Thesis Draft July
Thesis Draft July
Thesis Draft July
BY
MITIKU GELLAW MENGESHA (BSc.)
Advisor:
Dr. Solomon Shiferaw
April 2014
Abstract
Background
World health organization (WHO) and United Nations Children’s fund (UNICEF) recommends
breastfeeding children exclusively the first six months, and continuing breast-feeding along with
complementary foods up to 2 years or beyond is important. Despite the recommendations,
national exclusive breastfeeding prevalence in many countries remained very law which ranges
from 30%-67% only.
This study was intended to provide relevant information for government and nongovernmental
organizations’ (NGOs) officials on magnitudes and gaps on breastfeeding, exclusive
breastfeeding in particular. This will help for appropriate and relevant interventions.
Objective
To assess knowledge, attitude, and practices of mothers on exclusive breast-feeding and mixed
feeding and indicate areas of interventions for relevant stakeholders.
Methodology
This study was designed as an institution based cross-sectional study supplemented with
qualitative method. A structured and semi structured questionnaires were used for quantitative
and qualitative data collection respectively.
Results
Proportion of women with good knowledge and good exclusive breastfeeding practice was
259(65.1%) and 311(78.1%) respectively. Prevalence of mixed feeding practice was 73(18.3%).
In the hierarchical analysis; their spouse being educated, maternal age >35 years, married
mothers, being a housewife remained significant predictors of EBF knowledge. Mothers who
were formally educated and being a housewife were significant predictors of good EBF practice.
Even though mothers who visit health clinics are expected to have better knowledge status, their
knowledge status regarding EBF recommendations remained very low. Their EBF practice level
was still unsatisfactory. Their spouse being educated, mothers being married, being a housewife
and mothers’ illiteracy negatively affected their knowledge and practice status on EBF. A
i
support from family, health care providers, health policy makers and health project implementers
is imperative to improve appropriate breastfeeding practice among breastfeeding mothers.
ii
Acknowledgement
First and foremost my heartily felt thanks go to the Almighty God for giving me strength to
accomplish this task. I would also like to acknowledge Addis Ababa University School of public
health for the privilege and all supports it offered me in accomplishment of this study. My
sincere gratitude goes to my advisor Dr. Solomon Shiferaw for his unreserved assistance, timely
comments and relevant guidance from the beginning of the research proposal to the final report.
I would like to pass my heartfelt gratitude to Gubalafto health office, Hara health center and
Sanka health center officials at each level that had consented promptly to my study.
I would also like to thank all the Data collectors who participated in the study for having been
responsible and for efficiently filling the questionnaire and study subjects for their participation
and willing to be involved in the interview.
I am extremely grateful to my brothers Molla and Moges for their encouragement and support
starting from the beginning of my study. Lastly but not the least I would like also to pass my
gratitude to my friends Hailay and Haftay for sharing of their knowledge and skills in every
aspect during the process of the study.
iii
Acronyms
iv
Table of Contents
Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... i
Acknowledgement .................................................................................................................................. iii
Acronyms ............................................................................................................................................... iv
Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................... v
1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 1
2. Literature review ............................................................................................................................... 4
3. Objective .......................................................................................................................................... 7
4. Methodology ..................................................................................................................................... 8
4.1 Study Design .............................................................................................................................. 8
4.2 Study area ................................................................................................................................... 8
4.3 Study population ......................................................................................................................... 8
4.4 Sample size determination........................................................................................................... 9
4.5 Sampling procedure .................................................................................................................... 9
4.6 Data collection instrument and procedures ................................................................................ 10
4.7 Operational definitions .............................................................................................................. 10
4.8 Data management ..................................................................................................................... 12
4.9 Data analysis procedures ........................................................................................................... 12
5 Ethical considerations ..................................................................................................................... 12
6 Dissemination of results .................................................................................................................. 13
7 Results ............................................................................................................................................. 14
8. Discussion ......................................................................................................................................... 23
9. Conclusions ....................................................................................................................................... 25
10. Recommendations ........................................................................................................................... 26
11. References ...................................................................................................................................... 27
12. Annex.............................................................................................................................................. 29
A. Conceptual frame work of EBF.............................................................................................. 29
B. Information sheet ...................................................................................................................... 30
C. Consent form for study participants ........................................................................................... 30
D. Questionnaire............................................................................................................................ 31
E. Amharic translation of information and consent agreement sheet ............................................... 37
v
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
World health organization (WHO) and United Nations Children’s fund (UNICEF) recommends
breastfeeding children exclusively the first six months, and continuing breast-feeding along with
complementary foods up to 2 years or beyond, if the child and the mother demands. It had been
confirmed that almost all mothers can successfully breastfeed their children except for those rare
with defined maternal and child medical conditions [1]. Breast milk is superior in providing all
nutrients for an infant. It avoids childhood morbidity and mortality, enhances mother-child
attachment and serves as an effective family planning method for the mother [2]. A child who is
exclusively breastfed is 14 times less likely to die in the first six months compared to its
counterpart. Breastfeeding highly reduces deaths from the two famous child killer diseases;
respiratory infections and diarrhea [3].
More than 9 million under five children die each year globally. Majority of these under five
deaths are attributed by malnutrition, 70% of those deaths occur in the first year of life. Infant
and young child feeding practice has direct impact on nutritional status and ultimately affects
child survival under 2 year old children in particular. An estimated 1.30-1.45 million child deaths
could have been prevented each year with improved breastfeeding practices globally. Early
initiation of breastfeeding is also important in preventing neonatal deaths according a review
mad by UNICE. In this report, breastfeeding within the first hour of birth could prevent 22%
newborn deaths found in a research done in Ghana [2].
1
Uganda showed that infant mortality is six times higher in formula fed infants born to HIV
infected mothers than to mortality of breast- fed infants. This study also suggested that formula-
feeding might be hazardous even for HIV-infected infants, since all infants HIV infected by one
month of age in the formula-feeding group died by twelve months, compared to none in the
breast-feeding group [4,5].
Early cessation of breastfeeding has no significant benefit in HIV free survival to 24 months
according to randomized trial of behavioral intervention study done in Zambia. Only 68.4% and
64% survived to 24 months without HIV infection in the intervention and control group
respectively [6].
