Jurnal Halimahtun Saadiah
Jurnal Halimahtun Saadiah
Jurnal Halimahtun Saadiah
GMFCS, Gross Motor Function Classification System (Palisano et al. 1997). SpDi, spastic diplegia; SpTet, spastic
tetraplegia. Children were assigned to training group 1 or 2 for didactic reasons.
Figure 1: Timing of assessments before, during, and after intervention. Each interval indicates one month. Arrows indicate
timing. Gross Motor Function Measure-66 assessments (Russell et al. 2002) were made by three physical therapists (PTs)
following same child through indicated time-period. Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory (PEDI; Haley et al. 1992)
assessments were made by same three PTs and a special needs teacher. Goal assessment was made by parents in
collaboration with PTs and a special needs teacher; MPOC, Measure of Processes of Care (King et al. 1995).
Functional Therapy in Children with Cerebral Palsy Lena Ekström Ahl et al. 615
during the first two months of the intervention (Wilcoxon QUESTIONNAIRE
p<0.01). Between the following assessments a steady upward The supplementary questionnaire was completed to a larger
trend was found, but the change did not reach significance (p extent than the MPOC, by mothers (n=11), fathers (n=9),
values ranging from 0.02–0.05). Between the last three assess- and assistants (n=10). Preintervention, fathers had the lowest
ments performed post-intervention, no significant change was score relating to all four questions. After the intervention the
seen, indicating that functions gained through training were scores indicated a significant change in the knowledge they
sustained. The amount of change in gross motor function was had acquired (questions 1, 2, 3) and how clear the goals were
not related to age at onset of the intervention (rs=–0.17). (p<0.001). Mothers also expressed that they had an enhanced
knowledge in response to all four questions. Preschool assis-
PEDI tants initially graded the last three questions higher than the
According to the parents, the children significantly improved parents; no significant change caused by the intervention was
self-care performance (median 44 vs 49.2, p<0.001), mobility found. However, assistants felt they had acquired more knowl-
(median 41.3 vs 43.8, p<0.01), and social function (median edge on training the child during the intervention period
53.4 vs 56, p<0.01) after the intervention period (Fig. 4). (p<0.01).
Variation between children on the mobility domain was con-
siderable (see Fig 4). The amount of assistance from caregivers Discussion
in daily life activities changed significantly only on the mobility Functional, goal-directed therapy carried out in daily life settings
domain (p<0.001; Fig. 5). of 14 children with CP influenced their gross motor capacity
and their performance in self-care, mobility, and social function
MPOC over a five-month training period. The goals set were reached
Mothers and fathers in nine families, and preschool assistants in 77% of cases. Parents expressed a more positive perception
in two families, completed the MPOC questionnaire. In four of service delivery after the training period than before. Also, the
families only the mother of the child returned a filled-in ques- children’s preschool assistants showed that they had acquired
tionnaire: in three of these the child’s assistant also answered more knowledge on how to train and motivate the child.
the questions. For one child only, the assistant replied. A fundamental aspect of cooperation between families and
Parents’ perceptions of services received from the habilitation others actively involved in daily care of children with CP is the
team during the intervention period significantly improved in formulation of specific goals for treatment (Bower et al. 2001,
all domains after the training period (t-test p<0.001) although Ketelaar 2001). Goals can be viewed as being the ‘cement’ that
variability was large, especially before the intervention (Fig. 6). can assist in avoiding fragmentation of services. By making
Mothers and fathers exhibited significantly different opin- individual goals clear, everyone involved with the children
ions before and after the intervention in the domains of can understand them and can unite and work together with
enabling and partnership: (t-test p<0.01; pre: mother 4.7 [SD the children to achieve them. Goals that are understandable,
1.8], father 5.1 [SD 1.4]; post: mother 6 [SD 1.2], father 6.5 [SD
1]); and coordinated and comprehensive care (pre: mother 4.5
[SD 1.9], father 5 [SD 1.7] post: mother 6.2 [SD 1.2], father, 6.6
[SD 0.9]). Mothers indicated a lower level of satisfaction with 60
the intervention than fathers. In the domain of respectful and
supportive care the fathers rated a higher grade of satisfac- 55
tion with the services after the intervention than the mothers
(t-test p<0.01; father 6.9 [SD 0.4], mother 6.4 [SD 1]). 50
Six preschool assistants partially filled in the questionnaire.
GMFM-66 score
35
Participants
30 A
B
C
D
E
25 F
G
Assessment times
8 Intervention H
I
J
20 K
L
BL I
II
o
o
o
o
o
III
5
Po II
Po I
M
BL
1m
2m
3m
4m
5m
st
st
(mo)
st
N
Po
3
Assessments
Figure 3: Change in (Gross Motor Function Manual–66
0 20 40 60 80 98 (GMFM-66) scores; Russell et al. 2002). Different traces
indicate change in GMFM-66 score (y-axis) in individual
Number of goals children over 10 assessments (x-axis). GMFM-66 consists of 66
items grouped into five dimensions. Items form a hierarchical
Figure 2: Goal attainment. Black bar, seven goals set for each structure with interval scaling, ranging from 0 (low motor
child (n=98). Striped bars, goals fully achieved at 3, 5, and 8 ability) to 100 (high motor ability). BL, Baseline; Post, post
months’ follow-up. White bars, goals partially achieved. intervention.
75 a b b
80
65
Caregiver assistance
Functional scales
a
55
60
45
35 40
25
20
15
5 0
Self-care Mobility Social function Self-care Mobility Social function
Figure 4: Change in Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Figure 5: Change in Pediatric Evaluation of Disability
Inventory (PEDI; Haley et al. 1992) functional skill scores Inventory (Haley et al. 1992) caregiver assistance (n=14).
(n=14). Boxplots represent 25th, 50th, and 75th centile. Boxplots represent 25th, 50th, and 75th centile. Whiskers
Whiskers represent minimum and maximum values. White represent minimum and maximum values. White boxplots
boxplots indicate assessments before intervention and indicate assessments before intervention and black boxplots
black boxplots assessments after intervention. ap<0.001, assessments after intervention. ap<0.001 (Wilcoxon).
bp<0.01 (Wilcoxon). PEDI evaluates through a structured Caregiver assistance is evaluated in 20 different activity areas
interview if a child is able or unable to perform 197 skills using a 6-point scale. A score of 5 indicates independence and
(score 1 or 0) in everyday life situations. a score of 0 complete dependence on assistance.
Functional Therapy in Children with Cerebral Palsy Lena Ekström Ahl et al. 617
with disabilities, and supporting them in that role. Particular Assessing parental–professional interactions and the
attention was given to knowledge transfer between parents effect of parental participation in training programmes on
and professionals, but other forms of parental support appear parental well-being will be of importance in future studies to
to be important (Solomon et al. 2001). Results from the MPOC elucidate the complex interactions between different facets
indicate that there was a substantial change in the parents’ of an ecological framework.
experiences of caregiving. Considering that the MPOC is a
questionnaire and, therefore, subjective in nature, it is not Conclusion
surprising that parents who have actively chosen to participate Children with CP benefited from a functional goal-directed
and have dedicated much time to work together with their chil- training approach in their development of gross motor func-
dren and professionals, express positive feeling towards their tion and everyday activities. The ecological intervention appr-
experiences. Previous studies have demonstrated that MPOC is oach was also positively perceived by the parents. The study
sensitive to parents’ perceptions of various types of rehabilita- adds to the growing knowledge that the efficacy of treatment
tion efforts (King et al. 1997). lies within the child’s day-to-day environment.
Mothers and fathers expressed different views on how
they perceived services, a finding in agreement with that of a DOI: 10.1017/S0012162205001210
previous study (King et al. 1996). However, the sample in our Accepted for publication 15th September 2004.
study was small and no general conclusion could be drawn.
Determining such perceived differences for future studies could Acknowledgements
add valuable information to improve family-centred services, We sincerely thank the children, their parents and assistants, and
our colleagues for making this study possible.
also taking into account cultural differences.
