Welcome to the new profile
We're still working on updating some profile features. To see the badges, ratings breakdowns, and polls for this profile, please go to the previous version.
Reviews5
evilnail's rating
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon is the best picture of the year ...... blah blah blah. Many good words have been said about CTHD, and I have no wish to repeat them.
It is simply a wonderful experience that combines the best of both worlds. Ang Lee has captured the essence of the Wuxia genre from the traditional Chinese cinemas and add some Hollywood production values to it. The result is a romantic-martial-art-fantasy epic with breathtaking cinematography and a hauntingly beautiful score, that I have never seen before.
Most Westerner viewers, who have no previous exposure to the Wuxia genre, are dumbstruck by the action sequences. The actions in CTHD are very very good but you can find more outrageous (if not better) fight scenes in Jet Li's in China series and Donnie Yen's New Dragon Inn and Iron Monkey, just to name a few. However, these above-mentioned flicks are usually filled with a weak plot and hollow characters.
Some minor complaints:
1) The desert flashback sequence does seem a bit too long even it is essential to understand Jen's character.
2) The way that Ang Lee handled Mui Bai and Shu Lien's relationship is great but I wish there is more screen time on it.
3) As a Chinese, I do notice the actors' varying accents but it doesn't bother me as much as other Chinese viewers. It is a fact that people from different part of China do speak Mandarin with different accents.
With these complaints aside, I still find CTHD to be a wonderfully rewarding movie experience!
It is simply a wonderful experience that combines the best of both worlds. Ang Lee has captured the essence of the Wuxia genre from the traditional Chinese cinemas and add some Hollywood production values to it. The result is a romantic-martial-art-fantasy epic with breathtaking cinematography and a hauntingly beautiful score, that I have never seen before.
Most Westerner viewers, who have no previous exposure to the Wuxia genre, are dumbstruck by the action sequences. The actions in CTHD are very very good but you can find more outrageous (if not better) fight scenes in Jet Li's in China series and Donnie Yen's New Dragon Inn and Iron Monkey, just to name a few. However, these above-mentioned flicks are usually filled with a weak plot and hollow characters.
Some minor complaints:
1) The desert flashback sequence does seem a bit too long even it is essential to understand Jen's character.
2) The way that Ang Lee handled Mui Bai and Shu Lien's relationship is great but I wish there is more screen time on it.
3) As a Chinese, I do notice the actors' varying accents but it doesn't bother me as much as other Chinese viewers. It is a fact that people from different part of China do speak Mandarin with different accents.
With these complaints aside, I still find CTHD to be a wonderfully rewarding movie experience!
The story is based on the Taoist legendary figures: the Eight Immortals. The movie doesn't explain anything about Taoism, in stead, it borrows the figures and makes up a truly terrible story.
The story is basically cheap jokes glued together over the evil vs. evil plot. The acting is just awful. You can see how they are transformed but you don't see any real characters!!
It's so frustrating to see such a stupid movie to come out of HK. The HK movie industry has so much talents but somehow they just got wasted!!
The story is basically cheap jokes glued together over the evil vs. evil plot. The acting is just awful. You can see how they are transformed but you don't see any real characters!!
It's so frustrating to see such a stupid movie to come out of HK. The HK movie industry has so much talents but somehow they just got wasted!!
Titanic has made movie history!! It's unbelievable that such a bad tearjerker can be doing so well at the box office!!
Where is the plot? Well, the movie does have ... sort of a plot, but it's very very very weak. The love between Jack and Rose is so superficial.
Where are the characters? I can't find any real character! Everywhere I look, I find cliches and stereotypes. The rich must be arrogant, ignorant, evil, etc, while the poor must be the exact opposite.
Can the actors act? Sure, every single one can but not in this movie. The acting is somewhere between so-so and bad! I've seen better performance from Cathy Bates, Leonardo DiCarpio, Bill Paxton.. in other movies.
The visual effects is the only saving grace! The sinking of the ship is just magnificent!! It's just a shame they could have spent so much money to recreate the ship but they couldn't create a good story that has characters with substance!
For teenagers who are flooded with hormones and a not-so-well-developed brain, it's understandable that they love the movie. For those who love it because it makes them cry, I suggest cutting an onion. It's much cheaper and tears come out faster!!
Where is the plot? Well, the movie does have ... sort of a plot, but it's very very very weak. The love between Jack and Rose is so superficial.
Where are the characters? I can't find any real character! Everywhere I look, I find cliches and stereotypes. The rich must be arrogant, ignorant, evil, etc, while the poor must be the exact opposite.
Can the actors act? Sure, every single one can but not in this movie. The acting is somewhere between so-so and bad! I've seen better performance from Cathy Bates, Leonardo DiCarpio, Bill Paxton.. in other movies.
The visual effects is the only saving grace! The sinking of the ship is just magnificent!! It's just a shame they could have spent so much money to recreate the ship but they couldn't create a good story that has characters with substance!
For teenagers who are flooded with hormones and a not-so-well-developed brain, it's understandable that they love the movie. For those who love it because it makes them cry, I suggest cutting an onion. It's much cheaper and tears come out faster!!