PNS 8
PNS 8
PNS 8
DOI: 10.9738/INTSURG-D-15-00198.1
Department of Colon and Rectum/General Surgery, Ankara Numune Training and Research Hospital,
Ankara, Turkey
In the current prospective study, we compared the results of the Karydakis flap procedure
(KFP) and primary closure (PC). This study compared the short and long-term results of
the KFP and PC techniques. The sample of this study was a total of 352 patients (302
male: 85.7%; median age: 24 years) who underwent reconstruction after pilonidal sinus
excision in our clinic. The reconstruction was performed using the KFP (group 1, n ¼ 176,
50%) or PC (group 2, n ¼ 176, 50%). The following data on the patients was obtained; sex,
age, body mass index (BMI), duration of operation and hospital stay, length of time
patient could walk without pain, length of time patients could sit on toilet without pain,
complications (e.g., infection, recurrence). No significant difference was found between
groups 1 and 2 with respect to sex, age, BMI, and duration of operation. Moreover, length
of time patients could walk and sit on toilet without pain was similar in both groups. On
the other hand, the rate of recurrence was significantly lower in group 1 (n ¼ 4, 2%)
compared with group 2 (n ¼ 20, 11%, P , 0.001). KFP is preferable to PC since it is easier to
learn and perform and has lower complication and recurrence rates.
Corresponding author: Bülent C. Yüksel, MD, Ankara Numune Training and Research Hospital, General Surgery, Sıhhıye, 06680,
Ankara, Turkey.
Tel.: þ90 532 6342056; Fax: þ 90 312 418 27 60; E-mail: bulentcyuksel@yahoo.com.tr
wound. This allowed the flap to reach the contra- After their discharge, patients were instructed to
lateral side without tension. A layer of interrupted pay meticulous attention to hygiene rules and not to
absorbable Vicryl 0/0 sutures (Ethicon Endo-Sur- sit or be in a semi-sitting position for 2 weeks.
gery, Cincinnati, Ohio) were used to suture the Walking was not restricted. In addition, the follow-
deepest tissue of the flap to the underlying fascia ing recommendations were made: to use talc
and the corresponding tissue on the fixed side. powder to prevent moisture, then after complete
Then, the subcutaneous tissue was sutured directly healing to use depilatory cream for 6 months to
to the lateral edge of the tissue. Finally, interrupted remove hairs from the operation site, to avoid
vertical polypropylene mattress 2/0 sutures (Ethi- prolonged sitting and not to ride a horse or bicycle
con Endo-Surgery) were used for skin closure (Fig. for 6 weeks after the operation. Sutures were
1c). removed on postoperative day 14, and the patients
Excision and PC was performed as described by were allowed to return to work by postoperative
Soligher.12 The sinus tract was totally excised up to day 21.
the presacral fascia via a symmetric elliptic incision
in the midline, and a layer of interrupted absorbable Data collection and outcome measures
Vicryl 0/0 sutures (Ethicon Endo-Surgery) were
used to suture the deepest tissue. Finally, skin Data on sex, age, and body mass index (BMI, kg/
closure was undertaken using interrupted vertical m2), as well as history of previous treatment (when
polypropylene mattress 2/0 sutures (Ethicon Endo- applicable), was obtained from all patients.
Surgery). Duration of operation was defined as the time
A closed suction drain was placed in the resultant from the start of skin incision to the end of the last
dead space and sufficiently extended laterally stitch. Duration of hospital stay was noted. Postop-
through a separate stab incision. The suction drain erative complications such as seroma, wound
was removed when the effluent was less than 20 mL dehiscence, and wound infection were noted. A
for 24 hours. postoperative wound assessment was undertaken
using the asepsis method, in which an overall value , 0.05 was considered significant. Values were
above 20 indicated that the wound was infected.13 expressed as median (range).
