MASTER Publications Catalog March 2023 PDF
MASTER Publications Catalog March 2023 PDF
MASTER Publications Catalog March 2023 PDF
March 2023
Table of Contents
Index of AGMA Current Standards and Information Sheets ...................................................................... 1
Index of AGMA Standards and Information Sheets by Topic .................................................................... 5
Aerospace ......................................................................................................................................... 5
Calibration and Measurement Uncertainty ......................................................................................... 5
Couplings .......................................................................................................................................... 5
Design and Assembly – Bevel ........................................................................................................... 5
Design – Fine Pitch ........................................................................................................................... 5
Design – Spur and Helical ................................................................................................................. 5
Design – Wormgears......................................................................................................................... 5
Drive Components............................................................................................................................. 6
Enclosed Drives ................................................................................................................................ 6
Failure Modes ................................................................................................................................... 6
High Speed Units .............................................................................................................................. 6
Inspection and Tolerances................................................................................................................. 6
Lubrication ........................................................................................................................................ 6
Materials ........................................................................................................................................... 6
Metric Usage ..................................................................................................................................... 7
Mill Drives ......................................................................................................................................... 7
Nomenclature .................................................................................................................................... 7
Plastics Gears ................................................................................................................................... 7
Powder Metallurgy Gears .................................................................................................................. 7
Proportions........................................................................................................................................ 7
Rating: Spur, Helical and Bevel Gears ............................................................................................... 7
Sound and Vibration .......................................................................................................................... 8
Splines .............................................................................................................................................. 8
Style Manual ..................................................................................................................................... 8
Thermal............................................................................................................................................. 8
Vehicle .............................................................................................................................................. 8
Wind Turbine Units ............................................................................................................................ 8
Wormgears ....................................................................................................................................... 8
AGMA Standards and Information Sheets................................................................................................ 9
ISO Standards, Technical Reports, and Technical Specifications by ISO Technical Committee 60 ......... 24
Fall Technical Meeting Papers: 2000–2021............................................................................................ 27
2022 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 27
2021 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 32
2020 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 39
2019 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 43
2018 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 52
2017 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 57
2016 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 60
2015 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 63
2014 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 73
2013 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 78
2012 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 85
2011 PAPERS................................................................................................................................. 93
2010 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 102
2009 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 108
2008 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 112
2007 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 116
2006 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 121
2005 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 124
2004 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 128
2002 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 131
2001 PAPERS............................................................................................................................... 133
Index of AGMA Withdrawn Standards and Information Sheets ............................................................. 136
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Couplings
AGMA 922 Load Classification and Service Factors for Flexible Couplings
ANSI/AGMA 9000 Flexible Couplings – Potential Unbalance Classification
ANSI/AGMA 9001 Flexible Couplings – Lubrication
ANSI/AGMA 9002 Bores and Keyways for Flexible Couplings (Inch Series)
ANSI/AGMA 9003 Flexible Couplings – Keyless Fits
ANSI/AGMA 9004 Flexible Couplings – Mass Elastic Properties and Other Characteristics
ANSI/AGMA 9006 Flexible Couplings – Basis for Rating
ANSI/AGMA 9008 Flexible Couplings – Gear Type – Flange Dimensions, Inch Series
ANSI/AGMA 9009 Flexible Couplings – Nomenclature for Flexible Couplings
ANSI/AGMA 9103 Flexible Couplings – Keyless Fits (Metric Edition)
ANSI/AGMA 9104 Flexible Couplings – Mass Elastic Properties and Other Characteristics (Metric Edition)
ANSI/AGMA 9110 Flexible Couplings – Potential Unbalance Classification (Metric Edition)
ANSI/AGMA 9112 Bores and Keyways for Flexible Couplings (Metric Series)
Design – Wormgears
ANSI/AGMA 6022 Design Manual for Cylindrical Wormgearing
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Enclosed Drives
AGMA 940 Double Helical Epicyclic Gear Units
AGMA ISO 14179-1 Gear Reducers – Thermal Capacity Based on ISO/TR 14179-1
ANSI/AGMA 6013 Standard for Industrial Enclosed Gear Drives
ANSI/AGMA 6113 Standard for Industrial Enclosed Gear Drives (Metric)
ANSI/AGMA 6123 Design Manual for Enclosed Epicyclic Gear Drives (Metric)
Failure Modes
AGMA 944-A19, Mechanisms of Powder Metal, PM, Gear Failures
ANSI/AGMA 1010, Appearance of Gear Teeth – Terminology of Wear and Failure
Lubrication
AGMA 955 Guidance for Industrial Gear Lubrication
ANSI/AGMA 9005 Industrial Gear Lubrication
AGMA ISO 18792-A19 Lubrication of industrial gear drives
Materials
AGMA 920 Materials for Plastic Gears
AGMA 923 Metallurgical Specifications for Steel and Cast Iron Gearing
AGMA 938 Shot Peening of Gears
AGMA 939 Austempered Ductile Iron for Gears
ANSI/AGMA 2004 Gear Materials, Heat Treatment and Processing Manual
ANSI/AGMA 6033 Materials for Marine Propulsion Gearing
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Metric Usage
AGMA 904 Metric Usage
Mill Drives
ANSI/AGMA 6014 Gear Power Rating for Cylindrical Shell and Trunnion Supported Equipment
ANSI/AGMA 6015 Power Rating of Single and Double Helical Gearing for Rolling Mill Service
ANSI/AGMA 6114 Gear Power Rating for Cylindrical Shell and Trunnion Supported Equipment (Metric)
ANSI/AGMA 6115 Power Rating of Single and Double Helical Gearing for Rolling Mill Service (Metric Edition)
Nomenclature
AGMA 933 Basic Gear Geometry
ANSI/AGMA 1012 Gear Nomenclature, Definitions of Terms with Symbols
Plastics Gears
AGMA 905 Inspection of Molded Plastic Gears
AGMA 909 Specifications for Molded Plastic Gears
AGMA 920 Materials for Plastic Gears
AGMA 946 Test Methods for Plastic Gears
ANSI/AGMA 1006 Tooth Proportions for Plastic Gears
ANSI/AGMA 1106 Tooth Proportions for Plastic Gears
Proportions
ANSI/AGMA 1003 Tooth Proportions for Fine-Pitch Spur and Helical Gears
ANSI/AGMA 1006 Tooth Proportions for Plastic Gears
ANSI/AGMA 1103 Tooth Proportions for Fine-Pitch Spur and Helical Gears (Metric Edition)
ANSI/AGMA 1106 Tooth Proportions for Plastic Gears (Metric Edition)
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Splines
AGMA 945-1 Splines – Design and Application
AGMA 945-2 Splines – Design and Application (Inch Edition)
Style Manual
AGMA 900 Style Manual for the Preparation of Standards and Editorial Manuals
Thermal
AGMA ISO 14179-1 Gear Reducers – Thermal Capacity Based on ISO/TR 14179-1
Vehicle
ANSI/AGMA 6002 Design Guide for Vehicle Spur and Helical Gears
ANSI/AGMA 6102 Design Guide for Vehicle Spur and Helical Gears (Metric)
Wormgears
ANSI/AGMA 6034 Practice for Enclosed Cylindrical Wormgear Speed Reducers and Gearmotors
ANSI/AGMA 6035 Design, Rating and Application of Industrial Globoidal Wormgearing
ANSI/AGMA 6134 Practice for Enclosed Cylindrical Wormgear Speed Reducers and Gearmotors (Metric)
ANSI/AGMA 6135 Design, Rating and Application of Industrial Globoidal Wormgearing (Metric)
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
AGMA 900-K22 Style Manual for the Preparation of Standards, Information Sheets and Editorial Manuals
This information sheet is a compilation of the AGMA and ISO editorial style manuals. This document provides
guidelines for the way that the AGMA Brand is presented from both a graphic and language perspective in
publications of the Technical Division, specifically standards and information sheets. It is intended for use
ensuring multiple contributors create a clear and cohesive way that reflects the corporate style and ensures brand
consistency. These standards will be applied either for general use or individual publication. Revision of
AGMA 900-J20.
Pages: 34
AGMA 901-A92 A Rational Procedure for the Preliminary Design of Minimum Volume Gears
Presents a simple, closed-form procedure as a first step in the minimum volume spur and helical gearset design.
It Includes methods for selecting geometry and dimensions, considering maximum pitting resistance, bending
strength, and scuffing resistance, and methods for selecting profile shift. Reaffirmed April 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-579-4 Pages: 37
AGMA 908-B89 Geometry Factors for Determining the Pitting Resistance and Bending Strength of Spur,
Helical and Herringbone Gear Teeth
Gives the equations for calculating the pitting resistance geometry factor, I, for external and internal spur and
helical gears, and the bending strength geometry factor, J, for external spur and helical gears that are generated
by rack-type tools (hobs, rack cutters or generating grinding wheels) or pinion-type tools (shaper cutters). Includes
charts which provide geometry factors, I and J, for a range of typical gear sets and tooth forms. Reaffirmed
November 11, 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-525-5 Pages: 78
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
AGMA 913-A98 Method for Specifying the Geometry of Spur and Helical Gears
Provides information to translate tooth thickness specifications which are expressed in terms of tooth thickness,
center distance or diameter into profile shift coefficients. It describes the effect that profile shift has on the
geometry and performance of gears. Annexes are provided which contain practical examples on the calculation of
tool proportions and profile shift. Reaffirmed May 2021.
ISBN: 1-55589-714-2 Pages: 25
AGMA 914-B04, Gear Sound Manual – Part I: Fundamentals of Sound as Related to Gears; Part II: Sources,
Specifications and Levels of Gear Sound; Part III: Gear Noise Control
This information sheet discusses how noise measurement and control depend upon the individual characteristics
of the prime mover, gear unit, and driven machine, as well as their combined effects in a particular acoustical
environment. It indicates certain areas that might require special attention. This document is a revision of AGMA
299.01 to include updated references and a discussion of Fast Fourier Transform analysis. Replaces
AGMA 299.01. Reaffirmed March 15, 2018.
ISBN: 1-55589-820-3 Pages: 37
AGMA 915-2-B20 Inspection Practices – Part 2: Double Flank Radial Composite Measurements
This information sheet discusses inspection of cylindrical involute gears using the radial (double flank) composite
method, with recommended practices detailed. Also included is a clause on runout and eccentricity measurement
methods. This information sheet is a supplement to the standard ANSI/AGMA 2015-2. It replaced AGMA ISO
10064-2 and replaces double flank composite measurement section of AGMA 2000-A88.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-067-3 Pages: 52
AGMA 915-3-A99 Inspection Practices – Part 3: Gear Blanks, Shaft Center Distance and Parallelism
Provides recommended numerical values relating to the inspection of gear blanks, shaft center distance and
parallelism of shaft axes. Discussions include such topics as methods for defining datum axes on components;
the use of center holes and mounting surfaces during manufacturing and inspection; and, recommended values of
in-plane and out-of-plane deviations of shaft parallelism. Modified adoption of ISO/TR 10064-3:1996.
Reaffirmed October 2022.
ISBN: 1-55589-738-3 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
AGMA 919-1-A14 Condition Monitoring and Diagnostics of Gear Units and Open Gears: Part 1 – Basics
The new information sheet provides basic overviews of key approaches to establishing a condition monitoring and
diagnostics program for open gearing and enclosed gear units. This information sheet attempts to inform the
reader of the common techniques used and parameters measured for condition monitoring of a gear unit allowing
the reader to build a program based on individual needs. Reaffirmed March 25, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-61481-087-2 Pages: 20
AGMA 922-A96 Load Classification and Service Factors for Flexible Couplings
This Information Sheet provides load classifications and related service factors that are frequently used for various
flexible coupling applications. Typical applications using smooth prime movers and special considerations
involving unusual or more severe loading are discussed. Replaces AGMA 514.02. Reaffirmed April 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-680-4 Pages: 6
AGMA 923-C22 Metallurgical Specifications for Steel and Cast Iron Gearing
This document identifies metallurgical quality characteristics which are important to the performance of steel
gearing. The AGMA gear rating standards identify performance levels of gearing by heat treatment method and
grade number. For each heat treatment method and AGMA grade number, acceptance criteria are given for
various metallurgical characteristics identified in this document. Revision of AGMA 923-B05.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-119-9 Pages: 56
AGMA 927-A01 Load Distribution Factors – Analytical Methods for Cylindrical Gears
Describes an analytical procedure for the calculation of face load distribution factor. The iterative solution that is
described is compatible with the definitions of the term face load distribution of AGMA standards and longitudinal
load distribution of the ISO standards. The procedure is easily programmable and flow charts of the calculation
scheme, as well as examples from typical software are presented. Supplement to ANSI/AGMA 2001-D04.
Reaffirmed January 30, 2018.
ISBN: 1-55589-779-7 Pages: 31
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
AGMA 930-A05 Calculated Bending Load Capacity of Powder Metallurgy (P/M) External Spur Gears
This information sheet describes a procedure for calculating the load capacity of a pair of powder metallurgy
external spur gears based on tooth bending strength. Two types of loading are considered: 1) repeated loading
over many cycles; and 2) occasional peak loading. It also describes an essentially reverse procedure for
establishing an initial design from specified applied loads. As part of the load capacity calculations, there is a
detailed analysis of the gear teeth geometry, including tooth profiles and various fillets. Reaffirmed August 2022.
ISBN: 1-55589-845-9 Pages: 78
AGMA 932-A05 Rating the Pitting Resistance and Bending Strength of Hypoid Gears
This information sheet provides a method by which different hypoid gear designs can be compared. The formulas
are intended to establish a uniformly acceptable method for calculating the pitting resistance and bending strength
capacity of both curved and skewed tooth hypoid gears. They apply equally to tapered depth and uniform depth
teeth. Annexes contain graphs for geometry factors and a sample calculation to assist the user. Supplement to
ANSI/AGMA 2003-B97. Reaffirmed February 3, 2011.
ISBN: 1-55589-869-6 Pages: 18
AGMA 935-A05 Recommendations Relative to the Evaluation of Radial Composite Gear Double Flank Testers
The condition and alignment of gear measuring instruments can greatly influence the measurement of product
gears. This information sheet provides qualification procedures for double flank testers that are used for the
evaluation of radial composite deviations of gears. It discusses guidelines for alignment of double flank tester
elements such as centers, ways, probe systems, etc. It also covers the application of artifacts to determine
instrument accuracy. Supplement to standard ANSI/AGMA 2116-A05. Reaffirmed April 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-872-6 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
AGMA 942-A12 Metallurgical Specifications for Powder Metallurgy, PM, Steel Gearing
This information sheet recommends powder metallurgy, PM, steel materials and metallurgical quality
characteristics for use in specifying PM gearing. It identifies specifications and requirements for various PM steel
materials for as-sintered, through hardened or sinter hardened, carburized case hardened, and induction
hardened gearing. Requirements are coded by process and class number, the latter based on the density of the
PM gear teeth. Characteristics covered include material composition, density, sinter processing (conventional,
high temperature and sinter hardening), secondary heat treatments and post heat treatment processing, and their
associated inspections. Reaffirmed August 2022.
ISBN: 1-61481-031-5 Pages: 17
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
AGMA ISO 10064-5-A06 Code of Inspection Practice – Part 5: Recommendations Relative to Evaluation of
Gear Measuring Instruments
This information sheet provides methods and examples to support the implementation of ANSI/AGMA ISO 18653-
A06. It includes evaluation and calibration procedures for involute, helix, runout, and tooth thickness measurement
processes. Methods are given for the evaluation of condition and alignment of instrument elements such as
centers, guideways, probe systems, etc. Recommendations include statistical data evaluation procedures.
Guidance is given on the application of measurement processes to the inspection of product gears, including
fitness for use and the recommended limits of U95 uncertainty based on the accuracy tolerances of product gears
to be inspected. Many of its recommendations could be applied to the measurement of worms, worm wheels,
bevel gears and gear cutting tools. Replaces AGMA 931-A02. Reaffirmed November 1, 2012.
ISBN: 1-55589-881-5 Pages: 62
AGMA ISO 10064-6-A10 Code of Inspection Practice – Part 6: Bevel Gear Measurement Methods
This document provides information on measuring methods and practices of unassembled bevel and hypoid gears
and gear pairs. Tolerances are provided in ISO 17485:2006, for calculating the maximum values allowed by the
specific tolerance grade. These methods and practices are intended to promote uniform inspection procedures
which are accurate and repeatable to a degree compatible with the specified tolerance grade. Replaces
ANSI/AGMA 2009-B01. Reaffirmed November 1, 2012.
ISBN: 1-55589-994-3 Pages: 28
AGMA ISO 14179-1 Gear Reducers – Thermal Capacity Based on ISO/TR 14179-1
This information sheet utilizes an analytical heat balance model to provide a means of calculating the thermal
transmittable power for a single- or multi-stage gear drive lubricated with mineral oil. The calculation is based on
standard conditions of 25C maximum ambient temperature and 95C maximum oil sump temperature in a large
indoor space, but provides modifiers for other conditions. Differences from ISO/TR 14179-1 are: a) errors were
identified and corrected, b) text was added to clarify the calculation methods, and c) an illustrative example was
added to assist the reader. Modified adoption of ISO/TR 14179-1.
ISBN: 1-55589-821-1 Pages: 26
ANSI/AGMA 1003-H07 Tooth Proportions for Fine-Pitch Spur and Helical Gears
Tooth proportions for fine-pitch gearing are similar to those of coarse pitch gearing except in the matter of
clearance. This standard is applicable to external spur and helical gears with diametral pitch of 20 through
120 and a profile angle of 20 degrees. It provides a system of enlarged pinions which use the involute form above
5 degrees of roll. Data on 14-1/2 and 25-degree profile angle systems, and a discussion of enlargement and tooth
thicknesses are provided in annexes. In addition, it addresses, in a new annex, an analysis of comparative
systems of selecting tooth thicknesses of pinions. Revision of ANSI/AGMA 1003-G93. Reaffirmed February 6,
2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-902-8 Pages: 25
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 1103-H07 Tooth Proportions for Fine-Pitch Spur and Helical Gears (Metric Edition)
Tooth proportions for fine-pitch gearing are similar to those of coarse pitch gearing except in the matter of
clearance. This standard is applicable to external spur and helical gears with diametral pitch of 1.25 through
0.2 and a profile angle of 20 degrees. It provides a system of enlarged pinions which use the involute form above
5 degrees of roll. Data on 14-1/2 and 25-degree profile angle systems, and a discussion of enlargement and tooth
thicknesses are provided in annexes. In addition, it addresses, in a new annex, an analysis of comparative
systems of selecting tooth thicknesses of pinions. Metric version of ANSI/AGMA 1003-H07. Reaffirmed
February 6, 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-903-5 Pages: 25
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 2002-D19, Tooth Thickness and Backlash Measurement of Cylindrical Involute Gearing
Establishes the procedures for determining the specification limits for tooth thickness of external and internal
cylindrical involute gearing. Includes equations and calculation procedures for the commonly used measuring
methods. A specific tooth thickness specification limit can be established from the design thickness or from
another tooth thickness measurement. The procedures can be used with an established design tooth thickness, or
with actual tooth thickness dimensions. The effect of tooth geometric quality variations on tooth thickness
dimensions is discussed. Calculations for backlash are included, and are based on the specified tooth thickness,
center distance, and tolerances. Revision of ANSI/AGMA 2002-B88.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-068-0 Pages: 145
ANSI/AGMA 2003-D19 Rating the Pitting Resistance and Bending Strength of Generated Straight Bevel, Zerol
Bevel and Spiral Bevel Gear Teeth
This standard specifies a method for rating the pitting resistance and bending strength of generated straight bevel,
zerol bevel and spiral bevel gear teeth. A detailed discussion of factors influencing gear survival and a calculation
method are provided. Revision of ANSI/AGMA 2003-C10.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-037-6 Pages: 99
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 2116-A05 Evaluation of Double Flank Testers for Radial Composite Measurement of Gears
This standard provides the evaluation criteria for double flank testers. Recommended artifact sizes and geometry
are provided along with measurement system conditions. Annexes contain methods for estimating calibration
uncertainty and specifying artifact. Reaffirmed February 2, 2017.
ISBN: 1-55589-871-8 Pages: 9
ANSI/AGMA 6001-F19 Design and Selection of Components for Enclosed Gear Drives
This standard outlines the basic practices for the design and selection of components, other than gearing, for use
in commercial and industrial enclosed gear drives. Fundamental equations provide for the proper sizing of shafts,
keys, and fasteners based on stated allowable stresses. Other components are discussed in a manner to provide
an awareness of their function or specific requirements. This standard applies to the following types of commercial
and industrial enclosed gear drives, individually or in combination: spur, helical, herringbone, bevel and worm.
Revision of ANSI/AGMA 6001-E08.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-035-2 Pages: 66
ANSI/AGMA 6002-D20 Design Guide for Vehicle Spur and Helical Gears
This standard provides information on the design of spur and helical vehicle power transmission gears. Included
are considerations for design, material and heat treatment, lubrication, determination of load capacity, mounting
features, and typical design problems. Revision of ANSI/AGMA 6002-C15.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-074-1 Pages: 65
ANSI/AGMA 6006-B20 Standard for Design and Specification of Gearboxes for Wind Turbines
This standard is intended to apply to wind turbine gearboxes. It provides information for specifying, selecting,
designing, manufacturing, testing, procuring, operating and maintaining reliable speed increasing gearboxes for
wind turbine generator system service.
Annex information is supplied on wind turbine architecture, wind turbine load description, quality assurance,
operation and maintenance, minimum purchaser gearbox manufacturer ordering data, lubrication selection and
monitoring, determination of an application factor from a load spectrum using the equivalent torque, and bearing
stress calculations. Revision of ANSI/AGMA/AWEA 6006-A03.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-073-4 Pages: 46
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 6014-B15 Gear Power Rating for Cylindrical Shell and Trunnion Supported Equipment
This standard specifies a method for rating the pitting resistance and bending strength of open or semi-enclosed
gearing for use on cylindrical shell and trunnion supported equipment such as grinding mills, kilns, coolers, and
dryers. This includes spur, self-aligning spur, single helical, double helical, and herringbone gears made from
steel, ductile iron, and austempered ductile iron. Annexes cover installation, alignment, maintenance, combination
drives, and lubrication. Revision of ANSI/AGMA 6014-A06. Reaffirmed December 4, 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-045-2 Pages: 82
ANSI/AGMA 6015-A13 Power Rating of Single and Double Helical Gearing for Rolling Mill Service
This Standard provides a method for determining the power rating of gear sets used in main mill drives, pinion
stands, and combination units used for the reduction of material size in metal rolling mills. Applications include,
but are not limited to, hot mills and cold mills, roughing and finishing stands: reducing, increasing, and 1:1 ratio
sets. Auxiliary drives, including drives listed in ANSI/AGMA 6013-A06, such as bridles, coilers, uncoilers, edge
trimmers, flatteners, loopers (accumulators), pinch rolls, scrap choppers, shears, and slitters are not covered by
this document. This standard includes a method by which different gear tooth designs can be rated and compared
at extended life cycles typical for these applications, up to 175 000 hours. Reaffirmed December 17, 2018.
ISBN: 1-61481-056-8 Pages: 67
ANSI/AGMA 6025-E19 Sound for Enclosed Helical, Herringbone and Spiral Bevel Gear Drives
Describes a recommended method of acceptance testing and reporting of the sound pressure levels generated by
a gear speed reducer or increaser when tested at the manufacturer’s facility. The results obtained through the use
of this standard should represent only the sound of the gear unit, as other system influences, such as prime
mover or driven equipment are minimized. Annexes to the standard present sound power measurement methods
for use when required by specific contract provisions between the manufacturer and purchaser. Revision of
ANSI/AGMA 6025-D98.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-033-8 Pages: 32
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 6034-C21 Practice for Enclosed Cylindrical Wormgear Speed Reducers and Gearmotors
This standard gives a method for rating and design of specific enclosed cylindrical wormgear reducers and gear
motors at speeds not greater than 3600 rpm or mesh sliding velocities not more than 6000 ft/min. It contains
power, torque and efficiency equations with guidance on component design, thermal capacity, service factor
selection, lubrication, and self-locking features of wormgears. Annexes are supplied on service factors, user
recommendations. Replaces ANSI/AGMA 6034-B92.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-092-5 Pages: 43
ANSI/AGMA 6101-F19 Design and Selection of Components for Enclosed Gear Drives (Metric Edition)
This standard outlines the basic practices for the design and selection of components, other than gearing, for use
in commercial and industrial enclosed gear drives. Fundamental equations provide for the proper sizing of shafts,
keys, and fasteners based on stated allowable stresses. Other components are discussed in a manner to provide
an awareness of their function or specific requirements. This standard applies to the following types of commercial
and industrial enclosed gear drives, individually or in combination: spur, helical, herringbone, bevel and worm.
Metric Edition of ANSI/AGMA 6101-E08.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-034-5 Pages: 63
ANSI/AGMA 6102-D20 Design Guide for Vehicle Spur and Helical Gears (Metric Edition)
This standard provides information on the design of spur and helical vehicle power transmission gears. Included
are considerations for design, material and heat treatment, lubrication, determination of load capacity, mounting
features, and typical design problems. Metric edition of ANSI/AGMA 6002-D20.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-075-8 Pages: 65
ANSI/AGMA 6113-B16 Standard for Industrial Enclosed Gear Drives (Metric Edition)
This standard includes design, rating, lubrication, testing, and selection information for enclosed gear drives,
including foot mounted, shaft mounted, screw conveyor drives, and gearmotors. These drives may include spur,
helical, herringbone, double helical, or bevel gearing in single or multistage arrangements as either parallel,
concentric, or right angle configurations. Metric version of ANSI/AGMA 6013-B16. Replaces ANSI/AGMA 6113-
A06. Reaffirmed November 2021.
NOTE: ANSI/AGMA 6113-B16 has an errata included at the end of the document.
ISBN: 978-1-55589-051-3 Pages: 85
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 6115-A13 Power Rating of Single and Double Helical Gearing for Rolling Mill Service
(Metric Edition)
This Standard provides a method for determining the power rating of gear sets used in main mill drives, pinion
stands, and combination units used for the reduction of material size in metal rolling mills. Applications include,
but are not limited to, hot mills and cold mills, roughing and finishing stands: reducing, increasing, and 1:1 ratio
sets. Auxiliary drives, including drives listed in ANSI/AGMA 6113-A06, such as bridles, coilers, uncoilers, edge
trimmers, flatteners, loopers (accumulators), pinch rolls, scrap choppers, shears, and slitters are not covered by
this document. This standard includes a method by which different gear tooth designs can be rated and compared
at extended life cycles typical for these applications, up to 175 000 hours. Reaffirmed December 14, 2018.
ISBN: 1-61481-057-5 Pages: 67
ANSI/AGMA 6132-B13 Standard for Marine Gear Units: Rating and Application for Spur and Helical Gear
Teeth (Metric Edition)
This document considers rating practices for marine main propulsion, power take-off and auxiliary propulsion
service. Metric edition of ANSI/AGMA 6032-B13. Reaffirmed December 14, 2018.
ISBN: 1-61481-085-8 Pages: 52
ANSI/AGMA 6134-C21 Practice for Enclosed Cylindrical Wormgear Speed Reducers and Gearmotors (Metric
Edition)
This standard gives a method for rating and design of specific enclosed cylindrical wormgear reducers and gear
motors at speeds not greater than 3600 rpm or mesh sliding velocities not more than 30 m/s. It contains power,
torque and efficiency equations with guidance on component design, thermal capacity, service factor selection,
lubrication, and self-locking features of wormgears. Annexes are supplied on service factors, user
recommendations. Metric version of ANSI/AGMA 6034-C21.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-093-2 Pages: 43
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 9002-C14 Bores and Keyways for Flexible Couplings (Inch Series)
This standard describes sizes and tolerances for straight and tapered bores and the associated keys and
keyways, as furnished in flexible couplings. The data in the standard considers commercially standard coupling
bores and keyways, not special coupling bores and keyways that may require special tolerances. Annexes
provide material on inspection methods and design practices for tapered shafts. Revision of ANSI/AGMA
9002-B04. Reaffirmed June 8, 2020.
ISBN: 1-61481-091-9 Pages: 28
ANSI/AGMA 9004-B08 Flexible Couplings – Mass Elastic Properties and Other Characteristics
This standard provides calculation methods related to mass elastic properties of flexible couplings. Properties
discussed include coupling mass, polar mass moment of inertia (WR2), center of gravity, axial stiffness, axial
natural frequency, lateral stiffness, lateral natural frequency, and torsional stiffness. Calculation examples are
provided in informative annexes. Revision of ANSI/AGMA 9004-A99. Reaffirmed April 2020.
ISBN: 1-55589-973-8 Pages: 33
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
ANSI/AGMA 9104-A06 Flexible Couplings – Mass Elastic Properties and Other Characteristics (Metric Edition)
This standard provides calculation methods related to mass elastic properties of flexible couplings. Properties
discussed include coupling mass, polar mass moment of inertia, center of gravity, axial stiffness, axial natural
frequency, lateral stiffness, lateral natural frequency, and torsional stiffness. Calculation examples are provided in
informative annexes. Metric edition of ANSI/AGMA 9004-A99. Reaffirmed October 2022.
ISBN: 1-55589-900-4 Pages: 32
ANSI/AGMA 9112-B15 Bores and Keyways for Flexible Couplings (Metric Series)
This standard describes sizes and tolerances for straight and tapered bores and the associated keys and
keyways, as furnished in flexible couplings. The data in the standard considers commercially standard coupling
bores and keyways, not special coupling bores and keyways that may require special tolerances. Annexes
provide material on inspection methods and design practices for tapered shafts. Metric edition of ANSI/AGMA
9002-C14. Reaffirmed December 7, 2020
ISBN: 1-61481-092-6 Pages: 36
ANSI/AGMA ISO 1328-1-B14 Cylindrical gears – ISO system of flank tolerance classification – Part 1:
Definitions and allowable values of deviations relevant to flanks of gear teeth
This standard establishes a tolerance classification system relevant to manufacturing and conformity assessment
of tooth flanks of individual cylindrical involute gears. It specifies definitions for gear flank tolerance terms, the
structure of the flank tolerance class system, and allowable values. Replaces ANSI/AGMA 2015-1-A01.
ISBN: 1-61481-114-5 Pages: 47
ANSI/AGMA ISO 1328-2-A21 Cylindrical Gears — ISO System of Flank Tolerance Classification — Part 2:
Definitions and Allowable Values of Double Flank Radial Composite Deviations
This document establishes a gear tooth classification system relevant to double flank radial composite deviations
of individual cylindrical involute gears and sector gears. It provides formulae to calculate tolerances for individual
product gears when mated in double flank contact with a master gear. Identical to ISO 1328-2:2020.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-115-1 Pages: 26
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Supplemental Tables for ANSI/AGMA ISO 17485-A08 Bevel Gears – ISO System of Accuracy –
Tolerance Tables
This information sheet contains tolerance tables dealing with the measurements of bevel gear tooth flanks.
While the tables may be used to estimate the tolerance, the actual tolerances are provided in ANSI/AGMA
ISO 17485-A08.
ISBN: 1-55589-950-9 Pages: 39
ANSI/AGMA ISO 18653-A06 Gears – Evaluation of Instruments for the Measurement of Individual Gears
This International Standard specifies methods for the evaluation of measuring instruments used to measure
cylindrical gear involute, helix, pitch and runout. It includes instruments that measure runout directly or compute it
from index measurements. Of necessity, it includes the estimation of measurement uncertainty with the use of
calibrated gear artifacts. It also gives recommendations for the evaluation of tooth thickness measuring
instruments. The estimation of product gear measurement uncertainty is beyond its scope (see AGMA ISO 10064-
5-A06 for recommendations). This standard is an identical adoption of ISO 18653:2006. Replaces ANSI/AGMA
2010-A94, ANSI/AGMA 2110-A94, ANSI/AGMA 2113-A97 and ANSI/AGMA 2114-A98.
ISBN: 1-55589-882-3 Pages: 14
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Many standards require additional documents for their proper use. A list of these standards is normally
supplied after the scope, in the normative references section of a document. Be sure to inquire whether
the standard you need requires other documents listed herein.
ISO 53:1998 Cylindrical gears for general and heavy engineering – Standard basic rack tooth profile
ISO 54:1996 Cylindrical gears for general engineering and for heavy engineering – Modules
ISO 677:1976 Straight bevel gears for general engineering and heavy engineering – Basic rack
ISO 678:1976 Straight bevel gears for general engineering and heavy engineering – Modules and
diametral pitches
ISO 701:1998 International gear notation – Symbols for geometric data
ISO 1122-1:1998 (E/F) Cor 1:1999 Cor 2:2009 Vocabulary of gear terms – Part 1: Definitions related to
geometry
ISO 1122-2:1999 Vocabulary of gear terms – Part 2: Definitions related to worm gear geometry
*ISO 1328-1:2013 Cylindrical gears – ISO system of accuracy – Part 1: Definitions and allowable values
of deviations relevant to corresponding flanks of gear teeth
*NOTE: Adopted as ANSI/AGMA ISO 1328-1-B14
ISO 1328-2:2020 Cylindrical gears – ISO system of accuracy – Part 2: Definitions and allowable values of
deviations relevant to radial composite deviations and runout information
*NOTE: Adopted as ANSI/AGMA ISO 1328-2-A21
ISO 2490:2007 Single-start solid (monoblock) gear hobs with tenon drive or axial keyway, 1 to 40 module
– Nominal dimensions
ISO 4468:2020 Gear hobs – Accuracy requirements
ISO 6336-1:2019 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 1: Basic principles,
introduction and general influence factors
ISO 6336-2:2019 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 2: Calculation of surface
durability (pitting)
ISO 6336-3:2019 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 3: Calculation of tooth
bending strength
ISO/TS 6336-4:2019 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 4: Calculation of tooth
flank fracture load capacity
ISO 6336-5:2016 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 5: Strength and quality
of materials
*ISO 6336-6:2019 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 6: Calculation of service
life under variable load
ISO/TS 6336-20:2022 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 20: Calculation of
scuffing load capacity – Flash temperature method
ISO/TS 6336-21:2022 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 21: Calculation of
scuffing load capacity – Integral temperature method
ISO/TS 6336-22:2018 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – Part 22: Calculation of
micropitting load capacity
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
22FTM02. Mechanical Power Loss of Spur Gears Subject to Various Surface Finish Pairings
Author(s): Isaac Hong, Emily Aneshansley, David Talbot
Heat generation due to friction at the gear contact interface is a parasitic energy loss and may require designers
to include active cooling systems further decreasing the net usable energy. It is known that changing the surface
roughness of the mating gear flanks influences friction in the contact. Presenting different surface finishes to the
contact directly influences the amount of asperity interaction. Gear designers and manufacturers must carefully
balance costs associated with surface finishing processes while achieving target goals for transmission design.
This study utilizes a closed form model to predict friction in mixed lubrication contact conditions as well as gear
mechanical power loss under a wide variety of surface finish pairings for several operating conditions consistent
with automotive applications.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-122-9
22FTM03. Aspects of Gear Noise, Quality, and Manufacturing Technologies for Electro Mobility
Author(s): Hartmuth Müller, Christof Gorgels
This paper explains the formation of transmission noise and the basic cause being the tooth mesh excitation of
gears. For detecting the excitation, metrological and functional methods are presented. The paper shows
mathematical principles describing the tooth mesh. Beside physical properties, psychoacoustic metrics rating the
hearing experience are introduced. Methods for influencing the tooth mesh and the derived rating are presented in
the field of macro geometric design and flank form modifications as well as flank surface modulation.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-123-6
22FTM04. Optimizing the Operational Behavior of Double Helical Gears by Means of an FE-Based Tooth
Contact Analysis
Author(s): Alexander Mann, Jens Brimmers, Christian Brecher
Double helical gears are becoming increasingly relevant, especially in the fields of drive technology. Interaction
effects between the two halves of the gear are becoming increasingly important to ensure low-noise operation. In
the current state of the art design processes the interactions between the individual gear meshes of the left and
right half are neglected.
This paper, therefore, presents a method for considering the quasi-static stiffness behavior of double helical gears
for gear design by using an FE-based approach. The developed method is validated by means of experimental
studies. The validated method allows to derive design and tolerance recommendations for double helical gears in
order to optimize the excitation behavior.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-124-3
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
22FTM06. Methods for Checking the Profile of the Path of Contact of Involute Gears
Author(s): Zhaoyao Shi, Yanqiang Sun, Haobin Li
The profile of path of contact (PPC) is another significant characteristic curve beside involute and helix. During the
gear generating machining, this line is consistent with machining curve. During the gear transmission, this line is
also consistent with working curve. Therefore, the quality of gear machining and transmission can be reflected by
the PPC. However, the existing gear measuring instruments cannot measure it. The theoretical model is given
combining the forming principle of PPC. Based on the existing GMC, two methods for measuring the deviation of
PPC are proposed, including the four-axis method and the three-axis method. In measurement methods, the
measurement of PPC and involute profile is unified. The measurement practice shows that the measurement and
evaluation of PPC can be conveniently realized.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-126-7
22FTM09. A New Low Pressure Carburizing Solution in a Pit vs. Traditional Pit Carburizing Methods
Author(s): Thomas Hart
Pit LPC is a new and revolutionary furnace system that is a drop in replacement for traditional atmosphere pit
carburizing solutions. This approach can handle the same large and/or long loads with deep ECD while reducing
the process time and utility costs. These benefits drastically increase a ROI when converting from atmosphere
carburizing to LPC while eliminating carbon emissions associated with gas carburizing.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-129-8
22FTM10. Mathematical Model of a Straight Bevel Gear on the Straight Bevel Coniflex Generator and Gear
Flank Correction
Author(s): Yi-Pei Shih, Yu-Cheng Hung, Bor-Tyng Sheen, Szu-Hung Chen, Kuan-Heng Lin
Coniflex cutting, a popular mass production method for straight bevel gears, employs two giant interlocked circular
cutters to generate tooth surfaces. By controlling the tool pressure angle, Coniflex cutting enables profile and
lengthwise crownings that result in advantageously low assembly sensibility. This paper proposes a mathematical
model of a Coniflex bevel gear produced on a dedicated machine, whose coordinate systems between cutters and
work gear are empirically well-defined. Once the tooth surface is derived from coordinate transformation and gear
enveloping theory, ease off and tooth contact analysis can be conducted numerically; after which flank correction
is achieved using sensitivity analysis and optimization methods. Both the proposed model and the flank correction
are validated using cutting experiments on a straight bevel Coniflex generator No. 104.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-130-4
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
22FTM13. Effect of Tooth Root Fillet Design on Tooth Root Stress in Short Fiber Reinforced Plastic Gears
Author(s): Wassiem Kassem, Manuel Oehler, Oliver Koch
The geometry of plastic gears is usually based on conventional steel gears, which are bound to the restrictions of
the machining production of gears. The injection molding process provides more design freedom here. In this
work, simulative results in terms of tooth root stress in plastic gears with various tooth root fillet designs are
shown. The simulation method is based on finite element analysis and takes into account the different fiber
orientation as well as the complex material behavior of short fiber reinforced plastics.
The analysis includes fully rounded, elliptical and bionic tooth root fillets. In addition to the tooth root stress in the
initial state, results are also presented for the geometry changed by wear during operation.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-133-5
22FTM14. Investigations on the Tooth Root Bending Strength of Larger-Sized Induction Hardened Gears
Author(s): Holger Cermak, Thomas Tobie, Karsten Stahl
Especially for larger-sized gears surface hardening is an economical and technological alternative to case
hardening. Due to the necessary high case hardening depths required for larger case hardened gears and due to
technological boundaries (e.g., heat treatment furnace size and heat treatment duration) typical surface hardening
processes such as flame or induction hardening can exhibit their benefits for these parts. In the framework of this
paper, the influence of induction hardening on the tooth root bending strength of larger-sized gears is investigated.
Therefore, different variants of larger gears which were induction hardened gap-by-gap are compared. In order to
gain a deep understanding, a systematical variation of the surface hardening depth, gear size (mn = 14 mm and
20 mm), and surface condition was carried out.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-134-2
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
22FTM17. A Decomposition of the Torsional Stiffness of a Worm Gearbox into Individual Components
Author(s): Kevin Daubach, Manuel Oehler, Oliver Koch
In worm drive applications with precise transmission, the torsional stiffness of the worm gearbox is an important
parameter for the positioning accuracy. The torsional stiffness is a result of elasticities from all gearbox
components along the load path, which leads to various options for an optimization of the torsional stiffness within
the design process of worm gearboxes. However, a targeted optimization with high effectiveness requires
information about the distribution of displacements across the gearbox components.
A modeling approach is presented to decompose the total angular displacement of worm gearbox shafts under
load into individual components, by which sources with high displacement proportions can be identified as targets
for the optimization. The distribution of displacement proportions is investigated for specific worm gearboxes.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-137-3
22FTM19. Implementation of a Gear Health Monitoring System on a Power Recirculating Test Rig Using the
Average Log Ratio (ALR) Algorithm
Author(s): Matthew Wagner, William D. Mark, Aaron Isaacson
The ability to detect the onset of a gear system failure via accelerometer measurements is of interest in a
research environment as well as in gear systems deployed in the field. An accelerometer based gear health
monitoring system is described which was developed for use in a laboratory setting for monitoring power
recirculating gear tests. Even angle resampling, time synchronous averaging (TSA), and average log ratio (ALR)
algorithms are utilized to detect the onset of gear damage. A summary of these signal processing concepts is
given, along with an overview of system hardware, signal processing workflow, and sample data.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-139-7
22FTM20. Enhanced Calculation Method for Tooth Flank Fracture Risk with Consideration of Tensile
Residual Stresses in Larger Material Depths
Author(s): Daniel Müller, Thomas Tobie, Karsten Stahl
Tooth flank fracture (TFF) is a gear fatigue failure mode, which is initiated in larger material depths beneath the
active flank. Therefore, the residual stresses in larger material depths are decisive for TFF. In these larger
material depths, the residual stress conditions are almost unknown up to now. This paper presents a calculation
method to assess the residual stresses in gears. The calculated residual stress profiles also consider the existent
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
22FTM21. Experimental Evaluation of Wind Turbine Gearbox Structural Models Using Fiber Optic Strain
Sensors
Author(s): Unai Gutierrez Santiago, Xabier López Fuentes, Alfredo Fernández Sisón, Henk Polinder, Jan-Willem van
Wingerden
The rated power and size of wind turbines have grown considerably to reduce the cost of energy from wind. This
has pushed gearbox manufacturers to introduce multiple technological innovations to boost the torque density of
current designs. One of the critical challenges of next-generation gearbox designs is to optimize structural
components and gears. Complex models are needed to predict the gearbox components' load-carrying capacity
and fatigue life. These tools need to be verified through experimental evaluation. This study evaluates the
structural calculation models used for a modern 6MW wind turbine gearbox through physical testing. The
measurement system is composed of fifty-four fiber Bragg gratings. A good correlation between the structural
models and the test results in a full-scale back-to-back test bench has been achieved.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-141-0
22FTM22. Test Rig for Crowned Spline-Joints with Optimized Surface Treatments Under Misaligned
Conditions
Author(s): Gerrit Hellenbrand, Dieter Mevissen, Jens Brimmers, Christian Brecher
Increasing the load capacity of spline-joints in shaft-gear connections, such as UHBR-aero-engines, leads to a
lean and efficient design of the power train components. An approach for this is to apply optimized surface
treatments, such as coatings and laser structuring, which can reduce the risk of upcoming wear and fatigue
phenomena. To assess the potential of these surface treatments for spline-joints, tests under real working
conditions need to be carried out. As the application is an UHBR-aero-engine gas turbine, component tests are
not applicable in the application for economic reasons. Hence, a design for a test spline connection, as well as a
test rig for investigations of the wear and fatigue behaviour of surface treated spline-joints are presented.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-142-7
22SP1. Noise Analysis for e-Drive Gears and In-Process Gear Inspection
Author(s): Antoine Türich, Klaus Deininger
A new inspection concept developed by Gleason features a combination of double flank roll testing and laser
scanning. With this new approach gear inspection now can be performed as fast as a typical hard finishing
operation takes. As a result, 100% in-process inspection has become a reality, eliminating the need for statistical
process evaluation. In addition, the measured data can be further evaluated concerning waviness in profile and/or
lead allowing the evaluation of the noise behaviour. Hence, this new system allows an up to 100% in-process
noise analysis prediction of the finished gear. This new inspection concept has been integrated with a modern
grinding machine and a fast and flexible automation system to create the Hard Finishing Cell including a Closed
Loop correction system.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-144-1
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM02. Transient Friction and Wear Simulation of Worm Gears During Running-In
Author(s): K. Daubach, M. Oehler, B. Sauer
The load capacity of worm gears strongly depends on the size of the contact pattern. Worm wheels are often
manufactured by using an oversized hob, which results in a relatively small initial contact pattern. Wear on the
worm wheel with a softer material during the running-in process increases the contact pattern and thereby the
load capacity. For the investigation of the continuous change of friction in the tooth contact during that process, a
tribological simulation program is used. With a simplified model of the EHL-tooth contact, boundary as well as fluid
friction are calculated locally, and the tooth efficiency is evaluated. The included wear model associates abrasive
wear with solid friction energy occurring in the tooth contact and allows a time-dependent simulation by
considering the wear-modified tooth flank in the tribological calculation.
The simulative results are compared with experimental wear studies on the running-in of worm gears. Since
various values are determined in the simulation model, the comparison covers different aspects to verify the
model. However, for measurement reasons a comparison is taking place on the macro scale. The tooth friction is
reflected by the measured efficiency of the gearbox on the test bench. Wear is on one hand a directly measured
value, on the other hand it changes the geometry of the tooth flank and influences thereby the unloaded
kinematics of the gears. Both aspects are considered for a verification of the wear calculation.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-096-3
21FTM03. Tooth Flank Fracture – Design Process for a New Test Gearing and First Test Results
Author(s): Daniel Müller, Thomas Tobie, and Karsten Stahl
Tooth flank fracture (TFF) is a gear fatigue failure mode. TFF differs from tooth root breakage and pitting in that
the crack emerges below the hardened case of the active flank. However, like tooth root breakage, it leads to a
total breakdown of the gears in contact and often in severe failure of the entire transmission. TFF recently has
occurred more frequently, especially in larger sized gears. This makes it all the more important to investigate TFF
failures. In order to avoid TFF in the future, a calculation method, that must be applicable in the design phase is
needed and should be widely verified by experimental results. For the systematic investigation of TFF, smaller
sized test gears are used. So far, only test gears for TFF with a center distance of 200 mm are commonly used.
Although the gears are significantly smaller than those used in the relevant industrial applications, extensive
experimental investigations still result in high costs. A smaller sized test gearing with a center distance of 91.5 mm
would reduce the costs of manufacturing the test gears significantly and also offer more testing capabilities based
on the use of standardized FZG back-to-back gear test rigs. Based on the experimental results of the test gears
with a center distance of 200 mm, a calculation approach (ISO/TS 6336-4) was developed in the FVA 556 I
research project. In this work, this practical approach is used to design a smaller sized test gearing with a center
distance of 91.5 mm. The test gear pairing is tested with a back-to-back test rig and initial test results are shown
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM04. Effect of the ISO 6336 3:2019 Standard Update on the Specified Load Carrying Capacity Against
Tooth Root Breakage of Involute Gears
Author(s): Stefan Sendlbeck, Maximilian Fromberger, Michael Otto, and Karsten Stahl
Part 3 of the ISO 6336 standard contains a verified specification for calculating the tooth bending strength of
involute gears. In November 2019, an update of the previous version from the year 2006 was issued, which
includes more detailed calculation methods based on the most recent research findings. For an optimal gear
design, gear engineers need to be aware of how the changes in the standard affect the overall calculation result,
since the revised standard can yield a higher or lower safety factor against tooth root breakage.
This paper provides a detailed summary of the key changes in ISO 6336-3:2019, outlines their overall effects on
the basis of a calculation study, and presents a comparison of the results to the previous version of the standard,
ISO 6336-3:2006. The key changes in ISO 6336-3:2019 are a new load distribution influence factor that accounts
for the effects of high overlap ratios and a more precise consideration of the helix angle on the stresses.
Furthermore, the standard now also covers the determination of the tooth root geometry of internal gears by
means of a shaper cutter. To investigate these changes and their overall effect, we vary the contact ratio by using
gears with different transverse contact ratios and overlap ratios as a basis for computing the specifications of the
standard. In addition, by simultaneously varying the transmission ratio and the tool tip radius, we investigate the
effect on the calculation of internal gears with different tooth root geometries. The findings of this research give a
detailed insight into how the update enhances the ISO 6336 standard and how they affect the load carrying
capacity calculation.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-098-7
21FTM05. Double Differential for Electric Vehicle and Hybrid Transmissions – Sophisticated Simplicity
Author(s): Hermann Stadtfeld, Haris Ligata
The fascination of the automotive differential has led to the idea to build a second differential unit around a first
center unit. Both units have the same axes around which they rotate with different speeds.
The potential of double differentials as ultrahigh reduction speed reducers is significant. Only the tooth-count of
the gears in the outer differential unit must be changed to achieve ratios between 5 and 80 without a noticeable
change of the transmission size.
Double differentials are well suited for high input speeds. The fact that the carrier rotates with about half of the
input speed reduces the relative motion and with it the sliding velocity to 50% of the value of two conventionally
meshing bevel gears which roll with the same input speed.
Ground spiral bevel gears are recommended for the double differential application. Due to the load sharing of the
two opposite planets, the torque of each gear is only 50% compared to a conventional bevel gear mesh. This
effect results in very high-power density of this already very compact unit.
Also, the efficiency of the double differential is high in contrast to the fact that always two pairs of gears are
transmitting the rotation and torque. Double differentials show good efficiency results, which qualifies this new
transmission type very well for the speed reduction and transmission in electric vehicles and hybrids.
In addition to electric vehicles and hybrid cars, there are many other applications in the industry which require high
ratios. Double differentials could be used in helicopters, wind turbines, agricultural equipment, and many other
industrial applications.
The objective of the paper is to compare a transmission concept, which is based on bevel gear technology, with
cylindrical gear-based solutions, for designers and manufacturers of high reduction transmissions to have an
additional technology available for their different applications.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-099-4
21FTM06. Bevel Gear Strength Rating – The Appropriate Combination of FE with Rating Standards
Author(s): Jürg Langhart, Markus Bolze
Strength rating of bevel gears according to standards such as AGMA, ISO, etc. is executed based on virtual
cylindrical gears, only modified by a few specific bevel gear factors. The rating method of these standards also
includes the calculation of permissible stresses and finally resulting safety factors. Furthermore, the integrated S-
N curves consider also an increased permissible stress during limited life and allow a lifetime prediction.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM07. Use of Duty Cycles or Measured Torque-Time Data with AGMA Ratings
Author(s): Ulrich Kissling
Nowadays continuous torque measurement on gearboxes is increasingly popular, not only on very sensitive
installations but also on many industrial gearboxes and wind turbines. When the transmitted load is not uniform,
consideration should be given not only to the peak load and its anticipated number of cycles, but also to
intermediate loads and their numbers of cycles. This type of load is considered a duty cycle and may be
represented by a load spectrum. In such cases, the cumulative fatigue effect of the duty cycle is considered in
rating the gear set. A method of calculating the effect of the loads under these conditions, such as Miner’s Rule, is
not explained in AGMA rating methods (as AGMA 2001, 2101, 2003) but a reference is given to ISO/TR 10495
(nowadays replaced by ISO 6336-6:2019).
In this paper the application of torque spectra in AGMA rating methods is described. Furthermore, a procedure to
convert measured (or calculated by numerical simulation) torque data into a torque spectrum according to the
definition in ISO 6336-6 is described. This task is simple if the torque is always positive, but quite complicated
when also negative torque sequences happen.
The torque spectrum must represent the load on each single tooth, therefore in a first step the continuous torque
course has to be segmented in individual torque peaks applied on one tooth. If only positive torque occurs (no
load reversal), the "Simple Count" method can be used. The method counts how often a torque value happens to
be in a certain torque range. A tooth is always loaded by a torque value starting at zero to a peak, hence it is
subjected to pulsating stress (stress ratio R=0). Tooth bending stress calculation according to AGMA is assuming
pulsating stress, so the result of the “Simple Count” method can directly be used for the tooth bending strength
verification.
For complex loads, where the torque has both positive and negative signs, the “Rainflow method” (ISO 12110-2
[8]) should be applied. 'Rainflow Counting' is a method to determine the number of fatigue cycles present in a
load-time history. The method is used in the analysis of fatigue data in order to reduce a spectrum of varying
stress into an equivalent set of simple stress reversals. So, a tooth is loaded by cycles with a high and a low
torque (respectively stress), having a variable stress ratio R ≠ 0. To comply with the rules of AGMA ratings, a
reverse loading factor must be used to modify the admitted sat values for tooth bending. In ISO, this factor is the
mean stress influence factor YM which must be defined for every bin of the torque spectrum.
In the final part of this paper a practical application of the above method is presented.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-101-4
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM09. Algorithm-Based Optimization of Gear Mesh Efficiency in Stepped Planetary Gear Stages for
Electric Vehicles
Author(s): Christian Westphal, Jens Brimmers, Christian Brecher
The electrification of the automotive powertrain confronts the gearbox development with new challenges. High-
speed concepts require higher gear ratios, which cannot be optimally achieved with simple cylindrical gear stages.
For this reason, stepped planetary gear stages are increasingly used, as they offer high power density at high
gear ratios. To increase range and energy efficiency, the gear mesh losses are of great importance and must be
considered in the gear design.
The design of the macro geometry of gears is usually focused on ensuring the load-carrying capacity. In the
design of stepped planetary gear stages, there are constraints due to assembly restrictions as well as additional
degrees of freedom, such as the division of the total gear ratio. Due to many adjustable geometry parameters and
design combinations, manual optimization of the gear geometry would not be effective.
In this paper, a method for an automated optimization of the macro geometry of stepped planetary gear stages to
improve the gear mesh efficiency is presented, which considers the assembly restrictions. An FE based tooth
contact analysis is used to evaluate the design objectives: NVH (Noise, Vibration, Harshness), load-carrying
capacity, and efficiency. Since these objectives require different design strategies, a weighting of the objectives is
necessary. A particle-swarm algorithm is used to optimize the gear geometry and the tool data. Tooth flank
pressure, peak-to-peak transmission error, tooth root stress, and efficiency are evaluated. The influence of the
weighting of the design objectives on the gear design is shown. The results of various optimizations are
compared, and an efficiency-optimized variant is selected for a specific application.
With the method presented in this paper, it is possible to design the macro geometry of stepped planetary gear
stages using FE-based tooth contact analysis and to optimize the operational behavior for a given application.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-103-8
21FTM11. Design and Simulation of a Back-to-Back Test Rig for Ultra High Cycle Fatigue Testing of Gears
Under Fully Reversed Load
Author(s): J. Lövenich, M. Trippe, O. Malinowski, J. Brimmers, S. Neus, C. Brecher
Gear units for turbomachinery, especially in the aerospace sector, place high demands. In addition to the high
power density, the demands are also increased regarding the operating temperatures compared to automotive
applications. Furthermore, the high operating speed excites vibrations in the higher frequency range, which also
poses challenges for the transmission design in terms of NVH. The high dynamics of over 12 000 rpm combined
with the high number of load cycles under fully reversed load (N > 108) that an aviation planetary gearbox
experiences makes load capacity tests with standardized back-to-back test rigs uneconomical or even impossible
due to the extremely long testing times. To enable the Ultra High Cycle Fatigue (UHCF) testing, a high-speed
back-to-back test rig was developed. In addition to the design, particular focus is placed on the thermal and
dynamic simulation of the test rig. These two aspects are the basis for a safe commissioning and a successful
testing. In the area of thermal simulation, the behavior of the test rig components in the operating temperature
range from room temperature to T > 100°C is investigated regarding the thermal expansion and the resulting
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM14. Investigation of Gear Surface Topography and Deviations in Gear Power Skiving Through
Advanced CAD Modeling Based Simulation
Author(s): Nikolaos Tapoglou
Power skiving is an emerging gear cutting process that has been identified as a process that can provide a step
change in the production rate of high precision internal and external involute gear forms. The continuous
generating principle is the basis of the cutting process that ensures the increased throughput of the process that is
significant for internal gears. The understanding of the loads applied in the cutting tool and the gear as well as the
final characteristics of the gear machined through power skiving is of key importance in the optimization of the
cutting process. The present research focuses on two strands, first the development of a novel CAD based
simulation platform that is able to simulate the power skiving process and calculate the cutting forces and the
resulting gear topography. The second strand includes the validation of the model with analytical and
experimental data from literature. In depth, investigation in the quality of gears produced is presented as part of
this study with a focus in the influence of key process parameters in the resulting gear quality. Through this study
a series of process maps can be drawn that assist in the selection of the most productive parameters for
machining involute gears.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-108-3
21FTM15. Power Skiving – A Step Changing Manufacturing Process Applicable to Multifunctional 5-Axis
Machine Tools
Author(s): Bethany Cousins, Chao Sun, David Curtis, Michael Farmery, Steven Staley, Ben Cook
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM16. An Accurate Method of Generating Tool Paths for Helical Gears with Crowning Modifications Using
a 5-axis CNC Machine
Author(s): Fei Shen, Luis Vega, Mohammadrafi Marandi, Christoph Kossack, Joshua Tarbutton, Gert Goch
To manufacture gears, special machine tools and corresponding processes, such as hobbing, shaping, planing,
profile milling, and broaching, are usually needed. However, the huge investment in such gear machining is
prohibitive for manufacturers, which only produce the gears in small batches on an annual basis. To overcome
this economic problem in the manufacturing of gears, standard 5-axis CNC machines were proposed as an
alternative tool for machining them, and a few approaches were presented to implement this gear manufacturing
method. However, machining helical gears with crowning or other modifications has been little studied. This paper
proposes an accurate method to manufacture helical gears with crowning modifications using a standard 5-axis
CNC machine tool. As gear roughing process, milling using an end mill was selected, where the tool movement
follows the generation principle. By incorporating crowning modifications into the tool’s movement, an accurate
tool path generation method was developed. A CAM software written in C++ was developed to generate,
visualize, and simulate the tool path for machining the gear according to user-defined parameters. The tool path
was subsequently post-processed into NC code to run on a CNC machine. To validate the generated NC code, an
internal helical gear with crowning modification was machined on a conventional 5-axis CNC machine. The
machining results confirmed that the proposed method is feasible. The machined helical gears will be measured
using optical and tactile CMMs to determine their deviation parameters.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-110-6
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
21FTM18. Enhanced Distortion Control – ISO Class 8 Gears After Case Hardening
Author(s): Volker Heuer, David Bolton, Jochen Friedel
Controlling distortion during the case-hardening process is of key importance when manufacturing gears. By
effective control of distortion and the variation of distortion, significant costs in post heat treatment machining
processes can be avoided. Especially for E-drive gears such as Internal Ring gears or Final Drive Ring gears
significant cost-savings can be achieved.
If distortion is controlled in such manner that ISO class 8 is guaranteed after case hardening, the grinding
operation gets obsolete, and parts may be honed only.
The combination of Low-Pressure Carburizing (LPC) and High-Pressure Gas Quenching (HPGQ) offers the
potential to provide better control of distortion compared to other process-combinations such as Atmospheric
Carburizing with Oil Quenching.
This paper analyses distortion values of gear components from a planetary set of a six-speed automatic
transmission over a long period of time. The gears were analyzed in terms of circularity, helix average and helix
variation. It is demonstrated that distortion data stays stable and predictable even over a long period of time when
applying optimized heat treatment process parameters and if the process-steps in the manufacturing chain before
heat treatment are frozen and robust.
When combining this heat treatment technology with appropriate geometrical inspection, this will result in
guaranteed ISO class 8 geometry after heat treatment.
The paper gives directions how this goal can be achieved by combining an advanced heat treatment process with
advanced gear inspection technology.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-112-0
21FTM19. Tooth Root Bending Strength of Shot-Peened Gears Made of High-Purity Steels up to the VHCF
Range
Author(s): Daniel Fuchs, Thomas Tobie, and Karsten Stahl
The load capacity calculations for gears according to standardized methods, like AGMA 2001-D04 or ISO 6336,
are intentionally conservative to ensure broad applicability in industrial practice. However, due to new applications
and higher requirements, more detailed design calculations are nowadays often necessary in order to use
possible strength potentials. For example, in wind power gearboxes long operating lives are necessary and in e-
mobility applications, due to fewer gear stages and higher speeds at the electric motor, there are higher load
cycles per tooth. Hence, higher tooth flank and root load carrying capacities up to the very high cycle fatigue
(VHCF) range are desired for gears. To achieve a higher bending strength in the tooth root area of gears, one
approach is to induce increased compressive residual stresses into the stressed area, e.g. by a shot-peening
process. The drawback is that often there is a change in the crack mechanism. Crack initiation can now occur at
non-metallic inclusions in the steel matrix.
For that reason, the working hypothesis of this publication is: the higher the cleanliness the fewer the non-metallic
inclusions in the material and therefore the higher the tooth root capacity of case-hardened, shot-peened gears.
