I didn't expect to write a review for this, but after dwelling on the final episode for a few hours, I've decided it's worth it. Especially since most reviews are 8-10 or 1-3.
Overall, the show tends to be well directed, and the cast is good. There are a few interesting episodes (which I'll go over), and a few dull ones. The overarching narrative, is close to non-existent. It isn't an anthology, but it barely tries to tie anything together. Some episodes are just a slice of life for the characters it focuses on.
Episode 1:
Decent idea, not so sure about the execution. The twist feels like it comes early, and we don't know anything about these characters yet, so there's little payoff. It's not bad, but it's a relatively pointless first episode.
Episode 2:
My personal favorite. The plot line has been explored elsewhere, but I like how they do it here. The pacing is actually fine here.
Episode 3:
Another great idea that's been done before, but not explored as well as the previous episode. The girl in this one isn't the best character either, and this episode seems to have little to no attachment to the rest of the show, making it more pointless than Episode 1 (although more enjoyable).
Episode 4:
If you like questioning life and all that, this episode is for you. Unfortunately there's nothing interesting plot wise, so that's all we're left with aside from Jonathan Pryce.
Episode 5:
My least favorite episode. It's not too slow, but the poor script really shines through here. The man the episode focuses on has a very odd and overly complex "solution" to a problem imposed on his family. I like how the episode explored the grief of the characters in it, but almost none of the character decisions make any sense. You need to sleep at some point in the day, and standing outside every night, doing basically nothing, is such an obvious waste of time.
Episode 6:
Despite being the lowest rated episode at my time of writing, I enjoyed this one. It's a bit of a slow burn, but intriguing enough that I wasn't bored. That being said, this episode also had practically nothing to do with anything else in the series. It's pretty easy to skip this one and not need any kind of explanation later.
Episode 7:
Pretty solid, and I enjoyed the (admittedly out of place) horror elements, being a horror fan myself. The episode is actually just backstory, although it does give some key information for later. It does help that I like the character it focused on. A bit of an abrupt ending however.
Episode 8:
I'm quite surprised that this is currently the highest rated episode. I thought that either A: it'd be another solid standalone episode that barely ties into anything, or B: tie everything in the series together in a clever way. It's unfortunately the worst of both worlds. Not bad, but highly disappointing, and it made me feel like I wasted all of this time for absolutely no payoff. It tries to tie a few loose ends, but it feels like the writers of Game of Thrones trying to "subvert expectations" in a Michael Haneke type of way. In the end it was depressing, barely the most intertwined episode of the series, and featured very few interesting concepts.
So, after finishing the show, do I recommend it? It really depends. Casual viewers wanting a fun Sci-Fi series to watch will likely want to stay away (or watch the second episode by itself). Existential Arthouse fans? I'd say they may like it, but I know someone who loves Terrance Malik and Sci-Fi who had roughly the same opinion on this that I did. It's really not a bad show, but the writing leaves so much to be desired. It's not fascinating the way Black Mirror is, and it's not as cohesive as most other series are. It is free on Amazon Prime Video however, so if it truly piques your interest you might as well give it a go from the beginning.
4 out of 6 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends