What Is Combustion?
What Is Combustion?
What Is Combustion?
Combustion?
Combustion occurs when fossil fuels, such as
natural gas, fuel oil, coal or gasoline, react with
oxygen in the air to produce heat. The heat from
burning fossil fuels is used for industrial processes,
environmental heating or to expand gases in a
cylinder and push a piston. Boilers, furnaces and
engines are important users of fossil fuels.
• Fossil fuels are hydrocarbons, meaning they are composed primarily
of carbon and hydrogen. When fossil fuels are burned, carbon dioxide
(CO2) and water (H2O) are the principle chemical products, formed
from the reactants carbon and hydrogen in the fuel and oxygen (O2)
in the air.
• To measure gas concentration, a probe is inserted into the exhaust flue and a gas
sample drawn out. Exhaust gas temperature is measured using a thermocouple
positioned to measure the highest exhaust gas temperature. Soot is measured
from a gas sample drawn off the exhaust flue. Draft is the differential pressure
between the inside and outside of the exhaust flue.
• Once these measurements are made, the data is interpreted using calculated
combustion parameters such as combustion efficiency and excess air. A more in
depth analysis will examine the concentration of the undesirable products
described earlier.
Why perform
Combustion Analysis?
Improve Fuel Efficiency
The largest sources of boiler heat losses are shown Figure 2. Heat energy leaving
the system exhaust flue (or stack) is often the largest single source of lost fuel
energy and is made up of the Dry Gas loss and Latent Heat Loss. Although some
flue loss is unavoidable, an equipment tune-up using combustion analysis data
can often significantly reduce this source of heat loss and save fuel costs by
improving fuel efficiency. Table 1 gives examples of yearly cost savings that can
be realized by improving equipment efficiency by five percent.
Reduce Emissions
Carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and particles are undesirable
emissions associated with burning fossil fuels. These compounds are toxic,
contribute to acid rain and smog and can ultimately cause respiratory
problems. Federal and state laws govern the permissible emission rates for
these pollutants under the guidance of the Clean Air Act and oversight of the
federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). State and local environmental
agencies also exert authority in regulating the emissions of these pollutants.
Combustion analysis is performed to monitor toxic and acid rain forming
emissions in order to meet these federal, state and local regulations.
Improve Safety
Good equipment maintenance practice, which includes combustion analysis, enables
the boiler technician to fully verify and maintain the equipment operating specifications
for safe and efficient operation. Many boiler manufacturers suggest that flue gas
analysis be performed at least monthly. Boiler adjustments that affect combustion will
tend to drift with time. Wind conditions and seasonal changes in temperature and
barometric pressure can cause the excess air in a system to fluctuate several percent. A
reduction in excess air can cause, in turn, a rapid increase of highly toxic carbon
monoxide and explosive gases, resulting in rapid deterioration in system safety and
efficiency. Low draft pressures in the flue can further result in these combustion gases
building up in the combustion chamber or being vented indoors. Excessive draft
pressures in the flue also can cause turbulence in the system. This can prevent
complete combustion and pull explosive gases into the flue or cause flame
impingement and damage in the combustion chamber and to the heat exchanger
material
What’s Measured?
Combustion analysis involves the measurement of gas concentrations,
temperatures and pressure for boiler tune-ups, emissions checks and safety
improvements. Parameters that are commonly examined include:
• Oxygen (O2)
• Carbon Monoxide (CO)
• Carbon Dioxide (CO2)
• Exhaust gas temperature
• Supplied combustion air temperature
• Draft • Nitric Oxide (NO)
• Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2)
• Sulfur Dioxide (SO2)
Oxygen, Carbon Monoxide and Carbon Dioxide
As described earlier, simple combustion involves the reaction of oxygen in the air
with carbon and hydrogen in the fuel, to form carbon dioxide and water and
produce heat. Under ideal conditions, the only gases in the exhaust flue are CO2,
water vapor and nitrogen from the combustion air. When O2 appears in the flue
exhaust, it usually means that more air (20.9 percent of which is O2) was supplied
than was needed for complete combustion to occur. Some O2 is left over. In other
words, the measurement of O2 gas in the flue indicates that extra combustion air,
or Excess Air, was supplied to the combustion reaction.
This is demonstrated in Figure 3 where the bar on the right represents the exhaust
gas composition.