A cross sectional study done in 13 health institutions with anti-retro viral therapy (ART) and
prevention of mother to child transmission (PMTCT) facilities in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia showed
that nearly half of the study participants practice Exclusive replacement feeding while only a
quarter of them practice EBF; 50%, 30-40% and 5% of HIV positive mothers used exclusive
replacement feeding (ERF), EBF and practiced expressed breast milk feeding respectively.
Exclusive replacement magnitude in this study is very high, which may associate with
morbidities and mortalities in these study groups [7].
Ethiopian ministry of health has widely recognized the need for breastfeeding promotion. The
ministry took this initiative and planned to increase exclusively breastfeeding proportion to 70
percent by 2015 [10].
2
There are several reasons that affect the desire to practice exclusive breastfeeding shortly after
delivery. Poor feeding, inadequate support from husband and conflicting positions from the
significant others were dominant constraints in some African countries [11]. To design relevant
strategies for appropriate breastfeeding promotion interventions, understanding magnitude of
EBF practices and associated factors in this study area is important. I did a mixed quantitative
and qualitative study on mothers’ knowledge, attitude and practice towards EBF in Gubalafto
woreda north wollo zone of Amhara regional state of Ethiopia.
The purpose of this study was to describe magnitudes of knowledge, attitude and practices of
mothers towards EBF and identify factors that are associated with EBF knowledge, attitude and
practice.
The national demographic and health survey which is conducted every five years shows the
national EBF practice level. This survey lacks to show significant factors that are associated with
EBF. Researches were not also available that can show magnitude of gaps and specific factors
affecting breast feeding practice in this Woreda. Understanding the magnitude of mother’s
knowledge, attitude, and practice and associated factors to develop area appropriate intervention
strategies is important. By identifying these gaps, this study will be documented and provide
relevant information for Government policy makers and NGOs to develop relevant interventional
strategies. This will also help health care providers to understand gaps associated with
breastfeeding awareness and behavior so that they are more focused to these gaps during their
breastfeeding counseling.
3
2. Literature review
Negative attitude and bad cultural beliefs affects mothers’ compliance to the recommended
breastfeeding practice. A study done in Kware, Nigeria showed that nearly half (47%) of this
study participants have negative attitude towards first milk (colostrums) and they do not even
initiate their breast milk the first 3days [12].
Exclusive breastfeeding among mothers at a Sub- District Hospital in Kenya exclusive breast
feeding found being very low which was 33% only [13].Mixed feeding and mal practices of
child feeding the first six months were also very high in these study participants. Less than three
fourth (62.6%) breastfeeding mothers initiated breast milk to their neonate within one hour of
post-delivery in this study and nearly three fourth (72.2%) of this study participants gave
colostrum to their infants. Traditional mal practices were also dominant in this study. Half of
mothers practice mixed feeding in this study for different reasons. About half of mothers
provided butter (43%) and 53.2% gave rue (“tena-addam”) for stomach ache and common cold
treatments respectively [14].
4
Ethiopian Demographic and Health survey indicated that exclusive breast-feeding in Ethiopia
was not widely practiced and currently only half of children were breast fed the first six months
after birth (52%), while breast-feeding for some time is widely distributed 98% [9].
Additional national studies besides the EDHS 2011 regarding breastfeeding are still showing that
exclusive breastfeeding prevalence was minimal (49.0%) [4].8Nearly half of children in some
districts of Ethiopia were not exclusively breast fed the first six months of age. Two studies in
Bahirdar city, Ethiopia indicated that EBF prevalence was nearly half (49%, 50.3%) [15,16].
Breastfeeding prevalence in Harer city, Ethiopia was also similarly very low which was only half
(51.8%) [16].17 A better breastfeeding practice was shown in Goba district, south east Ethiopia
which was nearly three fourth (71.3%) [18].
Determinants of breastfeeding
There are several reasons that determine mothers Knowledge, attitude and practice regarding
breastfeeding, exclusive breastfeeding in particular. These determinants are different from place
to place. Studies in Pensular Malaysia indicated rural residence, ethnicity, non-working and non-
smoking mothers, multiparous mothers, term infants, mothers with husbands who support
breastfeeding and mothers who practice bed-sharing are positively associated with exclusive
breast feeding [19].
Longitudinal cohort study in Canada province of Novia Scotia, among mothers who initiated
breast feeding significant predictors of early cessation of exclusive breastfeeding was less than
high school education, lowest neighborhood income quintile, single motherhood, pregnancy,
obesity, smoking throughout pregnancy, no early breast contact by the infant (<1hour after birth)
and no intension to breastfeed[20].
A study by Li et al that investigated why mothers stop breastfeeding in united states stated
indicated that the top three reasons for mothers stopped breastfeeding within first month and
between first and second month after their child’s birth include, “Baby had trouble sucking and
latching on” (53.7% and 27.1%, respectively), “Breast milk alone didn’t satisfy my baby”
(49.7% and 55.6%), and “I didn’t have enough milk” (51.7% and 52.2%) [21].
5
Factors associated with sub-optimal infant breastfeeding and feeding practices in Nairobi Kenya
include child’s sex; perceived size at birth; mother’s marital status, ethnicity; education level;
family planning (pregnancy desirability); health seeking behavior (place of delivery) and;
neighborhood (slum of residence) [22].
In addition, a cross-sectional study in Jima Arjo Woreda of Ethiopia showed that thirty-seven
percent of mothers initiated breastfeeding later than one hour after delivery and indicted that not
attending formal education and painful breast-feeding experiences has significance association
[14].Optimal breastfeeding knowledge in Arba minch, Ethiopia has positive association with
paternal education level, total number of births, attending antenatal care, having radio access,
using family planning and giving birth by health provider [23]. A study done in Bahirdar city
Ethiopia showed, independent predictors for exclusive breastfeeding practice were Mothers
education, child sex, parity, family size and time of post natal care in this study area [15].
Exclusive breastfeeding practice in Harar, Ethiopia was associated with an average monthly
income of less than Ethiopian birr (ETB) 1000. Mothers who delivered in a health institution had
3.9 times more practice with exclusive breastfeeding than those who delivered at home. The
complementary feeding practice was 54.4% and was associated with a monthly income of less
than ETB1000 (p=0.003) and ETB1000-1999 (p=0.007). Mothers who followed antenatal care
(ANC) were 2.8 times more likely to practice timely complementary feeding than those who did
not follow the ANC service [17].