All patients were physically examined on post-
operative days 3 and 14 for wound inspection after Results
surgery. Patients were invited to the hospital for a
short follow-up 3 months after surgery. They were A flow diagram of patient disposition is shown in
asked about the length of time they could sit on Fig. 2. Of the 377 patients screened, 15 did not meet
toilet without pain and length of time they could the inclusion criteria, and 10 refused to participate
walk without pain. The responses were documented in the study. As a result, a total of 352 patients
including 302 men (85.7%) and 50 women (14.2%)
and analyzed. The long-term follow-up after 3
were randomly allocated to 2 treatment groups.
months was performed either by interviewing the
Patient age ranged from 13 to 59 years with a
patients every 3 months on the phone or in person at
median of 24 years.
the outpatient clinic to check for recurrences. Table 1 presents the patient characteristics of each
Patients were followed for 12 to 96 months (median: treatment group. No significant differences were
56.8 months). observed between the groups regarding age, sex
distribution, BMI, and history of recurrent disease.
Statistical analyses As shown in Table 2, the difference in operative
time and length of time patients could walk and sit
Power calculations were performed to test the
hypotheses related to the comparison between the Table 1 Patient demographics and operation features
treatment groups. The sample sizes of the KFP (n ¼
KFP PC
170) and PC groups (n ¼ 171) required a power of
(n ¼ 170) (n ¼ 171) P value
approximately .0.80 to compare the 2 groups.
Statistical analysis was carried out using statistical Sex, n (%)
Male 147 (86 ) 149 (87) 0.6
software (SPSS, version 18, IBM-SPSS, Chicago,
Female 23 (14) 22 (13)
Illinois). The Mann-Whitney U test and Student’s Age, y, median (range) 25 (15–56) 24 (13–59) 0.2
t-test were used to compare 2 groups in terms of the BMI, kg/m2, median (range) 24 (22–28) 24 (22–27) 0.1
continuous variables; and the v2 and Fisher’s exact Recurrent disease, n (%) 29 (17) 27 (15) 0.62
test were used for categorical variables. A value of P P values , 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Table 2 Analysis postoperative period for PSD in KFP versus PC groups in terms of subcutaneous fluid collection
KFP PC
(Table 2).
(n ¼ 170) (n ¼ 171) P value There was no statistically significant difference
between the groups in the length of time patients
Duration of operation, could walk and sit on the toilet without pain.
min, median (range) 31 (25–35) 26 (22–31) 0.32
Time to walk without pain,
However, a statistically significant difference was
d, median (range) 7 (5–9) 7 (5–10) 0.87 observed in terms of number of complications (P ,
Time to sitting on toilet 0.05). The clinical outcomes of both group treatment
ischemia as well as other less desirable esthetic One of the important points in the management
outcomes.2,4,15 of PSD is the time to return to normal daily activity.
PSD is a disease frequently affecting those of a Ertan et al20 compared the Limberg flap procedure
younger age with a high rate of morbidity, which with PC with respect to sitting on a toilet without
results in extended absence from work. It is a pain, and concluded that flap procedures are more
chronic inflammatory process of the skin caused by beneficial.20 In our study, patients were asked how
hair, keratin plugs, and debris.16 It is known that the long they could sit on a toilet and walk without
PSD incidence varies across countries and races. The pain. No statistically significant difference was
and follow-up period were found to have no 12. Soligher JC. Surgery of Anus, Rectum and Colon. 5th ed. London:
significant impact on recurrence. Wound infection Bailliere Tindal; 1984:256–276
was observed more in the PC group than in the KFP 13. Akin T, Akin M, Topaloglu S Berkem H, Yüksel B, Hengirmen
group, but this effect was not significant. S et al. External validation of SENİC and NNIS scores for
In conclusion, this study has shown that KFP has predicting wound infection in colorectal surgery. Surgical
several advantages and is superior to the PC method Science 2011;2(2):73–76
in the treatment of PSD. The closure of the excised 14. Singh R, Pavithran NM. Adipo-fascio-cutaneous flaps in the
area with a tension-free, off-midline, and well- treatment of pilonidal sinus. Experience with 50 cases. Asian J