User reviews

Although he usually gets high marks for being funny, W.C. Fields seldom gets credit for versatility. Even people familiar with his work tend to define his screen persona narrowly as a cantankerous, lecherous old blow-hard who hates kids and dogs, and is usually drunk. This image was firmly ingrained in the public imagination during the late 1930's and '40s through his radio work and most of his later movie appearances, but a look back at the films he made in the early to mid-'30s reveals distinct variations in his roles. He was capable of a surprising range of nuance, and was not at all a Johnny One Note who could only play "W.C. Fields" over and over.

As evidence of this, consider the four short films Fields made for producer Mack Sennett during the 1932-33 season. Three of the four bear certain similarities, each presenting our hero in the role of middle-class professional man: dentist, pharmacist, and barber. Each character lives over his place of business, and each has difficulties with his family and his customers, but beyond the superficial similarities there are decided shades of difference in Fields's portrayals. In The Dentist he is ornery, mean to his daughter, and openly contemptuous towards his patients. In The Pharmacist he's once more a petty tyrant when dealing with his family, but on the job he's ridiculously agreeable and positively masochistic in his desire to please his customers. In The Barber Shop, his last Sennett comedy, Fields is downright mellow, and the atmosphere is more laid-back and whimsical than in the other films.

Fields plays Cornelius O'Hare, barber of Felton City. ("Felton" was the maiden name of Fields' mother, and it's said that his mumbling delivery of wisecracks, as demonstrated in the opening scene, owed a lot to his mother's personal style.) O'Hare likes to hang out in front of his shop and shoot the breeze. His business is struggling and his wife is a nag, but his life has its compensations: he has a friendly relationship with his son, who likes to tell riddles, and gets to flirt with an attractive young manicurist named Hortense who works in his shop and seems to like him. During the course of the film we follow O'Hare through his dealings with difficult customers and various passersby. We learn that O'Hare is not a very good barber -- to put it politely -- but he seems to be a decent enough guy. And when his day ends in a humiliating encounter with a bank robber, we feel a little sorry for him.

The Barber Shop may not be the funniest short Fields ever made, but there are laughs throughout, and you'll seldom find him as sympathetic as he is here. I especially enjoy the surreal touches, such as the steam room that reduces an obese man to a skinny one in a matter of minutes, and the climactic gag involving O'Hare's bass fiddle. These wacky gags, in combination with Fields' more benign persona, make this one of The Great Man's most pleasant comedies, one that might win over non-fans who are put off by his nastier characterizations in other movies.

Released during the Depression summer of 1933, The Barber Shop holds a melancholy place in Hollywood history: according to Simon Louvish's biography of Mack Sennett, this was the last film put out by Sennett's studio before it went into bankruptcy and was forcibly closed. Sennett had been in business as a producer since he founded Keystone in 1912, and although he managed to limp along with minor projects for another year or two this pretty much marked the end of the line for him. Sad, but at least Mack was able to finish his career on a high note, thanks to Mr. Fields.

Personally, I like Fields' features much more than the few short films he made. The Bank Dick, You Can't Cheat an Honest Man, You're Telling Me, The Old-Fashioned Way, It's a Gift, Never Give a Sucker an Even Break, and The Man on the Flying Trapeze are some of the funniest films you're ever likely to see. But most of his shorts are somewhat lame. My favorite is The Golf Specialist, which is nothing more - nor should it be - than Fields' infamous vaudeville routine. The Dentist is famous for its sexual innuendo of the woman wrapping her legs around Fields while he pulls a tooth, but it's not very funny after that. The Barber Shop is the second funniest of these shorts. Fields is very funny in it, and so are the supporting cast members. Here Fields is in henpecked husband mode, taking it from his evil vegetarian wife. His little son likes to tell him the lamest riddles in history. The slight plot is a prelude to The Bank Dick, with a criminal on the run and Fields bragging that he'd throttle him good if he got a hold of him. A lot of good jokes here. See it on the Criterion disc of his short films. 8/10.

This is one of the oddest films I've seen of W. C. Fields because he seems to genuinely like his son! The young boy loves to tell really lame riddles and W. C. encourages him and acts pretty tenderly towards the kid (at least compared to the usual fare from this comedian). Children are either just tolerated or hated in his films. A good example was his famous line "Of course I love kids,....boiled". For whatever reason, this film is unusual in this respect.

Now as for the film itself, this one is very similar to THE PHARMACIST in that it is a very slow slice of life short, though it does have more gags and a more "Fields-like" ending. Don't expect the craziness of Fields shorts like THE DENTIST or THE FATAL GLASS OF BEER, but this isn't a positive or negative thing--I like both styles of his work. Funny, well-paced and cute--this is an excellent Fields short.

