Otc 20506
Otc 20506
Otc 20506
Abstract
The reel-lay method is generally the most effective way of installing infield subsea flowlines and risers particularly for sizes
up to around 16 inch. This paper describes one of the most advanced reeled pipeline installation vessels in the world, the
Seven Oceans, and the variety of pipelines and risers that she has installed including the welding and inspection of high
fatigue life SCRs and sour-service flowlines.
The paper goes on to present various recent developments for reeled installation including HFI pipe, PE lined pipe,
mechanically lined pipe, clad flowlines and SCRs, high strength pipe, hybrid risers and electrically heated-traced flowlines.
These show the continuing attraction of reel-lay for ever more technically demanding work and that for options such as
electrically heat-traced flowlines that reeling will be the main vessel based installation method.
1. Introduction
1.1 Vessels
The reeled pipelay concept has been in use since the Pipelines Under the Ocean (PLUTO) project across the English
Channel (Purvis, 1946). The reel ship Apache (Anon, 1979) is a notable name in the development of the technology and was
first operated in 1979. Other reel lay vessels followed including the Skandi Navica (Clarkson, 2006) now named as Seven
Navica. Another notable vessel was the Deep Blue (De Soras & Cruickshank, 2000) and more recently the Seven Oceans.
Other reeled vessels also exist but the characteristics of these main ones are given in Table 1.
Vessel Name
Vessel Type
Length
Breadth
Depth
Draught
Reel Hub Diameter
Reel Capacity
Installed Power
DP Power
Accommodation
Top Tension
Crane
ROVs
Apache
Rigid Reel Lay
122.91m
23.34m
8.69m
5.55m
16.44m
2,000te
15.09MW
10.74MW
95
156te
[197te including back
tension to reel]
27te
-
Seven Navica
Rigid Reel Lay
108.53m
22.00m
9.00m
7.17m
15.00m
2,200te
12.60MW
9.80MW
72
Deep Blue
Rigid Reel Lay
206.50m
32.00m
17.80m
10.00m
19.50m
2 x 2,700te
33.60MW
25.60MW
160
Seven Oceans
Rigid Reel Lay
157.30m
28.40m
12.50m
7.50m
18.00m
3,500te
18.90MW
15.85MW
120
205te
550te
400te
60te
Option
400te
2 x 3,000m
400te
2 x 3,000m
OTC 20506
OTC 20506
PLETs are handled using a dedicated PLET handling system. This system consists of a deck mounted rail system, a PLET
manipulator and a PLET line-up tool.
For planned (or unplanned) laydown of the pipe, a 450te A&R system is installed. The storage winch is capable of storing
3,000m of 119mm wire. The secondary A&R system has an 80te rating. The smaller wire enables the numerous smaller jobs
to be more readily handled on deck and subsea.
The Seven Oceans has a diesel electric propulsion system with power supplied by six diesel electric generator sets, three
in each of the two engine rooms. Each generator can run on either MGO or IFO to reduce costs. In transit, propulsion is
provided by three stern azimuth thrusters. In DP operations, station keeping is assured by the three stern azimuth thrusters
and at the bow, two drop-down azimuth thrusters and a tunnel thruster. The system has DP Class II notation but the as-fitted
specification is well in excess of the requirements making the vessel well suited for work adjacent to platforms such as SCR
hand-over operations.
The main offshore mast crane is installed on the port side of the vessel just aft of amidships and has a main hook with
capacity of 400te at 16.5m radius and a 50te whip line. An auxiliary crane with a capacity of 40te at 14m radius is installed
amidships on the starboard side of the vessel and two 12te cranes are installed aft to facilitate pipelay operations.
The aft deck of the vessel between the reel and the ramp has an area of 650m and has a strength rating of 10te/m. The
deck thickness has been increased to 25mm to allow for wastage associated with repeated seafastening of items and
subsequent removal and there are no fuel tanks immediately below the main deck so that hot work is facilitated.
Two work class ROVs are installated in a hangar situated at the aft end of the superstructure. Each ROV has an
independent LARS and umbilical allowing operations in 3,000m water depth.
A helideck suitable for Sikorsky S-61 or Super Puma is situated forward, above the level of the bridge.
Further details can be found in Smith & MacGregor, 2006, MacGregor et al 2009, Smith et al 2009.
OTC 20506
Further details of the general installation work are given by Hensley 2008 and are illustrated in Fig. 3.
The welding of these SCRs presented significant challenges due to the stringent acceptance criteria. The welding method
adopted was pulsed hot wire automated GTAW. This was selected for two main reasons:High weld quality;
High mechanical integrity.
Tables 2 and 3 show the mechanical properties achieved on SCR projects with this process. All test values given are
averages of three.
Location
Weld Metal
Weld Metal
Weld Metal
HAZ
HAZ
HAZ
Test Temperature
-5C
-5C
-5C
-5C
-5C
-5C
Test Temperature
Weld Metal
HAZ
-18C
-18C
425
408
434
431
Parent Material
-18C
412
436
OTC 20506
The scope was split between 2008 and 2009. All the reeled flowlines were installed by the Seven Oceans after fabrication
at the Luanda spoolbase (see Fig. 4) where the production welding was 100% done by Angolan welders.
3.3 Sour Service Flowlines
In Brazil two projects have been reel layed in which the flowline welds had to be qualified for sour service. On the first
the API 5L X65 pipes ranged from 273.1 mm diameter, 22.2mm w.t. to 323.9mm diameter, 28.6mm w.t. On the second the
pipes were X60 all 323.9mm diameter with wall thickness from 17.5mm to 25.4mm.
Resistance to sulphide stress corrosion cracking was established by first cyclic strain ageing (at strain levels duplicating
the installation of the worst case scenario) then testing in accordance with NACE TM 0177 with solution B and four point
bends in accordance with EFC-16. These tests were carried out at 85% of the specified minimum yield strength of the base
material. Welds had to comply with NACE MR 0175 / ISO 15156.
This demonstrates that welds can meet the requirements for sour-service after reeling.
3.4 BC10
BC-10 is located in the Campos Basin, offshore Brazil, in water depths between 1,600 and 2,000 metres including the
worlds first lazy wave SCRs (Hoffman et al 2010). The scope of work was the engineering fabrication and installation of
-
OTC 20506
Fig. 5 Seven Seas and Seven Oceans working together on project BC-10.
Of particular relevance here all 130km of flowlines were reeled as were the 7 lazy
wave SCRs. The main particular of the SCRs as shown in Fig. 6 were as follows.
-6 off API 5L X60, 6 x 15.9mm
-1 off API 5L X65, 12 x 19.1mm
Pulse
Weld
For BC10, pulsed hot wire automated GTAW was used again with pulsing
Fig. 8 Weld Schematic
focused at the bevel to ensure full fusion at each side wall, see Fig. 8. The
allowable weld defect size was on the limits of detectibility with current AUT systems.
Production welding rates increased significantly and spurious cut-outs reduced during the project due to close liaison with
the client and the use of on site macro sectioning and evaluation to help calibrate the AUT results.
OTC 20506
FrictionCoefficient,
12"PPCoatedPipelineduringInitiation
402mmODPP
365mmODPP
FrictionalSafetyFactor=1.42
TensionerTrackLoading,kn/mpertrack
Fig. 10 Friction Curves
OTC 20506
Carbon Steel
Outer Pipe
50mm
Nominal
3mm liner
In an extension to this work to allow BuBi pipe to be used for reel-layed risers some preliminary fatigue testing has been
conducted on samples of the pipe after reeling; see Fig. 12. Two tests have been conducted to date with both samples
reaching 20 million cycles. These tests will be run to destruction and further full scale fatigue testing will be carried out in
2010.
OTC 20506
10
OTC 20506
4.8 J-Lay
Separate work has also been done on J-Lay welding, (Chong et al, 2009) and
a suite of J-Lay equipment installed on Seven Seas, see Fig. 17, which can
potentially be used for those applications for which reeling is not accepted but is
outwith the scope of this paper.
4.9 High Strength Steel
With increasing water depths and increasing occurrence of HP/HT
developments there is an increasing potential benefit in using higher strength
steels particularly for risers. The lower wall thickness can reduce top tension for
the installation contactor, reduce the size of buoys on SLORS and CORS type
risers and reduce the loads on the production vessel. From the reeling point of
view the main issue is ensuring that the pipeline girth weld overmatches the
strength of the parent pipe material.
At present we have qualified weld procedures with girth weld metal yield
strengths of 109ksi (750MPa) with consumables having Nickel contents less than
1% and hardness limits within that required for sour service.
Fig. 17 Seven Seas J Lay Module
a)
to reduce the outer pipe diameter for a specified thermal performance thus reducing material costs, reducing top
tensions and allowing longer lengths on a vessel reel.
b) enhancing thermal performance for the benefit of the client, given specified pipe diameters.
Table 4 gives an example of the former based on an inner pipe OD of 236mm and U=0.6W/mK
OD
318 mm
367 mm
496 mm
Insulation
Izoflex
Aerogels
P U Foam
Table 4
Insulation
Aerogel
Izoflex
U
1.3W/mK
0.56W/mK
Cool Down
30 hours to 35C
95 hours to 35C
Table 5
As an example of the latter, for a nominal 6 x 10 PIP Table 5
clearly shows the very impressive performance of the Izoflex
system.
Fig. 19
OTC 20506
11
Full scale testing has been done both before and after reeling on a 6 x 10 design using a specially constructed thermal
test rig at Herriot Watt University; Fig. 19. The thermal performance was only reduced by 5-10% due to reeling which can
clearly be allowed for in the design process. Bending trials also showed that with the Izoflex material, because of its strength
in compression, centralisers are not required giving a significant further improvement in thermal performance.
Full scale construction trials have also been performed at a spool base to demonstrate that it is entirely practicable to build
stalks with no centralisers.
4.10 Pipe in Pipe; Electrically Heat Traced Flowlines
As a next step in improving thermal performance a number of
trials have been done with electrical trace heating (EHTF), see Fig.
20. Bench tests/bending trials were conducted which confirmed FE
model results and demonstrated that the mechanical integrity of the
wires was unaffected by the reeling process.
It should be noted that because of the continuous wires in the PIP
annulus this technology can only realistically be laid by the reel-lay
method or in towed bundles.
Electrical heating systems have been used elsewhere and several
projects have been installed with DEH (Direct Electrical Heating)
cables. However the EHTF technology combined with Izoflex
performance only requires approximately one tenth of the power of a
DEH system which is a considerable advantage. It is also suitable
for long step-out distances.
Typical ETHF power levels are in the order of 10W/m for hydrate mitigation. The ETHF is also useful for producing waxy
oils, with high wax appearance temperatures, because heat can be applied continuously over all, or a significant part, of the
project lifetime.
5. Conclusions
The reel lay method is a well established way of installing in-field flowlines and risers. This paper demonstrates that the
technology can be extended to provide further cost effective solutions and solutions for ever more challenging fields.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Subsea 7 for permission to publish this paper. None of it would have been possible
without the help of colleagues at Subsea 7 in preparing the paper and also a whole range of onshore and offshore personnel
who executed the projects as well as Clients, Contractors and Suppliers.
12
OTC 20506
References
- Anon, 1979, Recent Trends in Offshore Pipelay Equipment, Sea Technology, April 1979.
- Atkins, J.G., Lillig, D.B., Hoyt, D.S., 2006, Extension of Deepwater Riser Fatigue Life through Use of Nickel Based Welding
Consumables, DOT, 2006.
- Bertaso, D., Hutt, G., Wang, J., Tews, P., 2009, Improvement Of Fatigue Life Of SCR and OOL In West Africa, OTC 19192, 2009.
- Campbell, T., 2009, Polymer Liner and Connection Qualification for Use in Subsea Pipelines, OTC 19900, 2009.
- Chong, P.H., Smith, S.N., Rodgers, K J., Smith, M., 2009 Meeting Challenging Steel Catenary Risers (SCR) Fatigue Performance using
Standard 1% Nickel Wire, Floating Structures Conference, Glasgow 2009.
- Clarkson 2006, Construction Vessels of the World Eight Edition, 2006/2007, ISBN 1-902157-70-2.
- Denniel, S., 2009, Optimising Reeled Pipe Design Through Improved Knowledge Of Reeling Mechanics OTC 20043, 2009.
- Darcis, P.P., et al 2009, Fatigue Performance of SMLS SCR Girth Welds Comparison of Prefabrication Type WPS, OMAE 200979811.
- De Soras, D & Cruickshank, J., 2000, Combining Flexible and Rigid Pipelay Functions for Ultra Deepwater Operations, Offshore, May
2000.
- Hensley,S, 2008, Deepwater SCR installation by Reel Lay using Seven Oceans, DOT 2008.
- Hoffman, J., Yun, H., Modi, A., Pearce, R., 2010, Parque das Conchas (BC10) Pipeline, Flowline and Riser System Design, Installation
and Challenges, OTC 20650, 2010.
- Kan, W.C., Mortazari, M., Weir, M.S., 2009, Advances in Riser and Pipeline Technologies, Rio Pipeline 2009.
- Karunakaran, D., Lee, D., Mair, J., 2009, Qualification of the Grouped SLOR Riser System, OTC 1989, 2009.
- Karunakaran, D., Melling, T.S. Kristoffersen, S., & Lund, K.M., 2005, Weight Optimised SCRs for Deepwater Harsh Environments,
OTC 17224, 2005.
- Kopp, F., Perkins, G., Prentice, G., Stevens, D., Production and Inspection Issues for Steel Catenary Riser Welds, OTC 15144, 2003.
- Kristoffersen, S., Haagensen, P.J., Rorvik, G., 2008, Full Scale Fatigue Testing of Enhanced Girth Welds in Clad Pipes for SCRs
Installed by Reeling, OMAE 2008-57309.
- Lillig, D.B., Weir, M.S., Kan, W.C., Hoyt, D.S., 2005, Nickel-Based Alloy Welding for Enhanced Fatigue Performance, DOT, 2005.
- MacGregor, J.R., Smith, S.N., van der Hoek, P., 2009, A Family of Offshore Construction Vessels, Trans RINA, 2009.
- McCann, S., Rodgers, K., 2009, Effects of Reeling on the Properties of HFI Welded Pipes, 16th Scandanavian Oil and Gas, July 2009.
- Mair, J., Rommerskircken, I., Schramm, S., Banse, J., Schuller, T., 2010, Mechanical Lined Pipe Installation by Reel Lay, DOT
2010.
- Purvis, M.K, 1946, Craft and Cable Ships for Operation PLUTO, Trans INA (RINA) Volume 88, 1946.
- Smith, S.N., MacGregor, J.R, 2006, Deepwater Pipelay and Construction Vessel, 2nd World Marine Technology Conference, I Mar
EST, London, 2006.
- Smith, S.N., MacGregor, J.R, Rice, B.G.M, & Currie, N.I., 2009 Developing a Deepwater Construction and Pipelay Fleet, Floating
Structures Conference, Glasgow, 2009.
- Tanscheit, P., Sriskandarajah, T., Xavier, M., Solano, R., Braga, V., OMAE 79636, 2009, PDEG-B Overall Design and Installation
Challenges.