- Mr. Roarke: Once you begin a fantasy, you must see it through to its natural conclusion.
- Brax Weaver: NOBODY KNEW WHAT YOU MEANT!
- Brax Weaver: [to Roarke] Back in college I lost a bet and got the dumbest ink ever.
- [opens his shirt and reveals Tattoo tattooed on his chest]
- Mr. Roarke: [to Gwen] Most people would kill for your fantasy: a family. Enjoy them while you *can*.
- Patrick Sullivan: You're a hero!
- Lieutenant Sullivan: You know what a hero is? Somebody not smart enough to stay alive.
- Melanie Cole: What're you going to do, wish that you and your husband get back together?
- Sloane Maddison: No, that you and Nick do.
- Julia: [Gwen asks to redo her fantasy] Are you sure this is what you want?
- Gwen Olsen: It's not what I want, but it's what I have to do.
- Sloane Maddison: [picks up phone] Please, please, there's no time. I've been abducted. I've been taken to some crazy island.
- Mr. Roarke: Calm down. I know where you are. Stay there.
- Sloane Maddison: Thank you. Thank you so much. You have to hurry, you have to hurry, you have to hurry.
- Mr. Roarke: It will all be fine, Mrs. Maddison.
- Sloane Maddison: How do you know my name?
- Mr. Roarke: Because you are one of my guests.
- Julia: You have to do something, these are not the island's guests, they are yours.
- Mr. Roarke: It's not what I want.
- Julia: But it's what you have to do.
- Brax Weaver: You've put your life on hold because of me. Maybe it's time I just move out.
- J. D. Weaver: Then who would sleep on the couch?
- Chastity: Nobody. That's the point.
- Sloane Maddison: You did all of this because of a couple of pranks?
- Melanie Cole: Pranks? You tortured me every single day for years.
- Sloane Maddison: Oh please. I teased you a little.
- Melanie Cole: I was so traumatised by what you did I had to finish high school from home. Yes, trying to ruin your life was wrong but you ruined mine first.