With the great W.C. Fields in fine form, and a setup that provides him with a lot of good material, "The Barber Shop" is a very enjoyable short comedy. It is filled with the kinds of details and subtle gags that make Fields's comedies worth watching attentively.

"The Barber Shop" closely resembles the Fields feature "The Pharmacist", with very similar settings and stories. Both are very good, and in both of them Elise Cavanna is funny as the domineering wife of Fields's character. Both have some gags that are deliberately absurd, and others that are less obvious. Both feature amusing exchanges between Fields and numerous customers.

When Fields was at his best, he could really get across the wackiness of so much of what happens in daily life, and that's one of the things that works quite well here.

Another dose of madness from W. C. Fields, this short sees him playing the part of Cornelius O'Hare, small-town barber with a cutting observation for all who pass his path. Fields comes up with a number of gags that possibly only he would dream up, whether its testing the sharpness of a razor on his tongue, playing a bass fiddle in his own inimitable way, or shaving a hapless customer with all the delicacy of a blind man painting a barn door. This forms a loose trio with The Dentist and The Pharmacist, which Fields also made for Mack Sennett, and all of which present the comedian at the height of his talent – although this one is perhaps the weaker of the three.

THE BARBER SHOP (Paramount, 1933), directed by Arthur Ripley, marks the fourth and final Mack Sennett Star Comedy short to feature W.C. Fields (who also scripted), following THE DENTIST (1932), THE FATAL GLASS OF BEER (1933) and THE PHARMACIST (1933). Not quite as famous as the initial two, THE BARBER SHOP does bear a strong resemblance to THE PHARMACIST, that of Fields wearing a straw hat with an open top; his encounter with a bank robber; and having Elsie Cavanna (famous as the drill patient in THE DENTIST) in the role of his wife. As with THE DENTIST, however, the customers in THE BARBER SHOP are more victims than patrons. For Fields' final short (lasting 21 minutes), much of it falls into familiar territory in true Fields-comedic style, with touches of originality, especially his chosen character name, pun intended.

Set in Felton City, "Population 873, Elevation two feet below sea level," the story revolves around the day in the life of Cornelius O'Hare (W.C. Fields), a small town barber with a nagging wife (Elsie Cavanna) and a young son, Ronald (Harry Watson). O'Hare's morning starts off peacefully as he sits in front of his place of business (with his home in back of the barber shop), greeting the passing residents while sharpening his razor, then playing his huge bass fiddle he names "Lena." After dining at the breakfast table with his family, O'Hare's work day, shared by his manicurist (Dagmar Oakland), soon comes to a series of mishaps as he shaves off a mole from a man's chin, places an ultra hot towel over that same customer's (John St. Clair) face by holding a pair of tongs, and unwittingly locking a fat man ("Fatty" Alexander) in a steam room before O'Hare's day is complete as he finds himself face to face with an armed bank robber (Cyril Ring).

With Fields being best known playing one with a strong dislike for children and animals, THE BARBER SHOP shows his compassion towards his offspring, listening attentively listening to his riddles, rather than being short-tempered towards his annoyance. In fact, there's even a brief scene where he happily throws a ball over to the neighborhood street kids, only to have it landing on top of a man's noggin. So not to be a total loss, the plot does include Fields' encounter with a baby in a stroller hitting him over the head with a milk bottle, as well as his involvement with Mrs. Broadbottom's (Fay Holderness) bratty daughter, Gloria, wearing an assortment of party hats. A dog takes part sitting by the barber's chair awaiting for another chance for O'Hare to accidentally cut off an ear while shaving a customer, but all the dog can do is witness some "close shaves."

Although the brief climatic chase and its closing fail to recapture some rather amusing scenes earlier in the story, THE BARBER SHOP does recapture classic routines originated on stage by Fields himself, some for which he reprized to better advantage in his later feature film comedies. With Alison Skipworth and Kathleen Howard making the grade as Fields' most notable co-stars during his years (1932-38) at Paramount, Elsie Cavanna shouldn't go unnoticed with her participation in three of Fields four comedy shorts, with THE DENTIST as their most famous and revived.

THE BARBER SHOP, along with other Fields' shorts, has turned up occasionally on television over the years, notably cable stations (American Movie Classics in the 1990s, and Turner Classic Movies a decade later), and distribution on video and DVD formats, with best possible prints from the Criterion Collection. For some amusements, watch Cornelius O'Hare's barber shop methods. For a good haircut and a shave, try someplace else. (***)

The Barbershop was the fourth and last Mack Sennett short subject that W.C. Fields did for Paramount. In this last one and in The Pharmacist he honed his henpecked character to perfection.

