Rhett and Link attempt to become more confident by tucking their shirts into their pants. They test their newfound bravery by venturing down a dark alleyway, but Link's phone mysteriously disappears.
To search for the missing phone, Rhett and Link decide to retrace their steps in hopes of finding where they might have lost it, but along the way, Link stumbles upon Rhett's super secret exercise bike.
Rhett and Link return to the restaurant where Link believes he left his phone, but when Rhett dings the car door of the restaurant owner, the owner fights back.
Attempting to ignore Aimee's attempts to sabotage their channel, Rhett and Link continue their lives as normal, until they get caught up in rival roller skating gangs, and are forced to fight each other.
Rhett and Link go to see Maxwell's magic act on their way to meet up with Aimee. Maxwell gives them advice about their meeting, but Aimee then reveals what she was planning to do.
With a tough decision ahead of them, Rhett and Link venture out into the wilderness on a "soul search" to find answers. Rhett meets a strange but helpful man who wears only dirt, and Link accidentally creates clones of them both.
