG6NRSMHWKHSULQFLSDOFLW\RI
'%*"%&+! N4,%-#+(43! -#1(+4"%-! 60! "$%! 1(.$"0!
G\QDVW\RI WKHVKDNRXOODU
EB! L$%! -0+4*"0! #/ ! V45(! P?&%+#*! :%0! 4+-! ("*! -%,(*(?%! %! (+! "$%!
-%?%8#)1%+"! #/ ! *%?%&48! (1)#&"4+"! ,("(%*! #+! "$%! m+(' 95#($+(! '4*!
&%,%+"80! *"2-(%-! (+! 4! *%&(%*! #/ ! )268(,4"(#+*! 60! X#'&03! 9%4"$! [F!
T,"' &,(*+#5' .B ' $,"' -$$.0(#' 6(78(#&M' FHdK/FddK3' $,"' 1.#]2"&$M' &"$$7"0"#$'
e' +#B%(&$%21$2%(7' )"4"7.*0"#$' .B ' O.%$,"%#' f%""1" ,VWDQEXO %DKoHHKLU
8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV /RZU\ +HDWK : DQG VPDLO (UQVDO
T,"' 94%"#.&' )R#(&$R' .B ' r"#+1"' m(%)(%3' #.$"&' e' ).120"#$&F! S*"4+628K!
%DKoHHKLU8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
4/"%&3!,#11%&,(48!62(8-(+.*!*2,$!4*!:")"&$"#*3!(%(&/
$(*3!#&!,(#*!*2&+-%-!"$%!1#*Y2%3!4+-!(+!"$%!
*#@/#&1%-!,#11%&,(48!4&%4!*%?%&48!*1488%&!*(+.8%!
-#1%-!,#112+48!1#*Y2%*!4))%4&%-!"##F!A*!48@
&%4-0!)#(+"%-!#2"3!-%)%+-(+.!#+!"$%!(1)#&"4+,%!
4+-!14.+("2-%!#/ !"$%!,("03!#+%!#&!1#&%!L@*$4)%-!
+0(%"$kX(4+R"!,#1)8%R%*!'%&%!)84,%-!(+!*262&6*!4"!
"$%*%!,("(%*J!%+"&4+,%*F!A!?%&0!*(1(84&!)4""%&+!#/ !
2&64+!"&4+*/#&14"(#+3!"$%!)&#-2,"!#/ !"$%!/&#+@
"(%&! 0+7+"2 RI 2UKDQV VWDWH ZDV WUDQVIHUUHG WR
WKH%DONDQVIROORZLQJWKH2WWRPDQDGYDQFHLQWR
"$%! &%.(#+F! G2&"$%&1#&%3! "$%! *%1(@(+-%)%+-%+"!
-0+4*"(%*! #/ ! :48H4+! &4(-%&! ,#114+-%&*! ;DNQF
21:"R+VZKRPDGHWKHLUOLYLQJRQWKH2WWRPDQ
39
40
4+-!4!+216%&!#/ !*%&?(,%!62(8-(+.*3!'$(,$!(+!/4,"!
PXVWKDYHEHHQWKHUVW2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVRXW@
*(-%!"$%!'488*!#/ !"$%!#8-!:054+"(+%!A-&(4+#)8%F!
T+/#&"2+4"%80!+%("$%&!"$%!,#+?%&"%-!A04!=#/043!
SKRWRJUDSKHGLQWKH"$!,%+"2&03E`!+#&!N2&4-J*!
SDODFHSXOOHGGRZQLQWKH"$!,%+"2&0!(+!#&-%&!
WRRSHQURRPIRUWKHPDJQLFHQW6HOLPL\HDUH
%R"4+"! "#-40FEC! L$%! %R)4+*(#+! #/ ! "$%! ,("0! ,#+@
"(+2%-! 2+-%&! N2&4-J*! *2,,%**#&! :40%5(-! S! '$#3!
LQD%XUVDPDQQHUSODFHGD7VKDSHG+0(%"$k
X(4+R"! 4! ,#+*(-%&468%! -(*"4+,%! /! "$%! ,("0J*!
ZDOOV VWUHWFKLQJ WKH 2WWRPDQ SUHVHQFH EH\RQG
,("0J*!+4"2&48!6#&-%&!Z!"$%!L2+,4!Q(?%&F!=28"4+!
%D\H]LGV (GLUQH HGLFH LOO FHUWDLQO\ ODFNHG
"$%!.&4+-%2&!#/ !$(*!:2&*4!,#1)8%R3!62(8"!4!/%'!
0%4&*! %4&8(%&3! 62"! $%! *%"! 4+! (1)#&"4+"! "&%+-F! S+!
WKHIROORZLQJWR\HDUVIRXUPRUH7VKDSHG
+0(%"$kX(4+R"'/,%+"&%-! ,#1)8%R%*! ,#11(**(#+%-!
60! V45(! N($483Eb! "$%! :"R7"%:"R+' <XVXI 3DDEa!
N%5(-!:%03!4+-!=28"4+!N2&4-!SSBD!4))%4&%-!4"!
WKH RXWVNLUWV RI (GLUQH LOOV 7KH JURZLQJ
(1)#&"4+,%!#/ !"$%!,("0!4))%48%-!/#&!"$%!,#+*"&2,@
"(#+!#/ !4+!(1)%&(48!.&%4"!1#*Y2%3!'$(,$!'4*!62(8"!
E\%D\H]LGVVRQVLQWKHUVWGHFDGHRI WKH"$!
,%+"2&0!4+-!"$2*!(1("4"(+.!:2&*4J*!-%?%8#)1%+"!
"$%!,#11%&,(48!,#&%!#/ !P-(&+%!*$(/"%-!"#!4!+%'!
8#,4"(#+! #2"*(-%! "$%! '488%-! ,("0FBE! L$%! 128"(@
-#1%-!P*H(!741(!*##+!6%,41%!"##!*1488!/#&!"$%!
&4)(-80!%R)4+-(+.!)#)284"(#+!#/ !"$%!,%+"&48!4&%4F!
L'#!-%,4-%*!84"%&!N2&4-!SS!,#11(**(#+%-!4!+%'!
(1)%&(48!1#*Y2%!(+!"$%!,%+"&48!)4&"!#/ !"#'+3!"$%!
ho HUHIHOL PRVTXH ZKLFK QRW RQO\ HOHYDWHG
P-(&+%J*! 14.+("2-%3! 62"! 48*#! &%?#82"(#+(5%-! "$%!
-%*(.+!4+-!,#+*"&2,"(#+!"%,$+(Y2%*!#/ !"$%!.&%4"!
;272PRVTXHVRI WKH2WWRPDQVBB
(GLUQHV 2WWRPDQL]DWLRQ JUHDWO\ UHPLQGV
#+%!#/ !"$%!"&4+*/#&14"(#+!#/ !:2&*4F!A!+%'!2&@
64+! ,#&%! %1%&.%-! 4+-! 4+! (1)%&(48! 1#*Y2%!
'$(8%! 4! +216%&! #/ ! L@*$4)%-! +0(%"$kX(4+R"*!
BE! A0?%&-(F! dHOHEL YH ,, VXOWDQ 0XUDG GHYUL SS .XUDQ T,"'
0.&]2"3!))F!EC`@ECaF
BB! A0?%&-(F!dHOHELYH,,VXOWDQ0XUDGGHYULSS*RRGZLQ-$$.0(#'
(%1,+$"1$2%"MSS
41
42
)4"&#+(5%-!60!"$%!&28%&*!#&!"$%(&!-(.+("4&(%*!*2&@
+-%-!"$%!,("0F!L$%!"&4+*/%&!#/ !"$%!*016#8*!#/ !
2WWRPDQOHJLWLPDF\RQWR%DONDQVRLODORQJZLWK
WKHFRPSRQHQWVRI WKHERUGHUVRFLHW\UHPRG@
%88%-!P-(&+%!(+!*2,$!4!'40!"$4"!("!"&280!-%*%&?%-!
WKHODEHOVHUKDWWDNLSD\WDKWRUFDSLWDODWWKH
IURQWLHUXVHGDVDWLWOHRI DYROXPHGHGLFDWHGWR
,("0J*!$(*"#&0F!L$%!:48H4+!8#&-*!#/ !"$%!14&,$%*3!
'$#!(+!1#*"!,4*%*!'%&%!"$%!-&(?(+.!/#&,%!6%$(+-!
WKH 2WWRPDQ DGYDQFH LQ (XURSH DWWUDFWHG WKH
FHQWULIXJDO IRUFHV LQ WKH 2WWRPDQ VWDWH ZKLFK
"##H! 4! *8#'3! 62"! )%&*(*"%+"! -(&%,"(#+! "#'4&-*!
FHQWUDOL]DWLRQDQGJUDGXDOVXQQLFDWLRQ0DUJLQ@
DOL]HGJURXSVVXFKDVWKHLWLQHUDQWKHWHURGR[
-%&?(*$%*!*#2.$"!488(4+,%!'("$3!4+-!)&#"%,"(#+!#/3!
"$%! )#'%&/28! &4(-%&! ,#114+-%&*3! '$#! (+! 14+0!
(+*"4+,%*!,#11(**(#+%-!/#&!"$%1!L@*$4)%-!+0(/
OLDQG.R](GLUQHVHUKDWWDNLSD\WDKW
%"$kX(4+R"*F!X##H(+.!/#&!%R41)8%*!#+%!,#28-!)#(+"!
WR WKH EXLOGLQJV RI WKH 0LKDORXOODU LQ (GLUQH
DQGKWLPDQ(YUHQRV%H\V+0(%"$*!48#+.!"$%!m+('
95#($+(VKDN%H\VDQGKLVVRQVDVHGLFHVLQ
=H#)>%3!#&!4!+216%&!#/ !?4+(*$%-!62(8-(+.*!,#1@
1(**(#+%-!60!#"$%&!/41#2*!/41(8(%*F!=28"4+*3!#+!
"$%! #"$%&! $4+-3! #//%&%-! "$%(&! )4"&#+(5%-! ,#1@
)8%R%*! "#! -%&?(*$! #&-%&*! #/ ! "$%(&! ,$#(,%F! L$%!
N2&4-(0%!(+!P-(&+%3!'$(,$!*%&?%-!/#&!14+0!0%4&*!
4*!4!0"47"4+,(#"3!)&#?(-%*!4+!%R,%88%+"!%R41)8%!(+!
"$(*!&%*)%,"F
0DMRUWKFHQWXU\2WWRPDQPRQXPHQWVLGHQWLHGRQDSODQ
RI3ORYGLYUHGUDZQE\WKHDXWKRUDIWHU0DUJDULWD+DUERYD
L$%!)#*"@,#+Y2%*"!0%4&*!#/ !#2&!*%,#+-!,4*%3!
"$%! ,("0! #/ ! O$(8()#)#8(*! ;G(8(6%<3! 4&%! %?%+! 1#&%!
REVFXUHWKDQ(GLUQHVUVWGHFDGHVLQ2WWRPDQ
$4+-*FB` 7KH HDUOLHVW VWDQGLQJ 2WWRPDQ PRQX@
1%+"!"$%&%!(*!"$%!128"(@-#1%-!.&%4"!1#*Y2%!62(8"!
E\0XUDG,,LQWKHPLGVLOOBC!'$(,$!'4*!
DOPRVW\HDUVDIWHUWKHFLW\VXUUHQGHUHGWR/DOD
DKLQ3DD!S"!(*!$4&-!"#!6%8(%?%!"$4"!/#&!1#&%!
WKDQKDOI DFHQWXU\WKH2WWRPDQVGLGQRWOHDYH
"$%(&!(1)&(+"!#+!4+!(1)#&"4+"!:054+"(+%!,("0!8(H%!
O8#?-(?3!'$(,$!'4*!"$%!Q21%8(4+!:"R7"%:"R+J*!)84,%!
#/ !&%*(-%+,%!"##F!S!'#28-!8(H%!"#!)2"!/#&'4&-!4!
$0)#"$%*(*!4*!*)%,284"(?%!4*!)842*(68%F!7%&"4(+803!
WKH0XUDGL\HZDVQRWWKHHDUOLHVW2WWRPDQEXLOG@
(+.!(+!"$%!,("0F!7#+*"4+"(+%!"$%!O$(8#*#)$%&3!48*#!
NQRZQDV.RVWHQHNLZKLOHGHVFULELQJWKHVWUXJ@
.8%!6%"'%%+!:40%5(-J*!"'#!*#+*3!"$%!)&(+,%*!=o8@
%014+!4+-!N2*4!(+!"$%!%4&80!E`DD*3!1%+"(#+*!4!
,(0(0!(+!G(8(6%!2*%-!60!=o8%014+!/#&!$(*!/%4*"*FBb!
T+-#26"%-80! "$%! 64"$! -(-! +#"! *"4+-! 48#+%3! 62"!
12*"!$4?%!6%%+!4!)4&"!#/ !4!,#1)8%RF!U%%)(+.!(+!
1(+-!"$%!"&4-("(#+!4,,#&-(+.!"#!'$(,$!"$%!,#+@
TXHURUV2UKDQDQG0XUDGFRQYHUWHGDFKXUFK
'("$(+! "$%! *"&#+.$#8-! (+"#! 4! 1#*Y2%! '$(8%! *(@
128"4+%#2*80! *"4&"(+.! ,#+*"&2,"(#+! #2"*(-%! "$%!
'488*3!#+%!,#28-!4**21%!"$4"!"$%!,4*%!#/ !O8#?-(?!
'4*!+#"!12,$!-(//%&%+"F!L$%&%!(*!4!.##-!,$4+,%!
B` 1RWHVRQ3ORYGLYVSRVWFRQTXHVWSHULRGLQ.LHO0DFKLHO8UEDQ
-%?%8#)1%+"!(+!:28.4&(4!(+!"$%!L2&H(*$!)%&(#-K!"$%!)84,%!#/ !L2&H(*$!
DUFKLWHFWXUHLQWKHSURFHVVLQA#$"%#($+.#(7'>.2%#(7'.B 'T2%8+&,'U$2)+"&M'
9RO,91RSSSOXVSODWHVVHHSS%R\NRY
*ULJRU(WQRUHOLJLR]QLDWREOLNQDRVPDQVNLDJUDG)LOLEHNUD\DQD
;9QDFKDORWRQD;9,YHNLQ6(78(#&8+'+)"#$+1,#.&$+3!_#8F!SSSF!P-*F!
(YJHQL5DGXVKHYDQG6WHIND)HWYDGMLHYD6RD)RQGDWVLD2WYRUHQR
REVKWHVWYRSS
BC! S!'(88!-%48!'("$!"$%!-4"(+.!#/ !"$%!1#*Y2%!(+!4!/2"2&%!*"2-0F
! L$%! )&#,%%-(+.*! #/ ! "$%! ,#+/%&%+,%! -%?#"%-! "#! N2&4-(0%! 1#*Y2%!
(+! O8#?-(?3! $%8-! (+! BDDa! 4/"%&! "$%! &%*"#&4"(#+! #/ ! "$%! 1#*Y2%! '4*!
,#1)8%"%-3! '%&%! &%,%+"80! )268(*$%-! (+! 4! 8(1("%-! +216%&! 60! "$%!
S*"4+628! N%"&#)#8("4+! N2+(,()48("0F! L$%! ?#821%! b+7+:"' Ea7.4)+4L'
&XPD&DPLL.RQIHUDQV%LGLULOHUL)LOLEH3ORYGLY&XPD0RVTXH&RQIHUHQFH
a(*"%&(GV&HODOHGGLQ.oNDQG10LQH<DUVWDQEXOVWDQEXO
%\NHKLU%HOHGL\HVLQGQHYHUDSSHDUHGRQWKHPDUNHW$\YHUGL
2VPDQOPLPkUvVLQLQLONGHYULSS5XGORI+LOH*HUWUXGDDQG
2WWR5XGORI*UDG3ORYGLYLQHJRYLWHVJUDGLLQAX4"&$+('#(':(75(%&8+('
(%,".7.5+1,"&8+' +#&$+$2$k6277"$+#' .B ' 6275(%+(#' C%1,".7.5+1(7' A#&$+$2$"M' _#8F!
9,,,SS
Bb 7KHGHVWUXFWLYHDFWLRQVRI WKH2WWRPDQSULQFHV0XVDDQG6OH\PDQ
'$#!*4,H%-!G(8(6%!*%?%&48!"(1%*3!4&%!6%*"!-%*,&(6%-!60!U#+*"4+"(+!
.RVWHQHNL/HEHQVEHVFKUHLEXQJGHV'HVSRWHQ6WHIDQ/D]DUHYLF!L&F!4+-!%-F!
0D[LPLOLDQ%UDXQ:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW]SS
U4*"&("*(*3!c(1("&(*3!T,"'&.#&'.B '6(R"X+)3'"0*+%"':2+7)+#5'(#)'%"*%"&"#$($+.#'
+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'1+4+7'P(%'.B 'FoKJ/FHN'/HLGHQ%ULOOSS
Plovdiv (Filibe)
43
44
Ba! L$%!6&(-.%!#?%&!N%&(p\N4&("*4!(*!6%8(%?%-!"#!$4?%!6%%+!62(8"!60!X484!
DKLQ3DDVKRUWO\DIWHUWKHFRQTXHVW$VKRUWQRWHLQ1HULKRZHYHU
14H%*!"$(*!4**21)"(#+!Y2%*"(#+468%F!A,,#&-(+.!"#!"$%!+4&&4"(?%3!(+!
ZKLOHRQKLVZD\WR.RVRYRZLWKWKHYDQJXDUGRI WKH2WWRPDQ
DUP\dDQGDUO$OL3DDZDVIRUFHGWRVSHQGWZRPRQWKVLQ)LOLEH
6%,42*%!"$%!N%&(p!$4-!&(*%+!4+-!,#28-!+#"!6%!,&#**%-F!7/F!N%$1%-!
1HUL.LWkE&LKDQQPD9RO,(GV)DLN5HLW8QDWDQG0HKPHG
.|\PHQ$QNDUD7UN7DULK.XUXPXS
! A0?%&-(F!dHOHELYH,,VXOWDQ0XUDGGHYULSS5XGORI*UDG
3ORYGLYSS
! L$%! 64"$! 8#,4880! H+#'+! 4*! 7DKWDNDOH WDKWONDOk KDPDP! '4*!
-%*"�%-! (+! "$%! %4&80! BD"$! ,%+"2&03! '$(,$! -%)&(?%*! 2*! #/ ! "$%!
SRVVLELOLW\ WR QG RXW LWV VSRQVRU DQG GDWH RI FRQVWUXFWLRQ $Q
4,,#2+"(+.!6##H!;02,(&":"')"B$"%+RI LKDEHGGLQ3DDV)LOLEHP(]B3!
GDWLQJ IURP $ + %2$ 77 I UHYHDOV
"$4"!"$%!,(0(0!'4*!*2))#&"%-!60!"$%!P(]B!4+-!(+!"$%!,#2&*%!#/ !"$%!
0%4&!*#1%!&%)4(&!'#&H!'4*!-#+%F!L$(*!/4,"!,#+?(+,(+.80!)#(+"*!"#!
LKDEHGGLQ 3DD DV WKH SHUVRQ ZKR EXLOW WKH ,(0(0F! =(+,%! ("! '4*!
4))4&%+"80!1%4+"!"#!*%&?%!"$%!,#+.&%.4"(#+!#/ !"$%!+%4&60!N2&4-(0%3!
("! (*! $(.$80! 8(H%80! "$4"! "$%! 64"$! '4*! 62(8"! *(128"4+%#2*80! '("$! "$%!
PRVTXHRUVKRUWO\DIWHUZDUGVWKXVLQWKHV
Skopje (skb)
7KHPRGLFDWLRQRI RXUODVWH[DPSOHRI %\]@
DQWLQR6ODYLF6NRSMHEHFRPLQJ2WWRPDQhVNE
&%*%168%*!%?%+!1#&%!.&%4"80!"$%!"&4+*/#&14"(#+!
RI %XUVD -XVW DV LQ %XUVD XQGHU 2UKDQ VRRQ
! V>#&.(%?3!c&4.(F!U8.*V"'.)'$2%&8.$.'.&4.V24(#V"').'8%(V.$'#('smAAA'4"8N'
6NRSMH,QVWLWXW]DQDFLRQDOQDLVWRULMDSS%RMDQL/XND
'XDQND .DNR WXUFLWH VR SUH]HOH 6NRSMH LQ l:.%#+8' #('
;2X"V'#('5%()'U8.*V"9RO,,,,,SS2Q3DD<LLW%H\
DQGKLVGHVFHQGHQWVVHH(OH]RYL*OLD6NRSVNL,VKDNRYLLL3DD
-LJLW%HJLQ*ODVQLN6NRSVNRJ1DXQRJ'UXWYD9RO,;SS
45
46
0DMRUWKFHQWXU\2WWRPDQPRQXPHQWVLGHQWLHGRQDQ
SODQRI6NRSMHZLWKLGHQWLFDWLRQVRITXDUWHUQDPHVE\
0HKPHWQED
47
48
! (YOL\DdHOHELVH\DKDWQkPHVL9NLWDS7RSNDS6DUD\.WSKDQHVL%DGDW
QXPDUDO \D]PDQQ WUDQVNULSVL\RQXGL]LQL! P-*F! U4$&414+3! =%0("!
$OL<FHO'DODQGEUDKLP6H]JLQ',VWDQEXO<DS.UHGL<D\QODU
S
"$%!)4"&#+3!4+-!1#*"!8(H%80!48*#!4!*#2)!H(",$%+!
4+-!4!64"$!(+!("*!,8#*%!?(,(+("0F
L$%!%R)8#-(+.!)#)284"(#+!.&#'"$!#/ !=H#)>%3!
MXVW DV LQ %XUVD YHU\ VRRQ WXUQHG 3DD <LLWV
L@*$4)%-! ,#1)8%R! (+"#! 4! /#,48! )#(+"! #/ ! 4! +%'!
,#11%&,(48!+%(.$6#2&$##-!'$(,$!.&%'!4+-!
("F+LVGHVFHQGHQWVVKDN%H\DQGVD%H\DGGHG
"$%(&!#'+!L@*$4)%-!+0(%"$kX(4+R"&!"$4"!)2*$%-!"$%!
,("0J*! -(1%+*(#+*! /2&"$%&! "#! "$%! +#&"$%4*"! ;(88*F!
%RJRMHYL/LGLMD/HVWXUEpVGH6NRSMHLQC$$+')"7'&"1.#).'1.#5%"&&.'
+#$"#(X+.#(7"' )+' (%$"' $2%1(N' 1DSROL ,VWLWXWR 8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOH
6HPLQDULR GL 7XUFRORJLD SS FLW S .XPEDUDF
:#.#0%?(p3! hVNSWH 2VPDQO PLPDUv S g]HU hVNSWH 7UN
0+0(%+&+SS(OH]RYLT2%&8+'&*.0"#+1+'2'U8.*7V2SS
! V>#&.(%?3!U8.*V"SS
!L$%!84&.%!(1)%&(48!,#112+48!1#*Y2%3!
'$(,$!=H#)>%!+%%-%-3!'4*!62(8"!60!N2&4-!SS!#+80!
4!/%'!0%4&*!4/"%&!$%!,#1)8%"%-!4!*(1(84&!*"&2,"2&%!
(+!G(8(6%F
L$%!,("0!#/ !=H#)>%3!-2&(+.!"$%!)%&(#-!(+!Y2%*@
"(#+3!'4*!%+"(&%80!-#1(+4"%-!60!"$%!1%16%&*!#/ !
#+%! -0+4*"0! #/ ! &4(-%&! ,#114+-%&*3! "$%! 1(.$"0!
VKDNRXOODU IDPLO\ EXW WKH FLW\V UHPRGHOOLQJ
4+-! /2&"$%&! -%?%8#)1%+"! (1("4"%-! 4"! 4! *1488%&!
*,48%!)&#,%**%*!(+!:2&*4!#&!P-(&+%3!'$(,$!'%&%!
SDWURQL]HGE\WKHUXOLQJ2WWRPDQG\QDVW\-XVWDV
WKHUVW2WWRPDQUXOHUVXVHGWKH7VKDSHG+0(/
%"$kX(4+R"*! 4*! H%0! 1%,$4+(*1*! "#! %+,#2&4.%! "$%!
.&#'"$!#/ !2&64+!*%""8%1%+"3!"$%!21:"R+*!'$#!4"@
"&4,"%-!"$%!)%&()$%&0!/#&,%*!#/ !"$%!"(1%!4-#)"%-!
WKHVW\OHRI WKHUVWVXOWDQVDQGHPSOR\HGLWLQ
"$%!,("(%*!2+-%&!"$%(&!,#+"F!N#&%#?%&3!"$%!)%&@
,%)"(#+!#/ !4!,("0!4*!4+!%+"("0!(+!'$(,$3!#+!"$%!#+%!
$4+-3!"$%&%!'4*!4!,%+"&48!4&%4!'("$!4!,#112+48!
1#*Y2%!4+-!*2&+-(+.!,#11%&,(48!62(8-(+.*3!
4+-!#+!"$%!#"$%&!4!,#1)8%R!#/ !4!128"(/2+,"(#+48!
L@*$4)%-! 62(8-(+.! (+! "$%! *262&6*3! ,#1)&(*%-!
"$%!?%&0!/#2+-4"(#+!#/ !4!14&,$%&!8#&-J*!,#+,%)"!
/#&! %*"468(*$(+.! +%'! "#'+*F! S+! "$(*! &%*)%,"! "$%!
1#-%&+! ,("0! #/ ! =4&4>%?#3! ,&%4"%-! /! *,&4",$!
E\VKDNROXVD%H\PLJKWEHDQRWKHUH[FHOOHQW
%R41)8%F!
49
Ibolya Gerelyes
50
T,"'(2$,.%'*%.4+)"&'('&2%4"R'.B '&1,.7(%&,+*'1.#1"%#+#5'-$$.0(#'0.#20"#$&'+#'*%"&"#$/)(R'<2#5(%RM'(#)'
+#B.%0($+.#'(:.2$'%"1"#$')+&1.4"%+"&'1.#1"%#+#5'$,+&',"%+$(5"N'94"#'$,.25,'+#'$,"',(7B/1"#$2%R'(B$"%'$,"'<(:&:2%5'
1.#]2"&$'.B '-$$.0(#'<2#5(%R'(B$"%'FQIH'(%.2#)'GKt'.B '$,"':2+7)+#5&'P"%"'8#.18")').P#M')($('1.#1"%#+#5'
$,"&"'0.#20"#$&'+&'*%"&"%4")'$.'2&'+#'$"@$2(7'&.2%1"&'(#)'0(*&'*%.)21")'+#'$,+&'*"%+.)'(#)':"B.%"N'-B '$,"'B.%0"%'
JdK/HKK'0.&]2"&'(#)'1%*,(-&'B.%'"@(0*7"M'$.)(R'.#7R'"+5,$'0.&]2"&'&2%4+4"'+#'P,.7"'.%'+#'*(%$N'<.P"4"%M'&+#1"'
($'$,"'$+0"'$,"'P(%/)"4(&$($")'%"5+.#'#"")")'(#R'&"%4+1"(:7"':2+7)+#5'P,($&."4"%M'0(#R'-$$.0(#':2+7)+#5&'P"%"'
*2$'$.'2&"N'9@(0*7"&'.B ';2&7+0',.2&"&'.B 'P.%&,+*'$,($'P"%"'7($"%'1.#4"%$")'+#$.'1,2%1,"&'+#172)"'$,"'T.R52#'
3DD&DPLLLQ%XGDWKH$OL3DD&DPLLLQ6]LJHWYiUWKH*D]L.DVLP3DD&DPLLLQ3pFVDQGWKHVRFDOOHG
u5.&$.#'$=%'1%*,(-M'&+0+7(%7R'+#'a=1&N'S+$,'%"5(%)'$.'$,"'&$2)R'.B '-$$.0(#':2+7)+#5&'.%'*(%$&'$,"%".B '2$+7+X")'
&2:&"]2"#$7RM'#"P'8#.P7")5"',(&':""#'5(+#")'$,%.25,'('#20:"%'.B '%"1"#$'"@1(4($+.#&N'b.%'"@(0*7"M'$,"'JKKopd'
(%1,(".7.5+1(7'(#)'(%$',+&$.%+1(7'%"&"(%1,'($'62)(^&'\2)(&'6($,'1.27)'17(%+BR'&.0"'+&&2"&'%"5(%)+#5'$,"'&$%21$2%"^&'
(%1,+$"1$2%(7',+&$.%RN'T,"':($,^&':%+18/:2+7$').0"'P(&'&,.P#'$.':"'-$$.0(#'P.%8M'1.#$%(%R'$.'$,"'"&$(:7+&,")'4+"PN'
,QLQYHVWLJDWLRQVZHUHFDUULHGRXWDWWKH&ViV]iU%DWKOLNHZLVHLQ%XGDGXULQJZKLFKLWVVSHFLFDOO\
2WWRPDQSDUWVZHUHLGHQWLHGDQGVWXGLHG7KH\HDUVDZWKHUHVXPSWLRQRI H[FDYDWLRQVLQ(V]WHUJRPDWDQ
-$$.0(#':($,'.#1"'1.0*7"$"7R':2%+")'2#)"%'"(%$,_'+$'P(&'B.2#)'$.':"'&2%*%+&+#57R'+#$(1$'2*'$.'$,"'4(27$+#5^&'&2**.%$&N
$XWRULFDSUXDSUHJOHGDNDGHPVNLKVWXGLMDRRVPDQVNLPVSRPHQLFLPDGDQDQMLFHX0DDUVNRMLLQIRUPDFLMHR
QHGDYQLPRWNULLPDXYH]LRYRJQDVOLMHD'RNSRODVWROMHDQDNRQ+DEVEXUNRJRVYDMDQMDRVPDQVNH0DDUVNH
SRVOLMHJRGLQHRNRJUDHYLQDMHELORSRUXHQRGRNVXSRGDFLXYH]LRYLKVSRPHQLNDVDXYDQLXSLVDQLP
L]YRULPDLPDSDPDL]RYRJLOLUDQLMHJSHULRGD2GUDQLMHGDPLMDLPHVGLGDGDQDVQDSULPMHUVDPR
RVDPGDPLMDMHVDXYDQRXSRWSXQRVWLLOLGLMHORP.DNRMHELODYHOLNDSRWUDQMD]DXVOXQLPREMHNWLPDXUHJLML
XQLWHQLPXUDWQLPUD]DUDQMLPDVDGDMHHYLGHQWQRGDVXVHPQRJLREMHNWLRVPDQVNHDUKLWHNWXUHSRQRYRSRHOL
NRULVWLWL3ULPMHULFUNYLNRMHVXUDQLMHIXQNFLRQLVDOHNDRPXVOLPDQVNHYMHUVNHERJRPROMHVXGDPLMD7RMJXQSDH
X%XGLPXXSQDFUNYDXQXWUDQMHJJUDGDX3HWL$OLSDLQDGDPLMDX6LJHWYDUXGDPLMD*D]L.DVLPSDH
X3HXKXLWDNR]YDQLPHVGLGQDJRVWRQWUJXWDNRHUX3HXKX3RUHGVWXGLMHRSRQRYQRMXSRWUHELRVPDQVNLK
JUDHYLQD LOL QMLKRYLK GLMHORYD QRYD VD]QDQMD R RYRP QDVOLMHX PRJX ELWL GRVWXSQD NUR] QHGDYQD DUKHRORND
LVWUDLYDQMD1DSULPMHULVWUDLYDQMDXSROMXDUKHRORJLMHLLVWRULMHXPMHWQRVWLREDYOMHQDLJRGLQHQD
V(4#.0'82*($+72k,(0(02'\2)(&'2'62)+02M':+'0.57('*.V(#&+$+'#"8('&*.%#('*+$(#V('.'#V"5.4.V'8.#&$%281+V+N'
6XSURWQRUDQLMHXVYRMHQRPPLOMHQMXGRND]DQRMHGDMHNXSRODRGRSHNHQDKDPDPXELODL]JUDHQDRGVWUDQH
2VPDQOLMD8LJRGLQLVXWDNRHUNUHQXODLVWUDLYDQMDQD&DUHYRPKDPDPXVOLQRNDRLX%X/
GLPXQDQDLQQDNRMLVHRULJLQDOQLGLMHORYLL]RVPDQVNRJSHULRGDPRJXLGHQWLNRYDWLLLVWUDLWL8JRGLQL
SRQRYQDLVWUDLYDQMDQDNXSDWLOXKDPDPXX2VWURJRQXQHNDGDSRWSXQRVSDOMHQLPSRG]HPOMRPMHL]QHQDXMXH
SURQDHQRGDMHJUDHYLQDSRWSXQRQHWDNQXWDVYHGRQRVDDVYRGD
E!
G#&! "$%! $(*"#&0! #/ ! "$%! &%*%4&,$! 4+-! /#&! "$%! H+#'+! 62(8-(+.*! "$4"!
VWLOOVWDQGVHH*\]*HUVPRQRJUDSKSXEOLVKHGLQLWLVVWLOO
D NH\ ZRUN *HU *\] $] RV]PiQW|U|N pStWpV]HW 0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ
']ViPLN WUEpN IUGNFL 0YpV]HWW|UWpQHWL )]HWHN %XGDSHVW
$NDGpPLDL 7KDQNV DUH GXH WR KLP IRU VXSSOHPHQWLQJ WKH
KLVWRU\RI WKHUHVHDUFKZLWKQHZGDWD*HU*\]7KHKLVWRU\
RI 2WWRPDQ7XUNLVK DUFKDHRORJLFDO UHVHDUFK LQ +XQJDU\ LQ
C%1,(".7.5R'.B '$,"'-$$.0(#'*"%+.)'+#'<2#5(%RN'P-*F!S6#804!V%&%80%*!4+-!
V0m+.0('.RYiFV%XGDSHVW+XQJDULDQ1DWLRQDO0XVHXPSS
Eb@BBF
:4*%-!#+!*#2&,%!14"%&(48!/!6#"$!*(-%*3!"$%!"#@
"48!+216%&!#/ !1#*Y2%*!;1(0+*<!4+-!0"&1+)*';)&40%&!
$#2*%*<!#)%&4"(+.!#+!92+.4&(4+!"%&&("#&0!2+-%&!
2WWRPDQUXOHKDVEHHQSXWDWEHWZHHQDQG
B,QFRQWUDVWWRWKLVJXUHRQWKHWHUULWRU\
#/ !"#-40J*!92+.4&0!'%!H+#'!#/ !>2*"!%(.$"!1(0+*!
*2&?(?(+.! (+! '$#8%! #&! (+! )4&"F! L$%! 1%1#&0! #/ !
4+#"$%&!"'#!;(+!P.%&!4+-!(+!q&-<!(*!)&%*%&?%-!60!
4!1(+4&%"!(+!%4,$!,4*%F
L$%! )(,"2&%! (*! *(1(84&! '$%+! '%! %R41(+%! "$%!
-4"4!&%84"(+.!"#!64"$*!;,(0(0*!4+-!OFD*<F!A,,#&-@
(+.! "#! &%*%4&,$! '#&H! ,#+-2,"%-! (+! &%,%+"! 0%4&*!
#+! "$%! 64*(*! #/ ! "$%! ?4&(#2*! $(*"#&(,48! *#2&,%*3!
2WWRPDQEDWKVH[LVWHGLQGLIIHUHQWVHWWOH@
1%+"*F`!:0!,#+"&4*"3!(+!:2-4!"$%&%!4&%!+#'!>2*"!
IRXU VWDQGLQJ 2WWRPDQ EDWKV ZH NQRZ RI DQ@
#"$%&!"'#!64"$*3!#+%!(+!:2-4!4+-!#+%!(+!O%*"3!"$4"!
'%&%!-%1#8(*$%-!62"!"$%!/#2+-4"(#+*!#/ !'$(,$!
*2&?(?%F!N4>#&!)4&"*!#/ !"'#!64"$*!$4?%!*2&?(?%-!
(+!P.%&3!#+,%!4!4+7(R"$!,%+"&%F!Q%14(+*!#/ !4!64"$!
$4?%!48*#!*2&?(?%-!(+!V0284!4+-!(+!On,*!&%*)%,@
"(?%803!%4,$!(*!4!/#&1%&!&(#1(8!,%+"&%F!S+!4--("(#+3!
&%*%4&,$%&*!H+#'!#/ !4+#"$%&!*2,$!62(8-(+.!"$4"!
'4*! -%1#8(*$%-FC! 9%+,%3! #/ ! "$%*%! bC! 64"$*! '%!
H+#'!46#2"!EE!#+80F
[("$!"$%!%R,%)"(#+!#/ !"'#!%R41)8%*!"$4"!4&%!
*"(88! *"4+-(+.3! 92+.4&0J*! WUEH*! $4?%! ?4+(*$%-!
'("$#2"! "&4,%3! 4*! $4?%! ("*! 0")%"&"*3! 0"8$":*3! ,(#*3!
4+-!,4&4?4+*%&4(*F
*#1#+*%"$/'!&$"2'-+*341$2WWRPDQDUFKLWHF@
"2&%!-4"%*!64,H!1#&%!"$4+!4!,%+"2&0F!9#'%?%&3!
-%*)("%!"$%!,#+"(+248!%+&(,$1%+"!#/ !#2&!H+#'8@
%-.%!#/ !("*!*"&2,"2&%*!60!*2,,%**(?%!.%+%&4"(#+*!
RI VFKRODUVXQWLOWKHVLWVHHPHGDVWKRXJK
"$%!+216%&!#/ !*2&?(?(+.!#&!H+#'+!%R41)8%*!#/ !
2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHLQ+XQJDU\ZDVQHYHUJR@
(+.!"#!(+,&%4*%FE
$KLJKO\VLJQLFDQWSUREOHPIRUUHVHDUFKLQWR
2WWRPDQRULJLQEXLOGLQJVLQ+XQJDU\LVWKHWLQ\
+216%&!#/ !*2,$!62(8-(+.*!"$4"!$4?%!*2&?(?%-3!(+!
'$#8%! #&! (+! )4&"F! L$%&%! (*! 4! ,8%4&! -(*)4&("0! 6%@
"'%%+!"$%!-4"4!(+!"$%!,#+"%1)#&4&0!*#2&,%*!4+-!
"$%!+216%&!#/ !62(8-(+.*!"$4"!$4?%!,#1%!-#'+!"#!
XV2QHUHDVRQIRUWKHPLVPDWFKLVWKDWH[DPSOHV
RI 2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHLQ+XQJDU\KDYHGLVDS@
SHDUHGDOPRVWFRPSOHWHO\RYHUWKHODVW\HDUV
0RUHVSHFLFDOO\LQWKHUVWYHGHFDGHVIROORZ@
LQJWKHH[SXOVLRQRI WKH2WWRPDQVQDPHO\LQ
WKHSHULRGIURPWKHPLGVWRWKHPLGV
PRUHWKDQSHUFHQWRI WKHEXLOGLQJVHUHFWHG
E\ WKH 2WWRPDQV LQ +XQJDU\ GXULQJ WKH
0%4&*!#/ !"$%(&!&28%!'%&%!H+#,H%-!-#'+!#&!#"$%&@
'(*%!-%*"�%-F
7KHGDWDHPHUJLQJIURPWKH2WWRPDQVRXUFHV
(+-(,4"%! ,#+*(-%&468%! 4&,$("%,"2&48! 4,"(?("03! 4+-!
"$(*!(*!48*#!)&#?%-!60!946*62&.!1(8("4&0!*2&?%0*!
14-%!#/ !"#'+*!4"!"$%!"(1%!"$%0!'%&%!&%,4)"2&%-F!
51
52
&I 1HFLSROX *OUX T,"' (5"' .B ' U+#(#3' (%1,+$"1$2%(7' 127$2%"' +#' $,"'
-$$.0(#'"0*+%"N'/RQGRQ5HDNWLRQSVHHDOVRJRVWRQ
*iERU0XVOLPFXOWXUDOHQFODYHVLQ+XQJDU\XQGHU2WWRPDQUXOH
(+K!C1$('-%+"#$(7+('C1()"0+("'U1+"#$+(%+20'<2#5(%+1("3!_#8F!fX_3!M#*F!
SSFLWS
4!*("%F!S+!"$%!%+-3!"$%!62(8-(+.!'4*!#6"4(+%-!60!
-iQRV(QF]LQJHUD%XGDWRZQVPDQDQGJXQSRZ@
-%&!14+2/4,"2&%&3!'$#!*(1)80!1#?%-!(+!4+-!2*%-!
("!/#&!*"#&(+.!*48")%"&%F!A*!4!&%*28"3!("!'4*!H+#'+!
IRUPDQ\GHFDGHVDVWKH6DOWSHWUH0RVTXH,W
'4*!*"(88!6%(+.!2*%-!/#&!*"#&(+.!*48")%"&%!4*!84"%!4*!
(YHQWXDOO\WKHEXLOGLQJZDVGHPROLVKHGLQ
"$%!84"%!Ea"$!,%+"2&0Fb'
$QRWKHU HPEOHPDWLF EXLOGLQJ SXW XS LQ 2W@
"#14+!"(1%*!'4*!"$%!=28"4+!=o8%014+!741((!(+!
=5(.%"?r&F! S"*! ,#+*"&2,"(#+! 6%.4+! (11%-(4"%80!
DIWHUWKHFDSWXUHRI 6]LJHWYiU&DVWOHE\WKH2W@
"#14+*F!A,,#&-(+.!"#!"&4-("(#+3!("!'4*!,#1)8%"%-!
(+!>2*"!4!/%'!'%%H*3!4+!481#*"!2+6%8(%?4680!*$#&"!
)%&(#-F! =5(.%"?r&! 74*"8%! '4*! *2&&%+-%&%-! "#!
+DEVEXUJ LPSHULDO WURRSV E\ LWV 2WWRPDQ JDU@
ULVRQLQ,QLWLDOO\WKH6OH\PDQ&DPLLZDV
2*%-!60!"$%!,4*"8%!,#114+-%&!4*!$(*!&%*(-%+,%F!
X4"%&3! (+! "$%! +%R"! -%,4-%*3! "$%! 62(8-(+.! /2+,@
"(#+%-!4*!4!1(8("4&0!*"#&4.%!/4,(8("0!4+-!4*!4!$#*@
SLWDO %HWZHHQ DQG LW VHUYHG DV WKH
FKDSHOIRUWKHJDUULVRQ,QWKHHDUO\"$!,%+"2&03!
("!'4*!2*%-!4*!4!.&4+4&0!4+-!4,,#11#-4"(#+!/#&!
4!64(8(// !'4*!62(8"!#+"#!("*!*#2"$@'%*"%&+!*(-%Fa!S"!
ZDV DW WKLV WLPH WKDW -RVHSK +DPPHU 3XUJVWDOO
VWXGLHGWKHRULJLQDO2WWRPDQLQVFULSWLRQVRQWKH
(+*(-%!#/ !"$%!62(8-(+.F
2XU OLVW RI 1(0+! 62(8-(+.*! 2*%-! /#&! *%,284&3!
#/"%+! )&4,"(,483! )2&)#*%*! ,4+! 6%! ,#+"(+2%-F! A!
/2&"$%&!%R41)8%!,#28-!6%!"$%!N48H#p!:%0!741((!
DW 6LNOyV ,Q WKH PLG"$! ,%+"2&03! "$(*! 62(8-(+.!
#)%+%-! #+! "#! "$%! ,#2&"04&-! #/ ! '$4"! '4*! "$%+!
"$%!O%8(,4+!S++!4+-!'4*!)&%*214680!4!)4&"!#/ !"$%!
(++!("*%8/3!*%&?(+.!4*!4!&%*(-%+"(48!62(8-(+.F!X4"%&3!
("!'4*!2*%-!4*!=(H8s*J*!)##&!$#2*%FED
V0284J*!=o8%014+!741((3!"#!6%!-(*,2**%-!6%@
8#'3!84"%&!*%&?%-!4*!"$%!$#2*%!#/ !4+!%*"4"%!*"%'@
4&-3!4,,#&-(+.!"#!4!-%*,&()"(#+!/!Eba`FEE
b!
Mn1%"$03!X4>#*F!7|U|NPHFVHWHN%XGiQF!:2-4)%*"K!A"$%+4%213!EabaF
0ROQiU -y]VHI 6]OHMPiQ V]XOWiQ G]ViPLMD 6]LJHWYiURWW LQ
0YpV]HWW|UWpQHWLeUWHVtW1RSSN'
% +DPPHU 3XUJVWDOO -y]VHI 1pPHO\ 3pFV N|UQ\pNpQ WDOiOKDWy
W|U|N DUDE pV SHU]VD IHOLUDWUyO LQ 0DJ\DU $FDGHPLDL eUWHVLW3! _#8F!
9,,1RSS
ED *HU *\] $ VLNOyVL 0DONRFV EHM G]ViPL LQ eStWpV
eStWpV]HWWXGRPiQ\9RO;91RVSS
EE! O%"(H3! A16&2*F! %pNpV PHJ\H OHtUiVDF! V0284K! P&H%8! G%&%+,! Nt5%213!
S
EB! S6(-F3!)F!EbF
VXPPDU\ZRUNVZHUHSXEOLVKHGLQDOLVWRI
KLVWRULFDO PRQXPHQWV DQG LQ DQ DUFKLWHF@
WXUDOVXUYH\RI WKH2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVWKDWZHUH
*"(88! *"4+-(+.F! 9#'%?%&3! "$%! &%48! 6&%4H"$.$!
FDPHRQO\LQWKHVDQGV,WLVIURPWKLV
"(1%!#+'4&-*!"$4"!'%!,4+!*)%4H!#/ !1%"$#-(,48!
&%*%4&,$!4,"(?("0!4(1%-!4"!*#8?(+.!)4&"(,284&!)@
8%1*3! 4+-! #/ ! "$%! 8(+H*! 6%"'%%+! 4&,$4%#8#.(,48!
'#&H!4+-!'488!(+?%*"(.4"(#+*F!S"!'4*!4"!"$(*!"(1%!
WKDW VFLHQWLF H[FDYDWLRQ RI 3pFVV *D]L .DVP
3DD &DPLL RQH RI +XQJDU\V PRVW SURPLQHQW
2WWRPDQPRQXPHQWVZDVFRQGXFWHGE`!L$%!&%@
*%4&,$! '#&H! )%&/#&1%-! (+! 92+.4&0! -2&(+.! "$%!
*%,#+-!$48/ !#/ !"$%!BD"$!,%+"2&0!(*!84&.%80!4**#,(@
DWHGZLWKWKHDUFKLWHFW-y]VHI 0ROQiUEC!4+-!"$%!
DUFKDHRORJLVW*\]*HU:LWKDOOGXHUHVSHFW
"#!"$%13!(+!'$4"!/#88#'*!S!*$#28-!8(H%!"#!*)%4H!
QRWDERXWWKHLUZRUNEXWUDWKHUDERXWWKHQG@
(+.*!#/ !"$%!84*"!-%,4-%F
,OO,QWHULRURIWKH5iF%DWKLQ%XGDGXULQJH[FDYDWLRQZRUN
3KRWRJUDSKE\-XGLW/iV]D\
53
Recent discoveries
V4"$%&(+.!)4,%!(+!"$%!)4*"!BC!0%4&*!;4+-!%*)%@
,(4880!"$%!84*"!"%+<3!4&,$4%#8#.(,48!&%*%4&,$!'#&H!
$4*!$%8)%-!(+,&%4*%3!"#!4+!2+%R)%,"%-!-%.&%%3!"$%!
QXPEHURI 2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVNQRZQWRXVUVW
4+-!/#&%1#*"!#+!"$%!"%&&("#&(%*!#/ !:2-4!4+-!O%*"F!
S+!%4,$!,4*%3!"$%*%!+%'80!/#2+-!62(8-(+.*!*2&?(?%!
#+80! (+! )4&"3! 48"$#2.$! *#1%"(1%*! "$%(&! &%14(+*!
4&%! *26*"4+"(48F! X%4?(+.! 4*(-%! 4! .4"%! "#'%&! ;-(*@
,2**%-!6%8#'<3!&%14(+*!#/ !62(8-(+.*!#/ !"'#!"0)%*!
;1(0+*!4+-!64"$*<!$4?%!6%%+!2+%4&"$%-F
6RPH RI RXU QHZ QGLQJV VWHP IURP WKH
%R,4?4"(#+!#/ !62(8-(+.*!48&%4-0!H+#'+3!62"!,#+@
-2,"%-!#+!4!84&.%&!*,48%3!(+!4!1#&%!-%"4(8%-!'403!
4+-!2*(+.!1%"$#-*!4))&#)&(4"%!/#&!"$%!BE*"!,%+@
WXU\([DPSOHVDUHWKHQGLQJVIURPWKHUHFHQW
H[FDYDWLRQ RI D VHULHV RI 2WWRPDQ EDWKV DORQJ
:2-4J*!c4+26%!%164+H1%+"F!L$%!/#2&!64"$*!(+!
TXHVWLRQDUHZHOONQRZQDQGZHUHLGHQWLHGYHU\
HDUO\RQ*\]*HUZDVDEOHWRFRQGXFWPLQRU
&%*%4&,$!'#&H!#+!"$&%%!#/ !"$%*%!/#2&!64"$*!(+!"$%!
ODWHVLQWKHUVWKDOI RI WKHVDQGLQ
54
,OO,QWHULRURIWKH&ViV]iU%DWKLQ%XGDGXULQJH[FDYDWLRQ
ZRUN3KRWRJUDSKE\%HQFH7LKDQ\L
WKHPLGV!9#'%?%&3!'("$(+!"$%!/&41%'#&H!
#/ !14>#&!&%,#+*"&2,"(#+!'#&H!4"!"$%!64"$*3!"'#!
0#2+.!&%*%4&,$%&*!%?%+"24880!$4-!"$%!#))#&"2+("0!
"#!,#+-2,"!1#&%!*%&(#2*!&%*%4&,$!"$%&%F
=(1(84&!"#!"$%!&%*%4&,$!(+"#!:2-4J*!64"$*3!"$%!
/288! %R,4?4"(#+! #/ ! "'#! 1(0+*! $4*! 6%.2+! (+! "$%!
84*"! /%'! 0%4&*3! #+! "$%! 64*(*! #/ ! $(*"#&(,48! -4"4!
48&%4-0! H+#'+! 4+-! *1488%&@*,48%! &%*%4&,$! '#&H!
)%&/#&1%-! *#1%! -%,4-%*! %4&8(%&F! 7#+"&4&0! "#!
%R)%,"4"(#+*!4"!"$%!#2"*%"3!6#"$!%R,4?4"(#+*!$4?%!
5iF%DWK%XGD
5XGDV%DWK%XGD
&ViV]iU%DWK%XGD
L$(*!1#+21%+"!(*!H+#'+!/!84"%!Eb"$@,%+@
"2&0!*#2&,%*!4*!"$%!_%8(!:%0!:4"$3!62"!4!*2&?(?(+.!
(+*,&()"(#+! )&#?%*! "$4"! #&(.(+4880! ("! '4*! 4+#"$%&!
IRXQGDWLRQE\6RNROOX0XVWDID3DDDQGZDVEXLOW
LQ6LQFHWKHHQGRI WKH2WWRPDQSHULRG
"##3!("!$4*!6%%+!(+!,#+"(+248!2*%!4*!4!64"$F!L$%!
62(8-(+.!2+-%&'%+"!14>#&!48"%&4"(#+*!(+!"$%!1(-@
"$FHQWXU\DQGLQWKHV2QDFFRXQWRI LWV
#6*#8%"%!"%,$+(,48!%Y2()1%+"3!("!'4*!,8#*%-!(+!"$%!
84"%!BD"$!,%+"2&0F!L$(*!488#'%-!&%*%4&,$!'#&H!"#!
WDNHSODFHLQ$FFRUGLQJWRWKHQGLQJV
"$%!$#"!&##1!(+!"$%!62(8-(+.!$4*!*2&?(?%-!(+"4,"!
;(88F! B<3! 48#+.! '("$! "$%! /#2+-4"(#+*! #/ ! "$%! )##8!
4+-! "$%! 8#'%&1#*"! *"%)*! #/ ! ("F! S+! %4,$! #/ ! "$%!
/#2&!,#&+%&*!#/ !"$%!62(8-(+.!"$%&%!2*%-!"#!6%!4!
BD */iV]D\-XGLWDQG3DSS$GULHQQ$EXGDLW|U|NIUGNNXWDWiVD
D] pYH]UHG HOHMpQ LQ 0HPOpNYpGHOHP 9RO /,, 1R
SS 'DWD RQ WKH PHGLHYDO EDWKV RQ %XGDV 'DQXEH
HPEDQNPHQWEHIRUHWKH7XUNLVKSHULRGDUHWREHIRXQGLQHDUO\"$@
,%+"2&0!"("$%!&%,#&-*!4+-!(+!V%#&.![%&+$%&J*!"&%4"(*%!;W"'()0+%(#)+&'
<2#5(%+("'(]2+&xZULWWHQLQRQWKHZDWHUVRI +XQJDU\)RUD
IDFVLPLOHHGLWLRQRI WKLVVHH:HUQKHU-XUDM2SRGLYXKRGQFKYRGiFK
j,.%&8(0DUWLQ2VYHWD6HHDOVR9pJK$QGUiV%XGDYiURV
N|]pSNRUL KHO\UDM]D , LQ ;.#20"#$(' <+&$.%+1(' 62)(*"&$+#"#&+(M' _#8F!
%XGDSHVW%XGDSHVWL7|UWpQHWL0~]HXPSS
BE /iV]D\DQG3DSS$EXGDLW|U|NIUGNSS
dHPEHUFL$D&DPLL%XGD
55
6PDOO%DWK(V]WHUJRP
,OO7KHRQHWLPH2WWRPDQJXQSRZGHUWRZHUGLVFRYHUHGDW
WKH/XNiFV%DWKLQ%XGD3KRWRJUDSKE\-XGLW/iV]D\
VPDOOSULYDWHSRRO7KHRULJLQDORRULQJKDVWRDOO
(+"%+"*!4+-!)2&)#*%*!)%&(*$%-F!L$%!?%*"(628%!4+-!
1#*"!#/ !"$%!'4&1!&##1!$4?%!6%%+!-%*"�%-FBB
/XNiFV%DWK%XGD
56
BB ,ELGSS
/iV]D\ -XGLW DQG 3DSS $GULHQQ .XWDWiVRN D EXGDIHOKpYt]L
IUGNEHQLQ5pJpV]HWLNXWDWiVRN0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ!:2-4)%*"K!N4.04&!
1HP]HWL0~]HXPSS
S+!"$%![4"%&!L#'+!-(*"&(,"!#/ !P*5"%&.#13!'%!
,4+! &%)#&"! 4+! 4*"#+(*$(+.! %R,4?4"(#+F! L$(*! (+@
?%*"(.4"%-!4!64"$!'$(,$!'4*!8(H%'(*%!H+#'+!62"!
'$(,$!$4-!*2+H!(+"#!#68(?(#+!Z!8("%&48803!*(+,%!("!
$4-! 6%%+! 62&(%-! 2+-%&! %4&"$F! [%! -#! +#"! H+#'!
"$%! )&%,(*%! "(1%! #/ ! "$%! 64"$J*! ,#+*"&2,"(#+h! #+!
"$%!64*(*!#/ !&%84"%-!-4"43!("!140!$4?%!6%%+!62(8"!
EHWZHHQDQG(YOL\DdHOHELLGHQWLHG
("*! )&%,(*%! 8#,4"(#+! '("$(+! "$%! *%""8%1%+"F! L$(*!
*1488!62(8-(+.3!1%4*2&(+.!a!R!a!1%"&%*!4+-!*2&@
1#2+"%-! 60! 4! -#1%3! '4*! ,#1)8%"%80! 62&(%-! (+!
WKHPLG"$!,%+"2&0!'$%+!"$%!4&%4!4+-!("!'4*!
OOHGZLWKHDUWK7KHHGLFHKRZHYHUFRQWLQXHG
"#!6%!2*%-h!4,,%**!'4*!60!'40!#/ !4!*)%,(4880@62(8"!
*"4(&'40F! X(.$"! /#&! "$%! (++%&! *)4,%! '4*! %+*2&%-!
60! 4! 84+"%&+! *"&2,"2&%! 62(8"! #+! "$%! "#)! #/ ! "$%!
-#1%! '$(,$! &#*%! 46#?%! "$%! 8%?%8! #/ ! "$%! %4&"$F!
$IWHUWKHGRPHIHOOLQXQGHUWKHZHLJKWRI
"$%! %4&"$! #+! "#)! #/ ! ("3! 4+-! "$%! (++%&! *)4,%! #/ !
WKHEXLOGLQJZDVWKHQOOHGZLWKHDUWK7KHEDWK
UHPDLQHGLQWKLVFRQGLWLRQIRUDFHQWXU\,Q
"$%! 4&,$4%#8#.(*"! S*"?r+! 9#&?r"$! ,#+-2,"%-! 4+!
