Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]
Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 143 views

    Create A Chart Comparing in Detail The Accounts of The Two Writers Regarding The "Tejeros Convention" Santiago Alvarez Teodoro Agoncillo

    Uploaded by

    Cass Cruz
    1. Santiago Alvarez and Teodoro Agoncillo provide accounts of the Tejeros Convention in their writings. Alvarez's memoir provides direct quotes and details of interactions as a primary source, while Agoncillo's history provides analysis and interpretation as a secondary source. 2. Their accounts agree that Daniel Tirona objected to Andres Bonifacio's election, which led Bonifacio to draw his revolver in anger. They also both describe Baldomero Aguinaldo reconvening the disrupted meeting the next day. 3. Their accounts differ in some details, such as whether the Magdalo or Magdiwang factions held certain positions after voting, and descriptions of pre-

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Create A Chart Comparing in Detail The Accounts of The Two Writers Regarding The "Tejeros Convention" Santiago Alvarez Teodoro Agoncillo

    Uploaded by

    Cass Cruz
    143 views19 pages
    1. Santiago Alvarez and Teodoro Agoncillo provide accounts of the Tejeros Convention in their writings. Alvarez's memoir provides direct quotes and details of interactions as a primary source, while Agoncillo's history provides analysis and interpretation as a secondary source. 2. Their accounts agree that Daniel Tirona objected to Andres Bonifacio's election, which led Bonifacio to draw his revolver in anger. They also both describe Baldomero Aguinaldo reconvening the disrupted meeting the next day. 3. Their accounts differ in some details, such as whether the Magdalo or Magdiwang factions held certain positions after voting, and descriptions of pre-

    Original Description:

    Original Title

    RIPH

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    1. Santiago Alvarez and Teodoro Agoncillo provide accounts of the Tejeros Convention in their writings. Alvarez's memoir provides direct quotes and details of interactions as a primary source, while Agoncillo's history provides analysis and interpretation as a secondary source. 2. Their accounts agree that Daniel Tirona objected to Andres Bonifacio's election, which led Bonifacio to draw his revolver in anger. They also both describe Baldomero Aguinaldo reconvening the disrupted meeting the next day. 3. Their accounts differ in some details, such as whether the Magdalo or Magdiwang factions held certain positions after voting, and descriptions of pre-

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    143 views19 pages

    Create A Chart Comparing in Detail The Accounts of The Two Writers Regarding The "Tejeros Convention" Santiago Alvarez Teodoro Agoncillo

    Uploaded by

    Cass Cruz
    1. Santiago Alvarez and Teodoro Agoncillo provide accounts of the Tejeros Convention in their writings. Alvarez's memoir provides direct quotes and details of interactions as a primary source, while Agoncillo's history provides analysis and interpretation as a secondary source. 2. Their accounts agree that Daniel Tirona objected to Andres Bonifacio's election, which led Bonifacio to draw his revolver in anger. They also both describe Baldomero Aguinaldo reconvening the disrupted meeting the next day. 3. Their accounts differ in some details, such as whether the Magdalo or Magdiwang factions held certain positions after voting, and descriptions of pre-

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 19

    Activity #2

    1. Who is Santiago Alvarez? How come his writing is a primary source?


    - Santiago Alvarez was a revolutionary general and the founder and honorary president of the
    Nacionalista Party's first directorate. Because of his ferocious bravery and devotion as leader at
    the fight of Dalhican, Cavite, he was called as Kidlat ng Apoy (Lightning of Fire). He is the only
    son of General Mariano Alvarez. He was also known as the "Hero of the Battle of Dalahican." His
    writing is a primary source because Tejeros' convention is found in Chapter 32 of Gen. Santiago
    Alvarez's memoirs, and as we all know, a memoir is written from the author's perspective, about
    an important part of their life, so it's a primary source, and Alvarez was a direct participant and
    witness to the election's events.
    2. Who is Teodoro Agoncillo? How come his writing is a secondary source?
    - Teodoro Agoncillo was a 20th-century Filipino historian who was widely regarded as one of the
    best. He and his contemporary Renato Constantino were among the first Filipino historians to
    gain notoriety for promoting a strongly nationalist perspective of Philippine history. His writing
    was classified as a secondary source since he is a historian, which means he only researches,
    studies, analyzes, interprets, and documents historical facts. He hasn't had the same hands-on
    experience as Alvarez.
    3. Create a chart comparing in detail the accounts of the two writers regarding the “Tejeros
    Convention”

