User reviews

Did appreciate that 'My One and Only' tried to do something different to usual, though different doesn't always mean that it is immediately good. Pascale Hutton has always been a likeable performer and while Sam Page is not as consistent he's given charming performances too. Was very intrigued as to whether they would gel well together. Was mostly not particularly impressed by the 2019 Summer Nights films, with 'Love and Sunshine' being by far the best.

'My One and Only' is worth watching and it's charming enough, though it is uneven. With good things but also some things that didn't come off too great. Really appreciated what it tried to do and that it tried to not be too formulaic, but the differences don't always succeed. While it is a long way from being 'Love and Sunshine', it is much better than the previous Summer Nights film 'All Summer Long', which had a different setting but had too many typical elements not executed well.

There is a lot that is good here. It looks good, especially the scenery which is lovely. Other Hallmark films fare a lot worse when it comes to having ill fitting and intrusive music, neither of which were an issue really with me here. While the script is not Oscar worthy material, it at least has a natural flow and doesn't come over as too cheesy, schmaltzy or waffly.

Generally the story has a warm centre, is light-hearted and doesn't feel dull. The supporting cast all do solid work, especially for the mother courtesy of Susan Hogan. Hutton is the best thing about the film, she is so graceful and confident, while never coming over as arrogant or too perfect. Page is naturally easy going, though his character is not as interesting. Really liked the very relatable themes of facing and overcoming challenges, as someone who faces all that daily that resonated with me. The characters don't bore or irritate.

It is a long way from perfect. There are still familiar tropes that are not much done with that is new. The mystery date element comes over as very silly and forced, and any twist attempts come over as clumsy.

Really do have to agree with those that have panned the abrupt and incomplete feeling ending. Would have liked more chemistry between the leads, which seemed too cautious. Maybe it was an intentional choice for relationship development sake but it was so cautious and careful it came over as too distant.

Overall, uneven but decent. 6/10.

Firstly, I think pretty Pascale Hutton is one of a handful of Hallmark's great actresses. She played the part of Stephanie skillfully and believably. I also like that she 's got curves and that she wasn't playing a girl just barely out of college. As for the male lead, his part was so enjoyable and well-played! Regarding his look -I'm not sure the people criticizing go outside much but beards (from five o'clock shadows to five weeks worth of growth or more) are it nowadays and Sam Page worked it! There was great chemistry between him and Pascale. The fact that there were no advertising agencies or royal highnesses in sight made this a movie I will surely watch again. Go, Hallmark!

7.4 stars.

I don't know if it's the lead actress or the role she happens to be playing in "My One & Only", but at times it was bothersome. Take a woman who constantly hesitates to answer questions, inserts extremely long pauses between sentences, over emphasizes specific expressions...that was my feeling for the first half. As the movie progresses some of the monotony dissipates, but we must wade through a most exhausting reality tv plot. She redeems herself and transforms into a likable and very engaging character, so I was glad for that.

The question I was asking myself: will Hallmark get a reality tv story to be remotely plausible? The final answer for "My One & Only is: nope. Although we know what is transpiring, the obvious flirtation amongst other members... unfortunately the director attempts misdirection and the fallout from a lame attempt at subterfuge is a what I can only describe as a fragmented ending. At least the leads have good chemistry.

"You might just have to do it scared."

Stephanie, played by Pascale Hutton, gets roped into participating as a contestant on a reality show called The One, where they hope individuals find their "one". For this season, they have paired Stephanie with a fellow LA city slicker named Oliver for two weeks at a Wyoming ranch called Aurora Ranch.

Unfortunately, while Oliver is nice and he and Stephanie get along well...she seems to have more chemistry with the Aurora rancher Alex. When they meet, assumptions are made involving some catchy slogan and a hashtag. When it came down to it they actually have a lot in common.

I loved Pascale's wardrobe and the ranch setting was lovely. It was fun to see them work in a reality show into a hallmark romance.

Sweet and easy going, I think romantics will love this sunny offering.

Ironic that many reviews about the very best thing about this film: it's not your typical Hallmark formula! The ending isnt some nonsensical sudden change in the characters' values, but rather a (relatively) realistic stalemate of --but being willing to "do it scared."

Somehow none of the reviews mentioned the central theme: facing challenges even when it's scary or disheartening. It reminded me of the famous Gretsky quote "you miss 100% of the hits you don't take."

If you want a film with a meaningful message, a less predictable plotline, and genuine chemistry among ALL the characters, even the families friends and the "friendzoned couple" as my spouse called the set-up duo, then check this one out. My spouse often gets grumpy at Hallmarks but he was loving it and thought the reality show couple did an excellent job at acting "friends not lovers." I was very pleasantly surprised with this film after we have endured a couple "meh" Hallmarks--this one finally brought a new context (a reality show) with an assertive woman (we often get impatient with the clumsy/pushover woman leads of many Hallmarks--definitely not the case with this one!)

