Crumb's Apparition and Emerson's Compensation
Crumb's Apparition and Emerson's Compensation
Crumb's Apparition and Emerson's Compensation
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted
digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about
JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
Society for Music Theory is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Music
Theory Spectrum
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Crumbs Apparition and Emersons Compensation
robert c. cook
This essay addresses the problems of variety and eclecticism in the music of George Crumb through
a study of the song cycle Apparition (1979). I adopt Ralph Waldo Emersons Compensation
a broad, plural principle embracing cyclicity, periodicity, binary opposition, and convergence with the
divineas the perspective from which to interpret motivic threads that gather in the cycles fifth
song. I trace Emersonian themes in the cycles text (a portion of Walt Whitmans When Lilacs Last
in the Dooryard Bloomd) and music, identifying interactions among the pitch-class collections in
Crumbs diverse palette as expressions of various, sometimes irreconcilable, categories of Compen-
sation. This approach thus avoids choosing between labeling Crumbs music as novelty and asserting
hidden structure.
Keywords: Apparition, George Crumb, Ralph Waldo Emerson, text-music relations, transforma-
tional theory, Walt Whitman
T
hree times in Come Lovely and Soothing Death, Rehearsal numbers 26 and 27; the third Call, at Rehearsal 341,
the fifth song of George Crumbs Apparition (1979), ends the song. Though each Call uses a pair of descending
the soprano summons Death. Example 1 excerpts the whole-tone dyads, each pair makes a different sort of tetrachord:
passages, which I shall refer to as the Calls to Death. The first the first is whole-tone, 4-21[0246]; the second is octatonic or
and second Calls are near the beginning of the song, at possibly diatonic, 4-10[0235]; and the third is chromatic,
4-1[0123]. On the one hand, intentions of motivic unity are
clear: each utterance follows a soft striking, in time with the
sopranos initial eighth rest, of undamped strings in the pianos
lowest octave or so; Crumb calls for articulations and dynamics
that are identical or similar. On the other hand, the collectional
diversity resists ascription of unity on bases more comfortable
for theorists to formalize than subset inclusion or poetic
association.
The analytical problem raised by the Calls and other passages
in Apparition is representative of central concerns in scholarly
approaches to Crumbs music. Musicians are familiar with
Crumbs diverse palette of pitch materialnot to mention the
array of unconventional instrumental techniques, performance
directions, and even costumesof which the Calls are a rela-
tively orderly expression. In response to critical assessments of
Crumbs music as no more than an assemblage of spooky
effects1 or not a mere assemblage of sound effects but a sus-
tained and beautiful dream vision of the deep,2 scholars have
asserted logical and organic structure3 and motivically uni-
fied, complete musical structures4 that synthesize Crumbs
multiple juxtaposed figures and sonorities, despite . . . surface
Research for this study was supported by an Old Gold Summer Fellowship
from the University of Iowa and a Stanley-University of Iowa Foundation
Support Organization travel grant. Earlier versions of this paper were
presented at the annual meeting of Music Theory Midwest in Lawrence,
Kansas, in April 2007, and at the Sixth European Music Analysis
example 1. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Conference, Freiburg, Germany, October 2007.
Death, Calls to Death: (a) at Rehearsal 26, whole-tone; (b) at
Rehearsal 27, octatonic or diatonic; (c) one after Rehearsal 34, 1 Moevs (1976, 302).
2 Porter (1973, 136).
chromatic. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by
3 Wilkinson (1986, 61).
permission. 4 Bass (1994, 182).
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
2 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
simplicity.5 This work illuminates Crumbs interest in sym- the question is still begged; what if the diverse figures and
metry and motivic connections within and among movements, shifting referential collections in Crumbs music are meant to
but an interpretive dilemma remains: make no claims for remain distinct, to express variety as much as his instrumenta-
a controlling structure and risk a disintegrated interpretation, or tion and use of timbre? This is the question I seek to answer in
assert a single underlyingand hiddenorder and risk an this article. I presume that unity in Apparition is one of pur-
interpretation that dismisses as mere surface the composers pose in the travels of various figures, drawn from different ref-
strong stylistic eclecticism.6 To say that Crumbs music is a erential collections, along common transformational paths.
dynamic, organically conceived union of idiosyncratic and extra- Turning analytical attention from pitch-class-set identity and
musical elements with those involving more traditional structural inclusion to the transformational conditions orienting multiple
parameters, including that of pitch7 (emphasis mine) ac- paths through and among referential collections in Apparition, I
knowledges the dilemma but situates analytical study clearly on argue that pitch and pitch-class figures in Come Lovely and
the side of structure and unity. Soothing Death move in recognizably related ways through
To be sure, studies by Richard Bass, Dave Headlam, Edward distinct referential pitch-class collections.14 I interpret collec-
Pearsall, Ciro Scotto, and others8 broaden analytical under- tional diversity in the song and related movements of the cycle
standing of Crumbs music and, from different perspectives, as the changing environment across which figures move and
respect both the divergent characteristics of the music and the change independently, though in response to the same trans-
expediency of discerning a coherent set of principles and tech- formational conditions.15 No unified structure need be asserted;
niques through which one imagines it to have been composed. indeed, my interpretation shows how both music and text in
Bass investigates transformational intersections between col- Apparition actively avoid synthesis.16
lections;9 Headlam uses spectrographic analysis to support in- There are resonances in my approach with studies by Steven
terpretations that integrate pitch-class and timbre analyses; Bruns of multivalent intertextuality in Crumbs music.17 Bruns
Pearsall discerns in Crumbs music the articulation of overarch- explores intertextual associations of instrumentation, motive and
ing principlesdialectics, pitch symmetry, collection comple- motivic transformation, form, pitch-class centricity, and genre
tionor structural paradigms according to which motives with music by Haydn, Mahler, and Bartok. Bruns hears
and their relations may be ordered;10 Scottos analysis of Pro- Crumbs music in multiple contexts, echoing or responding
cessional traces aggregate-completing partitioning and transpo- to music of the antique tonal tradition.18 From this perspective,
sitional combination techniques to show that these surface Crumbs music is neither critique nor synthesis of received tra-
formations are the result of deeper or hidden processes.11 dition but a different voice seeking unity of purpose, singing not
Despite recognition of and sensitivity to Crumbs kaleido- in unison but in response.
scopic12 technique, the analytical work cited here ultimately The analytical framework for my argument, presented in
argues for structure and unity in his music within the framework Part I, takes up an observation Bass makes but does not pur-
of Western compositional traditions, identifying contrast and sue.19 I identify the transpositional and inversional conditions
restatement, varied repetition and development, long-range under which the initially whole-tone Call to Death becomes first
composing-out of musical ideas, and underlying motivic con-
nections, all of which cooperate to provide both a sense of unity
and a structural contour.13 14 My purpose here is not simply to shift the focus of analysis from object
(pitch-class set, motive, etc.) to relation (inclusion, transformation, etc.).
Perhaps the role of unity and structure is better understood as
Rather, I want to avoid interpreting objects as necessarily hierarchized by
coherently representing analytic engagement with Crumbs relations; or, I wish to avoid fixing a particular set of relations as structural
music than as asserting something immanent in the music. But and then fulfilled by objects. The metaphor of landscape or terrain through
which I shall argue is apt: if, as Lewin puts it, we can . . . regard them
5 De Dobay (1984, 90). [transformations] as ways of structuring an abstract space . . . through which
In a glowing review of a performance of Vox Balaenae, Porter substitutes the piece moves (Lewin [1993, 34]), we can also regard transformations as
one description entailing no expectation of logical order for another (Porter articulating the space as pathsand impassable placesmapping a land-
[1973]). Reviews by Lewis (1965) and Henahan (1968) are laudatory but scape through which the figures of a piece move. And two different figures
focus on Crumbs timbral effects and motivic collage, as does Moevss less may not move the same way.
positive essay. 15 This essay does not propose an interpretive model for timbre, including
6 Headlam (2005) offers a similar binary opposition. The hypothetical poles instrumentation and extended performance technique, in Apparition.
are perhaps extreme, but they mark out a heuristic frame for music that Headlams (2005) integrative approach offers much insight regarding the
resists delimitation by genre and/or medium. contributions of these features to pitch and rhythmic structure in Madrigals,
7 Bass (1991, 19). but a full account of timbre in Crumbs music will require investigation of
8 Bass (1991) and (1994); Headlam (2005); Pearsall (2004a) and (2005); and for lack of a better termsoundscapes, particularly the natural ones to
Scotto (2002). which many of Crumbs works make reference. That is a subject for
9 Bass (1994, 165"67, 176"82). another study.
10 Pearsall (2005), (2004a), and (2005, 58), respectively. 16 Cf. Szutor (1994, 2).
11 Scotto (2002, [5]). 17 Bruns (1993) and (2005).
12 Castanet (2009, 31). 18 Bruns (1993, 10).
13 Bass (2002, 59"60). 19 Bass (1994, 165"67).
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 3
table 1. Labeling conventions for referential collections. flora, fauna, and human endeavor celebrated in Whitmans
poetry. From the combined analytical and metaphysical perspec-
Pitch-Class Collection Label tives of Parts I and II, Parts III and IV interpret Come Lovely
and Soothing Death and other movements of Apparition as
fC,D,E,F ,A ,B g WTC Compensatory music, heterophonies of poetic and musical
fD ,E ,F,G,A,Bg WTD expression unified only by a common purpose.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
4 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
table 2. Crumb, Apparition, principal figures and strains. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by permission.
Referential Score
Label Sample Collection Locations
Figures
Octatonic R27
Chromatic R341
Strains
R28, 30,
Undulate Octatonic
before 33
which a figure moves, or might plausibly be considered as an octatonic figure to move within its original octatonic
moving, with respect to some referential collection.24 For collection by certain transpositions and inversions, and to
example, a given set of transformational conditions permit the other octatonic collections by certain other transpositions
and inversions. Examples with a contrapuntal design can
24 Despite the similarity of locutions to Pearsalls transformational also move into other referential collections. I mean the term
communities and transformational streams, transformational to have topographical connotations rather than, say, logical
conditions are in a sense the opposite of the former and inclusive of the or meteorological. I make the assumption that, though in
latter. The constituents of Pearsalls communities are motives that contain principle any transformation of a figure is possible, only
the same shapes and ordered interval content as the original (2004b, 72), a selection of possible transformations is available for a given
while the elements of my conditions are transformations. Pearsalls streams
figure. Metaphorically speaking, a given figure in Apparition
demarcate the step-by-step evolution of a motive toward new motivic
constructions that may differ quite radically from the source motive (77),
inhabits a terrain through which some transformational
while my conditions, were they expanded to include rotations, retrogrades, paths are accessible but not others; alternatively, a given
and motivic transmutations (73), would include such progressions along figure is able to travel through the landscape by some
with other possible transformational paths. transformational paths but not by others. These other
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 5
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
6 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 7
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
table 4. Effects of network transpositions on axes of invariance, by initial octatonic or whole-tone collections.
have not chosen, as Buchler does with his examples, to express The counterpoint through the Calls illustrates the different
the progression with Shaugn ODonnells dual-transposition responses of referential collections to changing transformational
networks. Certainly T5T10hT3i and T5T7hT0i, which conditions. The Calls can move from WTD to OCTD ,D to the
register the Call-to-Call transpositions in the dyad series, are chromatic because hT3i shifts the contrapuntal axis from F 4 (or
also pertinent to the transformational conditions through I0), about which pitch classes in WTD can only move to other
which the Calls move.33 I have chosen these elements of the pitch classes in WTD , to A 4-and-G4 (or I3), about which pitch
system because inversion and axis shifts are the most prominent classes in one whole-tone collection can only proceed to pitch
components of transformational conditions under which classes in the other whole-tone collection. The particular dyads
figures move between referential collections in the song. The in OCTD ,D that constitute the second Call (other 4-10[0235]
analyses in this article will otherwise remain neutral on the tetrachords are possible) are the result of dyad-to-dyad transpo-
appropriateness and efficacy of competing models for atonal sitions T5 and T10. The former flips whole-tone collection
voice leading.34 membership; the latter preserves it. About the new axis, I3, pitch
classes in OCTD ,D can only move to other pitch classes in
OCTD ,D, but the dyad-to-dyad transpositions from the second
between the [02] dyads as you move from tetrachord to tetrachord, and you Call to the third can only relay the pitch classes in OCTD ,D to
might characterize the situation as a sort of counterpoint between what
become the upper and lower series of [02] dyads in the Calls. This
one of the two other octatonic collections.
characterization might be enough for you, but if you wished to analyze Example 4s analysis of the Calls also engages the central
the situation, you would soon find that the axis of the counterpoint image of Deaths approach in Whitmans text, Deaths active
shifts. hT3i indexes the shift precisely. The correspondence between the response to the poets and singers summons; we will explore that
phenomenology of some music and a Klumpenhouwer-network analysis engagement in Part II.
of it might not be close enough to be useful, but it is in the case of Come
Lovely and Soothing Death.
33 ODonnell (1997).
34 I have also avoided the connections between Perles cyclic sets and leading is not so intuitive. I am interested in voice leading among figures
Klumpenhouwer networks (Perle [1993]; Headlam [2002]). While the in Come Lovely more than I am in the ways in which these figures are
Perle-cyclic perspective is useful for studying affiliations among sets embedded in cyclic set complexes. On Klumpenhouwer networks as
represented as Klumpenhouwer networks, the connection with voice interpretations of voice leading, see Klumpenhouwer (1991, 8:1"8:28).
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 9
ii. emersonian compensation in whitmans when lilacs a hermit thrush, whose voice is that of a Nature spirit and of
last in the dooryard bloomd Whitmans own, sings a carol of death for Abraham Lin-
coln.41 Crumb chooses the first of the carols seven stanzas,
whitmans text and crumbs text which summons and welcomes Death:
Music in general but especially songas pastime and as Come lovely and soothing death,
metonym for transcendental expressionwas important to Undulate round the world, serenely arriving, arriving,
Whitman. Studies of his musical interests have examined the In the day, in the night, to all, to each,
role of opera in his life and thought, and the influence of musical Sooner or later delicate death.
form on his poetry.35 Indeed, Manuel Villar Raso proposes
reading When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloomd in sonata Crumb alters the text of Whitmans carol by repeating the first
form.36 Rasos reading relies on a misunderstanding of tonal and line twice and the second line once, as well as repeating several
developmental principles in sonata practice, but some analogy to individual words:
music is inescapable. Writing of Lilacs in 1866, John Bur-
roughs said it is like intricate and involved music, with subtle, Come lovely and soothing death, mm
far-reaching harmonies.37 More to the point here, Burroughs Come lovely and soothing death, mm
writes, It is dramatic, yet there is no procession of events or Undulate mm round the world, mm, serenely arriving, arriving, mm
development of plot, but a constant interplaya turning and
re-turning of images and sentiments . . . .38 Whitmans famous Undulate, undulate round the world, serenely arriving, arriving
first section speaks not simply of Aprils blooms and stars recal- In the day, in the night, to all, to each,
Sooner or later delicate death.
ling Lincolns assassination, but of a cyclic return in Mircea
Eliades sense of eternal return:39 Come lovely and soothing death. mm
When lilacs last in the dooryard bloomd, The alterations focus attention on the pair of Undulate
And the great star early droopd in the western sky in the night, round the world lines, framed by the second statement of
I mournd, and yet shall mourn with ever-returning spring. Come lovely and soothing death and description of deaths
impartiality, In the day, in the night, to all, to each,/Sooner or
Ever-returning spring, trinity sure to me you bring,
later delicate death. The first and third statements of the
Lilac blooming perennial and drooping star in the west,
Come lovely and soothing death then frame the whole, as the
And thought of him I love.
antiphon of a liturgical proper chant frames a psalm verse.