This working hypothesis is verified with tests on FZG back-to-back test rigs up to the very high cycle fatigue
(VHCF) range. The test gear variants were manufactured from steels with different degrees of cleanliness. The
gears were also examined metallographically, with a special focus on the residual stress state in the tooth root
area. As a result, it could be shown that with a higher degree of cleanliness, higher tooth root load carrying
capacities up to a higher number of load cycles are possible even taking the different crack mechanism into
account.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-113-7
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
2020 PAPERS
20FTM01. Quasi-Static Transmission Error Behavior Under the Composite Effects of Temperature and Load
Author(s): Aitor Arana, Jon Larrañaga, Ibai Ulacia, Mikel Izquierdo, & Miren Larrañaga
Current demands for enhanced rotational speed in electric vehicle transmissions, aeronautical gearboxes and
industrial machinery is known to affect the thermal behavior of mechanical parts by increasing their steady-state
temperature. In geared transmissions, such condition is detrimental as the lubricating film is reduced thus
increasing failure probability, furthermore, if temperature levels are sufficiently high thermal distortion can affect
mesh behavior.
Scientific literature review has shown that no experimental evidence on the composite effect of temperature and
torque on transmission error exists up to date. Although some authors already pointed out that temperature
influences positioning accuracy, no previous reference to peak to peak behavior has been found and comparisons
to torque effects have not been performed.
In this work, quasi-static transmission error behavior is experimentally analyzed under increased thermo-
mechanical conditions. First, the development of a custom back-to-back test rig is described and test specimen
geometries, operating conditions and measurement procedure are presented. Next, loaded transmission error
tests are carried out in order to validate the expected mechanical behavior and then the influence of temperature
is analyzed by heating up the system in a controlled manner. Composite effect of temperature and load are
studied in terms of backlash, mean level of transmission error and its peak-to-peak value. Finally, experimental
measurements are compared to analytical predictions, results are discussed and conclusions are withdrawn.
It is shown that the effect of temperature and torque coexist in transmission error diagrams. Both parameters have
a significant role in the mean level of transmission error while the influence of torque on peak to peak is prominent
relative to that of temperature. Although the correlation between the change of mean level and that of backlash for
increasing temperatures is clear, peak-to-peak variation due to temperature is not obvious.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-079-6
20FTM02. A Comparison of an Analytical and FEA Approach in Determining Thermal Lead Correction for
High Speed Gears
Author(s): Andreas Beinstingel, Burkard Pinnekamp, Michael Heider, Daniel Stierli, & Steffen Marburg
Especially for high-speed applications, gears of large dimensions and high power density are used. Temperature
distribution in those rotors is much different in operation as compared to manufacturing. Therefore, the tooth
contact as it can be validated by blue ink during assembly is not only affected by distortion and bending under
load but also by non-uniform thermal growth. This influence has often been neglected in the past. As power
density and specific load are continuously increasing over time, for highly sophisticated applications, this influence
should be accounted for with suitable lead modification, as it is demanded by the latest version of API 613.
For many years, RENK has been using empiric methods for thermal lead correction based on measurements and
experience. Lately, the authors carried out complex finite element calculations to numerically investigate the
influence of temperature distribution on tooth contact. This kind of detailed finite element modeling for tooth
contact analyses requires a high effort with respect to FE meshing as well as extended computation time.
Therefore, the numerical method was further enhanced. As a result, a simplified approach for quick and reliable
heat analyses for thermal lead correction of high-speed gears was developed. The paper describes the theoretical
background and gives a comparison of the results with the different calculation approaches.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
20FTM04. Effects of Different Shot Peening Treatments in Combination with a Superfinishing Process on the
Surface Durability of Case-Hardened Gears
Author(s): Dominik Kratzer, Johannes König, Thomas Tobie, & Karsten Stahl
Modern gearbox designs set increasing requirements on the surface durability of gears in light of calls for
downsizing and performance optimization. Using additional manufacturing processes is one way to tackle these
challenges. The increase in the compressive residual stress state due to shot peening and the decrease in the
roughness of the gear flank surface due to superfinishing processes are two possible measures. While there have
been extensive scientific studies in the past on the positive effects of shot peening and superfinishing, a detailed
quantification of a calculation model of these two effects has not been subject to in-depth investigation yet. To
address this gap in knowledge, a study was carried out to examine and evaluate different peening processes and
the resulting residual stress profiles in combination with a superfinishing process. Experimental investigations
showed significant differences in the gear flank load-carrying capacity due to the different surface treatments. In
addition, a significant reduction in micropitting appearance was observed due to the superfinishing process, while
the increased compressive residual stresses due to shot peening showed no significant influence on the
development of micropitting. By correlating the pitting durability from the experimental investigations with existing
calculation methods, it was possible to extend the surface factor ZR from ISO 6336 to a wider range of roughness
values as well as to introduce a new factor ZS for different shot peening treatments. Based on the results of this
paper, the positive effects of different shot peening processes as well as superfinishing processes can be taken
into account for gearbox design and rating processes.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-082-6
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
20FTM08. Service Life of Cylindrical and Bevel Gears Under Variable Load and Stresses
Author(s): Daniel Vietze, Josef Pellkofer, Michael Hein, & Karsten Stahl
Transmissions are usually loaded by variable external loads under real operating conditions. The decisive load for
a gearbox is in most cases the applied torque. Commonly used allowable stress numbers σHlim/Flim (ISO) or
σHP/FP (AGMA) for calculating the load carrying capacity of cylindrical, bevel and hypoid gears are usually
derived from single stage tests carried out on pulsators or back-to-back test rigs. Variable loads can be
considered in the calculation of the load carrying capacity by using application factors, overload factors or more
complex standards like ISO 6336-6, which was recently revised. In case of variable loads, the calculation of the
load carrying capacity of gears is quite different to bearings. According to ISO 6336-6, a safety factor is
determined for gears and according to ISO 281, a service life is determined for bearings, respectively. Whereas all
of these calculation methods only consider a global safety or lifetime, continuously progressing failures like
micropitting or wear can – especially on bevel and hypoid gears – also lead to locally varying stresses even if only
a constant external load is applied.
This paper is intended to give a brief overview of currently applied methods to consider variable loads in the
design process of cylindrical as well as bevel and hypoid gears. Therefore, the scope of application of these
methods is shown and critically analyzed for the damage mechanisms pitting, tooth root breakage and tooth flank
fracture. Especially the changes made in the revised version of ISO 6336-6 are shown in detail. Furthermore, the
influence of locally changing stresses on the pitting load carrying capacity is explained on bevel and hypoid gears.
A method to assess such influence is shown for constant external loads.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-086-4
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
20FTM10. Analysis of the Operational Behavior of a High-Speed Planetary Gear Stage for Electric Heavy-Duty
Trucks in Multi-Body Simulation
Author(s): Christian Westphal, Jens Brimmers, & Christian Brecher
Stricter emission limits accelerate the development of electric trucks, especially for urban distribution traffic. The
use of electric motors instead of diesel engines confronts gearbox development with the challenge of higher
engine speeds and higher requirements on transmission acoustics. Planetary gearboxes are often used for this
purpose, as they allow high transmission ratios in reduced assembly space.
Dynamic multi-body simulation (MBS) is used for detailed dynamic modeling of drive trains. The interaction of
gears and shafts in planetary gearboxes requires, especially for NVH-analysis, advanced simulation methods due
to the sophisticated kinematics and the more sensitive displacement behavior. Dynamic simulation methods for
cylindrical gears usually describe the tooth contact based on analytical equations or consider only one rotational
degree of freedom, which leads to uncertainties in the simulation results. Misalignments are therefore, either
simplified or not considered at all. The authors developed a method that combines the advantages of the quasi-
static FE-based tooth contact analysis with the advantages of an integrated approach in the MBS.
In this paper the operational behavior of a high-speed planetary gear stage for electric heavy-duty trucks is
analyzed in dynamic MBS. The method for the tooth contact analysis in the MBS is used for the simulation of
planetary gearboxes. Different mesh sequences and model configurations for planetary gearboxes are compared
and the effects on the operational behavior are evaluated. In addition to the dynamic transmission error, the
dynamic tooth flank pressures are analyzed. Furthermore, dynamic misalignments in the tooth contact and the
load sharing behavior in dynamic operating conditions are evaluated. In the simulation, the misalignment of the
gears is directly taken into account by means of a penetration calculation in every time step. The presented
method allows a well-founded prediction of the operational behavior of planetary gear stages, considering the
dynamic interaction of the components.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-088-8
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM03. Spline Centering, Piloting, and Toggle: Torsional Stiffness, Shaft Bending, and Centering of
Moment Loads
Author: Stephen McKenny and Dustin Eseltine
Common practice for a splined joint is to assume that the load is theoretically transmitted along the entire length of
the tooth face, but several factors, including axial spline length and the ratio of hub to shaft torsional stiffness, can
impact how the load is distributed along the tooth face. Previous papers have considered the effect of pure torque
and combined torque plus radial load, but few have described the impact of splines loaded with torque plus both
moment and radial load.
A spline with short axial length, if sufficient torque is applied, can center a hub that is subjected to a radial load. A
sufficiently long spline may be able to center a hub that has both radial and moment loads acting upon it – but if
the hub torsional stiffness is much higher than the shaft stiffness there may not be sufficient torque transfer at the
far end of the spline to center the hub against its moment load.
This paper describes the behavior of spline interfaces in piloted (radially offset), full toggle, half toggle, and
centered alignment states. These alignment states are created by a combination of part geometry and load
conditions. Part geometry includes the influence of torsional stiffness of the hub relative to the shaft stiffness, and
spline length to diameter ratio. Load conditions considered include combinations of torque, radial load, and
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM09. Reduction of the Tonality of Gear Noise by Application of Topography Scattering for Ground Bevel
Gears
Author: Marcel Kasten, Christian Brecher, Christoph Löpenhaus, Andreas Lemmer, Werner Bläse, and Rolf
Schalaster
The noise behavior of transmission is mainly caused by the excitation in the gear mesh. The standardized design
and calculation methods for gears concentrate on the reduction of the excitation level. However, often the physical
noise characteristics do not conform with the human noise perception. Thus, gear design rules and guidelines are
required that are able to rate the excitation according to the perception. The effect of the targeted topography
scatter generally described is the reduction of the gear mesh amplitudes with an increase of the background
noise. In this report, the noise behavior of bevel gears is investigated with a targeted topography scattering. The
excitation and noise behavior is analyzed from the excitation in tooth contact by transmission error measurements
up to noise emission in the form of airborne noise. Finally, it is the objective to evaluate the impact of individual
topography scattering on the dynamic noise behavior. The analysis of the noise behavior of two variants are
compared regarding the difference in psychoacoustic parameters such as loudness and tonality. The potentials of
the topography deviation for the optimization of ground bevel gears in terms of tonality reduction will be shown by
test results. A test fixture for the evaluation of the operational behavior under loaded and dynamic conditions will
be used. Finally, the method is applied to a vehicle transmission and the noise behavior on the test bench and
inside of the vehicle is investigated and evaluated.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-048-2
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM12. Evaluation of Steel Cleanliness By Extreme Value Statistics and its Correlation With Fatigue
Performance
Author: Trishita Roy, Cassie L. Smith, Nikhil Deo, Carlos Wink, and Jason Carroll
Nonmetallic inclusions, primarily oxides play a significant role in the fatigue performance of components such as
bearings and gears that undergo fatigue loading. This leads to an increased demand for cleaner steel for longer-
life applications. Due to the advances made in steel making processes in the past decades, the oxygen level as
well as inclusion size and distribution have been brought under remarkable control enabling production of high-
quality steel. Consequently, the earlier inclusion rating methods such as ASTM A534, ASTM E-45 that use a
comparison with standard micrographs are insufficient to render an effective comparison of cleanliness of steels
from different heats or suppliers, especially for the cleaner heats. It thus becomes imperative to find a reliable
method to predict the size of the largest inclusions present in a steel volume and to further correlate it with the
fatigue limit of steel. This is another limitation of the existing inclusion rating methods. Extreme value analysis is a
method that can surmount these limitations and it comprises of examination of a small area of steel by Optical or
Scanning Electron Microscopy to predict the maximum size of inclusions which may inhabit a larger volume of
steel.
In this work, the effect of inclusion size distribution on fatigue performance is investigated from the experimental
data obtained using ultrasonic fatigue testing. Extreme value analysis is used to predict the characteristic size of
the largest inclusion based on the metallographic observations on polished surfaces and this inclusion size is then
correlated with the fatigue limit measured by ultrasonic fatigue testing, making use of the Murakami approach.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-051-2
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM14. 4D High Pressure Gas Quenching - A Leap in Performance vs. Press Quenching
Author: Thomas Hart and Dr. Maciej Korecki
Thermal processing and quenching of steels for hardening is a well-established practice performed by various
techniques over the centuries. A common thread has been the unpredictable nature of the size change during the
quenching process, which is known as dimensional change or distortion. Material distortion is the undesired trade-
off between the development of proper mechanical property and the necessity of rapidly quenching the material
from elevated temperatures into a quenching media (i.e. brine, water, polymer, oil, gas, molten salt, etc.). Due to
this compromise, users have been attempting to reduce part distortion because once a component is hardened, it
becomes very difficult and costly to remove excess material or form the part back into its original shape.
When one looks at the bearing and gearing industries, materials typically are hardened via austenitizing and
quenching. Not only do these components require high hardness and wear/corrosion resistance, they also require
high dimensional precision to tight tolerances as well as repeatability of results. One of the most common way to
reduce material distortion when quenching is a method by which a heated component is placed in a special fixture
and a steady force is applied to the component, which allow the part to resist material deformation when the
quenching media is applied. This method of quenching is known as “press quenching” and requires specialized
equipment, manual or robotic handling, custom die sets and high maintenance as well as being operator
dependent to achieve consistent results.
It is well known that machining after heat treatment is one of the most costly and difficult tasks to complete in the
entire manufacturing life cycle. This is why an extreme amount of engineering is devoted to the prevention of
distortion of a component to ease the post heat treatment machining operations. With the ever prevailing desire to
lower the cost of raw materials and still maintain proper mechanical performance, extreme amounts of pressure
are applied to the heat treatment process to bring up the quality level of the low cost steel. When using these low
quality steels, they are prone to high levels of distortion during the quenching process, such that they distort more
than the allowable amount and either become too challenging to hard machine or are not able to be used all
together. ~4% of the price for a hardened component is attributed to the removal of post heat treatment material
to so that it meets the finished size requirements. When users can control distortion, they lower the overall cost of
the component.
This paper will introduce the latest achievements in the advancement of distortion control by way of 4D High
Pressure Gas Quenching (HPGQ) versus press quenching. Both processes quench a single part at a time but the
4D HPGQ process does not subject a part to any clamping forces or issues associated with liquid quenching
inconsistencies. The 4D HPGQ process results in every single part being heated and quenched identically the
same at surprisingly low gas pressures thus producing extremely accurate dimensional variation with highly
repeatable results. 4D HPGQ systems are easily integrated into current manufacturing environments and the
process is a revolutionary advance in quenching technology, which has been shown to reduce or even eliminate
the need for expensive & difficult post hardening manufacturing processes.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-053-6
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM17. Chamfering of Cylindrical Gears - New Innovative Cutting Solutions for Efficient Gear Production
Author: Gottfried Klein
Cylindrical gear chamfering and deburring is a rather ‘unloved’ process that adds cost but without delivering
readily apparent improvements in gear quality. However, the chamfer process, when performed correctly,
provides significant advantages for downstream handling and processing. This is why manufacturers of
automotive- and truck-sized gears are increasingly exploring new technologies to chamfer their gears.
Two major chamfer technologies are used: forming and cutting. While chamfer rolling is a highly proven forming
process that has been used for decades mainly in mass production, cutting chamfer technologies are of
increasing market interest due to cost reduction and increased quality requirements; especially in dry cutting
conditions.
This paper will cover new chamfer cutting processes: Chamfer Contour Milling and Chamfer Hobbing and
compare them with the existing chamfer roll technology.
Chamfer Contour Milling uses a universal fly cutter tool with indexable carbide inserts. Chamfer angle and
chamfer size depend on programmable machine movements. Therefore, this process provides highest flexibility
for coarse pitch gears – even with different modules, pressure angles or number of teeth.
Chamfer Hobbing has been developed for modern gear production focusing on low tool cost per part with dry
cutting and short cycle times in mass production. As for the left and right gear flank, separate and dedicated
chamfer hobs are used to meet most customer specifications in the market.
By comparing the advantages and limits of the aforementioned chamfer processes in gear production for
workpieces up to 400 mm diameter and module 8 mm, it is possible to select the right process depending on the
specific requirements.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-056-7
19FTM18. Influence of Manufacturing Variations of Spline Couplings on Gear Root and Contact Stress
Author: Hareesh Kurup and Carlos Wink
Involute splines are widely used in mechanical systems to connect power transmitting gears to their supporting
shafts. These splines are as susceptible as gears to manufacturing variations, which change their loading pattern
and may eventually lead to failures. The influence of manufacturing variations of spline teeth on performance and
failure mechanisms of spline couplings is available in the literature. Similarly, the influence of manufacturing
variations of gear teeth on gear tooth stresses, and gear noise has been extensively studied. However, the effects
of manufacturing variations of spline teeth on gear tooth contact, noise, and stresses remain unseen in
publications. This study investigates how manufacturing variations of spline couplings affect gear performance. A
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM20. Rapid and Precise Manufacturing of Special Involute Gears for Prototype Testing
Author: Christian Weber, Thomas Tobie, and Karsten Stahl
Due to the steadily increasing demands on the power density of mechanical transmissions, gears with special
geometries are increasingly coming into focus and therefore the need for short-term availability of prototypes.
Such special gear designs are e.g. asymmetrical gears with different normal pressure angles on the drive and
coast flank. These are particularly suitable for use in gearboxes with preferred driving direction, whereby the
loaded flank can be optimized with regard to load carrying capacity. While for symmetrical gears with normal
pressure angles in the range of αn = 20° standardized calculation methods for gear design have been available
for decades, mainly theoretical numerical investigations have been carried out on asymmetrical gears so far. For
the qualification of any such designed asymmetrical gear geometry with increased load carrying capacity potential
for use in industrial practice, however, reliable load carrying capacity values are required. Therefore, according to
the current state of the art, prototype tests are indispensable to determine the actual gear strength. At the Gear
Research Centre (FZG), such load capacity investigations are carried out using back-to-back test rigs and
pulsator test rigs. The design and procurement of special tools for the production of such prototype gears is often
time-consuming and expensive. In this paper, an alternative method for a fast and cost-efficient production of
asymmetric gears for prototype tests is presented. The focus is on the grinding process from a full blank test
specimen. This process was applied at the FZG in cooperation with Liebherr-Verzahntechnik GmbH in order to
produce asymmetrical test gears for experimental investigations of the tooth root bending strength. Very good
results were achieved with regard to gear quality and shape accuracy, especially in the tooth root area, which is
then investigated. The results of this paper show therefore a suitable method for the fast, precise and cost-
efficient production of special gears for prototype tests.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-059-8
19FTM21. A Comparison of Surface Roughness Measurement Methods for Gear Tooth Working Surfaces
Author: Matthew Wagner, Aaron Isaacson, Mark Michaud, and Matt Bell
Surface roughness is a critical parameter for gears operating under a variety of conditions. It directly influences
friction and contact temperature, and therefore has an impact on various failure modes such as macropitting,
micropitting and scuffing. Typically, gear tooth surface roughness is measured using a stylus profilometer, which
yields a two dimensional cross section of the surface from which roughness parameters are taken.
Stylus profilometry can produce inconsistent results if measurements are not executed correctly. Variables such
as measurement parameters, stylus tip radius, and repeatability of stylus orientation relative to the gear tooth can
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
19FTM22. Influence of the Load-Dependent Shift of the Center Distance of Cylindrical Gears on the
Calculated Load Capacity and Noise Excitation Using an Analytical Mesh Stiffness Approach
Author: Stoyan Radev
The nominal center distance in cylindrical gears is defined for the non-loaded state. The center distance changes
under load conditions, which leads to a reduction of the plane of contact and respectively of the length of the
effective path of contact. The effective total contact ratio is also shortened. This affects the load and pressure
distribution on the flank and thus the load capacity of the gears. The transmission error is also mutated, which
affects the noise excitation of the gear pair.
For the analysis of these effects, we are using an analytical approach for the calculation of the local mesh
stiffness. It is based on the Schmidt plate theory and the local gear tooth deformation approach according to
Weber-Banaschek. We are evaluating the load capacity using the calculated pressure distribution on the flanks
based on the static deformation analysis of the gear system. Shafts are modelled analytically as Timoshenko
beams and bearings are considered as non-linear elements depending on the internal contact situation. In
addition, the tooth root stresses are taken into consideration using a boundary element method (BEM). The noise
excitation is evaluated using transmission error, force excitation, and other resulting characteristic values. These
are formed using a Fourier transformation and level formation. This analytical approach allows excellent
calculating precision while achieving high calculation performance. This paper shows the importance of
considering the load-dependent change of the center distance for the calculation and layout of cylindrical gears.
Furthermore, we show the advantages of using an analytical approach for calculating mesh stiffness.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-061-1
19FTM23. New Standardized Calculation Method of the Tooth Flank Fracture Load Capacity of Bevel and
Hypoid Gears
Author: Josef Pellkofer, Michael Hein, Karsten Stahl, Tobias Reimann, and Ivan Boiadjiev
Bevel and hypoid gears are widespread in automotive, industrial, marine and aeronautical applications for
transmitting power between crossed axles. Future trends show that the demands on bevel and hypoid gears for
higher power transmission and lower weight are continuously increasing. A major aspect in the design process is
therefore the load carrying capacity regarding different failure modes. Beside typical fatigue failures like pitting and
tooth root breakage, which are the results of cracks initiated at or just below the surface, there are also failures
caused by cracks starting in greater material depth in the area of the active flank that can be observed on bevel
and hypoid gears. These cracks typically propagate to the tooth root area of the unloaded flank and to the surface
of the active flank. The failure mode known as tooth flank fracture occurs particularly frequently on large spiral
bevel and hypoid gears because this gear type shows larger equivalent radii of curvature compared to spur and
helical gears. As a result of the larger equivalent radius of curvature the maximum shear stress occurs in a larger
material depth, where the material of a case hardened gear shows a decreased strength. Important parameters
influencing the tooth flank fracture load capacity are geometry, operating conditions, material and heat treatment
of the gear set. Tooth flank fracture usually leads to the total breakdown of the gearbox and generally occurs
suddenly and unexpected since the crack initiation and propagation takes place below the tooth surface and
therefore cannot be identified within visual inspections.
This paper will give an overview of the subsurface failure mode known as tooth flank fracture on bevel and hypoid
gears. Further a newly developed standardized calculation method for determining the tooth flank fracture load
capacity based on the geometry of virtual cylindrical gear according to the standard ISO 10300 (2014) will be
explained in detail.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-062-8
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
18FTM03. Optimization of a Rack and Pinion Design for Offshore Jack-Up Applications
Author: Adrian Nowoisky
Lift boats or Jack up oil rigs are essential for the oil and gas industry. One offshore jacking system is pinion and
rack to elevate legs and hull in operation. It is well known that rack and pinion of such applications exceed the
permissible contact stress by the factor of 2 to 5. The design and evaluation of such systems is still a technical
challenge. The pinion will be typically highly modified and analyzed based on the Hertzian contact stress theory of
two cylinders in contact. This method will show how to start with a basic rack and pinion design. The true involute
profile of the pinion will be replaced with a multi radii profile. In a second step, the pinion design will be analytical
optimized to reduce the contact stress and improve the life expectation. The influence of major gear parameter
such as module, profile shift coefficient as well as the pressure angle will be analyzed and explained. The results
of the final pinion will be compared with an existing pinion design to evaluate and discuss a reuse of existing
hardware. The results of the final designs will be verified by a numerical method. This paper demonstrates the
impact of major gear parameters for a pinion design and their impact on the life expectation. The benefit of a
custom pinion design and how much improvement can be achieved with emphasizing the design process properly
will be shown. Furthermore it shall serve as a guideline for best practice to design a rack and pinion for offshore
jacking applications.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-006-2 Pages: 13
18FTM04. Gearbox Development for the Food and Beverage Processing Industry
Author: Sandeep V. Thube
Industry-specific power transmission needs can be efficiently served by a streamlined product development
process. The ‘Food and Beverage’ industry has a variety of gearbox applications which are regulated by
governmental industry standards, such as NSF and FDA. The scope of this paper is to design and construct a
gearbox in compliance with these standards, which may be substantially different from typical industrial
requirements.
The paper discusses details of a gearbox development for food and beverage applications. It mainly includes
stainless steel housing and shaft designs, as well as oil seal, bearing and lubricant selections. The development
process utilizes tools, viz. Quality Function Deployment (QFD), Failure Mode Evaluation Analysis (FMEA),
computational ‘Finite Element Analysis’ (FEA), and 3D printing followed by prototype testing. QFD is used to
prioritize features to be included in the product. Potential failures of the gearbox are identified with FMEA. The
structural and thermal optimization of the newly designed housing is performed using FEA. 3D printing is utilized
to find design defect at early stage, and validate the gearbox assembly procedure. Minimizing the number of
physical prototype testing and iterations is the primary objective for the utilization of these tools.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-007-9 Pages: 20
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
18FTM08. Oil-Off Characterization Method Using In-Situ Friction Measurement for Gears Operating Under
Loss-of-Lubrication Conditions
Authors: Aaron C. Isaacson and Matthew E. Wagner
The oil-off performance evaluation of gears is of significant interest to the Department of Defense and various
rotorcraft manufacturers, so that the aircraft can safely land in an accidental loss-of-lubricant situation. However,
unlike typical gear failure modes, gear failure in an oil-off situation is very rapid and likely catastrophic. This paper
describes the procedure and instrumentation utilized for an oil-off test to measure the frictional loss in the test
gear mesh and the “air” temperature just out of mesh. Sound and vibration data was also recorded during testing.
Data from typical failures showing the detection of scuffing onset and its progression to catastrophic failure for
gears made from several aerospace alloy steels is presented.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-011-6 Pages: 17
18FTM09. Application of Finite Element Analysis for the Strain Wave Gear Tooth Surfaces Design and
Modifications
Authors: Zhiyuan Yu and Kwun-Lon Ting
This paper is on a rigorous definition and parametric study of tooth surface modification of the strain wave gear.
You will see that optimal modification for a sample strain wave gear is found from FEA and tested by contact
pattern, transmission error, and life cycling experiments. The resulting innovative design with modified fully
conjugate tooth surface improves accuracy, backlash, and the life of the existing design.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-012-3 Pages: 15
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
18FTM12. Load Intensity Distribution Factor Evaluation from Strain Gauges at the Gear Root
Authors: José Calvo Irisarri, Unai Gutierrez Santiago, Alfredo Fernández Sisón, and Pedro Olalde Arce
Strain gauges are commonly used to obtain the load intensity distribution on the flank of a gear mesh. To get the
load distribution on the flank, the strain data must be processed and changed into load intensity distribution on the
tooth flank. Research has been conducted on the best methodology to place strain gauges when calculating load
intensity distribution on the flanks of a gear. This paper discusses these research methods that use FEM models
and his analysis of how to deal with the effect of strain gauge positioning errors, in order to find the optimal
placement.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-015-4 Pages: 18
18FTM13. Impact of Root Geometry Manufacturing Deviations from a Theoretical Hob Rack on Gear Bending
Stress
Authors: Rahul V. Nigade and Carlos H. Wink
Gear reliability is a key requirement of any automotive transmission. Two common failure modes of gears are
pitting and bending fatigue. So, the total gearing reliability depends upon the bending and pitting reliability. This
paper discusses a comparison of a theoretical root fillet geometry generated by the hob racks of gear drawings to
an actual measured tooth fillet geometry of manufactured gears, which determines the impact of the different root
fillet geometries on tooth bending stresses. An emphasis is placed on the importance of using a root fillet
geometry truly representative of the actual gears in production for the bending stress calculation so that the
required bending reliability can be achieved in the field.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-016-1 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
18FTM16. Microgear Measurement Standards: Comparing Tactile, Optical and Computed Tomography
Measurements
Authors: Stephan Jantzen, Martin Stein, Karin Kniel, and Andreas Dietzel
Microgears are widely used in industry, as they are essential components of gearboxes used in precision
engineering, medical technology, and robotics. This paper discusses the development of a new internal involute
microgear measurement standard for research and industry. A comparison between the tactile calibration
performed using a micro coordinate measuring machine (µCMM) and the measurement results obtained by
means of a computer tomography (CT) system and optical CMM will be presented. The new results, compared
with the results of the comparison measurements of the external microgear measurement standard, are
discussed. The results and discussion will provide an overview of the state of the art in microgear metrology.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-019-2 Pages: 23
18FTM18. Reducing Tool Wear in Spiral Bevel Gear Machining with the Finite Element Method
Authors: Fang Hou, Yantao Zhang, Syed Wasif, Pete Mattson, and Kerry Marusich
Due to the complexity of spiral bevel gear machining, the cutting tools can be a significant cost of gear
manufacturing. Unlike the price of material which is fixed by the market, the cost of tooling and subsequent re-
grinding can be reduced through reducing tool wear and increasing tool life. This paper discusses an alternative
approach to physical testing for predicting and reducing tool wear using the finite element method. This virtual
design approach utilizes real-world cutting tool geometry, automatically generated gear blanks, and known
process kinematics to simulate the cutting process. Additionally, lessons learned, potential benefits and pitfalls of
this approach to tool wear reduction and future work will be discussed.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-021-5 Pages: 13
18FTM20. Fully Automated Roughness Measurement on Gears, Even on the Shop Floor
Author: Georg Mies, Klingelnberg
For many years, the focus of the design of precision components for transmissions has been on optimizing gear
geometry. The work in this area has come so far that we are now seeing a shift from design to a concentration on
surface quality of the functional surfaces. The roughness of highly stressed gear flanks has significant influences
on noise, wear, and power loss. Thanks to new or improved machining technologies, extremely smooth surfaces
can now be produced cost-effectively. The need now arises for reliable measurement of roughness of gears. This
paper discusses the newest solution that enables fully automatic measurements of gear geometry and roughness
in one clamping.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-023-9 Pages: 14
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
18FTM25. Combining Ultra-High-Strength and Toughness for Affordable Power Densification in Steel Gears
Author: E. Buddy Damm
In the last few years, improvements in clean steel technology have been coupled with development of new ultra-
high-strength, high-toughness steels. These technologies provide affordable solutions for critical, power-dense
components. This paper reviews and compares steel cleanness metrics between re-melted steels and steels that
meet AGMA grade 3 cleanness. The new steels provide yield strengths ranging from 175-210 KSI, ultimate tensile
strengths ranging from 230-250 KSI, and Charpy impact energies ranging from 35 to 50 ft.-lbs., allowing these
grades to provide longer life, more power, and/or lighter weight. The higher fatigue strength of these steels is
compared to more commonly used gear steels, and an analysis is presented that illustrates a potential for either a
30% reduction in gear set mass or a 45% increase in gear set torque capacity.