    Santiago Alvarez Teodoro Agoncillo


     Prior to the election of offices, there are  The Magdiwang chose the following men
    several discussions. Andres Bonifacio to oversee the administration after voting
    spearheaded the charge. General independently of the Magdalo. People in
    Artemio Ricarte was named Secretary by Magdalo were elected to seize control of
    Supremo Bonifacio. Mr. Diego Mojica the administration.
    warned the Supremo that many of the  Both sides agreed to use the same
    ballots had already been filled out and uniform for their separate forces. When
    that the voters had not done so. This was Cavite, commanded by competing
    ignored by Sumpremo. factions, successfully revolted, the
     Officers were elected from vice president leaders became embroiled in feuds over
    to lowest rank. Mr. Andres Bonifacio was the desire to lord over one another. The
    chosen Secretary of the Interior, but Mr. magdiwang faction claims it has the right
    Daniel Tirona requested that the order be to rule because it was the one who
    restored against Mr. Bonifacio. Mr. Jose started the revolution in Cavite. It was
    del Rosario, he claims, is superior to met with resistance by the magdalo men.
    Bonifacio because Bonifacio lacks any They claim that their commanders won
    qualifications attesting to any level of the majority of the victories in the former
    knowledge. This made Bonifacio stood area.
    up and said, “We agreed to abide by the  Bonifacio received three invitations, the
    majority vote and acceptits choice no third of which was prepared by Artemio
    matter what the station in life of the Ricarte on Mariano Alvarez's instructions,
    person elected. And because of this, I and Bonifacio ultimately accepted the
    demand from you, Mr. Daniel Tirona an invitation. He is accompanied by his wife
    apology. You must restore to the voters and two brothers.
    and the elected the honor you have only  The rebel leader led Bonifacio to Juan
    now besmirched.” Then he pulled out his Castaneda's house in Imus. Personnel
    revolver and took aim. came to pay him a visit. And seeing

    Mr. Tirona
    Fernandez reminded him of the combat
    at San Juan, which Fernandez was
    supposed to win but didn't. Because

    ignored
    there were so many misunderstandings,
    both sides' leaders decided to assemble a
    convention or assembly at Imus.

    Bonifacio, he  Bonifacio was appointed to the position


    of Director of the Interior. Magdalo man
    Daniel Tirona did not agree with the

    slid outcome and instead nominated Jose del


    Rosario. Bonifacio was so offended that
    he pulled out his revolver and prepared

    away and got to fire at Tirona, but Ricarte intervened.


    He was in excruciating anguish and
    heartbreak at his failure to win the
    lost in the presidency.

    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
     Mr. Tirona ignored Bonifacio, he slid
    away and got lost in the crowd. People
    began to disperse and the Supremo
    adjourned the meeting. Mr. Baldomero
    Aguinaldo, convinced the magdiwang
    leaders to reconvene the disrupted
    meeting the following day.
     A conference was called at the same friar
    estate residence in Terejos on the
    request of Magdalo Pres. Baldomero
    Aguinaldo. Sactiago Alvarez, Artemio
    Ricarte, and others waited until 5 p.m.,
    but no members of Magdalo arrived. The
    Magdalo leaders were supposed to be
    meeting in the parish house in Tanza on
    the same night.

    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day
    Mr. Tirona
    ignored
    Bonifacio, he
    slid
    away and got
    lost in the
    crowd. People
    began to
    disperse and the
    Supremo
    adjourned the
    meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo,
    convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to
    reconvene the
    disrupted
    meeting the
    following day

    Mr. Tirona ignored Bonifacio,


    he slid Mr. Tirona ignored
    Bonifacio, he slid
    away and got lost in the crowd.
    People
    began to disperse and the Supremo
    adjourned the meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo, convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to reconvene the disrupted
    meeting the following da
    away and got lost in the crowd.
    People
    began to disperse and the Supremo
    adjourned the meeting. Mr.
    Baldomero
    Aguinaldo, convinced the
    magdiwang
    leaders to reconvene the disrupted
    meeting the following da
    4. Form your internal and external criticisms over the two sources.
    - My internal criticisms of these two sources are that Alvarez's writing was thorough, and
    because there are dialogues between characters, we can truly assume that the author was
    present at the time. While Agoncillo's writing focuses on Andres Bonifacio's trip, it appears that
    Alvarez failed to incorporate a longer version of the past in his memoir, despite the fact that he
    put so much effort into research for this book. The meaning expressed in the source was clearly
    understood by both.
    - Both author shows the authenticity, validity, or reliability of each source for my external
    criticism. Alvarez as a witness itself on the election and Agoncillo, as a distinguished historian,
    did a lot of research for us to be able to know what else happened at that convention.
    1.

    You might also like