The death of the republics father/Captain/Martyr Chief is
re-experienced, always and again, in the smell of lilacs and
undulation and emersons compensation
brightness of Venus at dusk.40 The delicacy of the lilac-
perfumed, bird-haunted evening; the universal experience of
In Whitmans lengthy poem on Death, Undulate round the
death and the national experience for Whitmans America of
world is one of only two descriptions of Deaths approach.42
mourning the murdered president; the complementaryand
Both the phrase and the themes of Whitmans poem echo
contentiousvariety of peoples, occupations, and politics; and
portions of Emersons 1837 address to Harvards Phi Beta
the welcome summoning of Death are themes thatto borrow
Kappa Society, The American Scholar. Emerson said:
Burroughss termsdo not develop but are in constant inter-
play. Put another way, Lilacs spins out diverse themes and images That great principle of Undulation in nature, that shows itself in
that nonetheless act toward a common metaphysical purpose. the inspiring and expiring of the breath; in desire and satiety; in
The text of Come Lovely and Soothing Death comes from the ebb and flow of the sea, in day and night, in heat and cold,
Section 14 of Lilacs. At the emotional apex of the poem, and as yet more deeply ingrained in every atom and every fluid, is
known to us under the name of Polarity,these fits of easy
35 Faner (1951); Mayhan (1996); Picker (2000). See also Reynolds (2005,
transmission and reflection, as Newton called them, are the law
49"56).
of nature because they are the law of spirit.43
36 Raso (1994, 189"201).
37 Burroughs (1866, 612).
38 Ibid. (613). In 1841, Emerson renamed this principle Compensation,
39 Eliade (1954, 51"92). and in the essay of that title listed some of its manifestations.
40 Whitman names Lincoln father and Captain in O Captain! My
Captain (1982, 467) and Martyr Chief in the 1879 lecture Death of 41 Rugoff (2000, 134).
Abraham Lincoln (1047). Whitman speaks in the lecture of gathering 42 The other is gliding near with soft feet, two stanzas later in the carol and
annually for tragic reminiscence (1037) and of the cyclic, evocative set by Crumb in Apparition, III, Dark Mother Always Gliding Near with
powers of Nature at mid-April: It never fails (1041). See also Warble Soft Feet.
for Lilac-Time (505"6), written in 1870. 43 Emerson (1971, 61).
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
10 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 11
article, we examine each of the remaining figures and strains The tail of the final complete Warble on F is echoed by the
individually, establishing a musical Compensatory landscape tail of Warble on G (marked echo of d in Example 6[b]). T10
within which we may situate Come Lovely and other move- began the piece as an internal transformation in Warble and the
ments of the cycle with respect to one another. Calls, characteristic of both octatonic and whole-tone figures.
But T10 can also be a progressive transformation, a means of
leaving one octatonic collection for another: the first series of
warble45 Warbles ends with Warble on G and the second ends with
Warble on F, a T10 then echoed by the T2-related tails of
Example 6 shows the opening of the song (Example 6[a]) Warbles on F and G (as one imagines the song of Whitmans
and the two other passages (Examples 6[b] and [c]) involving bird echoes in the Long Island swamp) across the landscape
Warble, a strictly octatonic figure that moves within and among emerging out of Warbles transformations.
the octatonic collections by transposition. There is more to The transposition scheme of the Warble music discourages
Warbles motivic salience than its pitch-class features, and we intuitions of counterpoint that are encouraged by the Calls to
will explore its context in the preceding songs of Apparition in Death, but the scheme outlines an orientation of pitch-class
Part IV below. For now, though, we will study the transforma- space and associated transformational conditions through which
tions of Warble as transformational paths that articulate the inversional counterpoint will move in the future. Example 7
pitch-class terrain and point to other possible paths. shows how Warble articulates this space; the networks in the
Each Warble in Example 6 bears an italic label for ease of example model Warbles as anchor-toggle nodes. In some cases,
reference in the analysis to come. The first series of Warbles, such as Example 7(a), these nodes contain three pitch classes:
shown in Example 6(a), moves through OD ,D by T6 and T3 anchor, T10 toggle, and T1 toggle. In other cases, the nodes
(figured from anchors). Both kinds of toggle are present, at least contain the anchor and T10 toggle only. Each node is labeled
in Warbles on B (with toggles G , labeled a in the example, and for easy reference to the annotated scores in Example 6.
C , labeled b) and on G (toggles F, labeled d, and A , labeled e). The first series of Warbles, analyzed in Example 7(a), sug-
Warble on E, just before Rehearsal 25 and marked c, appears gests a T9 cycle of anchors, articulated T6"T3, above which the
only with toggle D. But there is at least a hint of Warble on E toggles make a second T9 cycle. The union of the two cycles is
with toggle F. The third figure in series of Warbles on G, OCTD ,D, of which the only element not heard in the first series
labeled f, follows F6 with E5. E is out of place in the context of of Warbles is C . (Indeed C is the only pitch class not to appear
Warbles on G, but F6 and E5 would have been likely toggle and as anchor or toggle; it is part of the tail of Warbles on B and A.)
anchor pitches in a series of Warbles on E. Examples 7(b) and 7(c) rotate the positions of pitch-class names
The Warbles on B are followed at T6 with Warble on E; one on the page to keep the T3 transformation in the same position it
might expect Warbles on G to be followed at T6 with Warble on occupied in Example 7(a) and to eliminate the need for nodes
C . Instead, the soprano sings the first Call to Death, the end of that must cross from the top to the bottom of the example, but
which appears again in Example 6(b).46 The first Call begins on otherwise the pitch-class landscape is identical. These net-
B4 and ends on C 4, however; this is the correct pitch interval works illustrate the unexpected appearancewith respect to
if not the correct figurefor a Warble on C and its T10 toggle. the first series of Warblesof Warble on A in the second
After the Call, Warble music returns at Rehearsal 262. The series, and the eventualand expectedprogression of
connection between the first series of Warbles, the first Call, and Warble on D to Warble on G in the third series.
