Well, I only watched it because Laura Leighton is in it, and as it turned out, that is the only reason to watch this TV movie. Leighton is believable and natural in the starring role and gorgeous as always. That's what the four stars are for.
Other than that, there is very little to it. I didn't think any of the characters had real depth. I found the male lead character rather boring. The story of Cate finding out more about her father and his motives falls short and unsatisfactory. Subplots involve a slight marital conflict and a falling out of two best friends, but there's not a lot to those either.
Oh, and the posh gay guy is not sharp enough a dresser for a posh gay guy.
The story takes place in a village that appears to be an Irish settlement in the state of Massachusetts, which adds a nice different flavour.