When too little air is supplied to the burner, there is not enough oxygen to completely form
CO2 with all the carbon in the fuel. Instead, some oxygen combines with carbon to form
carbon monoxide (CO). CO is a highly toxic gas associated with incomplete combustion and
efforts must be made to minimize its formation. This effort goes hand-in-hand with improving
fuel efficiency and reducing soot generation. This formation of CO gas is illustrated in Figure 4.
As a rule, the most efficient and cost-effective use of fuel takes place when the
CO2 concentration in the exhaust is maximized. Theoretically, this occurs when
there is just enough O2 in the supplied air to react with all the carbon in the
fuel supplied. This quantity of supplied air is often referred to as the theoretical
air.
The theoretical air required for the combustion reaction depends on fuel
composition and the rate at which the fuel is used (e.g. pounds per hour, cubic
feet per minute, etc.). In real-world combustion, factors such as the condition of
the burner and the burner design also influence the amount of air that is needed.
The theoretical air is rarely enough.
The general relationship between the O2 supplied and the concentration of CO2
and CO in the exhaust is illustrated in Figure 5. As the air level is increased and
approaches 100% of the theoretical air, the concentration of CO molecules
decreases rapidly as they pick up additional oxygen atoms and form CO2. Still
more combustion air and CO2 reaches a maximum value. After that, air begins to
dilute the exhaust gases, causing the CO2 concentration to drop. The maximum
value of CO2 is dependent on the type of fuel used.
Temperature and Draft
Exhaust Gas Temperature and Supplied Combustion Air Temperature
Heat leaving the exhaust flue with the hot gases is not transferred to do useful work, such as
producing steam. This heat loss becomes a major cause of lower fuel efficiency. Because the
heat content of the exhaust gas is proportional to its temperature, the fuel efficiency drops as
the temperature increases. An example of efficiency loss due to the increase in stack gas
temperature is shown in Figure 6.
When determining heat loss from the flue, the temperature of the supply air is subtracted
from the flue gas temperature. This gives the net temperature and accounts for the heat
supplied to the system by the supply air.
Some heat loss is unavoidable. The temperature in the flue needs to remain high enough to
avoid condensation inside the stack. One process for recovering some of the heat loss in the
exhaust is to use the hot flue gases to preheat the supply air before it is introduced into the
combustion chamber.
Draft
Draft refers to the flow of gases through the heat generating equipment, beginning with
the introduction of air at the back of the burner. Once combustion occurs, the heated gas
leaves the combustion chamber, passes heat exchangers and exits the exhaust stack.
Depending upon the design of the equipment, draft is natural, meaning combustion air is
pulled in by buoyant heated gases venting up the stack, or it is mechanical, meaning air is
pushed or pulled through the system by a fan. Often, draft relies on a combination of
both natural and mechanical means.
Adequate draft is typically verified by measuring the pressure in the exhaust stack. The
manufacturer of the fuel burning equipment provides specifications for the required draft
pressure and locations for making the draft measurement. Measurement is important
since environmental influences such as changes in barometric pressure and ambient
temperature can influence the flow. Typical draft pressures are in the range of –0.5 to 0.5
inches of water column.
Excessive draft can prevent heat transfer to the system and increase the flue
temperature if the excess air percentage is not elevated. If the excess air increases
from the high draft, the flue temperature will decrease. Low draft pressures can
cause temperatures in the flue to decrease, allowing water vapor to condense in
the flue, forming acid and damaging the system.
Nitrogen Oxides (NOx)
Nitrogen oxides, principally nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2), are
pollutant gases that contribute to the formation of acid rain, ozone and smog.
Nitrogen oxides result when oxygen combines with nitrogen in the air or in the fuel.
NO is generated first at high flame temperatures, then oxidizes further to form NO2
at cooler temperatures in the stack or after being exhausted. The NO
concentration is often measured alone, and the NO2 concentration is generally
assumed to comprise an additional five percent of the total nitrogen oxides. The
nitrogen oxide gas concentrations are sometimes combined and referred to as the
NOX concentration.
