Dave Meltzer's "The Wrestling Observer Newsletter" rated this the worst major wrestling show of 2009. On
Bryan Alvarez's podcast "The Brian and Vinny Show," he rated the Sharmell-Jenna Morasca match "MINUS FIVE STARS" and that it was the worst women's match he'd ever seen and that he couldn't remember the last time he had given such a low rating because it had been such a long time that he had seen a match that was that bad. The "MINUS FIVE STARS" quote took on a life of its own, and became featured regularly in the openings for the "Botchamania" series of YouTube videos that compiled all kinds of wrestling bloopers.
