A Theoretical Detailed Analysis For A PR
A Theoretical Detailed Analysis For A PR
A Theoretical Detailed Analysis For A PR
Independent researcher, Former lecturer at University of Baghdad / College of engineering/ Energy Engineering Department
A B S T R A C T
PAPER INFO
In this study, PVsyst simulation software is used to analyze a PV grid tied system in a typical primary school
in Iraq. The proposed system is 5kW which is affordable and applicable from the cost and required area points
Paper history: respectively. The monthly averaged electrical load for a typical school is approximately calculated. The system
Received 25 May 2018 simulation has been done for thirteen Iraqi provinces while it is described and its performance is analyzed in
Accepted in revised form 30 June 2018 details for Baghdad city as an example. The performance ratio for the system in Baghdad is 0.825 and about
9.82MWh is generated by the system per year, 62.7% is consumed by the load and the remaining is injected
to the national grid. The results showed that the initial capital cost is $5,442 which is returned after five and
Keywords: a half years. The cost of 1 kWh if the system operates for 10 years is $0.058. This study clearly demonstrates
Solar energy that photovoltaic power system can effectively assist the peak load on the grid. In addition, these systems are
Photovoltaic system very economical/no maintenance project and can be hooked to any the peak time load.
Grid-tied systems
Simulation
PVsyst doi: 10.5829/ijee.2018.09.02.05
105
Iranica Journal of Energy and Environment 9 (2): 105-113, 2018
exploit as much as possible of buildings roofs and even In this study, a Five KW Photovoltaic grid tied
facades to install small to relatively PV arrays. This (connected) system is proposed to cover the electrical
eliminates the cost of land from the capital initial cost. In demand of a typical primary school in Iraq. The system
this study, the suggestion is to install small GTS for contributes a reduction in the peak load demand on the
governmental primary schools which are featured with national grid. PVsyst (V 6.6.8) simulation software is
the following points: selected to perform the analysis of the system.
1. In Iraq, governmental schools usually have large
unexploited space areas roof, grounds etc., as shown in
Fig. 1. SIMULATION METHODOLOGY
The first step in sizing any PV GTS for a building is to
know the annual or monthly accumulated energy (kWh)
from electricity bills or meters. In this study, this type
information is not available so instead we considered a
nominal 5kW GTS. This system size has been selected
mainly based on the installing area and the initial cost
which can be considered acceptable for a building such
as school. The simulation steps using PVsyst software are
as follows:
1. Specifying location and importing the meteorological
data (global solar irradiance on horizontal plane, diffuse
Figure 1. Satellite image for typical schools in Iraq component of solar irradiance and ambient temperature)
from satellite data sources. In this study, Metronome 7.1
2. Daily load coincides with the peak load on the grid [19, with data range 1985-2002 was selected [28].
20]. 2. Defining the orientation of PV modules (tilt angle and
3. The project can be funded by local or international azimuth angle).
"environment or climate changes organizations". 3. Identifying system components such that PV modules
4. Rising children in a building with new, clean and and inverters.
promising energy source like solar energy. 4. Optional USER’NEEDS requirements for grid tied
The number of primary schools in Iraq was system.
14.048 in 2010/2011 while the number had reached about 5. Optional choice to adjust the losses types values.