%R)8#&4"#&0!%R,4?4"(#+!4+-!%*"468(*$%-!"$%!62(8-@
(+.J*! )&%,(*%! 8#,4"(#+F! L$%! 84*"! "'#! 0%4&*! $4?%!
'("+%**%-! "$%! -(..(+.! #2"! 4+-! 4&,$4%#8#.(,48!
H[FDYDWLRQRI WKHHGLFHZKLFKLVDOPRVWFRP@
,OO,QWHULRURIWKH6PDOO%DWKLQ(V]WHUJRPGXULQJH[FDYD
WLRQZRUN3KRWRJUDSKE\,VWYiQ+RUYiWK
)8%"%80!(+"4,"!2)!"#!"$%!*2))#&"*!/#&!"$%!?428"(+.!
;(88*F!`ZC<FB`
6XOWDQ6OH\PDQ&DPLL*\XOD
L$(*!62(8-(+.!(*!&%/%&&%-!"#!4*!%4&80!4*!"$%!&(#/
1(8UHJLVWHURI LWLVRI FRXUVHPHQWLRQHG
E\ (YOL\D dHOHEL LQ KLV WUDYHORJXH 7KH
62(8-(+.J*! )&%,(*%! 8#,4"(#+3! 4+-! ("*! ,#+-("(#+! (+!
"$%! %4&80! Ea"$! ,%+"2&03! ,4+! 6%! ,8%4&80! *%%+! #+! 4!
EbBB!*2&?%0!14-%!60!"$%!4&10!%+.(+%%&!X%#)#8-!
G&4+5!Q#*%+/%8-F!X4"%&!#+3!("!/%4"2&%-!#+!14+0!
)&(+"*3! &(.$"! 2)! "#! ("*! -%1#8("(#+! 4"! "$%! %+-! #/ !
"$%!Ea"$!,%+"2&0F!A+!4&,$4%#8#.(,48!%R,4?4"(#+!(+!
WKHPLGVXQFRYHUHGDEXLOGLQJRULHQWHGLQD
*#2"$%4*"Z+#&"$'%*"!-(&%,"(#+!'$(,$!'4*!BEFC!1!
8#+.!4+-!EBFC!1!'(-%F!S"!$4-!6%%+!8%?%88%-!"#!("*!
/#2+-4"(#+*F!S+!"$%*%!'%!/#2+-!4!/&41%'#&H!#/ !
EHDPV WKLV LV FKDUDFWHULVWLF RI 2WWRPDQ EXLOG@
(+.*!4+-!$4*!6%%+!#6*%&?%-!%8*%'$%&%!4*!'%88FBC
*DWHWRZHU*\XOD
L$%! 64&#Y2%! 14+*(#+! %&%,"%-! #+! "$%! *("%!
#/ !V0284J*!#2"%&!,4*"8%!(+!"$%!%4&80!Ea"$!,%+"2&0!
LQFRUSRUDWHG DQ 2WWRPDQ JDWH WRZHU WKDW ZDV
XQNQRZQWRUHVHDUFKHUVIRUDORQJSHULRG2QO\
(+!BDDD!-(-!4&,$4%#8#.(,48!4+-!'488@&%*%4&,$!(+@
?%*"(.4"(#+*!,84&(/0!"$%!#&(.(+*!#/ !"$(*!62(8-(+.F!S+!
WKHUVWKDOI RI WKH"$!,%+"2&03!4!64&#Y2%!"#'%&!
'4*!62(8"!#+!"#)!#/ !"$%!.4"%!%+"&4+,%3!'$(,$!'4*!
#&(.(+4880!#+!#+%!8%?%8F!L$(*!"#'%&!(*!*"(88!*"4+-@
(+.F! =2&?%0*! 14-%! #/ ! V0284! 74*"8%! 6%/#&%! 4+-!
DIWHULWZDVRFFXSLHGE\WKH2WWRPDQVSURYHWKDW
EHWZHHQDQGWKHHQWUDQFHWRWKHRXWHU
,4*"8%!'4*!8#,4"%-!"#!"$%!+#&"$!#/ !"$%!*#2"$!*(-%F!
M%?%&"$%8%**3!#+80!4&,$4%#8#.(,48!%R,4?4"(#+!'4*!
468%!"#!)&#?%!"$4"!"$(*!&%8#,4"(#+!#,,2&&%-!-2&(+.!
"$%!)%&(#-!(+!'$(,$!"$%!,4*"8%!'4*!#,,2)(%-!60!"$%!
2WWRPDQV)UDPHGE\WKHUDPSDUWRI WKHRXWHU
,4*"8%3! "$%! *(+.8%@8%?%8! .4"%! *"&2,"2&%! /%4"2&%-! 4!
&%,"4+.284&!.+-!)84+F!L$(*!*"&2,"2&%!'4*!62(8"!
)4&"80!/!-&%**%-!*"#+%!4+-!)4&"80!/!6&(,Hh!
"#!("*!%4*"!'488!'4*!>#(+%-!4!*1488!*"#+%!62(8-(+.!
WKDWLVQRZGHPROLVKHGLOOV
,OO,QWHULRURIWKH6PDOO%DWKLQ(V]WHUJRPGXULQJH[FDYD
WLRQZRUN3KRWRJUDSKE\,VWYiQ+RUYiWK
,ELGSS
Bb *HU *\] $ SpFVL )HUKiG SDVD G]ViPL pSOHWHJ\WWHVH pV D
)HUKiGSDVDPDKDOOHLQ0HPOpNYpGHOHP3'9RO;/,;1R
SS
)HUKDG3DD&DPLL3pFV)
B`! 9#&?r"$3!S*"?r+3!9F!U%8%1%+3!Nr&"43!4+-!L#&143!S*"?r+F!.RPiURP
PHJ\HUpJpV]HWLWRSRJUiiMD%XGDSHVW$NDGpPLDLSS
BC *HUHO\HV,ERO\D2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHLQWKHWRZQRI *\XODLQ
C%1,(".7.5R'.B '$,"'-$$.0(#'*"%+.)'+#!<2#5(%RSSFLWS
57
58
,OO6RXWKHUQZDOORIWKHLQWHULRURIWKH2WWRPDQJDWHWRZHU
LQ*\XOD3KRWRJUDSKE\,VWYiQ)HOG
,OO1RUWKHUQZDOORIWKHLQWHULRURIWKH2WWRPDQJDWHWRZHU
LQ*\XOD3KRWRJUDSKE\,VWYiQ)HOG
Conclusion
S! 41! ,#+?(+,%-! "$4"! "$%&%! 4&%! 1#&%! 2+-(*@
FRYHUHG 2WWRPDQ EXLOGLQJV RQ +XQJDULDQ VRLO
"$#*%! "$4"! 4&%! H+#'+! /! "$%! '&(""%+! *#2&,%*!
)82*!"$#*%!"$4"!&%*%4&,$!$4*!+#"!-(*,#?%&%-!4+-!
"$4"!4&%!+#"!1%+"(#+%-!(+!"$%!*#2&,%*F!L$%(&!8#,4@
"(#+!4+-!2+%4&"$(+.!'#28-!,8%4&80!6%!*%+*4"(#+48F!
[%! ,4++#"! &28%! #2"! %+"(&%80! "$%! )#**(6(8("0! "$4"!
62(8-(+.*!/2880!2+H+#'+!%4&8(%&!#+!140!0%"!,#1%!
"#!8(.$"F!L$%!6%*"!%R41)8%!#/ !*2,$!4!62(8-(+.!(*!
"$%!46#?%@1%+"(#+%-!.4"%!"#'%&3!'$(,$!S!10*%8/ !
2+%4&"$%-F
A"!"$%!*41%!"(1%3!6%,42*%!#/ !"$%!84&.%@*,48%!
-%1#8("(#+*3!'$4"!(+!#"$%&!,#2+"&(%*!6%8#+.*!"#!
"$%!&%1("!#/ !1#+21%+"!)&#"%,"(#+3!(+!92+.4&0!
8(%*!6%+%4"$!"$%!.+-!4*!4&,$4%#8#.(,48!14"%@
&(48F![%!,4+!6%!*2&%!"$4"!(+!"$%!,#1(+.!-%,4-%*!
4&,$4%#8#.(*"*! '(88! 2+,#?%&! &%14(+*! #/ ! 1#&%!
DQG PRUH 2WWRPDQ EXLOGLQJV :H KDYH RQO\ WR
6%4&!(+!1(+-!"$4"!*(+,%!"$%!4))%4&4+,%!#/ !6##H*!
E\ 3URIHVVRU $\YHUGBa DQG *\] *HU WKLUW\
0%4&*! 4.#3! "$%! 4&,$4%#8#.(,48! &%14(+*! #/ ! "$&%%!
4--("(#+48! 1(0+*' 4+-! "$&%%! 64"$*! $4?%! 6%%+! 2+@
,#?%&%-F![("$!-2%!&%*)%,"!"#!"$%!.%+%&4"(#+!#/ !
&%*%4&,$%&*!)&%,%-(+.!2*3!("!*%%1*!"$4"!"$%!$(*"#&0!
RI 2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHLQ+XQJDU\PXVWLQWKH
8(.$"!#/ !&%,%+"!&%*%4&,$3!*8#'80!6%!&%'&(""%+F
:LWKUHJDUGWRKLGGHQ2WWRPDQHGLFHVWKRVH
7$&(*"(4+!,$2&,$%*!"$4"!'%&%!&%62(8"!(+!"$%!%4&80!
Ea"$! ,%+"2&0! 4))%4&' "#! 6%! "$%! 1#*"! )(*(+.!
4&%4F!N#*"!*"4+-(+.!1(0+!*"&2,"2&%*!"$4"!*2&?(?%!
4&%!7$&(*"(4+!,$2&,$%*!*"(88!(+!2*%!"#-40F!PR41)8%*!
DUH WKH 7R\JXQ 3DD &DPLL LQ %XGD WKH 3DULVK
! =,$#%+3!A&+#8-F!AEXGDWDEiQL6]HQW.DWDOLQSOpEiQLDWHPSORP!:2-4)%*"K!
.DWROLNXV7|UWpQHWtUyN0XQNDN|]|VVpJH
1DJ\ /DMRV %XGDSHVW' W|UWpQHWH LQ 62)(*"&$' $w%$=#"$"'
D W|U|N NL]pVpWO D PiUFLXVL IRUUDGDORPLJF! P-F! c#1#H#*! U#*r&0F!
%XGDSHVW$NDGpPLDLSSFLWS
*HU*\],VWROQL%HRJUDGpStWpV]HWLHPOpNHLLQ6]pNHVIHKpUYiU
pYV]i]DGDL 7|U|N NRU! =5nH%*/%$n&?r&K! S*"?r+! U(&r80! Nt5%21!
.|]OHPpQ\HL$VRUR]DW1RSSFLWS
! 9#&?r"$3!9F!U%8%1%+3!4+-!L#&14F!.RPiURPPHJ\HSS
,OO(DVWDQGQRUWKZDOOVRIWKH)HUKDG3DD&DPLLLQ3pFV
3KRWRJUDSKE\/iV]Oy*HUH
WRLWWKHRQHWLPH0HPL3DD&DPLL!G(+48803!'%!
*$#28-!1%+"(#+!"$%!7$2&,$!#/ !"$%!G&4+,(*,4+*!
(+!P.%&F!A,,#&-(+.!"#!Ea"$@,%+"2&0!*#2&,%*3!"$(*!
,#+,%48*!4!Eb"$@,%+"2&0!1(0+3!"$%!+41%!#/ !'$(,$!
LVIRUWKHPRPHQWXQLGHQWLDEOH
S!*$#28-!8(H%!"#!%+-!'("$!4!"$#2.$"3!"$4"!"$#*%!
#/ ! 92+.4&0J*! /2+,"(#+(+.! 64&#Y2%! ,$2&,$%*!
'$(,$! (+! "$%(&! /#2+-4"(#+*! 4+-! *"4+-(+.! '488*!
FRQFHDO RQHWLPH 2WWRPDQ 1(0+*! &%)&%*%+"! )4&"!
#/ !4!,#11#+!,28"2&48!$%&("4.%F!
&KXUFKRI WKH,QQHU7RZQLQ3HVWWKH$OL3DD
&DPLLLQ6]LJHWYiUWKH*D]L.DVP3DD&DPLLLQ
3pFVDQGWKHVRFDOOHGJRVWRQWpU0"&1+)3!48*#!(+!
3pFV7KHQXPEHURI 2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVVXUYLY@
(+.!(+!)4&"!'(88!*2&%80!6%!$(.$%&F![("$!&%.4&-!"#!
+21%*! 7$&(*"(4+! ,$2&,$%*! %("$%&! ,#+?%&"%-!
IURP2WWRPDQ1(0+*!#&'&%,#+?%&"%-!"#!7$&(*"(4+!
2*%!4/"%&!*%&?(+.!4*!1(0+*!%4&8(%&!#+3!'%!H+#'!/#&!
,%&"4(+3!#+!"$%!64*(*!#/ !"$%!4&,$(?48!*#2&,%*3!"$4"!
-2&(+.! &%,#+*"&2,"(#+! '#&H! (+! "$%! Ea"$! ,%+"2&0!
,%&"4(+! %8%1%+"*! #/ ! "$%! %4&8(%&! 62(8-(+.*! '%&%!
(+,#&)#&4"%-!(+"#!+%'!#+%*!"$4"!4&%!*"(88!*"4+-(+.F!
,Q WKLV ZD\ WKH QXPEHU RI VXUYLYLQJ 2WWRPDQ
1#+21%+"*!140'(+,&%4*%!(+!"$%!/2"2&%F!:%8#'!S!
*$488!1%+"(#+!#+80!4!/%'!#2"*"4+-(+.!%R41)8%*F!
G#&! (+*"4+,%3! "$%! 7$2&,$! #/ ! ="F! 74"$%&(+%! Z! 4"!
RQHWLPHWKH0XVWDID3DD&DPLLLQWKH7DEiQ
-(*"&(,"! #/ ! :2-4! )&%*%&?%*! ,%&"4(+! )4&"*! #/ ! "$%!
%4&8(%&! 1(0+F! L$%! 7$2&,$! #/ ! "$%! G&4+,(*,4+*!
(+!O%*"!,#+"4(+*!)4&"*!#/ !"$%!/#&1%&!=(+4+!:%0!
741((3! 4+-! "$%! T+(?%&*("0! 7$2&,$3! 8(H%'(*%! (+!
3HVWDQGRQHRI WKHQHVWEDURTXHFKXUFKHVLQ
"$%!92+.4&(4+!,4)("483!)&%*%&?%*!)4&"*!#/ !4!1(0+!
ZKLFKDV\HWLVXQLGHQWLHG!S+!=5nH%*/%$n&?r&3!
VLJQLFDQW SDUWV PD\ VXUYLYH RI WKH RQHWLPH
9HOL%H\&DPLLZKLFKZDVUHEXLOWE\WKH-HVXLWV
(+!Eb``3!48"$#2.$!"$%!%R"%+"!#/ !"$%!1(0+J*!-%1#@
8("(#+!(*!2+,8%4&F6LQFHWKHUHFRQVWUXFWHG
62(8-(+.! $4*! 6%%+! 2*%-! 60! "$%! 7(*"%&,(4+! #&-%&F!
X(H%'(*%!-%*%&?(+.!#/ !"$%!4""%+"(#+!#/ !"$%!+%R"!
.%+%&4"(#+!#/ !&%*%4&,$%&*!(*!P*5"%&.#1J*!O4&(*$!
7$2&,$!#/ !"$%![4"%&!L#'+3!"$%!#+%@"(1%!N4$@
H%1%!741((3!'$(,$!'4*!2+-#26"%-80!*"(88!*"4+-(+.!
LQ!L$%!62(8-(+.!'4*!*8(.$"80!48"%&%-!(+!"$%!
%4&80!Ea"$FHQWXU\EHIRUHEHLQJPRGLHGVLJQL@
,4+"80!(+!EbbaF!S"*!.+-!)84+!"#-40!(*3!$#'%?%&3!
)&4,"(,4880!"$%!*41%!4*!"$4"!#/ !"$%!%4&8(%&!62(8-(+.F!
:LGHO\NQRZQLV3pFVVIRUPHU0HPL3DD%DWK
ZKLFKZDVH[FDYDWHGE\*\]*HU:RUWKUH@
*%4&,$(+.!(*!"$%!7$2&,$!#/ !"$%!G&4+,(*,4+*!+%R"!
59
Machiel Kiel
The campanile-minarets of the southern
Herzegovina: a blend of Islamic and
Christian elements in the architecture of
an outlying border area of the Balkans,
its spread in the past and sur vival until
our time
Zvonici-minareti u jugoistone
Hercegovine: spoj elemenata islama i
krianstva u arhitekturi pograni nog
pojasa Balkanskog poluostr va, njihovo
irenje u prolosti i opstanak d o
sadanjeg vremena
60
T,"'(2$,.%')+&12&&"&'$,"'&]2(%"/&,(*")'0+#(%"$'*,"#.0"#.#'.B '<"%X"5.4+#(N'C'B"($2%"'(7+"#'$.'$,"'-$$.0(#'
$%()+$+.#M'$,"'Z1(0*(#+7"'0+#(%"$&['(%"'+#)"")'%"&$%+1$")'$.'$,+&'#.%$,/P"&$"%#'6(78(#'%"5+.#N'T,"R',(4"':""#'
%"0(%8")'2*.#':R'&"4"%(7'(2$,.%&M':2$'#.'&"*(%($"'&$2)R',(&'"4"%':""#'P%+$$"#N'T,"+%'B.%0',(&':""#'$%()+$+.#(77R'
7+#8")'$.'$,"'1(0*(#+7"&'.B '$,"'#"(%:R'C)%+($+1'1.(&$M'P,"%"B%.0'$,"&"'0.&]2"&^':2+7)"%&'02&$',(4"'1.0"N'W"&*+$"'
WKHGLIFXOWLHVFDXVHGE\WKHGHVWUXFWLRQRI VRPDQ\FDPSDQLOHPLQDUHWPRVTXHH[DPSOHVHVSHFLDOO\LQWKH$,'
FHQWXU\WKHDXWKRUZDVDEOHWRLGHQWLI\IRXUWHHQPRQXPHQWVZKLFKKDGWKLVIHDWXUH$PRQJWKHVHLVWKH6HIHU$D
PRVTXHLQ'DEULFDQHDU6WRODFZKLFKGDWHVWRRUDQGWKHVRFDOOHG$YGLPRVTXHLQ3ODQD
QHDU%LOHD7KH\VKDUHDVIHDWXUHVQRWRQO\DVTXDUHPLQDUHWEXWDOVRDS\UDPLGDOVODWHFRYHUHGURRI
P,+1,'+&'('$R*+1(7'<"%X"5.4+#+(#'B"($2%"N'T,"'0.&]2"'+#'a7(#('P(&'1.0*7"$"7R')"&$%.R")'+#'$,"'%"1"#$'P(%_'.B '$,($'
LQ'DEULFDRQO\WKHZDOOVUHPDLQ7KHPRVTXHRI +DVDQ3DVKD3UHGRMHYLDW3ROMHQHDU%LOHDEXLOWFD
PXVWKDYHORRNHGYHU\VLPLODUEHIRUHLWZDVGDPDJHGLQ::,,)RUERWKPRVTXHVQHDU%LOHDLWLVORFDOO\VDLGWKDW
$,"+%';2&7+0'B.2#)"%&',()'(7&.'"%"1$")'1,2%1,"&'B.%'$,"+%'0.$,"%&'P,.'%"0(+#")'!,%+&$+(#N'
C2$.%')+&82$2V"'.'B"#.0"#2'0+#(%"$('&('*%(4.25(.#.0'.&#.4.0'#('$"%+$.%+V+'<"%1"5.4+#"N'a.$*2#.'#"*.X#($.'
XRVPDQVNRMWUDGLFLMLPLQDUHWL]YRQLFLVXSRMDYRPVXHQLQDRYXUHJLMXVMHYHURLVWRQRJ%DONDQD6SRPLQMDQLVX
.)'&$%(#"'*(%'(2$.%(M'(7+'#+V")#('*.&":#('&$2)+V('#+V"'+8()'#(*+&(#(N'OV+,.4('B.%0('V"'$%()+1+.#(7#.'*.4"X(#('&('
FUNYHQLPWRUQMHYLPDREOLQMH-DGUDQVNHREDOHRGDNOHVXGROD]LOLJUDGLWHOMLNRMLVXJUDGLOLRYHGDPLMH8VSUNRV
SRWHNRDPDNRMDVXX]URNRYDQDXQLWHQMHPEH]EURMQLKSULPMHUDPLQDUHWD]YRQLNDSRVHEQRXYLMHNXDXWRU
MHXVSLRGDLGHQWLNXMHVSRPHQLNDNRMLLPDMXRYXRVRELWRVW0HXQMLPDVX6HIHUDJLQDGDPLMDX'DEULFL
EOL]X6WRFDNRMDGDWLUDL]LOLLWDNR]YDQD$YGLHYDGDPLMDX3ODQRMSRUHG%LOHH
1MLKRYD]DMHGQLNDRVREHQRVWMHSRUHGSUDYRXJDRQRJPLQDUHWDLSLUDPLGDOQLNURYSRNULYHQHPNDPHQRPNULOMFHP
WLSLQLP]D+HUFHJRYLQX'DPLMDX3ODQLMHELODSRWSXQRXQLWHQDXVNRULMHPUDWXDRGGDPLMHX'DEULFLVX
RVWDOLMHGLQR]LGRYL+DVDQSDLQD3UHGRMHYLGDPLMDX3ROMXEOL]X%LOHHMHELODL]JUDHQDRGSULOLNHRNR
JLYMHURYDWQRMHL]JOHGDODVOLQRSULMHQHJRWRMHXQLWHQDYHX'UXJRPVYMHWVNRPUDWX.DUDNWHULVWLQRL
WXQR]DREMHGDPLMHXRNROLFL%LOHHMHVWHWRGDVXQMLKRYLPXVOLPDQVNLRVQLYDLWDNRHUL]JUDGLOLLFUNYH]DVYRMH
0(V8"'8.V"'&2'.&$(7"'8($.78+#V"N
`!
C!
B!
7KHDXWKRUZRXOGOLNHWRWKDQN'U$PUD+DGLPXKDPHGRYLRI
"$%! 7#11(**(#+! "#! O&%*%&?%! M4"(#+48! N#+21%+"*! ;=4&4>%?#<! /#&!
$%8)(+.! 2*! '("$! (+/#&14"(#+! +#"! "#! 6%! /#2+-! %8*%'$%&%F! [%! 48*#!
OLNHG WR WKDQN WKH \RXQJ 2WWRPDQLVW *ULJRU %RMNRY 6RD IRU
DFFRPSDQ\LQJ KLP GXULQJ WKH RIWHQ GLIFXOW HOGZRUN RI !
HOL 'HPDO 'RPDH L RULMHQWDOQR X PDWHULMDOQRP NXOWXUQRP
QDVOHGMX ERVDQVNRKHUFHJRYDNLK PXVOLPDQD LQ a%+7.X+' X('
-%+V"#$(7#2'b+7.7.5+V2M9ROSSFLWSI
G#&! A864+(43! *%%! U(%83! N4,$(%8F! -$$.0(#' (%1,+$"1$2%"' +#' C7:(#+(N!
,VWDQEXO,5&,&$
,Q$UWDRQO\RQHPRVTXHHVFDSHGWKHIXU\RI WKHUH+HOOHQL]DWLRQ
#/ ! "$%! 4&%4F! N#&%! 1#+21%+"*! 4&%! )&%*%&?%-! (+! "$%! ,4)("48! #/ !
2WWRPDQ(SLUXV,RDQQLQDEXWWKH\DOOEHORQJWRWKH"$!4+-!Ea"$!
FHQWXULHVZKHQWKHFODVVLFDOSHULRGRI 2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHZDV
RYHU)RUWKH2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVRI ,RDQQLQDVHHWKHH[FHOOHQWVWXG\
RI 6P\ULV*LRUJRV7D0RXVRXOPDQLNLWHPHQLWRQ,RDQQLQRQNDL
LSROHRGRPLDWLV2WKRPDQLNLVSROLVLQA*"+%.$+8('!,%.#+8(9RO
SS
G#&!"$%!&(#1(8!#/ !9%&5%.#?(+4!;9%&*%H<3!'$(,$!(*!"$%!/#,2*!#/ !"$(*!
VWXG\WKH\DUHSUHVHUYHGIRUWKH\HDUV
DQG7KHUHPXVWDWOHDVWKDYHEHHQRQHPRUHIURPWKH
%4&80! EC`D*3! 62"! ("! 4))%4&*! "#! 6%! 8#*"F! L$%*%! &%.(*"%&*! "&%4"! ?(884.%!
60! ?(884.%3! $#2*%$#8-! 60! $#2*%$#8-F! L$%0! 48*#! ,#+"4(+! 4! 8%4&+%-!
%*"(14"%!#/ !"$%!8#,48!4.&(,28"2&48!)&#-2,"(#+F
L4H%!/#&!%R41)8%!"$%!'%88@-#,21%+"%-!,4*%!#/ !7%+"&48!:#*+(4F!L$%!
*41)8%!#/ !"$&%%!"#'+*!;G#>+(,43!U&%]%?#3!4+-!_(*#H#<!(+!"$%!8(X(!
#/ !_(*#H#!*$#'!"$%!/#88#'(+.!-%?%8#)1%+"!4*!-#,21%+"%-!(+!"$%!
2WWRPDQ UHJLVWHUV 0XVOLP
)RUWKLVDQGRWKHU
H[DPSOHVVHH.LHO0DFKLHO2WWRPDQVRXUFHVIRUWKHGHPRJUDSKLF
$(*"#&0!4+-!"$%!)&#,%**!#/ !S*841(54"(#+!#/ !:#*+(4@9%&,%.#?(+4!(+!
"$%!EC"$@Eb"$FHQWXULHVROGVRXUFHVQHZPHWKRGRORJ\LQ-$$.0(#'
6.&#+(3' (' ,+&$.%R' +#' *"%+7F! P-*F! N4&H2*! U#88%&! 4+-! U%148! U4&)4"F!
0DGLVRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI :LVFRQVLQ3UHVVSS)RUYHU\
*(1(84&!)&#,%**%*!(+!9%&5%.#?(+43!*%%!6%8#'F
)&*$ !"#$&!!&,+'$P1)(&%!4+-!("*!4&"3!481#*"!
"$%!%+"(&%![%*"!:48H4+*!Z!:#*+(4@9%&5%.#?(+43!
A864+(43! V&%%H! P)(&2*3! 4+-! (+84+-! c4814"(4!
Z! '4*! 4! /&#+"(%&! 4&%4! (+"#! '$(,$! "$%! ,84**(,48!
2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHGLGQRWSHQHWUDWHGHHSO\
'HPDO HOL WKH ORQJWLPH GLUHFWRU RI WKH
:#*+(4+! =%&?(,%! /#&! N#+21%+"*! #/ ! 728"2&%3!
#+,%!&%14&H%-!"$4"3!#/ !"$%!.$80!EDDD!$(*"#&@
LFDOPRVTXHVLQ%RVQLD+HU]HJRYLQDRQO\RU
VRZHUHWUXHUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVRI FODVVLFDO2WWR@
PDQDUFKLWHFWXUHZKLOHWKHUHPDLQGHUVKRZHG
)&#/#2+-80! 8#,48! "&%+-*FE# S+! A864+(43! ,84**(,48!
2WWRPDQ DUFKLWHFWXUH LV XQGHUUHSUHVHQWHG DV
'%88F! L$(*! +#"! 6%,42*%! #/ ! 4! 84,H! #/ ! 62(8-(+.*3!
"#! 6%! ,8%4&3! 62"! 6%,42*%! #/ ! "$%! /4,"! "$4"! "$%&%!
S*841! #+80! *"4&"%-! "#! *)&%4-! ?(.#*80! /!
"$%!Eb"$!,%+"2&0!#+'4&-F!T+8(H%!N4,%-#+(4!#&!
7KUDFH $OEDQLD DIWHU WKH 2WWRPDQ FRQTXHVW
VDZ QR VLJQLFDQW LQX[ RI 7XUNLVKVSHDNLQJ
N2*8(1!,#8#+(*"*F!M21%*!4+-!84&.%!1#*Y2%*!
'%&%!+%%-%-!#+80!/!"$%!Eb"$!,%+"2&0!#+'4&-3!
ZKHQFODVVLFDO2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUHZDVDOUHDG\
)4*"!("*!*211("F!S+!A864+(43!"$%!84&.%*"!4+-!1#*"!
&%14&H468%!'#&H*!#/ !"$(*!4&,$("%,"2&%!'%&%!,&%@
4"%-!(+!"$%!Ea"$!,%+"2&0FB#S+!+%(.$6#2&(+.!V&%%H!
P)(&2*3! S*841! '4*! 14(+80! ,#+,%+"&4"%-! (+! "'#!
61
62
-(*4))%4&4+,%!#/ !"$%!:#*+(4+!7$2&,$!
&%14(+*! 4+! 2+&%*#8?%-! (**2%F! A*! ("!
$4*! 6%%+! ,#++%,"%-! "#! "$%! :#*+(4+!
N2*8(1*J! %"$+#.%+%*(*3! ("! (*! 48*#! 4!
)D%14"(,! #+%F! 7#+,%&+(+.! "$%!
SKHQRPHQRQRI WKH%RJRPLOVDQG
"$%! "%+*! #/ ! "$#2*4+-*! #/ ! /2+%&4&0!
1#+21%+"*! ;VWHFL<' "$%0! 4&%! 6%8(%?%-!
"#!$4?%!8%/"!488!#?%&!"$%!:#*+(4+!1%@
-(%?48!H(+.-#13!/#&%(.+!*,$#84&*!$4?%!
+#"! &4&%80! ,#1%! "#! ,#1)8%"%80! -(/@
/%&%+"! ,#+,82*(#+*! "$4+! 8#,48! #+%*F'
[("$#2"!6%(+.!468%!"#!.#!(+"#!-%"4(83!
"$%! .%#.&4)$(,! #?%&84)! 6%"'%%+! "$%!
10*"%&(#2*80! S*841(,(5%-! &%.(#+! (+!
"$%! M#&"$'%*"! :48H4+*3! "$%! 14(+!
4&%4! '$%&%! VWHFL 4&%! /#2+-3! 4+-! #+%!
LVRODWHGSKHQRPHQRQLQ2WWRPDQDU@
,$("%,"2&48!$(*"#&0!'$(,$!S!41!46#2"!
"#!-(*,2**!(*!,%&"4(+80!(+"%&%*"(+.F
L$(*! (**2%! (*! "$4"! #/ ! "$%! 1#*Y2%*!
'("$! *Y24&%@*$4)%-! 1(+4&%"*! #+! "$%!
"%&&("#&0!#/ !9%&5%.#?(+4F!A8(%+!"#!"$%!
2WWRPDQWUDGLWLRQWKHLURGGIRUPKDV
6%%+! &%14&H%-! 2)#+! 60! *%?%&48! 8#,48!
KLVWRULDQV'HPDOHOLKDVVHHQLQWKH
PLQDUHWVVW\OHUHWDUGHG5RPDQHVTXH
4+-!V#"$(,!/#&1*Fb$PLU3DLLQKLV
'#&H!#+!"$%!4&,$("%,"2&%!#/ !:#*+(4@9%&5%.#?(+43!
4)"80!8(H%+%-!"$%*%!1(+4&%"*!"#!"$%!,41)4+(8%*!#/ !
WKH$GULDWLFUHJLRQDQGKDGQRGLIFXOW\GLVFXVV@
LQJWKHPDV&KULVWLDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOHOHPHQWVLQ
PRVTXHVa#(NUHP+DNN$\YHUGLRQWKHRWKHU
$4+-3! ?%$%1%+"80! #))#*%-! "$(*! (-%4F! 9%! 64*%-!
$ NH\ WR WKH YDVW OLWHUDWXUH RQ WKH VXEMHFW LV 'DMD 6UHNR 0
Y.#B"&&+.#(7+$y$' 2#)' O($+.#(7+$y$' 6.&#+"#&' 2#)' )"%' <"%X"5.P+#(F! N2+(,$K!
2OGHQERXUJ)RUROGHUOLWHUDWXUHLQ(QJOLVKVHHWKHFODVVLFE\
2EROHQVN\ 'LPLWUL T,"' 6.5.0+7&3' (' &$2)R' +#' 6(78(#' #"./0(#+1,("+&0F!
&DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV )RU D GLIIHUHQW RYHUYLHZ RI
"$%! )D%1! 4+-! ("*! *#2&,%*3! *%%! N48,#813! M#%8F! 6.&#+(3' (' &,.%$'
,+&$.%R 1HZ <RUN 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV $ FODVVLF UHIXWDWLRQ RI
WKH%RJRPLOWKHVLVLV)LQH-RKQ9$T,"'6.&#+(#'!,2%1,3'('#"P'
+#$"%*%"$($+.#_'('&$2)R'.B '$,"'6.&#+(#'!,2%1,'(#)'+$&'*7(1"'+#'&$($"'(#)'&.1+"$R'
B%.0' $,"' FH$,' $.' $,"' Fd$,' 1"#$2%+"&N! :#28-%&K! P4*"! P2&#)%4+! u24&"%&803!
)RUWKH%RJRPLOWRPEVDQGWKHYDVWOLWHUDWXUHDERXWWKHP
VHH:HQ]HO0DULDQ%RVQLDQDQG+HUFHJRYLQLDQWRPEVWRQHVZKR
PDGHWKHPDQGZK\LQ6GRVW)RUVFKXQJHQ9ROSS
$ODUJHQXPEHURI %RJRPLOFHPHWHULHVKDYHEHHQSXEOLVKHG
E\HN%HODJLLQWKHULFKSHULRGLFDO1DH6WDULQH6DUDMHYR
HOL'HPDO'RPDHLRULMHQWDOQRS
3DL $PLU A&7(0+1' (%1,+$"1$2%"' +#' 6.&#+(' (#)' <"%1"5.4+#(F! S*"4+628K!
,5&,&$S
,OO7KHJHRJUDSKLFGLVWULEXWLRQRIFDPSDQLOHPLQDUHWVLQ
6RXWKHDVW+HU]HJRYLQD
ED 7KH 3ODLQ RI 3RSRYR LV DV WKH FURZ LHV RQO\ HLJKW NLORPHWUHV
LQODQGIURP'XEURYQLN2YHUWKHGLIFXOWPRXQWDLQURDGKRZHYHU
LWLVNPRUDIXOOGD\VMRXUQH\7RWKHSODFHZKHUHWKHZRUNZDV
-#+%3!N#*"4&3!("!'4*!4!"$&%%!-40*!>#2&+%0!/#&!"$%!O#)#?#!14*"%&*!4+-!
/#2&!-40*!/#&!"$#*%!/!c26&#?+(HF
EE )RUWKHVHWZRGRFXPHQWVFI$KNDP'HIWHULQWKH%DEDNDQON
2VPDQO$ULYL,VWDQEXOS)RUWKHPDVWHUVRI 'XEURYQLNDQG
WKH'DOPDWLDQFRDVWZRUNLQJIRUWKH2WWRPDQVVHH)LNRYL&YLWR
'XEURYDNLSULPRUVNLJUDGLWHOML;,,,;9,VWROMHDX6UELML%RVQLL
+HUFHJRYLQLLQa"%+&$+79ROSSRU=ODWDU%HKLMD
8WMHFDMSULPRUVNLKPDMVWRUDQDL]JUDGQMXQHNLKREMHNDWDL%L+X
RVPDQVNR GRED LQ l#(8.4+' 4%"0"#( 1R KWWSZZZ
LEQVLQDQHW]QDNRYL9UHPHQD",' WHNVW,'
,OO'DEULFDPRVTXHRI6HIHU$DEHIRUHGHVWUXFWLRQLQ
FRXUWHV\RI$PUD+DGLPXKDPHGRYL
63
Location
Nevesinjsko
polje
Donja
Bijenja
Bilea
Bijeljani
Dabarsko polje
Dabrica
Near Stolac
Glavatievo
Konjic district
Hatelj
Kljuni
Dabarsko polje
Nevesinje
district
Kruanj
Korita
10
Kruevljani
11
Mostar
12
Nevesinje
13
Plana
Bilea district
14
Svinjarina
Podvele,
Mostar district
64
Podvele,
Mostar district
Bilea district
Pridvorci,
Nevesinje
district
,OOV&RQWUDVWLQJHFRQRPLHVWKHPRQHWDU\YDOXHRIWKHDJULFXOWXUDO
SURGXFWLRQLQ'DEULFDDQG3UHGROMHLQDQG
EB HOL 'RPDH L RULMHQWDOQR S ZURWH WKDW 0RVWDU RQFH
KDGWKUHHPRVTXHVZLWKFKXUFKWRZHUPLQDUHWVWKH6LQDQ3DLQD
'DPLMDLQ0RVWDUSUREDEO\WKHROGHVWPRVTXHLQWKH+HUFHJRYLQD
WKH PRVTXH RI HMYDQ HKDMD .H\YDQ .HWKGD DQG WKH
0RVTXHRI )DWLPD.DGXQDULIURPWKHUVWGHFDGHVRI WKH"$!
FHQWXU\ 3DL LQ KLV XVHIXO VXUYH\ PHQWLRQV RQH PRUH H[DPSOH
LQWKHYLOODJHRI 2SOLLLQHDUDSOMLQDRQWKHORZHUFRXUVHRI WKH
1HUHWYDDQGDOVRKDVHMYDQHKDMLQDDQG6LQDQ3DVKDPRVTXHVLQ
N#*"4&F!L$%!84""%&3!$#'%?%&3!12*"!6%!4!*8()!#/ !"$%!)%+F!=(+4+!O4*$4J*!
PRVTXH WKH 2OG 0RVTXH RI 0RVWDU ZDV GHPROLVKHG LQ
KRZHYHUJRRGSKRWRJUDSKVRI LWVKRZDVWDQGDUG2WWRPDQPLQDUHW
DVLQWHJUDOSDUWRI WKLVEXLOGLQJHMYDQVPRVTXHVWLOOVWDQGVDQGDOVR
KDVWKHQRUPDO2WWRPDQPLQDUHWDSRO\JRQDOVKDIWRQWKHVTXDUH
64*(*! ;8(+)" 7KH PRVTXH RI )DWLPD .DGXQ DUL LQ 0RVWDU DOVR
PHQWLRQHGE\ERWKHOLDQG3DL,VODPLFDUFKLWHFWXUHS
-(-!(+-%%-!$4?%!4!*Y24&%!,8#,H!"#'%&!1(+4&%"!2+"(8!("!'4*!-%1#8(*$%-!
LQ 6RPH JRRG SKRWRJUDSKV RI LW UHPDLQ SUHVHUYHG )RU
2SOLLL ZH KDYH WR WDNH LQ DFFRXQW WKDW D FKXUFK WRZHU PLQDUHW
FRXOG KDYH H[LVWHG WKHUH ZKLFK ZDV UHSODFHG E\ D QRUPDO RQH
*#1%'$%&%!(+!"$%!%4&80!BD"$!,%+"2&0F!L$(*!(*!'$4"!4,"24880!$4))%+%-!
ZLWKWKHWZRH[DPSOHVRQWKH3RGYHOHSODWHDXRYHUORRNLQJ0RVWDU
%HVLGHV WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ JLYHQ E\ HOL DQG 3DL QXPHURXV
-%"4(8*!,#28-!6%!/#2+-!(+!"$%!'#&H*!#/ !"$%!8#,48!$(*"#&(4+!9(?5(>4!
+DVDQGHGLVHHKLV0XVOLPDQVNDEDWLQDXLVWRQRM+HUFHJRYLQLF!=4&4>%?#K!
(O.DOHP DQG 0XVOLPDQVNDEDWLQD%RQMDNDXMXQRMVUHGQMRM
<"%1"5.4+#+0RVWDU,VODPVNL&HQWDU
! L$%!"0)%!'4*!*"(88!2*%-!60!"$%!L2&,#14+!-0+4*"0!#/ !"$%!AH!U#02+82!
WKDW SUHFHGHG WKH 2WWRPDQV LQ ZKDW LV QRZ 6RXWKHDVW 7XUNH\ ,Q
DUWKLVWRULFDOWHUPVWKLVDUHDZDVRXWVLGHWKHFRUHDUHDRI 2WWRPDQ
4&"h!("!$4-!4+!S*841(,!62(8-(+.!"&4-("(#+!#/ !("*!#'+3!-4"(+.!64,H!"#!
"$%!T14004-!)%&(#-F!7/F!=m5%+3!N%"(+F!'L\DUEDNUGD7UNPLPDULVLF!
,VWDQEXO6LPXUJ
Dabrica
7RGD\DVLQWKHSDVW'DEULFDSRS
(*!#+%!#/ !"$%!84&.%*"!?(884.%*!#/ !"$%!4&%4!6%"'%%+!
WKHWRZQVRI 6WRODFDQG%LOHD,WVWLOOLVDSUHGRPL@
QDQWO\ 0XVOLP VHWWOHPHQW $V WKH FURZ LHV WKH
?(884.%!(*!"%+!H1!+#&"$@+#&"$@%4*"!#/ !="#84,!(+!4!
$(880!4+-!'##-%-!4&%43!62"!1#&%!"$4+!"'%+"0!H1!
#?%&!"$%!?%&0!64-!-F!A8"$#2.$!c46&(,43!&$%+1$.'
&"#&23! (*! +#"! *("24"%-! (+! "$%! c464&*H#! )#8>%3! ("! (*!
-(&%,"80!8(+H%-!'("$!"$(*!-(*"&(,"!"$.$!("*!+41%3!
ZKLFKWUDQVODWHVDV/LWWOH'DEDU'DEULFDLVEH@
OLHYHGWREHWKHVXFFHVVRURI WKHPHGLHYDOIRUWLHG
*%""8%1%+"!#/ !U#]"2+FEC!L$%!&2(+*!#/ !"$(*!*(5%468%!
,4*"8%#,4+!*"(88!6%!*%%+!4"!46#2"!#+%!$#2&J*!'48H@
A!/%'!1#&%!%R41)8%*!4&%!1%+"(#+%-!(+!"$%!8("@
%&4"2&%!62"!"$%0!4))%4&!"#!6%!64*%-!#+!1(*"4H%*FEB!
S/ !"$%!/#2&"%%+!%R41)8%*!#/ !,8#,H!"#'%&@1(+4&%"*!
4&%!)8#""%-!#+!4!14)!;(88F!E<3!'%!*%%!"$4"!"$%0!4&%!
/#2+-!#?%&!4!&%84"(?%80!84&.%!4&%4!(+!"$%!*#2"$%&+!
KDOI RI WKH+HU]HJRYLQDZLWK*ODYDWLHYRQHDU
.RQMLFDVWKHQRUWKHUQPRVWSRLQWDQG%LOHDDW
"$%! N#+"%+%.&(+! 6#&-%&! 4*! "$%! *#2"$%&+1#*"F!
[%! ,4+! 6%! *2&%! "$4"! 14+0! 1#&%! #+,%! %R(*"%-3!
%*)%,(4880! (+! "$%! )84(+! #/ ! M%?%*(+>%! '$%&%3! 60!
DOPRVWDOOYLOODJHVZHUH0XVOLPFILOO
4+-! 12*"! $4?%! $4-! $#2*%*! #/ ! '#&*$()F! c2%! "#!
&%4*#+*! -%*,&(6%-! 46#?%3! 4+-! 4+! %R"%+"! #/ ! -%@
*"&2,"(#+! "$4"! (*! $4&-! "#! %*"(14"%3! %R4,"80! $#'!
'(-%*)&%4-! "$%! *Y24&%! 1(+4&%"*! )$%+#1%+#+!
4,"24880!'4*!12*"!&%14(+!2+,8%4&F
7KH FODVVLFDO 2WWRPDQ PLQDUHW KDV D VOHQGHU
URXQGRUSRO\JRQDOVKDIWQHYHUDVTXDUHRQH2QO\
(+!*#2"$@%4*"%&+!A+4"#8(43!(+!(1)#&"4+"!,("(%*!8(H%!
'L\DUEDNUDUHVXFKFDVHVNQRZQIURP8PD\\DG
"(1%*! #+'4&-F! S+! "$%! :48H4+*3! #2"*(-%! :#*+(4@
9%&5%.#?(+43! "$%&%! (*! #+80! #+%! *Y24&%! 1(+4&%"!
NQRZQ WKDW RI WKH 2OG 0RVTXH RI <DPERO RQ
WKHULYHU7XQGDLQ%XOJDULDQ7KUDFH7KHIRUP
65
66
! L$%! ,4*"8%! #/ ! U#]"2+! (*! BED! 1F! 8#+.! 4+-! CD! 1F! '(-%F! L$%! '488*!
4+-! *(R! "#'%&*! 4&%! *"(88! *"4+-(+.! "#! "$%! $%(.$"! #/ ! *(R! 1%"%&*F! =%%!
.UHHYOMDNRYL+DPGLMDDQG+DPGLMD.DSLGL6WDULKHUFHJRYDNL
JUDGRYLLQ1DH6WDULQH9ROSSFLWS
Eb 7KH UHJLVWHU LV SUHVHUYHG LQ WKH $WDWUN .LWDSO %HOHGL\H
.WSKDQHVL 0XDOOLP &HYGHW <D]PDODU 2 ,W ZDV LQWHJUDOO\
SXEOLVKHGLQD6HUER&URDWWUDQVODWLRQE\$KPHG6$OLLDVU20(%#+'
SRSLV VDQGDND %RVQD L] JRGLQHF! N#*"4&K! S*841*H(! U28"2&+(!
7%+"4&3!BDDaF
Ea 7DSX 'HIWHU 1R LQ WKH %DEDNDQON 2VPDQO $ULYL %2$
,VWDQEXOSIRU'DEULFDSIRU3UHGROMH
-LUHHN.RQVWDQWLQW+"'<(#)"7&&$%(&&"#'2#)'6"%5P"%8"'4.#'U"%:+"#'2#)'
6.&#+"#' Py,%"#)' )"&' ;+$$"7(7$"%&F! O&4.2%K! :m$1(*,$%! V%*%88*,$4/"! -%&!
:LVVHQVFKDIWHQS
BD 7'S
$#2*%$#8-*!(+!c46&(,43!"$%!7$&(*"(4+*J!(+,&%4*(+.!
"#!*%?%+"%%+FBE#
,Q RU 6HIHU $D %HJRYL
62(8"!(+!c46&(,4!4!Z!/#&!8#,48!*"4+-4&-*!Z!*(5%468%!
PRVTXH LOOV DQNHG ZLWK D W\SLFDO FORFN
WRZHU RU FDPSDQLOH PLQDUHW 7KH FRQIXVLRQ
#?%&! ("*! -4"%! (*! -2%! "#! "$%! /#88#'(+.! *("24"(#+K!
46#?%! "$%! %+"&4+,%! #/ ! "$%! 1#*Y2%! '4*! 4+! (+@
VFULSWLRQLQ$UDELFFDUYHGRQWRDVWRQHVODE
[FPZKLFKLQIRXUOLQHVSUDLVHGWKHEXLOGHU
S"!.4?%!"$%!-4"%!#/ !,#+*"&2,"(#+!(+!"$%!/#&1!#/ !
4!,$&#+#.&41!Z! PDEHGODEUkUZDGkUOVkOLKvQ! Z!
ZKLFK \LHOGV WKH GDWH RI + $'
L$%!"%R"!(*!#/ !$(.$!,488(.&4)$(,!Y248("0h!8#,48!8#&%!
$#8-*!"$4"!("!4,"24880!'4*!'&(""%+!(+!S*"4+628!4+-!
*%+"!/!"$%&%!"#!c46&(,43!'$%&%!("!12*"!$4?%!
6%%+! 2*%-! 4*! 4! 1(7]2"! 60! "$%! 8#,48! *"#+%@,2""%&F!
L$(*!(1)8(%*!"$4"!"$%&%!'4*!+#!*H(88%-!,488(.&4)$%&!
(+!c46&(,4!#&!("*!-(*"&(,"F!:%8#'!"$%!"%R"!4+#"$%&!
-4"%!(*!.(?%+3!+#"!(+!4!,$&#+#.&41!62"!(+!+21@
EHUV+WKDWLVEHWZHHQ0DUFKDQG
0DUFK$',QP\RSLQLRQWKHVODELVWKH
'#&H!#/ !4!$48/@(.+#&4+"!*"#+%!,2""%&!'$#!4--%-!
"$%! -4"%! (+! +216%&*! 4*! 4! H(+-! #/ ! 4/"%&"$#2.$"3!
'$(8%!2*(+.!4!*"%+,(8!/#&!"$%!&%*"!#/ !"$%!"%R"F!L$%!
"%R"! (*! "##! .##-! "#! 6%8(%?%! #"$%&'(*%F! L$%! /4,"!
WKDW E\ WKH PLG"$! ,%+"2&0! 1#&%! "$4+! $48/ !
#/ ! "$%! ?(884.%! )#)284"(#+! '4*! N2*8(1! ;,/F! (88F!
BD<! '#28-! 48*#! *2))#&"! 4+! %4&8(%&! -4"%! /#&! "$%!
1#*Y2%J*!,#+*"&2,"(#+F
6HIHU $D PXVW KDYH KDG VRPH SUHWHQVLRQV
9(*! "("8%! *2..%*"*! "$4"! $%! '4*! 4! 1(8("4&0! 14+3! 4!
BB! L$%! "%R"! #/ ! "$%! (+*,&()"(#+! #/ ! "$%! 1#*Y2%! 4+-! *#1%! #/ ! "$%! #8-!
JUDYHVWRQHVZHUHSXEOLVKHGE\0HKPHG0XMH]LQRYLLQKLVA&7(0&8"'
HSLJUDND X %RVQL L +HUFHJRYLQL 9RO 6DUDMHYR 9HVHOLQ 0DVOHD
SS
,#+*"&2,"%-!60!'40!#/ !,#1)4&(*#+F!S+!E`bb!"$%!
"#"48!"4R!?482%!#/ !"$%!14(+!)&#-2,"*!#/ !c46&(,4!
ZKHDW EDUOH\ PLOOHW DQG RDWV ZDV DNoHF!
L$%*%! )&#-2,"*J! %,#+#1(,! (1)#&"4+,%! /#&! "$%!
?(884.%! %,#+#10! ,4+! %4*(80! 6%! *%%+! (+! "$%! "#"48!
"4R!?482%J*!)%&,%+"4.%F!S"!*$#28-!6%!&%1%16%&%-!
"$4"!(+!14+0!$2+-&%-*!#/ !?(884.%*!(+!"$%!/%&"(8%!
)84(+*! #/ ! N4,%-#+(43! L$%**4803! L$&4,%3! 4+-!
c4+26(4+! :28.4&(43! '$%4"! 4+-! 64&8%0! "#.%"$%&!
RIWHQDFFRXQWHGIRURURI WKHWRWDOZLWK
*$%%)!4+-!'(+%!14H(+.!2)!"$%!628H!#/ !"$%!&%*"!
#/ !"$%!%,#+#10F!9%&%3!(+!-&0!4+-!*"#+0!*#2"$%&+!
9%&5%.#?(+43! '$%4"! '4*! #+80! "$(&"%%+! )%&,%+"!
#/ !"$%!"#"483!'$(8%!64&8%0!'4*!/#2&"%%+!)%&,%+"F!
S+/%&(#&!,%&%48*!8(H%!1(88%"!4+-!#4"*!14-%!2)!"%+!
)%&,%+"!"#.%"$%&F!L$%!)&#-2,"*!"$4"!*2*"4(+%-!"$%!
HFRQRP\ZHUHJUDSHPXVWFRPSULVLQJIRO@
8#'%-!60!*$%%)!4"!/#2&"%%+!)%&,%+"3!4+-!$#+%03!
ZLWKVL[SHUFHQWOOLQJWKHJDS7KXVZLQHDQG
*$%%)!'%&%!"$%!)(884&*!#/ !"$%!c46&(,4!%,#+#10F!
A!"4R!#/ !`DC!DNoHZDVWDNHQDVFXVWRPDU\VKHHS
WD[7KLVPHDQVDWRWDORI KHDGVRI VKHHS
9HU\RIWHQWKHJUHDW2WWRPDQSRSXODWLRQDQGODQGUHJLVWUDWLRQVDUH
)&%,%-%-!60!*2&?%0*!#/ !"$%!8#,48!84'*!4+-!&28%*3!2*24880!(+,82-(+.!
"$%! &%84"(#+! #/ ! "$%! 8#,48! 1%4*2&%! "#! S*"4+628J*! 62*$%8F! G#&! "$%!
9%&5%.#?(+4! "$(*! (+/#&14"(#+! '4*! +#"! 4?4(8468%! "#! 2*F! A! -%"4(8%-!
8(#2##`0"!/!ECaC!%R(*"*!62"!("!-#%*!+#"!1%+"(#+!"$%!*(5%!#/ !"$%!
8#,48!1%4*2&%*F!S!$4?%!,#1)4&%-!c464&J*!4.&(,28"2&48!0(%8-!'("$!"$4"!
#/ !"'#!#"$%&!-(*"&(,"*!'("$!4!*(1(84&!,8(14"%!4+-!"$%!*41%!1%-(#,&%!
*#(8K!"$%!/#&1%&!8(X(RI $WKHQV$WWLFDDQGWKHLVODQGRI (ULER]
P26#(4F! L$%! 8(X( RI $WKHQV FRQWDLQHG WKH &LW\ RI WKH 6DJHV
4+-! CC! ?(884.%*! #/ ! ?4&(#2*! *(5%*F! L$%! (*84+-! #/ ! P26#(4! ,#+"4(+%-!
WKHWRZQRI &KDONLVDQGLQYLOODJHV7KHORDG,+07<!#/ !
$WWLFDDQG(ULER]ZDVWKHHTXLYDOHQWRI NLORJUDPV,QWKH
SULFHRI DORDGRI ZKHDWLQ(ULER]ZDVDNoH3!(+!c464&!B`!DNoHF!
7KHORDGXVHGLQ'DEDUZDVWKXVDURXQGRQHIWKOLJKWHUWKDQWKH
ORDGRQ(XERLDFDOFXODWLQJWRDERXWNJ7KHSULFHRI DORDGRI
A""(,4+!64&8%0!#&!1(88%"!'4*!BD!DNoHLQ'DEDUIWHHQDQGWKDWRI WKH
(+/%&(#&!.&4(+!R27(B!;#4"*<!'4*!+(+%!DNoHF![(+%!'4*!"4R%-!4*!12*"!#/ !
,&2*$%-!.&4)%*!;LUH<!4+-!"$%!)&(,%!)%&!0")%"ZDVQHDNoH,Q
"$%!)&(,%!#/ !4!0")%"'LQ$WKHQVDQG(ULER]ZDVWHQDNoH3!(+!c464&!
QHDNoH7KHZHLJKWRI DQ(ULER]0")%"!'4*!bD!H.F!L$2*3!"$%!c46&4!
0")%"PXVWKDYHEHHQDERXWNJ,QWKH"$!,%+"2&0!#+%!AHp%!)%&!
WKUHHVKHHSZDVWDNHQDVWD[2QHDNoH'4*!"4H%+!/#&!#+%!)(.!/4""%+%-!
4"!$#1%3!4+-!$48/ !4+!DNoH/#&!4+!4+(148!)(+.!4+-!/&%%F!L'#!
DNoHZHUHWDNHQIRUDVKHDI RI D[DQGRQHIRUHDFKEHHKLYH7KH
8(#2##`0"! #/ ! "$%! )&#?(+,%! #/ ! 9%&*%H! /! ECaC! ;)268(*$%-! 60!
AH.o+-o5<!*"4"%*!"$4"!"$%!"("$%!#+!.&4)%!12*"!'4*!#+%!*%?%+"$!/#&!
7$&(*"(4+!)&#-2,%&*!4+-!#+%!%(.$"$!/#&!N2*8(1*F![%!$4?%!"#!4**21%!
"$4"!(+!E`bb!"$(*!&28%!'4*!48*#!(+!/#&,%F![("$!"$(*!H+#'8%-.%!'%!,4+!
+#'!?%+"2&%!"#!&%,#+*"&2,"!"$%!?(884.%!%,#+#10!#/ !"$%!c464&*H#!
O#8>%3!&%1%16%&(+.3!$#'%?%&3!"$4"!"$(*!(*!62"!4!.$!%*"(14"%F
,4)"4(+3!'("$!4!.##-!%-2,4"(#+F!A,,#&-(+.!"#!8#,48!
8#&%3!$%!,41%!/!A+4"#8(4!4+-!*%""8%-!(+!c46@
&(,4F!9(*!-%*,%+-4+"*!*"(88!8(?%!(+!c46&(,4!"#-403!
4+-!4!+216%&!#/ !"$%1!4&%!62&(%-!(+!"$%!1#*Y2%J*!
.&4?%04&-FBB1H[WWRWKHPRVTXH6HIHU$DKDG
,#+*"&2,"%-! 4! *1488! ,(0(03! 4! ,(#! /#&! "&4?%88%&*3!
4+-! 4! 0"8$":! /#&! "$%! %-2,4"(#+! #/ ! "$%! ,$(8-&%+F!
L#.%"$%&!"$%0!,#+*"("2"%!#+%!#/ !"$%!NOOL\HV62(8"!
E\2WWRPDQVLQWKLVDUHD7KHRWKHUEXLOGLQJVGR
+#"!%R(*"!4+01#&%h!"$%0!'%&%!-%1#8(*$%-!-2&(+.!
::,7KHQDPH+DQLQHVWLOOPDUNVWKHSODFH
'$%&%!"$%!,(#!#+,%!*"##-3!4+-!"$%!,(0(0J*!*("%!
(*! 48*#! &%1%16%&%-! 8#,4880F! 9#'%?%&! 2+2*2483!
"$%! 1#*Y2%! 1#&%! ,8#*%80! /#88#'*! "$%! #&"$#-#R!
2WWRPDQVW\OHWKDQRWKHUH[DPSOHVLQWKHDUHD
L$%!/#2&@,%+"&%-!4&,$%*!46#?%!"$%!'(+-#'*3!/#&!
LQVWDQFHDUHSXUHO\2WWRPDQ/RFDOHOHPHQWVLQ@
,82-%!"$%!)0&41(-@*$4)%-!'##-%+!&##/3!,#?%&%-!
'("$!$%4?0!*"#+%!*846*3!&$#16(,!*84"%*!(+!"$%!*)%@
FLF+HU]HJRYLQDQPDQQHUIROORZLQJWKHPRUH
*"4"%80!62(8-(+.*!#/ !N#*"4&F
L$%! -%"4(8%-! 02B(&&(7! &%.(*"%&*! #/ ! E`bb! 4+-!
ECaC!)&#?(-%!2*!'("$!*#1%!(+/#&14"(#+!#+!"$%!
%,#+#1(%*! #/ ! c46&(,4! 4+-! "$%! ?(884.%*! #/ ! "$%!
c464&*H#!)#8>%F!L$%0!8(*"!"$%!"("$%!#+!"$%!14(+!
4.&(,28"2&48! )&#-2,"*! ?(884.%! 60! ?(884.%! 4+-! "$%!
DYHUDJH[HGSULFHV#(%,<!)%&!)&#-2,"F!L$%!1%4@
*2&%*! 2*%-! '%&%! "$%! 8#,48! #+%*3! "$%! &%84"(#+! #/ !
ZKLFK WR WKH ,PSHULDO %XVKHO RI ,VWDQEXO
H.F<!(*!+#"!H+#'+3!62"!,4+!6%!$0)#"$%"(,4880!&%@
67
68
B` ,Q WKLV FRQWH[W LW LV JRRG WR UHPHPEHU WKDW GXULQJ WKH V WKH
4?%&4.%! /41(80! #/ ! 1#2+"4(+! +#14-*! (+! %4*"%&+! L2&H%0! ,#28-! 8(?%!
IURP VKHHS &I +WWHURWK :ROI'LHWHU 6"%5#.0()"#' 2#)'
r(R7(:(2"%#' +0' 0+$$7"%"#' 82%)+&1,"#' T(2%2&F! N4&62&.K! V%#.&F! S+*"F! -F!
8QLY'XULQJDQLQWHUYLHZZLWK8OOD-RKDQVHQWKHRWKHUJUHDW
H[SHUW RQ <D\OD HFRQRP\ 3URI -RKDQVHQ VXJJHVWHG VKHHS DV
1(+(121F!O%4*4+"*!$4?(+.!+#!1#&%!"$4+!CD!4+(148*!'%&%!&%4880!?%&0!
SRRU7KHVDPHZDVWROGXVLQE\QRPDGVRQWKH7LHQ6KDQ
1#2+"4(+*!(+!,%+"&48!U0&.05*"4+F
BC! (YOL\D dHOHEL 6H\DKDWQkPHVL 9RO (GV <FHO 'DO DQG 6H\LW $OL
.DKUDPDQ,VWDQEXO<DS.UHGL<D\QODUS
! S"!4))%4&*!*#1%'$4"!(&#+(,48!"$4"!"$%!%,#+#1(,!64*(*!#/ !"$%!S*841(,!
,28"2&48!(+*"("2"(#+*!(+!"$(*!)4&"!#/ !"$%!%1)(&%!'4*!/#&1%-!60!'(+%3!
FDOOHGJUDSHMXLFHLUH<!(+!"$%!&%,#&-*3!62"!(+!/4,"!"$(*!(*!.&%%+!'(+%F!
V&4)%! >2(,%! ,4++#"! 6%! H%)"! 8#+.%&! "$4+! 4! /%'! '%%H*F! L$(*! (*! >2*"!
DQRWKHUH[DPSOHRI WKHROG2WWRPDQVWDWHVSUDJPDWLVP
Bb! S"! ,#28-! 6%! 4--%-! "$4"! 4+! %R)%&(%+,%-! 14+! 4+-! .&%4"! "&4?%88%&! 4*!
(YOL\DdHOHELH[WROOHGWKHVXSHUETXDOLW\RI 3UHGROMHVPXVNVPHOOLQJ
>2(,0!.&4)%*!4+-!"$%!-%8(,(#2*!'(+%!"$4"!,#28-!6%!14-%!/!"$%1F
Ba! L$%! %?%+"! 14-%! 4! -%%)! (1)&%**(#+! #+! "$%! )%#)8%F! O#)284&! *#+.*!
&%,#&-(+.! "$%! %?%+"! '%&%! *"(88! *2+.! 4"! "$%! 6%.(++(+.! #/ ! "$%! BD"$!
FHQWXU\6HHDOVR6WRHYL6W%DMR3LYOMDQLQL/LPRY+DUDPEDD
SDODGDPLMXX3UHGROMXLQ6.&(#&8('4+7(1RSS
1#*Y2%!'4*!-%1#8(*$%-F!S"!'4*!&%62(8"!(+!%R4,"80!
WKHVDPHVL]HDQGIRUPLQWKHVE\$KPHG
=HR$VDUHVXOW RI WKH ::,, YLROHQFH LQ WKH
c464&*H#!)#8>%3!"$%!1#*Y2%!'4*!64-80!-414.%-F!
L$%!&##/ !,#884)*%-!4+-!#+80!"$%!/#2&!'488*!4+-!
"$%! ,2&(#2*! 1(+4&%"! &%14(+%-F! A*! "$%! N2*8(1!
(+$46("4+"*!'%&%!481#*"!.#+%3!"$%&%!'4*!+#!+%%-!
WRUHEXLOGWKHROGPRVTXH,Q%LMHOMDQLKDG
RQO\WZR0XVOLPLQKDELWDQWVDQG6HUEV
,Q $PLU 3DL SXEOLVKHG D SKRWRJUDSK
RI %LMHOMDQLVPRVTXHLOOWDNHQDERXW\HDUV
HDUOLHU 2Q D YLVLW LQ -XO\ , UHGLVFRYHUHG
"$%! 62(8-(+.3! '("$! "$%! $%8)! #/ ! :(>%8>4+(J*! (+$46@
("4+"*3! 4"! "$%! ?(884.%J*! *#2"$%&+! %R"&%1("03! 6%8#'!
"$%! 14(+! -! 4+-! 6%0#+-! "$%! ?(884.%J*! 84*"! 2+@
(+$46("%-!$#2*%*!4+-!64&+*F!L$%!*("%!'4*!"#"4880!
RYHUJURZQZLWKLY\DQGSULFNO\VKUXEV2QO\WKH
(7"0!#+!"#)!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"!*"(88!4))%4&%-!46#?%!
"$%!8%4?%*F!=%,"(#+*!#/ !"$%!'488*!2)!"#!/#2&!1%@
"&%*!$(.$!48*#!8##H%-!"$.$!"$%!.&%%+%&0F!L$(*!
1#*Y2%J*! &%14(+*! $4?%! *2&?(?%-! "$%! *0*"%14"(,!
-%*"&2,"(#+!#/ !488!"&4,%*!#/ !"$%!4&%4J*!S*841(,!)4*"!
60! +4"(#+48(*"! 64+-*F! L$%! :(>%8>4+(! 1#*Y2%! '4*!
*(1)80!/#&.#""%+!60!"$%13!62"!("!'4*!+#"!/#&.#"@
"%+! 60! "$%! ?(884.%J*! =%&6! (+$46("4+"*3! '$#! '%&%!
?%&0! /&(%+-80! 4+-! $%8)/28! (+! .2(-(+.! 1%! "#! "$(*!
UDUHVSHFLPHQRI ,VODPLFDUFKLWHFWXUH
Hatelj
69
12,$!84"%&F!L$%!1#*Y2%!#/ !94"%8>3!4*!-%*,&(6%-!
E\+DVDQGHGLZDVDUHFWDQJXODUVWUXFWXUHPHD@
*2&(+.!a!R!b!1%"&%*F!S"!'4*!,#?%&%-!'("$!"$%!2*248!
9%&5%.#?(+(4+! )0&41(-! &##/ ! #/ ! .&%4"! &$#16(,!
*84"%*3!4+-!$4-!4!*Y24&%!*"#+%@62(8"!1(+4&%"!46#2"!
"%+! 1%"&%*! $(.$F! S"! 12*"! $4?%! 8##H%-! *(1(84&!
WR WKH PRVTXH RI +DVDQ 3DVKD LQ %LOHD VHH
6%8#'<3!62"!(*!8(H%80!"#!$4?%!6%%+!62(8"!4"!4!84"%&!
)#(+"!(+!"(1%3!)ﲨ!"$%!%4&80!Eb"$!,%+"2&03!4+-!
WKXVDURXQGWKHWLPHWKHPRVTXHLQ3ODQD
'4*! 62(8"F! L$%! 94"%8>! 1#*Y2%J*! /4"%! '4*! -(//%&@
%+"! /! #"$%&! 1#*Y2%*! (+! "$%! 4&%43! $#'%?%&F!
'XULQJ WKH "$! ,%+"2&0J*! '4&*! 4+-! &%?#8"*3! "$%!
1#*Y2%! '4*! -414.%-! 62"! +#"! -%*"�%-F! A/"%&!
Eaba3!"$%!A2*"&#@92+.4&(4+*!2*%-!("!4*!4!*"4"(#+!
/#&! "$%! .%+-4&1%&(%F! G#88#'(+.! [[S3! "$%! 94"@
%8>! 1#*Y2%! '4*! '$#880! &%62(8"3! 62"! ("! '4*! 4.4(+!
-414.%-!(+![[SSF!O#*"@[[SS3!"$%!1#*Y2%!'4*!
2*%-! 4*! )&(14&0! *,$##8! /#&! "$%! ?(884.%F! S"! '4*!
QDOO\ GHPROLVKHG LQ 7KLV VXJJHVWV WKDW
"$%!N2*8(1!,#112+("0!#/ !94"%8>!$4-!?4+(*$%-!
60! "$%+3! )&%*214680! 4! &%*28"! #/ ! "$%! (+"%&%"$+(,!
?(#8%+,%!-2&(+.![[SSF
Plana
70
)RU WKH LQVFULSWLRQ VHH 0XMH]LQRYL ,VODPVND HSLJUDND 9RO S
$QDFFRXQWIURPPHQWLRQVWKUHHSHRSOHIURP3ODQDDPRWKHU
RI \HDUV ZLWK WZR FKLOGUHQ RI WHQ DQG HLJKW \HDUV ROG VROG DW
WKH VODYH PDUNHW RI 9HQLFH &I 6RORYMHY $OHNVDQGDU 7UJRYDQMH
ERVDQVNLP UREOMHP GR JRGLQH LQ f7(&#+8' X"0(7V&8.5' 02X"V('
>1HZVHULHV@9ROSS3ODQDRQS
)RUPRUHRQ3ODQDVHH$YGLDPLO3ODQDNRG%LOHDLQO.4+'
6",(U9RO1RSDOVR,QWHUHVDQWQDGDPLMDNRG
3ODQHLQU7.:.)('>0RVWDU@1RS
! _%.#3!O(&"7V(3'))F!EE@B!'("$!/2&"$%&!&%/%&%+,%*F
6%.1RSYY&I+DVDQGHGL0XVOLPDQVNDEDWLQDXLVWRQRM
<"%1"5.4+#+ SS DQG %DDJL 6DIYHWEHJ l#(0"#+$+' <%4($+M'
%RQMDFLL+HUFHJRYFLX7XUVNRMFDUHYLQL=DJUHE%LURWLVNDN>@
SIRU$OL.D
! (YOL\D dHOHEL 6H\DKDWQkPHVL 9RO S +DVDQGHGL ;2&7+0(#&8('
EDWLQDXLVWRQRM+HUFHJRYLQLSS
71
S+!EabC!M%?%*(+>%!'4*!#,,2)(%-!60!&%6%88(#2*!
N#+"%+%.&(+*!4+-!84&.%80!62&+"!-#'+F!L$&%%!#/ !
"$%!1#*Y2%*!'%&%!48*#!62&+"F!_%8(o--(+J*!1#*Y2%!
'4*!&%)4(&%-!(+!EaaD3!62"!"$%!"#)!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"!
'4*!,$4+.%-F!S"!.#"!+#!HUHIH!62"!4!,#+(,48!,4)!4+-!
#)%+(+.*! (+! "$%! *$4/"! &%1(+(*,%+"! #/ ! "$%! ,41@
)4+(8%! 1(+4&%"*! #/ ! "$%! %4&8(%&! 4.%F! L$%! 1#*Y2%!
*%&?%-! 2+"(8! "$%! 0%4&*! 6%"'%%+! "$%! "'#! [#&8-!
[4&*!4+-!'4*!"$%+!2*%-!4!-%)#"F!L$%!1#*Y2%!#/ !
=(+4+!c%-%!'4*!48*#!62&+"!-#'+!(+!EabCF!S"!'4*!
UHVWRUHGLQDQGGHQLWLYHO\FORVHGLQ
,Q+DVDQGHGLRQO\VDZWKHIRXUZDOOVVWLOO
VWDQGLQJ 'XULQJ WKH ZDU WKH PRVTXH
#/ !=28"4+!:40%5(-3!"$%!#+80!#+%!*"(88!4,"(?%3!'4*!
-0+41("%-F!S+!BDDa!S!/#2+-!("*!-%6&(*!4"!4!-21)!
#/ !62(8-(+.!14"%&(483!%(.$"!H1!+#&"$!#/ !"$%!"#'+3!
#+!"$%!-!"#!O&(-?#&,(!4+-!O&%]%H4F!_%8(o--(+J*!
1#*Y2%! *2//%&%-! "$%! *41%! /4"%! 4*! "$%! *28"4+(,!
62(8-(+.F!S"*!*("%!(*!+#'!#,,2)(%-!60!4!)4&H(+.!8#"F!
2QO\WKHUXLQRI 6LQDQ'HGHVPRVTXHKDVVXU@
?(?%-F!S+!BDDa!("!'4*!(+!,#2&*%!#/ !&%62(8-(+.3!4+-!
$4-!4.4(+!4!-##&3!'(+-#'*3!4+-!4!+%'!'##-%+!
FHLOLQJ7KHIRXUZDOOVDQGWKHLUVSHFLFDOO\2W@
WRPDQ ZLQGRZV VKRZ WKDW LW LV D "$! ,%+"2&0!
62(8-(+.F
72
Kru evljane
L$%!*1488!4+-!*,4""%&%-!?(884.%!#/ !U&2]%?8>4+%!
LQ0XVOLPDQGWKUHH5RPDQ&DWKROLF
$#2*%$#8-*<3! (*! *("24"%-! #+! *8#)(+.! .+-! 4"!
M%?%*(+>*H#! )#8>%J*! +#&"$%&+! %+-3! "'%+"0! H1!
,OO.UXHYOMDQHLQVFULSWLRQRQPRVTXHDIWHUUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQFODLPLQJDGDWHRIFRQVWUXFWLRQDURXQG
/! "$%! "#'+! 4+-! 4"! 4! *("%! 4*! 6%42"(/28! 4*! "$%!
'#&8-!#+!"$%!-40!#/ !,&%4"(#+F!L$%!#,,4*(#+48!?(*(@
"#&!.%"*!"$%!/%%8(+.!"$4"!"$%!'#&8-!48*#!%+-*!$%&%F!
L$%&%!(*!+#!-!'$4"*#%?%&!#?%&!"$%!1#2+"4(+*!
"#! "$%! -(*"&(,"*! +#&"$! 4+-! %4*"F! A! 6("! 46#?%! "$%!
84*"!$#2*%*!#/ !U&2]%?8>4+%3!*2&+-%-!60!,%+@
"2&(%*!#8-!"&%%*3!(*!"$%!1#*Y2%!;(88F!ED<F!L$(*!(*!4!
UHFWDQJOHRI [PHWUHVZLWKZDOOVEXLOW
#/ ! +%4"80! ,2"3! .##-! Y248("0! 4*$84&3! bD! ,1! "$(,HF!
L$%!1(+4&%"!1%4*2&%*!"'#!1%"&%*!(+!*Y24&%!4+-!
&%4,$%*!4!$%(.$"!#/ !"%+!1%"&%*F!L$%&%!4&%!+#!-%,@
#&4"(?%!%8%1%+"*!4"!4883!62"!"$%!62(8-(+.J*!*%""(+.!
14H%*!2)!/#&!"$%!1(**(+.!4&,$("%,"2&48!Y248("(%*F!
S"!(*!?(*(68%!/!1(8%*!4'40F
A! "468%! .(?(+.! "$%! +216%&! #/ ! ?(884.%! $#2*%@
$#8-*! )&#?(-%*! 4+! (+-(,4"(#+! ,#+,%&+(+.! '$%+!
"$%!#&(.(+48!1#*Y2%!12*"!$4?%!6%%+!62(8"F!S+!"$%!
UVW\HDUVRI WKH2WWRPDQSHULRGQRWDVLQJOH
0XVOLPOLYHGLQWKHYLOODJH,QRQHTXDUWHU
#/ ! "$%! )#)284"(#+! '4*! N2*8(13! 4+-! (+! ECaC! 488!
#/ !"$%!?(884.%J*!&%*(-%+"*!'%&%!N2*8(13!+#!7$&(*@
"(4+!&%14(+(+.F!A&.2(+.!(+!8(.$"!#/ !"$(*!-4"43!"$%!
1#*Y2%! 12*"! $4?%! 6%%+! /#2+-%-! 4+-! "$%!
EC`D*F!L#!"$(*!-4"%!48*#!)#(+"*!"$%!1#*Y2%J*!#&(@
%+"4"(#+!"#'4&-*!N%,,4!4"!E`DJJ!#/ !"$%!,#1)4**3!
#&!=#2"$@=#2"$@P4*"3!'$(,$!(*!+#"!,#&&%,"F!A"!"$%!
HQGRI WKH"$!,%+"2&0!4!-%?(,%!'4*!-%?%8#)%-!
.(?(+.!"$%!,#&&%,"!#&(%+"4"(#+F!L$%!62(8-(+.!12*"!
WKXVEHIURPEHIRUH$WWKHVDPHWLPHWKHVH
+216%&*!(882*"&4"%!"$%!?%&0!8(1("%-!)#**(6(8("0!/#&!
4.&(,28"2&%!(+!"$(*!&%.(#+3!'$(,$!,#28-!+#"!*2)@
)#&"!1#&%!"$4+!1#&%!"$4+!BDD@BCD!)%#)8%F!A/"%&!
WKH SHDN RI WKH YLOODJH JUDYLWDWHG DURXQG
KRXVHKROGVXQWLOPRUHDGYDQFHGDJULFXOWXUDO
1%"$#-*!14-%!4!*8(.$"!(+,&%4*%!)#**(68%F!
Table 2: population of the village of
Kruevljane (in households)
1477
Musl.
Chr.
0
25
Total: 25
Muslim: 0%
1499
Musl.
Chr.
0
25
Total: 25
Muslim: 0%
1519
Musl.
Chr.
13
36
Total: 49
Muslim: 26%
"4H(+.!(+"#!4,,#2+"!"$4"!#2&!)#)284"(#+!+216%&*!
"4H%!6#"$!*(*"%&!?(884.%*!"#.%"$%&3!"$(*!1%4+*!"$4"!
#2&! 1#*Y2%! ,#28-! 4,,#11#-4"%! 4883! #&! 481#*"!
4883!'#&*$())%&*!-2&(+.!G&(-40!)&40%&*!4+-!"$#*%!
4,,#1)4+0(+.!"$%!.&%4"!/%4*"*F
1585
Musl.
Chr.
31
0
Total: 31
Muslim: 100%
1910
Musl.
Chr.
28
2
Total: 30
Muslim: 93%
1991
Musl.
Chr.
33
3
Total: 46
Muslim: 91%
$VHFRQGH[DPSOHRI DFDPSDQLOHPLQDUHW
PRVTXHV WRWDO UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ LV WKH HOHEL RU
6XUNRYL GDPLMD RI 'RQMD %LMHQMD LOO WR
U&2]%?8>4+%J*! *#2"$F! L$(*! 1#*Y2%! *"4+-*! #+!
4! *"%%)! *8#)%! 46#?%! "$%! )84(+J*! %-.%! 4+-3! 8(H%!
U&2]%?84+%3! (*! ?(*(68%! /! 1(8%*! 4'40F! L$%!
EXLOGLQJLVVPDOODVTXDUHRI [PHWUHV
'("$!"$%!1(+4&%"!#+!"$%!%+"&4+,%J*!&(.$"!*(-%F!L$%!
1#*Y2%!$4*!'(+-#'*!#+80!(+!"$%!0+,%(:!'488!4+-!
(+!"$%!&(.$"!84"%&48!'488F!L$%!8%/"!*(-%!'488!(*!68(+-!
6%,42*%!#/ !"$%!*"%%)!*8#)%!#+!'$(,$!"$%!1#*Y2%!
*"4+-*F! S"! (*! 62(8-! #/ ! "$%! *41%! Y248("0! '$("%3!
QHJUDLQHGDVKODUDV.UXHYOMDQH7KHPLQDUHW
(*! *8(.$"80! *1488%&! "$4+! "$4"! 4"! U&2]%?8>4+%3! 62"!
"$4+H*! "#! "$%! 84&.%! #)%+! )#&,$3! "$%! 1#*Y2%!
+%?%&"$%8%**! 14H%*! 4! 1#+21%+"48! (1)&%**(#+F!
L$%!(++%&!*)4,%!#/ !CC!*Y24&%!1%"&%*!,4+!$#2*%!
ZRUVKLSSHUV$VWKHYLOODJHRI *RUQMD%L@
MHQMD8SSHU%LMHQMDKDGLWVRZQPRVTXHDQG
`D 0RVW0XVOLPLQKDELWDQWVUHWXUQHGWRWKHLUQDWLYHKRPHVLQDQG
BDDbF!L$%!"$&%%!74"$#8(,!$#2*%$#8-*!#/ !U&2]%?8>4+%!-(-!+#"!&%"2&+F!
L$%(&!8(""8%!,$2&,$3!4!6("!#2"*(-%!"$%!?(884.%3!&%14(+%-!2+"#2,$%-F
A,,#&-(+.!"#!8#,48!"&4-("(#+3!"$%!1#*Y2%!'4*!
EXLOW E\ WKH HOHEL RU 6XUNRYL IDPLOLHV 7KH
4&,$("%,"*! '$#! &%,#+*"&2,"%-! "$%! 1#*Y2%! 4/"%&!
"$%!:#*+(4+![4&!*2..%*"%-!"$4"!"$%!1#*Y2%!'4*!
62(8"!(+!"$%!Eb"$FHQWXU\VUVWGHFDGHV7KHSRSX@
84"(#+!+216%&*!;$#2*%$#8-*<!4*!,#+"4(+%-!(+!"$%!
2WWRPDQUHJLVWHUVJLYHWKHIROORZLQJSLFWXUHDQG
73
*2..%*"!4+!%4&8(%&!-4"%K
1477
74
Musl.
Chr.
41
1499
Musl.
Chr.
53
60
1519
Musl.
Chr.
61
53
1585
1910
1991
Musl.
Chr.
Musl.
Chr.
Musl.
Chr.
72
100
69
33
Total: 41
Total: 113
Total: 114
Total: 78
Total: 100
Total: 102
Muslim: 0%
Muslim: 47%
Muslim: 53%
Muslim: 92%
Muslim: 100%
Muslim: 68%
L$%*%!+216%&*!4+-!-4"%*!*2..%*"!4!,#+*"&2,@
"(#+!"(1%!(+!"$%!84*"!-%,4-%!#/ !"$%!EC"$RUWKHUVW
GHFDGHRI WKH"$!,%+"2&0F!S"!'#28-!(+-%%-!$4?%!
6%%+! 2+6%4&468%! /#&! 4! N2*8(1! 14>#&("0! "#! 6%!
'("$#2"! 4! 1#*Y2%F! S+! 4! .##-! +216%&! #/ ! ,4*%*!
Z!/#&!%R41)8%!="#84,!;"$%!:40%5(-!SS!1#*Y2%<!#&!
.QHLQDWKH6HOLP,PRVTXHZHVHHWKDWWKH
*"4"%!(+"%&?%+%-!4+-!62(8"!4!1#*Y2%!'$%+!"$%!)%&@
,%+"4.%!#/ !N2*8(1*!(+!4!*1488!*%""8%1%+"!&%4,$%-!
RI WKHZKROHSRSXODWLRQ,QRWKHUFDVHV
ORFDO 2WWRPDQ RIFLDOV DFWHG LQ WKH VDPH ZD\
L$%! +216%&*! .(?%+! 46#?%! 48*#! 14H%! ,8%4&! "$4"!
6#"$!T))%&!4+-!X#'%&!:(>%+>4!$4-!12,$!1#&%!
4&468%!84+-!4"!"$%(&!-(*)#*48!"$4+!U&2]%?8>4+%!4+-!
,#28-!"$%&%/#&%!*2*"4(+!4!12,$!84&.%&!)#)284"(#+F!
%HWZHHQDQG%LMHQMDUHDFKHGDSHDN
6%0#+-!'$(,$!+#!/2&"$%&!%R)4+*(#+!'4*!)#**(68%3!
DQGHYHQLQWKHVGLGQRWVXUSDVVVOHYHO
,Q WKH PRVTXH ZDV EORZQ XS DQG LWV
-%6&(*! ,8%4&%-! #2"F! S"! '4*! '$#880! &%,#+*"&2,"%-!
(+! BDDb@a3! 4+-! (+! "$%! *41%! ,4&%/28! 14++%&! 4*!
U&2]%?8>4+%F!L$%!84""%&!'4*!&%62(8"!4"!"$%!(+("(4@
"(?%!4+-!*2))#&"!#/ !"$%!8#,48!?(884.%!)#)284"(#+!
DQG QDQFLDO KHOS IURP RXWVLGH 7KH %LMHQMD
1#*Y2%3! $#'%?%&3! '4*! &%,#+*"&2,"%-! 2+-%&! "$%!
:#*+(4+!M4"(#+48!9%&("4.%!/#2+-4"(#+J*!.2(-4+,%!
DQG ZLWK VXSSRUW IURP %UXVVHOV 7KH (XUR@
)%4+! 7#112+("0! 48*#! ,4&%-! /#&! "$%! %+#&1#2*!
#8-!,%1%"%&0!,#+"4(+(+.!$2+-&%-*!#/ !6%42"(/2880!
,4&?%-! .&4?%*"#+%*! ,&#'+%-! '("$! "2&64+*! 4+-!
4-#&+%-!'("$!,488(.&4)$%-!(+*,&()"(#+*3!/!"$%!
Eb"$"$!,%+"2&(%*F!L$%!'$#8%!04&-!'4*!*2&+-@
HG ZLWK DQ PHWUHVORQJ ZDOO DOVR QDQFHG
60!"$%!P2&#)%4+!7#112+("0F!L$%!.&4?%04&-!(*!4!
)#(.+4+"!&%1(+-%&!#/ !S*841J*!/#&1%&!(1)#&"4+,%!
(+!"$(*!/4&4'40!,#&+%&!#/ !"$%!#8-!S*841(,!'#&8-F
`E! 6WDQRYQLWYR3!))F!C`@CF
`B! _%.#3!O(&"7V(3!))F!EE@B3!'("$!/2&"$%&!&%/%&%+,%*F
)LQH -RKQ 9 $ T,"' 7($"' 0")+"4(7' 6(78(#&3' (' 1%+$+1(7' &2%4"R'
B%.0' $,"' 7($"' $P"7B$,' 1"#$2%R' $.' $,"' -$$.0(#' 1.#]2"&$F! A++! A&6#&K!
8QLY RI 0LFKLJDQ 3UHVV S ,PEHU &ROLQ T,"'
-$$.0(#' 90*+%"M' FHKK/FoIF ,VWDQEXO ,VLV 3UHVV S !
G#&! "$%! ,#1)8(,4"%-! )#8("(,48! $(*"#&0! 6%/#&%! 4+-! 4/"%&! "$%! :4""8%!
#/ ! U#*#?#! *%%! %*)%,(4880K! P11%&"3! LFAF! T,"' 6($$7"' .B ' Y.&.4.3' ('
UHFRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI LWV VLJQLFDQFH LQ WKH GHFOLQH RI 0HGLHYDO 6HUELDF! A++!
$UERU 8QLY RI 0LFKLJDQ 3UHVV $ VROLG RYHUYLHZ RI WKH
PHGLHYDOUXOHUVRI +XP+HU]HJRYLQDLVJLYHQE\'LQL0LKDMOR
<20&8./$%":+#V&8('47(&$"7(%HRJUDG6$18
4+-!(+!ECab!60!94+*!X2-'(.!?#+!X(,$"%+*"%(+F``#
X4"%&3!94*4+!O4*$4!6%,41%!&(#1(8:"R+'#/ !=5%.%-!
LQ +XQJDU\ DQG LQ URVH WR WKH ORIW\ UDQN
#/ ! :"R7"%:"R+! ;V#?%&+#&@V%+%&48<! #/ ! :#*+(4F! S"!
ZDVLQWKLVFDSDFLW\LQWKDWKHFRQTXHUHG
WKHLPSRUWDQWIRUWUHVVRI %LKDLQZKDWZDVWKHQ
&URDWLD RQO\ NP VRXWK RI =DJUHE WRJHWKHU
ZLWKWKHVWURQJKROGVVXUURXQGLQJLW7KH%LKD
-(*"&(,"! '4*! "#! 6%,#1%! "$%! +#&"$%&+1#*"! &%4,$!
#/ !:#*+(4!4+-!$4*!&%14(+%-!)4&"!#/ !("!2+"(8!"#-40F!
,Q-XQHGXULQJWKHIDWHIXO%DWWOHRI 6LVDN
94*4+!O4*$43!48#+.!'("$!#"$%&!)4*$4*!4+-!4!84&.%!
SDUWRI WKH2WWRPDQDUP\GURZQHGLQWKH.XSD
&(?%&J*! *'#88%+! '4"%&F! 9(*! 8(/%! 4+-! -%%-*! 8%/"! 4!
-%%)! (1)&(+"! (+! "$%! )%#)8%J*! 1%1#&03! $#'%?%&F!
N4+0!8%.%+-*!4&%!"#8-!46#2"!$(1!4+-!/#8H!64884-*!
46#2"!$(1!'%&%!*"(88!*2+.!(+!"$%!%4&80!BD"$!,%+"2&0F!
1LQHOHWWHUVRI +DVDQ3DVKDWR3DYOH3ULGRYLDQ
75
76
2WWRPDQVS\LQ'XEURYQLNDUHSUHVHUYHG`C#A+!
DQRQ\PRXVSRHWZURWHDSDQHJ\ULFLQ2WWRPDQ
L2&H(*$!46#2"!$(1F#
X#,4880!("!(*!"#8-!"$4"!94*4+!O4*$4!48*#!,#+@
*"&2,"%-!4!,$2&,$!/#&!$(*!1#"$%&!(+!"$%!?(884.%!#/ !
3ULMHYRU IRXU NP IURP %LOHD QHDU WKH URDG WR
O84+4!4+-!V4,H#F!L$%!8#,48!)#)284"(#+!,488%-!"$%!
SODFH3UHGRMHYLDFUNYDDIWHU+DVDQVSXUSRUW@
HGIDPLO\QDPH$WWKHHQGRI WKH"$!,%+"2&03!
)%#)8%! *"(88! *4+.! 46#2"! "$%! ,#+*"&2,"(#+! #/ ! "$%!
PRVTXHDQGWKHFKXUFKE\1HQDG3DVKD`b!L$%!
&2(+*!#/ !"$(*!,$2&,$!,4+!*"(88!6%!*%%+3!("*!84+-!&%.@
LVWHUHGDV2UWKRGR[&KXUFKSURSHUW\2WWRPDQ
-(.+("4&(%*!'$#!'%&%!*4(-!"#!$4?%!62(8"!1#*Y2%*!
4*! '%88! 4*! ,$2&,$%*! 4&%! /4?#2&%-! ,$4&4,"%&*! (+!
8#,48! /#8H8#&%! ;,#1)4&%! O84+4<F! 9%&%3! $#'%?%&3!
'%!*%%1!"#!$4?%!4+!4,"248!,4*%F`a!G#8H!"&4-("(#+*!
'&(""%+! -#'+! 4"! "$%! BD"$! ,%+"2&0J*! 6%.(++(+.!
4""&(62"%! %?%+! 1#&%! ,$2&,$%*! "#! c%8(! 94*4+!
O4*$43! (+,82-(+.! "$%! .&%4"! 1#+4*"%&0! ,$2&,$%*!
#/ ! N#]"4+(,4! 4+-! Q14+>! (+! +#&"$%&+! :#*+(43!
-(&%,"80! /4,(+.! 7"(4+! "%&&("#&0F! A,,#&-(+.! "#!
DQRWHLQWKH2OG&KXUFK6ODYRQLFa($"%#+8'EbB!
(+!"$%!=%&6(4+!1#+4*"%&0!#/ !9(8%+-4&!#+!N#2+"!
A"$#*3!"$%!.&%4"!,$2&,$!#/ !N#]"4+(,4!'4*!,#1@
SOHWHGLQ*D]L+DVDQ3DVKDLVVDLGWRKDYH
,#+Y2%&%-!"$%!7"(4+!/#&"&%**!#/ !O%"&(+>%!;CD!
H1! *#2"$! #/ ! W4.&%6<! (+! ECbCF! S"! (*! *2..%*"%-!
"$4"! $%! ,#+*"&2,"%-! "$%! ,$2&,$%*! #/ ! N#]"4+(,4!
4+-! Q14+>! 4*! *016#8*! #/ ! $(*! ?(,"#&0! #?%&! "$%!
74"$#8(,*!4"!O%"&(+>%F!N#*"!*"&(H(+.803!N#]"4+(,4J*!
JUHDWFKXUFKVKRZVVWURQJLQXHQFHIURP2WWR@
14+!,#+*"&2,"(#+!"%,$+(Y2%*!4+-!-%,#&4"(?%!%8@
`C 6HH ,YL $OHNVD 3LVPD +DVDQSDH +HUFHJRYDNRJ L] LQ
U*.0"#+8'U%*&8"'Y%(7V"4&8"'C8()"0+V"9ROSS
! A! ,#)0! #/ ! ("! (*! )&%*%&?%-! (+! "$%! ?4*"! ,#88%,"(#+! W6#&+(H! P+?%&(!
.DGL LQ WKH *D]L +XVUHYEHJ OLEUDU\ LQ 6DUDMHYR &I DEDQRYL
945(1F!.QMLHYQRVWPXVOLPDQD%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQHQDRULMHQWDOQLPMH]LFLPDF!
6DUDMHYR6YMHWORVWS7KHRULJLQDOZRUNRI WKHSDQHJ\ULF
ZDVLQWKHSULYDWHOLEUDU\RI WKHZHOONQRZQ%RVQLDQVFKRODU2VPDQ
6RNRORYLQRZLQWKH*D]L+XVUHYEHJOLEUDU\6DUDMHYR
`b &I.QH]%DMDJLL1HQDG3DDQDURGQDSMHVPDLQ6.&(#&8('4+7(3!
9ROSSVXQJZLWKVXSSRUWRI D52&7(E\-DQNR
HULQL
`a 0RUH DERXW WKLV EXLOGLQJ E\ .RML 'HVLPLU &UNYD YH]LUD LQ
U7.:.)(9RO1R
%1%+"*F!c2&(+.![[SS!7"!+4"(#+48(*"!/#&,%*!
EOHZXSWKH2UWKRGR[PRQDVWHU\RI 5PDQMDQG
KHDYLO\ GDPDJHG WKH 2UWKRGR[ 0RWDQLFD DV
UHYHQJHIRUWKH"$!,%+"2&0!-%/%4"*3!4+-!4*!4+!
HQGHDYRXUWRFRUUHFWDPLVWDNHRI KLVWRU\CD!
Kazanci
'XULQJWKHHQGOHVV&UHWDQ:DUWKH
2WWRPDQSDUWRI ,QQHU'DOPDWLDWKH.OLV&(#1(8<3!
4+-!12,$!#/ !9%&5%.#?(+4J*!*#2"$%&+!4+-!'%*"@
%&+!)4&"*3!*2//%&%-!"%&&(680!/!)82+-%&3!-%*"&2,@
WLRQDQGGHSRSXODWLRQ:KHQDIWHUWKHZDU2V@
14+!)4*$4!)#"%-!$(*!6(&"$!)84,%3!"$%!$418%"!
RI .D]DQFLZKHQFHKLVHSLWKHW.D]DQDFLQWR
DVPDOO2WWRPDQ8(&(:(!60!/#2+-(+.!4!1#*Y2%3!4!
0")%"&"3!4!0"8$":3!*"468%*3!4!DGUYDQ3!4+-!4!&#'!#/ !
*$#)*3!$%!48*#!6.$"!/&%*$!'4"%&!"#!"$%!*%""8%@
1%+"! "$.$! 4! *)%,(48! 2+-%&.+-! 62(8-(+.3!
ORFDOO\NQRZDVVWXEDQM)RUKLPVHOI KHKDGD
8.#(8HUHFWHG7KLVDOOWRRNSODFHLQWKHVLQ
"$%!-%,4-%!(11%-(4"%80!4/"%&!"$%!"%&&(68%!'4&!$4-!
HQGHGDQG2VPDQKDGEHHQHOHYDWHGWRWKHSRVW
RI 'DPDVFXVJRYHUQRU,QGXULQJWKHQHZ
ORQJZDUZLWKWKH&KULVWLDQFRDOLWLRQ
D IRUFH RI ,(V)28*! 4+-! N#+"%+%.&(+*!
2+-%&!"$%!12,$@/%4&%-!:4>#!O(?8>4+(+!-%*"�%-!
2VPDQVHQWLUHQHZ8(&(:(!4+-!H(88%-!#&!,4&&(%-!
RII DVVODYHVLWVSRSXODWLRQ2VPDQKLPVHOI IHOO
LQDV9L]LHURI %RVQLDGHIHQGLQJWKH2WWR@
PDQIURQWLHUDW(UL(JHULQQRUWKHUQ+XQJDU\
U454+,(J*!8#,48!)#)284"(#+!8#+.!&%1%16%&%-!("*!
-%*"&2,"(#+F! G#8H! *#+.*! 46#2"! ("! '%&%! ,#88%,"%-!
,OO6HWWOHPHQWSDWWHUQDQGSRSXODWLRQLQWKHND]DRI
1HYHVLQMHLQDFFRUGLQJWR7.*01R LQWKH
%2$
,OO6HWWOHPHQWSDWWHUQDQGSRSXODWLRQLQWKHND]DRI
1HYHVLQMHLQDFFRUGLQJWR7'LQWKH%2$
,OO6HWWOHPHQWSDWWHUQDQGSRSXODWLRQLQWKHIRUPHUND]DRI
1HYHVLQMHLQDFFRUGLQJWR6WDQRYQLWYR%RVQHL+HUFH
JRYLQHFLWHGLQIRRWQRWH
,OO6HWWOHPHQWSDWWHUQDQGSRSXODWLRQLQWKHND]DRI
1HYHVLQMHLQDFFRUGLQJWR7'LQWKH%DEDNDQON
2VPDQO$ULYL%2$
77
78
,OO.D]DQFLPLQDUHWRIVPRVTXHRI2VPDQ3DVKD
4*!4!"&2%!1(+4&%"!$4-!"#!6%F!L$%!U454+,(!1(+4&%"!
"$2*! )&%*214680! 14&H*! "$%! %+-! #/ ! "$%! ,2&(#2*!
FDPSDQLOHPLQDUHWFRQVWUXFWLRQ
Concluding remarks
[("$! $%8)! #/ ! *#8(-! -4"43! S! $4?%! *$#'+! "$4"!
"$%!*)&%4-!#/ !S*841!(+!"$%!#(,+R"&!#/ !c46&4!4+-!
M%?%*(+>%! '4*! 4! )&#,%**! '$(,$! *"&%",$%-! /#&!
1#&%!"$4+!4!,%+"2&0!;*%%!(88*F!E`@BE<F!G!5%&#!
LQLWURVHWRDOPRVWSHUFHQWLQWKHODWH
"$!,%+"2&0F!L$%!%1%&.%+,%!#/ !"$%!8(""8%!"#'+!#/ !
O&%-#8>%!4"!"$%!%-.%!#/ !"$%!c464&*H#!)#8>%3!"$%!
/#2+-4"(#+!#/ !"$%!8(&(:(!#/ !U454+,(!(+!"$%!/#&@
1%&!#(,+R"!#/ !V4,H#3!4+-!"$%!"#'+!#/ !M%?%*(+>%J*!
-%?%8#)1%+"3!'%&%!%R)&%**(#+*!#/ !4!,8%4&!2&64+@
(54"(#+!)#8(,03!'$(,$!'4*!#+80!"#!6%!2+-#+%!60!
H[WHUQDOIDFWRUVLQODWH2WWRPDQWLPHV+RZHYHU
"$%&%! (*! 4! ,#+*(-%&468%! -(//%&%+,%! 6%"'%%+! "$%!
-%?%8#)1%+"!#/ !S*841(,!,28"2&%!(+!"$%!)84(+*!#/ !
c464&! 4+-! M%?%*(+>%3! 4+-! "$4"! ,28"2&%J*! /4"%! (+!
"$%! BD"$ FHQWXU\ 'LVUHJDUGLQJ %LMHOMDQL %LOHD
4+-!c46&(,43!"$%!1#+21%+"*!#/ !c464&J*!S*841(,!
,28"2&%! ,4+! #+80! 6%! &%"&4,%-! (+! '&(""%+! *#2&,%*!
4+-!(+?%*"(.4"(#+!#+!"$%!*)#"F!N4+0!1#&%!*2,$!
1#+21%+"*! 12*"! $4?%! %R(*"%-! (+! "$%! )4*"3! 62"!
"$%! %?(-%+,%! (*! 8#*"F! S+! "$%! )84(+! #/ ! M%?%*(+>%3!
PDQ\PRUHEXLOGLQJVVWLOOVWRRGLQEXWWKLV
'4*!48*#!#+80!4!)4&"!#/ !4!12,$!.&%4"%&!)&#-2,@
"(#+F!L$%!*)&%4-!#/ !S*841!(+!"$%!-(*"&(,"!'4*3!4*!
%8*%'$%&%! (+! :#*+(4@9%&5%.#?(+43! *)#+"4+%#2*3!
?#82+"4&03!4+-3!1#*"!(1)#&"4+"803!Y2("%!.&4-248F!
7KH FDPSDQLOHPLQDUHWV SKHQRPHQRQ RI
'$(,$! #+80! "'#! #&(.(+48! %R41)8%*! *2&?(?%! 4+-!
"$&%%!,4+!6%!&%,#+*"&2,"%-3!?(?(-80!(882*"&4"%*!"$%!
/4,"!"$4"!"$%!*#2"$%&+!9%&5%.#?(+4!'4*!&%4880!4"!
"$%!?%&0!%-.%!#/ !"$%!S*841(,!'#&8-3!+#"!#+80!(+!
"$%! .%#.&4)$(,483! 62"! 48*#! (+! "$%! ,28"2&48! *%+*%F!
S+/#&14"(#+!#+!"$%!-(*"&(,"J*!,28"2&48!(+*"("2"(#+*!
$4*! 6%%+! 4**%168%-! )(%,%1%48F! S+! 4! )##&! 4+-!
*"#+0! -(*"&(,"! *2,$! 4*! "$%! c464&*H#! )#8>%! "$%0!
,#28-!#+80!6%!*1488!4+-!2+(1)&%**(?%F!S+!"$%!8(H%@
'(*%!)##&3!62"!$(.$!4+-!,#8-!)84(+!#/ !M%?%*(+>%!
"$%!*("24"(#+!'4*!12,$!"$%!*41%F!N#&%!&%14(+*!
"#!6%!8%4&+%-!46#2"!"$(*!*26>%,"F!L$%!Y2%*"(#+!#/ !
'$0!*#1%!)%#)8%!#)"%-!"#!$4?%!4!,$2&,$@"#'%&!
1(+4&%"! 4+-! #"$%&*! Z! 64*(,4880! (+! "$%! "#'+*3!
OLNH 0RVWDU .RQMLF RU 3RLWHOM RQ WKH 1HUHWYD
ZDQWHGWRKDYHDWUXH2WWRPDQPLQDUHWDW
,OO3RSXODWLRQDQGUHOLJLRQLQWKH'DEDUVNRSROMH
DFFRUGLQJWR2WWRPDQDUFKLYDOUHFRUGV
,OOV7KHQDKL\HRI'DEUDLQDQG
,OO3RSXODWLRQDQGUHOLJLRQLQWKH'DEDUVNRSROMH
DFFRUGLQJWR<XJRVODYFHQVXVUHFRUGVDVUHODWHGLQ
6WDQRYQLWYR%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQH
79
Marianne Boqvist
80
T,"'(2$,.%')+&12&&"&'$,"'5%()2(7'+#$"5%($+.#'.B 'W(0(&12&'*%.4+#1"'+#$.'$,"'-$$.0(#'&R&$"0'+#'$,"'FQ$,'1"#$2%RM'
(#)'(%1,+$"1$2%"^&'%.7"'+#'$,+&'*%.1"&&N'U,"'B.12&"&'.#'0.#20"#$&'.#'$,"'UR%+(#'&"1$+.#'.B '$,"'+0*"%+(7'%.()&M'P,+1,'
OLQNHGWKHFDSLWDOWRWKH5HG6HDDVZHOODVWRWKHWKUHHKRO\FLWLHV$VDUHVXOWRI LQFUHDVHGWUDIFRQWKHVHURDGV
WKHVXOWDQVDQGWKHLUKLJKRIFLDOVEXLOWDQXPEHURI ZD\VWDWLRQVWRSURYLGHSURWHFWLRQDQGIDFLOLWLHVIRUDOONLQGV
.B '$%(4"77"%&N'A#$"%"&$+#57RM'+#'$"%0&'.B '&$R7"'$,"&"'1.0*7"@"&'P"%"'17.&"%'$.'$,"'-$$.0(#'Z+0*"%+(7'&$R7"['.B 'A&$(#:27'
$,(#'$.'$,($'.B '-$$.0(#'W(0(&12&M'$,.25,'+$'(7&.'+#172)")'B"($2%"&'.B '$,"'7($$"%N'U*"1+(7'($$"#$+.#'+&')"4.$")'$.'
6.&#+(#/:.%#'q(7(';2&$(B('a(&,(^&'B.2#)($+.#'+#'z2#(R$%(M':"52#'+#'FdQHM'P,+1,'+#172)")'('b%+)(R'0.&]2"M'(#)'
$,"'"#).P0"#$')"")'.B 'P,+1,'*%.4+)"&'('5%"($')"(7'.B '+#B.%0($+.#'(:.2$'$,"'1.0*7"@^&'B2#1$+.#&N
$XWRULFDGLVNXWXMHSRVWHSHQXLQWHJUDFLMXSURYLQFLMH'DPDVNXRVPDQOLMVNLVLVWHPXVWROMHXLXORJXDUKL/
WHNWXUH X RYRP SURFHVX 2QD VH XVUHGRDYD QD VSRPHQLNH QD VLULMVNRP GLMHOX VXOWDQVNLK FHVWD NRMH SRYH]XMX
SULMHVWROQLFXL&UYHQRPRUHNDRLWULVYHWDJUDGD.DRUH]XOWDWSRMDDQRJSURPHWDQDRYLPSXWHYLPDVXOWDQLQMHJRYL
YLVRNLVOXEHQLFLJUDGHEURMQDVYUDWLWDGDELSXWQLFLPDVYLKYUVWDREH]EMHGLOL]DWLWXLGUXJHXVOXJH,QWHUHVDQWQR
XSRJOHGXVWLODRYLNRPSOHNVLVXEOLLRVPDQVNRPFDUVNRPVWLOX,VWDQEXODQHJRVWLOXXRVPDQVNRP'DPDVNX
PDGDVXNDVQLMHXNOMXHQLXLVWL3RVHEQDSDQMDMHSRVYHHQD]DGXELQDPD/DOD0XVWDID3DHNRMLMHELRURHQ
X%RVQLDXNOMXLYDOHVXGDPLMDX.XQHLWULL]JRGLQH]DWLPGMHOR]DGXELQHNRMHSUXDEURMQHLQIRUPDFLMH
.'B2#81+V(0('8.0*7"8&(N
E!
L$(*! )4)%&! (*! )4&"! #/ ! 4+! #+.#(+.! &%*%4&,$! )&#>%,"3! /2+-%-! 60! "$%!
='%-(*$! S+"%&+4"(#+48! c%?%8#)1%+"! 7##)%&4"(#+! A.%+,0! ;=(-4<F!
N0!.&4"("2-%!.#%*!"#!"$%!=0&(4+!1(+(*"&0!#/ !L#2&(*1!4+-!728"2&%3!
"$%! =0&(4+! c%)4&"1%+"! #/ ! A+"(Y2("(%*! 4+-! N2*%21*! 4*! '%88! 4*!
"$%! L2&H(*$! 1(+(*"&0! #/ ! 728"2&%3! '$#*%! 42"$#&(*4"(#+*! $4?%! 6%%+!
,&2,(48!/#&!"$(*!'#&H3!4*!'%88!4*!"#!"$%!#&.4+(5%&*!#/ !"$%!,#+/%&%+,%!
4+-! 79':! '$#! .4?%! 1%! "$%! #))#&"2+("0! "#! )&%*%+"! "$(*! )4)%&F!
6HH IRU LQVWDQFH .DIHVoLROX dLGHP ,Q WKH LPDJH RI 5P
2WWRPDQ DUFKLWHFWXUDO SDWURQDJH LQ "$! ,%+"2&0! A8%))#! 4+-!
'DPDVFXVLQ;2](%#(&9RO;9,SS:DWHQSDXJK
W%("8(4+3!9%.+4&F!T,"'+0(5"'.B '(#'-$$.0(#'1+$R3'+0*"%+(7'(%1,+$"1$2%"'(#)'
2%:(#'"@*"%+"#1"'+#'C7"**.'+#'$,"'FQ$,'(#)'Fn$,'1"#$2%+"&F!X%(-%+K!:&(883!BDD`F!
6HH IRU LQVWDQFH 3DVFXDO -HDQ3DXO 'DPDV j OD Q GX ;9,H VLqFOH
)^(*%v&' $%.+&' P(]B&' .$$.0(#& 'DPDVFXV ,)' :HEHU 6WHIDQ
7KH FUHDWLRQ RI 2WWRPDQ 'DPDVFXV DUFKLWHFWXUH DQG XUEDQ
GHYHORSPHQW RI 'DPDVFXV LQ WKH "$! 4+-! Eb"$ FHQWXULHV LQ
C\C;9RO,;;SS0HLQHFNH0LFKDHO'LH
RVPDQLVFKH$UFKLWHNWXUGHV-DKUKXQGHUWVLQ'DPDVNXVLQb+B$,'
A#$"%#($+.#(7'!.#5%"&&'.B 'T2%8+&,'C%$N'E62)(*"&$M'FGndLF!P-F!Vn54!G%$n&F!
%XGDSHVW$NDGpPLDL.LDGySS.DIHVoLROX,QWKH
,PDJHRI 5P%RTYLVW0DULDQQH$UFKLWHFWXUHHWGpYHORSSHPHQW
XUEDLQ D 'DPDV GH OD FRQTXrWH RWWRPDQH +
D OD IRQGDWLRQ GX ZDTI GH 0XUDG 3DVKD +
8QSXEOLVKHGGLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLWpGH6RUERQQH3DULV,9
/O0XDI3DVKDWKHFRQTXHURURI &\SUXVKHOGWKHJRYHUQRUVKLS
RI 'DPDVFXVIRUYH\HDUVKZKHUHKHIRXQGHGD
.&%4"!P(]BWRJHWKHUZLWKKLVZLIH)LPD.KQWKHJUDQGGDXJKWHU
RI WKHODVW0DPOXNVXOWDQ6LQQ3DVKDWKHFRQTXHURURI <HPHQ
ZDVDSSRLQWHGJRYHUQRURI 'DPDVFXVWZLFHEHWZHHQK
4+-!$(*!-%4"$!(+!KZKHQKHKDGKHOGWKHSRVLWLRQRI
JUDQGYL]LHUYHWLPHV
Introduction
81
,OOD4XQD\UDPRVTXHVHHQIURPWKHPLQDUHW$OOSKRWR
JUDSKVDUHE\WKHDXWKRU
82
DODPUDWKH\KDYHQRWDWWUDFWHGPXFKVFKRODUO\
;#&!#"$%&<!4""%+"(#+!"#!-4"%F`
L$%*%! *"#)*! 4&%! "#-40! (+! 2&.%+"! +%%-! #/ !
*#1%!H(+-!#/ !)&%*%&?4"(#+!4,"(#+F!L$%!1#*Y2%!
LQ4XQD\UDLVDQHPSW\VKHOOLQWKHPLGGOHRI
4!-%*%&"%-!"#'+hC!"$4"!(+!=4J*4J!$4*!&%,%+"80!6%%+!
&%*"#&%-3!62"!(*!8#,4"%-!(+!"$%!,%+"&%!#/ !4!&2(+%-!
IRUWLFDWLRQ 2QO\ WKDW LQ 4XD\ID ZKLFK ZDV
`!
C!
N4&-41! :%H3! U$48(8F! )LUPQ OLZ 6DLG ZD 6KP EL .KXVV ZDTI
/O 0XVWDI %DVK ZD ]DZMDWXKX )LPD .KWQ ELQW VXOQ DOUF!
'DPDVFXV DOPDWEDTD DOXPP\D K S 7KLV
"%&13!48*#!2*%-!/#&!"$%!*28"4+(,!/#2+-4"(#+*!(+!c414*,2*!(+-(,4"%*!
"$%!(1)%&(48!(+?#8?%1%+"!(+!"$%!/#2+-4"(#+F!S"!,4+!"$4"!,4+!6%!)2"!(+!
,#+"&4*"!'("$!"$%!"%&1!WDN\D!"$4"!'4*!2*%-!/#&!"$%!#"$%&!,#1)8%R%*!
(+!"$%!)&#?(+,%3!*#1%!#/ !'$(,$!(+,82-%-!)268(,!H(",$%+*F!=%%3!N%(%&3!
$VWULG )RU WKH VDNH RI *RG DORQH" )RRG GLVWULEXWLRQ SROLFLHV
WDNL\\DVDQGLPDUHWVLQHDUO\2WWRPDQ'DPDVFXVLQb"")+#5'*".*7"M'
B"")+#5'*.P"%3'+0(%"$&'+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'90*+%"F!P-*F!M(+4!P&.(+3!7$&(*"#)$!
1HXPDQQDQG$P\6LQJHU,VWDQEXO(UHQSSFLWS
E`E@E`BF!
A,,#&-(+.!"#!=,$214,$%&3!V#""8(%6F!T,"'>(27`#3'&2%4"R")'B.%'$,"'f"%0(#'
U.1+"$R'B.%'$,"'9@*7.%($+.#'.B '$,"'<.7R'q(#)F!X#+-#+K!QF!:%+"8%0!g!*#+3!
LWZDVHQWLUHO\UHEXLOWLQWKHV)RUIXUWKHULQIRUPDWLRQVHH
=DNDU\D$KPDG$O5I DO6U9RO,,'DPDVFXVDO%D\Q
)F!C`DF
,OOE4XQD\UDPRVTXHVHHQIURPWKHHDVW
b!
7KHUH DUH KRZHYHU VRPH H[FHSWLRQV VXFK DV 6DXYDJHW -HDQ /HV
74&4?4+*n&4(8*!=0&(%+*!-2!94->->!-%!7#+*"4+"(+#)8%3!(+K!C%&'A&7(0+1(3!
9RO ,9 SS .LHO 0DFKLHO 7KH FDUDYDQVDUD\ DQG
,(?(,!,%+"%&!#/ !c%/"%&-4&!N2&4-!7%8%6(!(+!N4J4&&4"!4+@M2J14+!4+-!
WKHNOOL\HRI <HPHQ)DWLKL6LQDQ3DVKDLQ6DVDLQn'1"#$2%+"&'.B '
-$$.0(#' (%1,+$"1$2%"3' Z(' &2*%(/#($+.#(7' <"%+$(5"[ (GV 1XU $NQ HW DO
,VWDQEXO<(0SS7KHIRXQGDWLRQKDVSUHYLRXVO\
6%%+! *"2-(%-! 4+-! )268(*$%-! 60! A&+4J#2"3! N2$4114-F! 0X\DW DQ
'LPDVKTZD%LOGDO6KPDO-DQE\DIQLD\DWDOTDUQDO6GLVDDVKDUD3!
'DPDVFXV 'U DODGN! O4*,2483! W(0(& )RU PRUH VSHFLF
(+/#&14"(#+! #+! "$%! *28"4+J*! (+?#8?%1%+"! (+! "$%! /#2+-4"(#+3! *%%!
9%0-3! T&(%8F! -$$.0(#' ).120"#$&' .#' a(7"&$+#"' FddJ/FQFd3' (' &$2)R' .B ' $,"'
UPDQDFFRUGLQJWRWKH0KLPPH'HIWHUL2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
SS )RU WUDYHO DFFRXQWV VHH IRU LQVWDQFH (YOL\D dHOHEL
U"R,($#(0"&+M' 9RO ,; (GV <FHO 'DO HW DO ,VWDQEXO <DS .UHGL
<D\QODUSS
N4&-41!:%H3!)LUPQ9DNDU*HQHO0GUOKHUHUDIWHU9*0
/O0XDI3DVKD9*0)LPDQ
9*0 9*0 6LQQ 3DVKD :DTI\D 6LQQ 3DVKD3!
'DPDVFXV,)($'0XGU\DDODZTI
Visualization of Ottoman
presence
L$%!%R)#*%-!*("24"(#+!#/ !"$%*%!"$&%%!*("%*3!#+!
"$%!6#&-%&!6%"'%%+!*%-%+"4&0!4+-!:%-#2(+!"%&&(@
"#&03!'4*!,8#*%80!,#++%,"%-!"#!"$%(&!/#2+-4"(#+3!
4+!2&.%+"!&%*)#+*%!"#!4!+%%-!/%8"!60!"$%!*28"4+!
"#!)&#"%,"!"&4?%88%&*!4+-!)(8.&(1*!4.4(+*"!:%-#2(+!
DWWDFNVDQGWRGHPRQVWUDWH2WWRPDQSUHVHQFHED!
A*!4!&%*28"3!"$%!-%"%&(#&4"%-!*"#)*!;0"#X+7L!#+!"$%!
4XQD\UDDQG6DVDZHUHRQO\DIHZNLORPHWUHVWRWKHVRXWKZHVWRI
'DPDVFXV RQ WKH URDG WRZDUGV 3DOHVWLQH DQG &DLUR DQG 4XD\ID
'4*!#+!"$%!-!"#'4&-*!9#1*!4+-!A8%))#F
ED! :4$("3! A-+4+F! T,"' -$$.0(#' *%.4+#1"' .B ' W(0(&12&' +#' $,"' FQ$,' 1"#$2%RF!
%HLUXW/LEUDLULHGX/LEDQSII+H\G-$$.0(#').1NNN3)F!EDE3!
,OO4XD\IDJURXQGSODQRIFRPSOH[IURP6DXYDJHW/HV
FDUDYDQVpUDLOVS
83
The layout of
buildings
84
,OO'DPDVFXV6LQQ\DPRVTXHJURXQGSODQIURP:DW]
LQJHU :XO]LQJHU'DPDVNXVSJ
*("%*!'%&%!%+84&.%-!(+"#!,#1)8%R%*!48#+.!'("$!4!
/#&"&%**! 4+-! 4! )%&14+%+"! .4&&(*#+3! $#&*%*! 4+-!
"$%(&!,4&%"4H%&*!/#&!"$%!)#*"48!*0*"%13EE!4+-!(+!"$%!
,4*%!#/ !=4J*4J3!'$(,$!'4*!)4&"(,284&80!%R)#*%-3!4+!
4--("(#+48!)#)284"(#+!#/ !)%4*4+"*!'4*!#&-%&%-!"#!
*%""8%!(+!"$%!+%(.$6#2&(+.!4&%4FEB!
c%*)("%!"$%!4,"(?%!(+?#8?%1%+"!#/ !"$%!*28"4+!
(+!"$%!,#+*"&2,"(#+!#/ !"$%*%!,#1)8%R%*!4+-!"$%(&!
-%*(.+4"(#+! 4*! (1)%&(48! (14&%"*3! "$%0! '%&%! 62(8"!
#+!4!*1488%&!*,48%!"$4+!1#+21%+"48!,#1)8%R%*!
EE! A,,#&-(+.! "#! 4! UPDQ IURP K WKHVH IDPLOLHV RI
,4&%"4H%&*!(+!%4,$!*"#)!'%&%!%R%1)"%-!/!)40(+.!"4R%*F!=%%!9%0-3!
-$$.0(#').120"#$&SS%DKLWT,"'-$$.0(#'*%.4+#1"S
EB 7KH RUGHU WR UHORFDWH WKHVH IDPLOLHV ZDV SODFHG LQ K
4+-!"$%0!'%&%!%R%1)"%-!/!"4R%*F'=%%!(6(-FNM')F!EDE3!:4H$("3!T,"'
-$$.0(#'a%.4+#1"3!)FBBEF
,OO4XQD\UDPRVTXH
Eb! S+! c414*,2*3! "$%! #+80! 1#*Y2%*! ,#?%&%-! '("$! "$%*%! "&4-("(#+4880!
2WWRPDQOHDGVKHHWVDUHWKH7DN\D6XOD\PQ\DDQGWKH6LQQ\D
Ea! L&4,%*!#/ !"$%!ULZT!(+!=4J*4J!,4+!6%!*%%+!#+!)$#"#*!/!"$%!4&,$(?%*!
#/ !$(*"#&(,48!1#+21%+"*F
,OO'DPDVFXVPRVTXHRIWKH7DN\D6XOD\PQ\D
85
,OO4XD\IDPRVTXH
86
'%&%!)#80.#+48!'("$!4!)#(+"%-!,4)3!62"!/4&!/!
DVVOHQGHUDVWKRVHRI WKH7DN\D6XOD\PQ\D!
S+!,#+,82*(#+3!"$%!840#2"*!#/ !"$%!"$&%%!1#*Y2%*!
UHSUHVHQWWZRYDULDWLRQVRI WKH2WWRPDQH[SRUW
PRGHORQHLVUHFWDQJXODUZLWKODWHUDOJDOOHULHV
"$%!#"$%&!*Y24&%!'("$!"$%!1(+4&%"!4,,%**(68%!/!
WKHULZTRUIURPWKHSUD\HUKDOO%RWKPRGHOV
FDQ EH WUDFHG WR 2WWRPDQ 'DPDVFXV DQG HYHQ
8##*%80! "#! S*"4+628F! 9#'%?%&3! 48"$#2.$! "$%0!
-(//%&! &4-(,4880! /! "$%! "&4-("(#+48! c414*,%+%!
1#*Y2%*3!6#"$!(+!"%&1*!#/ !"$%!#&.4+(*4"(#+!#/ !
*)4,%!4+-!"$%!*$4)%!#/ !-#1%*!4+-!1(+4&%"*3!"$%0!
4&%!14(+80!62(8"!#/ !8#,48!14"%&(48*!4+-!4,,#&-(+.!
"#! 8#,48! 62(8-(+.! "%,$+(Y2%*3! 4+-! "$2*! )ﲨ!
2+-%&!"$%!*2)%&?(*(#+!#/ !8#,48!;)#**(680!c414@
*,%+%<!14*"%&!62(8-%&*F
Building material
and decoration
L$%!14(+!62(8-(+.!14"%&(48!(+!"$%!"$&%%!*("%*!
'4*! 4-4)"%-! "#! "$%! .%#8#.(,48! *("24"(#+! #/ ! "$%!
UHJLRQZHQGEDVDOWLQ4XQD\UDOLPHVWRQHDQG
EDVDOW LQ 6DVD DQG OLPHVWRQH LQ 4XD\ID )RU
WKHGHQLWLRQRI PDWHULDOXVHGIRUSDUWLFXODUHOH@
1%+"*3!"$%!ZDTI\DIRU4XQD\UDKDVSURYHQWREH
"$%!1#*"!(+/#&14"(?%!*#2&,%F!S"!(+-(,4"%*!"$%!2*%!
7RGD\RQO\WKHPLQDUHWLQ4XD\IDKDVWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFSRLQWHGFDS
48"$#2.$!"$%0!)#**(680!488!-(-!#&(.(+4880F
,OO6DVDPRVTXH
#/ !,#*"80!62(8-(+.!14"%&(48!&4&%80!*%%+!6%0#+-!"$%!
,("0!8(1("*3!4!"%*"(1#+0!"#!"$%!)4&"(,284&!*"4"2*!#/ !
"$(*!,#1)8%RF!L$%!1#*"!#2"*"4+-(+.!%8%1%+"*!4&%!
)&%-#1(+4+"80!(+!"$%!(+"%&(#&!-%,#&4"(#+F
7KHPLQEDULQ4XQD\UDZDVPDGHRI ZRRG
4+-!'4*!,&#'+%-!60!4!*1488!,2)#843!)4(+"%-!'("$!
4!,#))%&!$48/ !1##+!(+!(1("4"(#+!#/ !.#8-FBD![$(8%!
1(+64&*!(+!14&68%!*%%1!"#!$4?%!6%%+!)&%/%&&%-!
LQ 2WWRPDQ PRVTXHV LQ WKH FDSLWDO DQG LWV 5X@
1%8(4+! 4+-! A+4"#8(4+! $(+"%&84+-*3! %846#&4"%!
ZRRGHQPLQEDUVZHUHFRPPRQLQSUH2WWRPDQ
=0&(4!4+-!P.0)"F!M#"$(+.!/2&"$%&!(*!H+#'+3!$#'@
%?%&3!#/ !"$%!*$4)%!#&!%846#&4"(#+!#/ !"$%!1(+64&!
DW 4XQD\UD 7KH OLPHVWRQH PLQEDU LQ 4XD\ID
(*! ,8%4&80! 4+! (1("4"(#+! #/ ! "$%! 14&68%! 1(+64&! (+!
WKH6LQQ\DPRVTXHLQ'DPDVFXVZKLOHWKDWLQ
=4J*4J!;(88F!a<!'4*!,#1)8%"%80!-(//%&%+"K!,2"!(+!8(1%@
*"#+%!4+-!*$4)%-!8(H%!4!*"4(&,4*%!4""4,$%-!"#!"$%!
BD! N4&-41!:%H3!b+%0(#S
BE! S6(-NS
BB $Q 2WWRPDQ RIFLDO RQ SRVW LQ 'DPDVFXV DW WKH VDPH WLPH DV
/O0XDID3DVKDUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI WKH7DN\D
6XOD\PQ\D
! N4&-41!:%H3!b+%0(#S
,OOD4XQD\WUDUHXVHGFRORXUSDVWHPHGDOOLRQV
,OOE4XQD\WUDUHXVHGFRORXUSDVWHPHGDOOLRQV
,OO6DVDPLQEDURIPRVTXH
B`! S+! "$(*! ,#+"%R"3! ("! (*! )4&"(,284&80! (+"%&%*"(+.! "#! ,#+"&4*"! "$%! ,#8#2&!
SDVWHGHFRUDWLRQLQ4XQD\UDH[HFXWHGLQEDVDOWZLWKWKHH[SHQVLYH
62(8-(+.! 14"%&(48*! "#! 6%! 2*%-! (+! "$(*! 1#*Y2%! 4*! -%*,&(6%-! (+! ("*!
ZDTI\DF
TLEODZDOORYHUDQ2WWRPDQDUFKZDVWKLVDORFDO
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQRI 2WWRPDQHOHPHQWV"
7KHPRVTXHLQ4XQD\UDKDGDZRRGHQPDK@
O ZLWK SDLQWHG GHFRUDWLRQ DQG ZDV VXSSRUWHG
60! *"#+%! ,#821+*FBE! M#"$(+.! *(1(84&! $4*! 6%%+!
IRXQGLQWKHPRVTXHVRI 6DVDRU4XD\IDEXW
LQ 'DPDVFXV ERWK WKH 6LQQ\D DQG WKH 7DN\D
6XOD\PQ\DZHUHIXUQLVKHGZLWKPDKOVHQWLUHO\
*,28)"%-! #/ ! 14&68%! 4+-! *2))#&"%-! 60! .&4+("%!
DQG SRUSK\U\ FROXPQV $ ZRRGHQ PDKO ZLWK
)4(+"%-!-%,#&4"(#+!,4+!6%!*%%+3!$#'%?%&3!(+!"$%!
PRVTXHRI 6LQQ$DBB
7KH ZDTI\D RI 4XQD\UD IXUWKHU PHQWLRQV
"$%!2*%!#/ !14&68%!)4+%8*!(+!"$%!*%,82-%-!*)4,%!
/#&!'#1%+F!=2,$!)4+%8*!&%1(+-!2*!#/ !"$#*%!(+!
WKH SUD\HU KDOOV RI WKH 6LQQ\D RU 'DUZVK\D
(+! c414*,2*! "$4"! 481#*"! ,%&"4(+80! '%&%! &%2*%-!
62(8-(+.!14"%&(48F
7KH PLKUDE LQ 4XQD\UD ZDV FRPSRVHG RI
-(//%&%+"! "0)%*! #/ ! *"#+%! 4+-! )4(+"%-\,#8#2&%-!
PDQTVK 7KLV HVWDEOLVKHV DQ DIOLDWLRQ ZLWK
"$%! c414*,%+%! 4&,$("%,"2&%! #/ ! "$%! *41%! )%@
&(#-3! '$%&%! "$%! 14>#&("0! #/ ! 1($&46*! (+,82-%-!
"'#!#&!"$&%%!"0)%*!#/ !,#8#2&%-!*"#+%!4+-!'%&%!
87
88
OOHGLQWRWKHSRO\JRQDOIUDPLQJRI WKHGHFRUD@
"(?%!)4+%8!;(88F!ED<F!L$%*%!1%-488(#+*!4+-!/&41%*!
'%&%!)4&"!#/ !"$%!#&(.(+48!,#+*"&2,"(#+!4+-!*$#'!
WKHFRQQHFWLRQQRWRQO\EHWZHHQ4XQD\UDDQG
6DVDEXWDOVRWR2WWRPDQ'DPDVFHQHDUFKLWHF@
"2&48!-%,#&4"(#+!;(88F!EE<F!
$QRWKHU2WWRPDQQRYHOW\REVHUYHGLQWKHVH
62(8-(+.*!(*!"$%!4&,$%-!82+%""%!,&#'+(+.!"$%!&%,"@
DQJXODUZLQGRZVFRPPRQO\XVHGLQ2WWRPDQDU@
,$("%,"2&%F!S+!c414*,2*!82+%""%*!'%&%!/&%Y2%+"80!
GHFRUDWHGZLWKWLOHVEXWFRXOGHOVHZKHUHEHOOHG
(+!'("$!1#28-%-!.0)*21!#&!>2*"!8%/"!684+H3!4*!#+!
"$%!%R"%&(#&!#/ !"$%!"$&%%!1#*Y2%*!*"2-(%-!(+!"$(*!
SDSHU,QWKHLQWHULRURI WKHPRVTXHLQ4XD\ID
"$%!82+%""%*!,#+"4(+!"$%!1#*"!(+"%&%*"(+.!-%,#&4@
"(?%!%8%1%+"!#6*%&?%-!(+!"$4"!1#*Y2%F!L$%0!4&%!
OOHGZLWKDJ\SVXPFRYHUDQGSDLQWHGZLWKRUDO
#&!%)(.&4)$(,!-%*(.+*!"$4"!,#28-!6%!4!8#,48!;4+-\
#&!84"%&<!(+"%&)&%"4"(#+!#/ !"$%!c414*,%+%!"(8%*!#/ !
WKH "$! ,%+"2&03! 1406%! 4! )&#?(+,(48! (+"%&)&%"4@
"(#+!#/ !"$%!c414*,%+%!"(8%!)&#-2,"(#+!;(88F!EB<F!
L$4"! "$%! ,#8846#&4"(#+! 6%"'%%+! '#&H1%+!
IURPWKHUR\DODUFKLWHFWVRIFHDQG'DPDVFHQH
ZRUNPHQ RQ WKH EXLOGLQJ VLWH RI WKH 7DN\D
6XOD\PQ\DLQWKHVSURGXFHGDQ2WWRPDQ
'DPDVFHQHDUFKLWHFWXUHLQFRUSRUDWLQJIRUHLJQ
4+-!8#,48!62(8-(+.!14"%&(48!4+-!"$%!&%8%?4+"!"%,$@
+(Y2%*! (*! &%,#.+(5%-F! A,,#&-(+.! "#! ,$&#+(,8%*!
DQG 2WWRPDQ DUFKLYDO VRXUFHV ZRUNPHQ ZHUH
*%+"!/!c414*,2*!"#!'#&H!#+!(1)%&(48!62(8-@
(+.!*("%*!*2,$!4*!"$%!c#1%!#/ !"$%!Q#,H!4+-!"$%!
DO$TVDPRVTXHLQ-HUXVDOHPDVZHOODVRQFRP@
)8%R%*! 4+-! /#&"&%**%*! #+! "$%! (1)%&(48! "%*! (+!
"$%!&%.(#+FBC!L$%*%!*#2&,%*!(+/#&1!2*!"$4"!"$%&%!
ZDVDVWRFNRI LPSHULDOEXLOGLQJPDWHULDOLQ-HUX@
*48%1!4+-!"$4"!"$%!)%&*#+!(+!,$4&.%!#/ !("!'4*!"$%!
.#?%&+#&!#/ !c414*,2*F!A*!"$%!&%)&%*%+"4"(?%!#/ !
"$%! *28"4+3! $%! '4*! 48*#! &%*)#+*(68%! /#&! "$%! %1@
)8#01%+"!#/ !*H(88%-!'#&H1%+!4+-!"$%!%R%,2"(#+!
#/ !(1)%&(48!62(8-(+.!)&#>%,"*F!S"!(*!"$2*!)#**(68%!
"$4"! 62(8-(+.! 14"%&(48! /! "$%*%! *"#,H*! ,#28-!
KDYHEHHQXVHGLQ4XQD\UDDQG6DVDDQGWKDW
*)%,(48(*%-!'#&H1%+!,#28-!$4?%!6%%+!%1)8#0%-!
"$%&%!'$(8%!"$%0!'%&%!"&4?%88(+.3!/#&!(+*"4+,%3!6%@
WZHHQ'DPDVFXVDQG-HUXVDOHP
L$(*!,#28-!48*#!6%!4+!%R)84+4"(#+!/#&!"$%!,#*"80!
PDWHULDOXVHGLQ4XQD\UD$QRWKHUUHDVRQFRXOG
6%!"$4"!"$(*!'4*!"$%!#+80!G&(-40!1#*Y2%!/#2+-%-!
E\/O0XDI3DVKDVLQFHKLVFRPSOH[LQ'D@
14*,2*!#+80!,#+"4(+%-!4!*1488!0(&V+)!8#,4"%-!(+!
"$%!,%+"&%!#/ !"$%!,#2&"04&-!#/ !$(*!H$4+FBb!L$(*!
48*#!14H%*!*%+*%!(+!,#1)4&(*#+!'("$!"$%!/#2+-4@
WLRQRI 6LQQ3DVKDZKRVHPRVTXHLQ'DPDVFXV
'4*!*(1(84&!(+!*$4)%!4+-!14"%&(48!"#!"$4"!2*%-!(+!
BC! G#&!/2&"$%&!-%"4(8*!#+!"$%*%!'#&H*3!*%%!:4H$("3!T,"'-$$.0(#'*%.4+#1"3!
S ZKR PHQWLRQV UHSDLUV DW DO=L]\D RQ WKH URDG EHWZHHQ
c414*,2*! 4+-! N%,,43! 4*! #&-%&%-! 60! "$%! *28"4+! 4+-! %R%,2"%-! 60!
'#&H1%+! 4+-! 14"%&(48! /! c414*,2*! 2+-%&! "$%! &%*)#+*(6(8("0!
#/ ! c414*,%+%! +#"468%*F! X4#2*"3! 9%+&(F! q"&' 5.24"%#"2%&' )"' W(0(&F!
'DPDVFXV,)'SPHQWLRQVUHSDLUVRI WKHIRUWVDWDO
$DULQK
! P?8(04!7%8%6(3!U"R(,($#(0"&+9RO,;S
Bb! [4"5(+.%&3! 74&8! 4+-! U4&8! [285(+.%&F! W(0(&82&M' )+"' A&7(0+&1,"' U$()$M'
:%&8(+K'[48"%&!-%!V&20"%&!g!,#MSS
,OO6DVDPLKUDERIPRVTXH
4XQD\UDZKLOHWKHRQHVLQKLVUXUDOFRPSOH[HV
'%&%!&%84"(?%80!*(1)8%FBa!
L$2*3! -%*)("%! "$%! -(//%&%+,%*! 6%"'%%+! "$%*%!
WKUHHPRVTXHVWKH\DUHDOOFOHDUO\DIOLDWHGZLWK
DUFKLWHFWXUDOWUHQGVIURPERWKWKH2WWRPDQFHQ@
WUHDQG2WWRPDQ'DPDVFXVDVPXFKWKURXJKDU@
,$("%,"2&48!%8%1%+"*!;*2,$!4*!"$%!*$4)%!(/ !-#1%*3!
1(+4&%"*3!'(+-#'*3!4+-!0+#:(%*<!4*!"$.$!"$%!
2*%!#/ !-%,#&4"(?%!%8%1%+"*3!*2,$!4*!,#8#2&!)4*"%!
1%-488(#+*! 4+-! )#80.#+48! #&! 1#28-%-! /&41%*F!
N#&%#?%&3! 48"$#2.$! "(8%*! -#! +#"! *%%1! "#! $4?%!
6%%+! )&#-2,%-! #2"*(-%! c414*,2*3! "$%&%! (*! 4+!
4'4&%+%**!#/ !"$%(&!%R(*"%+,%3!4+-!1#"(/*!-%&(?%-!
/! "$%1! 4&%! *%%+! (+! "$%! 82+%""%*! #/ ! )4(+"%-!
J\SVXP LQ 4XD\ID 6RPHWKLQJ VLPLODU FDQ EH
*4(-! 46#2"! "$%! 0+#:(%! (+! =4J*4JK! 4! 8#,48! (+"%&)&%@
WDWLRQ RI 2WWRPDQ HOHPHQWV LQWURGXFHG WR WKLV
&2&48! ,#+"%R"! "$.$! ,#8846#&4"(#+! 6%"'%%+!
c414*,%+%!4+-!8#,48!'#&H1%+F!
,OO'DPDVFXVOXQHWWHRI6LQQ\DPRVTXH
Conclusion
,OO'UDZLQJVIURP:DW]LQJHU :XOW]LQJHU'DPDVNXVS
J
Ba! 9%0-3! -$$.0(#' ).120"#$& S GLVFXVVHV LQ K WKH
14"%&(48!$%8-!(+!"$%!.#?%&+1%+"48!*"#,H*!4+-!'$(,$!(*!+#"!2*%-!-2%!
"#!"$%!84,H!#/ !,#1)%"%+"!'#&H1%+F!S6(-F!)F!ECb3!(*!1%+"(#+%-!"$%!
"&4+*)#&"!/!S*"4+628!#/ !8%4-!/#&!"$%!&##/*!#/ !48@AY*43!"$%!c#1%!
RI WKH5RFNDQGWKH8PD\\DGPRVTXHLQK
L$%!62(8-(+.!,#1)8%R%*!*"2-(%-!(+!"$(*!)4)%&!
'%&%! )4&"! #/ ! /#2+-4"(#+*! *)#+*#&%-! 60! $(.$@
UDQNLQJ2WWRPDQRIFLDOVFORVHO\UHODWHGWRWKH
,%+"&48! 42"$#&("(%*! (+! S*"4+6283! 4+-! '$(,$! '%&%!
)#"%-!4+-\#&!,#11(**(#+%-!60!"$%!*28"4+!4*!
4!&%*)#+*%!"#!"$%!(+*%,2&%!*("24"(#+!#+!"$%*%!-*!
DWWKHHQGRI WKH"$!,%+"2&0F!L$%*%!,#1)8%R%*!
*(128"4+%#2*80!)&#?(-%-!/4,(8("(%*!4+-!)&#"%,"(#+!
/#&!)(8.&(1*!4+-!"&4?%88%&*3!)#"%-!*%""8%1%+"!
LQWKHVXUURXQGLQJDUHDDQGYLVXDOL]HG2WWRPDQ
)&%*%+,%!#+!"$%!(1)%&(48!-*F!S+!4!,#+,%)"248!
'403!"$%*%!-*(-%!,#1)8%R%*!'%&%!,8#*%&!"#!"$%!
2WWRPDQDUFKLWHFWXUDOFDQRQRI WKHFHQWUHWKDQ
"#!("*!%,$#%*!(+!c414*,2*F!M#"'("$*"4+-(+.!"$%!
REYLRXV DUFKLWHFWXUDO LQXHQFH RI WKH 2WWR@
14+!,%+"&%3!62(8-(+.!14"%&(48*!4+-!,#+*"&2,"(#+!
"%,$+(Y2%*! ,#+"(+2%! "$%! 8#,48! "&4-("(#+F! c%*)("%!
"$%(&!-%*(.+4"(#+!4*!(1)%&(48!(14&%"*3!+#!62(8-(+.!
14"%&(48!'4*!*%+"!/!"$%!,4)("48!"#!62(8-!"$%*%!
,#1)8%R%*F! S+! /4,"3! ("! *%%1*! "$4"! "$%! /#2+-%&*!
,#1)8%"%80! &%8(%-! #+! 8#,48! '#&H1%+J*! *H(88*! 4+-!
"$%!Y248("0!#/ !"$%!4?4(8468%!62(8-(+.!14"%&(48!(+!4!
,#+"%R"! '$%&%! c414*,2*! '4*! "$%! &%8%?4+"! ,%+@
"&%F! L$%*%! 62(8-(+.*! ,4+! )&#?(-%! 2*! '("$! 1#&%!
(+/#&14"(#+! #+! "$%! )&#,%**%*! "$.$! '$(,$!
2WWRPDQLPSHULDODUFKLWHFWXUHZDVDGDSWHGWRD
8#,48\)%&()$%&48!,#+"%R"!%?%+!/2&"$%&!4'40!/!
"$%!4,"248!,%+"&%!#/ !"$%!%1)(&%!"$4+!"$%!=0&(4+!
89
1%"&#)#8(*F!
Federica Broilo
90
7KHDXWKRUGLVFXVVHVIRXU2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVDORQJWKHDQFLHQW9LD(JQDWLDUHGLVFRYHUHGGXULQJKHUHOGZRUN
+#'$,"'%"5+.#'+#'JKKnN'A#'b7.%+#(M'('$.P#'+#'f%""8';(1").#+('.B 'P,+1,'$,"'-$$.0(#',"%+$(5"',(&'#.$':""#'&2B/
FLHQWO\VWXGLHGVKHKDVLGHQWLHGWKUHHEXLOGLQJVIURPWKH2WWRPDQSHULRGWKHUHPDLQVRI DPRVTXHRI <DNXE
%H"RI ZKLFKRQO\WKHEDVHPHQWRI DPLQDUHWUHPDLQVDIRUPHUKDPDPQHDUFROODSVHDQGDEXLOGLQJRI \HW
XQLGHQWLHGIXQFWLRQZKLFKUHVHDUFKHUVDSSHDUWRKDYHRYHUORRNHGVRIDU,Q$SROORQLD/RXWUDRQ/DNH9ROYLVVKH
KDVLGHQWLHGDQ2WWRPDQWKHUPDOEDWKRI RFWDJRQDOVKDSH
$XWRULFDGLVNXWXMHRHWLULRVPDQVNHJUDHYLQHNRMHVHQDOD]HGXVWDURJULPVNRJSXWD9LD(JQDWLDLNRMH
&2'*.#.4.'.$8%+4"#"'$.8.0'#V"#.5'$"%"#&8.5'%()('2'%"5+V+'2'JKKnN5N'j'b7.%+#2M'5%()2'2'95"V&8.V';(8").#+V+M'
LMHRVPDQVNRQDVOLMHHQLMHGRYROMQRLVWUDLYDQRDXWRULFDMHLGHQWLNRYDODWULJUDHYLQHNRMHSRWLXL]RVPDQVNRJ
SHULRGDRVWDFLGDPLMH-DNXEEHJD"RGNRMHMHSUHRVWDRMHGLQRSRGUXPPLQDUHWDQHNDGDQMLKDPDPNRMLMHEOL]X
NRODSVD]DWLPJUDHYLQDNRMRMVHMRQLMHLGHQWLNRYDODIXQNFLMDNRMDMHYMHURYDWQRELODL]RVWDYOMHQDRGVWUDQH
LVWUDLYDDGRVDGD8$SRORQLD/RXWUDQDMH]HUX9ROYLVDXWRULFDMHLGHQWLNRYDODRVPDQVNRWHUPDOQRNXSDWLOR
#('.&0.25(.#.V'.&#.4+N
B!
7KLVHOGZRUNZDVPDGHSRVVLEOHWKDQNVWRVXSSRUWE\WKH%DUDNDW
7UXVW2[IRUG
L$%!*,$#84&80!8("%&4"2&%!#+!"$%!Q#14+@)%&(#-!_(4!P.+4"(4!(*!&4"$%&!
H[WHQVLYH)RUDUHFHQWELEOLRJUDSK\VHH$YUDPHD$QQD7UDFpHW
/#+,"(#+! -%! 84! m+(' 95#($+( GX ,,H VLqFOH DYDQW -& DX 9,H $SUqV
-& LQ T,"' m+(' 95#($+(' 2#)"%' -$$.0(#' \27"' EFHIK/FQGGLK' <(71R.#'
W(R&' +#' !%"$"' AA' hFGGoiF! P-F! P8(546%"$! W4,$4&(4-#2F! Q%"$01+#+K!
&UHWH 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV SS )DVROR 0LFKHOH q(' m+('
95#($+(' A3' )(' C*.77.#+(' "' WR%%(1,+20' ()' <"%(87"R(' qR#8"&$+).&3! i_(4%!
3XEOLFDH 5RPDQDH @ 5RPH ,VWLWXWR *UDFR (GLWRULDOH 5RPDQR
*XWWRUPVHQ 7RUJULP 6 7UDQVUHJLRQDO KLVWRULFDO URDGV LQ
ORFDOODQGVFDSHV9LD(JQDWLDLQ0DFHGRQLDQ*UHHFHLQW+"'9%)"'
i=)%,(48! (**2%K! ;")+$"%%(#"(#' q(#)&1(*"@ 9RO 1R SS
26XOOLYDQ )LUPLQ T,"' 95#($+(#' S(RF! M%'"#+! A66#""K! c4?(-! g!
&KDUOHVSS
EDQLDDQGLQSDUWLFXODUWKHVWUHWFKIURP'XUUsV
"#!L$%**48#+(H(!4+-!"$%+,%!"#!7#+*"4+"(+#)8%F`
Florina
G8#&(+4! (*! "$%! ,4)("48! #/ ! 4! $#1#+01#2*!
+#&"$%&+! V&%%H! )&%/%,"2&%! "$4"! 6#&-%&*! "$%! &%@
JLRQ DURXQG .RUos LQ $OEDQLD WKH )<5 0DFH@
-#+(4!4"!X4H%!O&%*)4!;*#2"$!#/ !:("#84<3!4+-!"$4"!
8(%*!6%"'%%+!"$%!V&%%H!,("(%*!#/ !L$%**48#+(H(!4+-!
U4*"#&(4F!G8#&(+4!(*!48*#!"$%!+%4&%*"!V&%%H!"#'+!
"#! "$%! GIQ! N4,%-#+(4+! 6#&-%&! ;#+80! "$(&"%%+!
H(8#1%"&%*! 4'40<! 4+-! *"4+-*! #+! *8(.$"80! &(*(+.!
JURXQG DERXW P DERYH VHD OHYHO 7KH KLV@
"#&(,!95#($+(!(*!*("24"%-!"#!"$%!"#'+J*!%4*"F!G8#&(+4!
'4*!62(8"!#+!"$%!*("%!#/ !"$%!4+,(%+"!N%8("#+2*3C!
ZKLOHDUFKDHRORJLFDOQGVKDYHSURYHQWKHDUHDV
,#+"(+2#2*!$46("4"(#+!*(+,%!)&%$(*"#&(,!"(1%*F!S"*!
)&%*%+"! +41%3! $#'%?%&3! (*! )%&$4)*! &%84"%-! "#! 4!
:054+"(+%! *%""8%1%+"! +41%-! 7$8#&#+3! '$(,$!
FDPHXQGHU2WWRPDQUXOHLQDQGUHPDLQHG
VRXQWLO
C!
6WRLDQRYLFK7UDMDQ$URXWHW\SHWKH9LD(JQDWLDXQGHU2WWRPDQ
5XOHLQT,"'m+('95#($+('2#)"%'-$$.0(#'\27"SSFLWS
L$(*!(*!'("$#2"!-#26"!%?%+!(+!"$%!,#1)8%"%!46*%+,%!#/ !4&,$4%#8#.(,48!
%?(-%+,%!/!"$(*!)%&(#-3!*(+,%!"$%!+216%&!#/ !Q#14+!1(8%*!/!
9%&4,8(4!X0+,%*"(*!;1#-%&+!:("#84<!"#!N%8("#+2*!;G8#&(+4<!4+-!"$%!
+216%&!#/ !*"4"2"%!1(8%*!;Eb<!481#*"!,#(+,(-%F
91
b!
92
(YOL\k dHOHEL VH\DKDWQkPHVL 9RO (GV <FHO 'DO HW DO ,VWDQEXO
<DS.UHGL<D\QODUS
7KHUHLVQRPHQWLRQRI 2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJVRQRIFLDOZHEVLWHVVXFK
DVKWWSZZZRULQDJURUKWWSZZZFXOWXUHJU
,OO)ORULQDSLFWXUHSRVWFDUGRIPDLQVWUHHWDWWKHWXUQRIWKH
FHQWXU\
,OO)ORULQDWKHUXLQVRIWKHPLQDUHWSRVVLEO\RI<DNXE%HV
!"#$%&'
,(0(0F%oDNoLQKLVERRNRQ7XUNLVKDUFKL@
"%,"2&%! (+! V&%%,%3! &%/%&*! "#! 4! 1(+4&%"J*! &%14(+*!
DVWKHFLW\VRQO\2WWRPDQUHOLFED!S+!4--("(#+!"#!
WKHVHWZRVWUXFWXUHV,LGHQWLHGDWKLUGEXLOGLQJ
GXULQJP\HOGZRUN
2QHRI WKHPRVWLQWHUHVWLQJYLVXDOVRXUFHVIRU
G8#&(+4J*! $(*"#&0! (*! 4! )(,"2&%! )#*",4&-! -4"(+.! "#!
WKHHQGRI WKH"$!,%+"2&0!#&!"$%!%4&80!BD"$!,%+@
"2&0!;(88F!E<F!L$(*!)$#"#.&4)$!)&%*%+"*!4!?(%'!#/ !
WKHIRUPHU2WWRPDQPDLQVWUHHWLQ)ORULQDOLQHG
#+!%4,$!*(-%!'("$!6#"$!*(+.8%@*"#&%0!4+-!"'#@*"#@
&%0! 62(8-(+.*F! S"! (882*"&4"%*! "$%! 14&H%"! 4&%4! '("$!
"$%! ,8#,H! "#'%&! ;&(($' 827"&+<! (+! "$%! 64,H.+-3!
.LHO0DFKLHO)ORULQDLQ7UNL\H'L\DQHW9DNI,VOkP$QVLNORSHGLVL3!
9RO,VWDQEXO7UNL\H'L\DQHW9DNIS
ED %oDNo ,VPDLO <XQDQLVWDQGD 7UN PLPDU HVHUOHULF! S*"4+628K! S=AQ3!
S
DQGEHKLQGLWDQXQLGHQWLHGPLQDUHWVVLOKRXHWWH
:#"$!62(8-(+.*!Z!1#*Y2%!4+-!,8#,H!"#'%&!Z!+#!
8#+.%&!%R(*"F!L$%!)$#"#.&4)$!$4&-80!488#'*!2*!"#!
QGVLPLODULWLHVEHWZHHQWKHFORFNWRZHULQ)OR@
&(+4!4+-!*"(88!*"4+-(+.!#+%*3!*2,$!4*!"$4"!(+!+%4&60!
:("#843! '$(,$! -4"%*! "#! "$%! Ea"$! ,%+"2&0h! 62"! 4"!
8%4*"!'%!,4+!,#+,82-%!"$4"!G8#&(+4!'4*!#+,%!48*#!
%Y2())%-!'("$!*2,$!4!62(8-(+.F!A*!/#&!"$%!%R"4+"!
VWUXFWXUHVLQWKHFLW\VRQO\WKUHH2WWRPDQ
62(8-(+.*!'%&%!"$%!/#88#'(+.K
7KHUVWLVWKHEDVHPHQWRI DIRUPHUPLQDUHW
LOO ORFDWHG DW 3DSDNRQ 1RX 1HUHWLV 1R
:2(8"!4,,#&-(+.!"#!"$%!*#@,488%-!.*"%('0+&$('"%,$@
+(Y2%3!(+!"$(*!)4&"(,284&!,4*%!"$%!14*#+&0!/%4"2&%*!
"$&%%!&#'*!#/ !6&(,H*!48"%&+4"(+.!'("$!4!840%&!#/ !
*"#+%3! %?%&0! *"#+%! *%)4&4"%-! /! "$%! #"$%&! 60!
*%?%&48!?%&"(,48!6&(,H*F!L$%!)$#"#.&4)$!*2..%*"*!
"$4"!"$%!&%14(+*!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"J*!*$4/"!'%&%!*(1(@
,OO)ORULQDWKHUHPDLQVRIWKHVRFDOOHG%\]DQWLQHNDVWHOORV
93
84&80!14-%!#/ !6&(,HF!L$%!1(+4&%"J*!64*%1%+"!$4*!
*(R!%Y248!*(-%*3!'$(8%!"$%!*%?%+"$!*(-%!;#&(.(+4880!
4""4,$%-!"#!"$%!1#*Y2%<!(*!84&.%&!4+-!$#*"*!"$%!
4,,%**!-##&F!O4&"!#/ !"$%!'(+-(+.!*"4(&,4*%!(*!*"(88!
?(*(68%! %?%+! (/ ! "$%! 4,,%**! (*! (+/%*"%-! 60! $2.%!
.&#'(+.!"$(*"8%*F
7KHVHFRQGEXLOGLQJLOOVLVVLWXDWHGQRW
/4&!/!"$%!1(+4&%"!4+-!(*!8#,4"%-!4"!"$%!(+"%&@
*%,"(#+!#/ !G#28%-4H(!4+-!P8%/"$%&(4*!*"&%%"3!64*(@
,4880!4"!"$%!64+H!#/ !"$%!=4H#28%?4*!Q(?%&F!X#,48*!
FDOO LW WKH %\]DQWLQH &DVWOH SUREDEO\ IRU LWV
14*#+&0F!L$(*!(*!4!)4&"(,284&80!(+"%&%*"(+.!62(8-@
(+.3!"$%!*(1)8%!%R"%&(#&!#/ !'$(,$!(*!/#&1%-!#2"!
#/ !"'#!(&&%.284&!*"#+%'#&H!'488*F!L$%!*(-%!#/ !"$%!
62(8-(+.! 8#,4"%-! #+! P8%/"$%&(4*! (*! 4-#&+%-! '("$!
4! *1488! '(+-#'3! *2&1#2+"%-! 60! 4+! 4&,$! 14-%!
RI EULFNV 7KH RULJLQDO ZRRGHQ OLQWHO LV VWLOO
?(*(68%F!L$%!462+-4+"!?%.%"4"(#+!.&#'(+.!#+!"$%!
HGLFHUHQGHUVYLHZLQJWKHVLGHWRZDUGV)RXOHGD@
NL6WUHHWGLIFXOW$FFHVVWRWKHEXLOGLQJVLQWHULRU
(*3!1#&%#?%&3!&%*"&(,"%-!60!64&6%-!'(&%F!M#+%"$%@
OHVVDYDXOWHGRUGRPHGVSDFHFRXOGEHLGHQWLHG
(+!("*!(+"%&(#&3!4*!'%88!4*!"'#@4+-@4@$48/ !)#(+"%-!
DUFKHVGHFRUDWLQJWKHZDOO7KHUVWSRLQWHGDUFK
(*!&%4880!4!+(,$%!(+!"$%!'488F!L$%!,%(8(+.!4+-!'488*!
DUHPDGHRI QHEULFNZRUN6FKRODUO\OLWHUDWXUH
,#+"4(+*!+#!&%/%&%+,%!"#!"$(*!62(8-(+.F!7#+*(-%&@
(+.! ("*! ?(,(+("0! "#! "$%! &2(+%-! 1(+4&%"3! #+%! 140!
*2&1(*%!"$4"!"$%0!'%&%!6#"$!)4&"!#/ !"$%!*41%!)(@
#2*!/#2+-4"(#+3!4+-!)#**(680!"$4"!"$%0!'%&%!)4&"!
RI WKH<DNXE%HFRPSOH[,QDVRXUFHUHIHUUHG
"#! 60! A0?%&-(! 4*! "$%! 0DQDVWU WDULKoHVL ULVDOHVL3!
WKHUH DUH UHIHUHQFHV WR WKUHH HGLFHV UHODWHG WR
<DNXE%HDPRVTXHDQ+0(%"$3!4+-!4!0"8$":FEE!
EE $\YHUGL (NUHP +DNN $YUXSDGD 2VPDQO PLPkUv HVHUOHUL3! _#8F! `F!
,VWDQEXO,VWDQEXO)HWLK&HPL\HWL>@S
,OO)ORULQDWKHLQWHULRURIWKHNDVWHOORV
94
T+/#&"2+4"%803!(+!"$%!46*%+,%!#/ !4+0!4&,$4%#8#.(@
,48!*2&?%0!#+!"$%!*2&+-(+.!4&%43!4+-!#+80!(+!
4+"(,()4"(#+! #/ ! 4! 1#&%! *26*"4+"(48! *"2-0! #/ ! "$%!
*#2&,%*!4?4(8468%3!'%!,4++#"!.#!6%0#+-!1%&%!4*@
*21)"(#+*!4+-!4+!%?#,4"(?%!$0)#"$%*(*F
L$%!"$(&-!62(8-(+.!(*!*("24"%-!/4&"$%&!/!"$%!
#"$%&! "'#! 62"! (*! 48*#! 8#,4"%-! +%4&! "$%! 64+H! #/ !
WKH ULYHU 6DNRXOHYDV DORQJ ZKLFK WKH 2WWRPDQ
,("0!$4-!-%?%8#)%-!;(88F!C<F!7#?%&%-!60!?%.%"4"(#+3!
#+,%!2*%-!4*!4!*$%8"%&!/#&!)##&!)%#)8%!4+-!+#'!
%1)8#0%-!4*!4!)268(,!-21)(+.!.+-3!"$%!62(8-@
(+.!(*!4!*1488!,(0(0'+%4&!,#884)*%F!L$%!%R"%&(#&!
(*!14-%!#2"!#/ !*"#+%'#&HF!_%&"(,48!6&(,H*!/&41%!
"$%!%+"&4+,%!-##&F!S+!"$%!&(.$"!'4883!+%R"!"#!"$%!
%+"&4+,%3!(*!4!*1488!&%,"4+.284&!+(,$%F!L'#!&##1*!
,#1)#*%! "$%! (+"%&(#&! #/ ! "$%! ,(0(03! '$(,$! (*!
)84*"%&%-F!X(.$"(+.!(*!)&#?(-%-!60!*Y24&%@*$4)%-!
#)%+(+.*!(+!"$%!-#1%F!L$%*%!#)%+(+.*!/#&1!4+!
(+"%&%*"(+.!-%,#&4"(?%!1#"(/K!-%*(.+%-!4,,#&-(+.!
"#!4!.%#1%"&(,48!)4""%&+3!"$%*%!8(.$"!,$4++%8*!)&#@
,OO)ORULQDWKHVWLOOVWDQGLQJKDPDP
,OO$SROORQLD/RXWUjWKHRFWDJRQDOEXLOGLQJH[WHULRU
95
96
,OO$SROORQLD/RXWUjQLFKHVDQGWKHRFWDJRQDOEDVLQ
Apollonia Loutr
U$#8#1%+-4*!*"&%413!2)#+!"$%!2))%&!,#2&*%!#/ !
'$(,$!*"4+-*!"$%!?(884.%!#/ !N%8(**2&.#*F!CB!H(8#@
PHWUHVIURP7KHVVDORQLNLLV/RXWUjZKHUHWKHUH
4&%!$#"!4+-!*28)$2*!1%-(,(+48!'4"%&*!?(*("%-!
E\WKHZHOONQRZQ2WWRPDQWUDYHOOHUV0HKPHG
$LNDQG(YOL\DdHOHELEB
7KH2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJLQTXHVWLRQLOOVLV
8#,4"%-! (+! 4+! 464+-#+%-! 4&%4! 6%"'%%+! "$%! ,2&@
&%+"!"$%&148!64"$*!4+-!"$%!?(884.%!#/ !M%4!A)#8@
8#+(43!#+!"$%!*$#&%!#/ !X4H%!_#8?(*F!S"*!8#,4"(#+!
481#*"!#+!"$%!*$#&%!#/ !"$%!84H%!(*!Y2("%!2+2*248K!
L$%!;(#&+.'C*.77.#+('sA3!4*!("!(*!&%/%&&%-!"#!(+!
WKHHDUO\"$@,%+"2&0!a"2$+#5"%'T(:7"3!,#&&%*)#+-*!
"#!"$%!*("%!#/ !"$%!1#-%&+!?(884.%!M%4!A)#88#+(4F!
A))4&%+"803! ("! $4-! 6%%+! /#2+-%-! (+! "$%! /#2&"$!
,%+"2&0!60!"$%!N4,%-#+(4+!H(+.!O%&-(,,4*!4*!4+!
#2")#*"!4.4(+*"!"$%!L$&4,(4+*!4+-!A"$%+(4+*!#+!
"$%! &(?%&! ="&01#+F! L$%! 1#-%&+! ?(884.%! (*! +%4&!
/DNH9ROYLVNQRZQDV%HLN*|OLQ2WWRPDQ
"(1%*<! #+! "$%! *%-(1%+"4&0! 84+-! /#&1%-! 60! "$%!
?(-%-!4!-(//2*%!8(.$"!'$(,$!,#+*"4+"80!,$4+.%-!("*!
#&(%+"4"(#+F! =2,$! *Y24&%! *$4)%-! #)%+(+.*! $4?%!
48*#! 6%%+! /#2+-! (+! "$%! 64"$! 4"! W416%8(#2! 4+-!
c#2H4! *"&%%"*! (+! 7$4+(4! ;7&%"%<3! 4+-! (+! 4! 64"$!
4"!N%"$#+(!;N#-#+<!,4*"8%!(+!"$%!O%8#)#++%*2*F
6HH.LHO0DFKLHO2WWRPDQEXLOGLQJDFWLYLW\DORQJWKH9LD(JQDWLD
WKHFDVHRI 3D]DUJDK.DYDODDQG)HUHFLNLQT,"'m+('95#($+('2#)"%'
-$$.0(#'%27"SS$QGIRUWKHRQO\VXUYH\H[LVWHQWRQWKHUXLQV
RI <HQL%D]DUVHH+DGMLWU\IRQRV(YDQJHOLD2WKRPDQLNR/RXWUR
VWLQ$SROORQLDWLV9ROYLVLQ;(8").#+8(9ROSS
DQGPRUHUHFHQWO\.DQHWDNL(OHQL7KHVWLOOH[LVWLQJ2WWRPDQ
KDPDPV LQ WKH *UHHN WHUULWRU\ LQ ;9Tj' >.2%#(7' .B ' C%1,+$"1$2%"3!
_#8F!BE3!M#F!E@B!;BDD`<3!))F!aE@EED!;48*#!4?4(8468%!#+8(+%!4"!$"")K\\
MIDDUFKPHWXHGXWUDUFKLYHFLOWVD\LB
EEDF)-/<F
,48!*2&?%0!6%/#&%!4+0!'#&H!#/ !,#+*#8(-4"(#+!#&!
&%*"#&4"(#+F
L$(*! (+"&(.2(+.! 62(8-(+.3! '$(,$! S! -(*,#?%&%-!
-2&(+.!"$%!*211%&!BDDb!*2&?%03!'4*!"$%+!)26@
8(*$%-!60!9%4"$!X#'&0!(+!#+%!#/ !$(*!&%,%+"!6##H*3!
LQDFKDSWHURQWKH2WWRPDQKRWVSULQJFXOWXUH
(+! N4,%-#+(4FE`! :%/#&%! X#'&0J*! "%R"*3! "$%! #+80!
&%/%&%+,%! "#! "$4"! 62(8-(+.! S! 41! 4'4&%! #/ ! '4*! 4!
)&#)#*48!/#&!&%*"#&4"(#+!60!4!0#2+.!V&%%H!4&,$(@
"%,"FEC!L$(*!)&#>%,"3!)&%*%+"%-!(+!BDDb3!)&#)#*%-!
"$%!62(8-(+.J*!"#"48!&%,#+*"&2,"(#+!&4"$%&!"$4+!("*!
&%*"#&4"(#+F! L$(*! '#28-! ,%&"4(+80! ,#1)(*%!
"$%!)%,28(4&!,$4&1!#/ !"$(*!8(""8%!62(8-(+.!*%"!(+!"$%!
6%42"(/28!84+-*,4)%!*2&+-(+.!"$%!84H%F!
97
98
)RUWKHKLVWRU\RI 3RLWHOMVHHHOL'HPDO3RLWHOMQD1HUHWYL
(+K!O4HVWDULQH9ROSS
())*+
,("0!'488*!(+!"$%!M%&%"?4!?488%0F!L$%!&%,%+"!'4&!(+!
%RVQLD DQG +HU]HJRYLQD DOVR FRQWULE@
XWHGWRWKHGHWHULRUDWLRQRI 3RLWHOM
A8"$#2.$! "$%! 94.2%! 7#+?%+"(#+! /#&! "$%!
O&#"%,"(#+! #/ ! 728"2&48! O&#)%&"0! (+! "$%! P?%+"!
RI $UPHG &RQLFW ZDV UDWLHG E\ WKH
)HGHUDO 3HRSOHV 5HSXEOLF RI <XJRVODYLD RQ
'HFHPEHU WKH UHFHQW ZDU ZLWQHVVHG D
6&2"48! -%*"&2,"(#+3! -%.&4-4"(#+3! 4+-! -%1#8("(#+!
RI FXOWXUDO KHULWDJH 3RLWHOMV YDOXDEOH KLVWRULF
62(8-(+.*! '%&%! 48*#! 4//%,"%-! 60! "$(*! 4"&#,(#2*!
-%?4*"4"(#+F! L$(*! (*! )4(+/2880! (882*"&4"%-! 60! "$%!
VHYHUHO\GDPDJHGPRVTXHRI +DGL$OLMDZKLFK
FRPSOHWHGLQLVDUWLVWLFDOO\WKHPRVWYDOX@
DEOHEXLOGLQJLQ3RLWHOM7KLVGRPHG"$@,%+"2&0!
EXLOGLQJWDUJHWHGLQZDVRQHRI WKHPRVW
6%42"(/28! (+! :#*+(4! 4+-! 9%&5%.#?(+4F! L$(*! 6%@
,#1%*! Y2("%! 4))4&%+"! '$%+! #+%! ,#+*(-%&*! "$%!
)&#)#&"(#+*!#/ !("*!/#&148!62(8-(+.!%8%1%+"*3!"$%!
GHOLFDF\RI WKHLUDSSHDUDQFHDQGWKHQHRUQD@
1%+"*!,4&?%-!(+!*"#+%!4+-!"$%!)&%,(*(#+!#/ !"$%(&!
%R%,2"(#+F!L$%!-0+41("%!%R)8#*(#+!"$4"!#,,2&&%-! 99
"$%!64*%!4+-!#+!"$%!1(--8%!,#821+J*!,4)("48!
;8%/"!#/ !"$%!%+"&4+,%!"#!"$%!1#*Y2%<h!
"$%! 1(+4&%"! 481#*"! ,#1)8%"%80! ,#884)*%-!
%R,%)"! /#&! #+%! #/ ! "$%! "2&&%"J*! )#80.#+@
*$4)%-!/#2+-4"(#+!*"#+%*!4+-!4!/%'!*"#+%!
*"%)*h
%R"%+*(?%!4+-!-4+.%*!,&4,H*!'%&%!/#2+-!
(+!"$%!'488*3!")*3!%16&4*2&%*3!4+-!'(+@
-#'*!4->4,%+"!"#!"$%!1(+4&%"h
"$%!*"#+%!'(+-#'!/&41%*!'%&%!6&#H%+!4+-!
-(*)84,%-h
"$%! 0(,4+7' ;L2&H(*$! PDKO<! ,#884)*%-3! "$%!
0+0:"%';0+#:"%<!'4*!)4&"80!-%1#8(*$%-!4+-!
"$%!$%(#X"#(*!'%&%!6&#H%+h
WKHZDOOGHFRUDWLRQVIURPZHUHGDP@
4.%-h
"$%! ,&#'+! #/ ! "$%! ,%+"2&(%*@#8-! ,0)&%**! (+!
IURQWRI WKHPRVTXHZDVVLJQLFDQWO\GDP@
4.%-h
4*!"$%!&%*28"!#/ !8#+.!%R)#*2&%!"#!&4(+3!*2+3!
'(+-3! /&%Y2%+"! %4&"$! "&%1#&*3! .&#'(+.!
'%%-*3!4+-!*"#+%!"$%/"*!;/!"$%!62(8-(+.!
4+-!*2&+-(+.!4&%4<!"$%!8%?%8!#/ !-414.%!
KDVLQFUHDVHGVLQFHZKHQWKLVDUHDZDV
OPHG
&RQVLGHULQJ WKH VLJQLFDQFH RI 3RLWHOM DV D
?482468%! ,28"2&48! 4+-! $(*"#&(,! %+?(&#+1%+"3! 4+-!
/#88#'(+.!"$%!(+("(4"(?%!#/ !"$%!G%-%&48!N(+(*"&0!#/ !
O$0*(,48!O84++(+.3!"$%!V#?%&+1%+"!#/ !"$%!:(9!
())'*,
())'*-
-2&(+.!"$%!&%,%+"!'4&!,42*%-!(11%+*%!-414.%!"#!
WKHPRVTXHLOOV$VWXG\FDUULHGRXWLQ-XO\
BDDE!&%)#&"%-!"$%!/#88#'(+.!-414.%K
"$%! 14(+! ,2)#84! -#1%! ,#884)*%-! (+"#! "$%!
)&40(+.!4&%4!4+-!#+80!)4&"*!#/ !"$%!"4162&3!
'$(,$!*2))#&"%-!("3!&%14(+%-!)4&"(4880!2+@
-414.%-h
"$%! )#&,$! )4&"(4880! ,#884)*%-! ;E! w! *1488!
,2)#84*3!6&#H%+!4&,$%*3!"'#!,#821+*!'("$!
64*%*! 4+-! ,4)("48*<F! 7#+*%Y2%+"803! "$%!
*%?%&%! -%/#&14"(#+*! #/ ! ("*! (&#+! >#(*"*! 4+-!
*$(/"%-! '%(.$"! ,42*%-! *%&(#2*! -414.%! 4"!
100
,OO
9ODGD)HGHUDFLMH%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQH9EURM
=4&4>%?#F
2QWKHUHYLWDOL]DWLRQRI KLVWRULF3RLWHOMPRUHJHQHUDOO\VHH%DUDNDW
=28"4+! 4+-! 7&4(.! [(8*#+F! T,"' \"4+$(7+X($+.#' .B ' $,"' ,+&$.%+1' &"$$7"0"#$'
3RLWHOM1#<RUN8QLYHUVLW\RI <RUN%HJL$]UDDQG9MHNRVODYD
6DQNRYL 6LPL ,QWHUQDWLRQDO DUW FRORQ\ 3RLWHOM 6DUDMHYR 8GUXHQMH
OLNRYQLKXPMHWQLND%L+6DQNRYL9MHNRVODYD5HYLWDOL]DFLMD
VWDURJJUDGD3RLWHOMDLQ1DHVWDULQH9ROSS
HDGHP/D5LYLWDOL]D]]LRQHGHOODFLWWDGL3RLWHOMLQW+"1+'$"&+'
)+' %"&$(2%.# EFGnK/FGIFLN! Q#1%K! T+(?%&*("4! -%.8(! *"2-(! -(# 5RPD /D
6DSLHQ]D
(+*"("2"%-!"#!,##&-(+4"%!,#+*"&2,"(#+!4+-!(1)8%@
1%+"4"(#+! #/ ! "$(*! )84+3! ("*! 14(+! &%*)#+*(6(8("0!
