User reviews

Melendez said he was a Trekker. Obviously the writers and the actor haven't a clue what Star Trek is.

That's all.

In "Moonshot," the eighth episode of the third season, The Good Doctor explores the theme of risk-taking, both in the operating room and in the characters' personal lives. The episode centers on Dr. Shaun Murphy as he faces a high-risk surgery involving a patient with a complex condition that requires an unconventional approach. Simultaneously, Shaun's relationship with Carly reaches a critical juncture as they contemplate taking a significant step forward in their relationship.

Directed by X, the episode maintains a tight focus on the concept of calculated risks, exploring how the characters weigh their options and the potential consequences of their decisions. The script, written by David Hoselton, is well-paced and engaging, keeping the audience invested in both the medical case and the characters' personal dilemmas. The pacing is brisk, reflecting the urgency of the surgical procedure while allowing for quieter moments of reflection and decision-making.

A key strength of "Moonshot" is its ability to balance the high-stakes medical drama with the emotional weight of the characters' personal lives. The cinematography uses dynamic camera movements and tight close-ups during the surgery scenes to heighten the tension, while softer, more static shots are employed in the scenes focusing on Shaun's relationship with Carly. This contrast effectively underscores the different types of risks that Shaun faces, both as a surgeon and as a partner.

One of the most striking scenes occurs during the surgery, where Shaun must make a split-second decision that could determine the patient's fate. The scene is intense and suspenseful, with the direction and editing working in tandem to create a sense of urgency and high stakes. Freddie Highmore's portrayal of Shaun's determination and focus is compelling, showcasing his growth as a surgeon who is willing to take risks when necessary.

However, "Moonshot" is not without its flaws. The subplot involving Dr. Morgan Reznick's ongoing health issues feels somewhat disconnected from the main narrative, lacking the depth and relevance that characterize the rest of the episode. Additionally, while the episode is effective in exploring the theme of risk, it could have benefited from a more nuanced exploration of the emotional repercussions of these decisions.

In summary, "Moonshot" is a well-executed episode that explores the theme of risk-taking with a balanced approach to both the medical drama and the characters' personal lives. With strong direction, a well-paced script, and standout performances, it provides a compelling and emotionally resonant installment in the series, highlighting the challenges and rewards of taking risks.