this next series of Warbles, is C 4, sung by the soprano in the One way to depict the orientation of pitch-class space, the
first Call and picked up immediately by the pianist as a pizzicato transformational conditions in which we hear Warble, is
accompaniment to Warble on D (g). a T1$T9 product network, as shown in Example 8. T10, which
The overall T3 motion through OCTC,D in the second set of has been particularly salient in both Calls and Warbles, is the
Warbles, from Warble on D to Warble on F, is similar enough ascending rightward diagonal. Each adjacent pair of T9 series
to the motion from Warble on B to Warble on G in the first set (the top and bottom series are adjacent) form one of the octa-
that we should expect Warble on G or B between Warbles on D tonic collections. The Warbles move about this network by
and F. Instead, the intervening Warble is on A (h, in OCTC,D ), transposition, but, as Table 3 indicates, a figure might also move
and the passage concludes with Warbles on F (i, j). Example within and among octatonic collections, and therefore between
6(c) begins with the sopranos Sooner or later delicate death, rows, columns, and diagonals of this network, by inversion.47
just after Rehearsal 32, followed by the third set of Warbles,
which follows Warble on D with Warble on G , labeled k, as 47 Strictly speaking, we may add only certain contextual inversions (Lewin
anticipated earlier. [1993] and [2008]; Kochavi [1998]; Clough [1998]; and Lambert
[2000]) to preserve the networks commutative structure. For example,
45 In the swamp in secluded recesses,/A shy and hidden bird is warbling we might define I 1 as inversion-about-the-ic1-adjacent-pc-in-
a song, from Lilacs, Part 4 (Whitman [1982, 459]). fB ,G,E,C g, I2 as inversion-about-the-ic2-adjacent-pc-in-fB ,G,E,C g,
46 Here and below I refer to Warbles as expected or unexpected with J inversions likewise about elements of fB,G ,F,Dg, and K inversions
respect to Warbles heard before. I mean it in precisely this empirical way, similarly about elements of fA,F ,D ,Cg. That step is unnecessary for the
not in the sense that the unexpected disrupts coherent motivic development. present analysis, however.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
12 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
example 6. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, Warbles: (a) beginning through Rehearsal 25; (b) Rehearsal 262
to just before 27; (c) after Rehearsal 32. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by permission.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 13
(a) B G F D
C A F D
a, b d, e c, f?
B G E C
B G E C
T3 T10
T1
T6
A F D C
(b) T9
B G T7 E C
example 8. Product network derived from Warble series.
h
T5 were some loose strand of yarn in a sweater would unravel the
A G D C network into two distinct whole-tone cycles. Likewise, tugging
on a T1 vertical would unravel the network into a chromatic
i, j cycle. Other passages in Come Lovely and Soothing Death
g
exploit these reorientations of pitch-class space.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
14 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
example 9. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, Undulate passages: (a) Rehearsal 28 to 291; (b) Rehearsal 30 to 31.
Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by permission.
from the OCTC,D of her Undulate to the OCTC,D of Arrive.50 The sopranos Undulate and Arrive passages trace trans-
As if taking a step back into the first serenely arriving, here positional paths along the T9 rows of the product network
she begins the figure on E4 and arrives on B 3 just before shown in Example 8; her moves from Undulate to Arrive trace
Rehearsal 31. inversional paths among these rows. The networks in Example
10 illustrate. Here I have inclined the T1 arrows upward and to
50 The soprano does not recall the G4 she sang earlier by singing A4. Instead,
she sings . . . round the world to alternating D5 "E 5 , followed by the right to depict the temporal order of pitch classes in the
serenely arriving to E4"E 5. E is the other pitch class on the I6 axis figures. Example 10(a) shows how the soprano sings Undulate
and so here stands in for A4, about which D5 inverts to E4. (Rehearsal 28) by beginning in the same T9 row that had
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 15
example 12. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, setting of In the day, in the night, to all, to each, Rehearsal 31 to
313. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by permission.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
16 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
(a)
(b)
(c)
example 13. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, In the day, in the night, to all, to each, analyses: (a) in relation to
the end of second serenely arriving; (b) inversional counterpoint; (c) Klumpenhouwer-network interpretation.
T10, return here as both an internal figural unit and a progressive of the (Rehearsal 311, last eighth note) prevent D 4"G4
transformation between different referential collection classes. from disturbing the otherwise WTC In the day, in the night,
The example continues by taking note of the common-tone link but the dyad opens up a path to the other whole-tone strand,
C5 between the end of In the day and the beginning of in the WTD , in which the soprano sings the to all, to each. The
night. The [02] dyadic arrangement of the passage dissolves bottom staff of Example 13(b) interprets the tritone F 4"C5,
here; the line continues to express WTC arranged about the both notes of which are common tones linking two figures in the
pitch axis E 5. Registral separation and grammatical function soprano line, as part of a pivot about G4-and-F 4 to D 4"G4.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 17
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
18 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
example 14. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, Dirge in E : (a) score; (b) voice-leading sketch; (c) inversional
counterpoint. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by permission.
the same time, however, the arrival on D effects progression, Dirge in D major (Rehearsal 31 to 32) supports the setting of
not only of one consonant triad to another, but within the songs In the day, in the night, to all, to each, ending on a B-major
transformational conditions. E "D presents T10, as the other triad (Rehearsal 32). Dirge in B major (Rehearsal 33 to 34) ends
figures and strains have done. While I10 preserves OCTC,D , on an A-major triad (Rehearsal 34), after which the soprano
which is the home of the preceding serenely arriving and of the sings the third Call to close the song. Example 15 summarizes
E major triad, and I6 preserves OCTD ,D, which is the home of the Dirges voice leading, including the first. The example takes
the D -major triad, both inversions retain whole-tone collection some analytic license with the register and direction of the upper
membership. voice in order to highlight the inversional conditions of each
Dirge appears two additional times in the song, each instance passage. From our Compensatory perspectivethat is, from the
a strict transposition down a whole tone of the previous one. perspective that says figures residing in different referential
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 19
example 15. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, synopsis of voice leading in Dirge passages.
collections respond differently to identical transformational con- appears in each of the first two measures; B and D are the only
ditionsthe Dirges integrate the familiar goal-directedness of two pitch classes not in figuration of the top and middle staves at
the diatonic collection as it ascends the major scale and as tonic- Rehearsal 33, and only E is absent from the top and middle
functioning harmonies progress to dominant-functioning har- staves at Rehearsal 331. The third measure lacks only C .
monies with the balance of whole-tone collections, the absence of Though all twelve pitch classes have been present in earlier
motions converging on a goal. Counterpoint about a single axis passages, the figures and referential collections to which they
within each Dirge emphasizes convergence; axis transpositions belong have been much more clear. Soon after, of course, the
by hT8i between passages emphasize balance because they do song closes with the chromatic tetrachord of the third Call to
not alter the inversional dispositions of whole-tone sonorities Death.
but do cycle through the inversional dispositions of octatonic We can find textual conceptual support, too, for the idea that
sonorities. hT8i is not a shift that takes the diatonic collection of the chromatic is both a goal and a source. For Emerson,
each Dirge to the next; in fact, shifting the active axis of inver- Compensation was but the nature of Nature. The spirit did not
sion in the E -major collection from I10 to I6 produces the B- partake of Compensation. Emerson writes,
major collection rather than the D -major collection, and similar
relations obtain among successive pairs of diatonic collections. The soul is not a compensation, but a life. The soul is. Under
Rather, hT8i is one of the axis transpositions that preserves all this running sea of circumstance, whose waters ebb and
whole-tone collection membership of pitch classes inverted flow with perfect balance, lies the aboriginal abyss of real
about the new axis, an effect that is aurally reinforced by the Being. Essence, or God, is not a relation, or a part, but the
series of 3-8[026] chords in the dominant section of each pas- whole. Being is the vast affirmative, excluding negation, self-
sage and the overall T10 progression from one diatonic collection balanced, and swallowing up all relations, parts and times,
to the next. In short, the passage moves in both balanced and within itself.56
convergent pathspaths in which intuitions of motion are in
one case balanced, in the other case convergent. In the death mourned and welcomed by Whitman, the spirit
unites with that Unity, that Over-Soul, . . . the eternal ONE .57
This sentiment, though, is precisely the sort of grand syn-
iv. apparition and compensation thesis avoided by the song, the cycle, Whitmans poetry beyond
Lilacs, and indeed even Emersons thought.58 As we saw in
The transformational conditions under which we hear Example 15, the structural downbeats marked by the diatonic
Come Lovely and Soothing Death are common to all refer- passages articulate a descending whole-tone tetrachord, the final
ential collections at work in any passage, but the responses of the A major of which rings on until just before the sopranos closing
figures are different according to the collection to which each utterance. That is, the song projects whole-tone balance, a resis-
figure is referred. Under changing conditions, specifically shifts tance to closure, on a relatively long-range scale even as the
of inversional axes, we recognize both the related ways the
figures respond to the conditions and the distinct collectional 56 Emerson (1979, 70).
57 Ibid. (160).
characters of the figures, which are not synthesized in a com-
58 Whitmans famous lists in Song of Myself (see especially the section
mon chromatic background. Still, one might be tempted to beginning The pure contralto sings in the organ loft [Whitman f1982,
assign figures and strains in Come Lovely and Soothing 200"3g]) speak of this diversity. Emersons address The Transcendental-
Death neatly to various categories of Compensation: whole- ist (1971, 201"16) is an exploration of the irreconcilability and the mutual
tone figures represent balance, octatonic figures and strains necessity of both mundane concerns and visions of spiritual transcendence
stand for periodicity, and diatonic strains indicate convergence. rather than an account of unified thought. Whatever its shortcomings as
The closing page of the song even lends some support to this a philosophical exposition, writes Lawrence Buell (2003, 206), as a per-
formance of . . . dilemmas The Transcendentalist is elegantly suggestive.
interpretation.
In his introduction to Emersons collected writings, Robert Spiller ascribes
At Rehearsal 33, as Dirge in B major begins, figural clarity to Emerson a suspended dualism of natural and moral laws in parallel, with
and collectional differentiation break down. Example 16 shows which one could live only if one found a way to accept apparent contra-
the first three measures of the passage. The chromatic aggregate dictions and to forego final answers (Emerson [1971, xviii]).
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
20 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
example 16. Crumb, Apparition, V. Come Lovely and Soothing Death, Rehearsal 33 through 332. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters
Corporation. Used by permission.
progression of the Calls projects convergence. Although the the second in Example 17, the pianist is directed to depress the
closing section of the song is more fully chromatic than any keys for a progression of minor triads in first inversion,
other, this is not an all-subsuming chromatic of a divine aborig- A"G"E"D, suggesting a latentor at least virtually inaudi-
inal abyss but a heterophony of whole-tone, octatonic, diatonic, blepair of descending [02] dyads forming a 4-23[0257]
and chromatic voicesa natural soundscape out of which figures tetrachord.