6%(+.! )&#/%**(#+483! #6>%,"(?%3! 4+-! +#+@)4&"(*4+!
-%8(6%&4"(#+!#+!488!&%8%?4+"!(**2%*F!
,OO
,OO
102
,OO
`!
S+!#&-%&!"#!*%8%,"!4!"%41!/#&!"$%!)&#-2,"(#+!#/ !
488!+%,%**4&0!"%,$+(,48!-#,21%+"4"(#+!4+-!*2)%&@
YLVLRQRI WKH+DGL$OLMLQDPRVTXHUHYLWDOL]DWLRQ
)&#,%**3! 4+! #)%+! (+"%&+4"(#+48! "%+-%&! '4*! 4+@
+#2+,%-3!'("$!"$%!*%8%,"(#+!)&#,%**J*!&%8%?4+"!,&(@
WHULDSUHFLVHO\GHQHG7KHFRPSHWLWLRQZDVZRQ
60!"$%!8%4*"!%R)%+*(?%!)&#>%,"3!)&#)#*%-!60!"$%!
,OO
,OO
103
,OO
104
C!
488!#"$%&!&%8%?4+"!-%"4(8*F!T+/#&"2+4"%803!"$%!)#@
"%+"(48!#/ !"$(*!,#1)&%$%+*(?%!,4"48#.2%!'4*!+#"!
%R$42*"%-! 60! "$%! 4&,$("%,"*! -2&(+.! "$%! )&#,%**!
#/ ! &%*"#&4"(#+F! S+! "$%! )&#>%,"J*! -#,21%+"4"(#+!
"$%0! ,$#*%! +#"! "#! (+-(,4"%! "$%! %R4,"! )84,%1%+"!
RI HYHU\LGHQWLHGIUDJPHQW7KLVRPLVVLRQSR@
"%+"(4880!%+-4+.%&%-!)&#)%&!&%*"#&4"(#+!4+-!4+4@
*"08#*(*F! S+! #&-%&! "#! 4?#(-! -%"&(1%+"48! &%*28"*! ("!
'4*!+%,%**4&0!/#&!"$%!"%41!#/ !%R)%&"*!"#!6%,#1%!
4,"(?%! 4"! *"4.%*! #/ ! "$%! '#&H! )&#,%**! "$%0! '%&%!
+#"!(+("(4880!4**(.+%-!"#3!/#&!("!'4*!(1)%&4"(?%!"#!
4?#(-! "$%! *%&(#2*! ,#+*%&?4"(#+! 4+-! &%*"#&4"(#+!
1(*"4H%*! 14-%! (+! "$%! )4*"F! L$%*%! $4-! (+,82-%-!
4+! (+4-%Y24"%! "&%4"1%+"! #/ ! (1)#&"4+"! $(*"#&(,!
1#+21%+"*!60!&4"$%&!/&%%@*"08%!(1)&#?(*4"(#+*FC
())'*++
())'*+,
105
**********())'*+-
)RU VXFK VHH HJ &HVFKL &DUOR T".%+(' "' &$.%+(' )"7' %"&$(2%.3! Q#1%K!
0DULR %XO]RQL (GLWRUH 'H $QGHOLV '2VVDW *XJOLHOPR
f2+)"'$.'$,"'0"$,.)+1(7'&$2)R'.B '0.#20"#$&'(#)!1(2&"&'.B '$,"+%')"$"%+.%($+.#"!
5RPH ,&&520 )HLOGHQ 0 %HUQDUG j4.)' 2' 8.#X"%4+%(#V"'
NXOWXUQRJQDVOMHD7U,YR0DURHYL=DJUHE'UXWYRNRQ]HUYDWRUD
+UYDWVNH A7' 0(#2(7"' )"7' %"&$(2%.' (%1,+$"$$.#+1.F! P-F! X2,4! W%?(F!
Q#1%K3N4+,#*2! P-("#&%3! BDDDB 0DURHYL ,YR Y.#X"%4($.%&8.' #.4.'
+4"%V"F!O%"&(+>4K!N4"(,4!$&?4"*H4!O%"&(+>43!BDDDh!:&2+#3!A+-&%4F!-7$%"'
+7'%"&$(2%.'{'\"&$.%($+.#'(#)':"R.#)F!N(84+K!P-(5(#+(!X06&4!S114.(+%3!
6DQNRYL 6LPL 9MHNRVODYD 5HYLWDOL]DFLMD JUDGLWHOMVNH EDWLQH
+#$"5%(1+V('&$(%./#.4.F!6DUDMHYR1131DDULMHGRR6FKXOOHU!
N4+/&%-F!62+7)+#5'(%1,(".7.5R0XQLFK,&2026
,OO
106
FDVHGXULQJRQHLQWHUYHQWLRQLQWKHVZKLFK
$4-! ,#+*(-%&4680! ,#1)(*%-! "$%! 42"$%+"(,("0!
RI WKH+DGL$OLMLQDPRVTXH
'HVSLWH DOO WKHVH SUREOHPV WKH +DGL $OLMD
1#*Y2%! -%*%&?%*! "$%! 4""%+"(#+! #/ ! 6#"$! "$%!
.%+%&48!)268(,!4+-!,#+*%&?4"(#+!4+-!&%*"#&4"(#+!
%R)%&"*F! 7#+*%Y2%+"80! '%! *$#28-! 6%! ?%&0! *4"(*@
HGZLWKWKHUHVXOWVDFKLHYHG7KHUHFRQVWUXFWHG
1#*Y2%!'(883!(+!("*!6%42"03!6%Y2%4"$!4!)4&"(,284&!
*)(&("248("0!4+-!,#1/#&"!"#!("*!14+0!?(*("#&*!4+-!
"#! "$#*%! '$#! '#&*$()! "$%&%F! L$%! -%*(&%-! 2+("0!
'4*! 4,$(%?%-! (+! 4,,#&-4+,%! '("$! ,#+"%1)#&4&0!
4)),$%*! 4+-! "%,$+(Y2%*! (+! ,28"2&48! $%&("4.%!
14+4.%1%+"F! 7#+*(-%&(+.! "$%! 14+0! (+*"4+,%*!
(+!'$(,$!$(*"#&(,!62(8-(+.*!-%*"�%-!(+!"$%!'4&!
$4?%!6%%+!&%+#?4"%-!4+-!"&4+*/#&1%-!(+!4+!414@
"%2&(*$!'403!'%!$#)%!"$4"!"$(*!%R41)8%!'(88!$4?%!
4!)#*("(?%!(1)4,"!4+-!&4(*%!4'4&%+%**!#/ !"$%!,2&@
&%+"! *"4+-4&-*! (+! ,#+*%&?4"(#+3! &%*"#&4"(#+! 4+-3!
(+!)4&"(,284&3!&%,#+*"&2,"(#+!'#&HF!
107
Zeynep Ahunbay
108
7KHDXWKRUGLVFXVVHVWKHUHFHQWUHVWRUDWLRQRI WKH+DGP6OH\PDQ$DPRVTXHLQ*MDNRYDORFDOO\NQRZQ
DVWKH+DGXP0RVTXHZKLFKZDVDPRQJWKHEXLOGLQJVGDPDJHGLQWKHDUPHGFRQLFWLQ.RVRYR$Q
+#+$+($+4"'$.'%"&$.%"'$,"').0")'7($"/FQ$,/1"#$2%R'0.&]2"'P(&'7(2#1,")':R'$,"'jU/:(&")'Y.&.4.'!27$2%(7'<"%+$(5"'
a%.V"1$M'&2**.%$")':R'$,"'a(18(%)'b.2#)($+.#_'$,"R'1,.&"'!27$2%(7'<"%+$(5"'P+$,.2$'6.%)"%&'E!<P6L'(&'$,"+%'
+0*7"0"#$+#5'*(%$#"%'E$,+&'*%.V"1$'&2*"%&")")'(#'"(%7+"%'.#"':R'U(2)+'+#&$+$2$+.#&'P,+1,'(+0")'($':2+7)+#5'#"P'
PRVTXHVUDWKHUWKDQUHVWRULQJKLVWRULFDORQHV7KHZRUNRQWKHVLWHVXSHUYLVHGE\WKH.RVRYR&+Z%RIFHVWDUWHG
P+$,'$,"'2%5"#$'%"*(+%&'(#)'$,"'&"(%1,'B.%'%"&$.%($+.#'0($"%+(7&N'U"4"%(7'"@*"%$&'P"%"'+#4.74")'+#'$,"'1.#&"%4($+.#'.B '
P..)'(#)'&$.#"M'*(+#$")')"1.%($+.#&M'(#)'5R*&20'P+#).P&N'b.%$2#($"7RM'$,"'0.&]2"')+)'#.$',(4"'&"%+.2&'&$%21$2%(7'
*%.:7"0&N'S.%8&,.*&M'&21,'(&'B.%'&$.#"'1.#&"%4($+.#'.%'7"()/7(R+#5M'P"%"'.%5(#+X")'.#/&+$"'$.'$%(+#'$,"'*%.V"1$'
P.%8"%&N'\"1.#&$+$2$+.#'.B '0+&&+#5'"7"0"#$&'*%.4+)")'(')+BB"%"#$'1,(77"#5"M'(&'$,"'0.&]2"',()'#.$':""#'$,.%.25,7R'
%"1.%)")':"B.%"'$,"'P(%N'U+0+7(%7R'1,(77"#5+#5'P(&'$,"'1.#&"%4($+.#'.B '*(+#$")'P(77'&2%B(1"&M'P,+1,'(11.2#$'$.'('
JUHDWH[WHQWIRUWKHPRVTXHVDUWKLVWRULFDOVLJQLFDQFH'DWLQJWRWKH$,'1"#$2%RM'P,"#'$,"R'P"%"'*(+#$")'.4"%'('
FQ$,/1"#$2%R'7(R"%')+&1.4"%")'+#'$,"'1.2%&"'.B '$,"'%"&$.%($+.#'*%.1"&&M'$,"&"'02%(7&')"*+1$'7(#)&1(*"&'(#)'(7&.'7.1(7'
HOHPHQWVVXFKDVWKHIRUWLHGUHVLGHQFHVNQRZQDVNXOODSDLQWHGE\ZKDWPXVWKDYHEHHQDORFDODUWLVW7KH
*%.V"1$'P(&'&211"&&B277R'1.0*7"$")'+#'JKKGN'
$XWRULFD GLVNXWXMH R QHGDYQRM UHVWDXUDFLML GDPLMH +DGXP 6XOHMPDQDJH X DNRYLFL ORNDOQR SR]QDWRM
NDR+DGXPGDPLMDNRMDMHNDRLEURMQHGUXJHELODMDNRXQLWHQDXRUXDQRPVXNREXQD.RVRYX
,QLFLMDWLYD]DUHVWDXUDFLMXSRWNXSROQHGDPLMHL]YLMHNDMHGRODRGVWUDQHDPHULNHQHYODGLQHRUJDQL]DFLMH
.&+SRGUDQRPRGVWUDQH3DNDUGIRQGDFLMHNRMLVXL]DEUDOLIRQGDFLMX.XOWXUQRQDVOLMHHEH]JUDQLFD]DVYRJ
SDUWQHUDXLPSOHPHQWDFLML2YDMSURMHNDWMH]DPLMHQLRUDQLMLSULMHGORHQRGVWUDQHVDXGLMVNHLQVWLWXFLMHNRMDMH
KWMHODUDGLMHGDL]JUDGLQRYXGDPLMXQHJRGDREQRYLKLVWRULMVNLVSRPHQLN5DGRYLQDJUDHYLQLVXELOLQDGJOH/
GDQLRGVWUDQH&+Z%NDQFHODULMHQD.RVRYXD]DSRHWLVXKLWQLPSRSUDYNDPDLSRWUDJRP]DUHVWDXUDWRUVNLP
PDWHULMDOLPD1HNROLNRVWUXQMDNDMHELORXNOMXHQRXSURFHVVUHVWDXUDFLMHGUYHWDLNDPHQDVOLNDQLKGHNRUDFLMD
LJLSVDQLKSUR]RUD1DVUHXGDPLMDQLMHLPDODYHLKNRQVWUXNWLYQLKSUREOHPD5DGLRQLFHVFLOMHPREXDYDQMD
PDMVWRUDQDWHPHNDRWRVXNRQ]HUYDFLMDNDPHQDLOLVWDYOMDQMHSRNULYDDRGRORYDQDNXSROXVXELOHRUJDQL]RYDQH
QDVDPRPJUDGLOLWX5HNRQVWUXNFLMDQHGRVWDMXLKGLMHORYDMHSUHGVWDYOMDODUD]OLLWHL]D]RYHMHUGDPLMDQLMHELOD
&#+07V"#('*%+V"'%($(N'>")#(8.'+X(X.4#.'V"':+7('+'%"&$(2%(1+V('&7+8(#+,'X+)#+,'*7.,(M'8.V"'&2'*%")&$(47V(7('4".0('
YDDQVHJPHQWXXPMHWQLNRKLVWRULMVNRP]QDDMXGDPLMH'DWLUDMXL]YLMHNDNDGDVXELOHSUHVOLNDQHSUHNR
VORMD L] YLMHND NRML MH RWNULYHQ GMHOLPLQR WRNRP SURFHVD UHVWDXUDFLMH GHNRUDFLMX LQH VWLOL]RYDQL SHM]DL L
ORNDQLHOHPHQWLNDRWRVXWUDGLFLRQDOQHNXHNXOHWDNRGDVXYMHURYDWQRQDVWDOHRGVWUDQHORNDOQLKXPMHWQLND
3URMHNDWMHXVSMHQRQDOL]LUDQXJ
!"#$+*#+$%&,(*/1/'-$1#-%&+!U#*#?4!6%,41%!
SDUWRI WKH2WWRPDQVWDWHEHWZHHQWKHODWH"$!
4+-!"$%!1(-@EC"$!,%+"2&0F!=%?%&48!2&64+!,%+"&%*!
'%&%! -%?%8#)%-! '("$! "$%! /#2+-4"(#+! #/ ! &%8(@
.(#2*! 4+-! %-2,4"(#+48! /4,(8("(%*3! 64"$*3! 6&(-.%*3!
DQGFDUDYDQVDULHV3ULVKWLQD3HMD3H3UL]UHQ
DQG *MDNRYR DUH WRZQV ZLWK VLJQLFDQW 2WWR@
14+!1#+21%+"*!*"%11(+.!/!"$%!EC"$!"#!"$%!
"$FHQWXULHV$IWHUWKHUHWUHDWRI WKH2WWRPDQV
/!"$%!:48H4+*3!U#*#?4!2+-%&'%+"!4!)%&(#-!
RI WXUPRLODQGQDOO\EHFDPHSDUWRI <XJRVOD@
YLD8QGHU<XJRVODYUXOHVRPHRI WKH2WWRPDQ
1#+21%+"*!'%&%!&%.(*"%&%-!4*!+4"(#+48!1#+2@
1%+"*!4+-!)&#"%,"%-!60!"$%!*"4"%F!=#1%3!'$(,$!
ZHUH QRW UHJDUGHG DV ZRUWK\ RI FODVVLFDWLRQ
'%&%!14(+"4(+%-!60!"$%!8#,48!)%#)8%!4+-!P(]B&F!
N#+21%+"*! (+! U#*#?4! '%&%! +#"! 4//%,"%-!
60! "$%! '4&! (+! :#*+(4F! A/"%&! "$%! c40"#+! O%4,%!
A.&%%1%+"3!U#*#?4!&%14(+%-!'("$(+!4!"&2+,4"%-!
I2.#*84?(43!&%+41%-!=%&6(4!4+-!N#+"%+%.&#!(+!
.RVRYD IRUPHG SDUW RI WKH 6HUELDQ KDOI
RI WKLV VWDWH WKDW ZRXOG EH GLVVROYHG LQ
%HWZHHQDQGZKHQ.RVRYDGHFODUHG
(+-%)%+-%+,%!/!=%&6(43!"$%!)&#?(+,%!'4*!2+@
-%&!TM!4-1(+(*"&4"(#+F!G#88#'(+.!"$%!6&%4H@2)!
#/ ! I2.#*84?(43! "$%! &%.(*"%&%-! $(*"#&(,! 62(8-(+.*!
*2*"4(+%-!"$%(&!*"4"2*!4+-!'%&%!)&#"%,"%-!60!"$%!
8#,48!S+*"("2"%*!/#&!"$%!O&#"%,"(#+!#/ !N#+21%+"*!
4-1(+(*"%&%-!/!:%8.&4-%F!L#'4&-*!"$%!%+-!#/ !
"$%!BD"$!,%+"2&03!4*!"%+*(#+!%*,484"%-!6%"'%%+!"$%!
=%&6(4+! .#?%&+1%+"! 4+-! "$%! A864+(4+! 14>#&("0!
LQ .RVRYD WKH 2WWRPDQ PRQXPHQWV EHFDPH
"4&.%"*F
N4+0! $(*"#&(,! 62(8-(+.*! '%&%! 4""4,H%-! 4+-!
UD]HGWRJURXQGGXULQJWKHDUPHGFRQ@
LFW LQ .RVRYD 7KLV FDOOHG IRU LQWHUQDWLRQDO
*#8(-4&("0F! P//#&"*! '%&%! ,#+,%+"&4"%-! "#! &%*"#&%!
,OO+DGXP0RVTXHEHIRUHGHVWUXFWLRQFRXUWHV\RI,30
*MDNRYD
109
110
,OO3RUFKDIWHUUHVWRUDWLRQ
)4&"+%&3!'#&H(+.!(+!,##)%&4"(#+!'("$!"$%!$%&("4.%!
-(?(*(#+!#/ !"$%!N(+(*"&0!#/ !728"2&%3!"$%!S+*"("2"%!
/#&! O&#"%,"(#+! #/ ! N#+21%+"*3! 4+-! "$%! S*841(,!
=#,(%"0!(+!V>4H#?4F
T*248803!"$%!84+-*,4)%*!)4(+"%-!#+!"$%!'488*!4+-!
,%(8(+.*!#/ !14+*(#+*!4+-!1#*Y2%*!(+,82-%-!)4+@
#&414*!#/ !S*"4+628!%16%88(*$%-!'("$!(14.%*!#/ !
94.(4!=#)$(43!4+-!(1)%&(48!1#*Y2%*!4+-!)484,%*F!
S+! U#*#?4! 4+-! A864+(43! *#1%! +%'! 1#*Y2%*!
ZHUH EXLOW DQG RWKHUV UHQRYDWHG LQ WKH "$!
,%+"2&0F`!L$%!)4(+"%-!-%,#&4"(#+!#/ !"$%*%!1#+2@
PHQWV UHHFWV WKH VW\OH RI WKH HUD 7KH TXDOLW\
#/ ! "$%! '#&H! 4+-! "$%! *26>%,"! #/ ! "$%! 84+-*,4)%!
-%)%+-%-!#+!"$%!4&"(*"F!L$%!4&"(*"!'$#!-%,#&4"%-!
94-21!N#*Y2%!'4*!A$1%-!Q%,%6!94&(h!$%!140!
$4?%!6%%+!/!"$%!&%.(#+!#&!#+%!#/ !*%?%&48!"&4?@
%88(+.!4&"(*"*!%+.4.%-!(+!-%,#&4"(+.!62(8-(+.*F!A*!
,OO(QWUDQFHWRPRVTXHZLWKYHVWLJHVRIUHGDPDJHIURPWKH
ZDU
`!
E!
HXQXFKVDWWKH7RSNDS3DODFHLQ,VWDQEXOE!7#+@
VWUXFWHG DURXQG WKH PRVTXH D PRGHVW
VL]HG PRQXPHQW LQ WKH FRQWH[W RI 2WWRPDQ
4&,$("%,"2&%3! ,#+*(*"%-! #/ ! 4! -#1%-! *"&2,"2&%!
'("$!4!"$&%%@640!)#&"(,#!4+-!4!1(+4&%"F!A!,#1@
)8%R!,#1)&(*(+.!4!8(6&4&03!4!)&(14&0!*,$##83!4+-!
4! .&4?%04&-! -%?%8#)%-! 4+-! "$%! 1#*Y2%F! A+!
#2"%&!)#&,$!'4*!4--%-!"#!"$%!1#*Y2%!4"!4!84"%&!
SRLQWSUREDEO\LQDVQRWHGE\WKH
$%.(&4! -4"%! &%,#&-%-! 46#?%! "$%! %+"&4+,%! "#! "$%!
1#*Y2%F!
7KH PRVTXHV VLJQLFDQFH GHULYHV IURP LWV
GHFRUDWLRQV ZKLFK GDWH IURP WKH "$! ,%+"2&0F!
'HFRUDWLRQ RI KRXVHV DQG PRVTXHV ZLWK RUDO
4&&4+.%1%+"*!4+-!84+-*,4)%*!6%,41%!4!"&%+-!(+!
2WWRPDQ DUFKLWHFWXUH GXULQJ WKH "$! ,%+"2&0FB!
7KHLPSDFWRI (XURSHDQ%DURTXHZDVUHHFWHG
(+! "$%! )%&(#-J*! 4&,$("%,"2&48! -%"4(8*! 4+-! -%,#&4@
"(#+*F! G(&*"3! P2&#)%4+! 4&"(*"*! '#&H(+.! /#&! "$%!
2WWRPDQFRXUWSDLQWHGODQGVFDSHVLQWKHSULYDWH
4)4&"1%+"*! #/ ! "$%! *28"4+! 4+-! $(*! /41(80h! 84"%&3!
8#,48! 4&"(*"*! '%&%! %1)8#0%-! /#&! *(1(84&! )&#>%,"*F!
,OO'HWDLORIGHFRUDWLRQRYHUSRUWDODIWHUUHVWRUDWLRQ
111
,OO2WWRPDQFODVVLFDOSHULRGGHFRUDWLRQRQWKHGRPHRYHUWKH
HQWUDQFHED\FRXUWHV\RISDLQWLQJUHVWRUHU1LKDGHQJL
112
"$%!-%,#&4"(#+!(+!"$%!2))%&!)4&"*!#/ !"$%!94-21!
N#*Y2%! (+?#8?%-! 14+0! 8#,48! 4&,$("%,"2&48! %8%@
1%+"*!8(H%!8277(*!;"#'%&!$#2*%*<3!"$%!4&"(*"!,#28-!
'%88!$4?%!6%%+!/!"$%!&%.(#+F!
War damage to
Hadum Mosque
$WWKHHQGRI 0DUFKDUHZDVVHWLQWKH
"(16%&!#2"%&!)#&,$!;,(R($<!#/ !"$%!1#*Y2%F!G#&"2@
+4"%803!("!'4*!*"#))%-!6%/#&%!("!,#28-!,42*%!-41@
DJHWRWKHLQWHULRU,Q0D\WKHWRSRI WKH
1(+4&%"!'4*!-%*"�%-!60!=%&6(4+!4&1%-!/#&,%*F!
L$%!,#884)*%!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"!#?%&!"$%!8(6&4&0!-41@
"$
4.%-!"$%!+#&"$%&+!)4&"!#/ !"$%!Ea !,%+"2&0!*"&2,@
"2&%F!L$%!)&(14&0!*,$##83!4!"'#@*"#&%0!"&4-("(#+48!
62(8-(+.! '("$! 4! "(16%&! &##/3! '4*! 48*#! -414.%-!
-2&(+.!"$%!4""4,H*F!
A/"%&!"$%!'4&!(+!U#*#?#3!&%8(%/ !4(-!'4*!)&#@
?(-%-!/!=42-(!A&46(4!"#!&%)4(&!"$%!-414.%*F!
T+/#&"2+4"%803! *#1%! #/ ! "$%! '#&H! ,4&&(%-! #2"!
'("$!=42-(!/2+-*!-(-!+#"!1%%"!"$%!(+"%&+4"(#+48!
*"4+-4&-*!#/ !)&%*%&?4"(#+F!L$%!=42-(*!(+"%+-%-!
,OO,QVFULSWLRQGDWHG+
,OO,QWHULRUEHIRUHUHVWRUDWLRQ
,QWKHDXWXPQRI WKH.RVRYR&XOWXUDO
+HULWDJH3URMHFWPDGHDQDJUHHPHQWZLWK&KZ%
"#!,4&&0!#2"!"$%!&%*"#&4"(#+!)&#>%,"F!L$%!4&,$("%,"!
c(,H!=4+-6%&.3!79':J*!U#*#?4!:&4+,$!,##&-(@
+4"#&3!(+?("%-!1%!"#!&%?(%'!"$%!)&#>%,"!)&%)4&%-!
E\3HKOLYDQROXDQGWRKHOSZLWKLWVLPSOHPHQWD@
"(#+F!S!4,,%)"%-!"$%!(+?("4"(#+!4+-!?(*("%-!"$%!*("%!
DWWKHHQGRI -DQXDU\2QO\VPDOOUHYLVLRQV
+%%-%-!"#!6%!14-%!(+!"$%!)&#>%,"3!*#!("!'4*!)#*@
*(68%!"#!*"4&"!("*!(1)8%1%+"4"(#+F!=%54(&!V4/2&&(3! 113
114
4!,(?(8!%+.(+%%&3!'4*!%+.4.%-!4*!"$%!*("%!14+4.%&F!
L$%! U#*#?4! 6&4+,$! #/ ! 79':3! (+! ,#+*28"4"(#+!
'("$!"$%!42"$#&3!*2)%&?(*%-!"$%!&%*"#&4"(#+!'#&HF
L$%!'#&H!#+!"$%!*("%!*"4&"%-!'("$!"$%!2&.%+"!
&%)4(&*! 4+-! "$%! *%4&,$! /#&! &%*"#&4"(#+! 14"%&(48*F!
=%?%&48! %R)%&"*! '%&%! (+?#8?%-! (+! "$%! ,#+*%&?4@
"(#+!#/ !'##-!4+-!*"#+%3!)4(+"%-!-%,#&4"(#+*3!4+-!
.0)*21! '(+-#'*F! G#&"2+4"%803! "$%! 1#*Y2%! -(-!
+#"!$4?%!*%&(#2*!*"&2,"2&48!)D%1*F!G#2+-4"(#+!
&%)4(&!4+-!"$%!(+*"4884"(#+!#/ !4!-&4(+4.%!*0*"%1!
4+-!"$%!64*%!#/ !"$%!1#*Y2%!'4*!(1)#&"4+"!(+!
*"#))(+.!"$%!&(*(+.!-41)F!L$%!4,Y2(*("(#+!#/ !+%'!
14"%&(48*!/#&!"$%!&%*"#&4"(#+!#/ !6&#H%+!%8%1%+"*!
4+-!"$%!,#+*%&?4"(#+!#/ !-%"%&(#&4"%-!*"#+%!'4*!
4+#"$%&! (1)#&"4+"! "4*HF! S+! #&-%&! "#! &%*"#&%! "$%!
*"&2,"2&%J*! 1(**(+.! )4&"*! 4+-! "#! &%)84,%! *#1%!
-%"%&(#&4"%-! #&! 6&#H%+! 68#,H*3! ("! '4*! +%,%**4&0!
WRQGWKHVXLWDEOHPDWHULDOVDQGFUDIWVPHQ6LWH
14+4.%&!V4/2&&(!'4*!468%!"#!.4(+!4,,%**!"#!Y24&@
&(%*!/!'$(,$!+4"2&48!*"#+%*!*(1(84&!"#!"$%!#+%*!
2*%-!(+!"$%!1(+4&%"!'%&%!4,Y2(&%-F!9%!48*#!/#2+-!
4! H(8+! '$(,$! ,#28-! )&#-2,%! $%R4.#+48! 6&(,H*F!
L$2*!("!'4*!)#**(68%!"#!,4&&0!#2"!"$%!&%)4(&*!"#!
WKHPLQDUHWDQGWKHSRUWLFRRRU
G#&!"&4(+(+.!*"#+%!,#+*%&?4"#&*3!4!,#2&*%!'4*!
#&.4+(5%-! 4"! "$%! *("%F! ="#+%! ,#+*%&?4"#&! =(1#+!
[4&&4,H! '4*! (+?("%-! "#! %-2,4"%! "$%! "&4(+%%*3!
*$#'(+.!"$%1!"$%!)&#)%&!'40!"#!&%)4(&!4+-!,#+@
*#8(-4"%!-414.%-!,#821+*!4+-!/4p4-%!%8%1%+"*FC!
=%?%&48! H(+-*! #/ ! *"#+%! $4-! 6%%+! 2*%-! (+! "$%!
,#+*"&2,"(#+! #/ ! "$%! 1#*Y2%F! L$%! ,#821+*! #/ !
"$%! )#&"(,#! '%&%! 14-%! #/ ! 4! *)%,(48! 48464*"&(+%!
OLPHVWRQH)RUWKHIDoDGHVDQHJUDLQHGVDQG@
*"#+%3!4!6&%,,(43!4!,#+.8#1%&4"%3!4+-!4!,48,4&%#2*!
8(1%*"#+%!'%&%!2*%-F!
Q%,#+*"("2"(#+!#/ !1(**(+.!%8%1%+"*!)&#?(-%-!
4!-(//%&%+"!,$488%+.%F!L$%!1#*Y2%!$4-!+#"!6%%+!
"$#.$80! &%,#&-%-! 6%/#&%! "$%! '4&F! N(**(+.!
%8%1%+"*!*2,$!4*!"$%!,#&+(,%*!#/ !"$%!)#&,$!4+-!
"$%!"#)!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"!'%&%!(1)#&"4+"!-%"4(8*!"#!
&%*"#&%F!
L$%! 1(+4&%"! #/ ! 94-21! N#*Y2%! '4*! Y2("%!
$(.$!4+-!("*!648,#+0!$4-!4!/#&1!'$(,$!)ﲨ!
"$
-4"%-! /! 4! &%,#+*"&2,"(#+! 4/"%&! 4! 84"%! Ea @
,%+"2&0!%4&"$Y24H%F! c2&(+.! "$%! '4&! (+! U#*#?43!
C!
[4&&4,H3!=(1#+F!C&&"&&0"#$'(#)'%"1.00"#)($+.#'B.%'$,"'1.#&"%4($+.#'(#)'
%"&$.%($+.#'.B '$,"'&$.#"'($'$,"'<()20';.&]2"M'fV(8.4(!;&%)#&"3!BDD`<F
,OO0LQDUHWDIWHUUHVWRUDWLRQFRXUWHV\RI1LKDGHQJL
"$%!)4&"!46#?%!"$%!648,#+0!;HUHIH<!'4*!-%*"�%-3!
*#!"$%!1(**(+.!)4&"!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"!*$4/"!4+-!"$%!
4&,$%-!-##&!8%4-(+.!"#!"$%!648,#+0!$4-!"#!6%!&%@
,#+*"&2,"%-F!
G#&!"$%!&%,#+*"("2"(#+!#/ !"$%!1(**(+.!-%"4(8*3!
"$%! *2&?(?(+.! )(%,%*! #/ ! "$%! 1(+4&%"! '%&%! *2&@
?%0%-F!L$%*%!840!(+!4!$%4)!(+!"$%!*#2"$'%*"!)4&"!
#/ !"$%!,#2&"04&-F!L$%!)(%,%*!#/ !"$%!)4&4)%"!*846*!
'%&%!*#&"%-!#2"!4+-!6.$"!"#.%"$%&!8(H%!)(%,%*!
RI DMLJVDZSX]]OHWRQGRXWWKHDFWXDOVL]HDQG
-%"4(8*!#/ !"$%!*$4""%&%-!*846*F!L$%&%!'%&%!*#1%!
#8-!)$#"#*!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"3!*$#'(+.!("*!HUHIH!4+-!
,4)3!62"!"$%*%!-(-!+#"!$%8)!12,$!'$%+!("!,41%!"#!
-%"4(8*!8(H%!"$%!1#28-(+.*!4+-!"$%!,4&?%-!-%,#&4@
"(#+F! L$%! *,4""%&%-! 68#,H*! 4+-! /&4.1%+"*! '%&%!
*#&"%-! #2"3! (+! 4+! 4""%1)"! "#! 6&(+.! "#.%"$%&! "$%!
*2&?(?(+.! /&4.1%+"*! #/ ! "$%! )4&4)%"*F! X2,H(803! ("!
'4*! )#**(68%! "#! 4**%168%! "$%! 6&#H%+! )(%,%*! #/ !
"$%!)4&4)%"*F![("$!,#1)8%"%!-4"4!46#2"!"$%!*(5%3!
#)%+(+.*!4"!"$%!"#)!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"!*$4/"!'%&%!(+@
*)%,"%-!/!(+*(-%!4+-!#2"F!L$%!#)%+(+.*!'%&%!
-%%)h!"$%0!'%+"!"$.$!"$%!'$#8%!"$(,H+%**!#/ !
"$%!*$4/"F!L$(*!(+/#&14"(#+!'4*!?482468%!/#&!-%@
?%8#)(+.!"$%!&%*"#&4"(#+!)&#)#*48F!L$2*3!'("$!"$%!
$%8)!#/ !#8-!)$#"#*!4+-!"$%!(+/#&14"(#+!4,Y2(&%-!
IURP%D\UDNO0RVTXHLWZDVSRVVLEOHWRQDOL]H
"$%!-%"4(8(+.!#/ !"$%!1(+4&%"J*!"#)F!
,OO6LJQDWXUHRISDLQWHURYHUDZLQGRZIURPWKHLQWHULRU
115
L$%!,#+*%&?4"(#+!#/ !"$%!)4(+"%-!'488!*2&/4,%*!
4+-!?428"*!'4*!4!,$488%+.(+.!#)%&4"(#+F!L$%!8#,48!
S+*"("2"%!/#&!"$%!O&#"%,"(#+!#/ !N#+21%+"*!$4-!
,#+-2,"%-! 4! &%*"#&4"(#+! #)%&4"(#+! (+! 94-21!
N#*Y2%! 6%/#&%! "$%! '4&F! A/"%&! "$%! 8#**! #/ ! "$%!
,(R($3! "$%! )#&"(,#J*! -%,#&4"(#+*! '%&%! %R)#*%-!
"#! &4(+3! 4+-! *#1%! #/ ! "$%! "#)! )4(+"! 840%&*! '%&%!
'4*$%-!4'40F!L$(*!6.$"!"#!8(.$"!*#1%!#/ !"$%!
RULJLQDO "$ FHQWXU\ 2WWRPDQ &ODVVLFDO VW\OH
-%,#&4"(?%! /%4"2&%*F! S"! '4*! )#**(68%! "#! *%%! "$%!
*2&?(?(+.!)(%,%*!#/ !"$%!#&(.(+48!)4(+"%-!-%,#&4@
"(#+!#+!"$%!)#&"(,#J*!,%+"&48!640!)%+-%+"(?%F!S+!
FRQWUDVWWRWKHHODERUDWH"$!,%+"2&0!-%,#&4"(#+!
RQWKHGRPHRI WKHVDPHED\WKH"$!,%+"2&0!
-%,#&4"(#+!#+!"$%!)%+-%+"(?%*!,#+*(*"%-!#/ !'(-%!
64+-*!#/ !&%-3!'("$!'$("%!8(8(%*!(+!&%8(%/3!)84,%-!4"!
"$%!,#&+%&*F!
116
S+!4--("(#+!"#!"$%!&(,$!)4(+"%-!-%,#&4"(#+*!#+!
"$%! '488*! 4+-! "$%! -#1%*3! 94-21! N#*Y2%! $4-!
?482468%! )4(+"%-! -%,#&4"(#+! #+! ("*! "(16%&! 0(,/
OF! L$%! ,#821+*3! ,2)6#4&-*3! 4+-! ,%(8(+.! #/ ! "$%!
PDKO! '%&%! -%,#&4"%-! '("$! 6&(.$"! ,#8#2&*F! L$%!
-%,#&4"(#+!#/ !"$%!"(16%&!%8%1%+"*3!%*)%,(4880!"$%!
,%(8(+.! #/ ! "$%! PDKO! 4+-! "$%! ,46(+%"*! 4&%! +#"%@
'#&"$0F! L$%! 64,H.+-! (*! .(8-%-! 4+-! "$%! &%-!
RZHUEXGVZLWKOHDYHVKDYHDYLYLGDSSHDUDQFH
L$%!"0)%!#/ !-%,#&4"(#+!4+-!,#8#2&!*,$%1%!&%/%&*!
"#! "$%! P-(&+%! "&4-("(#+! #/ ! '##-! )4(+"(+.F! L$%!
,#821+*!4+-!"$%!6482*"&4-%*!#/ !"$%!PDKO3!#+!"$%!
#"$%&!$4+-3!'%&%!)4(+"%-!(+!4!1#&%!)#)284&!*"08%!
,#++%,"%-!'("$!/#8H!4&"!"&4-("(#+3!'$(,$!#+%!,4+!
*%%!(+!$#&*%!,4&"*3!,&4-8%*3!4+-!"#0*F
A"!"$%!6%.(++(+.!#/ !"$%!)&#>%,"3!,#+*%&?4"#&!
L#-0! 7%54&! '4*! %+.4.%-3! 4+-! *$%! &%*"#&%-! "$%!
HQWUDQFHGRRUZKLFKKDGVXIIHUHGIURPWKH
UH6KHDOVRSUHSDUHGUHSRUWVDERXWWKHFRQGL@
"(#+! #/ ! "$%! )4(+"%-! -%,#&4"(#+! 4+-! $%&! &%,#1@
1%+-4"(#+*!/#&!(1)&#?%1%+"F
&H]DU 7RG\ C&&"&&0"#$' .B ' 02%(7' *(+#$+#5&' +#' Y.&.4.! ;&%)#&"3! BDDB<h!
(-%13! A#$"%+0' (&&"&&0"#$' (#)' %"1.00"#)($+.#&' B.%' $,"' 1.#&"%4($+.#' (#)'
%"&$.%($+.#' .B ' $,"' *(+#$")' &2%B(1"&' ($' s,(0+(' "' <()20M' fV(8.4(M' Y.&.4('
;&%)#&"3!BDD`<F
,OO8SSHUZLQGRZIURPWKFHQWXU\
The graveyard
A/"%&!,#1)8%"(#+!#/ !"$%!-&4(+4.%!*0*"%1!4+-!
"$%! ,#+*%&?4"(#+! #/ ! "$%! -%"%&(#&4"%-! *"#+%*! #+!
"$%! /4p4-%*3! "$%! .&4?%*! (+! "$%! 64,H04&-! #/ ! "$%!
1#*Y2%!'%&%!"&%4"%-!'("$!,4&%F!L$%!.&4?%04&-J*!
84+-*,4)(+.!'4*!,4&&(%-!#2"!(+!,##)%&4"(#+!'("$!
"$%!S*841(,!=#,(%"0!#/ !V>4H#?4!4+-!"$%!S+*"("2"%F!
A! )4?%-! )4"$'40! '4*! 84(-! "#! %+468%! ?(*("#&*! "#!
.#!(+"#!"$%!)%4,%/28!4"1#*)$%&%!#/ !"$%!.&4?%04&-!
4+-!?(*("!"$%!"#16*F!
Conclusion
94-21! N#*Y2%! (*! 4+! #2"*"4+-(+.! 1#+2@
1%+"!'("$!4!&(,$80!-%,#&4"%-!(+"%&(#&F!Q(%-8140%&!
4+-!9%&*,$%&!846#2&%-!*"&%+2#2*80!"#!*"4&"!4+-!
,#1)8%"%! "$%! 94-21! O&#>%,"F! L$%(&! (+*(.$"! (+!
%*"468(*$(+.! 8(+H*! '("$! 79':! '4*! /#88#'%-!
60! 4! *2,,%**/28! ,##)%&4"(#+F! L$%! ,#+"&(62"(#+!
IURP 81(6&2 ZDV YDOXDEOH LQ FRQVHUYLQJ
4+-! (1)&#?(+.! "$%! )&%*%+"4"(#+! #/ ! "$%! )4(+"%-!
*2&/4,%*F!74&%/28!(+"%&?%+"(#+*!(+!8(+%!'("$!(+"%&@
+4"(#+48!)&(+,()8%*!*4/%.24&-%-!"$%!$(*"#&(,48!4+-!
DUWLVWLF TXDOLWLHV RI WKH "$@,%+"2&0! 1#+21%+"F!
L$%! 8%4-%&*$()! #/ ! 79':! (+! 6&(+.(+.! "#.%"$%&!
H[SHUWV IURP GLIIHUHQW HOGV WR ZRUN RQ D VLJ@
QLFDQW SURMHFW LV SUDLVHZRUWK\ , ZRXOG OLNH WR
,#+.&4"284"%!488!"$%!*)#+*#&*3!"$%!%R)%&"*3!4+-!"$%!
"&4(+%%*!'$#!$4?%!,#+"&(62"%-!"#!"$%!*2,,%**!#/ !
"$%!)&#>%,"F!
L$%!)4(+"%-!-%,#&4"(#+!4"!"$%!2))%&!8%?%8*!#/ !
"$%!(+"%&(#&!&%Y2(&%-!8#+.!4+-!,4&%/28!'#&H!,#+@
-2,"%-!#+!*,4//#8-(+.F!A*!"$%!/2+-(+.!/!"$%!
O4,H4&-!G#2+-4"(#+!,#28-!+#"!,#?%&!"$%!&%*"#&4@
"(#+!#/ !488!"$%!)4(+"%-!*2&/4,%*!"$%!,#1)8%"(#+!#/ !
"$%!)#&,$!4+-!(+"%&(#&J*!&%*"#&4"(#+!'4*!)#**(68%!
E\ QDQFLDO VXSSRUW IURP 81(6&2 $ WHDP
OHG E\ SDLQWHUFRQVHUYDWRU 1LKDG HQJL DQG
4**(*"%-!60!0#2+.!"&4(+%%*!/!U#*#?43!,4&&(%-!
#2"!"$(*!&%*"#&4"(#+F!L$%!*2&/4,%*!'%&%!%R41(+%-!
'("$!,4&%3!4+-!"$%!Y248("0!4+-!42"$%+"(,("0!#/ !"$%!
)4(+"!840%&*!'%&%!%?4824"%-!,&("(,4880F!Q%)4(&*!4+-!
OOLQJVZLWKFHPHQWPRUWDUDQGXQVHHPO\SDLQW
840%&*!'%&%!&%1#?%-F!L$%!,8#*%!&4+.%!%R41(+4@
"(#+!#/ !"$%!)4(+"(+.*!#+!"$%!-#1%!&%?%48%-!+%'!
(+/#&14"(#+! 46#2"! "$%! -%"4(8*! 4+-! 840%&*F! L$%!
84+-*,4)%*! (+! "$%! 2))%&! 5#+%*! #/ ! "$%! 1#*Y2%!
(+,82-%-3!4"!"$%!64*%!#/ !"$%!-#1%3!,0)&%**!"&%%*3!
RZHUV8277(*3!4+-!4!6(.!*"&2,"2&%!'("$!?428"*!4+-!
1(+4&%"*3!(1)80(+.!4!1#+21%+"48!1#*Y2%3!)@
4680!4+!(1)%&(48!*"&2,"2&%!'("$!-#268%!1(+4&%"*!
4+-!HUHIH*F!S"!'4*!(+"%&%*"(+.!"#!*%%!"$4"!"$%!1(+4@
&%"! *$4/"*! $4-! *1488! #)%+(+.*! 4"! "$%(&! "#)*3! 8(H%!
"$%!94-21!N#*Y2%J*!1(+4&%"F!L$%!,4)*!#/ !"$%!
1(+4&%"*!'%&%!-%)(,"%-!'("$!.#8-!,&#'+*3!(+*"%4-!
#/ !"&4-("(#+48!(7"0*F
117
Nenad Makuljevi
118
C2$.%' %(&*%(47V(' .' 5%()+$"7V&8+0' (8$+4#.&$+0(' 2' :(78(#&8+0' *%.4+#1+V(0(' -&0(#&8.5' 1(%&$4(' 2' *"%+.)2'
L]PHX7DQ]LPDWVNLKUHIRUPLL]LJRGLQHSRVHEQRXYH]LVDGUDYQLPSRUH]LPDLQHPXVOLPDQVNLP
VWDQRYQLWYRP8RYRPSHULRGXRSXV$QGUHMD'DPMDQRYDPDNHGRQVNRJJUDGLWHOMDMHMHGDQRGUHSUH]HQWDWLYQLK
SULPMHUDSR]QRRVPDQVNHDUKLWHNWXUH,]PHXWLKLWLK'DPMDQRYMHELRYRHLSXWXMXLJUDGLWHOM
8.V+'V"'+X5%()+.'0#.5"'1%84"'#('*%.&$.%('6(78(#('EU8.*7V"M'm"7"&M'U0")"%"4.M';.&$(%M'U(%(V"4.M'+$)LN'j'U(%(V"42M'
'DPMDQRYMHL]JUDGLRQRYXRVPDQVNXNDVDUQX]DRVPDQVNXSURYLQFLMVNXDGPLQLVWUDFLMXL]DYULRMHJUDHQMH
VYRGDQDNDWROLNRMFUNYL8WLPLX6DUDMHYXLX%HRJUDGXL]JUDHQLVXQRYLNRQDFL]DSRWUHEHSURYLQFLMVNLK
YDOLMDLSDD.RQDNX6DUDMHYXL]JUDHQRGVWUDQHGYDJUDGLWHOMDL]'DOPDFLMHMHVDXYDQGRNMHNRQDNX%HR/
JUDGXXQLWHQX,6YMHWVNRPUDWX2VWDOHVXULMHWNHIRWRJUDMHLNUDWNLRSLVLQDSUDYOMHQLRGVWUDQH)HOLNVD.DQLFD
NRMLMHXNRQDNXYLGLRHYURSVNLXUHHQVDORQ
T,"'(2$,.%')+&12&&"&'1.#&$%21$+.#'(1$+4+$R'+#'$,"'-$$.0(#'6(78(#'*%.4+#1"&':"$P""#'$,"'T(#X+0($'9)+1$^&'*%.1/
7(0($+.#'+#'FIHG'(#)'1(N'FInI'P+$,'%"5(%)'$.'1.00+&&+.#&':R'$,"'&$($"'.%'+$&'#.#/;2&7+0'&2:V"1$&N'T,+&'*"%+.)'(7&.'
1.+#1+)"&'P+$,'$,"'1(%""%'.B '%"#.P#")';(1").#+(#/:.%#'(%1,+$"1$k:2+7)"%'C#)%"V('W(0V(#.4'EFIFH/nILN'6"$P""#'
$,"'FIHK&'(#)'FIQK&M',"'P(&'$,"'7"()"%'.B '(#'+$+#"%(#$':2+7)"%&^'P.%8&,.*'$,($':2+7$'+#1%"(&+#57R'0.#20"#$(7'
1,2%1,"&'+#'0(#R'6(78(#'7.1(7"&'EU8.*V"M'm"7"&M'U0")"%"4.M';.&$(%M'U(%(V"4.M'"$1NL'A#'U(%(V"4.M'W(0V(#.4'(7&.'
:2+7$'#"P':(%%(18&'B.%'$,"'-$$.0(#'*%.4+#1+(7'()0+#+&$%($+.#'(#)'1.0*7"$")'('!($,.7+1'1,2%1,^&'4(27$+#5N'A#'$,"'
FIQK&M':.$,'+#'U(%(V"4.'(#)'6"75%()"M'#"P'8.#(8&'P"%"':2+7$'B.%'$,"'*%.4+#1+(7'5.4"%#.%&N'T,"'H#+4H'+#'U(%(V"4.M'
:2+7$':R'$P.'W(70($+(#&M'&2%4+4"&M':2$'6"75%()"^&'P(&')"&$%.R")'+#'SSAN'A$'&2%4+4"&'+#'%(%"'*,.$.5%(*,&'(#)'('
)"&1%+*$+.#':R'b"7+@'Y(#+$XM'P,.'&(P'+#'+$'('&(7.#'B2%#+&,")'+#'$,"'92%.*"(#'0(##"%N
6O3DLQNRQDNQD.DOHPHJGDQXX%HRJUDGXQDVWDURM
IRWRJUDML
GUXWYHQLK]DMHGQLFDSRVWDMXQRVLRFLLYRGHLSD@
"&#+(!)#5+##*14+*H%!4&$("%H"#+*H%!)&#-2H,(>%F
M#?4! 4&$("%H"#+*H4! )&4H*4! )&?#6("+#! *%!
UD]YLMDOD X SUHVWRQLFL 2VPDQVNH LPSHULMH GD EL
SRVOHXYRHQMDWDQ]LPDWVNLKUHIRUPLRQDLPDOD
]QDDMQXXORJXXREOLNRYDQMXLGHQWLWHWD%DONDQD
7R MH ]QDLOR SULKYDWDQMH L SULPHQX UD]OLLWLK
VWLOVNLK L]UD]D NDR L PRJXQRVW DQJDRYDQMD
*"&4+($! 4&$("%H4"4F! T! *H84-2! *4! *4?&%1%+(1!
%?&#)*H(1! "#H#?(14! )&(1%+>2>%! *%! 4&$("%H"2&4!
(*"#&(514! (! 4H4-%1(5143! 4! 2! >4?+(1! #6>%H"(14!
*%! )#*"%)%+#! +4)2]"4>2! *"4&(>(! #*14+*H(! #68(,(F!
S51%+>%+%! -&2]"?%+%! #H#8+#*"(! 2"(,48(! *2! -4! *%!
?%8(H4! .&4-("%8>*H4! )&#-2H,(>4! #-?(>4! 54! )#"&%6%!
KULDQVNLK ]DMHGQLFD ,VWRYUHPHQR ]DSRLQMH L
Centri i periferije u osmanskoj arhitekturi: ponovo otkrivanje balkanskog naslijea
119
120
6O1RYDRVPDQVNDNDVDUQDX6DUDMHYXQDVWDURMIRWRJUDML
6O6DERUQDFUNYDX1LXQDVWDURMUD]JOHGQLFL
WXUHWRVYDNDNRQHRGJRYDUDQMHJRYRP]QDDMX
O#5+##*14+*H4!4&$("%H"2&4!N4H%-#+(>%3!=&6(>%!(!
%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQHSUHGVWDYOMDYDQXFHOLQXX
JUDGLWHOMVNRP QDVOHX 2VPDQVNH LPSHULMH 2QD
SRND]XMH GLQDPLQX WUDQVIRUPDFLMX DUKLWHN@
"#+*H%! H28"2&%! (! 2*?4>4+>%! *4?&%1%+%! %?&#)*H%!
.&4-("%8>*H%! )&4H*%3! ]"#! >%! 6(84! >4*+4! )#*8%-(,4!
SURPHQDXGUDYLLGUXWYX
XEDONDQVNRPGUXWYX2QMHRLJOHGQRELRSUH@
SR]QDW NDR QDMVSRVREQLML DUKLWHNWD QD SRGUXMX
N4H%-#+(>%3!=&6(>%!(!:#*+%!(!9%&,%.#?(+%F!M>%.#@
?4!*4H&48+4!(!)&#/4+4!5-4+>4!)#H452>2!-4!>%!#+!)&(@
PHQMLYDR LVWRULVWLNX L DNDGHPVNX DUKLWHNWRQVNX
SRHWLNX NRMD MH RGJRYDUDOD ]DKWHYLPD QDUXLODFD
_%8(H#1!.&4-("%8>*H#1!)&#-2H,(>#1!c41>4+#?!>%!
(51%+(#! ?(52%8+(! (-%+"("%"! :48H4+4F! S*"#?&%1%+#3!
#+! >%! #*"?4&(#! >%-(+*"?%+(! #)2*! 2! )#5+##*14+*@
NRMDUKLWHNWXULLGRSULQHRGDEDONDQVNRSRGUXMH
SRVWDQH YDDQ NXOWXUQL SURVWRU XSUNRV EXUQLP
SROLWLNLPGRJDGMDQMLPD
T! )#5+##*14+*H#>! 4&$("%H"2&(! :48H4+4! (*@
"4H+2"#!1%*"#!(14>2!(!.&4-("%8>(!H#>(!*2!*"(548(!(5!
VXVHGQLKVWUDQLKGUDYD2QLVXSRSXW)UDQMH
/LQDUGRYLD)UDQMH0RLVDL$QWH6LFLOLDQDGRQR@
*(8(! (! )&(1%+>(?48(! 4&$("%H"#+*H2! )#%"(H2! +4*"482!
L]YDQ2VPDQVNHLPSHULMH1DWDMQDLQMHGROD]LOR
GRNXOWXUQRJWUDQVIHUDLXVNODLYDQMDVDYUHPHQH
#*14+*H%!(!%?&#)*H%!.&4-("%8>*H%!)&4H*%F!
3RVWWDQ]LPDWVNR JUDGLWHOMVNR QDVOHH QD
:48H4+2! 6(8#! >%! )#")2+#! 14&.(+48(5#?4+#! 2!
GRVDGDQMLP SURXDYDQMLPD RVPDQVNH DUKLWHN@
6O6DERUQDFUNYDX0RVWDUXQDVWDURMUD]JOHGQLFL
121
Lejla Buatli
122
$XWRULFDUDVSUDYOMDRWUDQVIRUPDFLMDPDJUDGVNHNXHL]RVPDQVNRJSHULRGDX%RVQLL+HUFHJRYLQLQDNRQGRO/
DVND+DEVEXUJRYDFDNUR]WULHYLGHQWQDSULPMHUD6YU]LQDNXDL'HVSLDNXDX6DUDMHYX]DWLPNXDIDPLOLMH
+XVHGLQRYLX%DQMD/XFL.XD'HVSLDIDPLOLMHX6DUDMHYXMHQDSULPMHUSURODNUR]EURMQHWUDQVIRUPDFLMH
XSHULRGXL]PHXNDVQRJLNDVQRJVWROMHD8HWYUWRMID]LXUD]YRMXREMHNWDVYHYHLXWLFDM%HDSRVWDMH
RLJOHGDQ-HGDQGLRNXHMHGRGDQLNRULWHQ]DSRWUHEHWHDWUDQD]LGRYLPDVXVHYMHDOLIDPLOLMDUQLSRWUHWLXUDHQL
RGVWUDQHLQRVWUDQLKVOLNDUD1DVXSURWSRPHQXWLKNXDIDPLOLMH+XVHGLQRYLX%DQMD/XFLMHVDJUDHQD
JRGLQHSUHPDSURMHNWXDNDGHPVNLREUD]RYDQRJDXVWURXJDUVNRJDUKLWHNWH-RVLSD9DQFDDXQHRWUDGLFLRQDOQRP
&$+72'8(&#+V"'#(X4(#.0'Z:.&(#&8+'&7.5[N'-:V"8($'V"'#(&$(.'+#&*+%(1+V.0'$%()+1+.#(7#"':.&(#&8"'(%,+$"8$2%"'&'
MHGQHVWUDQHGRNVXYLVLQDVWRSRYDLGUXJLDVSHNWLNXHELOLSULODJRHQLPRGHUQRMDUKLWHNWXULWRJYUHPHQD3RGMHOD
NXHQDHQVNLLPXNLGLRMHELODMRXYMHN]DGUDQD6YU]LQDNXDMHSULPMHUDXWHQWLNHNXHRULMHQWDOQRJ
$+*(M'&('$%()+1+.#(7#.0'*.)V"7.0'&$(0:"#.5'8.0*7"8&(M'8.V('V"'8(&#+V"'$"8'.*%"07V"#('&('*.#"8+0'0.)"%#+0'
]DSDGQMDNLPGLMHORPPRELOLMDUDNRMLQLVXQDUXDYDOLL]YRUQXWUDGLFLRQDOQXNRQJXUDFLMXNXH
T,"' (2$,.%' )+&12&&"&' $%(#&B.%0($+.#&' $,"' -$$.0(#/*"%+.)' 2%:(#' ,.2&"' 2#)"%P"#$' B.77.P+#5' $,"' ()4"#$' .B '
+DEVEXUJUXOHDVHYLGHQFHGE\WKUHHH[DPSOHVWKH6YU]LQDDQG'HVSLKRXVHVLQ6DUDMHYRDQGWKH+XVHGLQRYL
IDPLO\KRXVHLQ%DQMD/XND7KH'HVSLIDPLO\KRXVHLQ6DUDMHYRIRULQVWDQFHVDZDQXPEHURI WUDQVIRUPD/
$+.#&':"$P""#'$,"'7($"'FI$,'1"#$2%R'(#)'$,"'7($"'FG$,'1"#$2%RN'A#'$,"'B.2%$,'1.#&$%21$+.#'*,(&"M'm+"##(^&'+#1%"(&+#5'
LQXHQFHEHFRPHVHYLGHQW2QHVSDFHZDVDGGHGDQGXVHGIRUWKHDWUHSHUIRUPDQFHVRQWKHZDOOVZHUHKXQJIDPLO\
SRUWUDLWVSDLQWHGE\DIRUHLJQDUWLVW7KH+XVHGLQRYLKRXVHLQ%DQMD/XNDE\FRQWUDVWZDVEXLOWRQO\LQ
(#)'(11.%)+#5'$.'('*%.V"1$':R'(#'C2&$%./<2#5(%+(#'(%1,+$"1$'+#'('#"./$%()+$+.#(7'0.)"'$,"#'1(77")'Z$,"'6.&#+(#'
&$R7"N['S,+7"'+#&*+%")':R'$%()+$+.#(7'6.&#+(#'(%1,+$"1$2%"M',"+5,$&'(#)'.$,"%'(&*"1$&'P"%"'()(*$")'$.'$,"'0.)"%#'
DUFKLWHFWXUHRI WKHGD\6WLOOPDOHIHPDOHVHSDUDWLRQZDVUHWDLQHG6YU]RV+RXVHQDOO\ZDVDWUDGLWLRQDO
KRPHRQDFRQVHUYDWLYHSODQLQZKLFKDIHZ:HVWHUQHOHPHQWVZHUHPHUHO\DGGHGWRDEDVLFFRQJXUDWLRQWKDW
%"0(+#")'$%()+$+.#(7N
E!