An area calling for further exploration is the role of pre- References
school assistants. Positive reactions to the approach expr- Bjerre I, Larsson M, Franzon AM, Nilsson M, Strömberg GB, Westblom
essed by the preschool assistants during the intervention L. (1997) Hur fungerar habiliteringsprocessen för föräldrar till barn
were not reflected to the same extent in the MPOC and the med funktionshinder? [How does the habilitation process work for
parents of children with disabilities?] Människa-hinder-livsvillkor.
questionnaire. Assistants were given continuous consultation Rapport 39. Psykiatri och habilitering. Örebro läns landsting.
and supervision throughout the intervention. The primary Bower E, McLellan D. (1992) Effect of increased exposure to
aim of supervision was to enable assistants to handle the child physiotherapy on skill acquisition of children with cerebral palsy.
and to enhance the child’s participation at preschool. Thus, Dev Med Child Neurol 34: 25–39.
their role in this approach should be considered very impor- Bower E, Michell D, Burnett M, Campbell M, McLellan D. (2001)
Randomized controlled trial of physiotherapy in 56 children with
tant. A meticulous look at the specific role of preschool assis- cerebral palsy followed for 18 months. Dev Med Child Neurol
tants could form the basis for a more valid way of evaluating 43: 4–15.
their contribution. Bronfenbrenner U. (1986) The Ecology of Human Development.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Gentile AM. (1998) Implicit and explicit processes during
acquisition of functional skills. Scan J Occup Ther 5: 7–16.
Gibson J, Pick A. (2003) An Ecological Approach To Perceptual
Learning And Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Measure of Processes of Care scores
Book Review space orientation, and gait, to guide the reader to an under-
standing of sensorimotor control. Furthermore, it often
draws upon philosophy and presents historical perspec-
tives on the interaction between perception and action.
The book is nicely divided into 14 important chapters
The Brain’s Sense of Movement with sexy subheadings, such as ‘The Art of Breaking’ and
By Alain Berthoz ‘What If Newton Had Wanted to Catch the Apple’, that cover
Cambridge, USA: Harvard University Press, 2000 many bases of perception and action, from control of bal-
pp 352, £16.95, US$24.95 ance, limb movement, and visual gaze. The central tenant is
ISBN 0 674 00980 0 (Paperback) that the brain uses sensory information proactively. The
brain is, above all, a biological machine for moving quickly
When I began my doctoral studies in sensorimotor control, with anticipation. Berthoz, a highly regarded neurophysiol-
I was intrigued by seemingly unexplainable phenomena ogist, boldly asserts that the brain uses configurations of
associated with both perceptual illusions and altered per- receptors to work out a perception and action. As the
ceptual experiences following unique brain lesions. How author acknowledges, science moves quickly. But despite
could vibrations applied to biceps while the fingertip is on having been published almost five years ago, the work was
the nose lead to the perception that the nose is growing ahead of its time and this has been reinforced by subsequent
(Pinocchio illusion)? How could two objects of identical experimental work. However, one exception is the author’s
weight but different size be perceived to have different rejection of the term ‘internal representation’. While he cor-
weights (size–weight illusion)? How could patients with rectly asserts that it is too easy to hide our ignorance behind
parietal area lesions not recognize one half of their body or such a generic term, considerable evidence for representa-
visual field (unilateral neglect)? What underlies amputees’ tions of manipulated objects and their use in proactive con-
perception that their amputated limb still exists or hurts trol has been published since this book was published.
(phantom limbs)? To me, answers to these questions However, as the author embraces the term ‘internal model’,
appeared to be the key to understanding sensorimotor I suspect the objection largely involves the term’s overuse
interactions in the brain. In The Brain’s Sense of Movement and that, therefore, Berthoz’s concern merely involves
(translated from French) the author, Alain Berthoz, uses syntax.
these or similar examples of perceptual disconnects as a Overall, The Brain’s Sense of Movement is a detailed and
guide to describing the relationship between perception refreshing review of sensorimotor control. The book is
and action. As stated by the author, the book is a reflection filled with wonderful examples which make the presenta-
on how the brain works proactively, with perception being tion of material practical, fascinating, and a delight to read.
much more than an interpretation of sensory messages. The relation of basic material to interesting clinical patholo-
Perception is proposed to be inseparable from action, and it gies makes it all the more interesting to clinicians. This book
is suggested that perceptual illusions are solutions to prob- contains information that should inspire research in clinical
lems of sen-sory conflict or ambiguity. motor control for decades to come.
What is truly unique is that the book frequently high-
lights these perceptual disconnects as well as practical DOI: 10.1017/S0012162205001283
examples and exercises that show how we control move-
ments, such as gaze control, posture and limb movement, Andrew M Gordon
Functional Therapy in Children with Cerebral Palsy Lena Ekström Ahl et al. 619