Breakthrough Infection After Covishield COVID-19 Vaccine Among Health Care Workers at Patan Academy of Health Sciences, Nepal
Breakthrough Infection After Covishield COVID-19 Vaccine Among Health Care Workers at Patan Academy of Health Sciences, Nepal
Breakthrough Infection After Covishield COVID-19 Vaccine Among Health Care Workers at Patan Academy of Health Sciences, Nepal
1
Prof. Surgery, 3Prof. Orthopedics and Trauma surgery, 4Asst. Prof.
General Practice and Emergency Medicine, 5Assoc. Prof. Biochemistry and
ISSN: 2091-2749 (Print) Molecular Lab Medicine, 6Nursing Director, Patan Hospital, School of Medicine;
2Assoc. Prof., 7Prof. & Nursing Dean, Lalitpur Nursing Campus, School of Nursing
2091-2757 (Online)
and Midwifery; Patan Academy of Health Sciences, Lalitpur, Kathmandu, Nepal
Abstract
Method: This cross-sectional survey was conducted among the health care
Peer Reviewers workers (HCWs) from May 2021 to July 2021 at Patan Hospital, Patan
Prof. Madhusudan Subedi, Academy of Health Sciences, Nepal who received the Covishield vaccine.
Patan Academy of Health The data were collected using Google form and a printed questionnaire on
Sciences, Nepal COVID 19 breakthrough infection ≥2w after vaccination. The rate of
breakthrough infection, hospitalization, and its association with age,
Prof. Dr. Gehanath Baral, Nobel
Medical College, Biratnagar, gender, and working departments of HCWs was analyzed using SPSS.
Nepal Ethical approval was obtained.
Submitted Result: Out of 1462 HCWs approached, 880 completed the survey, among
21 Aug 2021 which 819(93.1%) had a completed vaccination status. Infection after the
first and before the second dose was 164(18.7% of 880) and after two
Accepted doses 131(16%). The breakthrough infection occurred in 83 (10.1% of 819).
30 Aug 2021 There was no statistically significant association of breakthrough infection
with age, gender, and working department of HCWs. Total 74(8.4%) were
How to cite this article managed by admission in hospital.
Jay Shah, Priscilla Samson,
Nabees MS Pradhan, Ashis Conclusion: The findings of this study reveal a low breakthrough infection
Shrestha, Shreekrishna rate after Covishield vaccination among HCWs at Patan Academy of Health
Maharjan, Shanta Dangol, et al. Sciences, Kathmandu, Nepal. Overall, COVID-19 infection rates decreased
Breakthrough infection after after the first and second dose of the vaccine.
Covishield COVID-19 vaccine
among health care workers at Keywords: Breakthrough infection, Covishield COVID-19 vaccine,
Patan Academy of Health
reinfection, Nepal
Sciences, Nepal. Journal of
Patan Academy of Health
Sciences. 2021Aug;8(2):10-17.
https://doi.org/10.3126/jpahs.
v8i2.28833
Data were collected after obtaining ethical researcher during data processing and
approval from the Institutional Review thereafter deposited with the institution as
Committee of PAHS (Ref: drs2105281528). required by the ethical committee/institution
Confidentiality was maintained by not sharing for storage of at least 5 y, accessible to the
the data for any purpose other than this ethical committee and/or executive
research. Data were saved in a password- committee when required.
protected file on a personal computer of the
Survey form sent out 1462 (Google form 1309; Print 153)
Yes No
819(93.1%) 61(9.9%)
Breakthrough infection
83(10.1%)
Figure 1. Flowchart of Covishield COVID-19 vaccine breakthrough infection survey among HCWs at PAHS,
Nepal
Table 1. Demography HCWs at PAHS in Covishield COVID-19 vaccine breakthrough infection survey, N=880
Variable N %
Age in y <20 43 4.9
20-40 606 68.9
41-60 215 24.4
>60 16 1.8
Gender Male 194 22.0
Female 686 78.0
HCWs Medical Dr. 49 5.6
Nurse 350 39.8
Paramedics 65 7.4
HCWs Non-medical Administration 32 3.6
Teaching 35 4.0
Support 198 22.5
Student 151 17.2
Hospitalized 74 8.4
PCR confirmation, i.e., PCR positive 295 33.5
HCWs- health care workers (all the staff and students of PAHS/Patan Hospital, Nepal), PAHS- Patan Academy of Health
Sciences, Covishield- ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 Corona Virus Vaccine of AstraZeneca produced by Serum Institute of India
Table 2. COVID-19 infection after Covishield COVID-19 vaccine among HCWs at PAHS, Nepal
Table 3: Association of demographic variables for breakthrough infection (N=83) ≥14 d after Covishield
among HCWs at PAHS, Nepal
Variables Breakthrough infection, N=83 X2 value p value
Age ≤40y 60(72.3%) 0.086 0.770
Age >40y 23(27.7%)
Male 24(28.9%) 2.517 0.113
Female 59(71.8%)
Medical 44(53.0%) 0.000 0.991
Non-medical 39(47.0%)
Table 4. Comparison of reinfection in those who had COVID-19 infection before vaccination (Group A: N=215)
with those who did not (Group B: N=604) at PAHS, Nepal
Infection after vaccine Group A, prior infection before Group B, No prior infection before
vaccine (N=215), N, % vaccine (N=604), N, %
After 1st dose <14 d 58 26.9 22 3.6
≥14 d 39 18.1 33 5.5
After 2nd dose <14 d 23 10.7 23 3.8
≥14 d* 24 11.1 58 9.6
*breakthrough infection following complete vaccine, Chi Square statistics is 78.8, p value = <0.00001
support, and there was no mortality. This two doses of ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 vaccine. QJM.
