ÉVALUATION IMDb
7,5/10
59 k
MA NOTE
Une découverte accidentelle ravive les souvenirs douloureux d'un médecin, huit après le meurtre atroce de sa femme et les choses prennent une tournure inattendue. Le gentil docteur en sait-i... Tout lireUne découverte accidentelle ravive les souvenirs douloureux d'un médecin, huit après le meurtre atroce de sa femme et les choses prennent une tournure inattendue. Le gentil docteur en sait-il plus qu'il ne prétend ?Une découverte accidentelle ravive les souvenirs douloureux d'un médecin, huit après le meurtre atroce de sa femme et les choses prennent une tournure inattendue. Le gentil docteur en sait-il plus qu'il ne prétend ?
- Prix
- 13 victoires et 15 nominations au total
Kristin Scott Thomas
- Hélène Perkins
- (as Kristin Scott-Thomas)
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesOriginally, author Harlan Coben had optioned off his novel to Hollywood, with Director Michael Apted attached. During this time, Writer and Director Guillaume Canet, who had loved the novel, had been calling up Coben with his take on the novel. Coben was immediately impressed with Canet's passion for the story, and his vision, stating that Canet understood that the novel was a love story first, and a thriller second, which Hollywood never got. When the option with Hollywood fell through, Coben contacted Canet and decided to give him a chance.
- GaffesWhen Alexandre gets out of the water to go help Margot in the beginning, his attacker hits him twice with the bat. Towards the end, when they show this same attack from farther away his attacker hits him thrice.
Commentaire en vedette
Based on a mystery writer's novel which I've not read, the film succeeds courtesy of some great acting. So often a mystery is put together with clues and red herrings, and then at the end you fold a puzzle piece and voila it fits. I think it appeals to the clockwork mind, and as their is often crime involved, there is a sense of some extracurricular guidance towards justice.
While this film has that, and action moves like car chases, pistol whipping and a lengthy running script (the kind Tom Cruise would demand be inserted in a film of his), Francois Cluzet holds the center of the film in more gentle hands. He's a good guy, even when mixed up with the bad guys, he brings out their inherent benevolence. You go, Bruno!
Films like this hinge upon believing that bad moves are really the best moves one can take, the story and acting help sell that here in my opinion. In real life, I think in most cases perhaps not as intricate as this, I would Tell Some One, and likely an authority. Granted plenty of films from America North and South, make clear the dangers of corrupt cops and who watches the watchers. Maybe in Europe, things could be different.
Again for the genre, experts might not enjoy this (or pick it apart for a variety of reasons). But I was able to just enjoy the people on screen foremost (always helps to have Nathalie Baye involved), and then the pacing and plot.
Nice to see the director hatched the script and put himself in the mix on screen as well. Recommend you watch it, and then figure out the right someone to tell to see it next.
Also excellent music throughout, especially that closing track.
While this film has that, and action moves like car chases, pistol whipping and a lengthy running script (the kind Tom Cruise would demand be inserted in a film of his), Francois Cluzet holds the center of the film in more gentle hands. He's a good guy, even when mixed up with the bad guys, he brings out their inherent benevolence. You go, Bruno!
Films like this hinge upon believing that bad moves are really the best moves one can take, the story and acting help sell that here in my opinion. In real life, I think in most cases perhaps not as intricate as this, I would Tell Some One, and likely an authority. Granted plenty of films from America North and South, make clear the dangers of corrupt cops and who watches the watchers. Maybe in Europe, things could be different.
Again for the genre, experts might not enjoy this (or pick it apart for a variety of reasons). But I was able to just enjoy the people on screen foremost (always helps to have Nathalie Baye involved), and then the pacing and plot.
Nice to see the director hatched the script and put himself in the mix on screen as well. Recommend you watch it, and then figure out the right someone to tell to see it next.
Also excellent music throughout, especially that closing track.
- ThurstonHunger
- 15 janv. 2022
- Lien permanent
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Langue
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- Tell No One
- Lieux de tournage
- Boulevard périphérique, Paris 18, Paris, France(Beck flees across highway in front of Bichat Hospital)
- sociétés de production
- Consultez plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
Box-office
- Budget
- 11 700 000 € (estimation)
- Brut – États-Unis et Canada
- 6 177 192 $ US
- Fin de semaine d'ouverture – États-Unis et Canada
- 169 707 $ US
- 6 juill. 2008
- Brut – à l'échelle mondiale
- 33 428 799 $ US
- Durée2 heures 11 minutes
- Couleur
- Mixage
- Rapport de forme
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant
Lacune principale
What is the Japanese language plot outline for Ne le dis à personne (2006)?
Répondre