Problem Set 9
Problem Set 9
Problem Set 9
due on Sunday at 6 PM
Important: if you have any doubts about the exercises, please post a question on Piazza.
Learning outcomes:
- Intertemporal consumption decisions with imperfect credit markets
- Investment decisions
a) Derive the intertemporal budget constraint for Donald, and the collateral constraint that
he faces. Draw it in a diagram with current consumption on the horizontal axis, and
future consumption on the vertical axis. Explain.
b) What would be the optimal choice for Donald? Illustrate it using a diagram and explain
your reasoning.
c) The IRS, which is the agency in charge of collecting taxes, discovers that Donald owes
some unpaid taxes to the government. Donald has to pay t=0.5 in the first period, and
'
t =0.5 in the second period. How does the intertemporal budget constraint, the collateral
constraint and the optimal choice for Donald change?
d) Donald tries to strike a deal with the IRS: in the first period, Donald will give the
government his second flat in New York (the one with size H 2) instead of paying the
taxes due in the current and future period. How would this deal change the intertemporal
budget constraint and the collateral constraint for Donald with respect to question c? How
would his optimal choice of current and future consumption change?
e) Calculate the minimum size H 2 that the second flat must have for the IRS to accept this
deal. Explain the intuition.
f) Calculate a condition that H 2 must satisfy so that Donald is better off by striking the deal
than by paying taxes. Explain the intuition. [Hint: you need to establish if Donald can
reach a higher indifference curve with the deal, and remember that the indifference curve
is given by u=ac+ c ' ]
g) Based on your answers to questions e and f, will there be a deal? Explain why or why not.
h) How would your answer to question g change if the price of the second flat were still
p2=1, but the price of the first flat increased to p1 >1?
The US government in 2017 reduced the corporate tax rate from 34% to 21%.
a) Assume the user cost of capital before the tax cut was 12%. What the user cost will be
after the tax cut?
b) Will the investment rate increase? Assume the investment rate was 20% before the tax
cut.