robert-b-norby
Joined Aug 2014
Welcome to the new profile
We're still working on updating some profile features. To see the badges, ratings breakdowns, and polls for this profile, please go to the previous version.
Ratings23
robert-b-norby's rating
Reviews17
robert-b-norby's rating
(This review is coming from someone who has not seen the manga or read any comic books)
Season 1 is as much a journey through the East Blue as it is a journey through an amazing cast. Monkey D. Luffy, our main protagonist, dreams of becoming King of the Pirates. For this he needs a crew, and a boat, and throughout the season we follow him along as he meets up with more and more characters. More than 1 villain too. Everyone with their own dreams, or their own evil agenda. Luffy himself is a bit weird and naive, overly optimistic and good to a fault, and that - along with his rather formidable superpower to bend and stretch - is just the right combination of good and powerful to recruit some of the best pirates out there. And by best, we mean "good". It's time pirates starting acting a little nicer, don't you think?. The story is told in a linear fashion, and utilizes character flashbacks to great effect for both character depth and story arcs in present time.
Minor criticism: The story is perhaps a tad bit thin at first, with the plot primarily being moved forward by Luffy and his dream of being a great pirate, and some minor seemingly random events that needs to happen for him to meet more people and get a ship to pursue his dream. But I' not really criticizing this, merely mentioning it, as I'm probably not the only one heavily conditioned by typical tv shows to expect a great big injustice that needs redemption, or a great evil that threatens the whole world which must be stopped. But those elements do come with it's perks of drawing in the viewer, and this shows start very light on that front, and is instead character driven. Nothing wrong with that! AT ALL. But it means it will take some time for the show and the characters to grow on you.
There are plenty of bad guys though, but they pop in and out as beautifully extravagant freak shows that functions more as speed bumbs for the main story progression, and as a way to showcase some perfectly decent choreographed fight scenes. The only
The clichés are both amazing and a small drawback. There are some, at times, very on the nose story arcs for some of the main characters. This is a drawback because it feels like you have seen it before, and takes away the guesswork. You'll predict most of the outcomes before they happen. But the upside? Clichés are clichés for a reason. When done right, well written and acted, the result can be very powerful and captivating. And One Piece does them very well.
The great: I find every single main and supporting character in this show to be pretty darn amazing, both acting wise, but also style-wize. This IS based on a manga after all, where you can expect stereotypes to be very loudly portraited. It is not often you see these kinds of character translate as well into live action as some of the performances from the cast manages to do in One Piece (and I don't even have the built in forgiveness of someone who has seen the original). It is over-the-top manga-styled madness, but through character story-telling and good writing, it remains heartfelt and grounded at the same time. All actors bring uniqueness to their characters that they then stay true and consistent to. All (good) characters are very different, but also very likeable. A true ensemble of character fun, and glory.
Summary: Its a character driven show, packed with plenty of japanese manga-styled fun, with a larger than life message to follow your dreams - that take its time to draw you in with little to no intrigue. Give it a few episodes and allow the characters to be built up even further, and there is tons of charm and fun in this for most I dare say. The somewhat loose story plot does tighten in towards the end of the season, with a impactful and satisfying finale. It leaves you feeling excited for the characters, and their journey to come. And you'll probably want to join, when the next season comes.
It started out a 6, turn into a 7 halfway, and ends as and 8 for me = 7 average. If you already love the characters (from the original show), I totally get why this show has a strong 8 rating! :)
Season 1 is as much a journey through the East Blue as it is a journey through an amazing cast. Monkey D. Luffy, our main protagonist, dreams of becoming King of the Pirates. For this he needs a crew, and a boat, and throughout the season we follow him along as he meets up with more and more characters. More than 1 villain too. Everyone with their own dreams, or their own evil agenda. Luffy himself is a bit weird and naive, overly optimistic and good to a fault, and that - along with his rather formidable superpower to bend and stretch - is just the right combination of good and powerful to recruit some of the best pirates out there. And by best, we mean "good". It's time pirates starting acting a little nicer, don't you think?. The story is told in a linear fashion, and utilizes character flashbacks to great effect for both character depth and story arcs in present time.
Minor criticism: The story is perhaps a tad bit thin at first, with the plot primarily being moved forward by Luffy and his dream of being a great pirate, and some minor seemingly random events that needs to happen for him to meet more people and get a ship to pursue his dream. But I' not really criticizing this, merely mentioning it, as I'm probably not the only one heavily conditioned by typical tv shows to expect a great big injustice that needs redemption, or a great evil that threatens the whole world which must be stopped. But those elements do come with it's perks of drawing in the viewer, and this shows start very light on that front, and is instead character driven. Nothing wrong with that! AT ALL. But it means it will take some time for the show and the characters to grow on you.
There are plenty of bad guys though, but they pop in and out as beautifully extravagant freak shows that functions more as speed bumbs for the main story progression, and as a way to showcase some perfectly decent choreographed fight scenes. The only
The clichés are both amazing and a small drawback. There are some, at times, very on the nose story arcs for some of the main characters. This is a drawback because it feels like you have seen it before, and takes away the guesswork. You'll predict most of the outcomes before they happen. But the upside? Clichés are clichés for a reason. When done right, well written and acted, the result can be very powerful and captivating. And One Piece does them very well.
The great: I find every single main and supporting character in this show to be pretty darn amazing, both acting wise, but also style-wize. This IS based on a manga after all, where you can expect stereotypes to be very loudly portraited. It is not often you see these kinds of character translate as well into live action as some of the performances from the cast manages to do in One Piece (and I don't even have the built in forgiveness of someone who has seen the original). It is over-the-top manga-styled madness, but through character story-telling and good writing, it remains heartfelt and grounded at the same time. All actors bring uniqueness to their characters that they then stay true and consistent to. All (good) characters are very different, but also very likeable. A true ensemble of character fun, and glory.
Summary: Its a character driven show, packed with plenty of japanese manga-styled fun, with a larger than life message to follow your dreams - that take its time to draw you in with little to no intrigue. Give it a few episodes and allow the characters to be built up even further, and there is tons of charm and fun in this for most I dare say. The somewhat loose story plot does tighten in towards the end of the season, with a impactful and satisfying finale. It leaves you feeling excited for the characters, and their journey to come. And you'll probably want to join, when the next season comes.
It started out a 6, turn into a 7 halfway, and ends as and 8 for me = 7 average. If you already love the characters (from the original show), I totally get why this show has a strong 8 rating! :)
Its rare to see reviews so mixed I think. People hear Goslyng, Evans, the Russo brothers and a big budget, and get their expectations up. Im not all to easy to please, but I thought this was an action flick, it was, and to a decent score of 7. I feel like the entire point of «flicks» is to be easy entertainment, and that it was. Very much from start to finish. Are only actors like Jason Statham allowed to do movies like this and get a decent rating? Cmon. Why not let Gosling in on all the fun?!
Can you dissect the movie down to a series of flaws and missed opportunities and compare it to the best of all films? Sure, and then it's a 4-5. But let movie makers have some fun with it, and make some badass characters that does badass stuff and shrugs of some stab wounds that didnt hurt, pay the most expensive actors to do it, and roll with it. I normally don't let those things slide to easily, but it felt obvious to me the movie confessed it sins and said «I know, but hey, it looked cool, right?», and thus I forgave.
The movie is fast paced, jammed packed with action - some good, some bad - some cool and funny characters, Gosling in particular, a few momorable scenes, and a great child actor. Some questionable camera work at times, sure, but mostly top notch. A very decent action flick, which it clearly intended to be. And in that category, I think it deserves a 7.
Can you dissect the movie down to a series of flaws and missed opportunities and compare it to the best of all films? Sure, and then it's a 4-5. But let movie makers have some fun with it, and make some badass characters that does badass stuff and shrugs of some stab wounds that didnt hurt, pay the most expensive actors to do it, and roll with it. I normally don't let those things slide to easily, but it felt obvious to me the movie confessed it sins and said «I know, but hey, it looked cool, right?», and thus I forgave.
The movie is fast paced, jammed packed with action - some good, some bad - some cool and funny characters, Gosling in particular, a few momorable scenes, and a great child actor. Some questionable camera work at times, sure, but mostly top notch. A very decent action flick, which it clearly intended to be. And in that category, I think it deserves a 7.
If you want a good sci-fi time-travel to fight aliens movie, you can't go wrong with this one. It's highly entertaining and fast paced, and for it's genre, it's a strong 7.
To critize first: It has some plot holes, the occasional cliché explosion, and you might think they don't always make the smartest disicions in every situation they are in. But it's not riddled with flaws like this, and there luckily plenty of well directed scenes and situations that does seem really realistic, which helps balance it out.
The good: It's entertaining from start to finish, well acted (Pratt and Strahoviski both impressed me here actually), solid emotional stories are developed seemlessly with the fast pace of the movie (without long and slow scenes), some of the best done CGI I've seen in a long time, a decent chunk of humor, and a cool plot involving time travel - along with believable efforts in rooting it in science (within the movie). The ending is both long, and rushed at the same time, in that the last third of the movie is like a sequel within the movie. It almost feels like the movie ends twice. One can easily critize the writing and directing here, but I personally didn't mind. That is of course because of what took place in that part of the movie, and I won't get into details on that:) I'd like the movie less if the "second ending" wasn't there, is what I'm saying.
I am a true slave to the IMDB-rating, and I don't think it's current 6.6 is justified. For it's genre, it's a strong 7. Possibly an 8. As a movie in general, it's a weak 7.
To critize first: It has some plot holes, the occasional cliché explosion, and you might think they don't always make the smartest disicions in every situation they are in. But it's not riddled with flaws like this, and there luckily plenty of well directed scenes and situations that does seem really realistic, which helps balance it out.
The good: It's entertaining from start to finish, well acted (Pratt and Strahoviski both impressed me here actually), solid emotional stories are developed seemlessly with the fast pace of the movie (without long and slow scenes), some of the best done CGI I've seen in a long time, a decent chunk of humor, and a cool plot involving time travel - along with believable efforts in rooting it in science (within the movie). The ending is both long, and rushed at the same time, in that the last third of the movie is like a sequel within the movie. It almost feels like the movie ends twice. One can easily critize the writing and directing here, but I personally didn't mind. That is of course because of what took place in that part of the movie, and I won't get into details on that:) I'd like the movie less if the "second ending" wasn't there, is what I'm saying.
I am a true slave to the IMDB-rating, and I don't think it's current 6.6 is justified. For it's genre, it's a strong 7. Possibly an 8. As a movie in general, it's a weak 7.