6
3. Objective
• To assess knowledge, attitude, and practice and associated factors of mothers on
exclusive breast-feeding and mixed feeding.
• Assess knowledge of mothers about exclusive breastfeeding in the first six months.
• Assess mother’s attitudes towards exclusive breastfeeding.
• Assess respondent’s practices on exclusive breastfeeding and mixed feeding.
• Assess determinant factors associated with exclusive breastfeeding
7
4. Methodology
4.1 Study Design
An institution based descriptive cross-sectional study method employed for quantitative data
collection. Methods employed for qualitative data collection was mainly grounded theory with
some phenomenology features. Mainly, grounded theory with some of phenomenology
characteristics of qualitative study method was employed during qualitative data collection.
The study was conducted in 2 health centers (Hara and Sanka health center) in Gubalafto district,
North Wollo zone of Amhara regional state of Ethiopia. Gubalafto district comprises around
139,825 populations and more than 95% of the population lives in rural areas. There were 11
health centers in this Woreda, and one zonal hospital in Woldiya town of the district, which
serves more than 43,139 populations of Woldiya town and Gubalfto woreda as a whole [26].
This study was conducted from September to December 2013.
The study population were mothers paired with their child of age less than or equal to 12 months
who came to Hara and Sanka health centers for different reasons. Multi-Para (mothers who had
at least 2 live births) paired with their child of age less than or equal to 12 months were a
qualitative study participants.
8
4.4 Sample size determination
A total sample size of 422 was determined using a single sample proportion formula. Knowledge
and practice proportions were used during samples size determination separately and the later
chosen. Practice proportion (from EDHS 2011) yielded higher sample size in the calculation and
taken for the sample size determination. The following assumptions were considered and 10% of
the sample was added considering possible non response during the actual data collection
process.
n= sample size
p = taken as 0.52 a prevalence exclusive breastfeeding practice from EDHS 2011 [8].
Z (α/2) = 1.96 at confidence level of 95% and
d = Margin of error (5%)
Inclusion criteria:
• All mothers paired with their child of age less than or equal to 12 months were included
in the quantitative data collection process.
• Mothers paired with their child of age less than or equal to 12 months and have at least
two live births (Multi-Para).
Exclusion criteria:
9
4.6 Data collection instrument and procedures
A structured questionnaire was developed and translated in to the local language (Amharic).
College diploma holders were recruited to be engaged in data collection process. Mothers
coming to health centers were interviewed consecutively until the desired sample size was
attained. An open-ended semi structured questionnaire with probing was used to explore key
informants’ experiences, knowledge, factors or challenges regarding EBF practice and attitude
towards exclusive breastfeeding in the community during for the qualitative. Tape recorder and
hand note were used during qualitative data collection process.
One-day orientation was given to data collectors and supervisors and 5 % of sample
questionnaire (21 samples) that would not be included in during the analysis process were pre-
tested. The pretested questionnaires were reviewed by the study team. Questions that were
inconsistent, that were not clear for both interviewer and interviewee, and inappropriate skipping
patterns were corrected. Make view tool in an Epiinfo was used to create view (questionnaire)
for data entry. Commands that would prevent the errors in the data entry process (Legal value
table, required check box, and field or variable type and size) were used during data entry
template preparation process.
Exclusive breastfeeding under 6 months (EBF): Infant receives only breast milk (including
breast milk that has been expressed or from a wet nurse) and nothing else, except for ORS,
medicines and vitamins and minerals [3].
Early initiation of breast milk: initiation of breast milk immediately within an hour after birth
[27].
Formula: Artificial milks for babies made out of variety of products, including sugar, animal
milks, soybean, and vegetable oils. They are usually in powder form, to mix with water [8].
10
colostrum, time of weaning, and foods or fluids that are not recommended before six months)
and mothers who scored less than the average are labeled to have poor knowledge and those
scored above the average was scored as having good knowledge.
Attitude score on EBF: Four scaled lickert scale was used to measure the opinions of mothers
towards EBF. By computing mothers opinions on ‘no breast before an hour, discard colostrum
before initiating breast milk, wean a child when it gets 4 months old, and in addition to breast
milk only water should be given to a child of 3 months old’. All the attitude opinion variables
was computed and averaged. Those scored below the average was considered with negative
attitude and those scored above the average were considered with positive attitude.
Practice score on EBF: By taking the mean of practice variables, scores on time of breast
initiated, discarding colostrums status, Time of complementary feeding initiated, and foods or
fluids offered before six months; those who scored below the mean, labeled as having bad
practice and those scored above the mean, labeled as having good practice.
Multi-Para: a woman who has given birth to two or more live children [28].
Study variables
11
4.8 Data management
Ten Percent of the paper questionnaires were randomly selected and verified manually before
data entry. Eight questionnaires were discarded found containing missing important data and
inconsistent responses. Miner errors encountering during data entry process was corrected and
entered.
Data were entered into Epiinfo version 3_5_1 for windows and exported to IBM SPSS version
20. Each variable were coded, transformed and computed and got ready for the next analysis
process. Socio demographic and economic variables were described by frequency and
percentage. Knowledge, attitude and practice labels were cross tabulated with independent
variables. Multiple binary logistic regression analysis was used to identify independent
predictors and control potential confounders associated with the three outcome variables
(Knowledge, attitude and practice about breast feeding). A qualitative data were transcribed and
translated from Amharic in to English. Themes were coded, categorized and analyzed using
Open code qualitative data analysis software. Practices and attitudes of mothers in the
community was explored and arranged into categories.
5 Ethical considerations
Ethical clearance was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee at the School of Public
Health, AAU and official letter of co-operation in the study area was obtained from Gubalafto
Woreda Health Office. Respondents were consented after explaining the purpose, potential risks
and benefits of participating and the right to withdraw from the study at any time throughout
their interview (using their own language). Confidentiality of study participants was assured and
maintained by explaining, their answers would not be shared with anyone other than members of
our study team. They were also been told that they could stop or pass to the next during the
interview process if they were encountered any question they wouldn’t want to answer.
Participants were interviewed in a place where they felt comfortable and sitting alone with the
interviewer. Instead of study participant names, codes were used for identification purpose to
maintain participants’ trustworthiness of confidentiality.
