Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Seminar 8 BLAW Notes

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

NANYANG TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY

NANYANG BUSINESS SCHOOL

AB1301 - BUSINESS LAW


AUGUST 2018

Seminar 8: Remedies for Breach of Contract

Key Learning Points:


• To know and understand the various common law and equitable remedies available to the
innocent party for breach of contract
• To understand the doctrine of mitigation
• To know and be able to apply the rules relating to a claim of damages
• To be able to distinguish between liquidated damages and penalties, and to understand the
legal effect of both

Contents

A. Damages at Common Law


B. Equitable Remedies
C. Liquidated Damages v Penalties

A. Damages at Common Law


‒ Compensatory nature of damages
 Compensation for loss suffered, not punitive in nature
 Difficulty of assessment is no bar to recovery
 Compensation for non-pecuniary loss: inconvenience or disappointment
 Loss of reputation: bright line rule of non-recovery
‒ Principle of assessment: To place the innocent party, so far as money can do it, in the same
position that he would have been in had the guilty party not breached his obligations
‒ Basis of assessment
 Expectation loss
 Reliance loss
(Note: The rule against double recovery)
‒ Rules for claiming of damages
 Causation in fact (But-for test)
 Rule against remoteness (Two-limbed test in Hadley v Baxendale)
‒ Doctrine of mitigation

Comments:
‒ Students should be able to apply the rules relating to a claim of damages and to
understand the different bases of assessment.

B. Equitable remedies
‒ Discretionary nature of equitable remedies
‒ Specific performance
‒ Injunction (prohibitory and mandatory)
Comments:
‒ Students should be able to identify when the various equitable remedies are
appropriate as well as the conditions for granting these equitable remedies

C. Liquidated damages v penalties


‒ Definition of liquidated damages
‒ Guidelines for ascertaining whether liquidated damages clause or penalty clause: Dunlop
Pneumatic Tyre Co v New Garage Motor
‒ Effect of liquidated damages clause v effect of penalty clause

Comments:
‒ Students should be able to:
 distinguish between a liquidated damages clause and a penalty clause
 understand the legal effect of both

You might also like