NOTE IMDb
5,2/10
1,2 k
MA NOTE
Un film de guerre basé sur les affrontements de 1967 à Nathu La et Cho La le long de la frontière du Sikkim après la guerre sino-indienne de 1962.Un film de guerre basé sur les affrontements de 1967 à Nathu La et Cho La le long de la frontière du Sikkim après la guerre sino-indienne de 1962.Un film de guerre basé sur les affrontements de 1967 à Nathu La et Cho La le long de la frontière du Sikkim après la guerre sino-indienne de 1962.
- Récompenses
- 1 nomination au total
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesJP Dutta's comeback to direction after 12 years last release was Umrao Jaan 2006.
- GaffesThe movie is shown to take place in 1967. The village streets are shown to be paved with concrete. This was not common in the 60s. Most village streets were either unpaved at that time or paved with bricks. Concrete paved streets became common after 2000.
Commentaire à la une
Tone, Script & Story: Apart from a few factors changed, this movie tries to create what team J.P.Dutta created with Border. It was story of 1971 war between India and Pakistan. This is the story of war between India and China for post called Nathula. It takes place in year 1967 five years after India lost to China in 1962.
What it has copied from Border are the scenes highlighting family life, scenes highlighting love life, lone soldier taking entire bunker, waiting for orders from high authority to take further action.
Now what new has been introduced here is Chinese keep being a pain by exploiting border regulations. A chief explains how in some book it is written tactics to demoralize your enemy and China is acting in the same way.
The melodrama here in this movie is reduced maybe because today's audience won't accept it. For me Border was a better movie. Paltan on the other hand despite being rated low by me does not hurt to watch.
Direction, Screenplay, Cinematography: It was a story to be told and the director succeeded. Screenplay and Cinematography were justified.
Music: After giving such a good music in LOC Kargil and Border, I would say the Dutta team ended up on what I call less than average account. Acting: Acting was Justified.
Final Verdict: What should I say? In a journey to recreate Border it fails vaguely! Or Chichorapan handled well in this melodramatic patriotic deal.
What it has copied from Border are the scenes highlighting family life, scenes highlighting love life, lone soldier taking entire bunker, waiting for orders from high authority to take further action.
Now what new has been introduced here is Chinese keep being a pain by exploiting border regulations. A chief explains how in some book it is written tactics to demoralize your enemy and China is acting in the same way.
The melodrama here in this movie is reduced maybe because today's audience won't accept it. For me Border was a better movie. Paltan on the other hand despite being rated low by me does not hurt to watch.
Direction, Screenplay, Cinematography: It was a story to be told and the director succeeded. Screenplay and Cinematography were justified.
Music: After giving such a good music in LOC Kargil and Border, I would say the Dutta team ended up on what I call less than average account. Acting: Acting was Justified.
Final Verdict: What should I say? In a journey to recreate Border it fails vaguely! Or Chichorapan handled well in this melodramatic patriotic deal.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Paltan?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
Box-office
- Montant brut mondial
- 1 082 630 $US
- Durée2 heures 30 minutes
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant