Hallmark's Fall Harvest films in all their years have been variable. There are some good ones, some bad ones and some in between. Which is actually true of all their seasonal blockings, their Christmas films in particular. 2016's 'Autumn in the Vineyard' is the first of three 'Into the Vineyard' films, the others being 2017's 'Summer in the Vineyard' and 2019's 'Valentine in the Vineyard', all featuring the same two leads. Both of whom capable of good performances.
2016 varied with its Fall Harvest batch, and 'Autumn in the Vineyard' to me is one of the better ones. While not mind-blowing or anything that made me go wow, and it did feel more like a Valentine film yet meant to be set in Autumn, it was charming and fun and there was plenty to like. Of the three 'Into the Vineyard' films, 'Autumn in the Vineyard' is the best in my view. The other two are definitely watchable, though pretty more of the same.
Sure, the story is very formulaic and does very little new with a type of story that one pretty much knows how it is going to map out quite a bit of time before it happens. A bit over-simple too. The editing also could have been tighter and more refined, being on the haphazard side at times.
There are times early on where the script is corny and awkward.
On the other hand, there is a lot to like. Rachael Leigh Cook is immensely charming and perky, and of the three 'In the Vineyard' films her character is at her most likeable here. Brendan Penny proves that with a good leading lady his easy going and subtle charisma can shine and shine it does. The chemistry between them is heart-warming and has a playful. The supporting cast are also good with no exceptions, and while the characters are not meaty they are not ciphers, dull or irritating and motivations make sense.
Although the story is too simple and unoriginal, it is very light-hearted and heart-warming, with a nice energy. Liked too that it doesn't try to do too much, even with more than one subplot going on. The script isn't too cheesy or schmaltzy and is suitably playful in the two leads' interactions. The editing aside, 'Autumn in the Vineyard' looks good visually. Especially the gorgeous scenery. The music doesn't distract and really liked how the film made the absolute most of the setting without shoving it in the viewer's face.
Concluding, nicely done if not perfect. 7/10.