12
6 Dissemination of results
Results will be submitted to the School of Public Health, College of Health Sciences at AAU and
presented to the academic society of the university. After defending the results comments will be
incorporated and the final work of the study will be submitted to Amhara regional State Health
Bureau, North Wollo Zonal Health Office, Gubalafto woreda health office and the Federal
Ministry of Health of Ethiopia.
13
7 Results
Study population
Out of 422 mothers who gave birth in the last one year preceding the survey, 398 mothers paired
with their children participated in the study, making the response rate at 94.3%. Mean age of the
respondents was 28 ± 6.4 years ranging between 16-45 years. Majority of the study participants
316 (79.4%) were in the age group of 15-34 years and married 360 (90.5%). More than half of
the study participants had some level of formal education 213(53%) while the majority
271(68.1%) were unemployed/house wife (See Table 1).
Six key informants were purposively selected for an in-depth interview. The mean age of the key
informants were 28 years; ranging from 22 to 35 years. All of them had given birth to more than
2 child (Multi-para) and half of them 3 (50%) were not currently living with their husband or
they were separated. One third of them was illiterate or never attended any formal or informal
education. (See table 2)
14
Table 2: Characteristics of in-depth interviewees (Hara and Sanka Health center) Gubalafto
woreda, Amhara regional state of Ethiopia from August to December 2013 (n=6)
Marital
CODE Age status Education Number
1 22 Separated No formal education 2
2 30 Separated Primary 4
3 30 Married Primary 2
4 25 Separated Primary 2
5 35 Married No formal education 7
6 26 Married No formal education 2
Based on the knowledge score, 139(34.9%) of respondents were categorized as having poor
knowledge. The majority 361(90.7%) knew the importance of feeding first milk (colostrum),
363(91.3%) knew importance of early initiation of breastfeeding within an hour and nearly three
fourth 295(74%) of them knew to start complementary feeding at six month.
Base on the attitude score, 30(7.5 %) of respondents had negative attitude towards EBF
recommendations. Among these 25(6.3%) of them have negative attitude on early initiation of
breastfeeding, feeding colostrums and to ‘no water to a 4 month child’ opinion and 27 (6.8%) of
them had negative attitude to ‘no food or fluid to a child under six months age’ opinion.
According to practice score, more than three fourth 311(78.1%) of mothers had good practice
score on EBF the first six months. Early breastfeeding initiation prevalence among the
respondent mothers was 341(85.7%). The proportion of mothers who reported to have
exclusively breastfed was 325(81.7%) up-to six months while the rest 73(18.3%) of them were
mixed feeders. Formula feeding and cow's milk feeding was 20(5%) and 17(4.3%) respectively
while 42(10.6%) of mothers gave water before six months of their child age.
Majority of key informants in an in-depth interview mentioned that they initiated breast milk
immediately; and they don’t have a tradition of discarding colostrums nor offering fresh butter
immediately after birth. Interviews didn’t deny the tradition of fresh butter offering to a new born
in the previous times. A 22 year old mother for example stated that,
15
“On my behalf I immediately wash my breast and offered it to my newborn then started sucking.
My breast used to burst immediately I gave birth and starts milk flow and then my children used
to suck it until they get 9 months old”.
Most of respondents also reported that they breast feed their children exclusively up to six
months and have better understanding of IYCF counseling. A 30 year old mother said,
“Yes, up to six months we feed our breast milk only then after six months we start additional
foods. I prepare flour by mixing different cereals to my baby. By cooking thin gruel from this
cereal I feed my baby. Ya…I did not used to feed them this until they get six months old because
their stomach is not able to digest it. I give them this cereal gruel after they are six months old.”
Among bad practices identified from in-depth exploration of breastfeeding practice; practice of
offering water to young children before six months and negative attitude towards the sufficiency
of breast milk were identified. Some of the respondents also reported that there is a tradition of
offering ‘Abish’ (Fenugreek) immediately after birth and thereafter. A 30 year old mother said,
“Yes, they used to tell us not to give even water, but we give water in addition because the food
we are eating has salt and our infants may get thirsty. Ya, they drink water; they have their own
cup; they drink with that.”
This mother has believes towards the necessary to early breast initiation; but she has thoughts of
inadequacy of her breast milk for her neonate and believes that extra fluids are needed until her
breast has full milk flow. She said,
“Ehh…yes as we know, a child is born sucking its finger. I used to give my breast immediately I
gave birth but the breast has no adequate milk flow immediately. I use to give them my kids
‘Abish’ until my breast gets full milk flow.”
The second most mal practice raised during in-depth exploration was mixed feeding of other
foods like mashed potato and vegetables before six months. A 22 year old respondent said,
“……yes we give them water, mashed potato, and vegetables but no other foods.”
Almost half of the time a practice giving ‘Abish’ (Fenugreek) immediately a child is born was
raised by most of the time by the study participants. One of the respondents said that giving
‘Abish’ is good for children immediately they are born and she shared this experience from
Saudi women when she was in Saudi Arabia.
16
Socio-demographic and economic correlates of Knowledge on exclusive breastfeeding
Single mothers were more likely to have poor knowledge than married mothers [16(84.2%)
versus 112(31%); P<0.05]. Mothers and their spouses who are not formally educated were more
likely to have poor knowledge than those who are formally educated [108(58.4%) versus
31(14.6%); P<0.05] and [104(56.5%) versus 35(16.4); P=0.05] respectively. Mothers who have
low self-reported annual income (<= 12,000 ETB) were more likely to have poor knowledge
than those who had higher annual income (>12,000 ETB) [99(42.3%) versus 71(26.2%);
P<0.05]. Mothers who are engaged in formal or informal businesses outside their home were
significantly more likely to have poor knowledge than who are unemployed or house wives
[68(53.5%) versus 71(26.2%); P<0.05]. (See table 2 for detail)
17
Independent predictors of Good EBF knowledge
All variables which showed statistical significance at 25% level during the binary logistic
regression analysis were entered into multiple logistic regressions. The goodness of fit of the
model was checked by Hosmer and Lemeshow test model using backward likelihood ratio
method.