I did notice people complained about Sam's unkempt look, but that's clearly contrasted with the other male lead who is the clean-cut city boy. I found Sam's scruff hot.

Also, I want to figure out who played Sam's mother because she was spot-on! She stole every scene she was in!

A really feelgood movie with a beautiful story and characters.

Start with an experienced talented cast, add the perfect location, then add a brilliant but different story. Now you have the possibility of a ten star movie. This one does not deserve ten stars because of some missing ingredients. First is chemistry between the lead characters. It was almost absent partly because the makeup department failed in their job. No woman wants to spend time getting her makeup perfect then go kiss a porcupine. Sam did not have a beard, he had a dirty face with 3 days of stubble on it, so no kissing until a mandatory kiss at the end. The most important missing element was Love. She cared more about her job than she did him, and he loved his ranch more than her. That is not Love and therefore not a ten star movie.

AMAZING! AMAZING! AMAZING! Loved every minute of this movie and the Air Balloon scene was perfection! 😍

The leads in this are experienced Hallmark veterans with a history of good performances so I expected more. In fairness it wasn't the actors except maybe the one playing Oliver.

The premise is a bit unusual. The script did not really follow the typical format for the type of reality show it was supposed to be copying and so that contributed to the awkwardness that resulted. The story uses a couple of overused minor tropes like a formula and that only makes it worse. And much of the climax is predictable despite some clumsy red herrings.

The mystery date is just one more stupidity which I can't explain without giving away too much.

I love Hallmark movies, but I'll admit that some of them can be a little too "cheesy" or "sappy". I didn't feel that way about this one. Pascale is one of my favorite Hallmark actresses, and she really outdid herself on this one! I thought that she and the main guy had great chemistry, the storyline was a lot of fun and held my interest, the setting was GORGEOUS, and the ending was very satisfying. All in all a 10 out of 10 for me!

What a refreshing film this is! It combines the modern day concept of TV show "dating"..the idea that someone can meet a perfect stranger and develop a relationship in a matter of weeks..and then it introduces a twist. The leading actress, Pascale Hutton, played with her usual maturity and grace, is presented as an intelligent, striving employee of her firm, hoping to be considered for a significant promotion. She is sensible, cautious, and mature...a woman that many viewers can relate to. While she is reluctant to enter the TV dating show, she moves forward with skepticism and wisdom. The man who is presented to her as her bachelor "match" could not be a more inappropriate a partner for her. They are as opposite as any two people could be, but they strive to make the show's premise work..clearly without much success. The "hero" of the film is Sam Page, always an appealing and attractive leading man, with flawless acting skills, and with his engaging smile. There is a slow and cautious relationship developed between the two leads, something neither of them anticipated, and something that is clearly much more real than the TV show's contrived match-up. As the ranch owner/guide who is assigned to help the two contestants get to know one another through various activities, it becomes clear that he has much more in common with our heroine than the match she is set up with.. One of the very touching and poignant connections he makes with the young woman is that while some of her fears keep her from trying new experiences, she should take her fears and just do the dreaded activity while she is afraid. This simple act of kindness and understanding endears the two to one another..and she is able to take some risks she had not dared to take before. It is a life lesson for any viewer who is hobbled by a fear they cannot surmount. Two very small drawbacks..As is typical in a Hallmark movie, there is a misunderstanding that causes a rift. It gets resolved, of course.,.Also, the ranch guide's mother, is played by the wonderful Susan Hogan. While she has the most expressive features, deep and haunting eyes.. she seems to have a problem with a hairdo that could be better managed and kept from flying in her face. A small criticism.. To Hallmark's credit..this movie allows out leading lady and hero kiss before the last 30 seconds..What a delightful treat!! Send us more of this!!

Sorry.... I truly believed that Hallmark had already Presented their Best Movie of the Summer with " A Summer Romance. ". But they truly surprised me with an Equally and Possibly even Superior Presentation with their Summer Season Finale ..... " My One and Only. " Once again they were spot on with their selection of not only Co-Stars with Chemistry, But an entire Cast with Great Chemistry. Kudos to Both the Writers and Casting Directors for Producing such an Outstanding Production. I simply can't Wait for the Sequel to this Outstanding Film. Hopefully Next Summer!

A lovely film about manner to define yourself in different connections with others. Relationships more than romance, a TV dating show, spring colors and nice dialogues are virtues of this charming film, using Hallmark recipes but in smart manner, proposing, in gentle way, nice pieces of bachelor status and need of love, fair choice and essence of happiness.