Thing is, to people that love the genre this a 5. I mean 2 1/2 stars on a 1-10 format/10 star review, easy. People who don't love spaghetti - sure alright. 3.8 to scare you away with the TRUTH. If you love western's, especially spaghetti's.... It's at least a 5, notice i didn't get carried away with myself. Another thing is, i personally have found once i had pretty much exhausted most all spaghetti western's and had ran out of the new ones i could get my hands on, save a few.....I actually found myself to enjoy the Miles Deem (AKA) directed flicks, a bit more. It's just something that you either have in ya, or you don't, period. Italian/Spanish mash-ups i like to call em'. However if you happen to be normal, ya i guess a 3.8 ! Too Funny man.....