Metacritic reviews

It All Came True isn't a typical gangster movie. It's a lighthearted musical comedy that happens to feature a couple of sinister details, like the fact that Humphrey Bogart's character, Chips Maguire, is trying to keep a low profile after committing a murder.

A diverting trifle with Humphrey Bogart and Ann Sheridan that must have been shot during a Warner lunch hour. But it makes good, raffish fun. [18 May 1986, p.2A]

Neither comedy, strictly speaking, nor good red gangsterism, nor an altogether creditable combination of both.

A feeble attempt at comedy in the Damon Runyon mold (although based on a Louis Bromfield opus), this is a hit-and-miss affair with some offbeat casting.