Series Cast
| Jonathan Roumie | ... | Jesus | |
| Elizabeth Tabish | ... | Mary Magdalene | |
| Danny Nucci | ... | Abba (Eli) | |
| Paras Patel | ... | Matthew | |
| Omid Abtahi | ... | Roman Auger | |
| Jordin Sparks | ... | Fish | |
| Noah James | ... | Andrew | |
| Brandon Potter | ... | Quintus | |
| Yvonne Orji | ... | Pigeon | |
| George H. Xanthis | ... | John | |
| Joey Vahedi | ... | Thomas | |
| Zehra Fazal | ... | Eema (Hanna) | |
| Assaf Cohen | ... | Potter | |
| Panta Mosleh | ... | Eliza | |
| Annie Korzen | ... | Dinah | |
| Banks Pierce | ... | Hilarius Maximous | |
| Romy Fay | ... | Abby | |
| Julian Grant | ... | Cyrius Maximous | |
| Jude Zarzaur | ... | Joshua (voice) | |
| Melissa Shoshahi | ... | Yael's Mom | |
Series Casting By
| Christian Kaplan | ||
| Suzanne Yavuz | ||