aramkx
Joined Feb 2012
Welcome to the new profile
We're still working on updating some profile features. To see the badges, ratings breakdowns, and polls for this profile, please go to the previous version.
Reviews32
aramkx's rating
IMDb Review: Maria (2024)
I'm torn on whether I liked Maria or not. While it has its strengths, there were several aspects that left me feeling uneasy.
One of the most commonly criticized elements-the lip-syncing-isn't something I can assess with expertise, but I do agree that it felt off. That said, portraying a legendary opera singer is no easy feat. This raises an interesting debate: should the role have gone to someone like Angelina Jolie, whose beauty is undeniably a factor in casting, or someone who could have executed the vocal performance more convincingly?
What frustrated me the most was the dialogue. Nearly every conversation felt overly poetic, metaphorical, and philosophical, as if the characters were constantly trying to outwit each other in some intellectual duel. There was barely a single natural, human interaction in the film. Whether in her youth or later years, Maria always spoke with the same solemn expression and melancholic tone, as if delivering life lessons in every line. This became exhausting to watch.
In films like this, there are usually standout, unforgettable scenes that leave a lasting impression. Unfortunately, Maria lacked that for me. However, I must acknowledge the effort put into the cinematography, especially in the flashback sequences and the documentary-style scenes of her performances. The craftsmanship is evident, and visually, the film is stunning.
Overall, despite its flaws, I'd say a fair rating would be around 6/10, but not much higher.
I'm torn on whether I liked Maria or not. While it has its strengths, there were several aspects that left me feeling uneasy.
One of the most commonly criticized elements-the lip-syncing-isn't something I can assess with expertise, but I do agree that it felt off. That said, portraying a legendary opera singer is no easy feat. This raises an interesting debate: should the role have gone to someone like Angelina Jolie, whose beauty is undeniably a factor in casting, or someone who could have executed the vocal performance more convincingly?
What frustrated me the most was the dialogue. Nearly every conversation felt overly poetic, metaphorical, and philosophical, as if the characters were constantly trying to outwit each other in some intellectual duel. There was barely a single natural, human interaction in the film. Whether in her youth or later years, Maria always spoke with the same solemn expression and melancholic tone, as if delivering life lessons in every line. This became exhausting to watch.
In films like this, there are usually standout, unforgettable scenes that leave a lasting impression. Unfortunately, Maria lacked that for me. However, I must acknowledge the effort put into the cinematography, especially in the flashback sequences and the documentary-style scenes of her performances. The craftsmanship is evident, and visually, the film is stunning.
Overall, despite its flaws, I'd say a fair rating would be around 6/10, but not much higher.
The film was perfect in one word. The atmosphere of the time period and the setting were beautifully portrayed. Everything about the human experience and the messages conveyed were also excellent. I watched it as if I were reading a brilliant book. Additionally, the levels of excitement, romance, love, and suspense were just right. Daisy Edgar-Jones' performance was extraordinary. It was the first time I saw her, and I was truly impressed. She has an incredible energy, beauty, and expression. If I were a director, I'd cast her in every film. I'm sure she'll be one of the important actors of the future. The cinematographer also deserves great praise. I highly recommend everyone to watch it.
Even after watching just the first three episodes of the series, I passionately recommended it to all my friends who love cinema. By the time I finished it, my admiration for Oriol Paulo had grown several times over; he truly doesn't miss, and this series is nothing short of a masterpiece. Each episode feels like a magnificent film in itself. The cast is excellent, with characters carefully selected down to even the child roles.
The storytelling is exceptional, the script is incredibly detailed and meticulously crafted, and the suspense and mystery never waver for even a moment. I was genuinely sad when it ended; when such a beautiful and impactful series concludes, you're left with a sense of emptiness.
In my opinion, those who give this series a low rating or write negative reviews are either ill-intentioned or have no taste or appreciation for cinema and storytelling. Everything about this series related to cinema was done with excellence.
The storytelling is exceptional, the script is incredibly detailed and meticulously crafted, and the suspense and mystery never waver for even a moment. I was genuinely sad when it ended; when such a beautiful and impactful series concludes, you're left with a sense of emptiness.
In my opinion, those who give this series a low rating or write negative reviews are either ill-intentioned or have no taste or appreciation for cinema and storytelling. Everything about this series related to cinema was done with excellence.