As you gather by the title Fields is a barber and he lives above the shop with his wife Elsie Cavanna and son Harry Watson who is busy annoying dad with a lot of stupid riddles. It may have been in this film and in The Pharmacist that Fields developed his well known appetite for children. Remember he said he liked them if they were properly cooked.

His moment of sunshine every day is shapely manicurist Dagmar Oakland who brightens his working day. But Fields is so under the thumb of his wife he dare not make a move. Still he can and does dream.

My favorite gag is the very obese gentleman who went into the steam room Fields installed and came out like a third world starvation victim. If losing weight were only that simple.

I do also like that two bull fiddles mate and have a nice litter of violins as a result. That's another great sight gag.

In the end Fields does not get credit for an albeit accidental act of heroism. But it's all in a day for Fields whose characters just can't catch a break ever.

W. C. Fields had done a few silent shorts in the "teens" but it really did take sound to capture him at his best. He is not only a physical comedian, capable of broad slapstick, he is one of the best verbal comedians around, especially when allowed to ad-lib, as he does here. The story follows the adventures of barber Cornelius O'Hare through his extremely busy day. It has the look of a vaudeville routine, which no doubt it was based on. Fields' almost constant patter makes all his movies worth rewatching, just to catch his subtle remarks, often made under his breath and very quickly. I have read that, at the beginning of the short, as Fields is sitting out front of his shop, making rude comnents about people as they go by, that this is a tribute to his mother, who acted just like this as Fields was a boy, commenting cuttingly on the neighbors. If you like sardonic humor, Fields is the man for you. Recommended highly along with any of his other shorts as in these shorter films, much more is packed in and nothing is allowed to lag.

ONCE IN A LIFETIME, there is a short period of the most unusual, nearly unbelievable events occur. Call it coincidence or a Gift from God; but whatever there is no denying that something very extraordinary has happened. Such was the case at MACK SENNETT STUDIOS in 1932-33; when the four great W.C. Fields sound shorts were made.

TO THE DELIGHT of the Depression Era Moviegoers, the Sennett Fun Factiry had filmed and released what was destined to be a blueprint for what would be the W.C. Fields character and storyline for the rest of his career. Be it at the Movies or on Radio, whatever the character's name was, it was Fields.

OF THOSE PREVIOUSLY mentioned little masterpieces, our subject today, THE BARBER SHOP (Sennett/Paramount, 1933) was the last to reach the movie houses. Prior to this, we had been treated with THE DENTIST (19332), THE FATAL GLASS OF BEER (1933) and THE PHARMASIST ('33).

THESE FOUR SOUND Shorts combined out-produced many a feature length comedy, by far. That they would make an excellent presentation at a revival movie house goes without saying. A number of years ago, we were privileged in attending such a showing. It was a the Wilmette Theatre in suburban Chicago, that a marathon of 'Old Time Comedy Movies' was the playbill for the night. One segment played these four and the old laugh meter was nearly worn out.

AS FOR TODAY'S reviewed subject, THE BARBER SHOP, we can only say that it is that great W.C. Fields show; but with a little variation. He is once again a crusty, grumpy and largely misunderstood father. But this time he seems to have just a little more sympathetic treat from family; particularly from his one son, Ronald (Harry Watson). The son shares an affinity with his Pop for humorous riddles and recites many to please "the Old Man" at the supper table.

AS IS THE case with all of the 3 other Sennett two reelers, Mr. Fields insured his characterization by being the writer of the original stories. (This is clearly evident with the Barber's name, Corneilus O'Hare.) Sennett veteran Gag Man and Director, Arthur Ripley, directed and , many of the old Keystone players are seen in supporting roles.

W.C. plays the title role of the Barber. He gets to flirt with the manicurist in his shop all day, and go upstairs to his unadoring wife at night. His shaving technique is truly frightening, and his steamroom is truly amazing. He even manages to babysit for a neighbor and to capture a criminal in his shop, through no fault of his own, during his very full day. And you haven't lived till you've heard Fields play the bass fiddle!

Fields is good as usual in this film; it's not as hilarious as others of his but is fairly even.

After a perhaps sluggish 4-minute beginning (there is some possibility that I lost some good gags as W. C. Fields's accent is hard for not native speakers), the short film becomes quite funny. It is a slapstick dark humor short film that reminds a lot animated films. As a matter of fact, Cornelius O'Hare is almost as insane and dangerous as Woody Woodpecker in the Barber of Seville. However, the latter is an animated short film which would be made only 11 years afterwards! Then, W. C. Fields has a remarkable performance here. There are some hilarious dark humor situations between that tepid beginning and the more conventional end.