emerge and into which they recede.59 Preceding movements of The second movement, Vocalise 1: Summer Sounds,
the cycle create that soundscape and thence emerge the Call to continues the association of 3-3[014] figures with the night
Death and Warble in which the voices of the poet and hermit soundscape in which we now clearly hear [02] figures, perhaps
thrush are joined. bird calls; Example 18 shows these passages. These bird calls are
The opening song of Apparition, The Night in Silence under not yet entirely separate from the soundscape. In Examples 18(a)
Many a Star, describes the spring evening on which the song of and 18(c), the pianos major-seventh dyads include a pitch class
the hermit thrush becomes, for Whitman, a carol for the chromatically adjacent to one or both pitch classes in the sopra-
assassinated Lincoln. Above strums of the piano strings nos [02], blurring the dyad. In Example 18(b), the soprano
marked like a sound of nature and in fact much like the supplies such pitch classes herself. It is only at the very end of
continuous insect noise of a summer (N.B. not April!) night or the Vocalise, shown in Example 18(d), that the bird sings out in
the steady lapping of ocean waves on a calm nightthe soprano a figure Crumb marks as a Turtle-dove effect.
sings the first line of text, which the pianist answers with Thus out of the nights silence, which is no true silence at all
a pianississimo arpeggio strain. (Example 17 reproduces the but a soundscape teeming with quiet voices to which Whitmans
piano part.) The pianos response to the soprano is, but for the speaker will soon attend, emerge two motives. Figures using
A6"E7 fifth midway through the second system, a series of 3-3[014] begin to articulate a musical analogue to the space and
3-3[014] trichords drawn, again with the exception of A6 in the processes of the natural soundscape. We will hear 3-3[014] in
third and sixth figures and C7 in the last figure, from Come Lovely and Soothing Death as the tail of Warble,
OCTD ,D.60 At the end of the first system and the beginning of through which we learn the paths of the network in Example 8,
and we hear it as Arrive, through which the soprano portrays the
spiraling approach of Death. Figures using descending [02]
59 Crumbs own comments suggest that we should hear his music this way
dyads shape the tentative call of a singer bashful and tender,61
(Varga [1984, 200]).
60 With the exceptions of the cited As and Cs in the piano strain, A, C, and D
at a few places in the soprano part are the only played or sung notes in The
Night that are not elements of OCTD ,D. 61 Whitman (1982, 461).
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 21
example 17. Crumb, Apparition, I. The Night in Silence under Many a Star, piano. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by
permission.
foreshadowing the Calls to Death and their tetrachords made of Example 19 gives Vocalise 3 in its entirety. At the beginning
such dyads.62 and the end of this brief vocalise, a four-note figure consisting of
But the thrushs song is not yet the carol of death that [02] dyads articulates a 4-1[0123] tetrachord with the registral
Whitmans speaker and the bird sing togetherAnd the voice separation characteristic of the Calls in the next movement.
of my spirit tallied the song of the bird.63 That joining of voices From this figure the middle of the vocalise derives
requires some mutual transformation in which the birds song a 4-Z15[0146] tetrachord, an inversion of Warble. Example 20
embodies some recognizable human purpose and the speakers illustrates.
spirit sings in an avian voice.64 This transformation happens in The vocalise is short enough that the score requires no
Vocalise 3: Death Carol (Song of the Nightbird), which rehearsal numbers or system breaks, so for ease of reference,
immediately precedes Come Lovely and Soothing Death. Example 20 includes dashed bar lines at analytically useful
points and the discussion to follow refers to measures, corre-
spondingly. A second staff shows a new figure emerging in the
62 There are five tetrachord classes made of two [02] dyads. The Calls belong
middle of the vocalise, as the [02] dyads in the opening and
to three of them, 4-1[0123], 4-10[0235], and 4-21[0246], and to all, to
each (see Example 12) belongs to a fourth, 4-25[0268]. The fifth class, closing measures of the top staff move in contrary motion about
4-23[0257], lurks in the sound of nature at the beginning of the cycle. F4-and-E4, or I9. This figure is an inversion of the third Call,
Szutor (1994, 15, 33, 56) notes the importance of [02] dyads but does not while the contrary motion of the dyadsthat is, one dyad
explore motivic connections among figures involving the dyad in any detail. descends while the other ascendswill be picked up by the
63 Whitman (1982, 464). setting of to all, to each (see the end of Example 12). The
64 This is not to say that a birds song does not embody some purpose or figure in the second measure (not including B4 , which is shown
direction toward a goal, only that such a purpose or goal might not be
as part of a different figure in the lower staff), is T6 of the first
recognizable to a human. Thus I disagree with Szutors assertion that the
bird in Lilacs and bird sounds in Vocalise 1 initially are heard as figure and the contrapuntal arrangement of its constituent dyads
inarticulate sounds of nature that are later transformed into language that about B4-and-B 4 likewise expresses I9, but the dyads involved
we understand (1994, 26). are now [01]. B4 at the end of the figure is one of the axis
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
22 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
example 18. Crumb, Apparition, Vocalise 1: Summer Sounds, 3-3[014] figures and [02] bird calls: (a) beginning; (b) Rehearsal 5;
(c) before Rehearsal 7; (d) end. Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by permission.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 23
example 19. Crumb, Apparition, Vocalise 3: Death Carol (Song of the Nightbird). Copyright 1979 by C. F. Peters Corporation. Used by
permission.
works cited
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
24 music theory spectrum 34 (2012)
Intersections: Canadian Journal of Music/Revue canadienne de Lewin, David. 1982"83. Transformational Techniques in
musique 29 (1): 17"31. Atonal and Other Music Theories. Perspectives of New
Cherlin, Michael. 2007. Schoenbergs Musical Imagination. Music 21 (1"2): 312"71.
Music in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge . [1993] 2007. Musical Form and Transformation: Four
University Press. Analytic Essays. New York: Oxford University Press.
Clough, John. 1998. A Rudimentary Geometric Model for Originally published in New Haven: Yale University Press.