15,807 in 2013/2014 about 12.5% increase. Government
schools are 97% and 3% are private schools [21]. The PV Panel orientation
Iraqi ministry of education stated that in 2012/2013 there All solar energy collectors (PV panels, thermal) are
were 14,830 primary schools, number of pupils installed to face the sun as possible increase the amount
5,288,845, while the school buildings were 10,873. So of radiation intercepted and reduce reflection and cosine
we can consider about 500 pupils per school [22]. losses [29]. This is done by calculating optimum azimuth
Electrical energy demand of the schools on the national angle and tilt angle. Fixed PV array due to the south
grid may be reduced even can be eliminated by installing without any tracking has been selected to minimize
a PV GTS with appropriate size of GTS on each school. capital cost, less maintenance and limited land area of
PV simulation tools (such as PVsyst) are useful school buildings [30,31]. PVsyst gives in the orientation
to perform preliminary detailed analysis of systems step, the optimum tilt angles values for annual and
performance under various operating conditions. Some seasonal adjustment. For Baghdad, 30° is the optimum
tools do shading analysis on the PV array, investigate tilt angle while winter is 50°. In this study, 40°tilt angle
different load profiles, verify systemsizing for optimal was considered because of schools’ load is expected to
performance and evaluate the viability of a PV system in hardly decrease in summer. Where the larger tilt angle,
terms of energy productionand life cycle cost of the the more irradiance gets captured in winter. In addition to
system. Some studies used the benefits of quick process that larger tilt angle means less soiling, dust accumulation
of simulation using PVsyst to compare different options and better natural cooling [32].
provided by the software [23-27]. Some studies worked
on tilt angle adjustments like fixed tilt angle on annual or System Description
monthly basis or using of tracking adjustments. Some Selecting the system components in this project study
authors worked on different components like varying the take into consideration high efficiency, reliability, brand
PV modules types like mono-crystalline, poly-crystalline reputation (share in the market and number of sold items
or amorphous silicon. Other studies compared different recently) and it should have affordable cost to make the
brands or manufacturers of PV modules and inverters and system economically feasible [33].
so on.
106
Iranica Journal of Energy and Environment 9 (2): 105-113, 2018
7AM to 3PM for five days per week. Also, heating or temperature and it is higher than STC temperature with
cooling load time are assumed based on average room 20°C. Notice that According to PV module data sheet, the
temperature. The load profile is presented in Fig. 3. power drops from 270 W at STC to 198 W at Nominal
Operating Cell Temperature conditions (NOCT
conditions: Irradiance 800 W/m2, ambient temperature
20°C, air mass 1.5, wind speed 1 m/s).
Months like March, October and November were the Figure 4. The time in hours where the cell temperature
load is minimum, means neither heating nor cooling are reached to a specific value
used. Considering summer vacation, months from June
to August the overall load is low but still cooling load In practice, for Baghdad city, the module
works at its peak. May and September months where the temperature rarely found to be less 10°C only for the time
end/start of the school, the load is high as long as the right after the sunrise unfortunately the irradiance is not
weather considered hot comparing to winter months. high enough. To sum up, the results shows that high solar
irradiance and low operating module temperature hard to
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS meet together.
This section presents the simulation report detailed tables
and plots as presented by PVsyst. The case of Baghdad Irradiance analysis
city is considered in this study while the summary for PVsyst calls the horizontal global irradiation, horizontal
thirteen provinces is tabulated at the end of the section. diffuse irradiation and ambient temperature from
Meteorological data either from NASA or Metoenorm.
PV module temperature Next, it performs the transposition (global, diffuse,
The thermal behavior of PV modules strongly influences albedo irradiances) from horizontal to the tilted the
their electrical performance where the output voltage collector plane, using solar angles calculation and Perez
decreases drastically and slight increase in the output model [39].
current. The resultant is a decrease in PV power. PVsyst PVsyst applies corrections for the beam component
determines the cell temperature based on very simplified such that the horizon correction, shading effect (if near
energy balance as shown in Equation 1 [38]. Part of the shading is defined), Air Mass factor. If soiling loss is
amount of the absorbed irradiance by the PV is converted defined, PVsyst applied the soiling factor correction to all
to electrical power and the remaining power heats up the components (global, diffuse, Albedo). This leads to
cell itself. This heat eventually transferred to the ambient: “Geff”, the irradiance effectively and successfully
reaching the PV cell surface after optical corrections.