ISBN: 978-1-64353-028-4 Pages: 15
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
17FTM02. Understanding the Dynamic Influences of Gear Oils and Radial Shaft Seals
Authors: Matthias Adler, Joe Walker, Sascha Grasshoff, Craig Desrochers, Matthias Pfadt
Approximately 40 percent of long-term gearbox leakages can be traced back to poor interaction between the
Radial Shaft Seal (RSS) and the lubricant. This paper highlights the most critical interactions between the
industry’s most commonly used gear oil formulations, with emphasis on synthetic oils with Nitrile- and
Fluoroelastomers. Through an ideal combination of base oil and additives, the demand of life expectancy on the
radial shaft seals can be met.
ISBN: 1-55589-529-7 Pages: 15
17FTM03. Gear Tooth Strength Analysis of High Pressure Angle Cylindrical Gears
Authors: Alfonso Fuentes-Aznar, Ignacio Gonzalez-Perez
In this paper, the gear tooth strength of high pressure angle gears is studied and compared with that of
conventional pressure angle gears. The comparison will be performed regarding contact pressure, contact and
bending stresses, loaded function of transmission errors, and comparison of errors of alignment and shift of
contact pattern when mounted in similar shafts.
ISBN: 1-55589-537-2 Pages: 18
17FTM04. The Effectiveness of Shrouding on Reducing Meshed Spur Gear Power Loss – Test Results
Authors: Irebert R. Delgado, M. J. Hurrell
Reducing power losses to rotorcraft gearboxes, due to windage drag and viscous effects on rotating, meshed gear
components would allow gains in areas such as vehicle payload, range, mission type, and fuel consumption. One
method used in rotorcraft gearbox design attempts to reduce losses is to use close clearance walls to enclose the
gears in both the axial and radial directions. This paper examines using meshed spur gears at four shroud
configurations and compares the data to available data.
ISBN: 1-55589-547-1 Pages: 15
17FTM06. The Effect of Asymmetric Cutter Tip Radii on Gear Tooth Root Bending Stress
Authors: Abdullah Akpolat, Nihat Yildirim, Burak Sahin, Omer Yildirim, Bulent Karatas, Fatih Erdogan
The tooth root fillet is where the maximum bending stress concentration region is located during torque
transmission via gear pairs. An increase in gear root fillet radius provides a smooth transition from involute to
trochoid, increases root critical section thickness, and the moment of inertia against bending of tooth. A 10-11%
reduction in bending stress is obtained by using asymmetric cutter tip radii coefficients for two sides of the gear
tooth profile with standard center distance and no tooth interference.
ISBN: 1-55589-568-6 Pages: 20
17FTM07. Magnetic Barkhausen Noise as an Alternative to Nital Etch for the Detection of Grind Temper
on Gears
Authors: James Thomas, Stephen Kendrish
Magnetic Barkhausen Noise (MBN), is quantitative, repeatable, and non-destructive. Further, the MBN method is
easily automated thus removing operator influence, as seen with Nital Etch, as a variable. Using a sample set of
carburized spur gears ground to varying conditions of grinding burn, the MBN method is demonstrated to match or
exceed the detection effectiveness of traditional Nital Etch. Residual stress depth distributions measured with x-
ray diffraction and electrochemical layer removal are utilized as a quantitative verification method.
ISBN: 1-55589-570-9 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
17FTM11. FE-Based Method for Design of Robust Tooth Flank Modifications for Cylindrical and Planetary
Gear Stages Regarding Manufacturing Tolerances
Authors: Christian Brecher, Christoph Löpenhaus, Julian Theling, Marius Schroers, Daniel Piel
The authors present a method to evaluate the quality and stability of flank modifications regarding manufacturing
tolerances during the design process, using an FE-based tooth contact analysis. The presented design process
provides a method to examine and simulate characteristics of the excitation behavior and durability of a gear pair.
This enables the engineer to choose the most robust micro-geometry in terms of quality and stability already in the
design process.
ISBN: 1-55589-616-4 Pages: 17
17FTM13. A Comparison of Current AGMA, ISO and API Gear Rating Methods
Authors: John M. Rinaldo
There are many different gear rating methods in use today, and they can give substantially different results for any
given gear set. This paper will make it easy to understand the choices and the impact the choices have on
gearbox design. The eight standards examined are AGMA 2001, AGMA 6011, AGMA 6013, ISO 6336, API 613,
API 617, API 672, and API 677. This paper will provide a useful aid to customers who are unsure of the
differences between the standards.
ISBN: 1-55589-627-0 Pages: 45
17FTM14. Prediction of Dynamic Factors for Helical Gears in a High-Speed Multi-Body Gearbox System
Authors: Niranjan Raghuraman, Chad Glinsky, Sharad Jain
This paper will analyze the influence of operating speed, torque, system dynamics, and gear micro-geometry on
the dynamic factors of a high-speed gearbox. It will show that the dependence of dynamic factor on torque is
significant and must not be ignored, and that the presence of system resonance modes increases dynamic
factors. The dynamic factors calculated in this study are compared with the dynamic factor values suggested by
ISO and AGMA standards.
ISBN: 1-55589-628-7 Pages: 21
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
17FTM16. Predicting Life on Through Hardened Steel Rack and Pinion for Jacking Applications in the
Offshore Industry
Authors: Adrian Nowoisky
It is well known in the industry that, according to AGMA and ISO gear calculation methods, the contact stresses in
rack and pinion systems for jack up applications exceed the permissible limits by a factor of 3 to 6. However,
these applications have been in service without any failures for more than 20 years. This paper will outline the
process of the analytical evaluation of a specific design and validate it with systems currently in service.
*ISBN (former): 1-55589-736-9* Pages: 14
ISBN (new): 978-1-61481-400-9
*Please note that due to a technical error, this ISBN has changed. Please disregard the previous number.
17FTM18. Effect of Non-metallic Inclusions on Bending Fatigue Performance in High Strength 4140 Steel
Authors: Michael Burnett
This paper studies the fatigue performance of three sets of quench and tempered 4140 steel samples,
representing three distinctly different inclusion populations. The inclusion populations for each of the sample sets
were characterized using both an SEM-based image analysis system, primarily for the micro-inclusions, and a
high-resolution UT system for the macro-inclusions. The sample sets were also evaluated using both longitudinal
and transverse specimens in all the bending fatigue tests. The results of these tests will be presented.
ISBN: 1-55589-759-8 Pages: 23
17FTM19. Sensitivity Study of Press Quench Process and Concept of Tooling Design for Reduced Distortion
by Modeling
Authors: Zhichao (Charlie) Li, B. Lynn Ferguson
The press quench process includes parameters such as heating rate, austenitization temperature, applied load
type, load amount, load locations from the tooling, friction between the tooling and the gear, and the quench rate.
All these factors can lead to inconsistent distortion, especially for the radial size of thin-wall gears. In this paper,
the effects of several critical factors on the dimensional inconsistency and tooling design are analyzed by heat
treatment modeling software.
ISBN: 1-55589-760-4 Pages: 17
17FTM20. Influences of the Residual Stress Condition on the Load Carrying Capacity of Case
Hardened Gears
Authors: Christian Güntner, Thomas Tobie, Karsten Stahl
Compressive residual stresses, such as those generated by shot peening, result in an increased tooth root
bending strength. The author’s investigations show that shot peening can increase the load carrying capacity of
case hardened gears significantly. Correlations between the residual stress state and the load carrying capacity
limits were determined. This paper will give an overview of the main results of different investigations and discuss
influences of the residual stress condition on different failure modes of case hardened gears.
ISBN: 1-55589-761-1 Pages: 18
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
17FTM22. Full Contact Analysis Versus Standard Load Capacity Calculation for Cylindrical Gears
Authors: Michael Otto, Uwe Weinberger, Karsten Stahl
In this paper, local tooth contact analysis and standard calculation are used to determine the load capacity for the
failure modes pitting, tooth root breakage, micropitting and tooth flank breakage. Analogies and differences
between both the local and the standard approaches are shown. The example presented demonstrates a valid
possibility to optimize the gear design by using local tooth contact analysis while satisfying the requirement of
documenting the load carrying capacity by standard calculations.
ISBN: 1-55589-763-5 Pages: 14
17FTM23. The Influence of a Grinding Notch on the Gear Bending Strength Rating
Authors: Ulrich Kissling, Ioannis Zotos
To achieve the requested quality, most gears today are ground. If the gear is premanufactured with a tool without
protuberance, then at the position where the grinding tool retracts from the flank, a grinding notch in the tooth root
area is produced. A review of the formulas to calculate the effects of the grinding notch is necessary. A 3D-FEM
analysis that was used to deduce an improved formula will be presented.
ISBN: 1-55589-764-2 Pages: 19
2016 PAPERS
16FTM01. Efficient Hard Finishing of Asymmetric Tooth Profiles and Topological Modifications
by Generating Grinding
Authors: Andreas Mehr & Scott Yoders
New possibilities of modifications with the continuous generating grinding method will be presented, such as
Deviation Free Topological grinding (DFT), Generated End Relief (GER), Noise Excitation Optimized modification
(NEO), and hard finishing of asymmetric gears. The focus is on the explanation of the technical challenges, their
solutions, and the principle function of the dressing and grinding processes.
ISBN: 1-55589-060-5 Pages: 13
16FTM02. The Whirling Process in a Company that Produces Worm Gear Drives
Authors: Dr. Massimiliano Turci, Dr. Giampaolo Giacomozzi
This paper looks at the benefits that can be realized with the introduction a whirling machine into the wormgear
manufacturing facility. The benefits include time and cost savings, especially in regard to the need for grinding,
increased quality, and environmental considerations due to not needing cutting oils.
ISBN: 1-55589-061-2 Pages: 22
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
16FTM07. Performance and Machining of Advanced Engineering Steels in Power Transmission Applications
– Continued Developments
Authors: Lily Kamjou, Nicklas Bylund, Brent Marsh, Joakim Fagerlund, Thomas Björk
This paper discusses the potential gain for the power transmissions industry by making use of the material
properties of Advanced Engineering Steels to support more demanding applications. Machining the Advanced
Engineering Steels is discussed based on a number of recent studies. All studies indicate that by optimizing
machining parameters and tools, the productivity and efficiency of these processes can be maintained, or even
improved.
ISBN: 1-55589-067-4 Pages: 16
16FTM09. Development of High Hardness-Cast Gears for High-Power Applications in the Mining Industry
Author: Fabrice Wavelet
Multiple solutions are available to increase the transmissible power of girth gears, including using a larger module,
increasing the gear diameter, enlarging the face width, and increasing the hardness of the base material. Base
material hardness, the only parameter that is not limited by cutting machine size, is being increased to meet
higher power needs. This paper will review the related design and manufacturing impact of the high-hardness
gears needed to meet today’s industry demands.
ISBN: 1-55589-069-8 Pages: 14
16FTM10. Computerized Design of Straight Bevel Gears with Optimized Profiles for Forging, Molding,
or 3D Printing
Authors: Alfonso Fuentes, Ignacio Gonzalez-Perez, and Harish Pasapula
Research will be presented on whether there is a reference profile that will yeild the same advantages for bevel
gears as the involute for cylindrical gears. The spherical involute and octoidal profiles will be studied, and the
virtual generation of bevel gears with the different profiles will be developed, and simulated, using advanced tools
such as tooth contact analysis and finite element analysis.
ISBN: 1-55589-111-4 Pages: 21
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
16FTM13. Designing Very Strong Gear Teeth by Means of High Pressure Angles
Author: Richard Miller
This paper will show a method of designing and specifying gear teeth with much higher bending and surface
contact strength than that of conventional gear teeth. The primary means of achieving this is by specifying gear
teeth with significantly higher pressure angles. This paper will show calculation procedures, mathematical
solutions, and the theoretical background and equations to achieve this.
ISBN: 1-55589-114-5 Pages: 22
16FTM14. Impact of Surface Condition and Lubricant on Effective Gear Tooth Friction Coefficient
Authors: Aaron Isaacson, Matthew Wagner, Suren Rao, and Gary Sroka
Using a four-square, power re-circulating gear test rig with high accuracy torque transducers, losses due to
operating speed, surface roughness, and torque level, including two different lubricants, were compared, and
measurements of the effective coefficient of friction at the gear tooth flanks are provided. This paper summarizes
the results obtained.
ISBN: 1-55589-118-3 Pages: 12
16FTM17. Analysis of Excitation Behavior of a Two-Stage Gearbox Based on a Validated Simulation Model
Authors: Marius Schroers, Christian Brecher, and Christoph Löpenhaus
In order to reduce development and production costs of a gearbox, simulation models have been set up to predict
the noise and vibration behavior of a gearbox before the prototype phase. A simulation model, verified by
experimental results, is presented that is able to calculate the dynamic excitation behavior of a two-stage gearbox.
ISBN: 1-55589-121-3 Pages: 16
16FTM18. An Experimental and Analytical Comparison of the Noise Generated by Gears of Austempered
Ductile Iron (ADI) and Steel Materials
Authors: Dr. Donald Houser, Samuel Shon, Kathy Hayrynen, Justin Lefevre
Many have made claims concerning the relative noise performance of Austempered Ductile Iron (ADI) versus
steel as a gearing material. Predictions based on measured tooth topographies of the transmission error and "sum
of forces" gear noise metrics show that the iron gears should be slightly quieter than the steel gears at loads
beneath the transmission error optimization "notch" torque and slightly louder above this torque. This paper
presents results from a systematic experimental study to ascertain these differences.
ISBN: 1-55589-122-0 Pages: 25
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
16FTM20. Influence of the Defect Size on the Tooth Root Load Carrying Capacity
Authors: Jens Brimmers, Christian Brecher, Christoph Löpenhaus, and Jannik Henser
Conventional calculation methods for the flank and tooth root load carrying capacity are well-established, but
models that consider the defect size on the tooth root strength have not yet been applied in fatigue models for
gears. This paper will introduce a method for calculating the tooth root load carrying capacity for gears while
considering the influence of the defect size on the endurance fatigue strength of the tooth root.
ISBN: 1-55589-176-3 Pages: 14
16FTM21. Influence of Contact Conditions on the Onset of Micropitting in Rolling-Sliding Contacts Pertinent
to Gear Applications
Authors: Dr. Amir Kadiric & Dr. Pawel Rycerz
Recently, increased sliding has been one of the factors suggested to be responsible for the onset of micropitting,
with the proposed underlying mechanism being the potential reduction of film thickness through increased sliding
speed. This paper attempts to shed light on the tribological conditions that may lead to the onset of micropitting in
lubricated, concentrated contacts representative of those occurring between gear teeth. In particular, the effect of
slide-roll-ratio, surface roughness and film thickness is studied.
ISBN: 1-55589-480-1 Pages: 19
16FTM22. Comparison of Tooth Interior Fatigue Fracture Load Capacity to Standardized Gear Failure Modes
Authors: Baydu Al, Paul Langlois, Rupesh Patel
This study aims to improve the existing understanding of Tooth Interior Fatigue Fracture (TIFF) load capacity and
compare calculated load capacity to the allowable loading conditions for bending and pitting fatigue failure, based
on standard calculation procedures. Possible methods that could be used to mitigate TIFF risk are presented, and
the effect of these methods on the performance with respect to the other failure modes are quantified.
ISBN: 1-55589-497-9 Pages: 19
16FTM23. A New Approach to Repair Large Industrial Gears Damaged by Surface Degradation – The
Refurbishment Using the Modification of Both the Profile Shift Coefficient and the Pressure Angle
Authors: Horacio Albertini, Carlo Gorla, Francesco Rosa
Superficial degradation of industrial gears, and a lack of approaches to repair them, have resulted in many gears
being discarded prematurely. This paper presents a computer program and method for repairing industrial gears,
enabled by the recent advances in multi-axis CNC machine centers, and gear grinding, that considers the
modification of both the profile shift coefficient and the pressure angle.
ISBN: 1-55589-234-0 Pages: 20
2015 PAPERS
15FTM01. Influence of Surface Finishing on the Load Capacity of Coated and Uncoated Spur Gears
Authors: P. Konowalczyk, C. Brecher
In order to increase the power density of tribologically stressed drive train components, different approaches are
being pursued in material and production technology. In addition to the development of efficient base materials,
especially the optimization of surface finishing processes and the application of coating systems are promising. By
combining mechanically highly stressable substrate materials and tribologically effective, extremely thin coatings,
the components show modified wear and friction properties, which often lead to an increase of tooth flank load
carrying capacity. A major advantage of this approach is that the highly accurate component geometry is only
slightly changed by the coating.
The influence of PVD/PECVD hard coatings on the load carrying capacity of cylindrical gears made of alloy steel
is the subject of scientific research since the nineties. Several reports show that diamond-like carbon (DLC)
coating systems reduce the occurrence of specific forms of gear damages, such as pitting or scuffing, and
optimize the frictional behavior of gears. Despite the good results, PVD/PECVD coating technology could not be
established in gear transmission technology yet. The use of a PVD/PECVD coating leads to higher component
costs and longer manufacturing time. Furthermore, the surface finishing process before coating can influence the
resulting tooth flank load capacity, and in some studies, a reduction of tooth root strength by the application of a
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM02. Improved Materials and Enhanced Fatigue Resistance for Gear Components
Authors: Dr. Volker Heuer, Dr. Klaus Loeser, Gunther Schmitt
This paper shows the latest progress in steel grades and in case hardening technology for gear components.
To answer the demand for fuel-efficient vehicles, modern gear boxes are built much lighter. Improving fatigue
resistance is a key factor to allow for the design of thin components to be used in advanced vehicle transmissions.
The choice of material and the applied heat treat process are of key importance to enhance the fatigue resistance
of gear components.
By applying the technology of Low Pressure Carburizing (LPC) and High Pressure Gas Quenching (HPGQ), the
tooth root bending strength can be significantly enhanced, compared to traditional heat treatment with
atmospheric carburizing and oil quenching.
Besides heat treatment, significant progress has been made over the past years on the steels being used for gear
components. The hardenability of case hardening steels such as 5130H, 5120H, 20MnCr5, 27MnCr5,
18CrNiMo7-6 etc. has been stepwise increased in recent years. An important factor for fatigue resistance is the
grain size after heat treatment. Therefore, grain size control is a key goal when developing new modifications of
steel grades.
After enhancing grain size control, it was possible to increase the carburizing temperatures over the past years
from 930°C to 980°C (1700°F to 1800°F) which resulted in shorter heat treatment cycles and thus in significant
cost savings.
With the introduction of new microalloyed steels for grain size stability, carburizing temperatures can now be even
further increased to temperatures of up to 1050°C (1920°F), leading to even more economic process cycles. By
adding microelements such as Niobium or Titanium in the ppm-range, nitride and carbonitride-precipitates are
formed. These precipitates effectively limit the grain-growth during the heat treatment process.
ISBN: 1-55589-008-7 Pages: 16
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM05. Innovative Steel Design and Gear Machining of Advanced Engineering Steel
Authors: Lily Kamjou, Patrik Ölund, Erik Claesson, Joakim Fagerlund, Garry Wicks, Mats Wennmo,
Hans Hansson
The basis for high fatigue performance in high hardness steel originates in precise inclusion engineering. In
addition, recent research shows that by changing the alloying strategy, an increase in the bending fatigue limit can
be achieved similar to an additional shot-peening process. Therefore, the near surface structure will exhibit
excellent mechanical properties and compressive residual stresses in the as-carburized condition.
The current paper describes the potential of clean steel for new approaches in transmission gear box
manufacturing and possibilities to meet the future demands of being smaller, lighter and managing higher torque.
One important factor is the bending fatigue performance of the gear teeth where an increasing fatigue strength is
required. The paper discusses how shot peening might be eliminated in high-cleanliness, as-carburized steel
components using an alternative composition. The fatigue performance of such a solution is compared to
conventional grades used today, both with and without shot peening.
The full benefit of this new steel design can be obtained by using a high-quality steel with a decreased number of
critically-sized inclusions in the loaded volume. Results from extensive testing support how this type of steel
compares to commonly used carburizing steels. The effect of material cleanliness on contact fatigue is also
examined through FZG pitting testing.
To address potential machining issues of clean steels, the paper also deals with the production process, including
quantitative machining trials and the importance of tooling selection. The study is focused on the production of
gears, dealing mainly with turning and hobbing. Initial results show how these clean steels can be machined in full
scale production in standard conditions with equal or better efficiency and cost.
ISBN: 1-55589-016-2 Pages: 12
15FTM06. Powder Metal Gear Technology: A Review of the State of the Art
Author: Anders Flodin
During the past 10 years, the PM industry has put a lot of focus on how to make Powder Metal gears for
automotive transmissions a reality. To reach this goal, several hurdles had to be overcome, such as fatigue data
generation on gears, verification of calculation methods, production technology, materials development, heat
treatment recipes, design development, and cost studies.
All of these advancements will be discussed, and a number of vehicles with powder metal gears in their
transmissions will be presented. How the transmissions have been redesigned in order to achieve the required
stress levels while minimizing weight and inertia, thus increasing efficiency, will also be discussed.
ISBN: 1-55589-017-9 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM10. Influence of Hobbing Tool Generating Scallops on Root Fillet Stress Concentrations
Authors: Benjamin S. Sheen, Matthew Glass
In the design of gear and spline teeth, the root fillet area and its maximum tensile stress are of primary concern for
the gear designer. In general terms, the tensile stress in the root fillet is based on specific geometries of the
design: minor diameter, fillet radius, etc. However, additional concerns regarding the manufacturing method,
cutting tool geometry, and process parameters can greatly influence the impact of stress concentration factors in
the root fillet area.
For a hobbed tooth manufacturing process, the root fillet geometry is controlled by the rack design of the cutter,
but also by the number of generating scallops produced by the tool. For a shaping process, the generating
scallops are close together and can produce a surface with almost no visible signs of root fillet generating
scallops. However, for a hobbing process, the number of threads, number of gashes, and tip radius can create
multiple variations of generated scallops. These can create stress concentrations, which can increase the tensile
bending stress and potentially impact the service life of the component. For this discussion, stress concentrations
caused by root fillet generating scallops will be reviewed.
This paper will discuss a specific example regarding parallel-sided splines manufactured with a finish hobbing
process and their effects on generating root fillet stress concentrations. To estimate the value of the stress
concentrations, Finite Element Analysis was performed on the components for two unique hobbing tool designs.
The FE results are compared to actual component field service histories.
ISBN: 1-55589-021-6 Pages: 10
15FTM11. Selecting the Proper Gear Milling Cutter Design for the Machining of High Quality Parallel Axis,
Cylindrical Gears and Splines
Author: Brent Marsh
Gear milling cutters offer a versatile and timesaving solution for milling of high-quality gear profiles. Application
methods vary. There are many ways to utilize these cutters. Machines range from traditional gear hobbing
machines with single indexing capability to horizontal and vertical CNC machining centers with 4- or 5-axis
capability, modern multi-task turning and milling centers, CNC lathes with live milling capability, and dedicated
special-purpose machines.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM12. Simulation of Hobbing and Generation Grinding to Solve Quality and Noise Problems
Author: Günther Gravel
Due to increasing tolerance requirements for gearboxes and gears, it has become more and more important to
establish quality circles in production. A quick detection and correction of the causes of tolerance violation is
essential for high quality. This paper shows the possibilities and procedures of searching for the root cause in
general, especially with problems in hobbing and generation grinding using multi-start tools.
A new simulation tool has been developed, which allows for the simulation of typical faults that occur during
hobbing and generation grinding. The calculated contour on the workpiece is treated as a measured curve,
making it easy to compare workpiece measurements and simulations. In this way, possible error causes can be
simulated and compared with the real gear surface.
This paper uses practical examples to demonstrate the following applications for simulation. The influence of the
tool parameter’s "number of starts" and "number of flutes" on the cutting result is shown in connection with the
axial feed parameter. Protuberance and tooth tip rounding on the tool influence the profile form generated on the
workpiece. Wobble and eccentric in the tool clamping creates an s-shaped pattern on the profile, based on the
number of starts on the tool. The form of the pattern changes with different parameters.
In high-speed gearboxes, ripples on the gear surfaces are frequently the cause of noise problems. Simulation of a
tool error and a subsequent evaluation of the ripples enable conclusions to be drawn about the excitations caused
by the tool error during the cutting process. A practical comparison between the ripple measurement of a hobbed
and subsequently honed gear and the simulation shows that the noise-related ripples on the finished part arises
already in the pre-machining stage.
The applications presented in this paper show that the results of the simulation are a very good match with
practical tests. Thus, the simulation software is a highly precise tool for determining and eliminating the causes of
deviations in production. At the same time, design engineers and planners can quickly and easily develop new
process and tool designs, thereby significantly reducing the costs involved in testing.
ISBN: 1-55589-023-0 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM15. New Refinements to the Use of AGMA Load Reversal and Reliability Factors
Author: Ernie Reiter
AGMA standards use load reversal and reliability factors in the calculation of the rated load capacity for gear
teeth. ANSI/AGMA 2101-D04 recommends the use of a load reversal factor of 1.0 for most gears which see one-
way bending, and 0.7 for gears such as idler gears and planet gears that see a fully reversing bending condition.
Likewise, the standard uses a table format to assign a reliability factor based on a desired reliability level in an
application.
This paper suggests two ways to calculate a load reversal factor which would be material specific, based either on
Modified Goodman or Gerber Failure Theories. This paper further provides a method of calculating the reliability
factors which very closely match the AGMA tables found in ANSI/AGMA 2101-D04.
ISBN: 1-55589-028-5 Pages: 15
15FTM17. Homogeneous Geometry Calculation of Arbitrary Tooth Shapes – Mathematical Approach and
Practical Applications
Authors: Maximilian Zimmer, M. Otto, Karsten Stahl,
As an extensive machine element to transfer and convert rotational movement, gears meet high requirements for
construction and assembly. Due to existing modern production techniques, more sophisticated gear types can be
produced with high precision and maintainable financial effort. The benefits of traditional gear profiles, such as an
involute, are thus no longer of major importance. In particular, for gear types such as bevel, worm, and hypoid
gears, but also for non-standard gear types (e.g., beveloid gears, crown gears, or spiroid gearings), modern gear
production systems ensure high quality and reliability to the operator. Depending on the context of application,
different gear types have advantages and disadvantages concerning load carrying capacity, effectiveness, or
noise excitation. Supported by various calculation software tools for the particular gear type, it is possible to create
the optimal gear design, depending on the respective application. A homogeneous calculation software for
ubiquitous gear geometries—irrespective of the gear type, and especially for analyzing non-standard gears—
would be preferable.
This paper provides a mathematical framework and its implementation for calculating the tooth geometry of
arbitrary gear types, based on the basic law of gear kinematics. The rack or gear geometry can be generated in
two different ways: by calculating the conjugate geometry and the line of contact of a gear to the given geometric
shape of a known geometry (e.g., a cutting hob), or by prescribing the surface of action of two gears in contact
and calculating the correspondent flank shapes. Besides so-called standard gears like involute spur and helical
gears, bevel or worm gears, it is possible to analyze the tooth geometry of non-standard gears (e.g., non-involute
spur, conical, or spiroid gears). Depending on the type of gear, a distinction is made between tool-dependent and
tool-independent geometry calculation.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM23. Noise Reduction in an EV Hub Drive Using a Full Test and Simulation Methodology
Authors: Owen J. Harris, P.P. Langlois, G.A. Cooper
With the current trend towards Electric Vehicles (EVs), there is likely to be increasing focus on the noise impact of
the gearing required for the transmission of power from the electric motor (high speed) to the road. Current
automotive Noise, Vibration and Harshness (NVH) understanding and methodologies for total in-vehicle noise
presuppose relatively large Internal Combustion (IC) contributions compared to gear noise. Further, it may be
advantageous to run the electric motors at significantly higher rotational speed than conventional automotive IC
engines putting the gear trains into higher speed ranges. Thus, the move to EV or Hybrid Electric Vehicles (HEV)
places greater or different demands on gear train noise.
This work combines both a traditional NVH approach (in-vehicle and rig noise, waterfall plots, Campbell diagrams,
and Fourier analysis)—with highly detailed transmission error measurement and simulation of the complete
drivetrain—to fully understand noise sources within an EV hub drive.
The transmission error testing has been performed on both the full assembly with the three-stage gear train and
on individual gear pairs using a dedicated transmission error measurement rig. Highly accurate rotary encoders
are used to measure transmission error through different stages of the gear train in order to identify sources of
excitation.
For comparison, a full Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE) model has been built, which includes the flexibilities of
all components, gears, shafts, bearings, and casing. Standard analysis is used to simulate the system deflection
under input loads with corresponding gear misalignments, contact patches, and transmission errors. Contact
patches are compared to tooth marking test results. Further, a novel advanced calculation is performed which
iteratively couples deflections of the full system model with detailed tooth contact analysis at the gear meshes.
This analysis shows how the gear meshes and the deflections of the full transmission change through the gear
meshing cycles. This analysis can include detailed, measured, manufactured gear geometry, and various
tolerances and errors within the system and calculate both the associated individual mesh and system
transmission errors and their harmonic content.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
15FTM24. Tribological Coating Wear and Durability Performance Guideline for Gear Applications
Authors: Randy Kruse, Carl Hager, Ryan D. Evans
Diamond-like carbon (DLC) tribological coatings have demonstrated the ability to provide gear and bearing
performance enhancements in an initially narrow but increasing range of applications. These experiences have
heightened awareness and curiosity in industry about the potential of DLC coatings to enhance the performance
of gear train systems. Valuable benefits may include reducing the probability of micropitting wear and increasing
scuffing resistance, perhaps even to enable improved oil-out performance in aerospace applications. The
application of these coatings may be used to increase gearbox efficiency, not by reducing friction within tooth
contacts, but by increasing tooth surface durability to allow for less viscous lubricants and reduced lubricant
quantities.
It is generally known that extreme contact pressure and sliding velocity operating conditions can lead to coating
wear. However, a better understanding of the thresholds that constrain coating durability and usefulness are
needed so that gear and bearing engineers can more accurately specify and predict system life. This paper
reports the results of testing a tungsten carbide-reinforced diamond-like carbon coating (W-DLC) as applied to
AISI 4320 and AMS6308 gear materials using a rotating ball-on-disk tribology test rig under a range of conditions
that simulate the contact stresses and sliding velocities of gears.
ISBN: 1-55589-036-0 Pages: 13
15FTM25. An Experimental Evaluation of the Procedures of the ISO/TR 15144 Technical Report for the
Prediction of Micropitting
Authors: Donald R. Houser, Samuel Shon
This paper presents the results of several experimental analyses to explore some of the features and
methodologies of ISO 15144. A summary of ISO 15144 is first discussed, as is a spreadsheet that has been
written, to accept contact stresses calculated from load distribution analyses. Sample load distribution analyses
and subsequent ISO predictions are made for several experimental results that are reported in the literature.
Following these analyses, a series of experimental durability tests were run using the AGMA tribology gears
running with Dexron 6 automatic transmission fluid as the lubricant. An FVA 54 test was run to obtain the lubricant
pass/fail level and the permissible value of Lambda needed to calculate the safety factor for micropitting.