Among respondent mothers, odds of good knowledge among those having formal education
were 2 times more than those with no formal education [AOR= 2.3, 95% CI: 1.1-4.8]. Older
mothers (>=35years) have 2 times more good knowledge than younger mothers (<35years)
(AOR=2.1, 95% CI: 1.1-4.1). Marriage became statistically significant independent predictor of
good EBF knowledge. Mothers who are married or living with their spouse have nearly 4 times
more good knowledge label than single mothers (AOR=3.9, 95% CI: 1.7-8.8). Good knowledge
label increased among employed mothers by 2 times more than unemployed/housewives
(AOR=2.5, 95% CI: 1.4-4.5). (See Table 3)
Table 3: Factors associated with Good exclusive breast feeding Knowledge in Hara and Sanka
health center of Gubalafto woreda, Amhara regional state, from August to December 2013
18
Socio-demographic and economic correlates of Attitude towards exclusive breastfeeding
Several socio demographic factors showed significant association with negative attitude towards
the recommended exclusive breastfeeding practice. Mothers and their spouses who are not
formally educated were significantly more likely to have negative attitude than those who are
formally educated [27 (14.6%) versus 3(1.4%); P<0.05] and [27(14.7%) versus 3(1.4%); P<0.05]
respectively. Those who had no antenatal visit were significantly more likely to have negative
attitude than those who had at least one visit [2(33.3%) versus 2(1.9%); P=0.05]. Those with
lower income (<=1200 Birr) were more likely to have negative attitude than those with better
income (>1200 Birr) [24(10.3%) versus 6(3.7%); P<0.05]. (Table 4)
Table 4: Socio demographic and economic factors associated with Attitude towards
Exclusive breast feeding Hara and Sanka health center of Gubalafto woreda, Amhara
regional state from August to December 2013 (n=398)
19
Socio-demographic and economic correlates of exclusive breastfeeding practice of mothers
Single mothers were significantly less likely to exclusively breastfeed compared to married
mothers [14(36.8%) versus 73(20%); P<0.05]. Mothers and their spouses who are not able read
and write or formally educated were significantly more likely to have bad EBF practice than
those who are illiterate or not have any formal education [68(36.8%) versus 19(8.9%); P<0.05]
and [61(33.2%) versus 26(12.1%); P<0.05] respectively. Those who have currently older child
(>6 months) were significantly more likely to have bad practice than those having younger child
(<=6 months) [54(27.8%) versus 33(16.2%); P<0.05]. Those who have lower income
significantly showed more likely to have bad EBF practice than those with lower income
[61(26.1%) versus 26(15.9%); P<0.05]. Employed mothers were significantly more likely to
have bad EBF practice than unemployed or house wives [36(36.4%) versus 51(17.1%); P<0.05].
(See Table 5)
20
Table 5: Association of socio demographic and economic factors with Mothers' EBF
Practice Label, Gubalafto woreda Amhara regional state of Ethiopia from August to
December 2013(n=398)
In multivariate logistic regression analysis; only formal education, being housewife and older
age (>or=35) were found to be significant predictors of Good EBF practice. Formally educated
mothers were 6 times more likely practicing EBF than none educated (AOR=6.3, 95% CI: 3.5-
11.6). Housewives practiced EBF 3 times more likely than those mothers engaged in formal or
informal business (AOR=3.1, 95% CI: 1.7-5.5). Older age also contributed for better
breastfeeding practice, exclusive breastfeeding practice in particular. Older mothers (>or=35
years old) are 1.5 more likely to have good EBF practice than younger ones (< 35 years) (See
Table 6)
21
Table 6: Factors associated with Good exclusive breast feeding practice in Hara and Sanka health
center, Gubalafto woreda, Amhara regional state, August to December 2013
Most of the key informants believe on ‘mothers with better income do not want to breastfeed’
opinion were the first most raised opinion by interviewees. The other factors associated with no
breastfeeding and no EBF are having small breast (insufficient milk), lack of awareness, fear of
disease transmission to the infant, and assuming EBF recommendation to only women with the
‘disease’ (HIV) are mostly discussed opinions by the interviewees. For instance, a 30 year old
mother said,
“Ya, there are poor women that are not breastfeeding their kids as recommended; there are also
rich ones also that does not want to feed their breast and they start feeding bottle after feeding
their breast for only 1 months. Those riches think that they can afford formula milk and they
immediately start feeding formula milk by bottle.”
22
8. Discussion
The World Health Organization recommends exclusive breastfeeding in the first six months
weighing its clear benefits in reducing childhood morbidity and mortality, enhancing the mother-
child attachment and serving as an effective family planning method [1]. Mothers' knowledge
and attitude towards breastfeeding is important for effective infant feeding practice to bring the
desired outcome.
This study showed proportion of mothers who have no satisfactory knowledge on EBF was
34.9%.This is higher than findings from similar studies by Nbada et al in Nigeria [13]. But still
in this study, proportion of mothers with poor knowledge was lower than other studies in Nigeria
by Och MO et al. and a study done by Tamiru et al in Jima, Ethiopia [12, 13].
Determinants of knowledge in this study were married mothers, formal education of spouses,
employed mothers, and higher maternal age. Paternal formal education was similarly a
determinant factor for mothers’ knowledge on EBF by a study done in Arba minch, Ethiopia
[21].
Negative attitude regarding EBF recommendations in this study were minimal which is 7.5%.
This figure is lower than a study showed in Nigeria which was 47%. Similarly, in Nigeria it was
showed higher attitudinal status (46%) of mothers regarding EBF recommendations [,13].
Exclusive breast feeding practice was 81.7% which is much higher than a similar hospital based
study done in Pakistan which, 64.8% of the respondents found practicing EBF [10]. This is also
higher than a hospital based study done in Kenya sub-district (33%) [11]. This figure is higher
than other community based studies done in Ethiopia when comparing to studies like National
DHS (EDHS 2011) [8], EBF determinants in Ethiopia [11], Jima arjo woreda [12], Bahirdar
(14,24), Harar (15), and Goba districsts in Ethiopia [16].
Several studies are showing multiple factors that positively or negatively affecting breastfeeding,
exclusive breastfeeding in particular. Young maternal age (15-34 years), being single, illiteracy
23
of mothers and their spouses, has not or has only once ANC visit, Low annual income (<12, 000
ETB), and mother being employed in certain business has showed a significant association with
maternal poor knowledge status in this study. Similarly paternal education and ante natal visit
has significant association with knowledge status of mothers in exclusive breastfeeding a study
done in Arbaminch, Ethiopia [21].