𝛼𝐺𝑒𝑓𝑓 𝐴𝑚 (1 − 𝜂) From Fig. 5, it can be seen that the monthly averaged
𝑇𝑐 = 𝑇𝑎 + (1)
𝑈 daily horizontal solar radiation varies from 2.7 kWh/m2
in December to 7.65 kWh/m2 in September. In January
where, 𝑇𝑎 is the ambient temperature, from the About 60% is the enhancement in capturing solar
meteorological data. 𝐺𝑒𝑓𝑓 is the effective irradiance radiation due to the 40° tilt angle. In April and August,
absorbed by the PV cell. 𝛼 is absorption coefficient both tilt and horizontal nearly coincides only three
(assumed 0.9). 𝜂 is the module efficiency and 𝑈 is months the horizontal is greater than tilt reaching about
Thermal Loss factor Uc assumed constant 20.0 W/m²K. 18% in June.
PVsyst provides a plot of the number of hours at Fig. 6 shows the cumulative effective irradiance in
which the PV module reached a specific temperature (see kWh/m2 for every 1 W/m2 insolation in one year. This
Fig. 4). Simulation results shows that about 3081 figure shows that it is not about how high irradiance the
hours/year is the array running/operation time. About array can capture but the important is the period in which
71% of the time the module temperature reaches more the energy is collected. For example, the module will
than 45°C which is the nominal operating cell produce very much similar energy whether the insolation
108
Iranica Journal of Energy and Environment 9 (2): 105-113, 2018
is 100 W/m2 or 1000 W/m2 since the time that the module 𝑂𝑆𝐸
receives 100 W/m2 is higher than 1000 W/m2. The 𝐸𝑔𝑟𝑖𝑑
maximum energy collected along a year is 190 kWh/m2 = (3)
𝐸𝑡𝑖𝑙𝑡 𝐴𝑚
for insolation 800 W/m2 which means this insolation is
the most frequent value. Notice that so far, the module Performance ratio (PR) is the ratio of the produced
works at 45°C and 800 W/m2 which are the NOCT energy by the system to the energy which would be
conditions for most of the time. produced by a "perfect" system continuously operating at
STC [40].
𝑃𝑅
𝐸𝑔𝑟𝑖𝑑
=
𝐸𝑔𝑟𝑖𝑑 |
𝑆𝑇𝐶
110
Iranica Journal of Energy and Environment 9 (2): 105-113, 2018
The life-cycle cost (LCC) of a solar PV system is the sum (usually in years) for the investor to recover the initial
of initial capital cost, operation & maintenance cost and cost or what is called breakeven point. If the cost of
replacement cost [15]. electricity $0.1/kWh and 9,817 kWh/y and LCC is $5,442
Table 5 lists the prices of the system components and then the payback period will be 5.5 years.
the cost of structure and hand work and the total capital
cost is about $4,865. Such small system for a specific TABLE 5. Five kW PV-GTS initial capital cost
building requires very little maintenance and the cost for Item Qty $Unit $Total % of
this purpose like periodic cleaning of the PV array or price price total cost
replacing some cables or connectors can be ignored. PV modules 20 122 2,440 50.15
While Operation and maintenance cannot be ignored for Grid tied 1 855 855 17.57
single large mega scale PV power plant. inverter
The inverter is the component of second highest cost Mounting 1 940 940 19.32
after the PV modules and it is may be damage especially structure
with working at high ambient temperature [49]. Cables and 1 130 130 2.67
According to Reference [11] replacement cost of the connectors
inverter will be 577 $. Therefore, LCC is 5,442 $. Installation 1 500 500 10.28
Levelized cost of energy (LCOE) is the ratio of the total work
life cycle cost to the life time energy produced in $/kWh Total cost $ 4,865
[48]. If the system works for 10 years, 𝐸𝐿𝑇 will be
92.63MWh, LCOE is 0.058$/kWh while when the
system works for 25 years, 𝐸𝐿𝑇 will be 218.6MWh, CONCLUSION
LCOE is 0.025$/kWh. The payback period is the time
111
Iranica Journal of Energy and Environment 9 (2): 105-113, 2018
Meeting the electrical energy demand has now become a 11. Hammad, M., Ebaid, M.S., Halaseh, G. and Erekat, B.,
major challenge for a country like Iraq with the growth in 2015, "Large Scale Grid Connected (20MW) Photovoltaic
population and same old thermal/gas power plants which System for Peak Load Shaving in Sahab Industrial
already have their operational problems. Electricity District", Jordan J. of Mechanical and Industrial
generation using solar PV systems is a potential solution Engineering (JJMIE), Vol. 9, Issue 1, pp. 45-59.