shows that vaccination has benefits and 2021;hcab167. | DOI | PubMed | Google
effectively reduces severe infection and Scholar | Weblink |
mortality. Larger studies, preferably in the 4. Sharma P, Mishra S, Basu S, Tanwar N, Kumar
R. Breakthrough infection with SARS-CoV-2
community, with a diverse population and with
and its predictors among healthcare workers
comorbidities may provide further data on in a medical college and hospital complex in
these aspects of vaccine breakthrough Delhi, India. medRxiv. 2021 Jun 9. | DOI |
infection. Google Scholar | Full Text |
5. Keehner J, Horton LE, Pfeffer MA, Longhurst
CA, Schooley RT, Currier JS, et al. SARS-CoV-2
Conclusion infection after vaccination in health care
workers in California. N Engl J Med.
Breakthrough infection (≥14 d) after Covishield 2021;384(18):1774–5. | DOI | PubMed |
COVID-19 vaccination occurred with a low Google Scholar | Weblink |
frequency (10.1%) among health care workers 6. Ma C, Xu S, Yao Y, Yu P, Xu Y, Wu R, et al. Mild
breakthrough infection in a healthcare
at Patan Academy of Health Sciences, Nepal.
professional working in the isolation area of a
The vaccine was effective; as breakthroughs hospital designated for treating COVID-19
were mild, didn’t require ventilator support, patients — Shaanxi Province, China, March,
and mortality was nil as per hospital record. 2021 [Internet]. China CDC Weekly.
2021;3(19):397-400. | Google Scholar |
Acknowledgment Weblink |
We thank the HCWs of PAHS for taking out 7. Rajagopal D, Thacker T, ET Bureau. Post-
time to participate in the survey study. We inoculation possibility: May be many
acknowledge the contribution by intern Drs. breakthrough cases, but mild, says ICMR
Jenifei Shah and Jesifei Shah from Shanghai [Internet]. The Economic Times. 2021 May 7;
News. [cited 2021 May 23] | Weblink |
Jiao Tong University School of Medicine for
8. Tyagi K, Ghosh A, Nair D, Dutta K, Bhandari PS,
checking references and language revisions. Ansari IH, et al. Breakthrough COVID19
infections after vaccinations in healthcare and
Conflict of Interest other workers in a chronic care medical facility
None in New Delhi, India. Diabetes Metab Syndr.
2021;15(3):1007-8. | DOI | PubMed | Google
Funding Scholar | Weblink |
None 9. Poudel A. Nepal begins first phase of Covid-19
vaccination drive [Internet]. The Kathmandu
Author Contribution Post. 2021 Jan 28; Health. [cited 2021 Aug 6] |
Weblink |
Concept and design: All; Data collection: PS,
10. Shah J, Samson P, Pradhan NM, Maharjan S,
SD, SK; Data analysis: PS, AS, NP, JNS; Shrestha A, Shah J, et al. Breakthrough
Literature review, Draft manuscript: JNS; infection after COVID-19 vaccination: A threat
Revision of draft manuscript: PS, AS, NP, JNS; for Nepal due to SARS-CoV-2 variants
Final manuscript: ALL circulating in 2nd wave ravaging India:
Breakthrough infection after COVID-19
Reference vaccination. J Patan Acad Health Sci.
2021;8:e1-11. | DOI | Google Scholar | Full
1. Parry J. Covid-19: Hong Kong scientists report Text | Weblink |
first confirmed case of reinfection. BMJ. 11. Gavi. What is the difference between efficacy
2020;370:m3340. | DOI | PubMed | Google and effectiveness? [Internet] Gavi, the Vaccine
Scholar | Weblink | Alliance. 2020 Nov 18. [cited 2021 May 21] |
2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Weblink |
COVID-19 breakthrough case investigations 12. Ghosh P. Delta major reason for Covid
and reporting [Internet]. CDC. 2021. [cited breakthrough infection: 10 findings of ICMR
