Killer McCoy

While Killer McCoy might not sound like a winner at first glance, it's surprisingly smart, exciting, and fun. It might look like Mickey Rooney isn't the best choice for a prizefighter, and it might look like James Dunn is just reprising his Oscar- and Rag-winning role in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, and it might look like Brian Donlevy has a throwaway role as a typical bad guy, but this movie is one of the top of its kind.

Mickey Rooney shows off his acting chops in this meaty role, and not only does he show a different mastery of choreographed footwork, but he has a range of emotions that show great experience and street smarts. James Dunn once again plays a drunk who can't get ahead, but it is slightly different than two years ago's film. If you did enjoy A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, though, you'll want to watch this one. Brian Donlevy isn't a straight villain, and has a very interesting character. He's fleshed out and given layers to his performance, showing once again, that he's a very good and underused actor. Ann Blyth is Mickey's love interest and Brian's daughter, and while she is the contrast to Mickey's coarse boxing world, she's not a one-dimensional snob. She's sweet and loving, and it's clear why both Mickey and Brian want to shield her from their world.

The script of Killer McCoy is very strong. Frederick Hazlitt Brennan has written smart, snappy dialogue as well as dramatic scenes, and the plot unfolds at an even yet exciting pace. This is a surprising hidden gem that isn't remembered anymore, but when you watch it you'll realize it should be.