Volkov 2008 J. Phys. Condens. Matter 20 055217
Volkov 2008 J. Phys. Condens. Matter 20 055217
Volkov 2008 J. Phys. Condens. Matter 20 055217
E-mail: volk@iph.krasn.ru
Abstract
A Pb3 Mn7 O15 single crystal has been grown by the flux method and studied using x-ray
diffraction and magnetization measurements. The crystal is hexagonal ( P 63 /mcm space group,
Z = 4) and exhibits a pronounced layered nature. Along the [001] direction (c axis), the
structure consists of layers of edge-sharing MnO6 octahedra. Pairs of Mn atoms occupy the
octahedral sites located between layers forming ‘bridges’ along the c axis, which link
neighboring Mn layers. The magnetic properties of the crystal have been investigated using ac
and dc magnetization measurements in the temperature range 2–900 K at magnetic fields up to
90 kOe. The experimental data obtained suggest that in the temperature region under study
several different magnetic phases can be distinguished. Down to ∼250 K, the crystal is in the
paramagnetic state. Below this temperature, short-range antiferromagnetic ordering apparently
starts forming within Mn layers, although a transition to long-range magnetic order occurs at
70 K. The magnetization data obtained leads us to conclude that this state is canted
antiferromagnetic with moments lying in the basal plane of the crystal. In addition, below 20 K
the crystal undergoes one more magnetic transition that corresponds to spin reorientation.
coexistence of Mn ions in different oxidation states is one of compounds and allowing to avoid incorporation of foreign ions
the possible reasons for direct correlation between the FM state into a lattice. Synthesis of the Pb3 Mn7 O15 crystals started with
and conductivity in perovskite-like manganites. heating of a mixture of appropriate amounts of high purity
The variety of physical properties (with clear under- PbO and Mn2 O3 in a platinum crucible at 1000 ◦ C for 4 h.
standing of many phenomena being still lacking) observed Then the crucible was slowly cooled to 900 ◦ C with a rate
in doped perovskite-like manganites excites active search and V = 2–5 ◦ C h−1 and, finally, a furnace was cooled to room
study of other families of mixed-valence Mn oxides, which temperature. The single crystals of a plate–hexagonal form
do not possess of a perovskite structure. In particular, re- with black shiny surfaces were found at a level of a solidified
cently layered manganites of the Ruddlesden–Popper series liquid surface. The plates were up to 40 mm in ‘diameter’.
(E1−y R y )n+1 Mnn O3n+1 and RMn2 O5 compounds (R is the rare The grown crystals were extracted mechanically from the flux.
earth ion, either Y or Bi) have been intensively studied. The All the measurements reported here were performed on well-
former includes phases revealing the CMR phenomenon [6], polished plate-like samples with a required dimension cut from
whereas the latter exhibits strong correlation between the mag- the resulting single-crystal plates. The samples were oriented
netic and dielectric properties [7]. We paid attention to the Pb– by the back-Laue method.
Mn–O system, which includes a number of phases with com-
positions suggesting the mixed-valence state of Mn cations. 2.2. Experimental measurements
Some compounds belonging to this system were already de-
scribed [8], yet not thoroughly characterized and studied. Up Single-crystal x-ray patterns were collected using a SMART
to date, the available information on the electronic and mag- APEX autodiffractometer (Bruker AXS). These data were
netic properties of the mixed-valence Pb3 Mn7 O15 is insuffi- obtained with a purpose of refining a crystallographic structure
cient. Besides, the results of x-ray study presented by dif- at room temperature.
ferent authors are contradictory. Some authors described the The magnetic properties of the crystal were investigated
Pb3 Mn7 O15 structure in terms of an orthorhombic space group; using ac and dc magnetization measurements performed with
others indicated that the crystal belongs to the hexagonal space a physical property measurement system (PPMS, Quantum
group [9–12]. We should also notice a number of works de- Design) in the temperature range from 2 to 350 K at magnetic
voted to characterization of a crystal with the chemical formula fields up to 90 kOe. High-temperature (up to 900 K)
referred to as Pb3 Mn6 O13 [13]. Similarity of x-ray and mag- measurements of magnetic susceptibility were performed with
netic measurement data obtained by different authors suggests a vibrating sample magnetometer of our original construction.
