One big reason I am really enjoying this show is because Tosh is the host, I'm a big fan. Also, really don't like any reality TV shows I have seen, and I've seen quite a few...well, because I have dated a number of women, so it comes with the territory.
One thing I really have about reality TV is that these shows take themselves far to seriously, and the contenders as well. I'm sure in most reality TV shows have applied psychologists pick the reality actors, to be psychologically toxic, sociopathic, and create an environment for terrible behavior. Or, really most reality TV is just boring, and pointless.
The GOAT, is definitely a light hearted show, which really make fun of reality TV, via satire. I also, like the contestants, because they do have fun personalities, some are just charming. And in the GOAT things do "get real" so that aspect is fun to watch in moderate doses.
If you are like me, I think you will really enjoy the GOAT. For those who are big fans of reality TV, I can see how this show might not have enough entertainment value for you. Still, for the reality TV lovers, this show does have everything, so give it a go. You might enjoy a more light hearted funny satire.