Tracer Methodology: Frontline Strategies To Prepare For JCI Survey
Tracer Methodology: Frontline Strategies To Prepare For JCI Survey
Tracer Methodology: Frontline Strategies To Prepare For JCI Survey
Tracers are also the foundation of JCI on-site surveys, and can influence care in a multitude
of ways at JCI-surveyed hospitals. They are also components of some nations healthcare
regulations and other agencies requirements.
The issues outlined in Figure 1.2 also apply to JCI-accredited hospitals. Overall the improve-
ments have been well received. However, it is important to fully understand the importance
of several of these issues, and fully understand how they relate to tracer activities. One of
the processes to which I refer is the priority focus process (PFP).
Though the process has started, it is still in its nascent stage and much training for the
organizational staff is still necessary.
Challenges
Figure 1.2
Surveyor inconsistency in interpretation of standards is still troublesome.
Departments that are not surveyed often feel left out of the process.
Results of the survey are not negotiable with the surveyors. You have to wait for your survey
results to be submitted by the surveyors and then complete a clarification request.
It can be difficult to determine whether youve passed or failed the survey until you receive the
final word from the JCI
Focus areas selected by the JCI may not appear to be related to the organization
Maintaining continuous survey readiness must be balanced with major projects, such as new
construction, installation of electronic medical records, initiation of new services, etc.
5
Tr acer Met hodol ogy: An Evol ut i on
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
Focus areas
Priority focus areas (PFA) are not followed strictly by many surveyors internationally, but the
priority focus process is definitely a good practice and a baseline to prepare your organization
for the survey. Most of the time, though, focus areas are decided based only on the application
form or competencies of the surveyors (for example, a nurse might be more interested in an
infection control tracer, while an administrator will look more into facility issues).
Assess your organizations presurvey data (if you are going in for re-accreditation or for focus
surveys). Are there areas that you know require improvement?
Determining your focus areas is an integral part of tracer methodology. The JCI defines focus
areas as processes, systems, or structures in a hospital that significantly affect quality and
safety of care. Focus areas guide standards compliance assessment in relation to the patient/
resident/client tracer activities.
The JCI will identify focus areas specifically for your organization and then use them to select
patient tracers. Surveyors tracer findings provide focus for additional tracers and influence the
selection of others. Therefore, predicting your focus areas is a good first step in determining
which patients to select for your mock patient tracers. Mock tracers are discussed in more
detail in Chapter 4.
When determining whom and what to trace, JCI surveyors also consider your organizations spe-
cific patient populations and the services that you provide. These are called clinical service
groups. These groups are program-specific and defined as categories of patients or services for
which data are collected. These groups are derived from your accreditation application (for
example, from the top five diagnoses and top five surgeries) and other data used to select focus
areas. This aids in consistency with the surveyors selection for tracer activities.
Dont wait for the JCI to look at these areas for you: Use the following questions to help guide
your selection:
Has your hospital been cited for issues in a given area? If so, then you should select that area.
If comparable hospitals in your area or in your healthcare system have recently been
surveyed, what tracers did the surveyors conduct at those facilities?
What are the JCIs hot topics for survey? Depending on your region, these might include:
1.
2.
3.
6
Chapt er 1
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
Patient safety
Communication
Credentialed practitioners
Staffing
Patient safety would be a logical choice because the International Patient Safety Goals (IPSGs)
are a primary focus of the JCI. Other focus areas may be based on previous survey findings or
external data sources and outcomes monitoring efforts. Keep an eye on the JCI Web site,
national healthcare reports, and news from other local hospitals to help you determine addi-
tional areas on which to concentrate. For example, if you know that the JCI is focusing on pain
assessment, then the Assessment of Patients (AOP) standards are another good choice for
tracer selection.
Lets look at some of these focus area criteria more closely.
Outcomes data
To determine your organizations priority focus areas, the JCI uses several types of outcomes
data. With each of these data sources, look for spikes or outliers in data information. Also
pay close attention to trends in data over time (e.g., increased lengths of stay for particular
diagnoses or patient populations, readmission rates, and less-than-desirable outcomes of
patient care).
Using a rules-based system, the JCI evaluates the following organizational information:
Accreditation application information
Quality indicators shown to surveyors
Complaints received by the JCI Quality Monitoring System (QMS)
Lab proficiency testing failures
It is critical to monitor following outcomes on an ongoing basis to determine potential system-
and patient-tracer focus areas:
Hospital demographics
Admission rates
7
Tr acer Met hodol ogy: An Evol ut i on
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
Readmission rates
Observation status
Average daily census
Volumes
Complication rates
Lengths of stay
Infection rates
Medication error rates
Incident reporting
Inpatient days
Most countries do not have an advanced public reporting system as in the United States, so
surveyors will look at any data that are available as per the standards of that particular country
or state.
The type of information that might interest them depends on:
The hospitals use of computerized drug-order entry
Intensive care unit staffing ratios
Volume
Outcomes ratings for high-risk procedures, or conditions such as
coronary artery bypass graft
percutaneous coronary intervention
abdominal aortic aneurysm repair
esophagectomy
8
Chapt er 1
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
pancreatic resection
high-risk deliveries and neonatal ICU admissions
Even the report cards developed by organizations as a part of their quality improvement and
patient safety plans can serve as data points to determine the tracer activities.