ISBN: 1-55589-037-7 Pages: 18
15FTM26. Calculating the Risk of Micropitting Using ISO Technical Report 15144-1:2014 – Validation with
Practical Applications
Authors: Burkhard Pinnekamp, Michael Heider
Micropitting is a surface fatigue phenomenon on highly loaded gears with case-hardened gear flanks. Main
contributors are local stress, surface roughness, sliding speed, and lube oil properties.
General influence factors, testing, and earlier calculation methods were described in 11FTM15 [1]. Meanwhile, a
new version of the ISO Technical Report, TR 15144-1:2014 [2], was issued. It is intended to become an ISO
Standard within the next years.
This paper describes the definition of micropitting, the actual calculation method, and its application to practical
examples where micropitting has either occurred or not. The examples give evidence that the Technical Report
reliably predicts the risk of micropitting where it is later found on the gear flanks. For cases where no micropitting
occurs, the calculated safety factors are sufficiently high. Operating conditions for some examples are out of the
validated range of the Technical Report.
ISBN: 1-55589-038-4 Pages: 16
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
14FTM03 Surface Roughness Measurements of Cylindrical Gears and Bevel Gears on Gear
Inspection Machines
Author: G. Mikoleizig
Alongside the macro test parameters on tooth flanks for profile and tooth traces, surface properties (roughness)
play a decisive role in ensuring proper toothed gear function.
The generally increased load stresses on gear teeth can only be implemented by maintaining precisely defined
roughness parameters.
Roughness measurements are therefore conducted on the gearing flanks in all highly developed drives, in the
automotive industry, aircraft industry, or the area of wind energy drives, for example.
This article addresses roughness measurement systems on tooth flanks. In addition to universal test equipment,
modified test equipment based on the profile method for use on gears is addressed in particular. The equipment
application here refers to cylindrical gear flanks and bevel gear flanks.
ISBN: 1-61481-095-7 Pages: 13
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
14FTM08. The Efficiency of a Simple Spur Gearbox – A Thermally Coupled Lubrication Model
Authors: A.I. Christodoulias, A.V. Olver, A. Kadiric, A.E. Sworski, F.E. Lockwood
A thermally coupled efficiency model for a simple dip-lubricated gearbox is presented. The model includes
elastohydrodynamic friction losses in gear teeth contacts as well as bearing, seal and churning losses. An iterative
numerical scheme is used to fully account for the effects of contact temperature, pressure and shear rates on EHL
friction. The model is used to predict gearbox efficiency with selected transmission oils whose properties were first
obtained experimentally through rolling-sliding tribometer tests under representative contact conditions.
Although the gearbox was designed using standard methods against a fixed rating, the model was used to study
efficiency over a much wider range of conditions. Results are presented to illustrate the relative contribution of
different sources of energy loss and the effect of lubricant properties on the overall gearbox efficiency under
varying operating conditions.
ISBN: 1-61481-100-8 Pages: 18
14FTM10. Involute Spiral Face Couplings and Gears: Design Approach and Manufacturing Technique
Authors: A.L. Kapelevich, S.D. Korosec
Face gears typically have a straight or skewed tooth line and varying tooth profile in normal cross section at
different radii from major to minor diameter. These face gears are engaged with spur or helical involute pinions at
intersecting or crossed axes.
This paper presents spiral face gears with involute tooth line and identical tooth profile in the normal section at any
radius. There are two main applications for such face gears. One of them is an alternative solution with certain
advantages in performance and fabrication technology to the straight tooth, Hirth, or Curvic flange couplings.
Another application is when a face gear is engaged with an involute helical pinion or worm at intersecting or
crossed axes. Such engagement is also used in Helicon® type gears.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
14FTM11. Mathematical Modeling for the Design of Spiroid®, Helical, Spiral Bevel and Worm Gears
Author: G. Kazkaz
This paper will present a novel work for spiroid and worm gears that mathematically calculates the gear tooth
profile in terms of the geometry of the machining tool (hob) and the machining setup. Because of similarity, the
work was also expanded to spiral bevel gear. We have developed software to plot the gear tooth when the
parameters of the geometry of the tool and machining setup are entered. The gear tooth shape can then be
altered and optimized by manipulating the input parameters until a desired tooth profile is produced. In effect, the
result will be designing the hob and machining setup for best gear tooth profile on the computer. Afterward, the
generated gear tooth data are entered into CAD software to generate a true 3D model of the gear. The tool path
will also be generated from the data for CNC machining instead of hobbing.
ISBN: 1-61481-103-9 Pages: 16
14FTM14. Theoretical and Experimental Study of the Frictional Losses of Radial Shaft Seals for
Industrial Gearbox
Authors: M. Organisciak, P. Baart, S. Barbera, A. Paykin M. Schweig
In this paper SKF presents an engineering model for the prediction of radial lip seal friction based on a physical
approach. The friction model includes the generation of friction due to rubber dynamic deformation and lubricant
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
14FTM16. The Modified Life Rating of Rolling Bearings – A Criterion for Gearbox Design and
Reliability Optimization
Authors: A. Doyer, A. Gabelli, G. Morales-Espejel
This The concepts of rolling bearing rating life and basic load rating (load carrying capacity) were introduced by
Arvid Palmgren in 1937 [1]. At that time, until the 1950s, most bearing manufacturers listed in their catalogues the
load admissible on the bearing for thousands hours of operation at five different speeds. In those days the
selection of a bearing size for a given application was a rather simple and approximate matter.
The concept of a single rating factor to characterize the dynamic capacity of the bearing was new and initially
used only within the bearing company that developed this new technology. This rating method was backed by the
theory of Lundberg & Palmgren (L-P) [2] and by the Weibull statistics [3]. It was found that it could provide a
correct interpretation of the many series of endurance tests available at the time, [2], [4], [5]. This calculation
method prevailed on all the others methods used at the time and was adopted by ISO in 1962.
ISBN: 1-61481-108-4 Pages: 16
14FTM17. The Impact of Surface Condition and Lubricant on Gear Tooth Friction
Authors: S. Rao, A. Isaacson, G. Sroka, L. Winkelmann
Frictional losses in gear boxes are of significant interest to gear box designers as these losses transform into
heat. The direct result is a reduction in the fuel efficiency of the vehicle involved. Further, in many instances, this
heat has to be absorbed and dissipated so that lubricant properties and gear box performance are not significantly
compromised. This effort is to measure and document the comparative friction losses in a gear mesh due to gear
tooth surface condition and lubricant. Three distinct surface conditions are considered. They are ground, Isotropic
Superfinished (REM ISF®) and tungsten-incorporated diamond-like carbon coating (W-DLC). Two lubricants, MIL-
PRF-23699 and Mobil SHC 626 lubricants are considered.
The experimental effort is conducted on a high speed, power re-circulating (PC), gear test rig, which had been
specially instrumented with a precision torque transducer to measure input torque to the 4-square loop. The
torque required to drive the loop is measured under various speeds and tooth loads within the torque loop, with
test gears with different surface conditions and with different lubricants. Two operating torque levels within the
4-square loop at speeds ranging from 4,000 rpm (pitch-line velocity of 19 m/sec) to 10,000 rpm (pitch-line velocity
of 47 m/sec) are evaluated.
Based on the collected data a qualitative analysis of the effect of gear tooth surface condition on frictional losses
is presented. Further, the surface characteristics of the tooth flanks of the ground, superfinished and coated gears
are also described.
ISBN: 1-61481-109-1 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
14FTM19. Application of ICME to Optimize Metallurgy and Improve Performance of Carburizable Steels
Authors: J. Grabowski, J. Sebastian, A. Asphahani, C. Houser, K. Taskin, D. Snyder
QuesTek Innovations LLC has applied its Materials by Design® computational design technology and its
Integrated Computational Materials Engineering (ICME)-based methods to successfully design, develop and
implement two new high-performance gear steels (Ferrium® C61™ and Ferrium C64® steels) that are being used
in demanding gear and bearing applications in ground and aerospace military, commercial aerospace, high-
performance racing, oil & gas and other industries. Additionally, QuesTek has successfully designed and
developed two new high-performance structural steels (Ferrium S53® and Ferrium M54® steels). All four Ferrium
alloys are commercially available from Carpenter Technology and have been awarded SAE AMS numbers for
procurement. QuesTek has also designed several other high performance alloys using ICME technologies,
including a stainless nitridable bearing and gear steel and alloys for additive manufacturing applications.
ISBN: 1-61481-111-4 Pages: 10
14FTM20. Influence of Central Members Radial Support Stiffness on Load Sharing Characteristics of
Compound Planetary Gear Sets
Authors: Z. Peng, S. Wu
In this study, a non-linear dynamics model of Ravigneaux compound planetary gear set which adopts the
intermediate floating component is set up based on concentration parameter. By considering the position errors
and eccentric errors, the dynamic load sharing factors of the gear set are calculated. The relationship between
central members radial support stiffness and the dynamic load sharing factors is obtained and the influence of
central members radial support stiffness on load sharing characteristic is analyzed. The research results show
that central members radial support stiffness effect obvious to the gear pairs which are directly contacted to the
central members, while the effect is rather small to the gear pairs which are not directly connected. Reducing the
radial support stiffness of the central members helps improve the load sharing performance of the system.
ISBN: 1-61481-112-1 Pages: 12
14FTM21. On the Correlation of Specific Film Thickness and Gear Pitting Life
Author: T. Krantz
The effect of the lubrication regime on gear performance has been recognized, qualitatively, for decades. Often
the lubrication regime is characterized by the specific film thickness defined as the ratio of lubricant film thickness
to the composite surface roughness. It can be difficult to combine results of studies to create a cohesive and
comprehensive dataset. In this work gear surface fatigue lives for a wide range of specific film values were studied
using tests done with common rigs, speeds, lubricant temperatures, and test procedures. This study includes
previously reported data, results of an additional 50 tests, and detailed information from lab notes and tested
gears. The dataset comprised 258 tests covering specific film values [0.47 to 5.2]. The experimentally determined
surface fatigue lives, quantified as 10-percent life estimates, ranged from 8.7 to 86.8 million cycles. The trend is
one of increasing life for increasing specific film. The trend is nonlinear. The observed trends were found to be in
good agreement with data and recommended practice for gears and bearings. The results obtained will perhaps
allow for the specific film parameter to be used with more confidence and precision to assess gear surface fatigue
for purpose of design, rating, and technology development.
ISBN: 1-61481-113-8 Pages: 18
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM02. Performance and Technological Potential of Gears Ground by Dressable cBN Tools
Authors: J. Reimann, F. Klocke, M. Brumm, A. Mehr and K. Finkenwirth
Dressable vitrified bond cBN grinding tools combine the advantages of other common tool systems in generating
gear grinding. The cBN grains are a highly productive cutting material due to their high specific stock removal rate.
Vitrified bonds are dressable and thereby very flexible: By dressing different profile modifications can be set up
and constant gear quality can be guaranteed during the tool life time. Despite those technological advantages
there is only a small market distribution of these grinding tools due to high tool costs. Furthermore, only a few
published scientific analysis of generating gear grinding with dressable cBN exist. Especially, the influence of the
grinding tool system on manufacturing related component properties has not been analyzed yet. The research
objective of this report is to determine the advantages of dressable cBN tools in generating gear grinding.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-059-9 Pages: 12
13FTM03. Analysis of Gear Root Forms: A Review of Designs, Standards and Manufacturing Methods for
Root Forms in Cylindrical Gears
Authors: N. Chaphalkar, G. Hyatt, and N. Bylund
Gear root is an important but often neglected element of the gear. The stress concentration point typically lies in
the tooth to root transition area and it is this point that determines the life or the fatigue life of a gear in many
applications. Specific standards are in place on design of the involute part of a gear tooth, the root area however
is less standardized. New manufacturing methods enable the designer of gears greater latitude in the design of
strong alternative root forms. The standards on design and specification for the root geometry are lax so these
root forms fit into current standards.
This paper reviews the designs of various root forms for the gears. It compares the various root forms on basis of
their strength, fatigue resistance and other parameters. This analysis will be based on compilation of various
research previously conducted on gear root forms.
The paper also discusses current manufacturing methods to produce the roots, and recently introduced
alternatives. It will compare the traditional methods with new methods of gear manufacturing it terms of types of
roots produced and overall control over the root profile.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-060-5 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM05. Cubitron™ II: Precision Shaped Grains (PSG) Turn the Concept of Gear Grinding Upside Down
Author: W. Graf
To date, grinding, according to the German DIN Standard 8580, is “machining with geometrically undefined cutting
edges" while other machining processes such as turning and milling are classified as processes with
“geometrically defined cutting edges". New abrasive grains, called PSG and developed by 3M, stand this definition
on its head. For the first time, grinding wheels made with PSG, called Cubitron™ II, can claim to be made up of
“geometrically defined cutting edges" as each and every grain is exactly the same engineered shape. Hence, it
might be more appropriate to talk about “micro-milling" rather than grinding. This is borne out by looking at the
resulting “flowing" chips which are akin to chips seen in milling operations, just finer.
These free-flowing chips no longer clog up the grinding wheel and, therefore, the grinding wheel remains free-
cutting and dressing becomes only necessary due to loss of from rather than loss of cutting ability. In repeated
tests, this has shown to drastically reduce the risk of burning and to give consistent and predictable results.
Furthermore, tests and subsequent long term trials under production conditions have shown that grinding time can
be cut in most cases by at least 50% in comparison to grinding wheels made of standard ceramic abrasives.
Based on more than 100 carefully monitored and documented gear grinding trials, this paper will demonstrate how
Cubitron™ II grinding wheels work both in continuous generating grinding of car and truck gears, and in form
grinding of large diameter gears for wind generators, for example. Furthermore, the paper will discuss chip
formation, filmed with high resolution slow motion; and the benefits of the free-flowing chips in terms of resulting
consistent surface finish, superior form holding and extended dressing cycles.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-062-9 Pages: 10
13FTM07. Finite Element Analysis of a Floating Planetary Ring Gear with External Splines
Authors: V. Kirov and Y. Wang
This study investigates the stresses and deflections of a floating ring gear with external splines working in a large
planetary wheel motor of a mining truck. Such calculations carried out with conventional engineering approaches
described in popular standards and textbooks are not comprehensive because of the complexity of the problem.
These approaches can give us good stress numbers for non-floating gears and some guidance about the rim
thickness factor but they lack the capabilities to effectively calculate the deflections and their influences on the
stresses, especially for floating gears. Moreover, they cannot calculate an entire gearing system and the
interdependent influences of the different components.
The model studied consists of a floating ring gear driving a torque tube. The ring gear is driven through internal
gear meshing by three planets and it transmits the torque to the torque tube through its external splines. The
torque tube transmits the motion to the hub and the truck tires. A nonlinear static analysis of the ring gear and
torque tube was conducted in ABAQUS. Linear 8-node hex elements and linear tetra elements were used to
model the ring gear and torque tube. External torque was resolved into corresponding tangential force, which was
then applied directly onto three of the ring gear's internal teeth. Contact pairs were used to capture the load
transfer between the ring gear and torque tube through the splines.
The results show that the deflections in the ring gear were so excessive that about one-tenth of the spline teeth
were actually transmitting torque against the common engineering understanding that only half of the spline teeth
are typically engaged. The crowning of the spline teeth had also effect on the stresses though quite small
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM08. Application and Improvement of Face Load Factor Determination Based on AGMA 927 (Accurate
and Fast Algorithm for Load Distribution Calculation, for Gear Pair and Planetary Systems, Including Duty
Cycle Analysis)
Author: U. Kissling
The face load factor KHβ, which in rating equations represents the load distribution over the common face width in
meshing gears, is one of the most important items for a gear strength calculation. In the international standard for
cylindrical gear rating, the ISO 6336-1, using method C, some formulas are proposed to get a value for this factor.
But as the formulas are simplified, the result is often not very realistic. Also AGMA 2001 (or AGMA 2101)
proposes a formula for KHβ, different from ISO 6336, but again not always appropriate. Therefore, a note in AGMA
stipulates, that “it may be desirable to use an analytical approach to determine the load distribution factor".
In the last edition of ISO 6336 (2006), a new annex E was added: “Analytical determination of load distribution".
This annex is entirely based on AGMA 927-A01. It is a well-documented procedure to get a direct and precise
number for the face load factor. Today an increasing number of gear designers are using tooth contact analysis
(TCA) methods to get precise information over the load distribution on the full gear flank. Contact analysis is very
time consuming and does not permit to get a value for KHβ, as defined by the ISO or AGMA standard. A contact
analysis result combines different factors of ISO 6336 as KHβ, KHα, Zε, Zβ, ZB, ZD and buttressing effects, etc., thus
to `extract' KHβ from a TCA is not possible.
The use of the algorithm, as proposed by AGMA 927, is a good solution to get proper values for KHβ; it is simpler
and therefore much quicker than a contact analysis calculation. The paper explains how this algorithm can be
applied for classic gear pair rating procedure, for ratings with complex duty cycles and even for planetary systems
with interdependent meshings between sun, all planets and ring.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-065-0 Pages: 19
13FTM09. Investigations on Tooth Root Bending Strength of Case Hardened Gears in the Range of High
Cycle Fatigue
Authors: N. Bretl, S. Schurer, T. Tobie, K. Stahl and B.-R. Höhn
Tooth root load-carrying capacity is one of the determining factors in gear design. In addition to the strength of the
material itself, the existing state of stress significantly influences tooth root load-carrying capacity.
Based on extensive experimental investigations of gears, the beginning of the fatigue strength range is generally
set 3×106 load cycles, which common calculation methods, like ISO 6336, also take into account. According to
this, standard test methods for tooth root bending endurance strength usually assume a load cycle limit of 3-6 106.
However, current as well as completed studies on tooth root load carrying capacity show tooth root fractures with
relatively high numbers of load cycles in a range of general fatigue strength and above. Analysis of these fracture
surfaces shows that these late breakages are often initiated by small inclusions or microstructural defects in the
material. These tooth fractures that initiate with cracks under the surface have a negative effect on the tooth root
load-carrying capacity in the range of high cycle fatigue. Therefore, experimental investigations regarding high
cycle fatigue have been carried out in a pulsator test rig on gears of various sizes, materials and residual stress
conditions. As a result, depending on the existing residual stress condition, there are different levels of tooth root
load carrying capacity, different failure behaviors in high cycle fatigue and different types of damage. Especially
for test variants with high residual stresses, the size of the gear and the cleanness of the material have an impact
on the tooth root load-carrying capacity and the damage pattern.
This paper discusses the different fracture modes by means of examples. Furthermore, it presents the influence of
residual stresses, size and material cleanness on the tooth root load-carrying capacity and on the type of tooth
root fractures with crack initiation on and under the surface. These influences will be additionally confirmed by
examples of experimental test results.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-066-7 Pages: 16
13FTM10. Calculation of the Tooth Root Load Carrying Capacity of Beveloid Gears
Authors: C. Brecher, M. Brumm and J. Henser
In this paper, two developed methods of tooth root load carrying capacity calculations for beveloid gears with
parallel axes are presented. The first method calculates the tooth root load carrying capacity in an FE-based
approach. The initial step of the method is the manufacturing simulation in the WZL software GearGenerator. The
manufacturing simulation calculates the 3D geometry of the beveloid gears by simulating the generating grinding
process. The next step is an FE-based (finite element) tooth contact analysis with the WZL software ZaKo3D
which is able to calculate the tooth root stresses of several gear types during the meshing. From these stresses
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM11. Striving for High Load Capacity and Low Noise Excitation in Gear Design
Authors: K. Stahl, M. Otto and M. Zimmer
In the design process of gearboxes, common requirements are high load capacity and low noise excitation.
Reaching both goals is laborious and normally requires a trade-off. Detailed analyses of contact conditions and
deformations are necessary. These should take place in an early design stage to realize a mostly straightforward
design approach and prevent late design changes. Focused on cylindrical gears, the paper covers an approach
starting at the first draft of a gearbox.
Defining the macrogeometry of the teeth regarding load capacity calculation according to standards leads to a
reasonable gear design. On that basis, the micro geometry of the teeth is specified and load distribution as well as
noise excitation is calculated. The design parameters are interdependent so provisions have to be made to adjust
each step on the remaining ones. Effects resulting from changing profile contact ratio under load and contact
patterns not covering the whole flank have to be regarded. The beneficial effect of a modified microgeometry is
dependent on the ability to precisely account for contact conditions and meshing clearances.
To find an optimal solution for the competing goals of capacity and excitation, detailed calculation methods are
required. To be able to apply latest research results, these are implemented in highly specialized software. The
task described above is handled by using the software that was developed at the Gear Research Center (FZG)
with funding by the German Research Association for Gears and Transmissions (FVA). The underlying calculation
methods and analyzed phenomena are covered.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-068-1 Pages: 14
13FTM12. Practical Considerations for the Use of Double Flank Testing for the Manufacturing Control
of Gearing
Authors: E. Reiter and F. Eberle
The gearing industry has developed many unique measuring techniques for the production control of their
products. Each technique has inherent advantages and limitations which should be considered by designers and
manufacturers when selecting their use. Double flank composite inspection, (DFCI) is one such technique that can
functionally provide quality control results of test gears quickly and easily during manufacturing. The successful
use of DFCI requires careful planning from product design, through master gear design and gage control methods
in order to achieve the desired result in an application.
This document explains the practical considerations in the use of double flank testing for the manufacturing
control of spur, helical, and crossed axis helical gearing including:
- a general description of double flank inspection equipment including an explanation of what can
be measured;
- recommendations on practical master gear design;
- the calculation of tight mesh center distance and test radius limits;
- the resulting backlash that can be anticipated in gear meshes based on applying double flank tolerances in a
design;
- initial and ongoing statistical techniques in double flank testing and how they can be practically used to
improve gear quality;
- double flank gage measurement system analysis including case studies of gage repeatability and
reproducibility (R&R) and uncertainty analysis.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-069-8 Pages: 32
13FTM13. Gear Failure Analysis and Lessons Learned in Aircraft High-Lift Actuation
Authors: A. Wang, S. Gitnes, L. El-Bayoumy and J. Davies
Several gear failure cases and lessons learned in the development phase of aircraft high lift actuation systems are
presented, including leading edge geared rotary actuators, and trailing edge geared rotary actuators, sector gears
and pinions, and offset gearboxes. The high lift system of an aircraft, which contains trailing edge flaps and/or
leading edge slats, increases lift for takeoff, controls flight during cruise, and reduces speed while increasing lift
for shorter landing distance.
Many of these components contain highly loaded gears to increase the power to weight ratio. Because of
requirements on weight or envelope and consideration of cost, the gears are always designed to the limit with
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM15. White Structure Flaking in Rolling Bearings for Wind Turbine Gearboxes
Authors: H. Uyama and H. Yamada
Bearing failures in wind turbine gearboxes were investigated and rolling contact fatigue tests to reproduce them
using a hydrogen-charge method were conducted. Two main failure modes in wind turbine gearbox bearings were
white structure flaking and axial cracking, which were involving a microstructural change. Both failure modes can
be reproduced by using specimens charged with hydrogen. Operating conditions, which can induce hydrogen
generation from lubricant and penetration of the bearing steel were discussed. Effects of bearing material on white
structure flaking life were suggested as one of the countermeasures.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-072-8 Pages: 13
13FTM16. The Anatomy of a Lubrication Erosion Failure – Causation, Initiation, Progression and Prevention
Authors: R.J. Drago, R.J. Cunningham, W. Flynn
Visual examination of a compressor box revealed that the Low Speed (LS) Pinion exhibited pitting type defects on
each of its forty-seven (47) helical teeth. Review of the failed component revealed a somewhat repetitive type of
damage at one end of the teeth only. Each tooth showed what appeared to be one defect at a similar location
3600 around the Pinion. Each defect was located within ~0.5 inch of the end of the helical tooth. It was noted that
each tooth defect was observed on the coast side of the teeth only.
Visual examination of the mating gear revealed no evidence of similar damage. While of and by itself, this pitting
may not be cause for alarm, debris from the pitting can adversely affect other components in the gearbox,
especially the bearings, and the stress concentration effect of the pitting, even though it is on the coast flank,
could lead to partial tooth fracture in the region of the distress.
This paper presents a discussion of the causation, diagnosis and metallurgical failure investigation of this
lubrication erosion failure. Our effort was aimed at identifying the nature of the pitting and providing
recommendations to avoid repeat instances of this failure in this specific application and in other future designs for
similar applications.
The subject is presented by way of the discussion of detailed destructive metallurgical evaluations of this specific
lubrication erosion failure which the authors have conducted in order to analyze and characterize the failures.
Lubrication erosion is generally limited to helical gears but the authors have also found this type of distress when
evaluating damage to carburized, hardened and hard finished spiral bevel gears as well when operated under the
“right" circumstances. Lubrication erosion observed on helical gears only, however, will be addressed in this
presentation. Although a specific failure “case" is used as the vehicle for presentation, information has been
extracted and condensed from several individual actual failure investigations conducted by the authors so that a
better understanding of the specific conditions that lead to micropitting and the actual progression from
micropitting to fracture can be presented.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-073-5 Pages: 30
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM19. Gear Resonance Analysis and Experimental Verification Using Rapid Prototyped Gears
Authors: S.R. Davidson and J.D. Hayes
Determination of gear resonance frequencies is necessary in the design of light weight aerospace gears.
Resonant frequencies and mode shapes calculated are then identified as damaging or non-damaging and
compared to the gear's mesh frequencies to determine if gear tooth bending stresses will be amplified in a
particular operating speed range. Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is well suited to determining gear resonant
frequencies and modes. In order to verify the analysis quickly, rough gear geometry is fabricated and tested using
accelerometers and a calibrated hammer in a modal excitation test. In past efforts, rough geometry fabricated was
a simplified version of the final part minus gear teeth or other features. To reduce the time of fabrication and to
increase the accuracy of the prototype part, modern rapid prototyping manufacturing techniques may hold
promise in approaching the realism of the actual part with material properties that are similar to material properties
of gear steels.
This paper studies gear resonance modal excitation testing of two stage idler spur gear rapid prototyped parts,
using two different rapid prototyping techniques and compares results to the final production part and FEA model.
Damaging and non-damaging modes and nomenclature will be reviewed as well as the testing method.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-076-6 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM24. Innovative Induction Hardening Process with Preheating for Improved Fatigue Performance of
Gear Component
Author: Z. Li
Contact fatigue and bending fatigue are two main failure modes of steel gears. Surface pitting and spalling are two
common contact fatigue failures, which are due to the alternating subsurface shear stresses from the contact load
between two gear mates. When a gear is in service under cyclic load, concentrated bending stresses exist at the
root fillet, which is the main driver of bending fatigue failures. Heat treatment is required to increase the hardness
and strength of gears to meet the required contact and bending fatigue performance. Induction hardening is
becoming more popular due to its process consistency, reduced energy consumption, clean environment, and
improved product quality. It is well known that an induction hardening process of steel gears can generate
compressive residual stresses in the hardened case. Compressive residual stresses in the hardened case of tooth
flank benefit the contact fatigue performance, and residual compression in the root fillet benefits the bending
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
13FTM25. Press Quenching and the Effects of Prior Thermal History on Distortion during Heat Treatment
Author: A.C. Reardon
Precision components such as industrial bearing races and automotive gears often distort unpredictably during
heat treatment due to the deleterious effects of free or unconstrained oil quenching. Press quenching is a method
that can be utilized to minimize the distortion of these complex components during heat treatment. This is
accomplished in a quenching machine by utilizing specialized tooling for generating concentrated forces to
constrain the movement of the component during oil quenching. When performed correctly, this method of
quenching can often achieve the relatively stringent geometrical requirements stipulated by industrial
manufacturing specifications. It can be performed on a wide variety of steel alloys. These include high carbon
through-hardening grades such as AISI 52100 and A2 tool steel, as well as low carbon carburizing grades such as
AISI 3310, 8620, and 9310. The relevant aspects of this specialized quenching technique will be presented
together with a case study of the effects of prior thermal history on the distortion that is generated during press
quenching.
ISBN: 978-1-61481-082-7 Pages: 9
2012 PAPERS
12FTM01. Balancing – No Longer Smoke and Mirrors
Author: R. Mifsud Hines
In the late 1970's a balancing machine salesman visited a customer's plant who had just received a new balancer
from the salesman's competitor. The plant manager said they were very happy with their automatic balancing
machine and offered to show it to the salesman. The manager walked the salesman out on the floor and the two
of them watched the operator and balancer in action.
The operator placed a part on the balancer and closed the door. The balancer spun up the part, welded on a
weight, spun up again, and displayed “good part.” The operator removed the balanced part, put in a new part, and
closed the door. The balancer spun up the part, welded on a weight, spun up again, and displayed “good part.”
This scenario was repeated several more times as the salesman and the manager watched.
The manager commented, “We just love our new machine. All day long it balances parts by welding on weights
and puts out good parts.” The salesman suggested having the operator place a “balanced part” back in the
balancer again just to see what would happen. So the operator placed the previously balanced part back in the
balancer again and closed the door. The balancer spun up the part, welded on a second weight, spun up again,
and displayed “good part.” The manager had the operator take another balanced part and put it into the balancer
again. Again, the balancer spun up the part, welded on another weight, spun up again, and displayed “good part.”
Suddenly the manager was not so happy with his balancing machine. It seems this machine was not balancing
the parts at all. They had purchased an expensive welding machine to weld weights on their parts.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-032-2 Pages: 10
12FTM02. Power Loss and Axial Load Carrying Capacity of Radial Cylindrical Roller Bearings
Authors: S. Söndgen, W. Predki
The application of cylindrical roller bearings (CRB) is widely spread in mechanical engineering. CRB can carry
comparatively high loads and are usable in high speed ranges. These bearings have been proven to be variously
applicable and economic. With lipped inner and outer rings CRB permit the transmission of axial loads in addition
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM05. Combined Effects of Gravity, Bending Moment, Bearing Clearance, and Input Torque on Wind
Turbine Planetary Gear Load Sharing
Authors: Y. Guo, J. Keller, W. LaCava
This computational work investigates planetary gear load sharing of three-mount suspension wind turbine
gearboxes. A three dimensional multi-body dynamic model is established, including gravity, bending moments,
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM07. Validation of a Model of the NREL Gearbox Reliability Collaborative Wind Turbine Gearbox
Authors: C.K. Halse, Z.H. Wright, A.R. Crowther
Gearboxes in the wind industry have been suffering from a poor reputation due to major issues with reliability.
There has been a long list of issues; e.g. grind temper, material inclusions, axial cracking in bearings, poor load
sharing on shaft-bearing arrangements, significant gear misalignment, bearing ring creep, gear scuffing, gear and
bearing micropitting; all of which are common and often serial problems. There has been improvement in the last
few years for some of the products, yet it is not uncommon for wind sites built as recently as 2008 to have 20–
40% of gearboxes requiring a component replacement (such as a high speed pinion or intermediate shaft bearing)
already (by 2012) and 5–10% complete gearbox failures. An important program for the industry, “The Gearbox
Reliability Collaborative" (GRC), has been funded by the US Department of Energy and run by the National
Renewable Energy Laboratory for several years to aid the industry in improving the reliability of this key
component. The collaborative has brought together manufacturers, academia, national laboratories, engineering
consultants and gear and bearing software providers as part of a program to model, build, simulate and test
gearboxes with a goal to improve reliability and reduce the cost of energy.
