After having had a marathon of all 4 Chinese Ghost Stories after each other, I obviously watched this one last. It surprises me that it's from the same director that did all of the Donnie Yen Ip Man films, it also surprises me that he has said that this wasn't a remake of the previous ones but a new take. This is obviously a remake of the first one with some slight changes where the taoist priest is a demon hunter instead and there was also a love story between the Demon Hunter and the Demon before he performed a magic spell that made her forget about him because "Demons and Demon Hunters can't live together". Otherwise there's the same plot points with a Demon falling in love with a clumsy man and is trapped by a Tree Demon controlling her and other Demons to do her deeds.
If you watch the old ones, you can tell the screenplays in those is a bit wobbly, but what they lack in story, they have more of in charm and effects. Sure, this film got some amazing special effects and martial art scenes, The sword fight between the two Demon Hunters was amazing and I would go as far as saying that it's worth watching the film just for that. There's also the beautiful Yifei Liu as the Demon, on the same level as Joey Wang from the previous ones.
But it also feels like when you clean this film up with fine effects and really great choreographed fight scenes, there's some sort of personality that gets lost in it, if I hadn't seen the first 'A Chinese Ghost Story' before this one, I would probably have been more forgiving, but now it just feels like a pale copy of a better film. It would be like remaking an old 80s classic like Robocop... oh, they did. I would have given it an extra star if it tried to make a new story out of it, instead of just taking the previous one, it's really an ok film otherwise.
