Walt is rehanging his important collection of paintings in hopes of impressing the board of directors of the New York Museum of Art to become their next president. Bridget stumbles upon a sentimental painting of "Boo Boo Birdie". Bridget picked it out in an antique shop when she was three years old and it hung in her room growing up. She brings it home but Bernie hates the primitive painting of a roughly executed bird standing on grass with a lake, mountain, and another bird in the background. Bernie lets her hang it on the wall and she starts seeing it as ugly too and says they should give it away. Sophie sees it and instantly loves it and hangs it in the deli. Sam and Moe hate it and says its a dusty mess. When Sophie washes it she finds another painting underneath it that appears to be an Old Master. When Bernie finds it signed "Botticelli" they rush to have it authenticated with Sam and Walt arguing over ownership. A series of plot twists leads to an unexpected ending.
