FTV - Analysis On City of God
FTV - Analysis On City of God
FTV - Analysis On City of God
CITY of GOD
1
FTV1050 Contemporary Film Studies
C idade De Deus (City of God) is a Brazilian film that was nominated Academy
Award film in 2002. Directed by Fernando Meirelles and Kátia Lund, they have
portrayed the violence of the life in favelas, one of the slums in Rio de Janeiro. It was
film based on one of the people who live there, Rocket cast by Alexandre Rodrigues.
The success of this film has brought numerous Award nominations and wins
audience attention due to its film form. Film form is how the technical aspect that was
applied by using specific style or methods that will deliver the preferred scene. It has four
broad perspectives that are mise-en-scene, mise-en-shots, aspect of editing and dimension
of sounds. Directors use these technical aspects to give more intense visual portrayed in
Mise-en-scene is the “settings and sets refer to the location or the construction
where a scene is film” (Corrigan T, p49). As we are introduced to in the opening scene,
the director had a sneak peak of the condition of the favelas. The use of flash shot starting
from the chicken slaughter, boiled, stripping its feather, the people that is around in their
usual life routine. These scenes show the poor living condition of the slum in that area.
The richness of color and lighting are prominent in the retro clothing and shots of sunsets
and beaches, helps to give the film a '60s feel. The utilization of lighting and color seems
to have placed the scene particularly the shot in that time. When the film flash forward to
the 70’s changes were static. As the film goes to its climax, the changes of lighting and
color had to a much dim, gloomy and concentrates more dark night scene which signify
the theme of aggressive violence in this film. It made an inconsistent motion to the
2
FTV1050 Contemporary Film Studies
Mise-en-shots are the next aspect that involves many elements. This involves the
positioning of the camera, the camera movement, scale of the shot, length of a single shot
and pace of editing. The narration of City of God uses many close-up shots, extreme
close up’s shots and flash backs. Close up shots are “shows a character's face and
2003). This allows a bond to be built between the audience and the character. If
something would happen to a character, audience will feel the pain of losing the
character. In flash back, at a point of the story where Rocket was talking on the history of
the apartment, at that point, the camera position locks at an angle where different
character changes as the apartment owner change and return to the present. The camera
movements in this film in most of the scene are unstable, like they are hand held video
cam known as the dolly shot. This dolly shot in the chasing chicken scene where the
camera chases after the chicken give a human eye perspective as the audience are chasing
the chicken. The director has also used brilliantly the 360 degree camera movement
around Rocket that fades from the present to the past. This movement delivers clear flow
between two distinctive time scenes. The length in this film mostly is short due to the
The third perspective is the editing. Editing basically is “the work of selecting and
joining together shots to create a finished film” (Cinema Website). In film, “editing
deals with all aspects of filmic rhythm - from the transition of one image to another or the
detailed musical rhythm in a small sequence of edits, to the most general balancing of
pace and rhythm in the overall narrative structure” (Wiedemann V.). Thus this can
3
FTV1050 Contemporary Film Studies
manipulate the scenario of the film in terms of time. For instance when the scene shifts
from day to night, that is film editing. In City of God, the first scene that shows the knife
chopping in a flash shot is a kind of editing which one shot is use more than one time in
one scene. A different example would be the apartment scene where Rocket narrating on
Blacky and also showing Li’l Ze come thru the door three times at different times. This
gives the audience three separate reasons and information why Li’l Ze is there and how
Blacky got the place and how he lost it. There are various editing technique can be
applied in making a film, in this scene, it use the continuity editing. This editing style
prevents “the editing to distract from the story, avoids cut and transitions between images
The sound is an important element in film form. In film “sound can be used and
edited with as much complexity and intelligence as image can” (Corrigan T., p70). If a
film without sound, audience will have less exposure on what is going on the scenes. For
example the scene is showing a police chase and we hear gun fires. Although we don’t
see the weapon fires but we would use our imagination or assume there is a gun. Thus
sound provides movies an extra effect to the viewers by triggering their senses. Sound in
film can be diegetic or non diegetic as this film applies both. Through out the movie
audience will be able to hear gun fires, 70’s music, distant people’s conversation, chaos
and continuous background speech of Rocket narrating the story. Music gives audience
the feel of the film, for instance in the club scene, funk music that are played are clearly a
4
FTV1050 Contemporary Film Studies
movie. Due to film form is invincible, meaning that audience won’t notice them
moreover giving a review whether a movie is good or bad. Film form will provide more
relevant critics. It includes the scenes, the shots, the editing, and the sound. In City of