Using focus areas in the survey process
Before the surveyors arrive at your organization, they will already have access to your applica-
tion and they will have gone to your Web site. If its a re-accreditation process, they also will
have looked into your previous areas of noncompliance.
Just after the opening conference of the survey, the surveyors might discuss focus areas with
your organization. They might confirm with your organization that the focus areas are used
To convert presurvey data into focused organizational information
To aid in determining the survey activities
In tracer selection criteria during the initial stages of the survey
To improve consistency in survey activities for organizations with similar pre-survey data
To individualize the survey activities to suit the needs of each organization
Once tracer patients are selected, your focus areas will initially drive the surveyors assessment
activity. Questions directed at leadership and staff will center around the focus areas. As the
survey progresses, the surveyors may be satisfied that the focus areas identified are no longer
problematic or they may confirm that the focus areas are true issues for your organization.
In addition to focus areas, understand how the JCI scores elements of performance and, subse-
quently, standards based on findings from tracer activities. During the tracer activity, surveyors
will evaluate all of the priority areas without letting you know about them.
9
Tr acer Met hodol ogy: An Evol ut i on
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
Scoring guidelines
One of the most challenging aspects of the entire survey process is not really knowing how you
are doing on your survey. Sometimes, surveyors will respond as if you are doing well with the
survey or they may state that some of their findings might turn out to be insignificant. But when
the surveyors compile their findings, you could end up with multiple noncompliances that you
did not anticipate.
The best way to combat this confusion is to have a good grasp of the scoring guidelines. Use
this information to aid you with mock tracer assessments and PPR requirements.
To understand the approach to scoring, first understand how the standards are formatted.
Each standard has the following three basic components:
The standard itself, which is a statement of the objective.
The intent, which explains why this is a reasonable objective.
The measurable elements, a list of the elements that the organization must demonstrate
to be deemed in compliance.
A hospital is accredited when it demonstrates:
Acceptable level of compliance with each JCI standard (i.e., a score of at least 5 on
each standard);
Acceptable level of compliance with standards in each chapter (i.e., an aggregate score
of at least 7 for each chapter);
Overall acceptable level of compliance (i.e., aggregate score of at least 8.5 on all
standards; and
Acceptable level of compliance with all IPSGs (i.e., a score of at least 5 on all goal
requirements).
10
Chapt er 1
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
A hospital is denied accreditation when it is consistently not in compliance with JCI standards
and IPSGs, including:
One or more standards with a score of less than a 5;
An aggregate score of less than a 7 for each chapter;
An aggregate score of less than an 8.5 on all standards;
One or more requirements for IPSG scored at 0;
A follow-up focused survey does not result in acceptable compliance with the applicable
standards and/or IPSG requirements;
When the JCI withdraws accreditation for other reasons; or
When the facility voluntarily withdraws from the accreditation process.
Hospitals must demonstrate acceptable compliance with all standards and achieve a minimal
numerical score on these standards in order to be accredited by the JCI. Above this basic level
of standards compliance, the organizations numerical score indicates the overall standards
achievement level.
All of the JCI standards are evaluated during the course of tracer activities. Therefore, it is rec-
ommended that hospitals conduct mock tracerstracers that simulate a JCI visitto assess
their levels of compliance before the surveyors arrive, and throughout the year. See Figure 1.3
for a tracer-patient selection worksheet
11
Tr acer Met hodol ogy: An Evol ut i on
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
Sample Tracer-Patient Selection Worksheet
Figure 1.3
1. Identify your focus areas using previous tracer results or other informationwhat indicators have been
identified as opportunities for improvement?
Key measure: ____________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
Patient experience survey: ___________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
Previous survey results: What were the issues?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
2. Critical areas to survey: Use findings from the above to identify areas of opportunity for improvement.
Underline the areas that apply.
Assessment and care Communication
Credentialed practitioners Equipment use
Infection control Information management
Medication management Organizational structure
Orientation and training Physical environment
Rights and ethics Quality improvement activity
Patient safety Staffing
3. Identify clinical service group tracer information within the hospital (e.g., pulmonary, cardiovascular,
rehabilitative, emergency services, etc.).
a. ____________________________ i. _____________________________
b. ____________________________ j. _____________________________
c. ____________________________ k. _____________________________
d. ____________________________ l. _____________________________
e. ____________________________ m. ____________________________
f. ____________________________ n. ____________________________
g. ____________________________ o. ____________________________
h. ____________________________ p. ____________________________
12
Chapt er 1
Tracer Methodology, Global Edition
To make sure your mock tracers are accurate, it is recommended that you score your mock tracer
and periodic performance review assessments more toward noncompliant or partially compli-
ant, instead of giving your organization full credit. In addition, during hospital self-assessment
activities, staff members can present evidence of standards compliance to the organizations
accreditation committee when they are unsure about a borderline compliance issue.
When in doubt, lean toward partial compliance or noncompliance, which leaves plenty of room
for improvement and ensures follow-up on identified issues. The bottom line is to be harder on
your organization than you think the surveyors will be.
The next step is to apply the scoring guidelines to your mock tracer activities, the various types
of tracers, and other survey activities.
Sample Tracer-Patient Selection Worksheet (cont.)
Figure 1.3
4. Obtain an active patient list (including patient name, room number, diagnosis, and physician) and the daily
surgical/special procedures schedule.
On average, select four to six tracer patients per 50 beds.
To download customizable versions of this gure and others from the book, please go to
www.hcpro.com/global and click on Tools.