T!)#->%8(!+4!)&#*"#&(>%!54!)&(>%1!#&(>%+"(*4+%!)&%14!28(,(!(!(+"(1+(!
GLR NXH X NRMHP VH RGYLMD SRURGLQL LYRW RULMHQWLVDQ SUHPD
GYRULWXXJUNRMVWDPEHQRMDUKLWHNWXULPRHVHSUHSR]QDWLNRQFHSW
RVPDQVNH NXH 3R 9LWUXYLMX REMH JUXSH SURVWRULMD X JUNRM NXL
VDGUH LVWD RGMHOMHQMD DOL MH SRORDM JUXSD UD]OLLW SUHPD XOLFL MH
#&(>%+"(*4+4! .&2)4! )&#*"#&(>4! 4+-&#+("(*3! -#H! >%! .&2)4! #->%8>%+>4!
]D HQH JLQHNRQLWLV SR]DGL X GYRULWX %RJGDQ 1 1HVWRURYL
$UKLWHNWXUDVWDURJYHND1DXQDNQMLJD%HRJUDGVWU
&YLML NODVLFLUD QD SRGUXMX %DONDQD HWLUL WLSD JUDGVNLK NXD
GDOPDWLQVNRPOHWDNL JUNRPHGLWHUDQVNL EL]DQWVNRWXUVNL L
4&64+4]H(! "()F! S! -&2.(! 42"#&(! ;=#8-#! (! c%&#H#<! *14"&4>2! -4! >%! *"4&4!
JUDGVND NXD QD SRGUXMX NRQWLQHQWDOQRJ GLMHOD %DONDQD QDVWDOD
GLUHNWQRSRGXWLFDMHP2ULMHQWDDSUHNR%L]DQWLMH
H#+,%),(>%3!*4!+4.84*H#1!+4!#*#6%+#*"(!?%54+%!
2!)#>%-(+(1!H&4>%?(14!54!)&#*"#&+%3!H8(14"*H%3!
-&2]"?%+%! 2?>%"%F! O&#,%*! #&(>%+"48(54,(>%! 54$@
YDWDJRWRYRVYHVIHUHLYRWD2VPDQVNLSHULRG
QD RYR SRGUXMH GRYRGL QRYX RULMHQWDOQX NXO@
WXUXNRMDSURLPDQMHPVDORNDOQLPWUDGLFLMDPD
UDD QRYD RULJLQDODQD UMHHQMD X JUDGLWHOMVWYX
)4! "4H#! (! *"416%+#>! 4&$("%H"2&(! M4&4?+#! "&%64!
LPDWLXYLGXLRGUHHQHSRYH]QLFHVDVHRVNRP
NXRP 3UYRELWQD JUDGVND NXD MH LPDOD SUR@
VWRUQX VWUXNWXUX VHRVNH NXH MHU MH L]JUDHQD
#H#! >%5.&%3! *&%-(]+>%! )&#*"#&(>%! *4! #.+>(]"%1! 2!
H#>#>! *%! 6#&4?(8#! 2! "#H2! -4+4! (! *)4?48#F! U4*@
QLMRP GLIHUHQFLMDFLMRP RVQRYQR MH]JUR H VH
)#-(>%8("(! +4! -?(>%! )&#*"#&(>%3! $4>4"@)&%-*#68>%!
(! $48?4"@*#62! #H#! H#>($! *%! ?&%1%+#1! .&2)(]2!
RVWDOLSURVWRUL,PDMXLXYLGXVYHVSHFLQRVWL
*"416%+%! 4&$("%H"2&%! #*14+*H#.! )%&(#-4! 2!
%RVQL L +HUFHJRYLQL XWLFDMLPD QDVOLMHHQRJ
ORNDOQRJ JUDGLWHOMVWYD PRH VH JRYRULWL R
IHQRPHQXERVDQVNHNXH2QDQRVLRELOMHMD
RVPDQVNHNXHDOLLHOHPHQWHORNDOQHQDVOLMHHQH
"&4-(,(>%!*"416%+%!4&$("%H"2&%F!M>%+4!)#*%6+#*"!
YH]DQD MH ]D VSHFLQRVW SRGQHEOMD QD NRMHP
VH UD]YLMD $QDOL]LUDMXL VYH HOHPHQWH NRML VX
GHQLVDOLLXWLFDOLQDUD]YRMRYDNYRJWLSDJUDGQMH
PRHVH]DNOMXLLGDVHUDGLRSRVHEQRMSRMDYLX
RNYLUX RVPDQVNH DUKLWHNWXUH QD SRGUXMX %DO@
H4+4F!c#84*H#1!42*".4&*H%!?84*"(!-#845(!-#!
]QDDMQLK WUDQVIRUPDFLMD X DUKLWHNWRQVNLP L
XUEDQLVWLNLPUMHHQMPDQDRYRPSRGUXMX7DM
SURFHV SULODJRDYDQMD WUDGLFLRQDOQLK DUKLWHN@
"#+*H($! /#&1(! +#?(1! %2&#)*H(1! *"4+-4&-(14!
*%! #-?(>4#! )#*"2)+#! 2+#]%+>%1! )#>%-(+($!
-(>%8#?4!1#6(8(>4&4!;#.8%-4843!*4"#?43!*"#8(,4<3!-4!
6(! +4! H&4>2! H#1)8%"4+! %+"%&(>%&! -#6(#! (5.8%-! 2!
*H84-2!*!+#?(1!%2&#)*H(1!*"4+-4&-(14!H28"2&%!
VWDQRYDQMD2YDNYLPWUDQVIRUPDFLMDPDJXELVH
Uvod
123
124
6OD(QWHULMHUYHOLNRJKDOYDWDXHQVNRPGLMHOX6YU]LQHNXH
X6DUDMHYXSULPMHUXQRHQMDHOHPHQDWDHXURSHL]DFLMHXWUDGL
FLRQDOQRREOLNRYDQLSURVWRUERVDQVNHNXH
6OE(QWHULMHUYHOLNRJKDOYDWDXHQVNRPGLMHOX6YU]LQHNXH
X6DUDMHYXSULPMHUXQRHQMDHOHPHQDWDHXURSHL]DFLMHXWUDGL
FLRQDOQRREOLNRYDQLSURVWRUERVDQVNHNXH
Karakteristike, nastanak
i razvoj gradske kue
o rijentalnog tipa u Bosni i
Hercegovini
U4#! *(16#8! ?(*#H#! &45?(>%+%! H28"2&%!
VWDQRYDQMD ERVDQVND NXD MH REOLNRYDQD QD
)&(+,()(14! )#]"(?4+>4! )&(?4"+#.! )&#*"#&43! )&4?4!
+4!?(-(H3!)#?%5(?4+>4!)&(&#-%!(!4&$("%H"2&%3!H28"4!
YRGHLNXOWDNRPLOXND5DGLVHQDMHHRMHGQR@
VSUDWQRMJUDHYLQLREOLNRYDQRMRGWUDGLFLRQDOQLK
PDWHULMDOD GUYHWD NDPHQD L HUSLD .RULVWL VH
NRQWUDVWQL ERQGUXN VLVWHP HUSL FLJOD VXHQD
+4!*2+,2<3!(*)2+4!2!H#16(+4,(>(!*4!-&?%+(1!.&%@
GDPDKDWXODPDNRMHLQHNRQVWUXNFLMXYURP
.URY MH SRNULYHQ LQGURP LOL HUDPLGRP 8
6O3R]RULQDVREDX'HVSLDNXLX6DUDMHYX
125
6O6SDYDDVREDL]'HVSLDNXHX6DUDMHYX
126
LOLPRP8QRHQMHPPDQJDOHVRIUHLOLSURVWLUDQ@
>%1!-2]%H4!1(>%+>4!*%!(!/2+H,(>4!*#6%F!T!*H84-2!
*! H4&4H"%! (*841*H%! H28"2&%! 2! 12*8(14+*H(1!
NXDPD ERJDWD GHNRUDFLMD GUYRUH]EDULMH YH]D
NDOLJUDMH L REUDGH PHWDOD VYHGHQD MH QD ELOMQL L
JHRPHWULMVNLRUQDPHQWEH]JXUDWLYQLKVDGUDMD
2YDNDY WLS NXOWXUH VWDQRYDQMD MH SULKYDHQ L
H#-! +%12*8(14+*H#.! *"4+#?+(]"?4F! Q458(H%! *2!
ELOHPLQLPDOQH8HQWHULMHUXNUDQVNLKNXDMD@
YOMDMXVHVOLNHUHOLJLR]QRJVDGUDMDLNRQHNDQGLOD
WHVHNRULVWHSURVWLUNHQDVHLMDPDUD]OLLWHERMH
1HPD WUDGLFLRQDOQH SRGLMHOH QD PXNL L HQVNL
GLRVHLMHVXYLHLXHXRGQRVXQDPXVOLPDQ@
VNH NXH JGMH VX RQH SULODJRHQH XRELDMHQRP
QDLQXVMHGHQMDDOODWXUFD8VNODGXVWUDGLFLMRP
QMHJRYDQMDNXOWDYRGHLLVWRHXQXWUDQMHJSUR@
*"#&43!)&#(54]8#1!(5!(*841*H#.!*?>%"#+45#&4!(!&%@
8(.(>*H#.!#6&%-+#.!)&4+>4!)&%-!1#8("?2!;25(14+>%!
DEGHVWDQHL]ELMHDQGLRHQWHULMHUDPXVOLPDQVNLK
NXD MH DEGHVWOXN 7R MH MR MHGQD RG UD]OLND X
XQXWUDQMHP XUHHQMX L NXOWXUL VWDQRYDQMD PXV@
6O.XEHOLMDSURVWRULMDQDWNULYHQDNXSRORPX'HVSLDNXL
X6DUDMHYXVYRMLPXQXWUDQMLPXUHHQMHPXND]XMHQDSUHSOL
WDQMHWUDGLFLRQDOQLKLVUHGQMHHXURSVNLKVWDQGDUGDXNXOWXUL
VWDQRYDQMD
.&4-*H%!H28"2&%!*"4+#?4+>4!2!#*14+*H#1!)%&(#@
GX=DGUDODMHJRWRYRXSRWSXQRVWLDXWHQWLQRVW
JUDGVNH NXH RULMHQWDOQRJ WLSD X VYLP QMHQLP
4*)%H"(14! (! H4&4H"%&(*"(H414F! L&4-(,(#+48+(! 14@
WHULMDOLXRELDMHQDSRGMHODVWDPEHQRJNRPSOHNVD
+4!*48%182H!(!$4&%182H!;>4?+(!(!)&(?4"+(!)&#*"#&<3!
KDMDW KDOYDWL NDKYHRGDN GLYDQKDQD NDPHULMD
GRNVDW PXWYDN V YRGQLFRP HNVLELOQRVW L
?(]%*"&2H4! /2+H,(#+48+#*"! 2+2"&4]+>%.! )&#*"#&43!
4&$("%H"2&4! H4#! -(#! )&(&#-%! (! )&(&#-4! H4#! -(#!
4&$("%H"2&%!*?%!*2!"#!)&%)#5+4"8>(?%!H4&4H"%&(*"(H%!
"&4-(,(#+48+#.! .&4-("%8>*"?4F! T+2"&4]+>(! )&#*"#&!
MH RUJDQL]LUDQ L RSUHPOMHQ QD XRELDMHQ QDLQ
5DGLVHRNVQRPQDPMHWDMXVHLMDPDLPXVDQ@
GHUDPD V KDPDPGLNRP L GXHNOXNRP SRVWDY@
8>%+(1!25!5(-#?%!)&#*"#&(>4F!:#.4"4!-&?#&%564&(>4!
V JHRPHWULMVNRP L RUDOQRP RUQDPHQWLNRP
OMHSRWD YH]D EDNDUQR SRVXH VDKDQL GXJXPL
2H&4]%+(! "%$+(H#1! *4?4"43! 8%?$%! 2)#")2+>2>2!
FMHORNXSQLGRMDPVSHFLQRJHQWHULMHUDRYHNXH
c#1(+4"+(! *2! #&(>%+"48+#@(*841*H(! 2"(,4>(! *! ?&8#!
&(>%"H(1! )&(1>%&(143! )&(>%! *?%.4! 2! 2+2"&4]+>%1!
XUHHQMX SRMDYOMLYDQMD PRELOLMDUD NRML XND]XMH
+4! )&#,%*! %2&#)%(54,(>%F! T! %+"%&(>%&2! ?%8(H#.!
KDOYDWDQRYLMHJGLMHODHQVNHNXHQDPLMHQMHQRP
54! #H2)8>4+>%! )#&#-(,%! 54! ?&(>%1%! 64>&4143! (/@
WDUD L PHYOXGD L]QHQDXMH SRMDYD YHQHFLMDQVNRJ
#.8%-484!H4#!)&(1>%&!)#*"%)%+#.!)&#-(&4+>4!%2@
&#)*H($!*"4+-4&-4!(!)#?%5(?4+>4!*!"&4-(,(#+48+(1!
JUDGLWHOMVWYRP2YDNYLSUHGPHWLVYMHGRHRER@
JDWLPWUJRYDNLPYH]DPDQHVDPRV&DULJUDGRP
YHLV]QDDMQLPHXURSVNLPFHQWULPDNDRWRVX
9HQHFLMDL%H
=?#>(1! *"(8*H(1! H4&4H"%&(*"(H414! (! -(1%+5(@
>4143! #?4H?(! -(>%8#?(! +41>%]"4>4! +%! 2H84)4>2! *%!
2! 416(>%+"! "&4-(,(#+48+#.! .&4-("%8>*"?4! (! +>%.#?!
NRQFHSWDQWURSRPHWULQRVWL
3URVWRU REOLNRYDQ SR PMHUL RYMHND QLMH
H#1)4"(6(84+! *! 1#6(8(>4! H#>(! .4! *?#>#1!
PDVLYQRX]DJXXMHLRSWHUHXMHWRQLMHVOXDM
VD6YU]LQRPNXRPNRMDXVSLMHYDVDXYDWLL]YRUQL
(5.8%-! "&4-(,(#+48+%! *"416%+%! 4&$("%H"2&%! (5! #*@
14+*H#.!)%&(#-4F
127
6O7USH]DULMDX'HVSLDNXLX6DUDMHYX
128
4H4-%1(514!+%#*"(8#?4!(!*%,%*(>%F!T"(,4>(!(*841*H%!
DUKLWHNWXUHPRJXVHSUHSR]QDWLQDJUDHYLQDPD
)&#>%H"#?4+(1! 2! +%#142&*H#1! *"(823! 4&$(@
WHNWXURP NRMD QLNDGD QLMH ELOD NDUDNWHULVWLQD
]D RYDM SURVWRU 8 VNODGX V SRYHDQMHP EURMD
VWDQRYQLWYDMDYOMDVHLSRWUHED]DYHLPEURMHP
VWDPEHQLK REMHNDWD 2QL VH JUDGH X VLVWHPX
68#H#?4! (8(! 2! +(52! 25! +4*"#>4+>%! 14H*(148+#.!
NRULWHQMD ]HPOMLWD L VSUDWQRVWL 1DMHH VX WR
+4>41+%3! )#*8#?+#@*"416%+%! 5.&4-%3! *"416%+%!
)484"%!(!?(8%CF!AH#!*%!&4-(8#!#!"()2!)#*8#?+#@*"41@
EHQH]JUDGHXSUL]HPQRMHWDLVHRELQRQDOD]H
)#*8#?+(!)&#*"#&(!-#H!*%!+4!*)&4"#?(14!*"4+#?4@
8#F! c(*)#5(,(>4! >%! #&.4+(5(&4+4! "4H#! -4! *%! *48#+(!
(!&%)&%5%+"4"(?+%!)&#*"#&(>%!54!)&(>%1!#&(>%+"(&4>2!
NDXOLFLGRNVHVSDYDDVREDWUSH]DULMDVNXKLQ@
>#1!(!H2)4"(8#!#&(>%+"(]2!H4!-?#&(]"2F!T!*&%-(]"2!
MHKRGQLNNRULGRUVNRJWLSD9LOHVXJUDHQHNDR
VORERGQRVWRMHL REMHNWL RNUXHQL ]HOHQLORP
Q4*H#]+4! &>%]%+>4! /4*4-%! (! %+"%&(>%&4! .#?#&%! #!
-&2]"?%+#1!*"4"2*2!?84*+(H4F!=?%!"#!2H452>%!+4!
SURPMHQH GUXWYHQRHNRQRPVNLK L SROLWLNLK
)&(8(H4! 2! :#*+(! (! 9%&,%.#?(+(! (! 2! *H4-2! *! "(1!
SRMDYX QRYRJ QDLQD LYRWD NXOWXUH VWDQRYDQMD
L XNXVD JUDDQD 1DMERJDWLML GUXWYHQL VWDOH
PODGD EXURD]LMD QDVWRML GD VH XNORSL X VXYUH@
1%+4! *"&%18>%+>4! (! *"4+-4&-%! *&%-+>%%2&#)*H($!
H28"2&+($!H&2.#?4F!M4&4?+#!-4!*%!*?4!#?4!62&+4!
GHDYDQMD SURPMHQH DUKLWHNWRQVNRXUEDQLVWLNL
]#H!H#>(!*%!-%]4?4!-#84*H#1!42*".4&*H%!?84*"(!
UHHNWLUD L NUR] SURFHV WUDQVIRUPDFLMH L HXUR@
SHL]DFLMHJUDGVNHNXHRULMHQWDOQRJWLSD2QDVH
-%]4?4! )#*"2)+#3! 2+#]%+>%1! )#>%-(+($! -(>%8#?4!
1#6(8(>4&4K! *"#8(,43! #.8%-4843! -4! 6(! +4! H&4>2! )#@
>%-(+%! )&#*"#&(>%! -#6(>48%! (5.8%-! H#>(! )#")2+#!
#-.#?4&4! +#?#>! 54)4-+#>! H28"2&(! *"4+#?4+>4! 2!
*H84-2! *! *2?&%1%+(1! (1)#&"#?4+(1! *"(8*H#1!
#&(>%+"4,(>414F!
3ULKYDDQMHP QRYLK HXURSVNLK REUD]DFD X
NXOWXULVWDQRYDQMDGHDYDMXVH]QDDMQHSURPMHQH
2! H4&4H"%&2! "&4-(,(#+48+%! *"416%+%! 4&$("%H"2&%F!
G8%H*(6(8+#*"!/2+H,(#+48+#*"(!2+2"&4]+>%.!)&#*"#@
UDVHJXELXQRHQMHPPRELOLMDUDNDUDNWHULVWLQRJ
]DVUHGQMHHXURSVNHREUDVFHXQXWUDQMHJXUHHQMD
1DWDMQDLQQMHJRYDIXQNFLMDVHNVLUDLRQJXEL
*?#>2! 4-4)"(6(8+#*"! (! ?(]%*"&2H2! /2+H,(#+48+#*"F!
82H*25!)4!*%!54"?4&4>2!(!)&%"?4&4>2!2!*#6%Fb!="#.4!
*%!)#*"4?8>4!)("4+>%!-4!8(!%2&#)%(54,(>4!)&%-*"4?8>4!
-%.&4-4,(>23!-%*"&2H,(>2!(8(!+#?(!H?48("%"!2!H28"2&(!
VWDQRYDQMDLDUKLWHNWRQVNLPUMHHQMLPD"
b!
M41>%]"4>!H#>(!#-.#?4&4!*&%-+>%%2&#)*H(1!*"4+-4&-(14!2+2"&4]+>%.!
XUHHQMD VH PRH SRVPDWUDWL NDR ]DVHEQD FMHOLQD X RGQRVX QD
SURVWRUNRMLGHQLH9H]DL]PHXWUDGLFLRQDOQRJNVQRJQDPMHWDMD
XERVDQVNRMNXLLSURVWRUDNRMLRQGHQLHMHYUD6HLMHVHPRJX
RNDUDNWHULVDWLLNDRL]GLJQXWLGLRSRGDDPXVDQGHUHNDRXJUDHQLGLR
5(-4F!
6O(QWHULMHUDUDSVNHVREHSRURGLQDNXD+XVHGLQRYLDX
%DQMRM/XFL
129
130
6O'LYDQKDQDXHQVNRPGLMHOXSRURGLQHNXH
+XVHGLQRYLDX%DQMRM/XFL
RGYLMDRVHRGJGRNUDMD;,;VWROMHDNUR]
HWLUL ID]H 8 SUYRM ID]L VH GRJUDXMH VSUDW QD
12"?4H23! 2! -&2.#>! -#845(! -#! *)4>4+>4! H41%+%!
NXHLPXWYDNDMHGLQVWYHQLPNURYRPLGLYDQKD@
QRP7UHDID]DMHYH]DQD]DL]JUDGQMXQRYHNXH
SRHWNRP ;,; VW YHOLNH VREH V SR]RULQRP
+41(>%+#1!(!*48#+43!"%!+>($#?#!*)4>4+>%!>%-(+*"@
?%+(1! H&#?#1! (! /4*4-#1! *! 4&H4-#1! 2! )&(5%1@
OMXLQDVSUDWX8HWYUWRMID]LNUDMHP;,;VWVH
54"?4&4>2!82H#?(!+4!*)&4"2!(!54*"4H8>2>2!4&H4-%!2!
SUL]HPOMXLPHFLMHORIDVDGQRSODWQRGRELMDMHGLQ@
*"?%+!4&$("%H"#+*H(!(5&45!2!-2$2!+%#&%+%*4+*%!(!
4H4-%1(514F
8YHOLNRPSRDUXVWUDGDRMHNURYNXHGLRIDVDGHLUDVWLQMH
X GYRULWX 7DGDQML YODVQLN 0DNVR 'HVSL GRYHR MH PDMVWRUH L]
%URGDLREQRYLRNXX6RE]LURPQDSRULMHNORPDMVWRUDLQDHOHPHQWH
NRML VX SULPMHQMHQL QD IDVDGL GXERND UXVWLND XJORYD SURODFLMD
GRSUR]RUQLND SLODVWUL L QMLKRYL SRVWDPHQWL QDLQ REUDGH SUR]RUD
LWGPRJORELVHUHLGDMHWRSUYDSULPMHQDDNDGHPVNHHNOHNWLNHX
=4&4>%?2F''HVSLDNXD0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYRVWU
ED 0DPLQDVREDNDRGLRQDMVWDULMHJGLMHODNXHJGMHMHQDMHHERUDYLOD
VXSUXJD 0DNVH 'HVSLD MH PDQMD SURVWRULMD V RPDOWHULVDQRP
WDYDQLFRP QD LMRM VUHGLQL MH GUYHQD JUHGD RVOLNDQD RUDOQLP
RUPDQHQWRP0RHVHSUHWSRVWDYLWLGDMHSUYRELWQRELODQDWNULYHQD
GUYHQRP WDYDQLFRP ,QWHULMHU V GRODIRP VHLMRP PXVDQGURP
LOLPRP LPD VYD RELOMHMD RULMHQWDOQRLVODPVNLK XWLFDMD 1HNL RG
GHWDOMD NDR WR MH XD L YLD VHLMD SUHNULYHQD ERUGR VRPRWRP X
NUDQVNLPNXDPDNRULVWLODVHNDRSURVWLUND]DVHLMXERUGRRKD
GRNMHXPXVOLPDQVNLPNXDPDELODUD]OLLWLKERMDLNRQDVNDQGLORP
L]DYMHVRPXND]XMHGDVHUDGLRNXLSUDYRVODYQHSRURGLFH%UXVDOL
*?(8%+(! >4*"2,(! H4#! *"4"2*+(! *(16#8! .#?#&%! -4! *%! &4-(! #! 6#.4"#>!
)#&#-(,(F''HVSLDNXD0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYRVWU
EE %DELQD VRED X NRMRM MH ERUDYLR +DGL 0DNVR 'HVSL %DER VH
QDOD]LXSUL]HPQRPGLMHOXNXHSUHNRSXWDPDPLQHVREHVHOMH]QLP
YUDWLPDQDXOD]X8OLMHYRPXJOXVREHMHSHVORQLLPDUH]EDUHQD
12*4+-%&4!*!#"?#!(54!H#>%.!*2!2*H%!-&?%+%!*"%)%+(,%!H4#!?%54!
V NXEHOLMRP SURVWRULMRP NRMD VH QDOD]L L]QDG EDELQH VREH
1D VXSURWQRM VWUDQL LVSRG SUR]RUD L X] VXVMHGQL ]LG MH VHLMD X
REOLNXVORYD/VNDOXLMDVWXFLPD,]QDGVHLMHQD]LGXQDOD]LVH
*H2)#,(>%+4! *&%6&%+4! (H#+4F! T! *&%-(]+>%1! )&#*"#&2! >%! )#*"4?8>%+4!
*#/&4!@!-%1(&8(>4F!T5!5(-!-#!?&4"4!>%!*4+-2H!54!&2$#F''HVSLDNXD
0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYRVWU
EB .XEHOLMD MH MHGQD RG QDMQHRELQLMLKL L QDMLQWHUHVDQWQLMLK SURVWRULMD
X NXL 'RELOD MH QD]LY SR RVOLNDQRM NXSROL NRMRP MH QDWNULYHQD
Q4-(! *%! #! +%H#>! ?&*"(! .#*"(+*H%! *#6%F! T! *"416%+#>! 4&$("%H"2&(!
RYDNDY WLS QDWNULYDQMD NXSRORP QLMH XRELDMHQ HH VH NRULVWL X
PRQXPHQWDOQRM DUKLWHNWXUL MDYQLK L YMHUVNLK REMHNDWD GDPLMH
$4141(3! $4+#?(@L4]8($4+! >%! (14#! 14.45%! +4"H&(?%+%! H2)#8414F!
8 XQXWUDQMHP XUHHQMX VH YH MDVQR PRH SULPLMHWLWL PLMHDQMH
#&(>%+"48+($! (! 54)4-+#%?&#)*H($! 2"(,4>4F! T! (*"#>! )&#*"#&(>(! )#&%-!
VWDULQVNH SHL VD ORQLLPD VHLMH UH]EDUHQRJ VDQGXND
VWDPEROVNHPDQJDOHPRHPRYLGMHWLYHOLNLOXVWHUXNUDHQVHGHIRP
?%+%,(>4+*H#!#.8%-48#3!1482!*48#+*H2!.4&+("2&2!2H&4]%+2!&%564&(>#1!
LVHGHIRPRUPDULL]UDHQXWHKQLFLLQWDU]LMHVPHUPHUQRPSORRP
H2)8>%+!#-!/&4+,2*H#.!H#+284!(!*4"!%+.8%*H%!)&#(5?#-+>%F!O#*%64+!
XNUDVHQWHULMHUDVXPDODNULQMD]DXYDQMHGUDJRFLMHQRVWLLUDKOHRG
VHGHIDNRMHMH+DGL0DNVRGRQLRVDKDGLOXNDL]-HUXVDOHPD'YLMH
LNRQH L NDQGLOR XSRWSXQMXMX NRPSOHNVQRVW SURLPDQMD UD]OLLWLK
H28"2#]H($!(!*"(8*H($!#-&%-+(,4!#?#.!(525%"+#!54+(18>(#.!(+"%&(>%&4F'
'HVSLDNXD0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYRVWU
=4&4>%?2F!_%8(H4!*#64NRMDMHVOXLOD]DVWDQRYDQ@
MH L RGUDYDQMH SR]RULQLK SUHGVWDYD JRYRUL R
)#*"2)+#1!)&#,%*2!%2&#)%(54,(>%!"&4-(,(#+48+#.!
%+"%&(>%&43!+4&4?+#!(!*41#1!+41>%+#1!48(!(!)#>4@
YRPJUDDQVNRJVOLNDUVWYDSRURGLQLKSRUWUHWD
&4-! *8(H4&4! b%w&",7( NRML QLVX NDUDNWHULVWLQL ]D
RVPDQVNL SHULRG 3URVWRULMH QD VSDUWX VSDYDD
*#64E`3584"+(! *48#+EC! (! "&)%54&(>43! -%1#+*"&(&4>2!
4)*#82"+2! -#1(+4,(>2! %2&#)*H($! *"4+-4&4-4! 2!
XQXWUDQMHPXUHHQMXVSUHSR]QDWOMLYLPVWLOVNLP
NDUDNWHULVWLNDPD ELGHUPDMHUD $QDOL]LUDMXL VYH
RYH HOHPHQWH VWLH VH GRMDP GD GYD NRQFHSWD
H28"2&%! *"4+#?4+>43! 4&$("%H"#+*H#.! #68(H#?4+>4!
L GHQLUDQMD IXQNFLMH XQXWUDQMHJ SURVWRUD VH
PHXVREQRSURLPDMXDOLQLVXNRPSDWLELOQL
8 DQWURSRPHWULQL SURVWRU ERVDQVNH NXH
WHNR VH PRH XNORSLWL PDVLYQL QDPMHWDM VUHG@
+>%%2&#)*H%!#&(>%+"4,(>%!2!*"(82!6(-%&14>%&4F!Q%@
]XOWDWWDNYLKSRNXDMDMHRSWHUHLYDQMHL]DJXHQMH
XQXWUDQMHJSURVWRUDLQDUXDYDQMHDXWHQWLQRVWL
"&4-(,(#+48+%!*"416%+%!4&$("%H"2&%
9HOLND VREDSR]RULQD VRED MH YHD SURVWRULMD VD RVOLNDQRP
UDYQRPGUYHQRPWDYDQLFRPNRMDMHGMHOLPLQRUHNRQVWUXLVDQD]ERJ
RWHHQMD ,]D UH]EDUHQLK YUDWD VH QDOD]LOD PDOD SURVWRULMD NRMD MH
YMHURYDWQRVOXLODNDRJDUGHURED8QXWUDQMHXUHHQMHVDVHLMDPD
LOLPLPD V SRQHNLP GLMHORYLPD QDPMHWDMD ]DSDGQRHYURSVNRJ VWLOD
SRQRYR JRYRUH R GLMDORJX UD]OLLWLK REUD]DFD X NXOWXUL VWDQRYDQMD
'HVSLDNXD0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYRVWU
E` 6SDYDD VRED V NUHYHWLPD QRQLP RUPDULLPD SVLKRP VOLNRP
UHOLJLR]QRJ VDGUDMD QD ]LGX VWROLFH L PDOL VWROL GYRNULOQL RUPDU
LLYDDPDLQDXND]XMHQDDSVROXWQXGRPLQDFLMXVUHGQMHHXURSVNRJ
VWDQGDUGDXXQXWUDQMHPXUHHQMXSURVWRULMHLMDMHIXQNFLMDNVLUDQD
+>%+(1!1#6(8(>4F''HVSLDNXD0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYR
VWU
EC 6DORQ VD OXVWHURP VDORQVNRP JDUQLWXURP SUHVYXHQRP ]ODWQLP
EURNDWQLP PHEORP X VWLOX ELGHUPDMHUD ]ODWQRP YLWULQRP V QLP
SRUFXODQVNLP SRVXHP MH MDVQR GHQLUDQ HXURSVNLP PRGHOLPD
XUHHQMD XQXWUDQMHJ SURVWRUD' 'HVSLD NXD 0X]HM 6DUDMHYD
6DUDMHYRVWU
7USH]DULMDVDNODYLURPSURL]YRGRPUPH1HXEDXHUL]%HDPDQMLP
UH]EDUHQLPRUPDULHPVDWRPRJOHGDORPWUSH]DULMVNLPVWRORPVD
HVWVWROLFDVHELWQRUD]OLNXMHRGWUDGLFLRQDOQRJNRQFHSWDXUHHQMD
EDELQHVREHSURVWRULMHVDSRVWDYOMHQRPVRIURPXVUHGLWXLVHLMDPD
LPXVDQGHUDPDXUXEQLPGLMHORYLPDX]]LGRYHNDRNVQLPGLMHORP
QDPMHWDMD 2EMHGRYDQMH ]D VRIURP L] VDKDQD VMHGHL QD SRGX
]DPLMHQMHQR MH ]DSDGQMDNLP QDLQRP -DVQR VH UD]GYDMD L NVLUD
/2+H,(>4!)#>%-(+($!)&#*"#&(>4!#?4H?(1!"()#1!1#6(8(>4&4!H#>(!)#")2+#!
"&4+*/#&1(]%! (! H4&4H"%&! (! 416(>%+"48+2! ?&(>%-+#*"! "&&4-(,(#+48+#.!
JUDGLWHOMVWYD'HVSLDNXD0X]HM6DUDMHYD6DUDMHYRVWU
131
6OD1DPMHWDMXVWLOX/RXLVD;9L]UR]DVDORQDX
HQVNRPGLMHOXSRURGLQHNXH+XVHGLQRYLD8%DQMRM/XFL
6OE1DPMHWDMXVWLOX/RXLVD;9L]UR]DVDORQDX
HQVNRPGLMHOXSRURGLQHNXH+XVHGLQRYLD8%DQMRM/XFL
132
Ea .XUWR1HGDG6DUDMHYR3ULQWLQJDQG3XEOLVKLQJ+RXVH
6DUDMHYRVWU
=LGRYL GHEOMLQH FP JUDHQL VX RG RSHNH VRNO RSODWD GRQMLK
5#+4! /4*4-%! (! *"%)%+(]"%! >%! H41%+#3! -#H! *2! )#-#?(3! )&?#6("+4!
YHUDQGDLNURYQDNRQVWUXNFLMDRGGUYHWDVSRNULYDHPRGHWHUQLWD
c&?%+4! ?%&4+-4! *4! )#.8%-#1! +4! -?#&(]"%! (! &(>%H2! *&2](84! *%! 2*8>%-!
+%)#*"#>4+#*"(!14"%&(>4843!"%!>%!541(>%+>%+4!6%"#+*H#1F
,]DNXHQDOD]LODVHSURVWUDQDWHUDVDVDHGUYDQRPLVSRGNRMHVXVH
+4845(8%!?%]!H2$(+>4!(!H(+#!*484!-#!H#>($!*%!*(845(8#!*"%)%+(]"%1F!L%&4*4!
VHVUXLODJRGLQH]ERJVOLMHJDQMDWHUHQD1DNRQNDWDVWURIDOQRJ
]HPOMRWUHVDJNXDMHSUHWUSLOD]QDWQDRWHHQMD2EQRYOMHQDMH
LRGWDGDMHSRG]DWLWRPGUDYH
BD 7UREULGQL NXELQL HUNHU QLMH SXND GHNRUDFLMD YH MH ORJLDQ
SURGXNWIXQNFLMHLGLVSR]LFLMHXQXWUDQMHJSURVWRUD.XUWR1HGDG
A&$("%H"2&4!:#*+%!(!9%&,%.#?(+%3!&45?#>!6#*4+*H#.!*"(843!=4&4>%?#!
3XEOLVKLQJ0HXQDURGQLFHQWDU]DPLU6DUDMHYRVWU
BE .U]RYL ,EUDKLP $UKLWHNWXUD VHFHVLMH X %RVQL L +HUFHJLRYLQL
.XOWXUQRQDVOLMHH6DUDMHYR3XEOLVKLQJ6DUDMHYRVWU
(+"%&)&%"4,(>%!"&4-(,(#+48+#.F!S*"4H+2"%!*"&%$%!*%!
>4?8>4>2!(!(5+4-!2845+($!H4)(>4F!7%+"&48+#!&45?(>%+4!
-(*)#5(,(>4! #6>%H"4! )&4"(! /2+H,(#+48+2! )#->%82!
SURVWRULMD L SRGMHOX QD MDYQL PXNL GLR NXH L
SULYDWQL HQVNL LPH VH SRWXMH WUDGLFLRQDOQD
NXOWXUD VWDQRYDQMD 8QXWUDQMD GLVSR]LFLMD NXH
VHRGUDDYDQDIDVDGL
="(8*H%! H4&4H"%&(*"(H%! &4+%! 0.)"%#"! 1#.2!
VH SUHSR]QDWL X UMHHQMX IDVDGH SURLHQH L
RVORERHQH RG GHNRUDWLYQLK HOHPHQDWD L LVWLP
NXELQLPJHRPHWULMVNLPIRUPDPD
Q("1(54,(>2!(!*H84-+%!)&#)#&,(>%!.84?+%!/4*4-%!
QDJODDYDMXVLPHWULQRUDVSRUHHQLSUR]RUVNLRW@
YRULX]RQLSUL]HPOMDHWLULLX]RQLVSUDWDSHWQD
GRNVDWXLGYDVDERQLKVWUDQD1DMXQRMIDVDGL
)#&%-!)#&4!*#6%!54!H2$4&(,2!(!*"%)%+(]"4!>4?8>4!
*%! (! *8(>%)(! )#&3! >%-4+! #-! 4&$("%H"#+*H($! %8@
HPHQDWDNRML9DQFDHVWRNRULVWLXREUDGLIDVDGH
GDELQDJODVLRULWPL]DFLMXKDUPRQLQRVWLVLPHWU@
(>2! H#1)#5(,(>%FBB , SRUHG RLJOHGQLK UHIHULUDQMD
+4!"&4-(,(#+48+#!.&4-("%8>*"?#!1#.2!*%!)&(1(>%"("(!
L RGUHHQD RGVWXSDQMD RG XRELDMHQLK UMHHQMD
9LVLQD L LULQD SUL]HPQJ GLMHOD NXH RGJRYDUD
?(*(+(!)&?#.!*)&4"4!]"#!*%!6("+#!&458(H2>%!#-!H#+@
FHSWD WUDGLFLRQDOQH ERVDQVNH NXH NRMD RELQR
LPDJRUQMLVSUDWLULLQLLRGSUL]HPOMD2YGMHVH
QHUDGLRVLVWHPXGYRMQHNXHPXNHLHQVNH
)#?%54+#1!146%>+#1!2!>%-(+*"?%+!4&$("%H"#+*H(!
DQVDPEONDRWRMHWRVOXDMVD6YU]LQRPNXRP
X6DUDMHYXVDPXNLPLHQVNLPGYRULWHPL]D@
VHEQLP VWDPEHQLP REMHNWLPD YH R SRGMHOL QD
PXNLLHQVNLGLRSRHWDDPD.XDMHLPDODHVW
*48#+4!#&(>%+"(*4+($!+4!28(,2!;"&(!2!12]H#1!(!"&(!
XHQVNRPGLMHOXNXHLQXVSURVWRULMHNXKLQMX
NXSDWLOR WH VSDYDH VREH ]D GMHFX L URGLWHOMH
#&(>%+"(*4+%!+4!-?#&(]"%F!T!12]H#1!&%)&%5%+"4@
WLYQRPGLMHOXNXHVXWULVDORQDVDRULMHQWDFLMRP
BB 1D9DQFDHYRMNXLX6DUDMHYXQDJODYQRPSURHOMXX]RQLVSUDWRYD
MDYOMD VH RYDNDY YLG GHNRUDFLMH L UDODQMLYDQMD NXD 7HRGGRUD
7KRGHVKLQLMDX6DUDMHYXQDERQRMIDVDGLLPDWDNRHUVOLMHSLSUR]RU
133
H2$(+>%3!])4>543!*#6%!54!H2$4&(,2!(!"#48%"43!H#>(!*2!
#&(>%+"(*4+(!+4!-?#&(]"%F!W(-#?(!H2)4"(84!(!H2$(+>%!
VX REORHQL NHUDPLNLP SORLFDPD X' (' 7(' B%(#1(!
*"(82!]"#!*%!6("+#!&458(H2>%!#-!"&4-(,(#+48#.!H#+@
FHSWDKDPDPGLNDXVNORSXPXVDQGHUHLPXWYD@
NDVYRGQLFRP1DVSUDWXXHQVNRPGLMHOXNXH
+4845(1#! +4! (*"(! &4*)#&%-! )&#*"#&(>4F! L&(! *48#+4!
HQVND GLYDQKDQDB`3! 6! *48#+BC L GMHYRMDND
*#64<!#&(>%+"(*4+($!*2!+4!28(,2F!94>4"!#-?4>4!#?%!
SURVWRULMHRGVSDYDHVREHURGLWHOMDGMHLMHVREH
6O.HUDPLNDSHL]UR]DVDORQDREOLNRYDQDXSUH
SR]QDWOMLYLPIRUPDPDXPMHWQRVWLVHFHVLMH
134
B` 2YR MH MHGLQD SURVWRULMD X NXL NRMD MH VDXYDOD DXWHQWLDQ
PRELOLMDU 1DPMHWDM HQVNH GLYDQKDQH SUHGVWDYOMD L]YDQUHGDQ VSRM
*&%-+>%%2&#)*H($! *"(8*H($! #&(>%+"4,(>4! H4*+#.! 41)(&43! 6(-%&14>%&43!
*%,%*(>%!(!6#*4+*H#.!"&4-(,(#+48+#.!%+"%&(>%&4F!N#6(8(>4&!*48#+4!*4*"#>(!
VHRGGYDWUSH]DULMVNDRUPDUDHWYUWDVWRJVWRODVDHVWVWROLFDYHOLNH
NHUDPLNH SHL ]LGQRJ VDWD VWLOVNRJ OXVWHUD VHLMH X GRNVDWQRP
%&H%&2!H#>4!*%!54?&]4?4!*4!]H&46(>4143!14+.48%3!H#+,%&"+#.!H84?(&43!
VUHEUHQRJ VHFHVLMVNRJ DMQLND GL]DMQLUDQRJ X PDQLUL DUW QRXYHDXD
(! S+"#"%' S"%8&$y$$"LM' ORSDWLFH L HWNH ]D LHQMH VWROD L VUHEUHQRJ
HVFDMJD VD LQLFLMDOLPD YODVQLND NXH GLR PRELOLMDUD LQLR MH L NODYLU
.DUO .XWFKHUD EHNH SURL]YRGQMH 9HL GLR QDPMHWDMD HQVNH
GLYDQKDQH GRSUHPOMHQ MH L] %HD 9HOLNL VWLOVNL OXVWHU VDVWRML VH RG
YLH GLMHORYD UDHQLK RG UD]OLLWLK PDWHULMDOD PHWDOD VYLOH L GUYHWD
6WLOL]LUDQD IRUPD OXVWHUD VXJHULUD PRWLY VXQFD 7UL DEDXUD UDHQD
*2! #-! 6(>%8%! *?(8%3! 4! H#+*"&2H,(>4! 82*"%&4! H#16(+4,(>#1! 1%"484! *4!
SR]ODWRP L GUYHWD 9HOLNL ]LGQL VDW EHNH SURL]YRGQMH V RNYLURP
#-! "41+#.! &%564&%+#.! -&?%"4! +4-! *4"+(1! 1%$4+(51#1! (14!
XJUDYLUDQL WHNVW QD QMHPDNRP MH]LNX |W+"' l"+$' +&$' f"7)}! ;_&(>%1%!
>%! +#?4,<yF! L#! >%! 2>%-+#! (! +4>*"4&(>(! -(#! %+"%&(>%&43! )&()4-4#! >%! #,2!
YODVQLND NXH +DGL +DPLGX +XVHGLQRYLX 8 XJOX SRUHG YUDWD
VREHQDOD]LVHYLVRNDNHUDPLNDSHFLOLQGULQRJREOLNDELMHOHERMH
]D]ODWQRPGHNRUDFLMRP%LOMQLRUQDPHQWLPRWLYJLUODQGLUDHQLX
SR]ODWLQRVHSUHSR]QDWOMLYDVHFHVLMVNDVWLOVNDRELOMHMD0DOHGUYHQH
NUDELMH SRVWDYOMHQH QD NUDMHYLPD VHLMH NDR QMHQL ]DYUHFL UDHQH
*2!2!-&?#&%564&(>(!*4!,&+#1!(!6(>%8#1!*%-%/+#1!"#8%-#!(+"4&%5(>#1!
RG GUYHQH LSNH L SURVWRULPD XRNYLUHQLP ERJDWR SUROLVDQLP
LVODPVNLP OXNRYLPD X NRMLPD VX VH XYDOL XNUDVQL SUHGPHQWL L
SRVXH 2YDM GLR HQWHULMHUD QRVL VWLOVNH NDUDNWHULVWLNH LVODPVNH
21>%"+#*"(!N4.&%64!(!^)4+(>%!H4#!(!+41>%]"4>!(5!4&4)*H%!*#6%F!V#&+>%!
5#+%!5(-#?4!(!)84/#+!#*8(H4+(!*2!(7'&"11.!-%H#&4,(>#1!H#>4!)&%-*"4?8>4!
ULMHGDN SULPMHU VDXYDQH XQXWUDQMH GHNRUDFLMH X VWLOX VHFHVLMH 8
JRUQMLP ]RQDPD ]LGRYD WHH IUL] VD PRWLYRP LPLWDFLMH PR]DLND L
DHVDYLQRPRNUXHQHYLQRYRPOR]RPNRMLVHULWPLQRSRQDYOMD
=?4H4! H#1)#5(,(>*H4! ,>%8(+4! >%! #-?#>%+4! 1#"(?#1! .(&84+-%! *8(H4+%!
XJUL]DMWHKQLFL1DVOLDQQDLQMHRVOLNDQLSODIRQ,YLFDPDSODIRQD
WHHGHNRUDWLYQLIUL]JLUODQGLRVOLNDQXJUL]DMWHKQLFL8NYDGUDWQLP
SROMLPD VPMHWHQLP X XJORYLPD MDYOMD VH PRWLY OLD YLQRYH OR]H L
.-#?4F
BC 1DPMHWDM RYRJ VDORQD QDEDYOMHQ L] 3DUL]D SUHNR %HD VDVWRML VH
RG VRIH GYLMH IRWHOMHIRWHOMH OMXEDYQLNDWHWHDWHWHIUDQFRL X
RL X REOLNX VORYD 6 NRMH DVRFLUD QD URNDLO RUQDPHQW L] SHULRGD
/RXLVD ;9 L VWROLFD 8QXWUDQMH XUHHQMH VYH NDUDNWHULWLNH QRYLK
*"4+-4&-4! 2! H28"2&(! *"4+#?4+>4! *! +4.84*H#1! +4! 2"(,4>! /&4+,2*H#.!
URNRNRDVWLOD/RXLVD;96YLGLMHORYLQDPMHWDMDELOLVXSUHVYXHQL
UXLDVWLP EURNDWRP HWYUWDVWD NHUDPLND SH VPMHWHQD X XJOX
SRUHG YUDWD GHNRULVDQD MH JOHRVDQRP NHUDPLNRP ELMHOH SRGORJH
VD L]YDQUHGQRP VHFHVLMVNRP RUDOQRP GHNRUDFLMRP X REOLNX
FYLMHWD OMXELLFH SUHSR]QDWOMLYLP PRWLYRP XPMHWQRVWL VHFHVLMH
UDHQLK SDVWHOQR OMXELDVWLP WRQDOLWHWLPD VD DNFHQWLPD ]ODWQH
6#>%F!U#1)8%"4+!(+?%+"4&!*#6%!)&#-4>#1!+4H#+!*1&"(!)&?#6("+#.!
YODVQLNDGRVSLRMHX'XEURYQLN-HGLQRMHNHUDPLNDSHMRXYLMHN+#'
&+$2F
Umjesto zaklju ka
O&#,%*!"&4+*/#&14,(>%!"&4-(,(#+48+%!*"416%+%!
4&$("%H"2&%!)#-!2"(,4>%1!%2&#)%(54,(>%!-#84*H#1!
42*".4&*H%!2)&4?%!#62$?4"4!)%&(#-!H&4>4!fSf!
LSRHWND;;VW
=QDDMRYDNYLKREMHNDWDLHQWHULMHUDRJOHGDVH
X VSHFLQRP VSDMDQMX UD]OLLWLK NXOWXURORNLK
*"(8*H($! (! %*"%"*H($! *"4+-4&-4! +4! >%-4+! .#"#?#!
SRVWPRGHUQLVWLNLQDLQ
2QL VYMHGRH R VSRVREQRVWL SULODJRDYDQMD L
WUDQVIRUPDFLMH WUDGLFLRQDOQRJ QDLQD JUDGQMH X
H#+"%H*"2! /2+H,(#+48+($! 54$"(>%?4! *2?&%1%+#.!
QDLQD LYRWD 3UHOD]HL SXW RG WUDGLFLRQDOL]PD
RELOMHHQRJRULMHQWDOQLPQDLQRPJUDGQMHQMHJRY@
(1! )#?%5(?4+>%1! *! +#?(1! *&%-+>%%2&#)*H(1!
.&4-("%8>*H(1!*"4+-4&-(143!)&%H#!&%.(#+48(514!(+@
WHUSUHWLUDQRJQDVSHFLDQQDLQNUR]DUKLWHNWXUX
6#*4+*H#.! *8#.4! 2845(1#! 2! +#?2! /452! 2! &45?#>2!
DUKLWHNWXUHQDRYRPSRGUXMXRELOMHHQRPLQWHU@
+4,(#+48+(1!*"(8#1!0.)"%#"N!
,PDMXL X YLGX VYX SUREOHPDWLNX YH]DQX ]D
SURFHV HXURSHL]DFLMH JUDGVNH NXH RULMHQWDOQRJ
WLSDPRHVH]DNOMXLWLGDNDRSRVHEDQJUDGLWHOMVNL
LNXOWXURORNLIHQRPHQERVDQVNDNXDVYRMRP
YLWDOQRX VYMHGRL R NRQWLQLWHWX WUDGLFLRQDOQRJ
.&4-("%8>*"?43! )͍(! H! )&#,%*! "&4+*/#&14,(>%!
48(! #)*"4>%! H4#! (525%"+#! ?&(>%-4+! -(#! 6#.4"#.!
ERVDQVNRKHUFHJRYDNRJJUDGLWHOMVNRJQDVOLMHD
H2)4"(84!(!"#48%"4!H#>(!.8%-4>2!+4!-?#&(]"%F!O#*%6+2!
YULMHGQRVWNXHSUHGVWDYOMDOLVXL]X]HWQRYULMHGQL
ERJDWR RSUHPOMHQL HQWHULMHUL UD]OLLWLK VWLOVNLK
H4&4H"%&(*"(H4F! c#H! *41! #6>%H4"! (14! H4&4H"%&(*@
WLNHWUDGLFLRQDOQHDUKLWHNWXUHVDPRGHUQLVWLNLP
WHQGHQFLMDPDUHGXNFLMHVWLOLVWLNLKLQWHUSUHWDFLMDL
-%H#&4"(?+#*"(3!%+"%&(>%&(!(14>2!+4.84]%+!-%H#&4@
"(?+(! 416(>%+"48+(! H4&4H"%&F! Q4-(! *%! #! .#"#?#!
SRVWPRGHUQLVWLNRP SRYH]LYDQMX UD]OLLWLK VWLO@
*H($!#-&%-+(,4!6(-%&14>%&43!*%,%*(>%3!*"(84!X#2(*4!
f_3! *! 142&*H(1! *"(8#1! (! %8%1%+"(14! "&4-(,(#@
QDOQRJ HQWHULMHUD ERVDQVNH NXH %XGXL GD VH
UDGL R QRYRVDJUDHQRP REMHNWX V QDPMHQVNL
#*1(]8>%+(1!%+"%&(>%&(14!#*"?4&%+!>%!*H84-+(>(!#-@
QRVLYH]DL]PHXWUDGLFLRQDOQRJLVXYUHPHQRJ
'RNMHDUDSVNDVREDXUHHQDSRWSXQRXPDXU@
VNRPVWLOXYHOLNDVREDHQVNDGLYDQKDQDSUHG@
*"4?8>4! 54+(18>(?! *)#>! %8%1%+4"4! "&4-(,(#+48+#.!
%+"%&(>%&4! *! 1#6(8(>4! 2! *"(82! 6(-%&14>%&43! "%!
NHUDPLNRPSHLLVOLNDQRP]LGQRPGHNRUDFLMRP
2! *"(82! *%,%*(>%F! Q#54! *48#+! *4! *48#+*H#1! .4&+(@
WXURP X VWLOX /RXLVD ;9 L NHUDPLNRP SHL X
VWLOXVHFHVLMHRELOMHHQMHSRWSXQRPGRPLQDFLMRP
)&($?4"4+>4!+#?($!*"4+-4&4-4!(!*"(8*H($!#-&%-+(,4!
6%5! %8%1%+4"4! "&4-(,(#+48+#.! %+"%&(>%&4F! _(*(+4!
VWURSRYD L YHOLLQD SURVWRULMD X VNODGX V VWDQ@
-4&-(14! 42*".4&H#.! )%&(#-4! #-.#?4&4! 14@
*(?+#*"(!1#6(8(>4&4!H#>(!*%!+%!6(!1#.4#!2H8#)("(!2!
DQWURSRPHWULQLSURVWRUWUDGLFLRQDOQHVWDPEHQH
4&$("%H"2&%F
135
136
2YDMODQDNGLVNXWXMHRSODQLUDQMLPDQRYLKXUEDQLKQDVHOMDX%RVQLL+HUFHJRYLQLNDRSRVOMHGLFDSURJRQDRNR
KLOMDGD0XVOLPDQDL]6UELMHXSHULRGXLJX%RVQXLRVWDOHWHULWRULMHSRGRVPDQVNRPYODX
6WDYOMHQMHDNFHQDWSRVHEQRQDJUDGRYHVMHYHUQH%RVQHDPDF2UDMH%UH]RYR3ROMHL2UDKRYDNRMLVHQDOD]H
QDJUDQLFLVD$XVWULMVNRPFDUHYLQRPLNRMLVXSURVWRUQRSURMHNWRYDQLVDRUWRJRQDOQRPPUHRPXOLFD8DPFX
*RUQMD$]L]LMDQD]YDQDSRWDGDQMHPVXOWDQX$EGXOD]L]XMHQDSULPMHUL]JUDHQRGUYHQLKNXD]D
VWDQRYQLNDQDSODQLUDQRMRUWRJRQDOQRMPUHLXOLFDGL]DMQLUDQRMQDYRGQRRGVWUDQHIUDQFXVNRJLQLQMHUD
XVOXEL2VPDQVNRJFDUVWYD82UDMX'RQMD$]L]LMDLVWLEURMNXDMHXGRPLRUDVHOMHQHRVREHL]6UELMH
1D]LYLJUDGRYDL]NRMLKVXGROD]LOLXRYRPVOXDMXDEDFL8LFHUHHNWRYDOLVXVHXQD]LYLPDNYDUWRYD
NRMDVXQDVHOMDYDOL8VYLPRYLPQRYLPQDVHOMLPDL]JUDHQHVXGDPLMHQD]YDQH$]L]LMDPD$UKLWHNWRQVNL
QDM]QDDMQLMDRGRYLKQRYLKGDPLMDMHVWHGDPLMDL]JUDHQDX%UH]RYRP3ROMXRNRJ8SRJOHGXVWLOD
QD]YDQDMHSULPMHURPWXUVNRJEDURND2YDSDQMHYULMHGQDGDPLMDMHXSRWSXQRVWLXQLWHQDXUDWXJL
*.$.0'.:#.47V"#('2'&8.%+V"0'*"%+.)2N
T,+&'(%$+17"')+&12&&"&'$,"'*7(##+#5'.B '#"P'2%:(#'&"$$7"0"#$&'+#'6.&#+('(#)'<"%X"5.4+#('(&'('%"&*.#&"'$.'$,"'
HYDFXDWLRQRI 0XVOLPVIURP6HUELDWR%RVQLDDQGRWKHU2WWRPDQWHUULWRULHVLQ6SHFLFDOO\
DGGUHVVHGDUHWKHQRUWKHUQ%RVQLDQWRZQVRI DPDF2UDMH%UH]RYR3ROMHDQG2UDKRYDDOOVLWXDWHGDORQJWKH
ERUGHUZLWKWKH$XVWULDQ(PSLUHDQGSODQQHGRQDUHJXODUJULG,QDPDF8SSHU$]L]L\HVRQDPHGDIWHU
WKHWKHQFXUUHQW6XOWDQ$EGOD]L]IRULQVWDQFHWLPEHUKRXVHVZHUHEXLOWIRULQKDELWDQWVWKH\ZHUH
DOLJQHGRQDJULGSODQSXUSRUWHGO\GHVLJQHGE\D)UHQFKHQJLQHHULQWKHVHUYLFHRI WKH2WWRPDQVWDWH,Q2UDMH
EZq.P"%'CX+X+R"[LM'$,"'&(0"'#20:"%'.B ',.2&"&'P(&'$.'(11.00.)($"'GQH')+&*7(1")'*"%&.#&'B%.0'U"%:+(N'T,"+%'
WRZQVRI RULJLQKHUHDEDFDQG8LFHZHUHUHHFWHGLQWKHQDPHVRI WKHQHZTXDUWHUVWKH\FDPHWRLQKDELW
b%+)(R'0.&]2"&M'2&2(77R'#(0")'ZCX+X+R"M['P"%"'"%"1$")'+#'(77'.B '$,"'#"P'&"$$7"0"#$&N'T,"'0.&$'(%1,+$"1$2%(77R'
%"0(%8(:7"'.B '$,"&"'#"P'0.&]2"&'P(&':2+7$'+#'6%"X.4.'a.7V"'(%.2#)'FIQH'(#)M'+#'$"%0&'.B '&$R7"M',(&':""#'1(77")'
('%"*%"&"#$($+4"'.B '$,"'Z-$$.0(#'6(%.]2"N['T,+&'#.$"P.%$,R'0.&]2"'P(&'1.0*7"$"7R')"&$%.R")'+#'FGGH'(#)'+&'
*%"&"#$7R':"+#5'%"1.#&$%21$")N
5D]YRMRVPDQVNRGREQRJJUDGDQDSRGUXMX%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQH
RG GR VW PRH VH SURPDWUDWL NUR] QMHJRY #(&".:+#&8+'
2%:(#+' 8.#$"8&$ NRML VH VDVWRML RG QMHJRYH VDVWDYQH RGUHGQLFH
;*4*"4?+(,%<F! c%"48>+(>%! #! &45?#>2! #*14+*H#-#6+($! .&4-#?4! +4!