Several factors in this study predict practice of mothers in exclusive breastfeeding. Mothers who
are married or living together are 2.5 times more likely to practice EBF than single mothers and
mothers who have better annual income (>=12,000 ETB) are more likely to practice EBF than
mothers with lower income(<12,000). This is the same with the study done in Bahirdar by
Alemayehu et al [11]. Other factors like illiteracy of mothers and their spouses, child age 0-6
months, Employed mothers and mothers with no ANC visit or have only first visit have
associated with non EBF practice. These factors are almost similar with studies done in different
places of Ethiopia [11, 15, 22].
Since this is institution based study, it is not strong enough representing the communities living
in this Woreda. This study has also limitations to use Random sampling technique which may
affect the representativeness of the study. The study participants were mothers paired with their
child of age 0-12 months, so that making this study limited not to use the standard WHO
definition of (24 hour recall period) in measuring EBF practice indicator.
24
9. Conclusions
Mothers who visit health clinics are expected to have a better health seeking behavior and better
knowledge and attitude towards health care providers’ recommendation. However, proportion of
EBF knowledge and practice in this study were very low. Good knowledge and good EBF
practice status were still less than three quarter in this study. Mixed feeding practice among these
study participants were prevalent; which nearly one fifth of the study participants practiced
mixed feeding. Education status of mothers and their spouse, marital status, maternal age and
maternal occupation were closely related factors that influenced mothers’ knowledge, attitude,
and practice label towards EBF.
25
10. Recommendations
• Spouses support is required to breastfeeding mothers to effectively breastfeed their child
and ensure better child nutrition. This was found significantly associated with mothers’
knowledge which in turn affects mothers EBF practice.
• Health care practitioners should include mothers’ spouse during IYCF and birth
preparedness counseling session to boost mothers’ awareness and make EBF practice
compliance better. Young mothers need special attention and continued support on child
care, starting on birth preparedness counseling through all their follow ups of growth
monitoring and vaccination
• Health policy makers and organizations (GOs & NGOs) working in the areas of MCH
need to design a strategy that addresses mothers who have no access of health facility, for
better outcome of IYCF counseling within the community .
• Health project implementers continued support to health facilities and health care
providers working in IYCF counseling is important to improve mothers’ knowledge,
attitude and practice towards the recommended EBF practice.
26
11. References
1. CAR-USA; Infant and young child feeding practices. Collecting and using data: A step-by-step
guide 2010.
2. Luann Martin, SM Moazzem Hossain, Carmen Casanovas, and Agnes Guyon. Learning from
large-scale community-based programs to improve breast-feeding practice. WHO/UNICEF,
2008.
3. UNICEF. Nutrition-breastfeeding. Unite for children. Update: 6 November 2013.
http://www.unicef.org/nutrition/index_24824.html
4. Peter J. Iliffa, Ellen G. Piwozb, Naume V. Tavengwaa, et al., Early exclusive breastfeeding
reduces the risk of postnatal HIV-1 transmission and increases HIV-free survival available from:
http://www.ibfanasia.orgArticleEarly-EBF-HIV.pdf.
5. Joseph Kagaayi, Godfrey Kigozi, Fred Nalugoda,etal., Survival of Infants Born to HIV-Positive
Mothers, by Feeding Modality, in Rakai, Uganda available from:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2588542/pdf/pone.0003877.pdf
6. Louise Kuhn, Louise Kuhn, Moses Sinkala, Effects of Early, Abrupt Weaning on HIV-free
Survival of Children in Zambia available from.
http://www.nejm.org/doi/pdf/10.1056/NEJMoa073788
7. Yetayesh Maru, Jemal Haidar. Infant feeding practice of HIV positive mothers and its
determinants in selected health institutions of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Ethiop. J. Health Dev.
2009; 23(2):107-114.
8. Central Statistical Agency, ICF International Calverton. Ethiopia Demographic and Health
Survey 2011. March 2012
9. Makonnen Asefa, Robert Drewett, Fasil Tessema. A birth cohort study in South-West Ethiopia to
identify factors associated with infant mortality that are amenable for intervention: Ethiopian
Journal of Health Development, 2000, 14(2): 161-168
10. Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia Ministry of Health. Health Sector Development
Programme IV 2010/11 – 2014/15. October, 2010
11. Ojo M Agunbiade et al. Constraints to exclusive breastfeeding practice among breastfeeding
mothers in Southwest Nigeria: implications for scaling up. International breastfeeding journal.
2012, 7:5
12. Oche MO1, Umar AS1, Ahmed H2. Knowledge and practice of exclusive breastfeeding in
Kware, Nigeria. AFHS1103-0518.
13. Nyanga NM1, Musita C1, Otieno A1 and D Kaseje1. Factors influencing knowledge and practice
exclusive breastfeeding in Nyando district, Kenya. African journal of food, agriculture, nutrition
and development. Oct. 2012; 12 (6)
14. Tamiru et al. Sub-optimal breastfeeding of infants during the first six months and associated
factors in rural communities of Jimma Arjo Woreda, Southwest Ethiopia. BMC Public Health
2012, 12:363
15. Abay Sefene, Dereje Birhanu, Worku Awoke, Tesfaye Taye. Determinants of Exclusive
Breastfeeding Practice among Mothers of Children Age Less Than 6 Month in Bahir Dar City
Administration, Northwest Ethiopia; A Community Based Cross-Sectional Survey. Science
Journal of Clinical Medicine. Vol. 2, No. 6, 2013, pp. 153-159. doi:
10.11648/j.sjcm.20130206.12)
16. Seid et al. Prevalence of Exclusive Breastfeeding Practices and associated factors among mothers
in Bahir Dar city, Northwest Ethiopia: a community based cross-sectional study. International
Breastfeeding Journal 2013, 8:14
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/8/1/14
17. Kibebew Abera. Infant and young child feeding practice among mothers living in Harer, Ethiopia.
Harar Bulletin of Health Sciences. January 2012; 4
27
18. Setegn et al. Factors associated with exclusive breastfeeding practices among mothers in Goba
district, south east Ethiopia: a cross-sectional study International Breastfeeding Journal 2012, 7
19. Kok Leong Tan “Factors associated with exclusive breastfeeding among infants under six months
of age in peninsular Malaysia” International Breastfeeding Journal 2011, 6:2)
20. Catherine R.L. Brown MSc, Linda Dodds PhD, Rebecca Attenborough RN MN, and et al. Rates
and determinants of exclusive breastfeeding in first 6 months among women in Nova Scotia: a
population-based cohort study. cmajo January 16, 2013vol. 1 no. 1 E9-E17.