The team at NREL have instrumented two gearboxes with over 125 channels, for measurements such as
planetary tooth load distributions, annulus gear hoop strains, planet bearing load distribution, sun orbit and carrier
deflection. They were then subjected to a rigorous testing regime, both up-tower and on the NREL 2.5MW
dynamometer. Romax Technology have been a collaborator in the GRC Analysis Group and have developed
detailed computer simulation models of the gearbox including gear macro and micro-geometry, bearing macro
and micro-geometry, structural stiffness of gearbox housing, carrier and annulus gear, system clearances and
preloads, and surrounding boundary conditions (such as main shaft, rotor hub and bedplate). The model is used
for accurate simulation of the whole system deflections and the prediction of the resulting gear and bearing
contact conditions under various loading conditions.
The focus of this paper is a comparison between measurement and simulation for key parameters including gear
load distributions, annulus deflection and sun motion. The simulation results that are robust and those that are
sensitive to hard-to-predict parameters that include significant effects from manufacturing and assembly variations
will be outlined. Lessons learned in how best to apply computer-aided-engineering tools to improve wind turbine
gearbox reliability will be described.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-038-4 Pages: 12
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM09. Systematic Approach for the Psychoacoustic Analysis of Dynamic Gear Noise Excitation
Authors: C. Brecher, M. Brumm, C. Carl
The sound quality of technical products is an increasingly important quality criterion and has a significant influence
on the product acceptance. But sound quality does not only depend on the physical attributes of the sound signal.
It is defined to a large extent by human sound and noise perception. This perception is based on a physiological
and psychological signal processing. These aspects depend on complex properties of the physical signal like the
spectral distribution and a relative comparison. However, today the sound design of gearboxes is mainly based on
the physical reduction of the noise level that is detected by absolute and objectivized parameters. The noise
oriented gear design is based on a fundament of physical key parameters like the reduction of transmission error
in compliance with achievable manufacturing tolerances. Nevertheless, these design rules may lead to a minimal
sound pressure level but cannot solely be applied for an optimal sound quality in every case. Under economic and
technical aspects there is no excitation free gear set. Furthermore, modern tendencies such as lightweight design
and masking noise reduction (engine downsizing and electrification) lead more and more to scenarios where the
sound of a gear set, which is only designated to have low transmission error, can be perceived as annoying. This
requires design guidelines which take also the human related aspects of gear noise into account. Nowadays the
gear design does not yet consider human noise perception sufficiently.
Thus, a research project at the WZL has been established that investigates the correlation between gear mesh
excitation and the evaluation of gear noise. The objective of this project is to deduce a method for the
consideration of perception-based noise evaluation already in the stage of gear design. Therefore,
psychoacoustics metrics are used to analyze the gear noise of different gear sets in the dimensions of airborne
noise, structural vibration and the excitation due to meshing. The aim of this paper is to discuss the correlation
between the signal properties of the excitation and the radiated noise in order to investigate the possibilities to
transfer the perception related evaluation from sound pressure to the gear mesh excitation. The paper firstly
shows central psychoacoustic parameters that are most relevant for the properties of gear noise. Furthermore, a
new test fixture will be introduced that allows a dynamic measurement of gear mesh excitation directly adjacent to
the meshing. Regarding these aspects two different gear sets are discussed concerning the calculated
transmission error and the experimentally determined excitation, surface vibration and noise radiation. These
aspects are accordingly examined with respect to human noise perception, which is described by
psychoacoustics. It is shown that operating conditions, order distributions as well as the gear geometry are the
main influences on the signal evaluation. The influence of dynamic aspects and especially the influence of
resonance effects on the noise characteristics are additionally considered.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-040-7 Pages: 22
12FTM10. Development of Novel CBN Grade for Electroplated Finish Grinding of Hardened Steel Gears
Authors: U. Sridharan, S. Kompella, S. Ji, J. Fiecoat
The unique requirements of an electroplatable superabrasive CBN grit used in profile grinding of hardened steel
gears as well as the attributes and grinding behavior of a new CBN developed specifically for this application are
discussed. Profile gear grinding parameters were simulated in through-hardened AISI 4140 steel (56 HRC) and
the grinding performance of the new CBN was compared against a competitive CBN grade widely used in the
application. Consistent with field criteria, grinding performance was characterized based on occurrence of 'burn' or
'form' failure. The 'burn' or metallurgical phase transformation failure was detected by Barkhausen Noise Analysis
(BNA) and corroborated by microstructural and microhardness evaluations. The 'form' failure was simulated by
tracking average radial wheel wear to a threshold value where form loss was expected to occur. Grinding tests
indicate that the new CBN grit can grind 35% more parts compared to the competitive CBN grade before burn
failure. In addition, the new CBN displayed a lower wear rate. The new CBN grade also exhibited a unique ability
to grind with lower grinding power, resulting in a near constant BNA response on the ground surface throughout
the test. This implied minimal microstructural change on the ground part from start to end of the test compared to
the progressive softening of ground surface noticed with the competitive CBN.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-041-4 Pages: 13
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM12. Manufacturing Method of Pinion Member of Large-Sized Skew Bevel Gears Using Multi-Axis
Control and Multi-Tasking Machine Tool
Authors: I. Tsuji, K. Kawasaki, H. Gunbara, H. Houjyou, S. Matsumura
In this paper, a manufacturing method of the pinion member of large-sized skew bevel gears using multi-axis
control and multi-tasking machine tool considering that the gear member is provided is proposed. First, the tooth
surface forms of skew bevel gears are modeled. Next, the real tooth surfaces of the gear member are measured
using a coordinate measuring machine and the deviations between the real and theoretical tooth surface forms
are formalized using the measured coordinates. It is possible to analyze the tooth contact pattern of the skew
bevel gears with consideration of the deviations of the real and theoretical tooth surface forms expressing the
deviations as polynomial equations. Moreover, the deviations of the tooth surface form of the gear member are
fed back to the analysis of the tooth contact pattern and transmission errors, and the tooth surface form of the
pinion member that has a good performance mating with the gear member. Finally, the pinion member is
manufactured by swarf cutting using multi-axis control and multi-tasking machine tool. Afterward, the real tooth
surfaces of the manufactured pinion member were measured using a coordinate measuring machine and the
tooth surface form errors were detected. As a result, although the tooth surface form errors were large relatively
on the heel side, those were small on the other side. In addition, the tooth contact pattern of the manufactured
pinion member and provided gear member was compared with those of tooth contact analysis. As a result, there
was good agreement.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-043-8 Pages: 15
12FTM14. Large Pinions for Open Gears: The Increase of Single Mesh Load – A New Challenge for
Manufacturing and Quality Inspection
Author: M. Pasquier, and F. Wavelet
Most of the large open gear sets for mining industry are designed according to AGMA 6014-A06 and AGMA 2001-
D04. and rating according to AGMA standard (service factor) involve the final design of the pinion such as:
material and heat treatment (through hardening or case carburized pinion), and the finishing process of the teeth
(to achieve the design geometry).
Basically, customer specification and rating according to AGMA standard (service factor) involve the final design
of the pinion such as: material and heat treatment (through hardening or case carburized pinion), and the finishing
process of the teeth (to achieve the design geometry).
Moreover, the increase of applied load for a single meshing becomes a new challenge.
In addition to the mechanical properties for the material used and its associated heat treatment requirements
given in standards, elastic and thermal behavior and resulting accuracy, as well, have to be taken into account at
design stage, even for large open gears.
Beside design consideration, such increase of single meshing load cannot be achieved by using conventional
manufacturing and quality control methods.
Therefore, improvements in manufacturing process and in quality inspections for such heavily loaded single large
parts, as already performed for smaller parts in batch are now mandatory to achieve these new design
requirements.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM15. New Methods for the Calculation of the Load Capacity of Bevel and Hypoid Gears
Authors: C. Wirth, B.-R. Höhn, C. Braykoff
A failure mode called “flank breakage" is increasingly observed in different applications of cylindrical and bevel
gears. These breakages typically start from the active flank approximately in the middle of the active tooth height
and propagate to the tooth root of the unloaded flank side. Crack initiation can be localized below the surface in
the region between case and core of surface hardened gears. This failure mode can neither be explained by the
known mechanism of tooth root breakage nor by the mechanism of pitting. Even bevel gears in truck and bus
applications are at the risk to suffer from subsurface fatigue, if the optimum utilization of the material should be
achieved. In this case a balance between the flank breakage and pitting risk has to be found. The purpose of this
paper is to describe a new material physically based calculation method to evaluate the risk of flank breakage
versus the risk of pitting. The verification of this new method by experimental tests is exemplarily shown.
In cooperation with “ZG-Zahnräer und Getriebe GmbH” (ZG) “MAN truck and bus AG" (MTB) developed a new
method for the calculation of the risks of flank failure by flank breakage and pitting. The calculation method has
been adjusted and approved by experimental tests on powertrain test rigs of MAN. The ten different test gear
variants had an outer diameter of de2 = 390 mm to 465 mm, a ratio i = 4,5 to 5,7 and a normal module of mmn = 6
mm to 8 mm. Also variants with the same main geometry but different Ease-Off designs were examined. All gear
sets were tested under a defined load spectrum. Based on the research work at the FZG (Gear Research Center
at the Technical University of Munich in Germany) of Oster, Hertter and Wirth a calculation method for bevel gears
was established. The principle of the calculation model is the local comparison of the occurring stresses and the
available strength values over the whole tooth volume. Therefore, it is possible to evaluate the risk of initial cracks
beyond the surface of the flank. Close to the surface cracks may grow and cause pitting— especially in the flank
area with negative specific sliding. Cracks in the transient area between case and core lead to a high flank
breakage risk.
First the local stresses and forces on the flank are determined by a loaded tooth contact analysis followed by the
calculation of the maximum exposure (regarding yielding) and dynamic exposure (regarding fatigue) of the
material inside the tooth. Thereby the stress components from the Hertzian contact, bending, thermal effects
(flash temperature) and friction are considered. Furthermore, the positive effect of residual compressive stresses
and accordingly the disadvantageous effect of the residual tensile stresses can be implicated. Finite elements
method investigations have been carried out in order to achieve a sufficient approximation of the residual stress
distribution in the transverse tooth section. The strength values are locally considered, depending on the material
depth and the position on the flank.
The recalculation of the test gears showed a good correlation between the occurred type of damage and the
determined material exposure inside the tooth. The variants failed with flank breakage could be reliably
distinguished from the variants failed by pitting by the new material-physical method. With this knowledge it is now
possible to optimize the main geometry parameters of the gear set (e.g. number of teeth, spiral angle, pressure
angle) as well as the micro geometry (Ease-Off) that influences the load distribution on the flank. Altogether this
new method leads to an insured increase of the permissible material utilization and hence to smaller gear sizes
while keeping the load capacity on a constant level.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-046-9 Pages: 21
12FTM16. Gear Design Optimization for Low Contact Temperature of a High-Speed, Non-Lubricated Spur
Gear Pair
Authors: C.H. Wink, N.S. Mantri
This paper presents a gear design optimization approach that was applied to reduce both tooth contact
temperature and noise excitation of a high-speed spur gear pair running without lubricant. The optimum gear
design search was done using the RMC (Run Many Cases) program from The Ohio State University. Over 480
thousand possible gear designs were considered, which were narrowed down to the 31 best candidates based on
low contact temperature and low transmission error. The best gear design was selected considering, also, its
manufacturability. The selected optimum gear design was compared to an existing gear set using LDP (Load
Distribution Program) from The Ohio State University. Tooth contact temperature was calculated for both designs
using dry a steel-on-steel coefficient of friction. Predicted contact temperature correlated well with results
observed on dynamometer tests with the existing gear set. Predictions with the optimized design showed a 48%
contact temperature reduction and a 79% noise excitation reduction. The low contact temperature of the optimized
design will significantly contribute to preventing tooth surface damage under no lubricant operating conditions.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-047-6 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM22. Crack Testing and Heat Treat Verification of Gears Using Eddy Current Technology
Authors: D. DeVries
While eddy current technology has long been used in the testing of bar, tube, and wire stock, advances in
electronics, automation, and coil design have paved the way for a new generation of testers specifically designed
for component testing applications. This includes the testing of gears and bearings which go into automotive and
industrial applications. These testing systems easily integrate into production processes allowing for in-line testing
at production line speeds. In addition to enabling 100% of production components to be inspected, it can help
monitor upstream processes notifying operators that something is not functioning correctly. This greatly reduces
scrap and warranty costs for gear and bearing manufacturers.
Eddy current crack testing is performed by passing a small pair of coil windings over a section of the component
to be tested. These coil windings are small enough to test between gear teeth, and with multi-coil probes can test
very complex shapes. Most crack test applications require only one test frequency since most tests require the
detection of only surface flaws. Simultaneous testing with multiple frequencies allows for testing of both surface
and sub-surface defects when inspecting nonferromagnetic parts.
While not an absolute hardness test like a Rockwell test, eddy current heat treat verification can achieve sorting
results on par with Rockwell testing. This has been demonstrated with both forged and powder metal gears. Eddy
current heat treat inspection coils come in both standard encircling coil configurations and multi-coil custom
configurations. The custom configurations allow for precise location testing verifying that induction heating
parameters were correctly applied. Defects to be tested include misplaced case, shallow case, short quench,
delayed quench, air cooled, non-heat-treat, and ground out conditions. When performing heat-treat inspection,
multiple test frequencies are used to reliably detect these various heat-treat anomalies.
Eddy current testing offers fast, repeatable testing of gears and bearings. Testing data on each component can be
stored electronically and re-analyzed off-line at a later date. Eddy current test instruments are designed to
integrate with PLC's in material handling stations to set up real-time rejection capabilities. These are all features
that complement modern QC requirements.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-053-7 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
12FTM24. Recent Inventions and Innovations in Induction Hardening of Gears and Gear-like Components
Author: V. Rudnev
Presentation focuses on recent inventions and innovations (last 4–6 years) in induction hardening of gears and
gear-like components, including but not limited to:
- “Know-how" in controlling distortion of induction hardened gears.
- Simultaneous dual-frequency induction hardening.
- Advanced induction hardening process recipes when hardening small and medium size gears.
- Novel inductor designs to minimize a distortion when induction hardening of hypoid and spiral bevel gears.
- IFP technology for induction gear hardening.
- Induction tempering and stress relieving of gear-like components with improved temperature uniformity.
Presentation also provides a review of basic principles and applications devoted to induction hardening small,
medium and large size gears using tooth-by-tooth techniques and encircling method.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-055-1 Pages: 9
2011 PAPERS
11FTM01. A New Way of Face Gear Manufacturing
Author: H.J. Stadtfeld
There are two major intentions to apply face gears in power transmissions: the advantage to be able to use a
cylindrical gear as a pinion member; and particular design solutions which require a plurality of cylindrical driving
members as in a propulsion system.
While the automotive and truck industry conducted substantial research in the application of face gear systems in
their drive trains, the results did not favor face gears versus bevel and hypoid gears. In many cases, the face gear
system was found to be the less economical solution, as the manufacturing of the face gear itself was expensive.
Machine tools require a special design, are not readily available, and the cutting tools have to be designed
specifically for the particular face gear design.
The obstacles which prevented manufacturers in the past to apply face gears were removed entirely, when a new
way of forming the profile of face gear teeth, using standard bevel gear cutting and grinding machines as well as
standard cutter heads was designed. The idea is based on the tools used in straight bevel gear cutting and
grinding according to the CONIFLEX method, however, using a generating gear which is not flat like it is for
straight bevel gears but cylindrical, resembling the mating cylindrical pinion for the particular face gear design.
The complexity of modified cylindrical hobbing and shaping machines and job dependent custom tooling
disappears completely with the new CONIFACE cutting and grinding process.
ISBN: 1-61481-000-1 Pages: 14
11FTM02. Generating Gear Grinding – New Possibilities in Process Design and Analysis
Authors: J. Reimann, F. Klocke, and C. Gorgels
To improve load carrying capacity and noise behavior, case hardened gears usually are hard finished. One
possible process for the hard finishing of gears is the continuous generating gear grinding, which has replaced
other grinding processes in batch production of small to medium sized gears due to its high process efficiency.
Despite the wide industrial application of this process only a few published scientific analyses exist. The science-
based analysis of generating gear grinding needs a high amount of time and effort. This is due to the complex
contact conditions between tool and gear flank, which change continuously during the grinding process. These
complicate the application of the existing knowledge of other grinding processes onto the generating gear
grinding.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM03. Towards an Improved AGMA Accuracy Classification System on Double Flank Composite
Measurements
Author: E. Reiter
AGMA introduced ANSI/AGMA 2015-2-A06 – Accuracy Classification System – Radial System for Cylindrical
Gears – in 2006 as the first major rewrite of the double flank accuracy standard in over twelve years. Although this
document is not yet in wide use, many practical problems exist in the standard which affects its intended benefit.
This document explains the issues related to the use of ANSI/AGMA 2015-2-A06 as an Accuracy Classification
System and recommends a revised system which can be of more service to the gearing industry.
ISBN: 1-61481-002-5 Pages: 14
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM08. A Comprehensive System for Predicting Assembly Variation with Potential Application to
Transmission Design
Authors: K.W. Chase and C.D. Sorensen
Recent advances in tolerance analysis of assemblies allow designers to: predict tolerance stack-up due to
process variations; examine variation in clearances and fits critical to performance; use actual production variation
data or estimates from prior experience; and use engineering design limits to predict the percent rejects in
production runs.
A comprehensive system has been developed for modeling 1D, 2D, and 3D assemblies, which includes three
sources of variation: dimensional (lengths and angles), geometric (GD&T), and kinematic (small internal
adjustments due to dimensional variations).
Once the assembly has been described, an algebraic model is created, in which each dimension is represented
by a vector, with a nominal +/- tolerance. The vectors are linked into chains or loops, describing each critical
clearance or assembly feature in terms of the contributing dimensions. The chains form vector loops describing
the interaction and accumulation of the three sources of variation in the assembly.
Small variations are applied to each source and analyzed statistically to predict the resulting variation in the critical
assembly features. Solutions for the mean and standard deviations are obtained by matrix algebra. Only two
assemblies are analyzed: one for the mean and another for the variance of the assembly features. The same
modeling elements may be used to model complex assemblies.
Benefits of tolerance analysis include reduced reject rates, fewer problems on the assembly floor, reduced costs,
and shorter time to market. Critical requirements of shaft alignment, gear meshing and controls in transmissions
and gear trains are ideally suited for this efficient, comprehensive system.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-007-0 Pages: 18
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM10. New Methods for the Calculation of the Load Capacity of Bevel and Hypoid Gears
Authors: B.-R. Höhn, K. Stahl, and C. Wirth
Pitting and tooth root breakage are still the two most frequent failure types occurring in practical applications of
bevel gears. There are several national and international standards for the calculation of the load carrying
capacity of these gears such as DIN 3991, AGMA 2003 and ISO 10300. But up to now these standards do not
cover bevel gears with offset (hypoid gears). For that reason, a research project was carried out at FZG (Gear
Research Centre, Munich, Germany) to analyze the influence of the hypoid offset on the load capacity of bevel
gears by systematic theoretical and experimental investigations.
The results of the tooth root tests showed, as expected, an increasing load capacity with higher offsets. In
contrast, the pitting tests showed an increasing, but after reaching a maximum, a decreasing load capacity with
higher offsets. This can be explained by two interfering phenomena: On the one side higher offsets lead to
decreasing pinion loads and thus decreasing contact stresses; on the other side the permissible stresses are
decreasing due to the higher sliding velocities.
Regarding these test results a new standard capable calculation method was developed on the basis of ISO
10300. First the bevel gear geometry is transformed into a virtual cylindrical gear. Systematic theoretical
investigations and comparisons with tooth contact analysis methods have shown that the new virtual cylindrical
gears have representative mesh conditions compared to the bevel gears. This includes the size and shape of the
contact area as well as the load distribution between the mating teeth. Particularly with regard to hypoids it is
necessary to consider the unbalanced mesh conditions between drive and coast side flank, what can be
described by the limit pressure angle. Several influence factors were adjusted considering geometry, material
properties and operating conditions of the gear set. For the tooth root safety factor, the influence factors were
adapted to the specific conditions of hypoid gears. For the calculation of the pitting safety factor two new influence
factors were introduced to consider the hypoid specific sliding conditions on the gear flanks. The recalculation of
the pitting and tooth root tests showed a very good correlation of calculated with real load capacity of the test
gears.
Meanwhile the newly developed calculation method is widely-used in the gear manufacturing industry. For that
reason, it is currently introduced into the revision of ISO 10300 as method B1 beside method B2 based on the
AGMA calculation method for bevel and hypoid gears.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-009-4 Pages: 20
11FTM11. Marine Reversing Main Gear Rating Factor Versus Number of Loading Reversals and Shrink
Fit Stress
Authors: E.W. Jones, S. Ismonov and S.R. Daniewicz
The marine vessel reversing main gear tooth is subjected to three different loading cycles: ahead travel with load
pulsing from zero to 100% of full power; astern travel with load pulsing from zero to about minus 66% of full
power; and reversal of direction with load changing from 100% of full power to about minus 66% of full power.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM12. The Application of the First International Calculation Method for Micropitting
Authors: U. Kissling
The international calculation method for micropitting, ISO/TR 15144, was recently published. It is the first official
international calculation method to check for the risk of micropitting ever published. Years ago AGMA published a
method for the calculation of the specific oil film thickness containing some comments about micropitting, and the
German FVA published a calculation method based on intensive research results. The FVA and the AGMA are
close to the ISO/TR. New is the calculation of the micropitting safety factors.
The technical report presents two calculation rules, method A and B. Method A needs as input the Hertzian
pressure on every point of the tooth flank, based on an accurate calculation of the meshing of the gear pair,
considering tooth and shaft deflections to get the load distribution over the flank line in every meshing position.
Method B is much simpler; the load distribution is defined for different cases as spur or helical gears, with and
without profile modifications.
The risk of micropitting is highly influenced by profile and flank line modifications. A new software tool can
evaluate the risk of micropitting for gears by automatically varying different combinations of tip reliefs, other profile
modifications and flank line modifications, in combination with different torque levels, using method A. The user
can define the number of steps for variation of the amount of modification. Then all possible combinations are
checked combined with different (user defined) torque levels. Any modifications including flank twist, arc-like
profile modifications, etc. can be combined. The result is presented in a table, showing the safety factor against
micropitting for different subsets of profile/flank modifications, depending on the torque level.
Some applications from wind turbine and industrial gearboxes, known to the author, will be discussed.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-011-7 Pages: 15
11FTM13. Investigations on the Flank Load Carrying Capacity in the Newly Developed FZG Back-to-Back Test
Rig for Internal Gears
Authors: B.-R. Höhn, K. Stahl, J. Schudy, T. Tobie, and B. Zornek
Micropitting, pitting and wear are typical gear failure modes, which can occur on the flanks of slowly operated and
highly stressed internal gears. However, the calculation methods for the flank load carrying capacity have mainly
been established on the basis of experimental investigations on external gears.
The target of a research project was to verify the application of these calculation models to internal gears.
Therefore, two identical back-to-back test rigs for internal gears have been designed, constructed and
successfully used for gear running tests. These gear test rigs are especially designed for low and medium
circumferential speeds and allow the testing of the flank load carrying capacity of spur and helical internal gears
for different pairings of materials at realistic stresses. The three planet gears of the test rig are arranged uniformly
around the circumference. Experimental and theoretical investigations regarding the load distribution across the
face width, the contact pattern and the load sharing between the three planet gears have been carried out.
Furthermore, substantial theoretical investigations on the characteristics of internal gears were performed. Internal
and external spur gears were compared regarding their geometrical and kinematical differences as well as their
impact on the flank load. Based on the results of these theoretical investigations an extensive test program of load
stage tests and speed stage tests on internal gears of different material, different finishing of the flanks and
different operating conditions has been carried out. The main focus of this test program was on the fatigue failures
of micropitting and wear at low circumferential speeds.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM14. AGMA 925-A03 Predicted Scuffing Risk to Spur and Helical Gears in Commercial Vehicle
Transmissions
Author: C.H. Wink
The risk of gear tooth scuffing in commercial vehicle transmissions has gained more attention because of
increasing demand for fuel-efficient powertrain systems in which diesel engines run at lower speeds, power
density is higher, and lubricants are modified to improve efficiency and compatibility with components of new
technologies, such as dual clutch transmissions. Thus, predicting scuffing risk during the design phase is vital for
the development of commercial vehicle transmissions. AGMA 925-A03 is a comprehensive method to predict the
probability of gear scuffing. Therefore, this paper presents the AGMA 925-A03 scuffing risk predictions for a series
of spur and helical gear sets in transmissions that are used in commercial vehicles ranging from SAE class 3
through class 8. Limiting scuffing temperatures of mineral and synthetic lubricants were determined from FZG
scuffing tests, dynamometer tests and field data. The agreement between prediction, test results and actual usage
can provide confidence in the predictor of scuffing risk of gears in commercial vehicle transmissions.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-013-1 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM20. Case Study Involving Surface Durability and Improved Surface Finish
Authors: G. Blake and J. Reynolds
Gear tooth wear and micro-pitting is a very difficult phenomenon to predict analytically. The failure mode of micro-
pitting is closely correlated to the lambda ratio. Micropitting can be the limiting design parameter for long-term
durability. Also, the failure mode of micropitting can progress to wear or macropitting, and then manifest into more
severe failure modes such as bending. The results of a gearbox test and manufacturing process development
program will be presented to evaluate super finishing and its impact on micropitting.
Testing was designed using an existing aerospace two stage gearbox with a low lambda ratio. All gears were
carburized, ground and shot peened. Two populations were then created and tested. One population was finish
honed and the second was shot peened and isotropic super finished.
A standard qualification test was conducted for 150hrs at maximum continuous load. The honed gears
experienced micro and macro pitting during the test. The Isotropic Super Finishing (ISF) gears were also tested
for 150hr under the same loading. The ISF gears were absent of any surface distress. The ISF gears were further
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM21. Gearbox Bearing Service Life – A Matter of Mastering Many Design Parameters
Author: H. Wendeberg
The service life of a gearbox is determined by many factors. The bearings in the gearbox play a major role since
they themselves deliver an important function, and in addition interact with the shafts, the casing and the oil.
Without a doubt, the sizing of the bearings is of great importance for the gearbox reliability. Since more than 50
years the bearing dynamic carrying capacity has been used to determine a suitable size needed to deliver a
sufficient fatigue life – but despite the advanced calculation methods developed, the methods do not fully predict
service life. Producers of high quality bearings have introduced high performance class bearings and, lacking
better ways to express the improved performance, this is only represented by increased dynamic carrying
capacity.
The availability of high-strength shaft materials in combination with bearings with high carrying capacity allows
slimmer shafts to be used. The modulus of elasticity remains the same, so seat design for bearings and gears
must be given close attention.
This paper covers the following: sizing of bearings based on dynamic carrying capacity and how this relates to
service life; how the design of the interface between bearing and shafts should be adapted to modern shaft
materials; how the design of the interface between bearing and gearbox casing influences service life of the
gearbox; and influence of modern electric motor speed controls in bearing type selection.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-020-9 Pages: 17
11FTM22. Bearing Contribution to Gearbox Efficiency and Thermal Rating: How Bearing Design Can Improve
the Performance of a Gearbox
Author: A. Doyer
Gearbox efficiency is a topic of rising interest amongst both OEM and end-users due to an increased sensitivity to
gearbox performance, reliability, total cost of ownership (energy cost), overall impact on the environment, and also
anticipating future regulations.
In a gearbox there are difference sources of losses: gear, lubrication, seal and bearing loss. The use of modern
simulation tools makes easier the evaluation of losses in various load case conditions. It has been demonstrated
that the contribution of bearing loss on the system efficiency is dependent on the load cases. Even if the bearing
is by far not the primary source of losses, the optimization of the bearing set can significantly improve gearbox
performance. Simulation of a single stage gearbox using tapered roller bearings shows that the running
temperature of the gearbox can be reduced up to 10C, by using latest bearing generation. Such a saving could
improve the thermal rating of the gearbox by up to 30%. Experiments also demonstrated that different design of
tapered roller bearing shows significant variation in friction performance.
Having proper bearing design can significantly improve the performance of a gear unit: by a lower running
temperature, by improving lubricant life, potentially simplified lubrication system, and consequently reduced
running cost.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-022-3 Pages: 12
11FTM23. Integration of Case Hardening into the Manufacturing-Line: “One Piece Flow”
Authors: V. Heuer, K. Löser, G. Schmitt and K. Ritter
For decades the gear industry has addressed the challenge to produce high performance components in a cost-
efficient manner. To meet quality specifications, the components need to be heat treated, which traditionally takes
place in a central hardening shop. However, this separation between machining and heat treatment results in high
costs for transportation and logistics within the production plant. Therefore, for many years it has been being
discussed how to integrate heat treatment into the manufacturing line.
For about 10 years it has been possible to integrate heat treatment into the machining facility by applying the
technology of Low Pressure Carburizing (LPC) and High Pressure Gas Quenching (HPGQ). The components are
collected after soft-machining into big batches and treated with LPC- and HPGQ-technology. This means however
that the heat treatment is not synchronized with soft- and hard-machining since the components must be collected
in buffers before heat treatment and must be singularized again after heat treatment.
In order to totally integrate heat treatment into the manufacturing line and in order to synchronize heat-treatment
with machining, a new heat treatment cell has been developed. Following the philosophy of “One Piece Flow” the
parts are: taken one by one from the soft machining unit; then heat treated in time with the cycle-time of soft
machining (“synchronized heat treatment”) and then passed down one-by-one to the hard machining unit. To
allow for rapid case hardening, the components are low pressure carburized at high temperatures (1050°C)
followed by gas quenching.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM24. Induction Hardening of Gears with Superior Quality and Flexibility Using Simultaneous Dual
Frequency (SDF®)
Authors: C. Krause, F. Biasutti, and M. Davis
Induction hardening of gear teeth is well known for its challenges, but also for its potential for improved quality and
process control. For complex geometric parts like gears, the power density and induction frequency need to be
adjusted very precisely to achieve the required hardening pattern. Since 1940s it is known that working with two
simultaneous frequencies (1–15 kHz and 200–20 000 kHz) is the optimal way to heat a geared part to hardening
temperature. The key point in this process is that the medium frequency (about 10 kHz) affects primarily the tooth
root and the high frequency affects first of all the tip of the tooth and the flanks. The right combination of the power
densities of medium- and high-frequency energy values and the heating time are the crucial factors to reach a
contour true heating pattern and, thereby, a contour true hardening pattern.
