I get the 1 star and negative reviews. I get it having had a relative serve in the Union Army.
However, it's a "Documentary " in that it has to be difficult to condense such significant and prominent battles into an under hour show. It seems hastily done to fit the time allotted. The narrative seems relatively accurate, with some notable historians providing the narrative. One wonders how they feel or how they reacted to the final product. Take it for what it is - Entertainment. There are NO shows, documentaries or movies without flaw, errors, or inaccuracies. Oddly enough this Documentary about the US Civil War was filmed in Canada ??? In any case I'm sure it's difficult to maintain a 100% accuracy as modes and tactics morph throughout a battle. The chaos and confusion in these battles are incomprehensible. The sacrifice, carnage and slaughter is on a scale unmatched as it's American killing American. Sure.....Worse case Accuracy is perhaps a fail. Best case it brings the carnage of the US Civil War to the viewers.
To tacitusmk review, please reference The American Civil War Museum, American Battlefield Trust and as noted on the History Channel "On March 13, 1865, with the main Rebel armies facing long odds against much larger Union armies, the Confederacy, in a desperate measure, reluctantly approves the use of Black troops."
Granted is was a rarity yet it did exist.
No matter what "Side" you have attachments toward, the Civil War was a bloodbath for America Ultimately morphing from a War to Preserve the Union to the Freeing of Slaves. There is so much that is indeed debatable. The loss of AMERICAN LIVES for whatever the cause is not. That is a Fact....
To krizzby7. It's relatively cut and dry. It was to Preserve a still young Union. We were not far removed from the War of 1812. If one believes Lincoln decided to free the Slaves because he was a Great humanitarian you're kidding yourself. He's a politician through and through and seized an opportunity to exploit the Growing Anti Slave Movement and thus appear to be the Great Uniter. It was a political move executed by a savvy politician. His fortunes were heading south (Uh, no pun intended) and he needed a home run.... A Grand Slam Home Run. He got it, ran with it, and shifted America's opinion of the war from Preserving the Union to Setting People Free. It's all political. Don't fool yourself if you believe Lincoln cared about slavery. He cared about his political career.
My roots are with the 208th Pennsylvania Volunteers Infantry Regiment, Company H.