21. Li et al. “Why mothers stop breastfeeding: Mothers’ self-reported reasons for stopping
breastfeeding during the first year” Pediatrics 2008;122;S69
22. Kimani-Murage et al. Patterns and determinants of breastfeeding and complementary feeding
practices in urban informal settlements, Nairobi Kenya BMC Public Health 2011, 11:396
23. Dessalegn Tamiru, Shikur Mohammed. Maternal Knowledge of Optimal Breastfeeding Practices
and Associated Factors in Rural Communities of Arba Minch Zuria, International Journal of
Nutrition and Food Sciences. Vol. 2, No. 3, 2013, pp. 122-129
24. Tewodros Alemayehu, Jemal Haidar, Dereje Habte. Determinants of exclusive breastfeeding
practices in Ethiopia. Ethiop.J.Health Dev. 2009; 23(1)
25. Egata et al. Predictors of non-exclusive breastfeeding at 6 months among rural mothers in east
Ethiopia: a community-based analytical cross-sectional study International Breastfeeding Journal
2013, 8:8 Page 2 of 8 http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/8/1/8)
26. Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia. Summary and statistical report of the 2007 Population
and housing censuses. December 2008, Addis Ababa.
27. WHO Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data. Indicators for assessing infant and young child
feeding practices: conclusions of a consensus meeting held 6–8 November 2007 in Washington
D.C., USA.
28. A&C black. Dictionary of medical terms. 4th edition. 2004, London. www.abcblack.com
28
12. Annex
Maternal
factors and Socio economic
factors of the
Paternal household
factors
Knowledge Attitude
on EBF towards
EBF
Practice
On EBF
29
B. Information sheet
All of the answers you give will be confidential and will not be shared with anyone other than
members of our study team. You don't have to be in the study, but we hope you will agree to
answer the questions since your views are important. If I ask you any question you don't want to
answer, just let me know and I will go on to the next question or you can stop the interview at
any time.
I the undersigned have been informed about the purpose of this particular research project and I
have been informed that the information I give will be used only for the purpose of the study
only. In addition I am also informed that my identity as well as the information I provide will be
kept confidential. Based on this, I agree to participate in the research voluntarily.
Participant’s signature____________
Witnesses
1. ________________,
2. ________________
30
D. Questionnaire
101 Please tell me how old you are. What was your Age in Completed Years .......... |___|___|
age at your last birthday?
Record age in completed years.
a. Orthodox………......................1
b. Protestant………………..…..2
c. Catholic ………………..……3
d. Muslim………………..……..4
e. Other…………………..…….5
a. Amahra……………..…….1
b. Tigray……………..……...2
c. Afar……………..………...3
d. Agew……………..………4
e. Other……………...………5
107 What is your educational status now? Educational status of the mother
31
education………………….…..2
c. 1-8………………………….….3
d. 9-10+2…………….……….….4
e. 10+2 and above……….….…...5
108 What is your husband’s educational Eduational status of her husband
status?
a. Not able to read and write………1
b. Read and write or informal
education……………………….2
c. 1-8………………………………3
d. 9-10+2………………………….4
e. 10+2 and above………………...5
109 What is your current occupation? Government employee--------------1
Daily-laborer------------------3
House made/servant----------5
Merchant-----------------------6
Farming -----------------------7
Others(specify) ---------------8
Private employee--------------2
Merchant----------------------4
Farming ----------------------5
Others(specify)-----------------6
111 How many times did you visit a health Number of ANC follow up visit
facility for ANC follow up while you
were pregnant this child? No ANC follow up…………….1
Two times……………………...3
32
Three times…………………….4
Four times……………………...5
112 How many children did you give a live Number of live births(parity )_____
birth yet?
No………………….……2
202 Did you ever breast-feed your child? Yes……………………..1 If yes skip to
q204
No……………………...2
203 Why you did not breast feed Due to inverted nipple or small
breast…..1
Inconvenience with my
job……………...2
Due to medical
reasons………………….3
Other/specify_______............................
....4
204 How long after birth did you first put Immediately with in an
this child to the breast? hour………………………….………
….1
Adays or
after………………………….3
No……………………………………..
33
2
207 Did your child have had any one of the No other than breast If no skip to q15
following later, the first 5 months of milk………………1
age? Or now if the child is below 6 Plain
water……………………..………..2
months
Infant formula (local
example)…………3
Milk, tinned, powdered or fresh animal
milk?......................................................
...4
juice
drinks……………………………..5
Porridge(thin or
thick)…………………6
Any other
fluids……………………..….7
2. Knowledge
within an hour
…….………..…………..2
After 24
hours………………………….3
Feed immediately…………………….2
34
complementary foods in addition to less……………………….1
breast?
4months………………………………2
5months………………………………3
6months………………………………4
7 months or above……………………5
304 Which foods and or fluids are Only breast milk and
recommended to give a child under 6 or………………1
months?