The authors will describe the state of the art of induction hardening of gears with simultaneous dual frequency
using some examples of use and present the possibilities to manipulate the hardening pattern in a positive way for
different gear geometries.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-024-7 Pages: 8
11FTM25. Controlling Gear Distortion and Residual Stresses During Induction Hardening
Authors: Z. Li and B.L. Ferguson
Induction hardening is widely used in both automotive and aerospace gear industries to reduce distortion and
obtain favorable residual stresses. The heating process during induction hardening has a significant effect on the
quality of the heat-treated parts, but the importance of the quench portion of the process often receives less
attention. However, experiences have shown that the cooling rate, cooling fixture design and cooling duration can
significantly affect the quality of the hardened parts in terms of distortion, residual stresses, as well as the
possibility of cracking. DANTE is commercial heat treatment software based on finite element method. In this
paper, DANTE is used to study an induction hardening process for a helical ring gear made of AISI 5130 steel.
Prior to induction hardening, the helical gear is gas carburized and cooled at a controlled cooling rate. In this
study, two induction frequencies in sequential order are used to heat the gear tooth. After induction heating, the
gear is spray quenched using a polymer/water solution. By designing the spray nozzle configuration to quench the
gear surfaces with different cooling rates, the distortion and residual stresses of the gear can be controlled. The
crown and unwind distortions of the gear tooth are predicted and compared for different quenching process
designs. The study also demonstrates the importance of the spray duration on the distortion and residual stresses
of the quenched gear.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-025-4 Pages: 12
11FTM27. Manufacturing and Processing of a New Class of Vacuum-Carburized Gear Steels with Very
High Hardenability
Authors: C.P. Kern, J.A. Wright, J.T. Sebastian, J.L. Grabowski, D.F. Jordan and T.M. Jones
Ferrium C61 and C64 are new secondary-hardening steels that provide superior mechanical properties versus
9310, 8620, Pyrowear Alloy 53 and other steels typically used for power transmission, such as significantly higher
core tensile strength, fracture toughness, fatigue strength and thermal stability (i.e. tempering temperature). One
recent example of their application is the application of C61 to the forward rotor shaft of CH-47 Chinook helicopter,
in order to reduce the weight of the shaft by 15–25% and provide other benefits.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
11FTM28. Simulation of Wear for High Contact Ratio Gear – A Mixed FE and Analytical Approach
Authors: G. Venkatesan, M. Rameshkumar and P. Sivakumar
High contact ratio gears offer high load carrying capacity and increased life with less volume and weight. Gear
tooth wear of high contact ratio gears is of great importance as excessive wear is characterized by loss of tooth
profile and thickness, which might result in higher dynamic gear mesh and tooth forces. Surface wear changes not
only the contact pattern and load distribution, but also the vibration and noise characteristics of the gear system.
This paper deals with the simulation of wear for high contact ratio (HCR) and normal contact ratio (NCR) gears
using a Mixed Finite Element (FE) and analytical approach. A numerical model for wear prediction of gear pair is
developed. The methodology employs single point, observation-based gear contact mechanics in conjunction with
the Archard's wear formulation to predict the tooth wear in spur gears. The contact pressure and loads are
determined using a FE approach in which a two dimensional deformable body contact model of HCR and NCR
gears is analyzed in ANSYS software, and ANSYS Parametric Design language (APDL) is used for capturing the
load sharing ratio and contact stress variation on the complete mesh cycle of the gear pair. A MATLAB code
program is developed to determine the sliding velocities, equivalent contact radius and contact width along the
path of contact for both HCR and NCR gears. The contact loads and pressures obtained using FEM are used for
predicting the wear depth for NCR and HCR gear pair.
ISBN: 1-978-61481-021-6 Pages: 12
2010 PAPERS
10FTM01. Complete Machining of Gear Blank and Gear Teeth
Author: C. Kobialka
Demands for increased throughput, with smaller lot sizes at lower cost have led to the development of an
innovative approach to machining both: the gear bland and gear teeth on a single machine.
This paper will concentrate on the potentials and risks of combined process machines what are capable of turning,
hobbing, drilling, milling, chamfering and deburring of cylindrical gears. The same machine concept can be used
for singular operations of each manufacturing technology on the same design concept. This leads to reduced
amounts of different spare parts, increases achievable work piece quality and harmonizes on common user
friendliness. In the end the economic potential of combined process technology and a vision for integrated heat
treatment is shown.
ISBN: 1-55589-976-9 Pages: 8
10FTM02. Improving Heat Treating Flexibility for Wind Turbine Gear Systems through Carburizing,
Quenching and Material Handling Alternatives
Author: W. Titus
Part handling and processes for heat treating large gears have created challenges for decades. Growth in wind
energy technology has focused more attention on this issue in recent years. The vast majority of installations
processing such large parts utilize conventional methods via pit furnace systems. Such equipment has inherent
limitations with respect to quench flow and part handling, making true improvements in areas such as distortion
control difficult due to physical limitations of this processing approach. This presentation will explain alternative
methods for heat treating large components that allow part distortion to be minimized. Benefits will be quantified
regarding cost savings to produce such gearing and quality.
ISBN: 1-55589-977-6 Pages: 19
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
10FTM05. Comparison of the AGMA and FEA Calculations of Gears and Gearbox Components Applied in the
Environment of Small Gear Company
Author: V. Kirov
The current AGMA standards provide a lot of information about the calculations of loose gears and gearbox
components – shafts, splines, keys, etc. These recommendations are based mostly on the “traditional" methods of
mechanical engineering, found in many classical textbooks and research papers. Their accuracy and reliability
have been proven in many years of gearbox design and field tests. They are clear, concise, in most cases easy to
program and apply even by a small gear company with limited resources. However new methods for calculations
of mechanical engineering components like FEA (finite element analysis) are becoming wide spread. Once these
techniques were used only by big companies because of their complexity and price but with the development of
the computer technology they become more and more accessible to small gear companies which are the majority
of participants in the market.
Nowadays, in the gear business, even a small gear company is usually in possession of a modern CAD system
which always includes a basic or advanced FEA package. Such CAD systems are most often run by one gear
engineer who makes 3D models, engineering calculations and production drawings. The level of the FEA
packages is such that it allows the gear engineer to be able to do components calculations without deep
knowledge in the FEA itself.
So the question about the effectiveness of the traditional AGMA calculations and the new FEA methods becomes
of vital importance particularly for small firms.
ISBN: 1-55589-980-6 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
10FTM07. A New Statistical Model for Predicting Tooth Engagement and Load Sharing in Involute Splines
Authors: J. Silvers, C.D. Sorensen and K.W. Chase
Load-sharing among the teeth of involute splines is little understood. Designers typically assume only a fraction of
the teeth are engaged and distribute the load uniformly over the assumed number of engaged teeth. This
procedure can widely over- or underestimate tooth loads.
A new statistical model for involute spline tooth engagement has been developed and presented earlier, which
takes into account the random variation of gear manufacturing processes. It predicts the number of teeth engaged
and percent of load carried by each tooth pair. Tooth-to-tooth variations cause the clearance between each pair of
mating teeth to vary randomly, resulting in a sequential, rather than simultaneous tooth engagement. The
sequence begins with the tooth pair with the smallest clearance and proceeds to pick up additional teeth as the
load is increased to the maximum applied load. The new model can predict the number of teeth in contact and the
load share for each at any load increment.
This report presents an extension of the new sequential engagement model, which more completely predicts the
variations in the engagement sequence for a set of spline assemblies. A statistical distribution is derived for each
tooth in the sequence, along with its mean, standard deviation and skewness. Innovative techniques for
determining the resulting statistical distributions are described. The results of an in-depth study are also
presented, which verify the new statistical model. Monte Carlo Simulation of spline assemblies with random errors
was performed and the results compared to the closed-form solution. Extremely close agreement was found. The
new approach shows promise for providing keener insights into the performance of spline couplings and will serve
as an effective tool in the design of power transmission systems.
ISBN: 1-55589-982-0 Pages: 17
10FTM08. Calculation of Load Distribution in Planetary Gears for an Effective Gear Design Process
Authors: T. Schulze, C. Hartmann-Gerlach, B. Schlecht
The design of gears—especially planetary gears—can just be carried out by the consideration of influences of the
whole drive train and the analysis of all relevant machine elements. In this case the gear is more than the sum of
its machine elements. Relevant interactions need to be considered under real conditions. The standardized
calculations are decisive for the safe dimensioning of the machine elements with the consideration of realistic load
assumptions. But they need to be completed by extended analysis of load distribution, flank pressure, root stress,
transmission error and contact temperature.
ISBN: 1-55589-983-7 Pages: 11
10FTM10. Evaluation of Methods for Calculating Effects of Tip Relief on Transmission Error, Noise and
Stress in Loaded Spur Gears
Author: D. Palmer and M. Fish
The connection between transmission error and noise and vibration during operation has long been established.
Calculation methods have developed to describe the influence such that it is possible to evaluate the relative
effect of applying a specific modification at the design stage. The calculations can allow the designer to minimize
the excitation from the gear pair engagement at a specific load. This paper explains the theory behind
transmission error and the reasoning behind the method of applying the modifications through mapping the
surface profiles and deducing the load sharing. It can be used to explain the results of later experimental
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
10FTM12. Flank Load Carrying Capacity and Power Loss Reduction by Minimized Lubrication
Authors: B.-R. Höhn, K. Michaelis and H.-P. Otto
The lubrication of gears has two major functions: Reducing friction and wear as well as dissipating heat. The
power losses, especially the no-load losses, decrease with decreasing immersion depth using dip lubrication. The
load-dependent gear power losses are nearly unaffected by minimized lubrication. However, the gear bulk
temperatures rise dramatically by using minimized lubrication due to a lack of heat dissipation.
With minimized lubrication the scuffing load carrying capacity decreased by up to more than60%compared to rich
lubrication conditions. The dominating influence of the bulk temperature is therefore very clear. Starved lubrication
leads to more frequent metal-to-metal contact and the generation of high local flash temperatures must be
considered. An additional factor for the scuffing load carrying capacity calculation in case of minimized lubrication
conditions is proposed.
Concerning pitting damage test runs showed that by lowering the oil level the load cycles without pitting damage
decreased by approximately 50% up to 75% for minimized lubrication compared to the results with rich lubrication
conditions. The allowable contact stress is clearly reduced (up to 30%) by minimized lubrication. A reduced oil film
thickness as a consequence of increased bulk temperatures results in more frequent metal-to-metal contacts
causing a higher surface shear stress. In combination with a decreased material strength due to a possible
tempering effect at high bulk temperatures the failure risk of pitting damage is clearly increased. The common
pitting load carrying capacity calculation algorithms according to DIN/ISO are only valid for moderate oil
temperatures and rich lubrication conditions. For increased thermal conditions, the reduction of the pitting
endurance level at increased gear bulk temperatures can be approximated with the method of Knauer (FZG TU
München, 1988). An advanced calculation algorithm for pitting load carrying capacity calculation at high gear bulk
temperatures (valid for high oil temperatures as well as for minimized lubrication) is proposed.
The micropitting risk was increased by low oil levels, especially at high loads and during the endurance test. The
micropitting damage is caused by poor lubrication conditions which are characterized by a too low relative oil film
thickness due to high bulk temperatures. Again, the actual bulk temperatures are of major significance for
calculation of the micropitting load carrying capacity.
The wear rate of the gears is almost unaffected by the oil level. Only a slight increase of wear could be observed
with minimized lubrication. This increase can be explained by the higher bulk temperature of the gears running
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
10FTM13. Gear Design for Wind Turbine Gearboxes to Avoid Tonal Noise According to ISO/IEC 61400-11
Author: J. Litzba
Present wind turbine gearbox design usually includes one or two planetary gear stages and at least one high
speed helical gear stage, which play an important role regarding noise and vibration behavior. Next to the overall
noise of the gearbox and the structure-born noise on the gearbox housing also tonal noise is becoming a much
more important issue in recent years. Since tonal noise is problematic due to the human perception as
“uncomfortable", avoidance is important. Conventional theories regarding low noise gear design are not
developed in view of tonal noise. This leads to the question: How to deal with tonal noise in the design stage and
which gear parameters can be used for an optimization regarding good tonal noise behavior?
Within a research project measurements have been performed on different gearboxes using different gear
designs. These measurements have been evaluated according to ISO/IEC 61400-11 and the results have been
analyzed in view of the influence of different gear parameters. It was also investigated if it is possible to rank
gearboxes in wind turbines according to their tonal noise behavior as observed on the test rig.
The paper will give an introduction into the definition of tonal noise according to ISO/IEC 61400-11 and give
insight in measurement results from test rigs and from gearboxes in the field, where noise behavior is also
evaluated according to ISO/IEC 61400-11. Furthermore, the paper will show and discuss the link between
measurement results and different gear parameters, which are affecting tonal noise behavior. In addition,
simulation results will be presented, showing how tonal noise can be estimated within the design stage using
state-of-the–art calculation software.
The paper will give recommendations regarding a gear design process that is considering tonal noise in the
design stage and will compare an, regarding tonal noise, improved gear set with an older one.
ISBN: 1-55589-988-2 Pages: 19
10FTM14. Analysis and Testing of Gears with Asymmetric Involute Tooth Form and Optimized Fillet Form for
Potential Application in Helicopter Main Drives
Authors: F.W. Brown, S.R. Davidson, D.B. Hanes, D.J. Weires and A. Kapelevich
Gears with an asymmetric involute gear tooth form were analyzed to determine their bending and contact stresses
relative to symmetric involute gear tooth designs which are representative of helicopter main drive gears.
Asymmetric and baseline (symmetric) toothed gear test specimens were designed, fabricated and tested to
experimentally determine their single-tooth bending fatigue strength and scuffing resistance. Also, gears with an
analytically optimized root fillet form were tested to determine their single-tooth bending fatigue characteristics
relative to baseline specimens with a circular root fillet form. Test results demonstrated higher bending fatigue
strength for both the asymmetric tooth form and optimized fillet form compared to baseline designs. Scuffing
resistance was significantly increased for the asymmetric tooth form compared to a conventional symmetric
involute tooth design.
ISBN: 1-55589-989-9 Pages: 15
10FTM15. Drive Line Analysis for Tooth Contact Optimization of High Power Spiral Bevel Gears
Authors: J. Rontu, G. Szanti and E. Mäsä
It is a common practice in high power gear design to apply relieves to tooth flanks. They are meant to prevent
stress concentration near the tooth edges. Gears with crownings have point contact without load. When load is
applied, instantaneous contact turns from point into a Hertzian contact ellipse. The contact area grows and
changes location as load increases. To prevent edge contact, gear designer has to choose suitable relieves
considering contact indentations as well as relative displacements of gear members. In the majority of spiral bevel
gears spherical crownings are used. The contact pattern is set to the center of active tooth flank and the extent of
crownings is determined by experience. Feedback from service, as well as from full torque bench tests of
complete gear drives have shown that this conventional design practice leads to loaded contact patterns, which
are rarely optimal in location and extent. Too large relieves lead to small contact area and increased stresses and
noise; whereas too small relieves result in a too sensitive tooth contact.
Today it is possible to use calculative methods to predict the relative displacements of gears under operating load
and conditions. Displacements and deformations originating from shafts, bearings and housing are considered.
Shafts are modeled based on beam theory. Bearings are modeled as 5-DOF supports with non-linear stiffness in
all directions. Housing deformations are determined by FEM-analysis and taken into account as translations and
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
09FTM02. Implementing ISO 18653, Evaluation of Instruments for the Measurement of Gears
Authors: R.C. Frazer and S.J. Wilson
A trial test of the calibration procedures outlined in ISO 18653, Gears – Evaluation of instruments for the
measurement of individual gears, showed that the results are reasonable, but a minor change to the uncertainty
formula is recommended.
Gear measuring machine calibration methods are reviewed. The benefits from using work-piece like artifacts are
discussed and a procedure for implementing the standard in the work place is presented.
Problems with applying the standard to large gear measuring machines are considered and some
recommendations are offered.
ISBN: 1-55589-955-2 Pages: 15
09FTM03. Producing Profile and Lead Modifications in Threaded Wheel and Profile Grinding
Author: A. Türich
Modern gear boxes are characterized by high torque load demands, low running noise, and compact design. In
order to fulfill these demands, profile and lead modifications are being applied more and more. The main reason
for the application of profile and or lead modification is to compensate for the deformation of the teeth due to load,
thus ensuring proper meshing of the teeth which will result in optimized tooth contact pattern.
This paper will focus on how to produce profile and lead modifications by using the two most common grinding
processes, threaded wheel and profile grinding. In addition, more difficult modifications, such as defined flank twist
or topological flank corrections, will also be described in this paper.
ISBN: 1-55589-956-1 Pages: 16
09FTM05. HYPOLOID™ Gears with Small Shaft Angles and Zero to Large Offsets
Author: H. Stadtfeld
Beveloid gears are used to accommodate a small shaft angle. The manufacturing technology used for beveloid
gearing is a special set up of cylindrical gear cutting and grinding machines.
A new development, called Hypoloid gearing, addresses the desire of gear manufacturers for more freedom in
shaft angles. Hypoloid gear sets can realize shaft angles between zero and 20� and at the same time allow a
second shaft angle (or an offset) in space which provides the freedom to connect two points in space.
In all wheel-driven vehicles that traditionally use a transfer case with a pinion/idler/gear arrangement or a chain,
the exit of the transfer case needs to be connected with the front axle. This connection necessitates the use of two
CV joints, because the front axle input point has a vertical offset and is shifted sideways with respect to the
transfer case exit. Compared to a single CV joint, the two CV connections are more costly and less efficient.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
09FTM06. Dependency of the Peak-to-Peak Transmission Error on the Type of Profile Correction and
Transverse Contact Ratio of the Gear Pair
Author: U. Kissling
Profile corrections on gears are a commonly used method to reduce transmission error, contact shock, and
scoring risk. There are different types of profile corrections. It is a known fact, that the type of profile correction
used will have a strong influence on the resulting transmission error. The degree of this influence may be
determined by calculating tooth loading during mesh. The current method for this calculation is very complicated
and time consuming; however, a new approach has been developed which could reduce the calculation time.
This approach uses an algorithm which includes the conventional method for calculating tooth stiffness in regards
to bending and shearing deformation, flattening due to Hertzian pressure, and tilting of the tooth in the gear body.
The new method was tested by comparing its results with FEM and LVR.
This paper illustrates and discusses the results of this study. Furthermore, the maximum local power losses are
compared with the scoring safety calculated following the flash temperature criteria of AGMA 925 and DIN 3990.
ISBN: 1-55589-959-2 Pages: 19
09FTM07. Optimizing Gear Geometry for Minimum Transmission Error, Mesh Friction Losses and
Scuffing Risk
Authors: R.C. Frazer, B.A. Shaw, D. Palmer and M. Fish
Minimizing gear mesh friction losses is important if plant operating costs and environmental impact are to be
minimized. This paper describes how a validated 3D FEA and TCA can be used to optimize cylindrical gears for
low friction losses without compromising noise and power density. Some case studies are presented and generic
procedures for minimizing losses are proposed. Future development and further validation work is discussed.
ISBN: 1-55589-960-8 Pages: 20
09FTM08. Load Sharing Analysis of High Contact Ratio Spur Gears in Military Tracked Vehicle Application
Authors: M. Rameshkumar, P. Sivakumar, K. Gopinath and S. Sundaresh
Military tracked vehicles demand a very compact transmission to meet mobility requirements. Some of the
desirable characteristics of these transmissions include: increased rating, improved power to weight ratio, low
operating noise and vibration, and reduced weight. To achieve all or some of these characteristics, it is has been
decided to apply a High Contact Ratio (HCR) spur gearing concept which will improve load carrying capacity,
lower vibration, and reduce noise. Similar to helical gears, the load in HCR gearing is shared by minimum two pair
of teeth. Therefore, load sharing analysis was conducted on Normal Contact Ratio (NCR) gearing used in sun-
planet gears of an existing drive.
This paper deals with analysis of load sharing of individual teeth in mesh for different load conditions throughout
the profile for both sun and planet gears of NCR/HCR gearing using Finite Element Analysis. Also, the paper
reveals the variation of bending stress and deflection along the profile of both gearing designs.
ISBN: 1-55589-961-5 Pages: 12
09FTM09. Designing for Static and Dynamic Loading of a Gear Reducer Housing with FEA
Authors: M. Davis, Y. S. Mohammed, A.A. Elmustafa, P.F. Martin and C. Ritinski
A recent trend has been toward more user friendly products in the mechanical power transmission industry. One
of these products is a high horsepower, right angle, shaft mounted drive designed to minimize installation efforts.
Commonly referred to as “alignment-free” type, this drive assembly offers quick installation with minimum level of
expertise required. It is also more cost effective. These characteristics make this type of drive ideal for use in
applications such as underground mining where there is little room to maneuver parts.
An alignment free drive is direct coupled to the driven shaft only; it is not firmly attached to a foundation or rigid
structure. A connecting link or torque arm connects the drive to a fixed structure, which limits the drive's rotational
movement about the driven shaft. The electric motor is supported by the reducer housing through a fabricated
steel motor adapter; the coupling connecting the motor shaft and reducer shaft is enclosed by this motor adapter.
FEA was used to test the cast iron housing to determine any potential problem areas before production began.
Once analyses were completed, the motor adaptor was redesigned to lower stresses using the information from
the FEA and comparing it to the infield test data.
ISBN: 1-55589-962-2 Pages: 9
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
09FTM12. The Anatomy of a Micropitting Induced Tooth Fracture Failure – Causation, Initiation, Progression
and Prevention
Authors: R.J. Drago, R.J. Cunningham, and S. Cymbala
Micropitting has become a major concern in certain classes of industrial gear applications, especially wind power
and other relatively highly loaded somewhat slow speed applications, where carburized gears are used to
facilitate maximum load capacity in a compact package. While by itself the appearance of micropitting does not
generally cause much perturbation in the overall operation of a gear system, the ultimate consequences of a
micropitting failure can, and frequently are, much more catastrophic.
Micropitting is most often associated with parallel axis gears (spur and helical) however, the authors have also
found this type of distress when evaluating damage to carburized, hardened and hard finished spiral bevel gears.
This paper presents a discussion of the initiation, propagation and ultimate tooth fracture failure mechanism
associated with a micropitting failure. The subject is presented by way of the discussion of detailed destructive
metallurgical evaluations of several example micropitting failures that the authors have analyzed on both parallel
axis and bevel gears.
ISBN: 1-55589-965-3 Pages: 12
09FTM13. Bending Fatigue, Impact Strength and Pitting Resistance of Ausformed Powder Metal Gears
Authors: N. Sonti, S. Rao and G. Anderson
Powder metal (P/M) process is making inroads in automotive transmission applications because of substantially
lower cost of P/M steel components for high volume production as compared to wrought or forged steel parts.
Although P/M gears are increasingly used in powered hand tools, gear pumps, and as accessory components in
automotive transmissions, P/M steel gears are currently in limited use in vehicle transmission applications.
The primary objective of this project was to develop high strength P/M steel gears with bending fatigue, impact,
and pitting fatigue performance equivalent to current wrought steel gears. Ausform finishing tools and process
were developed and applied to powder forged (P/F) steel gears in order to enhance the strength and durability
characteristics of P/M gears, while maintaining the substantive cost advantage for vehicle transmission
applications.
This paper presents the processing techniques used to produce Ausform finished P/F steel gears, and
comparative bending fatigue, impact and surface durability performance characteristics of Ausform finished P/F
steel gears, as well as conventional wrought steel gears.
ISBN: 1-55589-966-0 Pages: 14
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
09FTM16. Allowable Contact Stresses of Jacking Gear Units Used in the Offshore Industry
Author: A. Montestruc
An offshore jack-up drilling rig is a barge upon which a drilling platform is placed. The barge has legs which can
be lowered to the sea floor to support the rig. Then the barge can be “jacked-up” out of the water providing a
stable work platform from which to drill for oil and gas. The rack and pinion systems used to raise and lower the
rig are enormous in terms of gear pitch or module by gear industry standards. Quarter pitch (101.6 module)
pinions are common. Lifetime number of cycles for these units are—again, by gear industry standards—small, as
rack teeth typically have 25-year lifetime cycles measured in the low hundreds. That is off the charts for AGMA
(and ISO or DIN) design rules which draw a straight line to zero cycles for contact stress cycles less than 10,000.
Use of any standards was abandoned from the start in the offshore industry for jacking applications. The author
presents methods, and experience of that industry and suggested allowable contact stresses in such applications.
ISBN: 1-55589-969-1 Pages: 8
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
09FTM18. Does the Type of Gear Action Affect the Appearance of Micro-Pitting and Gear Life?
Authors: A. Williston
Early results from testing conducted have raised questions concerning the role of gear action with the appearance
of micropitting as well as surface fatigue (macropitting). Comparisons between similar gear sets with the same
loads, speeds, and lubrication but operated either as speed increasers or as speed reducers have yielded
strikingly different propensities for wear. Further, these observations are not limited to lubrication based failures
such as micropitting, but, so far, have applied to traditional surface fatigue failures (macropitting) as well.
Findings point to an increase in the presence of micropitting on gearing operated as speed reducers. All
components are operating at the same speed and load, yet wear is greatly reduced for the driven components.
Perhaps more intriguing is that to date all macropitting failures have occurred to the driving pinions of gear sets
operated as speed reducers. While the number of samples is decidedly small, the length of life for these
components is much less than would be anticipated under smooth load circumstances. The other gear sets
(operated as speed increasers) do not show any fatigue wear.
In addition to how gear action affects micropitting in gearing is the question of how the gear action affects fatigue
life. Current gear rating standards are based upon statistical analysis of real-world experience and mathematical
stress-versus-cycle calculations. If gear action affects how gearing fails in fatigue, there may be significant
ramifications in the industry. However, before any such conclusion may be made, additional testing is necessary.
ISBN: 1-55589-971-4 Pages: 30
2008 PAPERS
08FTM01. Parametric Study of the Failure of Plastic Gears
Authors: M. Cassata and Dr. M. Morris
This paper presents the results of collaboration to develop tools for the prediction of plastic gear tooth failure for
any given set of operating conditions and to classify failure modes of these gears. The goal of the project is to
characterize and predict the failure of plastic gears over a range of given parameters.
A test plan was developed to explore the effect of rotational speed, root stress, and flank temperature on the life of
plastic gears. The dependent variable for the experiments was the number of cycles (or rotations) until failure.
ISBN: 1-55589-931-8 Pages: 7
08FTM02. A Methodology for Identifying Defective Cycloidal Reduction Components Using Vibration
Analysis and Techniques
Authors: V. Cochran and T. Bobak
For several years, predictive maintenance has been gaining popularity as method for preventing costly and time
consuming machine breakdowns. Vibration analysis is the cornerstone of predictive maintenance programs, and
the equations for calculating expected vibration frequencies for bearings and toothed gear sets are widely
available. Cycloidal reducers present a special case due to the nature of their reduction mechanism. This paper
will describe a method for utilizing vibration analysis in order to identify a defective Cycloidal ring gear housing,
disc, and eccentric bearing.
ISBN: 1-55589-932-5 Pages: 25
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
08FTM04. The Effect of Manufacturing Microgeometry Variations on the Load Distribution Factor and on Gear
Contact and Root Stresses
Authors: D. Houser
Traditionally, gear rating procedures directly consider manufacturing accuracy in the application of the dynamic
factor, but only indirectly through the load distribution consider such errors in the calculation of stresses used in
the durability and gear strength equations. This paper discusses how accuracy affects the calculation of stresses
and then uses both statistical designs of experiments and Monte Carlo simulation techniques to quantify the
effects of different manufacturing and assembly errors on root and contact stresses. Manufacturing deviations to
be considered include profile and lead slopes and curvatures, as well as misalignment. The effects of spacing
errors, runout and center distance variation will also be discussed.
ISBN: 1-55589-934-9 Pages: 15
08FTM06. Tooth Fillet Profile Optimization for Gears with Symmetric and Asymmetric Teeth
Authors: A. Kapelevich and Y. Shekhtman
Involute flanks are nominally well described and classified by different standard accuracy grades, depending on
gear application and defining their tolerance limits for such parameters as runout, profile, lead, pitch variation, and
others.
The gear tooth fillet is an area of maximum bending stress concentration. However, its profile is typically
marginally described as a cutting tool tip trajectory. Its accuracy is defined by a usually generous root diameter
tolerance. The most common way to reduce bending stress concentration is application of the basic (or
generating) rack with full radius.
This paper presents a fillet profile optimization technique based on the FEA and random search method, which
allows for a substantial bending stress reduction, by 15 to 30% compared to traditionally designed gears. This
reduction results in higher load capacity, longer lifetime, and lower cost. It includes numerical examples confirming
the benefits of fillet optimization.
ISBN: 1-55589-936-3 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
08FTM09. Concept for a Multi Megawatt Wind Turbine Gear and Field Experience
Authors: T. Weiss and B. Pinnekamp
The increasing call for the use of renewable energy in all industrial countries demands for the extension of wind
power generation capacity. In central Europe, as in parts of the Americas and Asia, such further expansion is only
possible by re-powering— replacement of existing turbines by higher rated ones—or by developing locations in
the open sea—offshore. To this end, the gear industry worldwide is challenged to develop and supply the required
number of reliable 5 MW class wind turbine gears.
This paper summarizes the concept evaluation and design of the 5 MW Multibrid® wind turbine transmission
arrangement, test bed measurements with the prototype, as well as field experience over a test period of 3 years.
ISBN: 1-55589-939-4 Pages 11
08FTM11. Bending Fatigue Tests of Helicopter Case Carburized Gears: Influence of Material, Design and
Manufacturing Parameters
Authors: G. Gasparini, U. Mariani, C. Gorla, M. Filippini, and F. Rosa
For helicopter gears many aspects of design and manufacturing must be analyzed, such as material cleanliness,
case depth and hardness, tooth root shape and roughness, and compressive residual stresses. Moreover, these
gears are designed to withstand loads in the gigacycle field, but are also subjected to short duration overloads.
Therefore, a precise knowledge of the shape of the S-N curve is of great importance for assessing their in-service
life.
A single tooth bending (STB) test procedure has been developed to optimally map gear design parameters and a
test program on case carburized, aerospace standard gears has been conceived and performed in order to
appreciate the influence of various technological parameters on fatigue resistance, and to draw the curve shape
up to the gigacycles region.
The program has been completed by failure analysis on specimens and by static tests. Some accessory
investigations, like roughness and micro-hardness measurements, have also been performed. Gigacycle tests
confirm the estimations done on the basis of the shorter tests, both in term of fatigue limit and of curve shapes.
ISBN: 1-55589-941-7 Pages: 12
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
08FTM13. Hydrogen & Internal Residual Stress Gear Failures – Some Failure Analyses and Case Studies
Author: R. Drago
Hydrogen and internal stress failures are relatively rare; however, when they occur they are often very costly and
sometimes quite catastrophic. While hydrogen and internal stress issues are generally recognized as significant in
the design and manufacture of larger gears, they are also important for smaller gears as well.