2021 May 25] | Weblink | study [Internet]. Hindustan Times. 2021 Jul 16;
3. Niyas VK, Arjun R. Breakthrough COVID-19 India News. [cited 2021 Aug 9] | Weblink |
infections among health care workers after
13. Wadman M. Having SARS-CoV-2 once confers 22. Amatya B, Pandey P, Dawadi S, Manandhar S.
much greater immunity than a vaccine – but COVID-19 in fully vaccinated Everest trekkers
vaccination remains vital. Science. in Nepal. J Travel Med. 2021:taab098. | DOI |
2021;373(6559):1067-8. | DOI | PubMed | PubMed | Google Scholar | Full Text |
Google Scholar | Weblink | Weblink |
14. Arkhipova-Jenkins I, Helfand M, Armstrong C, 23. Pinghui Z, McCarthy S. Chinese trial mixes
Gean E, Anderson J, Paynter RA, et al. Covid-19 vaccines using different technologies
Antibody response after SARS-CoV-2 infection [Internet]. South China Morning Post. 2021
and implications for immunity. Ann Intern Apr 19; China/Science. [cited 2021 Aug 9] |
Med. 2021;174(6):811-21. | DOI | PubMed | Weblink |
Google Scholar | Weblink | 24. Pinghui Z. Chinese health official says he’s had
15. Jeremijenko A, Chemaitelly H, Ayoub HH, a mix of 3 Covid-19 shots [Internet]. South
Alishaq M, Abou-Samra AB, Al Ajmi JA, et al. China Morning Post. 2021 Jul 20; Coronavirus
Herd immunity against severe acute Pandemic. [cited 2021 Aug 9] | Weblink |
respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 infection 25. The Tribune. Mixed Covishield, Covaxin doses
in 10 communities, Qatar. Emerg Infect Dis. produce better immunity: ICMR [Internet].
2021;27(5):1343-52. | DOI | PubMed | Google Tribune News Service, India. 2021 Aug 9;
Scholar | Weblink | Nation. [cited 2021 Aug 9] | Weblink |
16. Schuler CF, Gherasim C, O’Shea K, Manthei 26. Johansen K, Nohynek H. No country or
DM, Chen J, Zettel C, et al. Mild SARS-CoV-2 continent is on its own in the ongoing COVID-
illness is not associated with reinfections and 19 pandemic. Euro Surveill.
provides persistent spike, nucleocapsid, and 2021;26(17):2100430. | DOI | PubMed |
virus-neutralizing antibodies. Microbiol Google Scholar | Weblink |
Spectr. 2021;e0008721. | DOI | PubMed | 27. Yin Z, Rodewald L, Wu D. If the world doesn’t
Google Scholar | Weblink | share the vaccine, the virus will take on the
17. Jacobson KB, Pinsky BA, Rath ME, Wang H, world [Internet]. China CDC Weekly.
Miller JA, Skhiri M, et al. Post-vaccination 2021;3(13):265-6. [cited 2021 Aug 9] | DOI |
SARS-CoV-2 infections and incidence of the Google Scholar | Full Text | Weblink |
B.1.427/B.1.429 variant among healthcare 28. Shah JN. The ‘Vero Cell’ COVID-19 vaccine
personnel at a northern California academic rollout in Nepal: What we know about the
medical center. medRxiv. 2021 Apr 24. | DOI | Chinese vaccine development and access? J
Google Scholar | Full Text | Patan Acad Health Sci. 2021;8(1):1-8. | DOI |
18. Tinker B, Fox M. So far, 5,800 fully vaccinated Google Scholar | Full Text | Weblink |
people have caught Covid anyway in US, CDC 29. Yang J, Zheng W, Shi H, Yan X, Dong K, You Q,
says [Internet]. CNN. 2021 Apr 15; CNN et al. Who should be prioritized for COVID-19
Health. [cited 2021 May 25] | Weblink | vaccination in China? A descriptive study. BMC
19. Hacisuleyman E, Hale C, Saito Y, Blachere NE, Med. 2021;19(1):45. | DOI | PubMed | Google
Bergh M, Conlon EG, et al. Vaccine Scholar | Weblink |
breakthrough Infections with SARS-CoV-2 30. Yang J, Marziano V, Deng X, Guzzetta G, Zhang
variants. N Engl J Med. 2021;384(23):2212-8. | J, Trentini F, et al. Despite vaccination, China
DOI | PubMed | Google Scholar | Weblink | needs non-pharmaceutical interventions to
20. European Medicines Agency. ECDC and EMA prevent widespread outbreaks of COVID-19 in
update on COVID-19 [Internet]. European 2021. Nat Hum Behav. 2021;5(8);1009-1020. |
Medicines Agency. 2021 Apr 8; News. [cited DOI | PubMed | Google Scholar | Weblink |
2021 Aug 6] | Weblink | 31. The Himalayan Times Online. Nepal govt
21. World Health Organization. Vaccines are confirms detection of B.1.617.2 variant of
highly effective against severe illness and coronavirus months after advent of second
death caused by the COVID19 variants, wave [Internet]. The Himalayan Times. 2021
including Delta (Twitter post, WHO) [Internet]. May 19; Environment. [cited 2021 May 21] |
[cited 2021 Aug 6] | Weblink| Weblink |