Plain water and
or…………………….2
3. Attitude
Disagree…………………...3
strongly disagree………….4
35
disagree ……………………3
strongly disagree……………4
strongly disagree………………….4
Disagree………………………..….3
Strongly disagree…………………4
36
E. Amharic translation of information and consent agreement sheet
ጤና ይስጥልኝ ሥሜ-------------ይባላል፡፡ በ አዲስ አበባ ዩንቨርስቲ በሚሰጠው የማህበረሰብ ጤና ት/ቤት የሁለተኛ ዲግሪ
ትምርት ማሟያ ለሚሆን ጥናት መረጃ ሰብሳቢ ነኝ፡፡ ጥናቱ እናቶችን ስለ ጡት ብቻ ማጥባት እና ሌላ ወተት መመገብ ላይ
ያላቸውን ግንዛቤ፣ አመለካከት፣ ልምድ እንዲሁም ተያያዠ ጉዳዮችን ለማጥናት ነዉ፡፡ የጥናቱ ውጤት ለ መንግስት በ ጤና
አገልግሎቶች ዙሪያ ለማቀድ ይጠቅማል፡፡ ለዚሁ ጥናት እርሶ ተመርጠዋል፡፡ ቃለ መጠይቁ 10-20 ደቂቃ ይፈጅ ይሆናል፡፡
በዚህ ቃለ መጠይቅ የሚሰጡት መልስ ከ ጥናቱ አባላት ውጭ ለሌላ ወገን ተላልፎ አይሰጥም፡፡
የርሶ በዚህ ጥናት መሳተፍ ለጥናቱ በጣም አስፈላጊ ነዉ፡፡ ሆኖም ግን በዚህ ጥናት ለመሳተፍ አይገደዱም፡፡ በጥያቄው
ውስጥ መመለስ የማይፈልጉት ጥያቄ ሲያጋጥምዎት ይንገሩኝ፤ወደሚቀጥለው ጥያቄ አመራለሁ፡፡ ከፈለጉ በማንኛውም ሰአት
ቀለምልልሱን ማቆም ይችላሉ፡፡
የስምምነት ቅጽ
ከዚህ በታች በዚህ ጥናት ለመሳተፍ የፈረምኩት ግለሰብ፣ ስለጥናቱ ሙሉ መረጃ ተሰጥቶኝ ነው፡፡ እንዲሁም የምሰጠው
ሙሉ መረጃ ለዚሁ ጥናት አላማ ብቻ የሚውል ይሆናል፡፡ የኔ ማንነትም ሆነ የምሰጠው መረጃ ሚስጥራዊነት የተጠበቀ
እንደሚሆን ተገልጾልኛል፡፡ ሥለዚህ በዚህ ጥናት ለመሳተፍ በፈቃደኝነት ተስማምቻለሁ፡፡
የተሳተፊ ፊረማ…………………….
37
F. Amharic translation of questionnaire
ቃለመጠይቅ
በዚህ ቃለ መጠይቅ ተሳታፊ የሚሆኑት፡- ልጆቻቸውን ለማስከተብ ወይም ለማሳከም ወይም በሌላ ምክንያት ወደ ክሊኒኩ ልጅ ይዘው
የሚመጡ እናቶች ሆነው፤ባለፈው አንድ አመት ውስጥ ልጅ የወለዱ መሆን ይኖርባቸዋል ወይም የያዙት ልጅ ከአንድ አመት በታች
መሆን ይኖርበታል፡፡ምርጫ ለተቀመጠላቸው ጥያቄዎች መልሶችን ያክብቡ፡፡
ያክብቡ አጭር መልስ የሚጠይቁ ጥያቄዎችን ደግሞ መልሶችን
በተቀመጠው ክፍት ቦታ ያስፍሩ፡፡
1. ማህበራዊ መረጃ
መረጃ Skip pattern
ሴት-------------------2
ሙስሊም----------------2
ፕሮቴስታንት------------3
ሌላ ካለ ይጠቀስ_________
ትግሬ--------------------2
አፋር--------------------3
አገው-------------------4
ሌላ ካለ የጠቀስ________
ያገባች----------------------------------------2
የፈታች/የሞተባት/ለግዜው የተለያየች--------3
ከ 1-8--------2
ከ 9-10+2---3
38
ከ 10+2 በላይ--4
ከ 1-8--------2
ከ 9-10+2---3
ከ 10+2 በላይ--4
የቀን ስራ---------------------3
የቤት ሰራተኛ----------------5
ነጋዴ-------------------------6
ገበሬ--------------------------7
ሌላ ከለ ይጠቀስ ___________
የቀን ስራ---------------------3
ነጋዴ-------------------------6
ገበሬ--------------------------7
ሌላ ከለ ይጠቀስ __________
በ 30 ደቂቃ ዉስጥ------3
ከ 24 ሰዓት ቡሃላ--------4
ሌላ ካለ ይጠቀስ__________
39
202 የጡት የመጀመሪያውን ወተት(እንገር) ምን መረግ መድፋት ወይም ማስወገድ-------------1
ያስፈልጋል?
ልጁ ወዲያው እንዲጠባው ማረግ------2
ሌላ ካለ ይጠቀስ______________
5ወር--------------------------3
6ወር--------------------------4
7 ወር ወይም ከዛ በላይ-------5
ከዚህ በመቀጠል የምጠይቅሽ/ዎት፤የአንችን/እረሶን አስተያየት የሚጠይቁ አንቀጾች ይሆናሉ፡፡ አንች/እርሶ ወልሶትን/ሽን በጣም
እስማማለሁ ወይም እስማማለሁ ወይም በጣም አልስማማም ወይም አልስማማም ከሚሉት አመራጮች የሚስማማዎትን ትመርጫለሽ
/ይመርጣሉ ፡፡
አልስማማም-------------2
በጣም አልስማማም------1
አልስማማም-------------2
መጣም አልስማማም----1
አልስማማም-------------2
በጣም አልስማማም------1
40
በፊት ተጨማሪ ምግብ ማስጀመር ይገባል፡፡ እስማማለሁ--------------3
አልስማማም-------------2
በጣም አልስማማም------1
4. ልጆች ስድስት ወር እስኪሞላቸው ድረስ የነበረው ወይም ያለው ያመጋገብ ስርአት እና ተዛማች ጉዳዮች
ሁለቴ-------------------------3
ሶስቴ--------------------------4
አራት ግዜ-------------------5
የጡቴ ጫፍ ትንሽስለሆነች-------------------2
ከስራየ ጋር ስለማይመቸኝ--------------------3
በሀኪም ስለከለከለኝ-------------------------4
ሌላ ካለ ይጠቀስ____________
406 እንደወለድሽ ለልጅሽበምን ያክል ግዜ ውስጥ ጡት ወዲያውኑ/ከአንድ ሰዓት በታች----------------1 መልሱ 1 ከሆነ
ሰጠሸዉ? ወደ ጥያቄ
በሰአታት ውስጥ/ከአንድ ሰዓት በላይ ከሆነ----2 ቁጥር 408
ይለፉ
ካንድ ቀን በላይ--------------------------------3
41
እኔ ታምሜስለነበር----------------------------3
ልጁ ታሞ ስለነበር-----------------------------4
ምክንያት የለም--------------------------------5
ውሃ እና ስኳር ----------------------------4
ሌላ ካለ ይጠቀስ___________
42