Well after 45 years of being purportedly "lost", 90 hours of original footage have finally brought the world the definitive edit of Tinto Brass's controversial "historical" cult hit has finally arrived. And after seeing a special screening of this new edition earlier this week, I was not disappointed.
The biggest difference from the original edit put together by producer and financier Penthouse Magazine mogul Bob Guccione is we actually have a character study of the titular Roman emperor. While there is still some of the infamous smut included, we are allowed to actually see what makes the mad emperor tick despite what we know being mainly slander by Caligula's detractors but the myth has remained well known and interesting even to the uninitiated. Even side characters get some growth even though it isn't too much, but they are less comic relief (except for the depiction of the next emperor Claudius; if you want a real portrait of him, then watch "I, Claudius") and we get to see why some of them eventually grew to plot the death of Caligula.
The cast has remained memorable in this film the entire 45 years the theatrical cut has existed, but some of it was for the wrong reasons. Actress Teresa Ann Savoy, who plays the role of Caligula's sole surviving sister and lover Drusilla, was one cast member done dirty by Guccione and the editors who dubbed her voice in the '79 cut, but thanks to the new editing and restoration team her original voice has been returned and her performance is far better for it. Her emotions are often worn on her sleeve and her soft dulcet tones lend a welcome voice of reason to her brother's spiral into extravagance and insanity.
The film's two main leads in respected thespians Malcolm McDowell and Dame Helen Mirren are also well aided by the new edit especially for the dramatic chemistry between them. McDowell is still allowed to devour the scenery in certain scenes particularly Caligula's paranoia and a few hilarious one-liners, but here he is allowed far more expressive acting without the need for dialogue. For anyone who has seen "A Clockwork Orange" knows that the famed Brit can just act with his eyes alone and burrow into your soul with just a stare and there are quite a few moments here where the discomfort is shown by the action or reaction. Some of his goofier moments put into the original edit do show up here such as the infamous rain dance, but it brings joy to just see the improv at work.
As for (at the time) future Oscar winning Mirren, her role as Caligula's ill-fated final wife, Caesonia, is given some more depth even from her introduction. Her infamous reputation is still intact and her influence sprinkles its way into the depravity that eventually ensues with Caligula's extravagant indulgence. The famous dance with the new soundtrack is still one strange inclusion, but it is a memorable spectacle. While her screen-time is limited, Mirren still brings a regal air and nuance to the Empress who is as doomed as her husband, but only due to being associated by marriage and not the architect of their demise.
The Ultimate Cut also comes with a brand-new soundtrack that is far more fitting than just public domain classical tracks. Even though one's brain is programmed to hear the "Adagio" movement from the "Spartacus" ballet or Prokofiev's "Dance of the Knights" from his balletic adaptation of "Romeo and Juliet" over the opening credits, but I enjoy the much more haunting score that forebodes the doom ahead. Eerie gong crescendos paired with dread-inducing percussive accompanied by chilling basses underscore the debauchery and madness we are about to witness, but the composer manages to utilize lilts of strings and woodwinds to the more tender moments in between the insanity.
If you can handle the madness and want to see the true version its director, writer and cast had wanted the world to see, this cut will be available for home media in late October.
The biggest difference from the original edit put together by producer and financier Penthouse Magazine mogul Bob Guccione is we actually have a character study of the titular Roman emperor. While there is still some of the infamous smut included, we are allowed to actually see what makes the mad emperor tick despite what we know being mainly slander by Caligula's detractors but the myth has remained well known and interesting even to the uninitiated. Even side characters get some growth even though it isn't too much, but they are less comic relief (except for the depiction of the next emperor Claudius; if you want a real portrait of him, then watch "I, Claudius") and we get to see why some of them eventually grew to plot the death of Caligula.
The cast has remained memorable in this film the entire 45 years the theatrical cut has existed, but some of it was for the wrong reasons. Actress Teresa Ann Savoy, who plays the role of Caligula's sole surviving sister and lover Drusilla, was one cast member done dirty by Guccione and the editors who dubbed her voice in the '79 cut, but thanks to the new editing and restoration team her original voice has been returned and her performance is far better for it. Her emotions are often worn on her sleeve and her soft dulcet tones lend a welcome voice of reason to her brother's spiral into extravagance and insanity.
The film's two main leads in respected thespians Malcolm McDowell and Dame Helen Mirren are also well aided by the new edit especially for the dramatic chemistry between them. McDowell is still allowed to devour the scenery in certain scenes particularly Caligula's paranoia and a few hilarious one-liners, but here he is allowed far more expressive acting without the need for dialogue. For anyone who has seen "A Clockwork Orange" knows that the famed Brit can just act with his eyes alone and burrow into your soul with just a stare and there are quite a few moments here where the discomfort is shown by the action or reaction. Some of his goofier moments put into the original edit do show up here such as the infamous rain dance, but it brings joy to just see the improv at work.
As for (at the time) future Oscar winning Mirren, her role as Caligula's ill-fated final wife, Caesonia, is given some more depth even from her introduction. Her infamous reputation is still intact and her influence sprinkles its way into the depravity that eventually ensues with Caligula's extravagant indulgence. The famous dance with the new soundtrack is still one strange inclusion, but it is a memorable spectacle. While her screen-time is limited, Mirren still brings a regal air and nuance to the Empress who is as doomed as her husband, but only due to being associated by marriage and not the architect of their demise.
The Ultimate Cut also comes with a brand-new soundtrack that is far more fitting than just public domain classical tracks. Even though one's brain is programmed to hear the "Adagio" movement from the "Spartacus" ballet or Prokofiev's "Dance of the Knights" from his balletic adaptation of "Romeo and Juliet" over the opening credits, but I enjoy the much more haunting score that forebodes the doom ahead. Eerie gong crescendos paired with dread-inducing percussive accompanied by chilling basses underscore the debauchery and madness we are about to witness, but the composer manages to utilize lilts of strings and woodwinds to the more tender moments in between the insanity.
If you can handle the madness and want to see the true version its director, writer and cast had wanted the world to see, this cut will be available for home media in late October.
Tell Your Friends