L'affaire de la mutinerie du Caine

Titre original : The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial

2023
TV-14
1h 48min

NOTE IMDb

6,7/10

5,6 k

MA NOTE

L'affaire de la mutinerie du Caine (2023)

Follows a naval officer who stands trial for mutiny after taking command from a ship captain he feels is acting in an unstable way, putting in danger both the ship and its crew.

Lire trailer1:46

1 Video

26 photos

Drama War

L'histoire d'un officier de marine jugé pour mutinerie après avoir pris le commandement d'un capitaine de navire qu'il juge instable et qui met en danger le navire et son équipage.L'histoire d'un officier de marine jugé pour mutinerie après avoir pris le commandement d'un capitaine de navire qu'il juge instable et qui met en danger le navire et son équipage.L'histoire d'un officier de marine jugé pour mutinerie après avoir pris le commandement d'un capitaine de navire qu'il juge instable et qui met en danger le navire et son équipage.

Réalisation
- William Friedkin
Scénario
- William Friedkin
- Herman Wouk
Casting principal

Voir les informations de production sur IMDbPro

NOTE IMDb

6,7/10

5,6 k

MA NOTE

Réalisation
- William Friedkin
Scénario
- William Friedkin
- Herman Wouk
Casting principal

Voir les informations de production sur IMDbPro

Récompenses
- 3 nominations au total

Anecdotes
According to Guillermo del Toro, who served as a back-up director (due to insurance purposes), the late director William Friedkin was given 15 days to complete the shooting. He had finished shooting at the 14th day.

Gaffes
The President of the Board of Court Martial was a navy captain. Sitting to his left, as a member of the court, was an officer wearing the stripes of a Rear Admiral. In a military court martial the senior officer is automatically the President.

Citations
Challee: Sir, the witness is obviously and understandably agitated by this ordeal and I request a recess to give him a breathing space.
Lieutenant Commander Phillip Queeg: I'm not agitated in the least. I'm glad to answer any and all questions. In fact, I-I demand the opportunity to set the record straight for any derogatory statements made about me in testimony that's gone before. I didn't make a single mistake in the 15 months I was aboard the Caine, and I-I can prove it. I've had a spotless record up until now and I don't want it being discredited by these lies and distortions told by these disloyal officers.
Captain Luther Blakely: Commander, would you like a recess?
Lieutenant Commander Phillip Queeg: Certainly not. In fact, if I had any say in this, I would ask there be no recess.

Connexions
Referenced in Film Junk Podcast: Episode 921: Godzilla Minus One (2023)

Bandes originales
Lowdown
Written by Boz Scaggs and David Paich
Published by Boz Scaggs Music (GMR) administered by Concord Global Music (GMR) and Hudmar Publishing Co. Inc. c/o Spirit Four Music Crescendo

Avis des utilisateurs53

Commentaire à la une

6/10

Good until it wasn't

Having recently watched the original Caine Mutiny, I was excited to see how such a strong cast and director could retell the story for a modern audience.

Right out of the gate, the pace of the movie was off. Cut scene to each witness, no time spend on any transition between them.

Then there's the scene with Lt Keefer. The original movie provided a clear understanding of his motives. In this one the Keefer and Maryk dynamic during the trial is not explored. No dots connected for the viewer, just a simple glazed over opportunity to develop the story.

The final scene left me puzzled. The message it sends is diminished from the takeaway of the original. Moral courage and fortitude are nowhere to be found. Maryk is made to be a one dimensional buffoon.

9/10 for the actors, 4/10 for the message and muddled delivery.