to support the national grid. In this study, PVSYST 12. M. S. Hassan, Adel A. Elbaset, 2015, "A Comparative
software has been used to analyze a proposed 5 kW PV Study for Optimum Design of Grid Connected PV System
system, output electricity and system losses installed in a based on Actual System Specifications”, International
typical governmental primary school. It is found that 5 Journal of Computer Applications. Vol. 116, Issue 3, pp.
kW system covers the schools load completely and 19-34.
exports the excess to the national grid. The project has 13. Rehman, S., Ahmed, M.A., Mohamed, M.H. and Al-
tempting advantages economically and environmentally Sulaiman, F.A., 2017," Feasibility study of the grid
connected 10 MW installed capacity PV power plants in
which may encourage the government and the investors
Saudi Arabia" Renewable and Sustainable Energy
for similar projects in the future.
Reviews, Vol. 80, pp.319–329.
14. Celik, A. N. "Present status of photovoltaic energy in
Turkey and life cycle techno-economic analysis of a grid-
REFERENCES connected photovoltaic-house." Renewable and
Sustainable Energy Reviews 10, no. 4 (2006), pp.370-387.
1. Nowak, S., 2004, "Trends in Photovoltaic Applications:
15. Kazem, H. A., Albadi, M.H., Al-Waeli, A. H.A., Al-
Survey report of selected IEA countries between 1992 and
Busaidid A. H., Chaichane, M. T., 2017, " Techno-
2003." Proceedings of the International Energy Agency
economic feasibility analysis of 1 MW photovoltaic grid
Photovoltaic Power Systems Program (IEA-PVPS).
connected system in Oman" Case Studies in Thermal
2. Kerekes, T., Koutroulis, E., Séra, D., Teodorescu, R. and
Engineering, Vol.10, pp.131 –141
Katsanevakis, M., 2013,"An Optimization Method for
16. Al-Sabounchi, A. M., Yalyali, S. A. and Al-Thani, H.
Designing Large PV Plants". IEEE Journal of
A.,2013,"Design and performance evaluation of a
Photovoltaics, 3(2), pp.814-822.
photovoltaic grid-connected system in hot weather
3. Partain, L. D., 1995,” Solar cell fundamentals. Solar Cells
conditions." Renewable energy 53, pp. 71-78.
and Their Applications”, ed. LD Partain, Wiley.
17. Kazem, H. A., and M. T. Chaichan. ,2012,"Status and
4. Eltawil, M. A., and Zhao Z., 2010, "Grid-connected
future prospects of renewable energy in Iraq." Renewable
photovoltaic power systems: Technical and potential
and Sustainable Energy Reviews 16, no. 8, pp.6007-6012.
problems—A review." Renewable and Sustainable Energy
18. General Electric, 2003, "Iraq Exploration Team Trip
Reviews 14, no. 1, pp. 112-129.
Report", briefing slides.
5. Bojic, M., Blagojevic, M., 2006, “Photovoltaic electricity
19. Allen, N., Hazlett, S. and Nerlinger, M., 2009,"Smart grid:
production of a grad-connected urban house in Serbia”.
the next infrastructure revolution". New York: Morgan
Energy Policy;34(17), pp. 2941–8.
Stanley.
6. Fernández-Infantes A, Contreras J, Bernal-Agustín JL. ,
20. Abed, F.M., Al-Douri, Y. and Al-Shahery, G.M.,
2006, “Design of grid connected PV systems considering
2014,"Review on the energy and renewable energy status
electrical, economical and environmental aspects: a
in Iraq: The outlooks" Renewable and Sustainable Energy
practical case”. Renew Energy; 31(13), pp.2042–62.
Reviews 39, pp. 816-827.