Contextual Transposition and Inversion. Journal of Music . 2008. Transformational Considerations in
Theory 42 (2): 297"306. Schoenbergs Opus 23, Number 3. In Music Theory and
Cohn, Richard Lawrence. 1987. Transpositional Combination Mathematics: Chords, Collections, and Transformations. Ed.
in Twentieth-Century Music. Ph.D. diss., University of Jack Douthett, Martha M. Hyde, and Charles J. Smith.
Rochester. 197"221. Eastman Studies in Music 50. Rochester:
Dahlhaus, Carl. 1991. Ludwig van Beethoven: Approaches to His University of Rochester Press.
Music. Trans. Mary Whittall. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Lewis, Robert Hall. 1965. Review of Night Music I, by George
De Dobay, Thomas R. 1984. The Evolution of Harmonic Style Crumb. Perspectives of New Music 3 (2): 143"51.
in the Lorca Works of Crumb. Journal of Music Theory 28 Mayhan, William F. 1996. The Idea of Music in Out of the
(1): 89"111. Cradle Endlessly Rocking. Walt Whitman Quarterly Review
Eliade, Mircea. [1954] 2005. The Myth of the Eternal Return; or, 13 (3): 113"28.
Cosmos and History. Trans. Willard R. Trask. Bollingen Moevs, Robert. 1976. Review of Music for a Summer Evening
Series 46. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (Makrokosmos III), by George Crumb, Nonesuch H 71311,
Emerson, Ralph Waldo. 1971. The Collected Works of Ralph 33 1=3 rpm. The Musical Quarterly 62 (2): 293"302.
Waldo Emerson. Vol. 1. Nature, Addresses and Lectures. ODonnell, Shaugn J. 1997. Transformational Voice Leading
Introductions and notes by Robert E. Spiller, texts estab- in Atonal Music. Ph.D. diss., City University of New York.
lished by Alfred R. Ferguson. Cambridge [MA]: The Pearsall, Edward. 2004a. Symmetry and Goal-Directed
Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. Motion in Music by Bela Bartok and George Crumb.
. 1979. The Collected Works of Ralph Waldo Emerson. Vol. Tempo 58 (228): 32"39.
2. Essays: First Series. Introduction and notes by Joseph . 2004b. Transformational Streams: Unraveling Melodic
Slater, text established by Alfred R. Ferguson and Jean Processes in Twentieth-Century Motivic Music. Journal of
Ferguson Carr. Cambridge [MA]: The Belknap Press of Music Theory 48 (1): 69"98.
Harvard University Press. . 2005. Dialectical Relations among Pitch Structures in
Faner, Robert D. 1951. Walt Whitman and Opera. Philadelphia: the Music of George Crumb. In George Crumb and the
University of Pennsylvania Press. Alchemy of Sound: Essays on His Music. Ed. Steven Bruns and
Headlam, Dave. 2002. Perles Cyclic Sets and Klumpenhouwer Ofer Ben-Amots. 57"81. Colorado Springs: Colorado
Networks: A Response. Music Theory Spectrum 24 (2): College Music Press.
246"56. Perle, George. 1993. Letter to the Editor. Music Theory
. 2005. Integrating Analytical Approaches to George Spectrum 15 (2): 300"3.
Crumbs Madrigals, Book I, No. 3. In George Crumb and the Picker, John M. 2000. Red War is My Song: Whitman,
Alchemy of Sound: Essays on His Music. Ed. Steven Bruns and Higginson, and Civil War Music. In Walt Whitman and
Ofer Ben-Amots. 235"67. Colorado Springs: Colorado Modern Music: War, Desire, and the Trials of Nationhood.
College Music Press. Ed. Lawrence Kramer. 1"23. Border Crossings 10. New
Henahan, Donal. 1968. Review of Echoes of Time and the York: Garland.
River (Echoes II), by George Crumb, performed by the Porter, Andrew. 1973. Musical Events: Potpourri. The New
Chicago Symphony Orchestra. The Musical Quarterly 54 Yorker April 28: 135"41.
(1): 83"87. Raso, Manuel Villar. 1994. Musical Structure of Whitmans
Hoffmann, E. T. A. 1810. Review of Beethovens Fifth Poems. International Conference on Walt Whitman,
Symphony. Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung 12 (40"41): cols. University of Macerata, 29"30 October 1992. In Utopia in
630"42, 652"59. the Present Tense: Walt Whitman and the Language of the New
Klumpenhouwer, Henry James. 1991. A Generalized Model of World. Ed. Marina Camboni. 189"201. Rome: Il Calamo.
Voice-Leading for Atonal Music. 2 vols. Ph.D. diss., Reynolds, David S. 2005. Walt Whitman. Lives and Legacies.
Harvard University. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kochavi, Jonathan. 1998. Some Structural Features of Rugoff, Kathy. 2000. Three American Requiems:
Contextually-Defined Inversion Operators. Journal of Contemplating When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard
Music Theory 42 (2): 307"20. Bloomd. In Walt Whitman and Modern Music: War,
Lambert, Philip. 2000. On Contextual Transformations. Desire, and the Trials of Nationhood. Ed. Lawrence Kramer,
Perspectives of New Music 38 (1): 45"76. 133"50. Border Crossings 10. New York: Garland.
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
crumbs apparition and emersons compensation 25
Music Theory Spectrum, Vol. 34, Issue 2, pp. 1"25, ISSN 0195-6167,
electronic ISSN 1533-8339. 2012 by The Society for Music Theory.
All rights reserved. Please direct all requests for permission to photocopy or
reproduce article content through the University of California Presss
Rights and Permissions website, at http://www.ucpressjournals.com/
reprintinfo.asp. DOI: 10.1525/mts.2012.34.2.1
This content downloaded from 157.138.191.67 on Wed, 28 Jun 2017 15:46:04 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms