"[...]transcendent moments are in short supply these days."
--Martin Scorsese, on Wes Anderson
At first I was very skeptical about this movie, because the ads made it sound like a shaolin soccer ripoff, you know, a movie that takes a normal sport to a comically extreme level or something. Then I realized the movie was nothing like that--it didn't really have any of that over the top cg or any of that ingenious mo lit tao (an asian "nonsensical/ absurdist" type comedy, kinda neo-Groucho Marxian I guess) comedy of Stephen Chow. It was simply a very down to earth sports movie. what makes it so good? first and foremost, the characters. The movie depicts the relationship between two high school guys on the ping pong team--Peco and smile. Peco is the crazy genius ping pong player seen beating some college champ for money in the first scene, while Smile ("they call him that because he never does") his nerdy awkward buddy who envies Peco's talent. Peco's dream is to be the best ping pong player "on the planet" while Smile just wants to play for fun. But then we realize that maybe Peco isn't so good after all, and maybe Smile is the real genius who concedes on purpose because he just wants to play for fun, not for victory.
Then there is the hot shot player from Shanghai (hong kong's Sam Lee of Gen-X Cops); the militant, all-bald rival ping pong team dressed in all black; the crazy granny with her own "ping pong dojo" and a frustrated coach named "Butterfly Joe"--all of them sounding like real familiar sports movie archetypes, but there is a twist at the end of every scene, when we realize that they are a lot more human than anything we've seen in a long time. For instance, the Shanghai hotshot is under constant stress because he knows he's just a failed junior national player in China, playing against Japanese high school kids to feed his own complex ("I coulda gone to Germany, I coulda gone to Sweden..." he keeps on telling himself). And ironically, these are orginally comicbook characters.
The actors are really good--probably too old for high school roles, but they display a real innocence, and that makes you forget that the main guy's got smoker's teeth of a 25-year old. The little kids that play the younger version of the high school characters are especially nice. My favorite parts of the movie are the flashback sequences interspersed throughout the movie when Smile keeps on remembering a young Peco with the mask of a popular manga robot hero from the 60's, proclaiming "enter the hero!" in front of a temple. Those kids are so natural, and so confident, but not jaded like those TV kids. Either that or they are so jaded they are fooling me.
The music is good too, just like the rest of the movie, it has a real innocence about it. it's just catchy electronic pop, but never crosses the line to being stupid or bad or cheesy pop, at least not in the context of the film. The energy is high, and it attacks in short assaults--it comes in, drops out before you realize it, then attacks again. Half of the movie is carried through ambient noises, but the sound design does an excellent job of creating that sense of rhythm in a ping pong hall, between the cheers and the conversations, just a symphony of crispy ping pong sounds, layered with heavy breathing and the echoy sneakers. It is intense.
The style in which the movie's shot is real flashy, a lot of handheld work, mixed with a lot of crane. in fact, I don't think the movie used a dolly or steadicam at all--when the camera is not flying up and around the characters, it's following them step by step via handheld. and between all the cool extreme closeups and quick cuts, it also reminds you that this is a Japanese film by pulling all the way back and leave the characters on screen doing about their thing, free of extradiagetic sounds or any medium shots, Ozu-style. it's flashy but never obtrusive. I don't think there was any quick cut simply for the sake of showing off, but to simply elevate the tension of a ping pong game. there were some lengthy takes on the crane of two players going at it, uncut, with the assistance of some nice CG to show off the long takes, but those didn't last too long, and I think that's the only instance of showing off I can remember. and showing off isn't even a real crime, just a minor petty nit petty petty pick.
This movie reminds me in a lot of ways of Inoue's Slam Dunk, where gifted (and soulful) high school jocks center their lives around the sports, and the comedy and the drama just comes from how easily they have it and the tension between them and other people who try and try but just don't got it (but the story doesn't side with either of the party in these two instances). However, while Slam Dunk packs the plot and character development so tightly within the basketball games, where every point seems life and death--Ping Pong really isn't concerned about the games, and the message of the movie seems to be reminding us that hey, it's just a game, a beautiful, transcendent game.
