User reviews

One of those overlooked Films in Cinema History, Honest, multi-layered and amazingly contemporary, this is one of those movies that have admirably stood the test of time, add to that Winning the prestigious Palm d'Or at Cannes 1962.

It is not a surprise that this movie won the golden palm in Cannes. The story of the man that carry a big and heavy cross as a promise for the healing of his donkey is the simpliest and the most beautiful. The poetic way as it is shown became the film an unforgettable classic, with Zé as the protagonist. For sure, technically it is a pre-historic film, the sound quality and editing is really bad, but it even help the audience to focus what really cares. That is not only about poverty, but about humanity. If you liked Central Station, you can't miss.

It's really a shame that this masterpiece is constantly overlooked by All-Time Greatest Lists, even though it won the prestigious Palm d'Or at Cannes.

"The Bicycle Thieves" is frequently cited as the greatest entry into Social Cinema, yet unfortunately the public and the critics seem to forget the sheer beauty that "The Payer of Promises" is. While "Bicycle"'s influence is undeniable, "Payer" goes beyond that.

Honest, multi-layered and amazingly contemporary, this is one of those movies that have admirably stood the test of time - specially if one considers the difficulty it is making Films in Brazil.

Featuring incredibly believable and dramatic performances, a rich, vivid setting and neo-realist technique employed in an elegant and sincere manner, this movie should not be missed. I found impressive how well the film flows - nothing is there gratuitously and the pacing is pitch perfect.

The amazing strength, courage and valor of Brazilian Cinema is a force to be reckoned with, as we take a look at the works of Film Makers such as Peixoto, Duarte, Rocha, Candeias, Bressane, Khouri, Salles and most recently, Meirelles. To list a very short list.

In fact, I can say without fear that it is a better Film than The Bicycle Thieves. It is easily one of the Best Brazilian Films in History - if not one of the Best in Film History. Period.

A shame such an important movie has no poster here on IMDb. I wanted to add the one that is used on Wikipedia, but I would have to pay to do that. Strange. (Edit: it has a poster now.)

If you are critical of religion fanaticism, you must see this movie! It shows what can become of fanatic people, how lack of education plays an important role in fanaticism, the arrogance of the church and the hypocrisy of our society.

Zé do Burro (Joe of the Donkey) has the soul of a child. He is a good guy, but extremely naive. His naivety is shamelessly exploited, and people cruelly distort his good intentions, making an evil person out of him, when all he wanted was to do good.

The movie won the Golden Palm in Cannes and other prizes. It's a classic. Dialogs are a bit theatrical (only if you understand Portuguese), but so they used to be that time. A movie that will get under your skin.

The only old thing about this movie is its release date. It's very contemporary and universal. O Pagador de Promessas (1962) is based on a play written by Dias Gomes and performed for the first time in 1960.

(About the first scene so not really a spoiler) Zé and his wife, Rosa, left their land, in the country, and went to the city so Zé could pay a promise he made for a saint called Santa Bárbara. He promised to carry a wooden cross all the way to the city and enter Santa Bárbara church with it if his best friend was healed by the saint. (Paying promisses is still common in Brazil ).

I won't say why exactly but the priest doesn't let he enters the church.

It might seem a minor conflict, but it's not and it escalates through the narrative in a chocking way to Zé, Rosa and audience.

Through the obstacles, Gomes criticizes many social institutions and Brazilian society as a whole in a brilliant way, mixing comedy with drama, what was totally brought to light in Anselmo's adaptation.

In this path, the acting is really important and it's fantastic.

Leonardo Villar portrays perfectly Zé certainty and naivety; Glória Menezes thought of everything, from the accent to the way of moving and the confusion Rosa shows; Dionísio Azevedo made a perfect traditional priest and everybody else were great in their respective roles, an awesome cast.

The technical features are amazing, the sets, the costume design, Duarte's shots, Chock Fowle cinematography and Gabriel Migliori scores.

What stands out in the movie is the representation of Brazilian Culture, which is what the film defends, the beautiful mix Brazil is, of European, Indian, African and many other cultures.

This great film, received the principal prize in Cannes and it is one of the best Brazilian films of all the times. A simple man, whose donkey was sick, gets its cure and he decides like this to pay a promise Saint Barbra, to who attributed the salvation of the animal.

Main representative of the brazilian "Cinema Novo" , the film is based on an exceptional play, and it is a realistic film, very well interpreted and driven, and it shows one on the most dramatic sides of the Brazilian people: the fidelity in paying a promise, cost what to cost!

Alas, if only people in this world were even one iota as determined to abide by their words and keep their promises as this man was!

Felt like a rough template for Billy Wilder's "Ace in the Hole" many decades later. A humble man's plight becomes a media sensation, which in turn becomes a fiasco that can only end in misery for the once ordinary farmer that suddenly, unwillingly finds the spotlight on him.

#AnimalLove #LikeSeriousAnimalLove

Excellent film, but I cannot ignore the obsessive focus on religion that makes this feel like it lacks greater perspective. Also, that ending was so cliche that- even though it could have been expected and oh so predictable- watching it play out anyways was ever so exasperating!

O Pagador de Promessas / Keeper of Promises (1962) : Brief Review -

A powerful Brazilian film about a religious circus. The film centers on Zé, a man who is a strong believer in God. When his donkey falls ill, he promises to carry a cross to the Santa Bárbara church in exchange for the donkey's health. As the miracle occurs, the donkey is saved and becomes healthy in just one day. Zé carries a cross on his shoulder for seven leagues and reaches the church alongside his wife, who is reluctant about his beliefs and promises. Just for the sake of a bed, she spends a night with a local pimp, becoming disloyal to her kind-hearted husband. This is the film's biggest flaw, as we later see a crowd gathered outside the church learning about his wife's affair with the pimp, yet Zé does nothing about it. That was quite foolish. Anyway, the father of the church denies Zé's entry because he made his promise in a way that contradicts Catholic beliefs. Zé's simple promise becomes a topic of political, religious, and social hysteria, and he becomes a sensation in no time. While he could make money and become a hero, he denies fame and remains true to his promise. The system does everything to stop him, and the tragic ending shatters you from within. I liked the theme, the way events are explored, and the powerful climax. I just didn't appreciate the wife's character. She was so shameless that she asked her husband to take her home after spending a night with a pimp. One of the hookers humiliates her and her husband in front of a large crowd by calling him a "cuckold," and still, there are no reactions from him regarding her or her mistake. This conflict undermines the purity of the otherwise noble subject, making it appear highly contradictory. Thanks to the powerful message in the climax and the one-man show by Leonardo Villar, this film is a must-watch.

RATING - 7/10*

By - #samthebestest.

This film is great! One of the best movies I have ever seen. About faith, religion, poverty...well, about life and all that surrounds us

Could have been just another sentimental and dishonest movie about human condition but no! It is beautiful and trully rewarding... A Masterpiece, do yourselves a favor and watch this movie!

In my opinion this is one of the best Brazilian movie ever made and also the best movie about religion and its implications to a society in general.

It is a mix of religion, politic, culture, beliefs, prejudices, intolerance. It starts as a simple and innocence gesture from a poor man to pay homage to a Saint after his donkey gets miraculous healed, but instead it becomes a bizarre show of enormous proportions. The authority of the church, the misleading politicians, the media and the crowd use the cause for their own gain. It's a battle between the bureaucracy of norms and the innocence of simple causes. Amazing performances by the main cast.

This movie was awarded with Palme D'Or and the Oscar candidate for Brazil.

THIS IS A MUST SEE MOVIE, it worth every minute of it.

I love to watch old black and white movies and if you look for the history of foreign films up for an Oskar you find some gems like this movie. Such a real Brazilian movie and especially from Salvador de Bahia, the old capital where the cultural history of Brazil (except for the original people) is present. Colonial white oppression, the corrupt white middle class, the African people with their religious cultures and capoeira, the Catholic Church between them but like always only saving it's own position and then simple campesino who embodies the true values of human kind. In a collusion of them all, feasts, religion and fights occur and turn into a spiritual happening, a cruxifiction in which human dignity prevails. A wonderful movie from times when things seems to be clear.

Brazilian cinema is extremely judged by Brazilians themselves. These criticisms always come from people who have never actually watched films like The Given Word. This film has a Brazilian essence. It doesn't try to adapt to the style of cinema that Hollywood produces. It's a completely original film made with a lot of heart. The way religious intolerance is addressed throughout the plot is fantastic. The characters are wonderful and the protagonist has a wonderful charisma. The ending is extremely symbolic. A beautiful ending and a perfect conclusion to this story. It may seem very simple, because maybe it is, but the way it is told is what makes it special. The setting is very well used, in a way that makes the story flow, even if it sticks to one location. A film that makes you proud of Brazil. Not only one of the best Brazilian films, but also one of the best films in the history of cinema.