This paper presents, via illustrated actual case studies, the mechanisms by which these failures occur, the
manner in which they progress, and methods for testing finished gears for the possibility of internal problems. In
addition, precautionary steps that can be taken during design, manufacture, heat treatment and quality control to
minimize the possibility of these problems occurring in a finished part along with similar steps required to prevent
any flawed gears from entering service are also presented and discussed.
ISBN: 1-55589-943-1 Pages: 11
08FTM14. Effects of Axle Deflection and Tooth Flank Modification on Hypoid Gear Stress Distribution and
Contact Fatigue Life
Authors: H. Xu, J. Chakraborty, and J.C. Wang
Flank modifications are often made to overcome the influences of errors coming from manufacturing and
assembly processes, as well as deflections of the system. This paper presents a semi-analytical approach on
estimating the axle system deflections by combining computer simulations and actual loaded contact patterns
obtained from lab tests. By using an example hypoid gear design, influences of axle deflections and typical flank
modifications (lengthwise crowning, profile crowning and twist) on stress distribution of the hypoid gear drive are
simulated. Finally, several experimental gear samples are made and tested. Tooth surface topography is
examined by using a Coordinate Measuring Machine. Test results are reported to illustrate the effect of tooth flank
modifications on contact fatigue life cycles.
ISBN: 1-55589-944-8 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
08FTM19. How Are You Dealing with the Bias Error in Your Helical Gears?
Author: J. Lange
Using illustrations this paper explains that bias error (“the twisted tooth phoneme”) is a by-product of applying
conventional radial crowning methods to produced crowned leads on helical gears. The methods considered are
gears that are finished, shaped, shaved, form and generated ground. The paper explains why bias error occurs in
these methods, and then addresses what techniques are used to limit/eliminate bias error. Profile and lead
inspection charts will be used to detail bias error and the ability to eliminate it.
The paper details the simultaneous interpolation of multiple axes in the gear manufacturing machine to achieve
the elimination of bias error. It also explains that CNC machine software can be used to predict bias error, and
equally important that it could be used to create an “engineered bias correction” to increase the load carrying
capacity of an existing gear set.
ISBN: 1-55589-949-3 Pages: 14
2007 PAPERS
07FTM01. Estimation of Lifetime of Plastic Gears
Author: S. Beermann
This paper gives an overview on the state of art in plastic gear resistance calculation. The main problem with
plastics is the dependency of the stress cycle curve (Woehler line) with temperature. Today, more plastic gears
(as in automobile headlights) are used in a high temperature range. Furthermore, flank resistance depends
strongly on lubrication (lifetime may vary by a factor of ten and more, if oil, grease lubricated or dry running).
As no secure data for plastic gears is available, how can nevertheless plastic gear design and life time prediction
be improved? The best strategy is to use the feedback of existing reducers. Plastic gearboxes, before starting
production in big series, are normally submitted to endurance tests. If these tests are used to check also the real
lifetime limits — or by increasing test length, or by increasing applied torque — these results can be used to
define the required safety factors for future gear design. This procedure has been very successful, and will be
described with some examples.
ISBN: 1-55589-905-9 Pages: 14
07FTM02. Study of the Correlation Between Theoretical and Actual Gear Fatigue Test Data on a Polyamide
Author: S. Wasson
Fatigue tests have been run on actual molded gears in order to provide design data, using fully lubricated, plastic
on plastic spur gears in a temperature controlled experiment. The purpose of the testing is to see if there is a good
correlation between fatigue data, generated in a lab on test bars, versus the actual fatigue performance in a gear.
In order to do this, the theories of gear calculations to get root stresses also had to be examined. Advanced FEA
showed that there are corrections needed to account for high loading or high temperatures in plastic gears. The
chemistry of various nylons used in gears is explained. A high crystalline nylon has been found which is an
excellent material for gears in demanding applications and can withstand high torques and operating
temperatures. The material has very good wear properties and excellent retention of mechanical properties
(strength, stiffness, and fatigue) especially at elevated temperatures. Several commercial gear applications are
currently utilizing these properties. These will be shown to demonstrate the benefits and manufacturability of this
material.
ISBN: 1-55589-906-6 Pages: 6
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
07FTM05. Vacuum Carburizing Technology for Powder Metal Gears and Parts
Authors: J. Kowalewski and K. Kucharski,
Carburizing is one of the leading surface hardening processes applied to the sintered, low-alloyed steel gears in
the automotive industry. While diffusion of carbon in wrought steel is well documented, this is not the case for PM
steel subject to carburizing in vacuum furnaces. This paper presents results that show that the density of the
powder metal is the main factor for the final carbon content and distribution. Also important is the state of the
surface of the part; either sintered with open porosity or machined with closed porosity. The way the carburizing
gas moves through the furnace might be of some influence as well.
ISBN: 1-55589-909-7 Pages: 5
07FTM06. Using Barkhausen Noise Analysis for Process and Quality Control in the Production of Gears
Authors: S. Kendrish, T. Rickert and R. Fix
The use of magnetic Barkhausen Noise Analysis (BNA) has been proven to be an effective tool for the non-
destructive detection of microstructural anomalies in ferrous materials. Used as an in-process tool for the
detection of grinding burn, heat treat defects and stresses, BNA is a quick comparative and quantitative
alternative to traditional destructive methods.
This paper presents examples that demonstrate how BNA is used to evaluate changes in microstructural
properties. Quantitative results correlate BNA test values to x-ray diffraction values for the detection of changes in
residual stress. Qualitative results correlate BNA test values to acid etch patterns/colors for the detection of
grinding burn defects.
ISBN: 1-55589-910-3 Pages: 5
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
07FTM11. Helicopter Accessory Gear Failure Analysis Involving Wear and Bending Fatigue
Authors: G. Blake and D. Schwerin
Gear tooth wear is a very difficult phenomenon to predict analytically. The failure mode of wear is closely
correlated to the lambda ratio, and can manifest into more severe failure modes, such as bending. Presented is a
failure analysis in which this occurred. A legacy aerospace gear mesh experienced nine failures within a two-year
time period. The failures occurred after more than eight years in service and within tight range of cycles to one
another. Each failure resulted in the loss of all gear teeth with origins consistent with classic bending fatigue.
Non-failed gears, with slightly lower time than the failed gears, were removed from service and inspected. Gear
metrology measurements quantified a significant amount of wear. The flank form of these worn gears was
measured and the measured data used to analytically predict the new dynamic load distribution and bending
stress. To predict if the failure mode of wear was expected for this gear mesh, an empirical relationship of wear to
lambda ratio was created using field data from multiple gear meshes in multiple applications. Presented are the
metallurgical failure analysis findings, dynamic gear mesh analysis, the empirical wear rate curve developed, and
design changes.
ISBN: 1-55589-915-8 Pages: 12
07FTM12. The Effect of Start-Up Load Conditions on Gearbox Performance and Life – Failure Analysis and
Case Study
Author: R.J. Drago
When gearboxes are used in applications in which the connected load has high inertia, the starting torque
transmitted by the gearbox can be much higher than the rated load of the prime mover. Power plants often require
several evaporative cooling towers or large banks of air cooled condensers (ACC) to discharge waste heat.
Because of the very large size of the fans used in these applications, they fall into this category of high inertia
starting load devices. When started from zero speed, a very high torque is required to accelerate the fan to normal
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
07FTM13. Influence of Grinding Burn on the Load Carrying Capacity of Parts under Rolling Stress
Authors: F. Klocke, T. Schröder and C. Gorgels
The demand for continuous improvement concerning economic efficiency of products and processes leads to an
increasing cost pressure in manufacturing and design of power transmissions. Also, the power density of gears
has been increased which leads to a demand for higher gear quality. In more and more cases this can only be
achieved using hard finishing processes.
The demand for higher gear qualities leads to an increased use of gear grinding, which incurs the risk of thermal
damage, such as grinding burn on the gear flank. The influence of thermal damage on the set in operation is
nevertheless hard to judge so that damaged gears are often scrapped. This leads to increasing failure costs.
The lack of knowledge of the effect of grinding burn on the load carrying capacity of gears leads to the point that
the same degree of damage is judged differently by different companies. Therefore, it is necessary to do trials with
thermally damaged parts in order to know how much a certain degree of thermal damage influences the load
carrying capacity.
The investigations described in this report are aimed at determining the load carrying capacity of parts under
rolling stress. Thermally damaged rollers are employed on a roller test rig, since with this analogy process the part
geometry is easier to describe and easier to damage reproducibly.
ISBN: 1-55589-917-2 Pages: 10
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
07FTM17. Simulation Model for the Emulation of the Dynamic Behavior of Bevel Gears
Authors: C. Brecher, T. Schröder and A. Gacka
The impact of bevel gear deviations on the noise excitation behavior can only be examined under varying working
conditions such as different rotational speed and torque. The vibration excitation of bevel gears resulting from the
tooth contact is primarily determined by the contact conditions and the stiffness properties of the gears. By the use
of a detailed tooth contact analysis, the geometry based gear properties can be developed and provided for a
dynamical analysis of the tooth mesh.
A model has been developed for the simulation of the dynamic behavior of bevel gears. With the aid of a load-free
tooth contact analysis, the geometry-based part of the path excitation is determined. With a tooth contact analysis
under load, the path excitation caused by deflections can be calculated. The geometry based part of the path
excitation and a characteristic surface of the excitation values is created and provided for dynamic simulation.
This dynamic model is able to consider every deviation of the micro- and macrogeometry from the ideal flank
topography, i.e., waves and/or grooves in the surface structure, in combination with two and three dimensional
flank deviations like profile deviations, helix deviations and twists. It is also possible to consider the influence of
friction and the contact impact caused by load and/or manufacturing errors with a test rig to verify the calculations.
ISBN: 1-55589-921-9 Pages: 8
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
06FTM03. Detailed Procedure for the Optimum Design of an Epicyclic Transmission Using Plastic Gears
Authors: I. Regalado and A. Hernández
Shows the steps to get an optimum (volume based) design for an epicyclic transmission using plastic materials,
the tooth proportions of ANSI/AGMA 1006-A97, the recommendations given in ANSI/AGMA 6023-A88, and
ANSI/AGMA 2101-C95. It gives the effect of changing the number of planets, the bending fatigue and contact
strength of the plastic materials, and the temperature effects on the size of the gears. The design procedure starts
with a preliminary analysis of gear performance in a proposed (not optimized) transmission; going step by step to
an optimum design for the given load conditions and expected minimum life.
ISBN: 1-55589-885-8 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
06FTM08. An Evaluation of FZG Micropitting Test Procedures and Results for the Crowned AGMA Test Gears
Authors: D.R. Houser, S. Shon and J. Harianto
This paper reports on surface fatigue testing. The goal was to develop models for predicting wear. As part of this
goal, the study reports on developing an understanding of the stresses and wear predictors using FZG tests.
Since the focus was on micropitting, the first tests used the method described in FVA Information Sheet
No. 54/I-IV. Later, the procedure was modified to account for higher contact stress levels that are predicted for the
heavily crowned and tip relieved AGMA test gears that were manufactured as a part of the AGMA tribology test
program. This paper provides extensive analysis that includes detailed topography measurements of the tooth
profiles, predictions of contact stresses and contact patterns. It discusses factors that affect contact stresses, flash
temperatures, and test film thickness.
ISBN: 1-55589-890-4 Pages: 12
06FTM10. Fabrication, Assembly and Test of a High Ratio, Ultra Safe, High Contact Ratio, Double Helical
Planetary Transmission for Helicopter Applications
Authors: F.W. Brown, M.J. Robuck, M. Kozachyn, J.R. Lawrence and T.E. Beck
An ultra-safe, high ratio planetary transmission, for application as a helicopter main rotor final drive, has been
designed, fabricated and tested. The transmission improvements are reduced weight, reduced noise and
improved fail-safety and efficiency. This paper discusses the fabrication, assembly and testing of the planetary
transmission. An existing planetary transmission utilized a two-stage conventional spur gear design with fixed
internal ring gears. The new double helical planetary (DHP) system design uses a compound planetary
arrangement with staggered planets and high contact ratio gearing in a unique configuration. Double helical gears
in the planet to ring meshes balance axial tooth forces without axial planet bearing reactions. The spur gear sun to
planet meshes are staggered to achieve a compact arrangement. The sun gear is fully floating.
ISBN: 1-55589-892-0 Pages: 12
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
06FTM14. The Optimal High Speed Cutting of Bevel Gears – New Tools and New Cutting Parameters
Author: H.J. Stadtfeld
High speed carbide dry cutting improvements have a dependency of many important parameters upon the
particular job situation, which makes it difficult for a manufacturing engineer to establish an optimal cutting
scenario. An analysis of the different parameters and their influence on the cutting process, allows the
establishment of five, nearly independent areas of attention: blade geometry and placement in the cutter head;
cutting edge micro geometry; surface condition of front face and side relief surfaces; speeds and feeds in the
cutting process; and, kinematic relationship between tool and work (climb or conventional cutting, vector feet).
This paper presents explanations and guidelines for optimal high speed cutting depending on cutting method, part
geometry and manufacturing environment. Also, how to choose the blade system, thus giving the manufacturing
engineer information to support optimizing cutter performance, tool life and part quality.
ISBN: 1-55589-896-3 Pages: 13
06FTM15. Optimal Tooth Modifications in Spiral Bevel Gears Introduced by Machine Tool Setting Variation
Author: V. Simon
A method for the determination of optimal tooth modifications in spiral bevel gears based on load distribution,
minimized tooth root stresses, and reduced transmission errors is presented. Modifications are introduced into the
pinion tooth surface considering the bending and shearing deflections of gear teeth, local contact deformations of
mating surfaces, gear body bending and torsion, deflections of the supporting shafts, and manufacturing and
alignment of mating members. By applying a set of machine tool setting parameters, the maximum tooth contact
pressure can be reduced by 5.4%, the tooth fillet stresses in the pinion by 8% and the angular position error of the
driven gear by 48%, based on a spiral bevel gear pair manufactured by machine tool settings determined by a
commonly used method.
ISBN: 1-55589-897-1 Pages: 12
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
05FTM02. The Effects of Pre Rough Machine Processing on Dimensional Distortion During Carburizing
Author: G. Blake
A study to isolate the influence of pre-rough machine processing on final dimensional distortion. Methods are
discussed to aid process development and minimize dimensional change during carburizing. The study examined
the distortion during carburizing between five possible raw material starting conditions. Coupons were used and
manufactured from each population of material processing. Dimensions were made before and after carburizing
using a scanning coordinate measurement machine. The results show that dimensional distortion during
carburizing increases with mechanical and thermal processing.
ISBN: 1-55589-850-5 Pages: 18
05FTM04. Tooth Meshing Stiffness Optimization Based on Gear Tooth Form Determination for a Production
Process Using Different Tools
Authors: U. Kissling, M. Raabe, M. Fish
The variation of the tooth meshing stiffness is a source of noise and the exact calculation of tooth form is
important for the stiffness determination. For this purpose, software was written with the concept of an unlimited
number of tools such as hobs, grinding disk, and honing defining a manufacturing sequence. Stiffness variation
can be improved by optimization of final gear geometry with a calculation of the contact path under load. The
meshing stiffness is derived making it possible to study the effect of a proposed profile correction of a gear under
different loads. Calculations with AGMA2001 or ISO6336 check the point with the highest root stress. Effect of a
grinding notch is also included.
ISBN: 1-55589-852-1 Pages: 11
05FTM05. Computerized Design of Face Hobbed Hypoid Gears: Tooth Surface Generation, Contact Analysis
and Stress Calculation
Authors: M. Vimercati and A. Piazza
Face milled hypoid gears have been widely studied. Aim of this paper is just to propose an accurate tool for
computerized design of face hobbed hypoid gears. A mathematical model able to compute detailed gear tooth
surface is presented. Then, the obtained surfaces will be employed as input for an advanced contact solver that,
using a hybrid method combining finite element technique with semi analytical solutions, is able to efficiently carry
out contact analysis under light and heavy loads and stress calculation of these gears.
ISBN: 1-55589-853-3 Pages: 13
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
05FTM08. New Developments in Tooth Contact Analysis (TCA) and Loaded TCA for Spiral Bevel and Hypoid
Gear Drives
Authors: Q. Fan and L. Wilcox
Tooth Contact Analysis (TCA) and Loaded Tooth Contact Analysis (LTCA) are two powerful tools for the design
and analysis of spiral bevel and hypoid gear drives. TCA and LTCA respectively simulate gear meshing contact
characteristics under light load and under significant load. Application of CNC hypoid gear generators has brought
new concepts in design of spiral bevel and hypoid gears with sophisticated modifications. This paper presents
new developments in TCA and LTCA of spiral bevel and hypoid gears. The first part of the paper describes a new
universal tooth surface generation model with consideration of capabilities of CNC bevel gear generators. The
universal model is based on the kinematical modeling of the basic machine settings and motions of a virtual bevel
gear generator which simulates the hypoid gear generator and integrates both face milling and face hobbing
processes. Mathematical descriptions of gear tooth surfaces are represented by a series of coordinate
transformations in terms of surface point position vector, unit normal, and unit tangent. Accordingly, a generalized
TCA algorithm and program are developed. In the second part of this paper the development of a finite element
analysis (FEA) based LTCA is presented. The LTCA contact model is formulated using TCA generated tooth
surface and fillet geometries. The FEA models accommodate multiple pairs of meshing teeth to consider a
realistic load distribution among the adjacent teeth. An improved flexibility matrix algorithm is formulated by
introducing specialized gap elements with considerations of deflection and deformation due to tooth bending,
shearing, local Hertzian contact, and axle stiffness. Two numerical examples, a face-hobbing design and a face
milling design, are illustrated to verify the developed mathematical models and programs.
ISBN: 1-55589-856-4 Pages: 12
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
05FTM18. Planet Pac: Increasing Epicyclic Power Density and Performance through Integration
Author: D.R. Lucas
Epicyclical gear systems are typically equipped with straddle-mounted planetary idlers and are supported by pins
on the input and output sides of a carrier. These carriers can be either one-piece or two-piece carrier designs.
Traditionally many of the higher power rated epicyclic gear systems use cylindrical roller bearings to support the
planetary gears. This paper will demonstrate that using a preloaded taper roller bearing in an integrated package
should be the preferred choice for this application to increase the bearing capacity, power density, and fatigue life
performance. Based on DIN281-4 calculations, this patented, fully integrated solution allows for calculated bearing
fatigue lives to be 5 times greater than a non-integrated solution and more than 1.5 times greater than a semi-
integrated solution, without changing the planet gear envelope.
ISBN: 1-55589-866-1 Pages: 7
05FTM19. The Application of Very Large, Weld Fabricated, Carburized, Hardened & Hard Finished Advanced
Technology Gears in Steel Mill Gear Drives
Authors: R.J. Drago, R. Cunningham and S. Cymbala
In the 1980's, Advanced Technology Gear (ATG) steel rolling mill gear drives consisting of carburized pinions in
mesh with very large, weld fabricated, high through hardened gears were introduced to improve capacity.
Recently, even the improvements obtained from these ATG gear sets were not sufficient to meet higher
production rates and rolling loads. For greater load capacity ATG sets have been developed consisting of
carburized, hardened pinions in mesh with very large, weld fabricated, carburized and hard finished gears. Single
and double helical gears of this type, ranging in size from 80 to 136 inches pitch diameter have been implemented
in several steel rolling applications. This paper describes the conditions that require the use of these gears and
the technology required to design, manufacture, and, especially, heat treat, these very special, very large gear
sets.
ISBN: 1-55589-867-0 Pages: 16
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
2004 PAPERS
04FTM1. Gear Noise – Challenge and Success Based on Optimized Gear Geometries
Authors: F. Hoppe and B. Pinnekamp
Airborne and structure borne noise behavior becomes more and more an important feature for industrial
applications. Noise excitation requirements may differ with applications. Industrial conveyor belts or cement mills
are less sensitive with respect to noise emission than military applications, such as navy ship propulsion. This
paper describes requirements and solutions with regard to noise behavior focusing on examples taken from wind
turbine gear transmissions and navy applications. The individual approaches have to be a suitable compromise to
meet the challenge of noise requirement and cost optimization without restrictions on gear load carrying capacity.
Therefore, the paper shows requirements and measurements examples from shop and field tests in comparison
to gear micro geometry and calculation results.
ISBN: 1-55589-824-6 Pages: 15
04FTM3. A Method to Define Profile Modification of Spur Gear and Minimize the Transmission Error
Authors: M. Beghini, F. Presicce, and C. Santus
The object of this presentation is to propose a simple method to reduce the transmission error for a given spur
gear set, at a nominal torque, by means of profile modification parameters. Iterative simulations with advanced
software are needed. A hybrid method has been used, combining the finite element technique with semi analytical
solutions. A two dimensional analysis is thought to be adequate for this kind of work; in fact, the resulting software
does not require much time for model definition and simulations, with very high precision in the results. The
starting configuration is presented. At each subsequent step, little alteration of one parameter is introduced, and
the best improvement in terms of static transmission error is followed, until a minimum peak-to-peak value is
achieved. At the end a check is needed to verify that the tip relief is enough to avoid the non-conjugate contact on
the tip corner for a smooth transfer load.
ISBN: 1-55589-826-2 Pages: 11
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
04FTM6. The Effect of a ZnDTP Anti-Wear Additive on Micropitting Resistance of Carburized Steel Rollers
Authors: C. Benyajati and A.V. Olver
Zinc di-alkyl dithio-phosphate (ZnDTP) compounds are widely used in engine and transmission oils both as anti-
oxidants and as anti-wear additives. However, recent work has shown that many anti-wear additives appear to
have a detrimental effect on the resistance of gears and other contacting components to various types of rolling
contact fatigue, including micropitting. The paper examines the effect of a secondary C6 ZnDTP presence in low
viscosity synthetic base oil on the resistance to micropitting and wear of carburized steel rollers, using a triple-
contact disk tester. It was found that the additive caused severe micropitting and associated wear, whereas the
pure base oil did not give rise to any micropitting. It was further found that the additive was not detrimental unless
it was present during the first 100 000 cycles of the test when it was found to exert a strong effect on the
development of roughness on the counter-rollers. It is concluded that the additive is detrimental to micropitting
resistance because it retards wear-in of the contact surfaces, favoring the development of damaging fatigue
cracks. This contrast with some earlier speculation that suggested a direct chemical effect could be responsible.
ISBN: 1-55589-829-7 Pages: 10
04FTM7. A Short Procedure to Evaluate Micropitting Using the New AGMA Designed Gears
Authors: K.J. Buzdygon and A.B. Cardis
At the 1998 AGMA Fall Technical Meeting, encouraging results of a prototype micropitting test using specially
designed gears on the standard FZG test rig were reported. Additional gear sets became available from AGMA in
2000. Subsequently, several sets of these experimental AGMA test gears were used in an attempt to develop a
relatively short test procedure to evaluate micropitting. The detailed results of these tests are discussed in the
paper. The procedure involved running the test gears on the standard FZG test rig with oil circulation for 168
hours. At the end of test, the gears are rated for micropitting, weight loss, pitting, and scuffing. Five commercially
available ISO VG 320 gear oils, with performance in the FVA Procedure 54 micropitting test ranging from FLS 9-
low to FLS >10-high, were evaluated using this procedure. The degree of micropitting coverage ranged from 34%
to 7% in the new test procedure. Micropitting generally originated in the middle of the gear tooth, instead of the
root or tip. Overall, there was excellent correlation of the degree of micropitting damage between the new test
procedure and FVA Procedure 54.
ISBN: 1-55589-830-0 Pages: 8
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
04FTM12. Improved Tooth Load Distribution in an Involute Spline Joint Using Lead Modifications Based on
Finite Element Analysis
Authors: F.W. Brown, J.D. Hayes and G.K. Roddis
Involute splines are prone to non-uniform contact loading along their length, especially in lightweight, flexible
applications such as a helicopter main rotor shaft-to-rotor hub joint. A significantly improved tooth load distribution
is achieved by applying, to the internally splined member, complex lead corrections which vary continuously along
the length of the spline. Rotor hub splines with analytically determined lead corrections were manufactured and
tested under design load conditions. A standard rotor shaft-to-hub joint, which uses a step lead correction
between splines, was also tested as a baseline. Test data indicated that the complex lead corrections resulted in a
nearly uniform contact load distribution along the length of the spline at the design torque load. The data also
showed that the load distribution for the splines with the complex lead corrections was significantly improved
relative to the baseline splines.
ISBN: 1-55589-835-1 Pages: 16
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
2002 PAPERS
02FTM1. The Effect of Chemically Accelerated Vibratory Finishing on Gear Metrology
Authors: L. Winklemann, M. Michaud, G. Sroka, J. Arvin and A. Manesh
Chemically accelerated vibratory finishing is a commercially proven process that is capable of isotropically
superfinishing metals to an Ra < 1.0 in. Gears have less friction, run significantly cooler and have lower noise and
vibration when this technology is applied. Scuffing, contact fatigue (pitting), and bending fatigue are also reduced
or eliminated both in laboratory testing and field trials. This paper presents studies done on aerospace Q13 spiral
bevel gears showing that the amount of metal removed to superfinish the surface is both negligible and
controllable. Media selection and metal removal monitoring procedures are described ensuring uniform surface
finishing, controllability and preservation of gear metrology.
ISBN: 1-55589-801-7 Pages: 18
02FTM2. Development and Application of Computer-Aided Design and Tooth Contact Analysis of Spiral-Type
Gears with Cylindrical Worm
Authors: V.I. Goldfarb and E.S. Trubachov
This paper presents the method of step-by-step computer-aided design of spiroid-type gears, which involves gear
scheme design, geometric calculation of gearing, drive design, calculation of machine settings and tooth-contact
analysis. Models of operating and generating gearing have been developed, including models of manufacture and
assembly errors, force and temperature deformations acting in real gearing, and drive element wear. Possibilities
of CAD-technique application are shown to solve design and manufacture tasks for gearboxes and gear-motors
with spiroid-type gears.
ISBN: 1-55589-802-5 Pages: 15
02FTM3. The Application of Statistical Stability and Capability for Gear Cutting Machine Acceptance Criteria
Author: T.J. Maiuri
Over the years the criteria for gear cutting machine acceptance has changed. In the past, cutting a standard test
gear or cutting a customer gear to their specification was all that was expected for machine acceptance. Today,
statistical process control (SPC) is required for virtually every machine runoff. This paper will cover the basic
theory of stability and capability and its application to bevel and cylindrical gear cutting machine acceptance
criteria. Actual case studies will be presented to demonstrate the utilization of these SPC techniques.
ISBN: 1-55589-803-3 Pages: 26
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
02FTM7. Selecting the Best Carburizing Method for the Heat Treatment of Gears
Authors: D. Herring, G. Lindell, D. Breuer and B. Madlock
Vacuum carburizing has proven itself a robust heat treatment process and a viable alternative to atmosphere
carburizing. This paper will present scientific data in support of this choice. A comparison of atmosphere
carburized gears requiring press quenching to achieve dimensional tolerances in a “one piece at a time” heat
treating operation, with a vacuum carburized processing a full load of gears that have been high gas pressure
quenched within required tolerances.
ISBN: 1-55589-807-6 Pages: 13
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
02FTMS1 Design and Stress Analysis of New Version of Novikov-Wildhaber Helical Gears
Author: I. Gonzalez-Perez
This paper covers design, generation, tooth contact analysis and stress analysis of a new type of Novikov-
Wildhaber helical gear drive. Great advantages of the developed gear drive in comparison with the previous ones
will be discussed, including: reduction of noise and vibration caused by errors of alignment, the possibility of
grinding, and application of hardened materials and reduction of stresses. These achievements are obtained by
application of: new geometry based on application of parabolic rack-cutters, double-crowning of pinion and
parabolic type of transmission errors.
ISBN: 1-55589-812-2 Pages: 25
2001 PAPERS
01FTM1. Carbide Hobbing Case Study
Author: Y. Kotlyar
Carbide hobbing improves productivity and cost, however many questions remain regarding the best application,
carbide material, hob sharpening, coating and re-coating, hob handling, consistency and optimum hob wear, best
cutting conditions, and concerns for the initial cutting tool investment. This paper is a case study of a successful
implementation of carbide hobbing for an annual output of 250,000 gears, average lot size of about 200–300
gears, producing gears of about 150 different sizes and pitches, with 4 setups per day on average.
ISBN: 1-55589-780-0 Pages: 16
01FTM4. How to Inspect Large Cylindrical Gears with an Outside Diameter of More Than 40 Inches
Author: G. Mikoleizig
This paper discusses the design and function of the relevant machines used for individual error measurements
such as lead and profile form as well as gear pitch and runout. The author will cover different types of inspection
machines such as: stationary, CNC-controlled gear measuring centers, and transportable equipment for checking
individual parameters directly on the gear cutting or gear grinding machine.
ISBN: 1-55589-783-5 Pages: 20
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
01FTM7. Chemically Accelerated Vibratory Finishing for the Elimination of Wear and Pitting of Alloy
Steel Gears
Authors: M. Michaud, G. Sroka and L. Winkelmann
Chemically accelerated vibratory finishing eliminates wear and contact fatigue, resulting in gears surviving higher
power densities for a longer life compared to traditional finishes. Studies have confirmed this process is
metallurgically safe for both through hardened and case carburized alloy steels. The superfinish can achieve an
Ra < 1.5 μinch, while maintaining tolerance levels. Metrology, topography, scanning electron microscopy,
hydrogen embrittlement, contact fatigue, and lubrication results are presented.
ISBN: 1-55589-786-4 Pages: 16
01FTM8. The Effect of Spacing Errors and Runout on Transverse Load Sharing and the Dynamic Factor of
Spur and Helical Gears
Authors: H. Wijaya, D.R. Houser and J. Harianto
This paper addresses the effect of two common manufacturing errors on the performance of spur and helical
gears; spacing error and gear runout. In spacing error analysis, load sharing for two worst-case scenarios are
treated, one where a tooth is out of position and the second where stepped index errors are applied. The analyzed
results are then used as inputs to predict gear dynamic loads, dynamic tooth stresses and dynamic factors for
gear rating.
ISBN: 1-55589-787-8 Pages: 16
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Figure 9 – Design and Selection of Components for Enclosed Gear Drives Documents
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Figure 12 – Gear Power Rating for Cylindrical Shell and Trunnion Supported Equipment Documents
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Figure 13 – Sound for Enclosed Helical Herringbone and Spiral Bevel Gear Drives Documents
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Figure 14 – Practice for Enclosed Cylindrical Wormgear Speed Reducers and Gearmotors Documents
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Figure 16 – Bores and Keyways for Flexible Couplings (Inch Series) Documents
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.
Obsolete and withdrawn documents should not be used; please use replacements.
Most historical documents are available for purchase. Contact AGMA Headquarters for pricing and availability.