Sulfur Dioxide (SO2)
Sulfur dioxide combines with water vapor in the exhaust to form a sulfuric acid
mist. Airborne sulfuric acid is a pollutant in fog, smog, acid rain and snow, ending
up in the soil and ground water. Sulfur dioxide itself is corrosive and harmful to the
environment. Sulfur dioxide occurs when the fuel contains sulfur and where the
emission levels are directly related to the amount of sulfur in the fuel. The most
cost-effective way to reduce sulfur emissions is to select a low-sulfur or de-sulfured
fuel.
Hydrocarbons (HCs)/Volatile Organic Compounds
(VOCs)
• Excess Air
• Carbon Dioxide
• Combustion Efficiency
• O2 Reference
• Emissions Conversions
Excess Air
Insufficient combustion air causes a reduction in fuel efficiency, creates highly toxic
carbon monoxide gas and produces soot. To ensure there is enough oxygen to
completely react with the fuel, extra combustion air is usually supplied. This extra
air, called “Excess Air,” is expressed as the percent air above the amount
theoretically needed for complete combustion. In real-world combustion, the excess
air required for gaseous fuels is typically about 15 percent. Significantly more may
be needed for liquid and solid fuels.
A good estimate of excess air can be determined using the following formula. This
calculation uses the oxygen concentration measured in the exhaust. If the CO
concentration is very high, it may also be included in the excess air calculation. This
is shown in Appendix C, “Calculations.”
Although required, higher excess air comes with a price—it wastes fuel. There are a
number of reasons why this occurs but, stated simply, supply air cools the
combustion system by absorbing heat and transporting it out the exhaust flue. The
more air, the more the cooling. Consider, too, that nitrogen, which makes up about
eighty percent of the air, plays no role chemically to produce heat. It does,
however, add significantly to the weight of gas that absorbs heat energy. Figure 8
illustrates how increasing excess air reduces combustion efficiency.
Using too much excess air is one of the principal causes of poor fuel economy. For
this reason, optimizing excess air usage can be one of the simplest ways to achieve
significant fuel savings.
Stack heat losses are primarily from the heated dry exhaust gases (CO2, N2, O2)
and from water vapor formed from the reaction of hydrogen in the fuel with O2 in
the air (refer to Figure 2). When water goes through a phase change from liquid to
vapor, it absorbs a tremendous amount of heat energy in the process. This “heat of
vaporization,” or latent heat, is usually not recovered. The white cloud seen exiting
a stack on a cold day is mostly condensing water vapor giving up its latent heat to
the atmosphere.
Modern portable analyzers, like TSI’s CA-CALC Combustion Analyzers, automatically
perform combustion efficiency calculations, typically with better accuracy than
manual calculations or charts. Table 2 below shows the combustion efficiency for
fuel oil under various conditions.
NOTE: Other Definitions of Efficiency
Local regulatory agencies have guidelines for monitoring NO, NO2, CO, and SO2 gases.
Generally, it is required that the concentration of these gases be corrected for the diluting
effects of excess air. The amount of excess air is determined from the O2 concentration
measured in the flue. The measured O2 concentration, together with the O2 reference
value is used in the equation below to obtain the corrected gas concentration. O2
reference values of 3 and 6 percent are often used, giving a corrected gas concentration
equivalent to that at oxygen concentrations of 3 or 6 percent. When an O2 reference of
zero is used, the gas concentration is referred to as undiluted or air free.
To obtain the O2 referenced concentration of gasses in the flue, the following
equation is used:
Emission Conversions
A measure of the toxic gas concentration in parts per million (PPM) or percent does
not indicate the actual weight of pollutant entering the atmosphere. The EPA
requires the conversion of pollutant concentrations to pounds per million Btu of
fuel consumed (lb/MBtu). This is done so the weight of pollutants can be readily
determined from the pollutant concentration and the rate of fuel usage. EPA
Method 19 has equations for performing the conversions and presents fuel-specific
conversion factors for use in performing the calculations.
Making the
Measurements
Taking Gas Samples
Extracting flue gases to measure their concentration is done using a stainless
sampling probe inserted through a small hole in the exhaust flue. Probe placement
is important, and several factors must be considered when choosing a sampling
location.
To get the most accurate measurement, the gas sampling probe must be placed
prior to any draft damper or diverter, so that the gases are not diluted, and as close
to the equipment breach as possible so the gases have not cooled in the flue. If
there is a stack economizer or similar device, the measurement should be taken
just downstream of the installed device.
Figures 9 and 10 show two examples of recommended insertion points for gas
sampling probes.