SRGUXMX%RVDQVNRJ'"V(7"$(YLGMHWLNRG0LU]D+DVDQHPDQa.4+V"&$M'
WLSRORJLMDVDGUDMLIXQNFLMHVWUXNWXUDLWRSRJUDMDJUDGDX%RVDQVNRPHMDOHWX
.)' FdN' &$N' ).' FGN' &$N! c(*%&"4,(>4F! A#&$+$2$20' U$2)+.%20' <20(#+$($+&! Z!
;V&4-24"%! =,$##8! #/ ! 9214+("(%*<3! X>268>4+43! _#8F! E@`3! X>268>4+43!
BDDCF!;2!-48>+>%1!"%H*"2!,("(&4!*%!H4#!3RYLMHVWWLSRORJLMDVDGUDML<F
3RVHEQRUD]YRMQDVHOMD7UHELQMH/DW1/RQJ
(L6WRODF/DW1/RQJ(
48(!(!+%H($!-&2.($!14+>($!1>%*"4F
Urgentno i plansko
osnivanje urbanih naselja
tokom 1862. i 1863. g.
W4+(18>(?!)&(1>%&!+4*"4+H4!(!&45?#>4!;H4*+($<!
#*14+*H#-#6+($! +4*%8>4! )&%-*"4?8>4>2! +4*%8>4!
;8(&(:"<! H#>4! *2! +4*"484! +4H#+! )&#.#+4! 12*8(@
PDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYDL]6UELMHLJ8
VORHQLPRGQRVLPDNRMLVXQDVWXSLOLQDNRQ,L,,
=&)*H#.!2*"4+H43!"%!)#*%6+#!+4H#+!]"#!*2!)&%H#@
-&(+*H(!8()+721+'QDSRGUXMXGDQDQMH5HSXEOLNH
9LGM0LU]D+DVDQHPDQ3RYLMHVWWLSRORJLMDVDGUDML3!)4**(1F!
2$ !&<2$ 2*=+'/>+%/;#$:#*4+*H#.'"V(7"$(!"#H#1!
RVPDQVNH YODVWL ]QDDMQR UD]GREOMH L REOLN XU@
64+(54,(>%! )&%-*"4?8>4! $("+#! )#-(54+>%! +#?($!
QDVHOMD XUEDQRJ WLSD ]ERJ SRMDYH SURJQDQLNR
L]EMHJOLNLKNUL]DXYLHQDYUDWDPMHVQHKLVWR@
&(>%FE! L4H?4! +4*%8>4! )#! #-82,(! #*14+*H%! ?84*"(!
QDMHHVXRGPDKSRRVQLYDQMXLOLQHWRNDV@
+(>%3!*">%,484!*"4"2*!8(&(:"3UREOHPSURJQDQLNR
L]EMHJOLNLKNUL]DUMHDYDQMHLQDQDLQQDVHOMD@
?4+>4!-(>%84!)&#.+4+(H4!(!(56>%.8(,4!;PXKDGLUD<!2!
YHSRVWRMHDXUEDQDQDVHOMD8(&(:"F!T!#?#1!
ODQNX GDW MH QDJODVDN QD ]ELYDQMD X VMHYHUQRM
:#*+(F! A+48(54! 56(?4+>4! 2! 54)4-+#>! :#*+(! (!
LVWRQRM+HUFHJRYLQLB!+4H#+!)4-4!9%&,%.!M#@
YRJSRGPOHWDNXYODVWJ]DKWLMHYD
QHWRGUXJDLMLSULVWXSNRMLL]OD]LL]YDQSURVWRU@
+#.!#H?(&4!H#>(!*%!+4845(!+4!&4*)#84.4+>2!54!#?4>!
"%H*"F!
2VLPKLVWRULMHQRYRRVQRYDQLKQDVHOMDLPMHUD
NRMHVXSUHGX]LPDQH]DUD]UMHHQMHSURJQDQLNR
L]EMHJOLNLK NUL]D ]D LVWUDLYDQMD VX ]QDDMQL L
VDGUDML VWUXNWXUH IXQNFLMH L WRSRJUDMD WDNYLK
+#?##*+#?4+($! +4*%8>4! ;8(&(:( 8 VOXDMHYLPD
+4*%8>4?4+>4! -(>%84! )&#.+4+(H4! (! (56>%.8(,4!
;PXKDGLUD X YH SRVWRMHD XUEDQD QDVHOMD 8(&/
(:"<'YHRPD]DQLPOMLYLPLQHVHGUXWYHQLRGQRVL
XQXWDUWDNYLKQDVHOMDNRMLVXVHSRMDYLOLLXREOLLOL
137
6UELMHNRMLVXGRJSULSDGDOL=YRUQLNRP
VDQGDNX! #-82H#1! *&%-(]+>%! #*14+*H%! ?84*"(!
XVWXSOMHQL .QHHYLQL 6UELML XVOLMHGLOR MH SUR@
">%&(?4+>4! 12*8(14+*H#.! *"4+#?+(]"?4! (5! (*"($!
8()+728(3ROLWLNLSUREOHPNRMLVHSRMDYLRDNRML
VH WLFDR SRORDMD PXVOLPDQVNRJ VWDQRYQLWYD X
.QHHYLQL6UELMLQDVWRMDORVHULMHLWLSUHJRYRULPD
L]PHX 2VPDQVNRJ FDUVWYD L .QHHYLQH 6UELMH
O&%.#?#&(!*2!54?&]%+(!*)#&4521#1!#!(*%8>4?4+>2!
*?#.! 12*8(14+*H#.! *"4+#?+(]"?4` L] .QHHYLQH
6UELMHQDSRGUXMH%RVDQVNRJ"V(7"$(FC!c?(>%!?84-%!
2! *)#&2! #H#! +4?%-%+#.! *"4+#?+(]"?4! -#.#?#&@
(8%!*2!*%!-4!*%!12*8(14+*H#!*"4+#?+(]"?#!=&6(>%!
LVHOLQDSRGUXMH%RVDQVNRJ "V(7"$(3!"%!-4!*%!+>(@
KRYDQHSRNUHWQDLPRYLQDQDGRNQDGLRGUHHQRP
YULMHGQRXNRMXMHWUHEDODRVLJXUDWLYODGD6UELMH!
:#*4+*H(! "V(7"$' )#+#?#! >%! 54)8>2*+2#! ?48! )&#.@
+4+(H4! (! (56>%.8(,4F! L#! +%*&%"+#! *"4+#?+(]"?#! 2!
+4&#-2! >%! +45LYDQR PXKDGLULPD D X VOXEHQRM
#*14+*H#>!H#&%*)#+-%+,(>(!+45(?4!*%'|&27$(#.4+0'
PXVDULPDn' T! ?&(>%1%! +4?%-%+($! 56(?4+>4! +4!
1>%*"2!:#*4+*H#.!4(7+V"QDOD]LRVHHULI 2VPDQ
7RSDO3DDa
138
C!
b!
,]JRQPXVOLPDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYD]DSRHRMH
XYHHPRELPXLXRUJDQL]LUDQRPREOLNX
LSRORYLQRPJ0XKDGLUL*2!+%#&.4+(5(&4@
QR GROD]LOL QD SRGUXMH =YRUQLNRJ VDQGDND
JGMH VX QDVWRMDOL SURQDL VSDV VNORQLWH L ULMHLWL
VYRM QHVLJXUQL SRORDM 7X VX PXKDGLUL 6(8(!
SULKYDHQL RG VWUDQH ORNDOQH RVPDQVNH YODVWL L
GRPDHJ ERVDQVNRJ VWDQRYQLWYD 8 SUYR YUL@
>%1%! PXKDGLUL *2! 6(8(! *1>%]"%+(! )#! )&(?4"+(1!
NXDPDDL]GUDYDQLVXQDWHUHWFDUVNHGUDYQH
684.4>+%! (! -#6&#?#8>+(1! )&(8#5(143! "%! 2! +%H(1!
VOXDMHYLPD REDYH]QLP QRYDQLP SULOR]LPD!
6UHGLQMDRVPDQVNDYODVWWDQLMHVDP&27$(#'A6-!
@!28!A5(53!)&%25%84!>%!#64?%52!-4!PXKDGLUH!+4*%8(!
QD SRGUXMX %RVDQVNRJ "V(7"$(! (! -4! &(>%](! )("4+>%!
QMLKRYRJ VPMHWDMD L EXGXHJ LYRWD X "V(7"$2 2
QDLQXUMHHQMDQDYHGHQRJSUREOHPDPLOMHQMDVX
6(84!)#-(>%8>%+4F!L4H#!>%!:#*4+*H(!4(7+V(HULI 2V@
14+!@!O4]4!)&%-84.4#!-4!*%!+%H4-4]+>(!*"4+#?+(,(!
SUHNRGULQVNLKJUDGRYD=YRUQLNRJVDQGDND!=#@
NRODL8LFDWUDMQRQDVHOHUD]PMHVWHX%LMHOMLQL
N4.84>23!=4&4>%?23!L258(!(!W?#&+(H2F!M4!#?4H?#!
1(]8>%+>%! 4(7+V"! 2">%,484! >%! +>%.#?4! *)#5+4>4! -4!
*2! PXKDGLUL! (5! +4?%-%+($! )&%H#-&(+*H($! .&4@
GRYD =YRUQLNRJ VDQGDND! )&%-*"4?8>48(! .&4-*H#!
VWDQRYQLWYR GD VX GR WDGD LYMHOL X JUDGRYLPD
2!H#>(14!*2!*%!64?(8(!.&4-*H(1!#68(,(14!.#*)#@
-4&*"?4!;"&.#?(+4!(!#6&"<3!"%!-4!6(!6(8#!-#6&#!H4H#!
54! +>($! *41%3! "4H#! (! 54! #*14+*H2! ?84*"! -4! (*"(!
62-2!+4*"4+>%+(!2!6#*4+*H(1!.&4-#?(14F!L4H?#!
&>%]%+>%!#-.#?4&48#!>%!(!PXKDGLULPD!(5!+4?%-%+($!
JUDGRYD NRML VX RHNLYDOL REHWHHQMH ]D L]JX@
EOMHQD LPDQMD L LPHWDN X 6UELML L PRJXQRVW GD
*%! )#"#1! +4*%8%! 2! .&4-#?(14! :#*4+*H#.! "V(7"$('
L WX UD]YLMDMX YODVWLWX SRVORYQX GMHODWQRVW HN
@! :%>3! )&%-*"4?+(H! *&%-(]+>%! #*14+*H%! ?84*"(! 2!
RYRPSLWDQMXSUHGODJDRMHRLWRSRQDUHHQMLPD
&27$(#(3!-4!*%!PXKDGLUL!+4*%8%!+4!>%-+#!1>%*"#!(!
GD VH ]D LVWH L]JUDGL QRYR QDVHOMH QD GUDYQRP
]HPOMLWXNRMHMHQHNRGRNRQVNDFLMHL]D
J SULSDGDOR +XVHLQ.DSHWDQX *UDGDHYLXED!
.RQDQX RGOXNX GRQHR MH %RVDQVNL 4(7+V(' ^%&(/ !
2VPDQ 3DD NRML MH RLWR SRG SULWLVNRP
VUHGLQMH RVPDQVNH YODVWL RGOXLR GD VH QDMYHL
6&#>! VXOWDQRYLK PXVDUD! H#>(! *2! 6(8(! )&#.+4+(! (5!
6UELMH QDVHOL XQXWDU QDVHOMD NRMD H VH SRGLL ]D
*DOLEOMLYR2UDMH3!Ea!(!-F!
ED! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH,EUDKLP7HSL6.&#('+'<"%1"5.4+#('2'%2&8+0'
+X4.%+0('FIdQ/FInI6DUDMHYR
EE! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH3!BBF
EB 'HWDOMQLMH YLGMHWL NRG DEDQ +RGL ;+5%(1+V(' 02&7+0(#&8.5'
VWDQRYQLWYD
! W"47"$3!"2&F3!(5?F!(5!4&F!)yP7yVRVQRYQLP]QDHQMHPGUDYDFDUVWYR
#-+#*+#! ,4&%?(+43! 4! 2! H#+"%H*"2! "%H*"4! H#>(! *%! ,("(&4K! *&%-(]+>4!
RVPDQVNDYODVW 9LVRND3RUWD
E`! A2"#&!"%H*"4!1(*8(!+4!4(7+V2'HULI 2VPDQ7RSDO3DX9LGM3DYDR
LYNRYL3ROLWLNHJRVSRGDUVNHHWQLNHNXOWXUQHLYMHUVNHSULOLNH
X XSL 7ROLVD X VUHGQMHP YLMHNXRVPDQVNRP L DXVWURXJDUVNRP
SHULRGX9,'R;;6W8XSD7ROLVDF3!L#8(*43!BDDB3!
CCF
EC! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH
*DOLEOMLYR1DYGM
MSULKYDWOMLYLMHUMHHQMHRGQRVQRXQHPRJXQRVWL
#*"?4&%+>4! (*"#.! -(*H&%"+#! >%! *2.%&(&484! (-%>2! #!
)#?&4"H2!PXKDGLUD!2!=&6(>2FEb!
1DNUDMXSULKYDHQMHSODQRSRGL]DQMXQRYLK
QDVHOMD3DYDRLYNRYLQDYRGLNDNRVOLMHGLO(/
NRQXYLDMDL]YUHQRJWHJRGLQHVSRPHQXWLSDD2VPDQ
HULI 3DDJQDORLGDVHX]6DYXSRGLJQHSHW
QRYLKQDVHOMD]DL]EMHJOLFHL]6UELMH3RHORMHQDVHOMDYDQMH
%UH]RYD3ROMDL'UHQRYFDXELMHOMLQVNRMQDKLML2UDMDL
%RVDPFDXJUDGDDNRML2UDKRYDXEDQMDOXNRMQDKL/
ML,]GDQRMHQDUHHQMHGDVHUDVHOLSUDYRVODYQRLNDWROLNR
VWDQRYQLWYRL]VSRPHQXWLKPMHVWDLWDNRRPRJXLQDVHO/
MDYDQMH0XVOLPDQD82UDMHVXGROL0XVOLPDQLL]
8LFD9DOMHYDDSFDL%HRJUDGD!Ea!
,] QDYRGD 3 LYNRYLD PRH VH YLG@
MHWL GD MH ]D RVOREDDQMH SURVWRUD ]D QDVHOMD@
YDQMHSURJQDQLNRJLL]EMHJOLNRJPXVOLPDQVNRJ
VWDQRYQLWYDL]6UELMHELORSRWUHEQRQDSRGUXMX
:#*+%! (! 9%&,%.#?(+%! &(>%]("(! )("4+>%! 8#H4,(>4! +4!
NRMDHLVWRVWDQRYQLWYRELWLQDVHOMHQRRGQRVQR
SLWDQMH RVOREDDQMD RGUHHQLK ORNDFLMD RG QH@
12*8(14+*H#.!*"4+#?+(]"?4!H#>%!>%!+4!(*"(14!6(8#!
QDVHOMHQR L YH]DQR ]D ]HPOMX 8 RYRP VOXDMX
VX WR NDWROLNR L SUDYRVODYQR VWDQRYQLWYR
=DQLPOMLYR MH GD 3 LYNRYL X GDOMQMHP GLMHOX
WHNVWD QH UDVSUDYOMD R QDLQX QD NRML MH ULMHHQR
SLWDQMHQDVHOMDYDQMDPXVOLPDQVNRJSURJQDQLNRJ
L L]EMHJOLNRJ VWDQRYQLWYD QD ]HPOMLQH SDUFHOH
NRMH MH YH RG UDQLMH XLYDOR QHPXVOLPDQVNR
VWDQRYQLWYR 3 LYNRYL NUDWNR L MDVQR QDYRGL
=ERJ WLK QDPMHUD L] 2UDMD MH WUHEDOR LVHOLWL VUSVNR
VWDQRYQLWYRBD! #-+#*+#3! z,]GDQR MH QDUHHQMH GD VH
UDVHOLSUDYRVODYQRLNDWROLNRVWDQRYQLWYRL]VSRPHQXWLK
PMHVWDLWDNRRPRJXLQDVHOMDYDQMH0XVOLPDQDBE!W4!
RHNLYDWLMHGDXNROLNRDXWRUUDVSUDYOMDRSLWDQMX
QDVHOMDYDQMD SURJQDQLNRJ L L]EMHJOLNRJ PXVOL@
PDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYDL]6UELMHQDSRGUXMH%RVQH
L +HUFHJRYLQH L LVWLH SRMDYX SUREOHPD QDVHOMD@
?4+>4!(*"#.!*"4+#?+(]"?4!+4!5%18>(]+%!)4&,%8%!+4!
Eb 9LGMHWLSRSLVL]YRUDNRG*DOLEOMLYR1DYGM
Ea 3DYDR LYNRYL 3ROLWLNH JRVSRGDUVNH HWQLNH NXOWXUQH L YMHUVNH SULOLNH!
9LGMHWLL3LYNRYL3UHJOHGKLVWRULMH%UNRJVDRNROLQRP
RG QDMUDQLMLK YUHPHQD GR DXVWURXJDUVNH RNXSDFLMH JRGLQH
TK! %UNR L RNROLQD X UDGQLNRP SRNUHWX L 12%X7X]OD
W4+(18>(?#! >%! -4! *%! c&%+#?4,! .26(! (5! )&%,(5+(>%! %?(-%+,(>%! "#H4! (!
SURFHVDQDVHOMDYDQMDQDVHOMDYDQMDQDSRGUXMX%LMHOMLQVNH#(,+V"F
3DYDRLYNRYL3ROLWLNHJRVSRGDUVNHHWQLNHNXOWXUQHLYMHUVNHSULOLNHFFFF3!
CCF
BD 3DYDRLYNRYL1DYGM
BE 3DYDRLYNRYL1DYGM
QMLKXEOL]LQLULMHNH6DYHQDSRGUXMX%RVDQVNRJ
"V(7"$(WDQLMH=YRUQLNRJVDQGDNDFEE!N4+>(!6&#>!
VXOWDQRYLKPXVDUDELRMHYHUD]PMHWHQXQHNLP
YHRGUDQLMHSRVWRMHLPERVDQNLPJUDGRYLPDEB!
2 RYLP ]ELYDQMLPD 3DYDR LYNRYL GRQRVL ]D@
+(18>(?!+4?#-K!z9H]LUMHUHNDRVYHHQLFLPDNDWROLNLP
+'*%(4.&7(4#+0'$"'8#"X.4+0('.4.5'8%(V(')('V"').:+.'#(7.5'
W"47"$(GDQDPLULQVNRP]HPOMLWXQDVHOLPXVDUHLV/
HOMHQHL]6UELMHSURWMHUDQHRGVUSVNHYODVWL8VHOR2UDMH
LPDQDPMHUXQDVHOLWLPXVDUVNLKIDPLOLMDLL]JUDGLWL
LVWRWROLNRNXD=ERJWLKQDPMHUDL]2UDMDMHWUHEDOR
LVHOLWLVUSVNRVWDQRYQLWYRE`
O("4+>%! #*+(?4+>4! +#?($! +4*%8>4! 54! PXKDGLUH!
SUHUDVOR MH L X PHXQDURGQL SUREOHP 3ODQ
*&%-(]+>%! #*14+*H%! ?84*"(! -4! *%! &(>%](! )D%1!
PXKDGLUD! )&?#! >%! 25+%1(&(#! ?84*"(! A2*"&(>*H%!
,4&%?(+%! H#>4! *%! 2! )&?#1! "&%+2"H2! )&(6#>4@
?484!-4!6(!*%!#?#!)("4+>%!1#.8#!&(>%]("(!+4!2]"&6!
NUDQVNRJ NDWROLNRJ VWDQRYQLWYD %RVDQVNRJ
"V(7"$(3!4!H4*+(>%!(!56#.!)84+4!*&%-(]+>%!#*14+*H%!
?84*"(! -4! +#?4! +4*%8>4! 62-2! )#-(.+2"4! 25! &(>%H2!
=4?23!-4H8%!25!*412!.&4+(,2!)&%14!A2*"&(>*H#1!
,4&*"?2FEC7DNRMHYHRGSUROMHDRGQRVQR
J]DSRHRQL]SULSUHPD]DRVQLYDQMHQRYLK
+4*%8>4F!M>($#?#!)#-(54+>%!+4-.8%-4#!>%!*41!:#@
*4+*H(!4(7+V(HULI 2VPDQ7RSDO3DD,]PHX
PXKDGLUD!(!8#H48+%!#*14+*H%!?84*"(!+4!&45(+(!"V(7"/
$('(!VDQGDND!?84-484!>%!-#*"4!?%8(H4!+4)%"#*"!)#!
SLWDQMX NRQDQRJ LVKRGD L UMHHQMD PXKDGLUVNRJ
)("4+>4F! O&%14! +%H(1! *45+4+>(14! "%1%8>%+(1!
QD SRGDFLPD L] SRYLMHVQLK L]YRUD QHVUHHQH L
QHWUSHOMLYH RGQRVH SRGJULMDYDOD MH QD UD]OLLWH
QDLQH L DXVWULMVND YODVW SUHNR VYRMLK DJHQDWD X
QDVWRMDQMX GD RQHPRJXL QDVHOMDYDQMH PXKDGLUD!
X SRJUDQLQRP SRMDVX 6WRJD MH DXVWULMVND YODVW
)&%H#! *?#>($! 4.%+4"4! &4*)(&(?484! +%54-#?#8>*"?#!
PXKDGLUD! (! )84*(&484! (-%>2! #! +4*%8>4?4+>2! 2+2"4&!
6#*4+*H($!.&4-#?4!2!2+2"&4]+>#*"(!"V(7"$(!H4#!+4@
139
140
NRMLPDMHYHSRVWRMDORGUXJRXRYRPVOXDMXQH@
12*8(14+*H#<!*"4+#?+(]"?#3!-4!"4-4!"&%64!54?&]("(!
FLNOXV LVWUDLYDQMD L SRSUDWQLK SRMDYD L ]DYULWL
SUREOHPDWLQX PLVDR RNR QDLQD UMHDYDQMD SL@
"4+>4!z+&"7V(4(#V(VUSVNRJRGQRVQR%(&"7V(4(#V('
SUDYRVODYQRJLNDWROLNRJVWDQRYQLWYD,]QDLQD
WUHWLUDQMDQDYHGHQRJSUREOHPDNRG3LYNRYLD
PRJORELVH]DNOMXLWLGDVXVUHGLQMDLSRNUDMLQVND
#*14+*H4! ?84*"! #?4>! )D%1! &(>%](8(! -#*8#?+(1!
z+&"7V(4(#V"0 L %(&"7V(4(#V"0 QHPXVOLPDQVNRJ
VWDQRYQLWYD " 'UXJLP ULMHLPD PRJOR EL VH
]DNOMXLWLGDMHLVWRVWDQRYQLWYRELORSURWMHUDQRV
]HPOMLQLKSDUFHODLRVWDORQH]EULQXWR"1RWR
*%!+(>%!"4H#!-%*(8#F!W4!+4*%8>4?4+>%!12*8(14+*H#.!
SURJQDQLNRJ L L]EMHJOLNRJ VWDQRYQLWYD L] 6U@
ELMHNUR]VDPLLQSRGL]DQMDQRYLKQDVHOMDELORMH
SRWUHEQR RVORERGLWL RGUHHQH ORNDFLMH SDUFHOH
+4! H#>(14! >%! #-! &4+(>%! 6(8#! +4*%8>%+#! +%12*8(@
14+*H#!*"4+#?+(]"?#!H#>%!>%!*(*"%1#1!5%18>(]+($!
YODVQLNLK L XLYDWHOMVNLK RGQRVD ELOR YH]DQR
54! "2! (*"2! 5%18>2F! L(1%! *%3! 2>%-+#3! 54-(&48#! (! 2!
*"&2H"2&2!5%18>(]+($!)#*>%-4!(!/%2-48+($!#-+#*4F!
S5.8%-4! -4! *2! *&%-(]+>4! (! )#H&4>(+*H4! #*14+*H4!
YODVWLOHOLQLMRPLVWRJSUDJPDWL]PDXRXYDQMX
IHXGDOQLK RGQRVD 1DLPH L]GYDMDQMH RGUHHQLK
)4&,%84! H#>%! *2! *%! +4845(8%! 2! )#*>%-2! >4*+#!
RGUHHQLK]HPOMRSRVMHGQLNDXVORQMDYDORELIHX@
GDOQHRGQRVHSDVHVWRJDWDLVWDYODVWRGOXLODGD
VHQRYDQDVHOMDJGMHJRGMHWRPRJXHSRGLJQX
QDGUDYQRP]HPOMLWX0+%+V(3!1(&(>*H#!5%18>(]"%<F!
8 RYRP NRQNUHWQRP VOXDMX X VMHYHURLVWRQRM
%RVQL ELOR MH WR ]HPOMLWH NRMH MH QHNR GR
NRQVNDFLMH L]D J SULSDGDOR +XVHLQ.D@
SHWDQX*UDGDHYLXBB0HXWLPXREDPRJXD
UMHHQMD RGQRVQR VOXDMD L]GYDMDQMHP ]HPOMLWD
NRMH VH QDOD]LOR X L]UDYQRP YODVQLWYX GUDYH
GUDYQR ]HPOMLWH LOL ]HPOMLWD X SRVMHGX' &*(/
,+V"NDRXLYDWHOMD$+0(%(3'6(8#!>%!)#"&%6+#!&(>%]("(!
SLWDQMH SRORDMD L VXGELQH QHPXVOLPDQVNRJ
VWDQRYQLWYDQDSDUFHODPDNRMHMHLVWRXLYDORX
IHXGDOQRP NPHWRYVNRP RGQRVX 8 RED VOXDMD
SRVWRMHHSDUFHOHNRMHMHXLYDORQHPXVOLPDQVNR
*"4+#?+(]"?#! (! /%2-48+%! H1%"#?*H%! #64?%5%! (!
#-+#*(! 6(8(! *2! )&%*"&2H"2&(&4+(! +4! "%1%8>2! )&4?4!
YODVQLNDLXLYDWHOMD]HPOMLQLKSRVMHGDGDPRJX
)#1>%&("(!H1%"#?*H#!*"4+#?+(]"?#!*!>%-+#.!)#*@
BB! !V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH,EUDKLP7HSL6.&#('+'<"%1"5.4+#(
>%-4!+4!-&2.(F!L4H?4!)#1>%&4+>4!*2!2!&4+(>(1!&45@
GREOMLPDELODUHODWLYQRHVWDSRMDYD3UHPDWRPH
+%12*8(14+*H#!*"4+#?+(]"?#!H#>%!>%!)#1>%&%+#!
*4!5%18>(]+($!)4&,%84!H#>%!*2!6(8%!(5-?#>%+%!54!)#@
-(54+>%!+#?($!+4*%8>4!54!+4*%8>4?4+>%!)&#.+4+($!(!
(56>%.8($!12*8(14+4!(5!=&6(>%3!6(8#!>%!+4*%8>%+#!+4!
-&2.%!)4&,%8%3!4!+($#?!*"4"2*!>%!#*"4#!+%(51(>%+@
>%+F!c4H8%3!+%12*8(14+*H#!*"4+#?+(]"?#!+(>%!6(8#!
)&#">%&4+#!*!5%18>(]+($!)4&,%84!+4!H#>(14!>%!6(8#!
QDVWDQMHQR
Q%528"4"! +4?%-%+#.! )84+4! 6(#! >%! -4! *2! +4!
SRGUXMX=YRUQLNRJVDQGDND#6(84!)#-(.+2"4!"&(!
+#?4!+4*%8>4F!L#!*2!6(84!+4*%8>4!\M#?#\!:&%5#?#!
3ROMH 1RYR%UH]RYR6HOR'RQMD CX+X+V(!
2UDMH L *RUQMD CX+X+V(' %RVDQVNL
DPDF GRN MH HWYUWR QDVHOMH 2UDKRYD ELOR
SRGLJQXWR QD SRGUXMX %DQMDOXNRJ VDQGDND!
H&4>! V&4-(]H%F! T)#&%-#! *! )#-(54+>%1! +#?($!
;*)#1%+2"($<! +4*%8>4! +4?%-%+(! )84+! )#-&4521(@
MHYDRMHGDVHQDSRGUXMX%LKDNRJVDQGDND!2!
PMHVWX %RVDQVND .RVWDMQLFD NRMH MH YH RG
UDQLMHSRVWRMDORQDREDOLULMHNH8QHL=YRUQLNRJ
VDQGDND X PMHVWX .R]OXN NRMH MH WDNRHU YH
#-! &4+(>%! )#*"#>48#3! +4! 8(>%?#>! #648(! &(>%H%! c&(+%!
QD SXWQRP SUDYFX L] =YRUQLND X SUDYFX -DQMH
(! :(>%8>(+%<! )#-(.+2! +%H(! *"416%+(! #6>%H"(! 54!
*1>%]"4>!zVXOWDQRYLKPXKDGLUDB`#;*8F!E<
3UHPDQDYRGLPD)HKLPD+DGLPXKDPHGRYLD
+4H#+!(56(>4+>4!H&(5%!2!#-+#*2!*4!=&6(>#1!z.&0(#/
VNDYODGDXVNRURSRGLH]DQMLKi"F>F!54!)&#.+4+(H%!(!
(56>%.8(,%!(5!=&6(>%k')4('#.4('#(&"7V('#('U(4+M'f.%#V2'
+' W.#V2' CX+X+V2' E#(X4(#+,' *.' &27($(#2' C:)' p' 27'
$]L]XGDQDV%RVDQVNLDPDFL2UDMHBC#0HXWLP
NDRWRMHYHUHHQR#*&%-(]+>4!#*14+*H4!?84*"!+4!
SRGUXMXVMHYHUQH%RVQHRVQRYDODMHHWLULQRYD
+4*%8>4K!V#&+>4'CX+X+V(';:#*4+*H(!^414,<3'c#+>4'
CX+X+V('2UDMH%UH]RYR3ROMHLOL%UH]RYRVHORL
2UDKRYX
,VFUSDQEURMDQLSRSLVGRVHOMHQLKRELWHOMLNRMLVDGULLQL]SRGDWDND
&%8%?4+"+($! 54! )#&(>%H8#! )&#.+4+(H4! (! (56>%.8(,4! ?(->%"(! H#-! ^464+!
+RGL0LJUDFLMDPXVOLPDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYDLG*(&&+0!54!)#>%-(+4!
1>%*"4F
B`! V48(6! ^8>(?#3! 2UDMH DEDQ +RGL ;+5%(1+V(' 02&7+0(#&8.5'
VWDQRYQLWYDFFF3!aD@aaF
BC 9LGM )HKLP +DGLPXKDPHGRYL 7XUVNL QHRNODVLFL]DP $]L]LMH
GDPLMH X %UH]RYRP 3ROMX 7KH 7XUNLVK 1HR&ODVVLFLVP RI WKH
$]L]LMD0RVTXHLQ%UH]RYR3ROMH%DWLQD!#!V#-(]+>4H!U#1(*(>%!54!
RXYDQMH QDFLRQDOQLK VSRPHQLND %RVQH L +HUFHJRYLQH 6DUDMHYR
9
6O8UJHQWQRLSODQVNLUD]YLMHQDLSRVWRMHDQDVHOMDXNRMDVX
QDVHOMHQLSURJQDQLFLLL]EHJOLFHL]DJ
141
142
VDDLGUXJDQDVHOMDNRMDVDPQDYHRSURMHNWRYDQD
zXREOLNXDKRYVNHSORHVXOLFDPDNRMHVHQDVODQMDMXSRG
*%(4+0' 82$.0 WUHED WXPDLWL QD GUXJDLML QDLQ
M4! .%#1%"&(>*H2! )&4?(8+#*"! &4*"%&4! +4?%-%+($!
+4*%8>4!1#.4#!>%3!)&(>%!*?%.43!2">%,4"(!)&4.14"(541!
(5?&]+($! H#1(*(>4! *&%-(]+>%! #*14+*H%! ?84*"(! >%&! >%!
-(+41(H4!#*+(?4+>4!+4?%-%+($!+4*%8>4!6(84!(5&45("#!
XUJHQWQD HOMD GD VH QDYHGHQD QDVHOMD XWHPHOMH
;#*+2>2<! (! (5.&4-%! ]"#! )&(>%! ;64&! 2! 1(+(148+#1!
#6(12<3!-4!*%!2!(*"4!+4*%8%!)&#.+4+(,(!(!(56>%.8(,%!
;zVXOWDQRYLPXVDULWHGDVH]DLVWHSURYHGHDWUL@
EXFLMD RGUHHQLK ]HPOMLQLK SDUFHOD ]DKWLMHYDOD
>%! *?#>%?&*+2! .%#1%"&(54,(>2! H4H#! *41($! +4*%8>4!
WDNRLMDVQRL]GYDMDQMHRGUHHQLK]HPOMLQLKSDU@
,%84! 2! +%)#*&%-+#>! 68(5(+(! *41($! +4*%8>4F! M4(1%3!
SUHGYLHQD GLVWULEXFLMD L DWULEXFLMD RGUHHQLK
)4&,%84! 54! .&4-+>2! *"416%+($! #6>%H4"4! 2! )#>%@
GLQLPQDVHOMLPDWHRGUHHQLK]HPOMLQLKSDUFHODX
+%)#*&%-+#>!68(5(+(!*41($!+4*%8>4!541(]8>%+4!>%!H4#!
LQVYRMHYUVQRJRVLJXUDQMDVUHGVWDYD]DQRUPDOQL
QDVWDYDN LYRWD SURJQDQLND L L]EMHJOLFD X QRYRM
)&#*"#&+#>! ;5%18>#)(*+#><! (! -&2]"?%+#>! *&%-(+(F!
6DPLLQGLVWULEXFLMHLDWULEXFLMHRGUHHQLKSDUFHOD
+#?(1! ?84*+(,(14! ;)&#.+4+(,(14! (! (56>%.8(,414<3!
)#*%6+#! #+($! 2+2"4&! 541(]8>%+#.! +#?#.! +4*%8>43!
SRGXSUW KLWQRX ]D SURYRHQMHP LVWLK SROXLR
MHORJLNLLQJHRPHWUL]DFLMHUDVWHUDQRYLKQDVHOMD
0HXWLPXVOXDMXSRMDYHJHRPHWULMVNLSUDYLOQRJ
&4*"%&4!+4?%-%+($!+4*%8>43!]"#!>%!)#*%6+#!?(-8>(?#!2!
VOXDMX%RVDQVNRJDPFD2UDMDL%UH]RYD3ROMD
PRGD EL VH PRJOR QDVOXWLWL L QHL]UDYQL XWMHFDM
#-&454!%2&#)*H#.!2&64+(514!*!H#>(14!*2!#*14+@
*H(!)84+%&(!(!4&$("%H"%!*?4H4H#!6(8(!2)#5+4"(3!4H#!+%!
DNLUDQLMHWDGDVYDNDNRRGVUHGLQHVW
=?4!+#?#*+#?4+4!+4*%8>4!2!*?#1!*&%-(]"2!(1484!
*2!)#!>%-+2!GDPLMX!H#>4!>%!6(84!)#-(.+2"4!*&%-*"@
YLPDGUDYHL]GUDYQHEODJDMQH#H4#!"4H?%!6(8%!*2!
SRVYHHQH &27$(#2 $EGXO $]L]X SD
*%!*"#.4!(!+45(?4>2!CX+X+V"F!=?%!+4*%8>%+%!#6("%8>(!
-#6(8%!*2!+4!&4*)#84.4+>%!;2!?84*+(]"?#<!#6&4-(?#!
5%18>(]"%! 2! )#?&](+*H#1! (5+#*2! #-! #H#! B`@`D!
! V48(6! ^8>(?#3! 2UDMH 2YGMH PLVOLP QD DXVWULMVNH NDWDVWDUVNH
14)%! (5! &45-#68>4! )&%1>%&4?4+>4! 5%18>(]"4! (! *+(14+>4! H4"4*"&4! +4!
SRGUXMX%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQHNRMHMHL]YHGHQRL]PHX
(!EaaCF!.F
Bb )HKLP+DGLPXKDPHGRYLT2%&8+'#".87(&+1+X(0FFF3!BCEF
Ba 3DYDRLYNRYL3ROLWLNHJRVSRGDUVNHHWQLNHNXOWXUQHLYMHUVNHSULOLNH!FFF3!
)HKLP+DGLPXKDPHGRYLT2%&8+'#".87(&+1+X(0ELOM
! W2#203!)27203!(5?F!(5!"2&F!G|QP3!>%-(+(,4!1>%&%!54!)#?&](+23!E!)2#20!
P
3DYDRLYNRYL3ROLWLNHJRVSRGDUVNHHWQLNHNXOWXUQHLYMHUVNHSULOLNHFFF3!
8SLDEDQ+RGL0LJUDFLMDPXVOLPDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYDLG
! !V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH
5D]OLLWHL]YRUHYLGMHWLNRG*DOLEOMLYR2UDMH
! V48(6! ^8>(?#3! 2UDMH L ELOM 9LGM L DEDQ +RGL ;+5%(1+V('
PXVOLPDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYDDPDFVWUL2UDMHVWU
1DSRPHQH]DSRMHGLQDGUXJDPMHVWDYLGMHWL*(&&+0!2!*"&2H"2&(!
,>%8#H2)+#.!"%H*"4F
,EUDKLP7HSL6.&#('+'<"%1"5.4+#('NNNNM'8SL*DOLEOMLYR2UDMH3!
BBF
! !V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH
9LGMHWLGLRYHQDYHGHQRJFLWDWDm"X+%FFFFF!8VHOR2UDMHLPDQDPMHUX
QDVHOLWLPXVDUVNLKIDPLOLMDLL]JUDGLWLLVWRWROLNRNXD9LGM3DYDR
LYNRYL3ROLWLNHJRVSRGDUVNHHWQLNHNXOWXUQHLYMHUVNHSULOLNHFFF3!CCF
143
144
MQLFDL.R]OXN0RJORELVH]DNOMXLWLGDVXX]URN
WRPHELODWUL]QDDMQDUD]ORJD-HGDQMHUSUHGVWDY@
8>4#!-()8#14"*H(!)&("(*4H!A2*"&(>%!H#>4!>%!+4*"#>484!
GD VSULMHL RGQRVQR VPDQML RELP QDVHOMDYDQMD
SURJQDQLND L L]EMHJOLFD X SRJUDQLQRP SRMDVX
:#*4+*H#.! "V(7"$(' 25! &(>%H2! =4?2F! c&2.(! &458#.!
SUHGVWDYOMDORMHRLWRMHSLWDQMHRGUDQMDQHPL@
MHQMDQMDYODVQLNLKRGQRVDXWRPGLMHOX%RVDQ@
*H#.' "V(7"$( WR MH SROXLOR QDVWRMDQMD L NRQDQL
(*$#-! -4! *%! )D%1! #*+(?4+>4! +#?($! +4*%8>4!
ULMHL LVNOMXLYR " QD GUDYQRM D QH QD &*(,+V&/
8.V!5%18>(F#,QDNUDMXWUHLUD]ORJPRJDRELELWL
+4*"#>4+>%!*&%-(]+>%!(!)#H&4>(+*H%!#*14+*H%!?84*"(!
GD LQRP L]EMHJDYDQMD RELPQLMHJ QDVHOMDYDQMD
SURJQDQLNDLL]EMHJOLFDXYHSRVWRMHHJUDGRYHX
*&%-(]"2!:#*4+*H#.!"V(7"$('QHUHPHWLGUXWYHQH
(!%H#+#1*H%!#-+#*%!2!"(1!.&4-#?(14!2!?&(>%1%!
NRMHMHXSROLWLNRPVPLVOXULMHLXRGUHHQRP
VWHSHQX YH ELOR GRVWD QHVWDELOQR 1D NUDMX
PRJOR EL VH QHWR VORERGQLMH ]DNOMXLWL GD VX
*&%-(]+>4! (! )#H&4>(+*H4! #*14+*H4! ?84*"! zPXVDU/
&8.SLWDQMHULMHLOLQDWHPHOMXSULQFLSDXYDDYDQMD
SROLWLNH QDMEROMHJ PRJXHJ SRWH]D D WDM MH ELR
#*+(?4+>%!14+>%.!6&#>4!2!)#")2+#*"(!+#?($!+4*@
HOMD EXGXLK 8(&(:( QDVHOMDYDQMH QHWR YHHJ
EURMDSURJQDQLNDLL]EMHJOLFDXGYDYHRGUDQLMH
SRVWRMHDQDVHOMD%RVDQVND.RVWDMQLFDL.R]OXN
Z!#64!+4!.&4+(,414!:#*4+*H#.!"V(7"$(K!>%-+#!+4!
.&4+(,(!*!A2*"&(>#13!4!-&2.#!*4!=&6(>#1<3!"%!+4*%8@
>4?4+>%!+%]"#!14+>%.!6&#>4!)&#.+4+(H4!(!(56>%.8(,4!
XPDQMHPEURMXYHRGUDQLMHSRVWRMHLKQDVHOMD
;8(&(:(<!2+2"4&!:#*4+*H#.!"V(7"$(F!
M4! -&2.#>! *"&4+(! *&%-(]+>4! (! )#H&4>(+*H4! #*@
PDQVNDYODVWVXRLOHVXVHLVRGUHHQLPSURWLY@
OMHQMHP LWHOMD GUXJLK ERVDQVNLK JUDGRYD GD VH
2! +>($! +4*%8%! )&#.+4+(,(! (! (56>%.8(,%F! M4]4?](! *%!
L]PHXGYDRSUHQD]DKWMHYDLSULWLVNDXQXWDUQ@
MHJ GRPDHJ L YDQMVNRJ VWUDQRJ L X] WR MR
-()8#14"*H#.<!#6>%!?84*"(3!*&%-(]+>4!(!)#H&4>(+*H4!
#*14+*H4!?84*"3!+(*2!6(8%!-#&4*8%!)D%12!*!H#@
MLPVXVHVXRLOH%XGXLPLVWUDLYDLPDRVWDMHGD
SURXHNROLNRMHQHVQDODHQMHVUHGLQMHLSRNUD@
MLQVNHYODVWLXRYRMNUL]LSROXLORPLJUDFLMDERVDQ@
VNRKHUFHJRYDNRJPXVOLPDQVNRJVWDQRYQLWYD
2!-4+4]+>2!L2&*H2F!
V#&+>4!CX+X+V('SUHGVWDYOMDMHGQRRG]QDDMQLK
+#?#)#-(.+2"($! +4*%8>4F! =1>%]%"%+#! >%! 2! 68(5(+(!
XDULMHNH%RVQHXULMHNX6DYX2GYUHPHQDRV@
+(?4+>4!)#5+4"#!>%!)#-!(1%+#1!V#&+>4!CX+X+V(F!
U4*+(>%!>%!6(8#!)#5+4"#!)#-!(1%+#1!;:#*4+*H(<'
^414,F! O&%14! +%H(1! (5?#&(14! 2! +4*%8>2! 6(8#! >%!
SRGLJQXWRDSUHPDGUXJLPNXD7DQLML
SRGDWDNGDMHVWDQMHRGL]JUDHQLKNXDV
*"4+#?+(H4F`D7RVXELOHPDQMHNXHSRGLJQXWHL]
`D! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH0DWHULMDOL$XVWULMVNRJJHQHUDOQRJNRQ]XODWD
X6DUDMHYX9LFHNRQ]XODWDX%UNRPQDVORYOMHQL%URGVHSWHPEUD
JL7X]ODVHSWHPEUDJL]$UKLYD%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQH
XNRMLPDWDGDQMLNRQ]XODUQLDJHQWX7X]OLPDMRU2PLNXVGDMHRSLV
QRYRSRGLJQXWRJQDVHOMDX*RUQMRM$]L]LMLDPFXQDDORVWQLVXELOL
GRVWXSQL 8S L DEDQ +RGL 0LJUDFLMD PXVOLPDQVNRJ VWDQRYQLWYD3!
3RWYUGXLPHQDPMHVWDCX+X+R"/+'6`7`<!-#+#*(!W4/%&!Vm8%+3!
7DQ]LPDW '|QHPLQGH %RVQD +HUVHNWH (LWLP (GXFDWLRQ LQ
%RVQLD +HU]HJRYLQD GXULQJ WKH 7DQ]LPDW 3HULRG a%+7.X+' X('
RULMHQWDOQXORORJLMX
6O%RVDQVNLDPDFWRSRJUDIVNDPDSD,]GDQMH-3*HRGHWVNL
]DYRG)HGHUDFLMD%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQH6DUDMHYR
2EMDYOMHQRVGR]YRORP
GUYHQHJUDHLVGUYHQLPNURYRPLQGUD<F!M4*@
HOMHMHELORRNUXHQRYLVRNLP]HPOMHQLPQDVLSRP
]DGDDNRMHJDMHELODGDVSULMHLSODYOMHQMHQDVHOMD
"#H#1! ?(*#H#.! ?#-#*"4>4! &(>%H%! =4?%F`E! T)&4?#!
WLK GDQD JRGLQD QDVHOMH DPDF EROMH UHHQR
SRGUXMHRNRQDYHGHQRJQDVHOMDSRYH]LYDORVHVD
=4&4>%?#1!+#?(1!)2"%1!H#>(!>%!6(#!2!(5.&4-+>(!(!
SUHGVWDYOMDRMHGQXRGYDQLK]DGDDQDPMHVQLND
HULI 2VPDQ3DH
8DQDOL]LSRULMHNODVWDQRYQLWYDVMHYHURLVWRQH
%RVQH 0LOHQNR 6 )LOLSRYL GRQRVL YLH ]D@
+(18>(?($! )#-4"4H4! H#>(! *%! #-+#*%! +4! :#*4+*H(!
DPDF 2Q QDYRGL ,QDH 0XVOLPDQD LPD VDPR
MRSRYDURLPD0RGULL%RVDPFXL%UNRP,WL
YDURNL0XVOLPDQLVXGREULPGHORPSRUHNORPL]JUDGRYD
X6UELMLRQLVXRVQRYDOL%RVDPDF'RGRODVNDWLK
0XVOLPDQDQDPHVWXGDQDQMHJ%RVDPFDQLMHQLELOR
QDVHOMDWHNVXSRMHGLQFLELOLSRHOLGDVHQDVHOMDYDMX$OL
WXMHELODYDQDVNHOD]DSUHOD]SUHNR6DYHSDX0DMHYLFL
+')(#(&'EFGHnNL'5.4.%"'~U8"7(Z'0"&$.'i21>%*"#k!6.&N'
DPDF`B1DGDOMHLVWLDXWRUNDHl('02&7+0(#&8"'
L]EMHJOLFHL]JUDGRYDX6UELMLYODVWMH]DQMLKVDJUDGLODNXH
QDSDQMHYLPD7HNXHVXELOHRGHSHUDLSRNULYHQH
GDVNRP 3RVOMHGQMD NXD RYRJ WLSD MH VUXHQD RNR
FGKK!
3UHPD 0 0XMH]LQRYLX GDPLMX! 2! :#*4+*@
NRP DPFX GDR MH SRGLL 0LU $KPHG VLQ $E@
GXONHULP$JHJQDNRQWRMHGRVHOLRL]
%HRJUDGD2VQRYQLQDFUW]DSURVWRUQRSODQLUDQMH
(!2&64+2!&%.284,(>2!+4*%8>4!-4#!>%!=48($!%/F!N2?%@
NLW0HXWLPWDMQDFUWUD]UDGLRMH#"8+'B%(#12&8+'
LQHQMHU``8VOXDMXRYRJPMHVWDDWULEXFLMDPMHVQH
GDPLMHVXOWDQX$EGXO$]L]XPRHVHLVNOMXLWLMHU
>%! >4*+#! ?(-8>(?#! -4! >%! #?2! GDPLMX )#-(.4#! N(&!
A$1%-3! )4! *%3! *"#.43! (*"4! (! +45(?4! +45(?4! N(&!
A$1%-#?4!GDPLMDF#
`E! _(->%"(!)#)(*!(5?#&4!H#-!V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH
`B )LOLSRYL0LOHQNR63ULOR]LHWQRORNRPSR]QDYDQMXVHYHURLVWRQH
%RVQH$18%,+*UDDNQM2GMHOMHQMHGUXWYHQLKQDXNDNQM
6DUDMHYRSRVHEQRSRVHEQRELOM
)LOLSRYL 0LOHQNR 6 3ULOR]L HWQRORNRP SR]QDYDQMXFFF3! EEE3! )#*%6+#!
SRVHEQR
`` 0HKPHG0XMH]LQRYL,VODPVNDHSLJUDND%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQH!;-48>%!*%!
FLWLUDNDR,(%+YRO,,6DUDMHYR2YDGDPLMDHVWRVH
)#.&%]+#!26&4>4!2!A5(5(>%!GDPLMHSRGLJQXWHQDNRQJ
O&%-*"4?8>4!>%-+#!#-!+4*%8>4!#*+#?4+($!"#H#1!
JNDRUH]XOWDWGMHORYDQMD%RVDQVNRJ4(7+V"F!
1DVHOMHMHL]JUDHQRQHSRVUHGQRX]ULMHNX6DYX
DQDOD]LVHQDVSUDPXSDQMHQDDXVWULMVNRMGDQDV
+4! $&?4"*H#>\! *"&4+(! &(>%H%! =4?%F# M4*%8>%! >%! )#@
GLJQXWR QD GUDYQRP ]HPOMLWX 0+%+V(3! 1(&(>*H#!
]HPOMLWH NRMH MH J ELOR RGX]HWR +XVHLQ
6O2UDMHWRSRJUDIVNDPDSD-3*HRGHWVNL]DYRG
145
146
1RYR%UH]RYR3ROMHQDOD]LVHLVWRQRRGGD@
+4*<! 14+>%.! ="4&#.! :&%5#?#.! O#8>4F! =1>%]"%+#!
MH QDVSUDP 5DLQRYDFD QD DXVWULMVNRM GDQDV
+4! $&?4"*H#>\! *"&4+(! &(>%H%! =4?%F# LQMHQLFD GD MH
`C! !V48(6!^8>(?#3!6.&#('+'<"%1"5.4+#('FIJn/FIoG3!*(&&+0h!V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH3!
$KPHG $OLL LXFL +XVHLQ NDSHWDQD *UDGDHYLD
3ULOR]L ]D RULMHQWDOQX ORORJLMX 6DUDMHYR
8SL%HULVODY*DYUDQRYL'6.&#('+'<"%1"5.4+#('.)'FIdH').FInKN'
5.)+#"N' 6DUDMHYR SDVVLP SRVHEQR ! O#"?&-2! (1%+4!
1>%*"4!;CX+X+R"/'+'l+%GRQRVL=DIHU*|OHQ1DYGM
! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH3!BEF
`b! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH8SLDEDQ+RGL;+5%(1+V('02&7+0(#&8.5'
VWDQRYQLWYD
`a 3DYDRLYNRYL3ROLWLNHJRVSRGDUVNHHWQLNHNXOWXUQHLYMHUVNHSULOLNHFFF3!
9LGMHWL3LYNRYL3UHJOHGKLVWRULMH%UNRJ
! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMHLG
CD 0HKPHG0XMH]LQRYLA96A<YRO,,
CE )LOLSRYL0LOHQNR63ULOR]LHWQRORNRPSR]QDYDQMXFFF3!EEE!(!-F3!)#*%6+#!
EEBF
CB )LOLSRYL0LOHQNR61DYGM
6O%UH]RYR3ROMHWRSRJUDIVNDPDSD-3*HRGHWVNL]DYRG
! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH8SLDEDQ+RGL;+5%(1+V('02&7+0(#&8.5'
VWDQRYQLWYD
C`! =14"&41!-4!H#&(]"%+>%!"%&1(+4!z$2%&8+':(%.8#+'&$+7QLMHSULPMHUHQR
L]YDQ HXURSVNRJ NDWROLNRJ L SURWHVWDQWVNRJ NRQWHNVWD D XQXWDU
RSHJ LVODPVNRJ L SRVHEQRJ RVPDQVNRJ NRQWHNVWD %LOR EL
SRHOMQRXVYRMLWLGUXJLWHUPLQ]DRGUHLYDQMHRYRJDUKLWHNWRQVNRJ
LXPMHWQLNRJVWLODNRMLVHSRMDYLRXRVPDQVNRGREQRMDUKLWHNWXULL
21>%"+#*"(3!)#*%6+#!2!-%H#&4,(>(F
CC 0HKPHG 0XMH]LQRYL A96A< YRO ,, ! _(->F! G%$(1!
+DGLPXKDPHGRYLT2%&8+'#".87(&+1+X(0FFF3!BCDF
)HKLP+DGLPXKDPHGRYLT2%&8+'#".87(&+1+X(0
)HKLPXL$PUL+DGLPXKDPHGRYLGDPLMD!>%!2!
"#H2!#6+#?%FCb!
Orahova
!Lat. 45 11 50.71 N, Long. 17
1 55.43 E " (sl. 6)
6O2UDKRYDWRSRJUDIVNDPDSD-3*HRGHWVNL]DYRG
147
148
Bosanska Kostajnica
! Lat. 45 13 5.81 N, Long. 16
32 44.94 E " (sl. 7)
2RYRPSLWDQMXQLVDPPRJDRGRELWLSRWSXQHLSRX]GDQHSRGDWNHX
0HGLOLVX,VODPVNH]DMHGQLFH%RVDQVND*UDGLND
6O.RVWDMQLFDWRSRJUDIVNDPDSD-3*HRGHWVNL]DYRG
Kozluk
!Lat. 44 29 49.52 N, Long. 19
6 40.89 E" (sl. 8)
6O.R]OXNWRSRJUDIVNDPDSD-3*HRGHWVNL]DYRG
XQXWDUYHSRVWRMHHJQDVHOMDWDNRLQDQMHJRYLP
&26+(1!-(>%8#?(14F
Podizanje d amija u
urgentno osnovanim
naseljima urbanog tipa
8 VNODGX V RSLP SULQFLSLPD UD]YRMD LVODP@
*H#.!)#?(>%*+#.!.&4-43!H#>4!*2!)#]"(?4+4!(!"#H#1!
#*+(?4+>4!#*14+*H#-#6+($!+4*%8>4!2&64+#.!"()43!
2! *&%-(]"2! +4*%8>4! 6(84! >%! )#-(54+4! (! GDPLMD H4#!
REDYH]XMXL QDVHRELQVNL VDGUDM L DUKLWHNWRQVNL
REMHNWWHYHRPD]QDDMQDWRSRJUDMVNDSURVWRUQD
RGUHGQLFD2YDMSULQFLSSRWLYDQMHXSRWSXQRVWL
H4H#!2!,(>%8#>!)#?(>%*"(!#*14+*H#-#6+($!2&64+($!
QDVHOMD WDNR L X RYRP VOXDMX RVQRYDQMD QRYLK
QDVHOMDXYULMHPHSURJQDQLNHLL]EMHJOLNHNUL]H
J QD SRGUXMX %RVDQVNRJ "V(7"$(F!