7. Bialasiewicz, J.T., 2008, “Renewable energy system with
21. http://cosit.gov.iq/ar/60-press-releases/667-57-2014
photovoltaic power generators: Operation and modeling”,
22. http://www.moedu.gov.iq/upload/upfile/ar/131.xlsx
IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, Vol. 55, pp.
23. R. Tallab and A. Malek. ,2015, "Predict system efficiency
2752-2758.
of 1 MWc photovoltaic power plant interconnected to the
8. King, D.L., 1997, “Photovoltaic module and array
distribution network using PVSYST software". In
performance characterization methods for all system
Proceedings of 2015 3rd International Renewable and
operating conditions”. In: NREL/SNL photovoltaics
Sustainable Energy Conference (IRSEC), Marrakech,
program review—Proceedings of the 14th conference—a
Morocco; pp. 1 -4.
joint meeting, vol. 394; pp. 347–368.
24. Shiva Kumar, B. and Sudhakar, K. ,2015, "Performance
9. Ali, A.H.H., Zeid, H.A.S. and AlFadhli, H.M., 2017,"
evaluation of 10 MW grid connected solar photovoltaic
Energy performance, environmental impact, and cost
power plant in India". Energy Reports; 1, pp. 184-192.
assessments of a photovoltaic plant under Kuwait climate
25. Irwan, Y. M., Amelia, A. R., Irwanto, M., Fareq. M, Leow,
condition" Sustainable Energy Technologies and
W. Z., Gomesh, N., Safwati I., 2015, "Stand-alone
Assessments, Vol. 22, pp. 25–33.
photovoltaic (SAPV) system assessment using PVSYST
10. Al-Hasan, A. Y., A. A. Ghoneim, and A. H. Abdullah. ,
software". Energy Procedia; 79, pp.596-603.
2004,"Optimizing electrical load pattern in Kuwait using
26. Matiyali, K. and Ashok, A. ,2016,"Performance evaluation
grid connected photovoltaic systems" Energy conversion
of grid connected solar PV power plant". In Proceedings
and management 45, no. 4, pp. 483-494.
of 2016 2nd International Conference on Advances in
112
Iranica Journal of Energy and Environment 9 (2): 105-113, 2018
Computing, Communication, & Automation (ICACCA) on buildings in southeast Europe". International Journal of
(fall), Bareilly; pp: 1 -5. Advances in Engineering & Technology, 1(5), pp.58-68.
27. Nirwan, D. and Thakur, T., 2017,"Performance Evaluation 42. Tarigan, E. and Kartikasari, F.D., 2015. "Techno-
of Grid Connected Solar PV Plant Using PVsyst" economic simulation of a grid-connected PV system
International Research Journal of Engineering and design as specifically applied to residential in Surabaya,
Technology (IRJET) Volume: 04 Issue: 05.,pp.3190-3194. Indonesia". Energy Procedia, 65, pp.90-99.
28. http://www.pvsyst.com/en/publications/meteo-data- 43. Bharathkumar, M., and H. V. Byregowda., 2014,
sources "Performance Evaluation of 5 MW Grid Connected Solar
29. Duffie, J. A., and Beckman, W. A., 2013,"Solar Photovoltaic Power Plant Established in Karnataka."
Engineering of Thermal Processes", John Wiley & Sons, International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Inc., 4th Edition, Engineering and Technology 3, no. 6, pp.13862-13868.
30. Häberlin, H., 2012, "Photovoltaics system design and 44. Yoo, S.H. and Lee, E.T., 2002, "Efficiency characteristic
practice": John Wiley & Sons. of building integrated photovoltaics as a shading device".
31. Wang, U., 2011, "The rise of concentrating solar thermal Build Environ; 37(6), pp.615–623
power". Renewable Energy World, 6. 45. Nochang, P., Changwoon, H., Wonsik, H., Donghwan, K.,
32. Li, D.H., Cheung, K.L., Lam, T.N. and Chan, W.W., 2012. 2011, “The effect of encapsulant delamination on
"A study of grid-connected photovoltaic (PV) system in electrical performance of PV module”, 37th IEEE
Hong Kong". Applied Energy, 90(1), pp.122-127. Photovoltaic Specialists Conference (PVSC), Seattle,
33. Messenger, R. A., and Ventre, J., 2010,"Photovoltaic Washington. pp. 1113-1115.
Systems Engineering" 3th Edition, Taylor & Francis 46. Quintana, M. A., D. L. King, T. J. McMahon, C. R.