that the material under study does belong to the Pb3 Mn7 O15
composition. However, the mentioned investigations had rather 3. Results
an incomplete character, so the authors could hardly draw more
or less definite conclusion about a crystal structure and mag- 3.1. Crystal structure
netic state. Nevertheless, we paid attention to study of the di-
electric properties, which suggested arising of the ferroelectric Structure of the Pb3 Mn7 O15 crystal was refined using the
(FE) or anti-FE state. This fact appeared not so surprising, single-crystal x-ray data collected at room temperature. All
considering the so-called stereoactivity of Pb2+ ions [14] that the reflections were indexed in the hexagonal space group
facilitates the creation of local dipoles and, thus, the forma- P 63 /mcm with lattice parameters a = 10.0287(4) Å and
tion of FE or anti-FE fashion. Possible correlation between c = 13.6137(6) Å. The atomic positions, selected bond
the magnetic and dielectric properties has been another reason distances, and bond angles are listed in tables 1–3, respectively.
stimulated the detailed study of Pb3 Mn7 O15 . There are four formula units per unit cell. It should be
In this paper, we present and discuss the results noted that the crystal structure of Pb3 Mn7 O15 we found
of thorough investigations of the unique structural and coincides with that of mineral Pb3 (Fe, Mn)4 Mn3 O15 known
intriguing magnetic properties of the Pb3 Mn7 O15 single as zenzenite [12], with just minor distinctions in lattice
crystal. Crystallographic structure of the compound has been parameters, bonding distances and angles, related apparently
refined using the single-crystal x-ray diffraction data. Possible to the presence of Fe ions in the mineral.
magnetic structure has been clarified through analyzing the In figure 1, a crystallographic structure of the compound
data of ac/dc magnetization measurements and calculations of is schematically presented. Mn cations occupy four
Mn–O–Mn interactions made in the framework of an indirect crystallographically nonequivalent positions (Mn1, Mn2, Mn3,
coupling model. We hope that our results and conclusions and Mn4), each of them being coordinated by six oxygen
would be of interest for researchers who study the compounds atoms in octahedral configuration. A unit cell includes
exhibiting mixed valence of manganese ions and develop twelve Mn1 sites (12i) located within slightly compressed
models of magnetic interactions in manganese oxides. oxygen octahedra, eight Mn2 sites (8h) located within trigonal
distorted octahedra, two Mn3 sites (2b) coordinated by oxygen
atoms in a regular octahedral configuration, and six Mn4
2. Experimental details sites (6f) having tetragonal oblate octahedra in environment.
Crystallographic structure of Pb3 Mn7 O15 has a pronounced
2.1. Sample preparation
layered nature. Along the [001] direction (c axis), the structure
Single crystals were grown by the flux method. As a flux, consists of layers of edge-sharing MnO6 octahedra (Mn1,
PbO was chosen, known as an effective solvent for many oxide Mn3, and Mn4 positions). Pairs of Mn2 atoms occupy the
2
J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 20 (2008) 055217 N V Volkov et al
Atom Site x y z 2 2
Table 2. Selected Mn–O bond lengths for Pb3 Mn7 O15 (the left
column) and zenzenite [12] (the right column). c
3
J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 20 (2008) 055217 N V Volkov et al
2.8
T2
8 T3
T1
80000
-4
60000
χ'ac (10 emu/g)
6 2.4
θp=-520 K
1/χ
0 100 200 300
-4
Temperature (K)
40000
4
T3 T1
20000 T~250 K
2 0
-500 -250 0 250 500 750
Temperature (K) Temperature (K)
Figure 2. Real part of ac magnetic susceptibility χac as a function of Figure 3. Reciprocal magnetic susceptibility versus temperature
temperature measured at a frequency f = 1 kHz and ac field ( H = 0.5 kOe). The solid line is a fit to the Curie–Weiss law.
amplitude of 10 Oe without dc bias field. Inset: the same curve in an
extended scale.
4
J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 20 (2008) 055217 N V Volkov et al
-2
Magnetization (emu/g)
65
Magnetization (emu/g)
1.2
75
T2 1.1
100 150 200 250
Temperature (K)
[100] ZFC
[100] FC H II [100]
T1 [001] FC
H=500 Oe
b 65
Temperature (K)
75
Magnetization (emu/g)
Figure 4. Dc magnetization versus temperature for different
directions of magnetic field relative to a crystallographic axis in 4.2
Pb3 Mn7 O15 under the zero-field-cooled (ZFC) and field-cooled (FC)
conditions ( H = 0.5 kOe). Inset: the same curves in an extended
scale.
5
J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 20 (2008) 055217 N V Volkov et al
The appearance of hysteresis loops characterized by high 4:3. Data of magnetic measurements suggest that several dif-
coercive fields up to 20 kOe at a temperature of 4.2 K ferent magnetic phases can be distinguished over the studied
is actually unexpected. It is well known that the high temperature region. The paramagnetic behavior is observed at
coercivity may arise due to relatively large concentration temperatures down to ∼250 K. On further cooling, short-range
of defects that hinder motion of magnetic walls or very correlations occur in the system and extensive antiferromag-
high magnetocrystalline anisotropy of a sample in the single- netic clusters start forming at ∼160 K. At 70 K the long-range
domain state. High intrinsic magnetic anisotropy seems magnetic order is established, and low spontaneous magnetiza-
fairly a probable reason for the observed high coercivity tion is observed in all the ordered regions. At ∼20 K one more
in Pb3 Mn7 O15 . Indeed, large magnetocrystalline anisotropy magnetic transition occurs in the crystals, which can be related
with an easy axis occurring in a uniaxial crystal system to reorientation of a magnetic moment.
(Pb3 Mn7 O15 belongs to this type of symmetry) may lead
to the high coercivity because the sample cannot become Acknowledgments
demagnetized without rotating magnetization towards a hard
direction. Meanwhile, for the crystal under investigation We are grateful to Professor Victor Zinenko (Kirensky Institute
hysteresis loops are observed only at magnetization lying in of Physics SB RAS) for useful discussion. This study
the basal plane, although, relative to rotation of the magnetic was supported by the INTAS (Project No. 06-1000013-
moments in this plane, magnetic anisotropy should not be 9002) and the Program ‘Spin-dependent Effects in Solids and
high for a hexagonal antiferromagnetic in the easy plane state. Spintronics’ of the Division of Physical Sciences of RAS
Actually, in terms of the thermodynamic approach, the in- (Project No. 2.4.2 SB RAS). NV also thanks the Foundation
plane anisotropy is determined by the sixth order invariants on for Support of Russian Science.
components of the antiferromagnetism vector.
We can expect arising of domains with noncollinear References
antiferromagnetism vectors in the basal plane of the crystal,
since there are several equivalent antiferromagnetic axes [1] Kim K H, Uehara M, Kiryukhin V and Cheong S W 2004
in this plane. When magnetic field is applied along the Colossal Magnetoresistive Manganites
ed T Chatterji (Dordrecht: Kluwer–Academic)
sixfold axis, domains have equal energies, and the field
[2] Rodriguez-Martinez L M and Attfield J P 1996 Phys. Rev. B
does not cause a displacement of interdomain walls. In 54 R15622
this case, the magnetization process takes place, as if an [3] Dagotto E, Burgy J and Moreo A 2003 Solid State Commun.
antiferromagnetic is in the single-domain state. Indeed, the 126 9
experimental dependences of magnetization do not reveal [4] Dagotto E, Hotta T and Moreo A 2001 Phys. Rep. 344 1
[5] Argyriou D N and Ling C D 2004 Colossal Magnetoresistive
any peculiarities that would indicate rearrangement of the
Manganites ed T Chatterji (Dordrecht: Kluwer–Academic)
domain structure. However, when magnetic field is applied [6] Chatterji T, Jackeli G and Shannon N 2004 Colossal
in the basal plane, domains are energetically nonequivalent, Magnetoresistive Manganites ed T Chatterji (Dordrecht:
and the field exerts a pressure on interdomain walls causing Kluwer–Academic)
their displacement. Irreversible displacement gives rise to [7] Higashiyama D, Miyasaka S, Kida N, Arima T and
Tokura Y 2004 Phys. Rev. B 70 174405
magnetic hysteresis. Now we can make no conclusion
[8] Latourrette B, Devalette M, Guillen F and Fouassier C 1978
about the nature of possible anisotropic centers that determine Mater. Res. Bull. 13 567
the displacement of interdomain walls, since unambiguous [9] Darriet B, Devalette M and Latourrette B 1978 Acta
explanation of the observed phenomena certainly requires a Crystallogr. B 34 3528
detailed micromagnetic study. [10] Marsh R E and Herbstein F H 1983 Acta Crystallogr. B 39 280
[11] Le Page Y and Calvert L D 1984 Acta Crystallogr. C 40 1787
[12] Holtstam D, Lindqvist B, Johnsson M and Norrestam R 1991
5. Conclusion Can. Mineral. 29 347
[13] Bush A A, Titov A V, Al’shin B I and Venevtsev Yu N 1977
The Pb3 Mn7 O15 single crystal was synthesized; its crystal Russ. J. Inorg. Chem. 22 1211
structure and magnetic properties were investigated. Crystallo- [14] Moore P B, Sen Gupta P K and Le Page Y 1989
Am. Mineral. 74 1186
graphic structure of Pb3 Mn7 O15 possesses of hexagonal sym- [15] Levy L P 2000 Magnetism and Superconductivity
metry and has pronounced layered nature. The crystal contains (Berlin: Springer) chapter 2, p 56
Mn ions in two oxidation states Mn3+ and Mn4+ in a ratio [16] Brown I D and Altermatt D 1985 Acta Crystallogr. B 41 244