This Popeye is one of my favorite shorts and my pick for one of the better ones in the series. My favorite character, one J. Wellington Wimpy, is prominently featured (with an amusing twist on his own well-known catch-phrase) and Bluto is smarmy, rude and surly, even for Bluto. A little something for almost everyone in this one. A little gem. Well worth watching and most recommended.
I've heard from a fair number of people about some of my specific comments, but also occasionally on my comments in general. So I decided to put down my approach to comments in general:
As a rule, I confine my comments to things I have (though there are exceptions) and to things I have liked (also with exceptions). Thus, there will be very few killer comments. Even when something I want to review doesn't quite work for me, I will say what I liked as well as what I didn't and leave it as an exercise to the reader to decide if it interests them. Different people like different things. Finally, I tend to review animated shorts, as animation tends to get short shrift, even here at the IMDb. There you have it, ladies and gentleducks. For any who are curious (all three of you in the balcony), that's my policy on comments.