Group, (LLC). Osterwald. 2002, “Commonly observed degradation in
34. http://en.sungrowpower.com/sungrow/about field-aged photovoltaic modules”, 29th IEEE Photovoltaic
35. Al-Khazzar A. A. A., 2017, "The Required Land Area for Specialists Conference, New Orleans, Louisiana. pp.
Installing a Photovoltaic Power Plant”, Iranica Journal of 1436-1439,
Energy and Environment 8, 1, pp.11 – 17 47. Rehman, S., Bader, M. A., Al-Moallem, S. A., 2007, "Cost
36. https://moelc.gov.iq/upload/upfile/ar/449.pdf of solar energy generated using PV panels". Renew
37. https://moelc.gov.iq/upload/upfile/ar/823.pdf Sustain Energy Rev;11(8), pp. 1843–57.
38. http://files.pvsyst.com/help/index.html 48. Edalati, S., Ameri, M., Iranmanesh, M., Tarmahi, H. and
39. Perez, R., Seals, R., Ineichen, P., Stewart, R. and Gholampour, M., 2016. "Technical and economic
Menicucci, D., 1987, "A new simplified version of the assessments of grid-connected photovoltaic power plants:
Perez diffuse irradiance model for tilted surfaces". Solar Iran case study". Energy, 114, pp.923-934.
energy, 39(3), pp.221-231. 49. Sangwongwanich, A., Yang, Y., Sera, D. and Blaabjerg,
40. JRC, 1993, "Guidelines for the assessment of photovoltaic F., 2018. "Lifetime evaluation of grid-connected PV
plants", Document B, Analysis and presentation of inverters considering panel degradation rates and
monitoring data, Issue 4.1. Joint Research Centre,Ispra, installation sites". IEEE Transactions on Power
Italy. Electronics, 33(2), pp.1225-1236.
41. Agai, F., Caka, N. and Komoni, V., 2011. "Design
optimization and simulation of the photovoltaic systems
Persian Abstract
DOI: 10.5829/ijee.2018.09.02.05
چکیده
در یک مدرسه ابتدایی معمول در عراق مورد استفادهPV برای تجزیه و تحلیل یک شبکه متصل شده به شبکهPVSyst نرم افزار شبیه سازی،در این مطالعه
متوسط بار الکتریکی. کیلو وات است که به ترتیب مقرون به صرفه و قابل استفاده از هزینه ها و نقاط منطقه مورد نیاز است5 سیستم پیشنهادی.قرار می گیرد
در حالی که آن را شرح داده است و عملکرد، شبیه سازی سیستم در سیزده استان عراق انجام شده است.ماهانه برای مدرسه معمولی تقریبا محاسبه شده است
مگاوات ساعت در228. است و در حدود528.5 نسبت عملکرد سیستم در بغداد.آن به صورت نمونه ای برای شهر بغداد مورد تجزیه و تحلیل قرار گرفته است
دالر است544. نتایج نشان می دهد که هزینه اولیه سرمایه. از طریق بار مصرف می شود و باقیمانده به شبکه ملی تزریق می شود٪7.26 ،سال تولید می شود
این مطالعه به وضوح نشان. دالر است52558 ، سال کار می کند15 اگر سیستم برای، کیلو وات ساعت1 هزینه.که بعد از پنج سال و نیم بازپرداخت می شود
بدون/ این سیستم ها پروژه بسیار با ارزش، عالوه بر این.می دهد که سیستم قدرت فتوولتائیک می تواند به طور موثر به بار پیک بر روی شبکه کمک کند
.تعمیر و نگهداری می باشد و می تواند به هر بار بار حداکثر زمان برسد
113