2ELQRMHQRYRQDVHOMHVYRMHSRVWRMDQMHLGDOMQML
UD]YRM ]DSRLQMDOR RVQLYDQMHP PMHVQH GDPLMHF!
0HKPHG0XMH]LQRYLA96A<YRO,,8SL(YOLMDHOHELMD
a2$.*+&M'`aCF
149
0HXWLP]ERJKLWQRVWLXVWURMDYDQMDLSRGL]DQMD
+#?#.! +4*%8>4! 1#.8#! *%! -%*("(! -4! *%! )#-(54+>%!
GDPLMH#-?(>4!2)#&%-#!*!)#-(54+>%1!+4*%8>4!(8(!-4!
*%!+>%+#!)#-(54+>%!#-?(>4!+%]"#!*)#&(>%!+%.#!]"#!
*%!&45?(>4!*41#!+4*%8>%F!U4#!)&(1>%&!54!(82*"&4,(>2!
PRHVHQDYHVWLVOXDM$]L]LMDGDPLMH!2!M#?#1!
%UH]RYRP3ROMX]DNRMXVHVPDWUDGDMH]DSRHWD
LOLD]DYUHQDXSRWSXQRVWLWHN
.F 2VLP SRWUHED PMHVQRJ VWDQRYQLWYD ]D
?>%&*H(1! #6>%H"#1! ;GDPLMRP<! )#-(54+>%! GDPLMD!
)&%-*"4?8>48#!>%!(!>%-4+!#-!2?>%"4!+4!"%1%8>2!H#>($!
>%! +#?##*+#?4+#! +4*%8>%! *">%,48#! )&4?+(! *"4"2*!
8(&(:"F
Azizije d amije
150
XQDVHOMX2UDKRYD!H&4>!V&4-(]H%F!W4!+4*%8>%!U#@
]OXNQD'ULQLX=YRUQLNRPVDQGDNX!5+4!*%!-4!
MHSRVWRMDORVUHGLQRPVWLGDMHYHRGUDQLMH
(148#!1>%*+2!GDPLMXF!T!+>%12!+(>%!)#-(.+2"4!
+#?4!GDPLMDWRLVNOMXXMHSRMDYX$]L]LMDGDPLMH!
2!#?#1!+4*%8>2F!
=?4!+4?%-%+4!+4*%8>4!(1484!*2!)#!>%-+2!GDPLMX!
2!*&%-(]"2!+4*%8>4F'DPLMHVXYHLQRPELOHSRGLJ@
QXWDGUDYQLPVUHGVWYLPDWHVXNDRWRMHYH
UHHQR ELOH SRVYHHQH &27$(#2! A6-@28! A5(52F!
="#.4! *%! (! +45(?4>2! CX+X+V"FbD! S525%"4H! )&%-*"4?@
8>4! N(&! A$1%-#?4! GDPLMD 2! V#&+>#>' CX+X+V+'
;CX+X+R"/+'6`7`'{'\:#*4+*H(\!^414,<bE!H#>2!+%H(!
42"#&(3! ()4H3! +45(?4>2! A5(5(>4! GDPLMRPFbB! G%$(1!
+DQGLPXKDPHGRYLQDYRGLSRGDWDNGDVXVYH
A5(5(>%!GDPLMHL]X]HYRQHX2UDMXSRUXHQHX
UDWXWHGRQRVLXSRUHGEHVSRPHQX@
"($!GDPLMD!*!GDPLMDPD!2!L2&*H#>!;A5(5(>4GDPLMD!
2!U#+>(<!(!Q212+(>(!;GDPLMH! 2! 1>%*"(14! L28,%! (!
7#+*"4+"4<F
,VWUDLYDQMD DUKLWHNWRQVNLK NRQVWUXNFLMVNLK
(! *"(8*H($! #-8(H4! A5(5(>4! GDPLMD3! H4#! (! #+%! N(&!
A$1%-#?%!GDPLMH2!f.%#V.V'CX+X+V+';:#*4+*H#1!
^41,2<3!-#!-4+4*!+(*2!)&#?%-%+4F!Q458#.!"#1%!
PRJDR EL ELWL QH]DLQWHUHVLUDQRVW LVWUDLYDD ]D
! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH
! V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH9LGM(YOLMDHOHELMDa2$.*+&M'`aCF
bD 9LGMHWLGHWDOMQLMHNRG0LU]D+DVDQHPDQ3RYLMHVWWLSRORJLMDVDGUDML3!
2!S_F!c(>%823!2!)#.84?8>2!fSF!a%.1"&+'+'$.8'2$"0"7V"#V('+'+X5%()#V"'#(&"7V('
2%:(#.5'$+*(9RO,VWULG
bE 2YD G(0+V(' HVWR VH SRJUHQR XEUDMD X $]L]LMD GDPLMH )#-(.+2"%!
QDNRQJ9LGM0HKPHG0XMH]LQRYLA96A<YRO,,
_(->F!(!V48(6!^8>(?#3!2UDMH0DWHULMDOL$XVWULMVNRJJHQHUDOQRJ
NRQ]XODWD X 6DUDMHYX 9LFHNRQ]XODWD X %UNRP QDVORYOMHQL %URG
VHSWHPEUD J L 7X]OD VHSWHPEUD J L] $UKLYD
:#*+%! (! 9%&,%.#?(+%3! 2! H#>(14! "4-4]+>(! H#+5284&+(! 4.%+"! 2! L258(!
PDMRU2PLNXVGDMHRSLVQRYRSRGLJQXWRJQDVHOMDX*RUQMRM$]L]LML
DPFX QDDORVW QLVX ELOL GRVWXSQL 8S L 0HKPHG 0XMH]LQRYL
A96A<YRO,,6DUDMHYR
bB 9LGM 0HKPHG 0XMH]LQRYL A96A< YRO ,, ! T)F! (! N%$1%-!
0XMH]LQRYL A96A< YRO ,, )HKLP +DGLPXKDPHGRYL
+4?#-(! -4! >%! &27$(#' A6-@28@A5(5! zj' 6.&#+M' *.$(8#2$' %(X7.X+0('
SUHVHOMHQMD VWDQRYQLWYD i(5! =&6(>%k' i*4k5%()+i#k HWLUL GDPLMH X %UH]RYRP
3ROMX 2UDMX %RVDQVNRP DPFX %RVDQVNRM .RVWDMQLFL 9LGM! G%$(1!
+DGLPXKDPHGRYL T2%&8+' #".87(&+1+X(0 3UHPD
*)#1%+2"#1! +4?#-2! GDPLMD 2! V#&+>#>' CX+X+V+' ;CX+X+R"/+' 6`7`'
{' \:#*4+*H(\! ^414,<! )&%-*"4?8>484! 6(! A5(5(>4! GDPLMX3! "F>F! GDPLMX!
SRGLJQXWXRGVWUDQHVUHGLQMHRVPDQVNHYODVWLNRMXSHUVRQLFLUDVDP'
&27$(#$EGXO$]L]0HXWLPQDWSLVQDVSRPHQXWRMGDPLML>4*+#!
+4?#-(!(!-4"(&4!#?2!GDPLMX!H4H#!*8(>%-(K!z;+%'C,0")M'&+#'C:)27"8%+0/
DJHGRVHOLYLRYDPRL]%HRJUDGD]D%RMH]DGRYROMVWYRQLMHDOLRVUHGVWYDSDMH
]DYMHWDRWUHLQXVYRJLPHWNDLRYXDVQXGDPLMXX$]L]LMLSRVGLJDRRLYLR
HN'\":+27'p'C,+%N9,,J9LGM00XMH]LQRYLA96A<M'?#8F!
SS3'6WRJDVH0LU$KPHGRYDGDPLMD2!V#&+>#>'CX+X+V+'QHPRH
RGUHLYDWLQLWLQD]LYDWLNDR$]L]LMDGDPLMDF
)HKLP+DGLPXKDPHGRYLT2%&8+'#".87(&+1+X(0
b` =QDQVWYHQDREUDGDQDYHGHQLKGDPLMDL]OD]LL]YDQRNYLUDRYRJODQND
.DRWRMHYHUHHQRLVWUDLYDQMDDUKLWHNWRQVNLKNRQVWUXNFLMVNLKL
VWLOVNLK RGOLND $]L]LMD GDPLMD GR GDQDV QLVX SURYHGHQD ,]X]HWDN
LQLUHFHQWQLLVFUSQLODQDN)HKLPD+DGLPXKDPHGRYLDSRVYHHQ
$]L]LMD GDPLML! 2! ;M#?#1<! :&%5#?#1! O#8>23! H#>(! )&%-*"4?8>4!
VWUXQL ]QDQVWYHQL L PHWRGRORJLMVNL SULPMHU NRMHJ WUHED VOLMHGLWL X
REUDGLJUDGLWHOMVNRJQDVOLMHD2GUHHQDVNURPQRVWDUKLWHNWRQVNLK
#6>%H4"4! (! &%84"(?+#! *(]"?#! -%H#&4,(>%! H#-! -&2.($! CX+X+V('
GDPLMDQHELVPMHOLGMHORYDWLREHVKUDEUXMXHQDEXGXHLVWUDLYDH
8SRUHGR VD VSRPHQXWLP ODQNRP PRH VH L WUHED VWDYLWL L ODQDN
$PUH +DGLPXKDPHGRYL SRVYHHQ HYDOXDFLML REQRYH LVWH
GDPLMH 2ED UDGD QDVWDOD VX NDR UH]XOWDW GMHODWQRVWL XVPMHUHQLK
QD REQRYX RYRJ REMHNWD NRML MH GR WHPHOMD VUXHQ J 9LGM
)HUKLP +DGLPXKDPHGRYL T2%&8+' #".87(&+1+X(0FFF3! )4**(1! (! A1&4!
+DGLPXKDPHGRYL 3RMHGLQDQD L XNXSQD HYDOXDFLMD REQRYH $]L]LMH
GDPLMH
bC =DQLPOMLYSRGDWDNVDXYDQMHXPMHVQRMWUDGLFLMLXJOHGQLKWUJRYDNLK
RELWHOMLJUDGD7HQMDNDRMDNRJWUJRYDNRJVUHGLWD1DLPHODQRYL
LVWLKRELWHOMLXUD]GREOMXSRRVQLYDQMXQRYLKQDVHOMDQDNRQJ
LQDNRQDXVWURPDDUVNHRNXSDFLMH%RVQHL+HUFHJRYLQHJ
*?#>%!)#*8#?4+>%!?(]%!*2!2*1>%&4?48(!+4!*2*>%-+(!.&4-!c#6#>3!+%]"#!
GDOML *UDGDDF L 7X]OX WH QD SUHNRVDYVND QDVHOMD QD DXVWULMVNRM
GDQDVKUYDWVNRMVWUDQL1RYDQDVHOMDRVQRYDQDL]DJRVWDOD
VX L]YDQ L]UD]LWLMHJ SRVORYQRJ LQWHUHVD WUJRYDFD 7HQMD 0RGD VX
UD]ORJ WRPH ELOL L QDLQ SRVORYDQMD WHDQMVNLK WUJRYDFD NRML VH X
RGUHHQRM PMHUL WHPHOMLR QD NUHGLWQRP SRVORYDQMX WH VSHFLQL
)&#(5?#-(!+41(>%+>%+(!54!(5?#53!#-+#*+#!2?#5F!=?%!>%!"#!1#.8#!+4!
RGUHHQLQDLQLVNOMXLWLQRYRRVQRYDQDQDVHOMDXVMHYHUQRM%RVQL
(5! )#*8#?4+>4! 6#*4+*H($! .&4-#?4! )#)2"! L%]+>4F! ="#.43! 1(]8>%+>%! OF!
LYNRYLDGDMH1DVHOMDYDQMHP2UDMDPXVOLPDQVNLPLYOMHPLVWYDUDQMHP
SUYH YDURL X RYRP GLMHOX 3RVDYLQH RPRJXHQ iV"k' %(X4.V' .:%$(' +' $%5.4+#"NNNN
L PRMX SUHWSRVWDYNX GD EL VH RGUHHQL SRGDFL L PLOMHQMD L]QHVHQL
X FLWLUDQRP RGORPNX 3 LYNRYLD PRJOL RGQRVLWL L QD GUXJD
+#?##*+#?4+4!+4*%8>43!"&%64!25%"(!2!&4514"&4+>%!2?>%"+#F!M4(1%3!4H#!
1>%*+#!*"4+#?+(]"?#!+#?##*+#?4+($!+4*%8>4!2!*>%?%&+#>!:#*+(!+(>%!
LPDORWRSRQXGLWLRGSURL]YRGDNDNRELVHXNOMXLORXSRVORYDQMD
V UD]YLMHQLP WUJRYDNLP JUDGRYLPD X %RVQL SRSXW 7HQMD DOL
(! *! 42*"&(>*H(1! 2&64+(1! +4*%8>(14! )&%H#! =4?%3! "4-4! 6(! *%! 1#.8#!
]DNOMXLWLGDMH1DVHOMDYDQMHP2UDMDi(!-&2.($!+#?#*+#?4+($!+4*%8>4k!
PXVOLPDQVNLPLYOMHPLVWYDUDQMHPSUYHi48(!(!-&2.($k!YDURLXRYRPGLMHOX
3RVDYLQHRPRJXHQiV"k'%(X4.V'.:%$('+'$%5.4+#"NNNNVDPRQDORNDOQRMUD]LQL
151
azim Hadimejli
152
$XWRUGLVNXWXMHRPLKUDELPDSRULMHNOXQMLKRYRJ]QDHQMDLQMLKRYRXYRHQMHXLVODPVNLVYLMHWVDDNFHQWRP
QD%RVQXL+HUFHJRYLQX0LKUDELVXSROXNUXQHQLHX]LGXJUDHYLQDVDIXQNFLMDPDSRYH]DQLPVDULWXDORP
2ULMHQWLVDQLVXSUHPDMXJRLVWRNXXSUDYFX0HNHRGUHXMXLSUDYDFNRMLPVHPXVOLPDQLRNUHXWRNRPPROLWYH
2QLVSDGDMXXJODYQRPXXNUDHQHHOHPHQWHJUDHYLQHXNRMRMVHQDOD]H1MLKRYREOLNVHSUHWHQRPRHQDLQD
LOLPLPDWLPHXND]XMXLQDYDQRVWVLPEROLNHPLKUDEDNDRPHGLMD]DNRPXQLNDFLMXVD%RDQVNLP8%RVQL
JGMHQDOD]LPRPLKUDEHQDLQMHQHRGUD]OLLWLKPDWHULMDODQDMUHSUH]HQWDWLYQLMLHOHPHQWMHVWHVWDODNWLWQLXNUDVPL/
KUDEDLGUXJLXNUDVLLVNOHVDQLXPUDPRUXSUHPDRGUHHQLPJHRPHWULMVNLPLOLELOMQLPGHNRUDWLYQLPVKHPDPD,DNR
HVWHWVNLVOLQLRQLVXMHGQRVWDYQLMHIRUPHQHJRPLKUDELNRMHPRHPRQDLXYHOLNLPGDPLMDPDLOLFHQWULPDNDRWR
MH,VWDQEXO.DOLJUDVNLQDWSLVLQDOXNXPLKUDEDHVWRVOXHNDRSRGVMHWQLNQD.XUDQVNHSULHRKD]UHWL0HUMHPL
6YHWD'MHYLFDSRVHEQRXRVPDQVNLPJUDHYLQDPD8QRYLMLPSULPMHULPDPLKUDEDQDWSLVLVXHVWRL]RVWDYOMHQL
7KHDXWKRUGLVFXVVHVPLKUDEVWKHIHDWXUHVRULJLQVDQGWKHLUH[HFXWLRQLQWKHZRUOGRI ,VODPDQGVSHFLFDOO\
6.&#+(N';+,%(:&'(%"'$,"'&"0+1+%127(%'#+1,"&'+#'$,"'P(77&'.B ':2+7)+#5&'P+$,'%+$2(7'B2#1$+.#&N'-%+"#$")'$.P(%)'$,"'
&.2$,"(&$M'$,"R'+#)+1($"'$,"')+%"1$+.#'.B '$,"'&(#1$2(%R'.B ';"11(M'(#)'$,2&'$,"'*%"&1%+:")')+%"1$+.#'$,($';2&7+0&'02&$'
B(1"'P,+7"'*%(R+#5N'T,"R'(%"'$R*+1(77R'(0.#5'$,"'0.&$'.%#(0"#$")'*(%$&'.B '$,"':2+7)+#5&'+#'P,+1,'$,"R'(%"'B.2#)N'
T,"+%'&,(*"'+&'.B$"#'(7&.'B.2#)'.#'*%(R"%'%25&M'$,"%":R'&$%"&&+#5'$,"'0+,%(:^&'&R0:.7+1'+0*.%$(#1"'(&'('0")+20'B.%'
FRPPXQLFDWLRQZLWKWKHGLYLQH,Q%RVQLDZKHUHZHQGPLKUDEVPDGHIURPYDULRXVPDWHULDOVWKHPRVWUHPDUN/
(:7"'"@(0*7"&'B"($2%"'&$(7(1$+$"'.%#(0"#$&'(#)'.$,"%'.%#(0"#$&'1(%4")'+#'0(%:7"'(11.%)+#5'$.'1"%$(+#'5".0"$%+1'.%'
4"5"$(7')"1.%($+4"'&1,"0"&N'T,.25,'("&$,"$+1(77R'&+0+7(%M'$,"R'(%"'5"#"%(77R'&+0*7"%'$,(#'$,"'0+,%(:&'B.2#)'+#'$,"'
5%"($'0.&]2"&'.B '1"#$%"&'7+8"'A&$(#:27N''!(77+5%(*,+1'+#&1%+*$+.#&'($'$,"'0+,%(:^&'(%1,'.B$"#'&"%4"'(&'('%"0+#)"%'.B '
$,"'Y.%(#+1'#(%%($+4"'.B ';(%RM'"&*"1+(77R'+#'-$$.0(#':2+7)+#5&N'-#'0.%"'%"1"#$'0+,%(:'"@(0*7"&M'$"@$&'(%"'.B$"#'
.0+$$")'(7$.5"$,"%N
6O8OD]X%HJRYXGDPLMX6DUDMHYR
153
154
N%-(+(!>%!1#.84!)&%-*"4?8>4"(!1#+#8("+4!H41%+4!
SORDNRMDMHR]QDDYDODVPMHU0HNHLVSUHGNRMH
>%!*"4>4#!O#*84+(H3!*F?F*F4F!(!?#-(#!1#8("?2F!O#&%-!
WRJD WR PLKUDE LPD VYUKX GD R]QDDYD VPMHU
1#8("?%!)&%1!N%H(3!#+!(*"#!"4H#!)&%-*"4?8>4!#-4@
YDQMH SRDVWL SUHPD 3RVODQLNX VYVD L PMHVWX
.->%!>%!*"4>4#!(!)&%-?#-(#!1#8("?2F
G#&14!+(]%!H4#!1#8("?%+#.!)&4?,4!+4845%!*%!(!
)#!-&2.(1!*4H&48+(1!+%(*841*H(1!#6>%H"(143!H4#!
WRVXFUNYHQHDSVLGHVSRUDGLQLVOXDMHYLQLHX
RGUHHQLPVLQDJRJDPDWRVDPRSRVHELLQLFLUD
SLWDQMHGDOLPRHPRVLPEROQLHNDRPROLWYHQRJ
SUDYFDWXPDLWLJOREDOQLPVLPERORP
,QWHUHVDQWQDMHSRMDYDNRGSRMHGLQLKGDPLMD
QDURLWRXGMHOXYHOLNRJDUKLWHNWH0LPDU6LQDQD
GD X RVQRYL GDPLMVNRJ SURVWRUD SURQDOD]LPR
VOLQR NDR NRG DUKLWHNWXUH FUNDYD DSVLGDOQL GLR
JUDHYLQH ]DVYRHQ SROXNXSRORP QD NRMHP VH
+4845(!1($&46F
3UHPD WXPDHQMX WHRUHWLDUD XPMHWQRVWL
/#&14!1($&464!*4!*?#>(1!*?#-#1!H#&%*)#+-(&4!
QHEHVLPDDQMHJRYRSRVWROMH]HPOMLWRLQLQLX
GRVOMHGQRP VOLNRP SLOMH LOL SHLQH VYLMHWD
3HLQDVYLMHWDMHPMHVWRSRMDYQRVWL%RDQVNRJ
ELORGDMHWRVOXDMYLGOMLYRJVYLMHWDNDRFMHOLQHLOL
2+2"&4]+>%.!*?(>%"43!*?%"%!])(8>%!*&,4F
6YHRULMHQWDOQHWUDGLFLMHSUHSR]QDOHVXYDQRVW
#?%! 1#8("?%+%! +(]%3! 1($&464F! T*)#*"4?8>4+>%!
6O6HUGDGHNDRRGUD]IRUPLPLKUDED
6O-HGQRVWDYDQPLKUDEXWHNLML1DGPOLQLVDNDUDNWHULVWLQLP
]DYUHWNRPXREOLNXWDGDNDSH
6O-HGQRVWDYQDIRUPDPLKUDEDXREOLNX]DVYRHQHQLH
,PDUHWUHVWRUDQ$HURSODQ6DUDMHYR
156
6O0LKUDEGDPLMH0LPDU6LQDQDL]VWROMHDEH]VOLNDQH
GHNRUDFLMH
6O)RUPDPLKUDEDX6DUD,VPDLORYRMGDPLML
Mihrabi u
Bosni i Hercegovini
2G SUYH GDPLMH SD GR GDQDV PLKUDEX VH
SRVYHLYDOD SRVHEQD SDQMD WR PMHVWR JGMH
(141! )&%-?#-(! ?>%&+(H%! 2! 1#8("?(3! &%)&%5%+"4@
WLYQRMHXNUDDYDQRNUR]UD]QHHSRKH,]UDLYDQ
MH RG UD]OLLWLK PDWHULMDOD QDMHH RG NDPHQD
*"4H8%+($! 1#54(H43! &%564&%+#.! -&?%"43! ,(.8%3!
2H&4]4?4+!/4>4+*+#1!)84*"(H#13!4!2!#*14+*H#1!
SHULRGX]QDDMPXMHGDYDQQHVDPRGHNRULVDQ@
MHPLL]ERURPPRWLYDYHMHLVWLFDQLYHOLLQRP
=D ERVDQVNRKHUFHJRYDNH GDPLMH RVPDQVNRJ
SHULRGD NDUDNWHULVWLQD MH REDYH]QD QLD ER@
JDWR SUROLVDQL PHUPHUQL RNYLURYL L VWDODNWLWQD
6O0LKUDEXQHNDGDQMRMGDPLML$OLMH7RNPLDGDQDV
QDNLEHQGLMVNDWHNLMD3LUXD
6O0DJULELMDGDPLMD
2!#-+#*2!+4!)#1%+2"%!1#+21%+"48+%!1($&46%!
YHOLNLK JUDGVNLK FHQWDUD RVPDQVNH GUDYH 'L@
1%+5(>%!1($&464!?4&(&4>2!2!#-+#*2!+4!)&#)#&,(>%!
VDPHGDPLMHXNRMRMVHQDOD]L1DMMHGQRVWDYQLML
)&(1>%&,(!1($&464!*2!#+(!6%5!2H&4*4!(8(!*4!1(+(@
PDOQLPWRELVHRLWRYDORX]DVYRHQRPGMHOXX
YLGXOXNDNDRSROXNUXQLYLWLDVWLLOLSUHORPOMHQL
82HF! P?%+"248+#! )#>%-(+(! >%-+#*"4?+(>(! 1($&46(!
1#.2!(14"(!?(]%*"&4+%!+(]%!;*8F!C@b<F
1DLQXNUDDYDQMDPLKUDEDSRVWDYOMDQHNROLNR
#*+#?+($!.&2)4K!1($&46(!6%5!2H&4*43!1($&46(!*4!
SUL]PDWLQLP XNUDVLPD PLKUDEL VD WURXJODVWLP
2H&4*(143! 1($&46(! *4! 2H&4*(14! 2! ?(-2! +(]43! 1(@
KUDEL VD VSHFLQLP XNUDVLPD PLKUDEL VD VWDO@
4H"("+(1!2H&4*(14!(!-4+4]+>(!1($&46(!H#>(!*2!6%5!
157
6O0LKUDEDULMVNHGDPLMH6DUDMHYR
VOLNDQDGHNRUDFLMDQRYLMHJGDWXPD
158
6O.DPHQLPLKUDEX%HJRYRMGDPLMLEH]VOLNDQRJ
VDGUDMD
6O'DPLMD+DP]D%DOL,VWDQEXO
LNDNYLKGHNRUDFLMDVDWHLQRPPDWHULMDODRGNRMLK
*2!)#*"4?8>%+(!;*8F!a@ED<F
1DMHD GHNRUDFLMD ERVDQVNLK PLKUDED
X GDPLMDPD L] RVPDQVNRJ SHULRGD RELOXMH
UD]OLLWLPIRUPDPDVWDODNWLWDWRMHQDQHNLQDLQ
NUXQDWRJSROMDNRMHR]QDDYDVPLMHUPROLWYH1D@
JODVDNSODVWLQRVWLMHHVWRELRSRMDDYDQERMHQLP
NRORULVWLNLPSORKDPD%RJDWLMHXNUDHQLPLKUDEL
H#16(+(&4>2! *%! *4! -#8>+(1! ->%8#1! 1($&464! H#>(!
>%!)#->%8>%+!2!?%&"(H48+%!)#>4*%?%!(!.#&+>(1!->%@
8#1!H#>(!*%!H#1)8%H*+#!54?&]4?4!*4!*"484H"("(14!
IRUPLUDMXLUD]OLLWH]DYUHWNHVO
6WDODNWLW NDR GHNRUDWLYQX IRUPX PRHPR
SUDWLWL MR L] UDQRLVODPVNH XPMHWQRVWL L] L
VWROMHD NUR] SHU]LMVNX XPMHWQRVW D X WXUVNRM
DUKLWHNWXUL VX GRLYMHOL SRWSXQL SURFYDW SRHY
RG VHOGXNLK 7XUDND SD SUHNR 2VPDQOLMD NRML
*2!-48(!+4>(1)&%*(?+(>43!+4>H#1)8%H*+(>4!+4>)2+(>4!
L SODVWLQLMD UMHHQMD 6WDODNWLW NDR GHNRUDWLYQL
%8%1%+"! +(>%! 6(#! *41#! &%5%&?(*4+! 54! 1($&46%3!
QDJRWRYRVYDNRPPMHVWXNRMHELRPRJXDYDOR
UD]YRM RYLK IRUPL SRVWDYOMDOL EL VH SRHY RG
)#&"4843! 1($&4643! */%&+($! ".8#?43! H4)("%84! +4!
*"26#?(14!(!-&2.#.!;*8F!BD<F
0LKUDE X VYRMRM GHNRUDFLML JHQHUDOQR VDGUL
*%-41!)#8>43!H#>4!)&%-*"4?8>4>2!-2$#?+4!25-(54@
QMDRYMHNDNUR]VHGDPVIHUDWRMHSUHGVWDYOMHQR
*4! *%-41! +(?#43! *"%)%+(H4! H4#! )#8>4! 25-(54+>4!
GXHRGQDMQLHJGRQDMVDYUHQLMHJ8GXKRYQRP
25-(54+>2! (! 2*4?&]%+>2! "(! +(?#(! *%! +45(?4>2! #"B&/+'
"00(%"M'#"B&/+'7"44(0"M'#"B&/+'027,+0"M'#"B&/+'02$0"+##"M'
QHIVLUDGLMMHQHIVLPHUGLMMHLQHIVLNDPLOHVDMMH2YL
QLYRLVHRGUDDYDMXNUR]GHNRUDFLMXVWDODNWLWDQD
1($&4623!*?4H#!)#8>%!>%!>%-+4H#!>%-+#1!*"%)%+23!
RGGROMQMHJGMHODPLKUDEDVWHSHQDVWRUDVWXLGR
*41%! xH&2+%y! 1($&4643! ]"#! )&%-*"4?8>4! )#")2+#!
SUHGDQMH $OODKX G VD]ULMHYDQMH GXH NRMH
PRH VDPR LVWD GXD XSRWSXQMHQD GXD GD
)#*"(.+%!;*8F!EC<F
N($&46!H#>(!*"#>(!+4!5%18>(3!+4!"82!]"#!)&%-*"4?@
OMDVLPEROGDMHRYMHNYH]DQ]D]HPOMXLGDQDQMRM
SRVWLHWRGXKRYQRX]GLJQXHNUR]WHVWHSHQLFH
(8(!)#8>4F!N($&46!>%!2!*?#>#>!$(*"#&(>(!)͍(#!H!
ID]HXPMHWQLNRJUD]YRMDQDWRMHXWLFDRNXOWXUQL
+4)&%-4H!"#.!+4&#-43!)&#*"#&4!(!1>%*"4F!
%RVQD VSHFLQD SR VYRMRM JHRJUDML L
GUXWYHQRP SRORDMX L YH]DQRVWL ]D RVPDQVNX
GUDYX LPD YHRPD PQRJR VOLQRVWL X PLKUDEX
H4H#! 8(H#?+#@%*"%"*H(! "4H#! *4H&48+#F! M(>4+*%! (8(!
159
160
6O6KHPDPLKUDEDNDRVLPERODGXKRYQRJX]GL]DQMD
6O3ULPMHUVDYUHPHQHJUDGQMHPLKUDEEH]VLPEROLNHL
VSRJUHQLPRGDELURPNDOLJUDIVNRJLVSLVDPH]GLGX%%,
FHQWUX
UD]OLLWRVWLSRVWRMH]DRQHNRMLPRJXGDWRSUH@
)#5+4>2F!
c4+4]+>%! *"4+>%! x*4?&%1%+%! .&4-+>%y! (8(!
x*4?&%1%+%!4&$("%H"2&%y!)#H452>2!+%)#5+4?4+>%!
+4>#*+#?+(>($! )&(+,()43! 1($&4643! *4H&48+#*"(! (!
-2$#?+#*"(!1($&4643!]"#!(5845(!(5!/#&1%3!4&$("%H@
"#+*H($3!%*"%"*H($!(!-2$#?+($!*(16#843!4!*(16#@
8(H%!2#)]"%!+%14F!O4!"4H#!(!"%H*"248+4!Z!H48(.&4/@
VNDGHNRUDFLMDHVWRMHL]RVWDYOMHQDLOLMHSRWSXQR
)#.&%]+#!#-46&4+4!(!)#*"4?8>%+4!;*8F!Eb<F!
161
Mehmet Z. Ibrahimgil
162
C2$.%'%(&*%(47V('.'&*.0"#+1+0('+'.:V"8$+0('8.V+'&"'#(7(X"'#('5%()+$"7V&8.V'1V"7+#+'('*.4"X(#+'&2'&('$2%:"$.0'+'
GDPLMRPSRGLJQXWRMXDVW0XUDG5HLVDXJUDGXQDRVWUYX5RGRV1DMVWDULMDJUDHYLQDQDORNDFLMLMHVWHWHNLMD
SR]QDWDNDRPXIWLMLQDNXDQDNLEHQGLMVNRJUHGDSUHWSRVWDYOMDVHGDMHL]JUDHQDQHGXJRQDNRQRVYDMDQMD
.&$%4('FdJFN'5.)+#"N'a.&7+V"'0#.5+,'+#$"%4"#1+V(M')(#(&'&"'8.%+&$+'8(.'8.#1"%$#(')4.%(#(N'T2%:"';2%()'\"+&/(M'
SR]QDWRJRVPDQOLMVNRJSRPRUFDSRULMHNORPL]$OLUDNRMLMHL]UD]LRHOMXGDEXGHVDKUDQMHQQDRVWUYX5RGRV
MHRVPRXJDRQDJUDHYLQDSRNULYHQDNXSRORPNRMDQDMYMHURYDWQLMHSRWLHL]SHULRGDQMHJRYHSRJLELMHJRGLQH
2EQRYDWXUEHWDMHXUDHQDJRGLQH8QMHJRYRMRNROLFLSURQDHQLVXLPQRJDGUXJDWXUEHWDNRMDSRWLXL]
SHULRGDVWROMHDXNOMXXMXLLWXUEHWDODQRYDNULPVNHGLQDVWLMH*LUDMLLUDQVNHGLQDVWLMH6DIHYLMDNRML
VXSRJLQXOLQD5RGRVXXL]JQDQVWYXNDRLRNRPXVOLPDQVNLKPH]DUD1DMPRQXPHQWDOQLMDJUDHYLQDX
NRPSOHNVXMHVWHWDNR]YDQDGDPLMD0XUDG5HLVD8VWYDULMHELODL]JUDHQDRGVWUDQH(EX%HNLUSDHJ
GDNOHVNRURFLMHOXMHGQXGHNDGXQDNRQVPUWLLXDVWSRPRUFD0XUDG5HLVD5HVWDXULUDQDMH
]DWLPJRGLQH*UDHYLQDMH]DWYRUHQD]DREUHGHJRGLQH0LQDUHWMHGRELRVYRMGDQDQMLULMHGDNL]JOHG
WRNRPSHULRGD,,WDOLMDQVNHYODGDYLQHQD5RGRVXL]PHXGYD6YMHWVNDUDWD
T,"'(2$,.%')+&12&&"&'0.#20"#$&'(#)'.:V"1$&'.#'$,"'&+$"'1.##"1$")'$.'$,"'$.0:'(#)'0.&]2"'"%"1$")'+#';2%()'
5HLVVKRQRXULQWKHFLW\RI 5KRGHV7KHROGHVWEXLOGLQJRQVLWHLVD1DNLEHQGLGHUYLVKFRQYHQWSRSXODUO\NQRZQ
(&'Z$,"'02B$+^&',.2&"[LM'P,+1,'+&'*%"&20")'$.',(4"':""#':2+7$'#.$'7.#5'(B$"%'$,"'+&7(#)^&'1.#]2"&$'+#'FdJFN'CB$"%'
VLJQLFDQWLQWHUYHQWLRQVLWLVXVHGDVDFRQFHUWKDOOWRGD\7KHPDXVROHXPRI 0XUDG5HLVDIDPRXV$OJHULDQERUQ
-$$.0(#'&"(0(#'P,.'P+&,")'$.':"':2%+")'.#'\,.)"&M'+&'(#'.1$(5.#(7').0")':2+7)+#5'$,($'02&$')($"'$.'$,"'$+0"'.B '
,+&')"($,'+#'FQKG_'+$'P(&'%"&$.%")'+#'FIdGN'A#'+$&'4+1+#+$R'(%"'B.2#)'.$,"%'0(2&.7"20&'B%.0'$,"'Fn$,/FG$,'1"#$2%+"&M'
+#172)+#5'$.0:&'.B '0"0:"%&'.B '$,"'f+%(R'(#)'U(B(4+)')R#(&$+"&'.B '$,"'!%+0"('(#)'A%(#M'P,.')+")'.#'\,.)"&'+#'
"@+7"M'(&'P"77'(&'JdQ';2&7+0'5%(4"&$.#"&N'T,"'0.&$'0.#20"#$(7':2+7)+#5'.#'&+$"'+&'$,"'&./1(77")'0.&]2"'.B ';2%()'
5HLV,WZDVLQUHDOLW\EXLOWLQ0XUDG5HLVKRQRXUE\(EX%HNLU3DDLQPRUHWKDQDGHFDGHDIWHUWKH
&"(0(#^&')"($,N'A$'P(&'%"&$.%")'+#'FnInkIM'FnGoM'(#)'FGnQN'T,"':2+7)+#5'%"0(+#&'17.&")'B.%'*%(R"%'&+#1"'JKKKN'
T,"'0+#(%"$'5.$'+$&'12%+.2&'*%"&"#$'&,(*"')2%+#5'A$(7+(#'%27"'.4"%'\,.)"&'+#'$,"'+#$"%P(%'*"%+.)N
U7N'FN'a%.&$.%#+'*7(#'.:V"8($('8.0*7"8&(';2%()'\"+&/(3'FN'T"8+V(';2%()'
5HLVDVWROMHH7XUEH0XUDG5HLVRYR7XUEH0HPL
3DH'DPLMD0XUDG5HLVD(EX%HNLU7XUEH
'DQEHUN*LUDM+DQRYR7XUEHWDDKLQ*LUDM+DQD
L)HWKL*LUDM+DQD7XUEHDK6D0LU]LQR
HVPD0XUDG5HLVD7XUEH+DYYD6DQGDURYR
7XUEH6HUDVNHU0HKPHG5HGLI 3DH7XUEH0HKPHGHNLS
3DHHVPD0H]DUMH
!"#$%&''#($')*$)'+*),-!.',)%'/"0-$+'1*"2'!"#$%&'()&(*%+,(-&*.'345'26*)#'*$-%'
2"%76$' )!+' %$*8-/$' 09)/$%' ,$*$' /"0-$+' 1*"2' /0,102% 3()+455&' :;'
)22)*'-:*)(-2.-9
163
164
Vjerski objekti
Obrazovne
institucije
Trgovaki objekti
Vojni objekti
Socijalni objekti
Civilini objekti
Javni objekti
Ukupno
Kompleks
Damija i mesdidi
Tekija
Turbe
Mezarje
Medrese
Mekteb
Biblioteka
Rudija
Bezistan
Arasta/Loca
Kule
Dvorac
Oruarnica/tersane
Kasarna
Barutana
Skladite municije
Zatvor
tab
Tabija
Kupatilo
esma
Sebilj
Sarni
Imaret
Konak
Zgrada (Konak) vlade
Zgrada (Konak) za valiju
Vrsta objekta
Tabela -1
Funkcija
3
30
5
6
2
5
4
1
1
1
1
4
1
4
4
2
2
1
1
1
5
25
1
4
2
3
3
2
124
)4-484!+4H](6%+-(>*H#1!"4&(H4"2!4!(1484!>%!*#62!
54!*"4+#?4+>%3!54!#6>%-#?4+>%3!*#62!54!5(H&3!*#62!
54!-%&?(]%3!*#62!54!#*418>(?4+>%!-%&?(]43!H2)4"(8#!
L GUXJH SURVWRULMH QHRSKRGQH ]D WHNLMX 0RH
*%! )&(1(>%"("(! -4! *2! +%H(! -(>%8#?(! "%H(>%! H4*+(>%!
JUDHQLLSUHXUHLYDQL.D]XMHVHGDMHSULSDGDOD
+4H](6%+-(>*H#1! &%-2F! c4+4*3! )#-! (5.#?#!
&%*"42&4,(>%3! c(&%H,(>4! 54! U28"2&2! Q#-#*4! #?4>!
#6>%H4"!H#&(*"(!H4#!H#+,%&"+(!,%+"4&!4!+4H#+!&4@
-#?4!H#>(!*2!)(>%+(8(!H#+,%)"!,(>%8#.4!#6>%H"4F!
8XQXWUDQMRVWLVXXUDHQHYHOLNHSURPMHQHDX]
VDPLREMHNDWGRJUDHQHVXQRYHSURVWRULMHWHMH
WLPHWHNLMDGRELOD]QDWQRGUXJDLMLL]JOHG
U7N'JN'T2%:"';2%()'\"+&/('EFQKGN'5NL
165
N2&4-!Q%(*3!)#!H#1%!>%!H#1)8%H*!-#6(#!(1%3!
>%!)#5+4"(!)#1#&4,!(5!?&%1%+4!*28"4+4!=28%>14+4!
W4H#+#-4?,4F# O#&(>%H8#1! >%# L] $OLUD SRWRPDN
"41#]+>($!.2*4&43!48(!>%!2!&4+#>!184-#*"(!(546&4+!
2! #-&%-! *"&4+4,4! 4! H4*+(>%! >%3! 2! *4*"4?2! 1#&@
+4&(,%3!6(#!)#-!-(&%H"+#1!H#14+-#1!:4&64&#*!
+DMUXGLQSDH 8HVWYRYDR MH V QMLP X EURMQLP
)#$#-(14F!W6#.!*?#>%!(5&45("%!$&46&#*"(3!-#)&(@
QRVD SRUWYRYDQMD L VSRVREQRVWL LPHQRYDQ MH
]DNDSHWDQD(XUR,QGLMVNHRWHJRGLQHD
)&(8(H#1!#*?#>%+>4!U()&4!6(#!>%!H4)%"4+!*%H"#&4!
2WNULYDQMHLVLJXUQRVWWHQDSRNRQJRGLQH
6(?4!(1%+#?4+!H#14+-4+"#1!O#1#&*H%!H4&428%!
QDOLQLML.ULW5RGRV.LSDU*RGLQHNDGDVH
RWYDUD(JHMVNRPRUHLNDGD0DOWHDQLSRNXDYDMX
SUHVMHLWUJRYDNLSRPRUVNLSXWL]PHX$QDGR@
8(>%!(!P.()"43!2*)(#!>%!542*"4?("(!(!54("(!148"%]H2!
RWXQDRWYRUHQRPPRUXEOL]X.LSUD8RYRMYR@
MQLXVSLRMH]DURELWLXYHQLPDOWHNLEURG&UYHQL
'HKHQQHP9HXSRRGPDNOLPJRGLQDPD0X@
166
UDG5HLVMHWRNRPERUELVD0DOWHDQLPDUDQMHQ
.DSWDQ 'HU\D! 948(8@)4]4! .4! >%! )#*84#! 6&#-#1!
SUHPD .LSUX QD OLMHHQMH 7HNR UDQMHQL 0XUDG
5HLVMHSUHVHOLRQDDKLUHWJRGLQHSRKLGUL
RGQRVQR JRGLQH 3UHPD RSRUXFL NRMX MH
RVWDYLRQMHJRYRWLMHORHELWLSUHQHVHQRQD5RGRV
(!*4$&4+>%+#!2!"2&6%"2!H#>%!>%!-4#!*4.&4-("(F
L2&6%!>%!#*1#2.4#+#!(!)#H&(?%+#!H2)#8#1F!
1DXOD]XVDOLMHYHVWUDQHXGYDUHGDVDHWLULVWURIH
*"#>(! +4")(*! 2! "48(H2F! M4! *?4H#>! #-! *"&4+(,4! "2&@
EHWDL]X]HYRQHJGMHVXYUDWDVHQDOD]LHWYUWDVWL
)#&F! M4! )&%-+>#>! *"&4+(! 2! ]8>2+H#?("#1! H4@
PHQXQDOD]LVHPRWLYVLGUDLHPSUHVRYRJGUYHWD
T+2"&4]+>#*"! "2&6%"4! >%! 2H&4]%+4! +4")(*(14F! T!
2+2"&4]+>#*"(! H2)#8%! +4845(1#! 1#"(?%! 5?(>%5-4F!
S5!+4")(*4!+4!?&4"(14!-4!*%!&4521>%"(!-4!>%!#6+#?4!
WXUEHWDXUDHQDJRGLQHSRKLGULRGQRVQR
JRGLQH
3. Turbe Memi-pa e
0HPLSDDMHJRGLQH]DYULMHPHVXOWDQD
A$1%-4!S3!(1%+#?4+!54!6%.4!Q#-#*H#.F!:(#!>%!
YUOR ]DSDHQ X RVPDQOLMVNRM PRUQDULFL QD 6UH@
GR]HPOMX D SUHVHOLR MH QD DKLUHW JRGLQH
=! #65(! -4! >%! 6(#! )#1#&4,! +>%.#?! 1%54&! >%!
RJUDHQ HOMH]QLP ODQFLPD SD VX JD X QDURGX
]YDOL =LQGLUOLGHGH 1MHJRYR WXUEH VH QDOD]L
2! U#1)8%H*2! N2&4-! Q%(*@4F! G#+-4,(>4! Q#-#*!
MH GDOD REQRYLWL RYR WXUEH ,]JUDHQR
MH RVPRXJDRQR WXUEH VD NXSRORP *UDHQR
>%! #-! H8%*4+#.! H41%+43! 4! H2)#84! *"#>(! +4! -?4!
*"2)4! *! )&%-+>%! *"&4+%! (! 5(-#?(14F! S! *"26#?(! *2!
L]JUDHQLRGNOHVDQRJNDPHQD1DVYDNRMVWUDQL
#6>%H"4!(14!)#!>%-4+!)#&F!T!2+2"&4]+>#*"(!*%!
QDOD]L JUREQLFD VDJUDHQD X PHUPHUX 6MHYHUQL
-(#!.+(,%!>%!)&#)4#!2!5%18>2F!M4!25.84?8>2!(!
SRGQRMX VH QDOD]H RVPRXJDRQL VWXERYL &LMHOD
SRYUQD JUREQFH MH XNUDHQD PRWLYLPD ELOMDND
X UR]HWDPD 'DQDV MH WXUEH SULOLQR ]DSXWHQR
.DR L YHLQD GUXJLK REMHNDWD RYGMH L QMHPX MH
)#"&%6+4!$("+4!&%*"42&4,(>4F!
6O'DPLMD0XUDG5HLVDJ
6O'DPLMD0XUDG5HLVDJ
167
6O'DPLMD0XUDG5HLVDJ
168
2VPDQOLMVNRMGUDYLSRVODQXL]JQDQVWYRQDRV@
WUYR5RGRV8PURMHX]DWRHQLWYXQD5RGRVX
KJRGLQH1MHJRYRWXUEHVHQDOD]L
2!H#1)8%H*2!N2&4-!Q%(*@4!54>%-+#!*4!"2&6%"#1!
^4$(+!V(&4>!94+4F!S!#?#!"2&6%!(14!#*1#2.4#+2!
RVQRYXLSRNULYHQRMHNXSRORP,]JUDHQRMHRG
H8%*4+#.!H41%+43!4!-4+4*!*%!+4845(!2!&2]%?+#1!
*"4+>2F!T!2+2"&4]+>#*"(!"2&6%"4!*%!+4845(!1%&1%&@
QD JUREQLFD D QD MXQRP ]LGX MH L]JUDHQ PL@
$&46F! V+(,4! >%! 2H&4]%+4! 1#"(?(14! 6(8>4H4! (!
)&%-1%"4!H#>(!#*8(H4?4>2!21>%"+#*"!"#.!?&%1%+4F!
1DMXQRMVWUDQLXVUHGLWXMHGQHUR]HWHVHQDOD]L
FUWHVPRWLYRPKDQGDUD
)#$?48(#3!4!54?#8(#!.4!>%!(!?%8(H(!?%5(&!=(+4+@)4]43!
)#! 54?&]%"H2! ?#>+%3! -4#! 12! >%! +4! 2)&4?8>4+>%!
U&(1F!U4-4!>%!S6&4$(1@)4]4!541(>%+(#!+4!1>%*"2!
?%8(H#.!?%5(&4!=(+4+@)4]2!#+!>%!/4?#&(5(&4#!*?#.4!
)#5+4+(H4! V45(! V(&4>43! 6&4"4! G%"$(! V(&4>! 94+4!
H#>%.!>%!)#5?4#!2!S*"4+628!2!c4&@2!*44-%3!4!)#@
"#1!.4!#")&%1(#!2!)&#.#+*"?#!+4!Q#-#*F!T1&#!
MH X SURJRQVWYX QD 5RGRVX X JRGLQL LYRWD
K JRGLQH 0H]DU PX VH QDOD]L X
(*"#1!"2&6%"2!H4#!(!^4$(+!V(&4>!$4+#?F!
*UREQLFD RG PHUPHUD MH VD VYH HWLUL VWUDQH
2H&4]%+4! 1#"(?(14! 6(8>+#.4! *?(>%"4! 2! %"414F!
M(]4+! +4! 25.84?8>2! >%! #)4*4+! "2&64+#1! )#@
-(>%8>%+(1!H?4-&4"+#1!#*+#?#1!+4!?(]%!-(>%8#?4F!
M4!)&%-+>#>!*"&4+(!*%!+4845(!+4")(*!2!-%?%"!&%-#?4F!
2YRWXUEHMHQDMYLHVWUDGDORWRNRPYUHPHQDLQD@
845(!*%!2!+4>8#](>%1!*"4+>2!#-!*?($!#6>%H4"4!H#1@
)8%H*4F! S*)&%-! 2845+($! ?&4"4! >%3! )&%14! #*"4,(14!
H#>(!2H452>2!+4!"#3!)#*"#>4#!"&(>%1!H#>(!>%!+%*"4#!
XSRWSXQRVWLLLMHVXVSHFLQRVWLXQLWHQHNDVQL@
>(1!(+"%&?%+,(>414F!A8(3!4H#!6(!*%!-#+(>%84!#-82H4!
(!4H#!6(!*%!(5?&](84!"%1%8>("4!&%*"42&4,(>43!+4!)#"@
SXQRVWUXDQQDLQELWUHEDORL]YULWLLDUKHRORND
(*H#)4?4+>4! (! 2H8#+("(! +4H+4-+%! (+"%&?%+,(>%F!
7DNRHUWRNRPQDHJLVWUDLYDQMDXRLOLVPRGD
VXSUR]RULXNORQMHQLLGDMHQDNXSROLSUHVYXHQD
/4*4-4F! O&%14! "(1! )#H454"%8>(14! "&%648#! 6(! +4!
RVQRYX XJUDHQRJ PDWHULMDOD X GLMHORYLPD JGMH
*2!6(8(!)#&(3!"%!14"%&(>484!H#&(]"%+#.!54!/4*4-2!
NXSROHXVWDQRYLWLNDGDVXWHLQWHUYHQFLMHXUDHQH
4!"%H!+4H#+!"#.4!($!2H8#+("(F!
6O7XUEHDKLQL)HWKL*LUDM+DQRYR
DK6D0LU]DMHVLQDK+XVHMLQD6DIHYLMDGH@
?%"#.!(!)#*8>%-+>%.!?84-4&4!S&4+4!(5!-(+4*"(>%!=4/%@
?(>4F#U4-4!>%!M4-(&!^4$!*(8#1!)&%25%#!)&(>%*"#8>%#
DK6D0LU]DVHVNORQLRX2VPDQOLMVNXGUDYX
3RVODQMHQD5RGRVJGMHMHXPURK
JRGLQH 7XUEH L]JUDHQR X QMHJRYR LPH VH
QDOD]L X VNORSX NRPSOHNVD 0XUDG 5HLVD 2YR
"2&6%! *4! #*1#2.4#+#1! #*+#?#13! )&%H&(?%+#! 169
6O7XUEHDK6D0LU]LQR
170
8. esma/adrvan Murad
Reis-a
2GPDK SRUHG WXUEHWD# N2&4-! Q%(*@4! *"#>(!
HVPD NRMX MH NDNR VH YLGL L] QDWSLVD GDR VD@
JUDGLWL X] GRSXWHQMH VXOWDQD $EGXOPHGLGD
%DPDEHMLQGL +DPGLEHJ K
JRGLQH 6DJUDHQD MH RG NOHVDQRJ NDPHQD
HWYUWDVWRJ REOLND VD NXSRORP NRMD MX SRNULYD
_#-4! >%! -#845(84! (5! ](8>4"($! 82H#?4! *1>%]"%+(! +4!
>%-+#>! *"&4+(! -%)#4! 54! ?#-2! 2+2"4&! H#>%.! *2!
+4*8(H4+%!%"%!*4!1#"(?(14!6(8>+#.4!*?(>%"43!"%!(5!
H41%+#.!H#&("4!*1>%]"%+#.!2!*&%-(]"2!%"4F!L4!
RJOHGDOFDLQDWSLVQDYUKXVXL]JUDHQLGMHOLPLQR
#-!1%&1%&+($!8%?$(F!U#&("4!*2!-4+4*!2!)#")2+#!
UDVSDGQXWRP VWDQMX 9RGD WHH NUR] HVPX
SULNRSDQXQDFULMHYRNRMHMHSUXHQRXRNROR
9. Turbe Havva
Sand arovo (sl. 9)
M4H#+!>%-+%!)#62+%!H#>4!>%!(56(84!2!A+4-#@
8(>(#94??4]@6%.!>%!)&#">%&4+!+4!Q#-#*F!M4!+>%.#@
YRP PH]DUX VWRML ]DSLVDQR GD MH XPUR
K JRGLQH 7XUEH LPD RVPRXJDRQX RV@
QRYXDVDJUDHQRMHRGNOHVDQRJNDPHQD7XUEH
SRNULYHQRNXSRORPMHL]JXELORVYRMXDXWHQWLQRVW
(!%*"%"*H2!?&(>%-+#*"!+4H#+!(+"%&?%+,(>4!+4!+>%12!
)&(8(H#1!H#>($!>%!H#&(]"%+!6%"#+*H(!14"%&(>48F!M4-!
XOD]QLPYUDWLPDWHQDVYHHWLULVWUDQHJUREQLFH
+4845(!*%!+4")(*!)(*4+!"48(H!)(*1#1F!
6O7XUEH+DYYD6DQGDURYR
171
172
14. esma
HVPD VH QDOD]L GR YDQMVNRJD ]LGD WHNLMH
H#>(! .8%-4! )&%14! 82,(! 2! *H8#)2! H#1)8%H*4! N2@
&4-! Q%(*@4F! N%&1%&+(! *?#-! 54?&]4?4! *4! 5(-#1!
WHNLMH D VDJUDGLR MX MH K JRGLQH
%DPDEHMLQGLL+DPGLEHJHVPDNRMDVHQDOD]L
25!?4+>*H(!5(-!"%H(>%!#64?(>%+4!>%!1%&1%!+4!
HWLULVWUDQH1DYUKXVHQDOD]LQDWSLVDXGRQML
-(#!>%!](8>4"(!1%&1%&+(!82H!2!H#1%!*%!+4845(!/4&4F!
9UKRYL HVPH VPMHWHQL VX X VUHGLWX UR]HWH
1%&1%&+#.!/4&4F!
15. Mezarje
,VWUDLYDQMD NRMD VX REDYLOL VWUXQMDFL *D]L
8QLYHU]LWHWD X RNYLUX =QDQVWYHQRLVWUDLYDNRJ
SURMHNWD%$3LJRGLQHXWYUGLODVX
SRVWRMDQMH PH]DUD XQXWDU PH]DUMD ,(X+%"<!
N2&4-! Q%(*@4F! =?4H(! +(]4+! >%! -#6(#! (+?%+"4&*H(!
EURMLSUHPDQMHPXVXUDHQDLVWUDLYDQMDLVWRYUH@
PHQRJDVPMHWDMXLXSURVWRUQXVKHPXPH]DUMD
6YL QDWSLVL QD QLDQLPD VX GHLIULUDQL SUL HPX
>%!2*"4+#?8>%+#!)(*1#!2!H#>%1!>%!)(*4+!+4")(*!4!
)#"#1!)&%?%-%+!+4!1#-%&+(!"2&*H(!>%5(HF!O&%14!
QDWSLVLPD QD QLDQLPD XUDHQD MH WLSRORJLMD
+4! #*+#?2! H#>%! >%! 2*"4+#?8>%+#! -4! 8(! )&()4-4!
PXNDUFX LOL HQL WH LPD OL LOL QHPD VDUNRIDJ
7DNRHU RVREH NRMH VX SRNRSDQH X PH]DUMX
*2! *?&*"4?4+%! 2! .&2)%! )&%14! /2+H,(>(! H#>2! *2!
REQDDOL L SRVOX NRMLP VX VH EDYLOL 0HX RYLP
.&2)414! )#*"#>%! ?%8(H(! ?%5(&(3! ?%5(&(3! )#1#&*H(!
+4-5#&+(,(3!)4]%3!?48(>%3!H4>14H41(3!NDSWDQGHU\D3!
NHWKGD SMHVQLFL NQMLHYQLFL XHQMDFL PXIWLMH
L GUXJH SR]LFLMH L GXQRVWL 7RNRP GHLIULUDQMD
QDWSLVD WH NRULVWHL UD]OLLWH L]YRUH PRJOL VPR
XVWDQRYLWL UD]ORJH VPUWL SRMHGLQLK VWDQRYQLND
#?#.!1%54&>4F!L(!)#-4,(!-4"(!2!"46%8(!#*8(H4?4>2!
VRFLRHNRQRPVNH SULOLNH UD]OLLWLK SHULRGD YUH@
PHQDQDRYRPSRGUXMX8NUDHQLQLDQLVXQD
8(,2! 1>%*"4! )&%*8(H4?4+(! (! ?48#&(5(&4+(! *4! 4*)%H"4!
SODVWLQH XPMHWQRVWL 9HLQD QDGJUREQLK VSR@
PHQLND RG GR VWROMHD MH L]JUDHQD RG
6(>%8#.!1%&1%&4!(!?&8#!*2!-&4.#,>%+(!*)#1%+(,(!
H28"2&%! (! 21>%"+#*"(! *4! 4*)%H"4! +>($#?%! %*"%"*H%!
YULMHGQRVWL2YR]DSRVWDYOMHQRLSRKDUDQRNXO@
WXUQRQDVOLMHH]DKWMHYDKLWQXDNFLMXQDQMHJRYRP
*)4]4?4+>2!(!&%*"42&4,(>(F!
Zakljuak i pogovor
173